A Missing Man: Major Milton Joel, Fighter Pilot, 38th Fighter Squadron, 55th Fighter Group, 8th Air Force: IV (1) – Autumn Over Europe

Autumn Over Europe

If a tale is most directly told in the “first person”, what better way to present the nature of aerial combat in the P-38 Lightning over Europe, than in the words of Major Joel himself?

To that end, this post presents the following information and documents:

1) A list of Major Joel’s combat missions;

2) His accounts of aerial engagements with the Luftwaffe – recorded in documents known as “Pilot’s Personal Encounter Reports” – specifically for missions on November 3, 5, and 13, of 1943; 

3) Encounter Reports filed by other 38th Fighter Squadron pilots on those same dates;

4) “Mission Reports” (albeit not specifically entitled as such) filed by the 38th Fighter Squadron for the above missions (well, such Reports were recorded for all missions, even the most uneventful), encompassing the names of pilots on the mission, the nature and destination of the mission, a summary of events during the mission, and finally, the planned organization of the squadron in terms of the arrangement of its aircraft.

Speaking of the latter…  The 38th Fighter Squadron, akin to its brother squadrons (and I suppose in a general sense, other VIII Fighter Command squadrons?), organized its aircraft in units dubbed “elements” and “flights”, comprised of two and four aircraft, respectively, with a flight consisting of two elements.  For organizational and communication purposes, the flights were designated by colors, with the lead flight being “white”, followed (sequentially) by “red”, “yellow”, “blue”, and “purple”.  (These terms did not mean that the aircraft were physically marked or painted in these colors!)  As such, Major Joel generally lead the 38th Fighter Squadron as flight leader of “white” flight.

For the three missions during which Major Joel engaged in combat with German aircraft, copies of all relevant squadron Mission Report, and Encounter Reports filed by participating pilots are included.

Due to the poor legibility of the these documents (at least as 16mm microfilm) Encounter and Mission Reports are here presented as reproductions of the originals.  These were created using a 50s-era manual typewriter (remember those?) which fortuitously had same font as that of the original Reports: Times New Roman.  So…  As such, these recreated Reports – scroll below – are identical in format and layout to the originals. 

The main text of these Reports is presented here, as well.

Major Joel’s Combat Missions

The 55th Fighter Group’s first mission took place on October 15, 1943.  This was a fighter sweep of Dutch coastal islands, the first of the nineteen missions that Major Joel would fly until his death nearly a month and a half later.  One of these missions (October 16) was a practice mission, and another (October 30) was recalled by the mission Controller – and thus aborted for the entire 55th Fighter Group – after take-off.  Major Joel’s other missions comprised six fighter sweeps, and, three escorts of medium bombers (B-26s Marauders), the remainder having been fighter escorts of B-17s and B-24s

During this time Major Joel was credited with destroying 2 ½ German planes, damaging 3, and probably destroying 2. 

A list of the Major’s missions appears below.  While this compilation is primarily based on the historical records of the 38th Fighter Squadron, it’s supplemented by information in Major Joel’s biographical profile at the 55th Fighter Group, and, information about the 55th Fighter Group via the American Air Museum in Britain

Each entry includes the date of the mission, the 8th Fighter Command’s alpha-numeric designation of the mission, and the type and / or destination of the mission.  The names of Major Joel’s wingmen and the names of the other two pilots in his flight’s second element are also listed, along with the “color” designation of Major Joel’s flight. 

On those missions where Major Joel destroyed or damaged German aircraft, the number and types of the enemy warplanes are also listed.  Reviewing this list reveals that with one exception, he flew with the same wingman no more than twice.  The exception?  2 Lt. James M. Garvin, who was also killed on November 29, the third occasion on which the Major and Lt. Garvin flew as element leader and wingman.

And so, Major Joel’s missions…

1) October 15, 1943 – VIII Fighter Command Mission FO-157 or FO-158
Fighter Sweep – Dutch Islands
(Squadron organization was not recorded.)

2) October 16, 1943
Practice Bomber Escort – England (Orfordness and Great Yarmouth)
(Joel & F/O David D. Fisher; Capt. Joseph Myers & 2 Lt. Willard A. Kreft)
(White Leader)

3) October 16, 1943 – VIII Fighter Command Mission FO-159
Fighter Sweep – Netherlands (Amsterdam)
Red Leader
(Joel & 2 Lt. Richard W. Forsblad; Capt. James H. Hancock & 2 Lt. Hugh E. Gillette)

4) October 17, 1943 – VIII Fighter Command Mission FO-161
Fighter Sweep – Northern France / Dutch Islands
White Leader
(Joel & 2 Lt. James M. Garvin; Hancock & 2 Lt. Ernest R. Marcy)

5) October 18, 1943 – VIII Fighter Command Mission FO-162
Fighter Sweep – Dutch Islands
(Mission profile changed by Controller from Withdrawal Cover to Fighter Sweep)
Red Leader
(Joel & 2 Lt. Edward F. Peters; Hancock & Marcy)

6) October 19, 1943
Fighter Sweep – France (Amiens Area)
White Leader
(Joel & Capt. Thomas Beaird; Myers & 2 Lt. Paul Fisher, Jr.)

7) October 20, 1943 – VIII Fighter Command Mission FO-163
Withdrawal Fighter Escort – Netherlands (Duren / Schouwen)
Yellow Leader
(Joel & 2 Lt. William K. Birch; 1 Lt. Gerald F. Leinweber & 1 Lt. Wilton E. Wyche)

8) October 22, 1943 VIII Fighter Command Mission FO-165
Medium Bomber (B-26) Escort – France (Cambrai)
White Leader
(Joel & 2 Lt. John J. Carroll; Leinweber & Wyche)

9) October 24, 1943 – VIII Fighter Command Mission FO-166
Fighter Escort – France (Saint-Andre-de-l’Eure)
White Leader
(Joel & Forsblad; Leinweber & Wyche)

10) October 30, 1943
Fighter Escort (Mission Aborted – “Mission was recalled soon after take off.”)
Yellow Leader
(Joel & 2 Lt. Clair W. Des Voignes; Leinweber & Wyche)

11) November 3, 1943 – VIII Fighter Command Mission FO-168
Fighter Escort – Germany (Wilhelmshaven)
White Leader
(Joel & Kreft; Hancock & 2 Lt. Robert E. Erickson)
One FW-190 destroyed – half-credit shared with Lt. Kreft (Westerholt-Wittmund)
Two FW-190s damaged (north of Wilhelmshaven)

12) November 5, 1943 – VIII Fighter Command Mission FO-170
Fighter Escort – Germany (Gelsenkirchen)
White Leader
(Joel & Carroll; Myers & Forsblad)
One Me-109 destroyed (west of Arnheim)

13) November 7, 1943 – VIII Fighter Command Mission FO-173 (?)
Medium Bomber (B-26) Close Support – Belgium (Ostend) / France (Saint Omer)
Yellow Leader
(Joel & Kreft; Capt. Jerry H. Ayers & Erickson)

14) November 7, 1943 – VIII Fighter Command Mission FO-173 (?)
Fighter Sweep – France (Lille)
White Leader
(Joel & 2 Lt. Gerald Brown; Myers & 2 Lt. Allen R. Peters)

15) November 10, 1943 – VIII Fighter Command Mission FO-175
Medium Bomber (B-26) Escort – France (Montdidier Airdrome)
White Leader
(Joel & Garvin; Ayers & 2 Lt. John A. Stacker)

16) November 11, 1943 – VIII Fighter Command Mission FO-177
Fighter Escort – Germany (Munster)
White Leader
(Joel & Des Voignes; Leinweber & Wyche)

17) November 13, 1943 – VIII Fighter Command Mission FO-180
Fighter Escort – Germany (Bremen)
Yellow Leader
(Joel & Stacker; Leinweber & Wyche)
One Ju-88 destroyed (Bremen)
One Ju-88 probable (Bremen)
One Me-109 probable (Bremen)
One Me-109 damaged (shared with Lt. Stacker) (Bremen)

18) November 26, 1943 – VIII Fighter Command Mission FO-191
Fighter Escort – Germany (Bremen)
White Leader
(Joel & 2 Lt. Robert F. Maloney; Beaird & Des Voignes)

19) November 29, 1943 – VIII Fighter Command Mission FO-192
Fighter Escort – Germany (Bremen)
White Leader
(Joel & Garvin; Marcy & Maloney)

________________________________________

This image, from World War Photos, shows Major Joel’s P-38 before it actually became his P-38:  Note that the plane lacks the 38th Fighter Squadron’s “CG” squadron code on its tail boom, and bears a hastily chalked “20” (probably based on the last two digits of its serial number) on its port rudder.  This suggests that the image was taken prior to or immediately upon its actual delivery to the Army Air Force.  Unfortunately, the source of the image isn’t given.

In the image below (Roger Freeman photo FRE 5514 via the American Air Museum in Britain) P-38H 42-67020 has now been assigned to Major Joel, and has become his un-nicknamed “flying wolf”.

The plane’s nose art, which has very much of a Walt Disney look, was – like most (all?) of the 38th Fighter Squadron’s P-38 nose-art – painted by Sergeant Robert T. Sand, who, seemingly having an ample supply of Kodachrome film (remember film?), created an invaluable photographic record of the English countryside, villages, and towns near Nuthampstead, as well as 55th Fighter Group aircraft and personnel.  Other examples of his artistic skill include – in the prior post – Jerry Ayers’ “Mountain Ayers” and Major Mark Shipman’s “Skylark IV”, and in a future posts, Lt. Albert A. Albino’s “Spirit of Aberdeen”.

“Sergeant Robert T. Sand, a pipe-smoking member of ground crew of the 55th Fighter Group, wearing an apron for carrying hand tools.  Handwritten on slide:”1-32″”

As for Major Joel’s aircraft, Sergeant Sand completed the insignia about 18 November, eleven days before Major Joel was shot down.  Paralleling the central mystery of what actually happened to Major Joel, there lies a minor mystery: The specific “identity” – the squadron identification letter – of the flying wolf.  Unfortunately, typical of the great majority of MACRs for 8th Air Force fighter losses (the 355th Fighter Group being a notable exception), MACRs for 55th Fighter Group planes did not record specific aircraft squadron letters.  Similarly, while the Squadron’s Mission Reports list the full names and serial numbers of pilots and their “positions” in squadron formations, both aircraft identification letters and aircraft serial numbers are absent from these documents.  

Another view of the flying wolf in a photograph by Sgt. Sand.  42-67020, with engines running, prepares for take-off with other 38th Fighter Squadron P-38s.  This photograph appears in Robert Littlefield’s Double Nickel, Double Trouble.

Here’s the Air Force Historical record card for Major Joel’s P-38.  The aircraft, at a 1943 cost of nearly $99,000 (nearly 1.5 million in 2020 dollars (to put it another way, 1/52 the cost of an F-35A Lighting II)), was delivered to the Air Force in Newark, N.J., on July 30, 1943. 

Before we go to Mission and Encounter Reports, here are two brief films from Critical Past pertaining to the 38th Fighter Squadron’s first combat mission, the films also including views of P-38s of the 338th Fighter Squadron. 

This video, clip: 65675030628, is entitled “P-38 aircraft of the U.S. 55th Fighter Group at Nuthampstead Airfield, England”.

Though a description of the film is available at Critical Past, here’s a much more detailed breakdown of the scenes in the film:

0:04 – 0:08: General view of 55th Fighter Group P-38s
0:08 – 0:12: General view of 38th FS P-38s being prepared for a mission.

0:13 – 0:28: Close-up of a P-38.  Ground crewman loads parachute and dinghy in cockpit, another attends to .50 machine guns, another closes canopy, another examines engine plumbing and buttons up access panels.
0:28 – 0:34: An armorer cleans the barrel of the P-38’s 20mm cannon.
0:34 – 0:36: Finishing touches on the P-38.
0:36 – 1:12: Group Commander Colonel Frank James briefs 38th Fighter Squadron pilots prior to the mission.  This scene was filmed from two different angles.  The first view, from the “side” at 0:44 to 1:01, shows the entire group of pilots with P-38H “C” in the background.  The “second”, from the “front” at 1:01 to 1:13, shows Colonel James at left, and fourteen pilots who are facing the camera directly.

In the “first” view – a screen-grab of which at 0:48 appearing below – there’s something interesting about the bare-headed pilot standing third from right (the only pilot not wearing a flight helmet, and, one of the two pilots in the group who is not wearing a leather jacket).  Allowing for the screen-shot’s distorted perspective and very low resolution, notice that this man’s shoulder insignia appears round-ish – like a Major’s oak-leaf viewed from a distance.  More importantly, he seems to be relatively short in stature.  Given Milton Joel’s military rank and physical description – he was five feet six; his nickname “Gum” or Gummy” – this person may indeed be the Major himself.

In total, 21 (?) pilots are visible besides Colonel James, and, the man who appears to be Major Joel.  Though it would be challenging to correlate “names to faces” 77 years later (as if anyone would be remembered by now!), the ten other 38th Fighter Squadron pilots definitely are: 

Capt. Mark K. Shipman
1 Lt. Jerry H. Ayers
1 Lt. James H. Hancock
1 Lt. Joseph Myers
1 Lt. Gerald F. Leinweber
1 Lt. Morris Leve
1 Lt. Wilton E. Wyche
2 Lt. Gerald Brown
2 Lt. Hugh E. Gillette (replaced on the mission by 2 Lt. Allen R. Peters)
2 Lt. Delorn L. Steiner
…along with…
Lt. Colonel Jack S. Jenkins

…thus, the other pilots are presumably members of the 338th or 343rd Fighter Squadrons, or the 20th Fighter Group.

Other scenes show:

1:13 – 1:20: A pilot (probably Lt. Colonel Jenkins) climbs into Texas Ranger
1:20 – 1:22: The “business end” of Texas Ranger.
1:23 – 1:26: Lt. Colonel Jenkins fires up Texas Ranger’s engines. 
1:27 – 1:32: P-38H CG * O taxies out.
1:33 – 1:44: Texas Ranger taxies out.

This second film sequentially follows the first film, entitled “P-38 planes fly over B-17 planes in European Theatre of Operations” (clip: 65675030629).

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The film shows the following:

0:04 – 0:35: P-38s taxi to take-off.  (Lt. Jerry Ayers’ P-38H 42-67077 CG * Q (Mountain Ayers) and Lt. Stanley Richardson’s 338th Fighter Squadron P-38H 42-67057 CL * X (Miss Mona)).
0:36 – 0:45: 38th FS P-38s take off
0:46 – 1:06: 338th Fighter Squadron P-38s take off
1:07 – 1:19: 38th FS P-38s take off (Jerry Ayers in CG * Q)
1:20 – 1:43: 55th FG P-38s overfly Nuthampstead as flights of four (or three)
1:44 – 3:00: 55th FG P-38s as viewed from 91st Bomb Group B-17s
3:00 – 3:12: P-38s return to Nuthampstead
3:13 – 3:24: P-38s land (CL * P at 3:23)
3:24 – 3:33: While landing, P-38 releases 165 gallon tank (3:28-3:29), which almost strikes his wingman.  (Verily: “Whoops.”)
3:34 – 3:40 – A 338th Fighter Squadron P-38 lands (CL * O)

And so, here are accounts for the missions of November 3, 5, and 13, of 1943.

November 3, 1943

From Roger Freeman’s The Mighty Eighth

Two days later the three squadrons of the 55th, despatched from Nuthampstead, were accompanied by eight aircraft of the 20th Group all being flown by 79th Ftr. Sqdn. pilots.  Not long after take-off some Lightnings experienced mechanical troubles and were forced to abort, leaving 47 to climb up through the overcast towards their rendezvous with Liberators bound for Munster.  These became separated in the bad visibility, and 50° temperature at 25,000 ft caused further aircraft to turn back with engine trouble.  At the rendezvous point they found no sign of the bombers and only one squadron, the 38th, finally contacted them – near the target at about the same time as a strong force of Me109s and rocket-carrying Do217s launched an attack.  Outnumbered, perhaps three to one, the sixteen remaining Lightnings led by Major Milton Joel set about breaking up the enemy attacks.  Most combats were inconclusive as pilots did not let themselves be drawn away from the bombers.  Even so, claims of 5-3-4 were made on return to Nuthampstead, for no loss to the 55th.  Their escort value was also evinced by only three of the B-24s failing to return from the mission.

One FW-190 destroyed – half-credit shared with Lt. Kreft (Westerholt-Wittmund)

Two FW-190s damaged (north of Wilhelmshaven)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Mission Report

Extract from Mission Report

Mission: Landfall out at 1200 and landfall over Dutch Coast at 1245 at altitude of 29,000 feet.  R/V with bombers Task Force made at 1245.  38th Squadron was on the starboard side, conducting 1st box of task force over target, bombs away in about 8 minutes later than scheduled.  Escort was at 26,000 feet.  Bombers escorted back out to coast, landfall over England north of Norwich at 1415.  (Flight plan attached.) 

Action: On making landfall about 10 E/A seen at about Sneek, about 7,000 feet below, shortly afterwards 3 E/A observed about 3 miles behind coming in from 5 o’clock but did not press attack.  In nearing target area, 13 to 20 E/A type FW 190 observed below climbing in spirals.  5 minutes later a series of fighters in groups seen below and a flight of P-38’s seen to go down after them.  Over target area 5 FW 190’s approached formation from 2 o’clock and 2000 feet below, Major Joel broke into them and fired at about a 600 yard range, one A/C half rolled and was last seen my Capt. Myers disappearing through the overcast in vertical rolls, time about 1310.  About same time Capt. Myers and Lt. Brown at 25,000 feet observed formation of five FW 190’s in “V” formation attacking bombers from 4 o’clock and some 2000 feet below.  Capt. Myers and Lt. Brown attacked and E/A broke 3 to the left and 2 to the right.  Lt. Brown attacked group of 2 and Capt. Myers attacked group of 3 giving a 2 second burst dead astern at range of 100 yards.  Lt. Brown fired 60 rounds at 100 yards range result unobserved.  On returning to target area 4 or 5 FW 190’s were seen on the tail of 1 P-38 behind the bomber formation.  Major Joel dove down to intercept E/A which broke and Major Joel fired at one, damage unobserved, the next minute he observed in his rear view mirror an FW 190 behind in flames.  Major Joel and Lt. Kreft met with 4 FW 190’s well above and approaching from 6 o’clock, the E/A pulled up and away when pulled into.  Light flak inaccurate for altitude and behind flights encountered just after landfall over coast also meager and inaccurate flak encountered over target area. 

Pilot’s Personal Encounter Report – Major Milton Joel

Transcript of Pilot’s Personal Encounter Report – Major Milton Joel

As we were about to leave the bombers, I, leading Swindle White Flight, heard a call for help giving position as behind rear box of bombers.  As we reached the rear box we saw a single P-38 in a steep dive being closely followed by four or five FW190’s.  At about 17,000, the P-38 pulled up and started turning with the enemy aircraft.  We dove in to help.  As we started in, my second element saw enemy aircraft turning and firing at the single P-38, break off and dive away.  I pulled up thinking the P-38 would join in, but he did not.  I made a climbing turn to 22,000 feet, leveled off, and began a shallow left turn to orient myself.  We were then attacked by enemy aircraft from 10 o’clock out of the sun.  I turned into him in a tight chandelle and fired as he closed almost head on.  At the time the enemy aircraft was in a diving right turn.  Enemy aircraft passed close enough for me to see oil streaming out of his cowling, which was painted red.  Enemy aircraft passed just below me.  Using my rear-vision mirror to see my wing man, I saw the plane crossing my path, behind Lt. Kreft, at 90 degrees in flames and disintegrating.  When the enemy aircraft appeared in my mirror, there seemed to be an explosion, and the enemy aircraft seemed to stop in mid-air.  As there were other enemy aircraft in the area, I did not try to watch him farther.

Pilot’s Personal Encounter Report

Major Milton Joel and Captain Jerry H. Ayers

Transcript of Pilot’s Personal Encounter Report

Major Milton Joel and Capt. Jerry H. Ayers

A formation of 5 FW-190’s approached bomber from 2 o’clock flying parallel to course at about 2000 feet below us.  I began a parallel dive toward them from astern.  Two FW 190’s pulled off into half rolls to right and one to left leaving two who started gentle turn.  I fired from behind with about 10 degrees deflection, range about 500 yards and closed seeing what I believed to be strikes.  Before I could close within good range, one of them half rolled and the one I was firing at pulled up and did what appeared to be vertical rolls at the ground.  I pulled up to rejoin bombers.  Capt. Ayers states ship spun through clouds.

I saw Major Joel’s flight engage some FW 190’s below me, 1000 or 1500 feet.  After completing a 260 degree turn, I looked behind and below me and saw a FW 190 spinning down and smoke was coming from the cowling.  I saw the FW 190 spin through the overcast.

Pilot’s Personal Encounter Report

2 Lt. Robert W. Forsblad

Transcript of Pilot’s Personal Encounter Report – 2 Lt. Robert W. Forsblad

When Major Joel started his attack on the E/A, I turned inside of him getting on his right wing well forward in a line abreast position.  I saw Major Joel open fire at about 400 yard range, I was then trying to take a lead on the same E/A.  The E/A went into a dive, I followed for about a second after Major Joel broke off the attack.  I saw black smoke come from the E/A’s engine.  I then broke off and got back in formation.

November 5, 1943

From Roger Freeman’s The Mighty Eighth

The Lightnings were not always so fortunate in combat.  In another, two days later, the 55th was assigned to escort Marauders bombing Melun airfield in France.  Here Focke-Wulfs slipped out of the cloud and attacked elements of the 20th Group that had gone along.  One Lightning was severely damaged, the pilot baling out over the Channel and another failed to return to base, its fate unknown.

One Me-109 destroyed (west of Arnheim, Holland)

Mission Report

Extract from Mission Report

Mission:  After crossing Dutch Coast, Bombers sighted 10 miles North East at 1316.  Bombers were late.  Orbited to meet bombers.  R/V 1346/25,000 as planned.  Flights 1 and 2 covered forward part of formation, Flights 3 and 4 covered rear of formation.  They escorted the bombers all the way to and from the target. 

Action: Three ME 190’s in midst of bomber formation at time of R/V, one pass made at them and they left.  A few fighters seen to right of formation as going over target.  Five minutes after leaving target, 3 ME 109’s came in on straggler at 12,000 feet.  Major Joel’s flight went down to help.  By this time the B-24 exploded and rolled over, one parachute seen.  Turned into attackers at least 5 times helping stragglers out to coast.  Two ME 109’s and 1 FW 190 attacked B-24’s in area of Arnhem.  Major Joel fired at one and No. 4 man saw smoke pour out and No. 2 man saw a parachute bloom.  Three FW 109’s seen at about 14,000 making attack from 3 o’clock position area of Arnhem.  Capt. Myers opened fire, numerous hits especially 3 direct 20 MM blasted large holes in side of one.  Pilot bailed out and plane went down in flames.  In same engagement, Lt. Forsblad damaged an ME 109.  At R/V time, 12 to 15 e/a were observed above bomber formation took off when turned into.  Another 4 ME 109’s driven off just after passing over target.  Beyond target about 15 FW 190’s with rocket guns observed above the bombers and about 3 twin-engined ships, DO 217’s with rockets behind at 1500 yards.  Capt. Myers scored hits on one DO 217 and it was seen going down with left engine on fire, seen by Lt. Wyche.  Lt. Steiner fired at another DO 217 at close range but did not observe results.  Between Wintersvijk and Doetinchem about 3 Squadrons of FW 190’s came up behind the bombers.  Capt. Shipman bounced one and observed hits and smoke.  Two others attacked by Capt. Shipman and Lt. Des Voignes, one seen by Capt. Ayers to have large pieces falling off and in flames, the other blew up.  All combat 20,000 to 25,000 feet.  Attacks were constant but not aggressive towards fighters.  Near the coast, in area of Rotterdam, Lt. Leinweber and flight attacked five e/a from dead astern.  Engine of one e/a exploded with considerable smoke and large flames.  Flak very heavy over target, accurate for altitude.  No tracers. 

Pilot’s Personal Encounter Report

Major Milton Joel and 2 Lt. James M. Garvin

Transcript of Pilot’s Personal Encounter Report

Major Milton Joel and 2 Lt. James M. Garvin

Flying parallel and behind #2 bomber box at 26,000 ft. when I saw 2 stragglers about to be attacked by three 190’s.  Stragglers were behind first two boxes about 2 miles at 18,000 ft, approximately.  We were just in front of stragglers.  E/A were about to make a diving head on pass from 2 o’clock on the bombers.  I attempted to head them off by making a diving right turn firing at the lead 109 at about 400 yards or more at about 15-20 degrees deflection, trying to close from behind.  Two E/A did a rudder roll downward into a vertical dive as I opened fire.  Before I closed much beyond 300 yards, the leader went into a vertical dive and I could no longer hold my lead and head nearly reached compressibility, I pulled up and over the bombers.  E/A got no closer than 1000  yards to bombers.  My wing man Lt. Forsblad claims seeing heavy black smoke come from E/A though I saw no results while firing.  Lt. Garvin in cover flight above saw parachute break out below us.

At the time of Major Joel’s encounter with a 109, I was above and behind the two straggling bombers about 2,000 ft.  Shortly after, 1/2 to 1 minutes, of the approximate time of encounter, I saw a parachute about 2,000 ft. below these two stragglers.  This chute was in about a 10 o’clock position to me, and would have been about a 2 o’clock position to the two bombers.  No E/A were seen. 

The following article, by Philadelphia Inquirer correspondent Paul W. Ramsey, appeared in that newspaper on November 29, 1943 – ironically, the very day on which Major Joel and Lt. Garvin were killed.  (The article was found at FultonHistory.)

Old Newspapers

Transcript of Article…

Lightning Fighters
Squadron of 16 Has Battle-Filled Hour Protecting Bombers on Muenster Raid

By Paul W. Ramsey
Inquirer War Correspondent
The Philadelphia Inquirer
November 29, 1943

AN AMERICAN FIGHTER BASE, SOMEWHERE IN ENGLAND
(Delayed)

THE squadron of Lightning Fighters roared along high over Germany.  It was Friday, Nov. 5, a rare, sunny day and the job was to escort Liberators over Muenster and bring them home

Leading the squadron was a Richmond, Va., boy – 23-year-old Major Milton Joel, a slightly pudgy, good-natured and very capable pilot and officer.  His young wife and some of his closer friends call him Gummy.

As the squadron of fast, twin-engined fighters neared the rendezvous point where Lightnings were to take over the escort task from the single-engined Thunderbolts, the pilots scanned the sales anxiously for the other squadrons which should have joined up much earlier.

They could see for many miles in all directions but there was no sign of the other Lightnings.  Gummy led his men on toward the rendezvous.  When one of his pilots suddenly called over radio phones, “There are our big friends at 11 o’clock,” Joel knew his 16 Lightnings would have to do the escort job alone – 16 Lightnings to protect more than 300 Liberators!

His squadron, with one exception, had had less than a month of combat experience.  The job ahead was a large order.

Splits Squadron

Joel split up his squadron and led his own section of eight planes forward to protect the leading “box” of heavy bombers.  The Liberators were strung out for miles.  They looked like great flocks of birds when first seen, but grew larger rapidly as the Lightnings sped toward them.

As Joel took up his position over the forward box his second section, commanded by Captain Mark Shipment [Captain Mark K. Shipman], a carrot-haired veteran of the African campaign, dropped behind to cover the rear formation.

German fighters showed up at once and so began a furious running fight which lasted nearly a full hour.  The 16 Lightnings raced up and down the skies, now over the formation, now darting far below to protect stragglers, now racing to the sides to fight off flank attacks. 

The long-range Lightnings dropped their belly tanks when the first enemy craft appeared.  Joel’s section was cruising along, protecting the forward box, when one of his pilots called out:

“Three bandits at 12 o’clock attacking the lead formation.”

Always Fight in Teams

American fighter pilots always fight in teams.  Joel had eight planes in his section.  Now he must further divide his forces.  He could, with prudence, take only four of his eight planes into the attack at once because top cover must be maintained.

Leading his second flight of four planes was Captain James H. Hancock, of Sebring, Fla.  So when Joel called over radio phone, “Joel to Hancock, I’m going down,” Hancock knew what to do.

From an altitude of five miles Joel led his four Lightnings forward in a fast, gradual dive at three Messerschmitt-109s which were attacking the toad formation head-on.

As soon as the 109s saw the Lightnings the rolled on their backs and dived away right through the middle of the formation.  The bombers blazed away at the Germans as they streaked down.

Quickly Joel took his four planes back up over the formation and rejoined Hancock’s flight.  But almost immediately they spotted a flight of Germans attacking two straggling Liberators which had dropped four miles back of the front box and 3000 feet below.

Disperse Germans

Joel’s flight dove immediately to the stragglers’ rescue and quickly dispersed the Germans, who apparently have orders to attack bombers an often as possible while generally avoiding action with our fighters.

Once more Joel led his men back up to their position over the rear of the front box of Liberators.  They had hardly gotten back there when a third straggler, which had fallen farther behind than the other two, was attacked by three 109s from dead astern.

Major Joel took his four planes down at grant speed but it looked like a lost race from the beginning.  The three 109s were coming in on the tall of the lone Liberator with machine-guns and cannon blazing.

The Liberator returned the fire until the very last.  Her guns were still firing – and the Lightnings were within 5000 yards – when the big bomber suddenly exploded and spun down in earth.  Joel and his men did not see any parachutes open.  It was the only bomber lost to enemy fighters.  [Possibly B-24H 42-7490, EC * U-, “Big Ass Bird”, of the 578th Bomb Squadron, 392nd Bomb Group, piloted by 1 Lt. Douglas R. Steinmetz.  There were no survivors.]

Stricken Fortress Appears

Then an odd thing happened.  A stricken Flying Fortress which apparently had started out with other B-17s on the Gelsenkirschen raid that day flew over, trying to reach the protection of the Liberator formation.  The Fortress was obviously crippled and losing altitude.

By this time the Liberators had dropped their bombs on the Muenster railway yards – but the Lightning pilots bad no opportunity to observe results – and were on the long haul home.  The lone Fortress was 12,000 feet below the first box and about 10 miles to rear.

Hardly had the Lightning pilots spotted the big bomber when three ME-109s, which were flying high, saw it too and went for it.

Leaving Hancock’s four planes to cover the B-24s, Major Joel took his four down.  They had been flying about 20,000 feet and it looked like a toss-up whether the Lightnings or the 109s would get to the crippled B-17 first. 

Major Joel flipped on his back and went down in a screaming dive with his wingman close beside him.  Following them came Captain Joseph Myers, 24, of Canton, O., and his wingman.

Closing in Fast

The three 109s were closing in fast, approaching the Fortress from the port quarter and flying in a line astern.  It looked like the Germans would get there first, so Major Joel led his men down at terrific speed, hoping to scare them away before they had lined up their shots.

Captain Myers gave his plane all it would take.  At 20,000 feet he saw the Messerschmitts turning into the Fortress.  At 17,000 feet when going nearly 600 miles an hour in an almost vertical dive, so fast that his ship was buffeting and shaking, the German plane second in line came Into Myers’ sights

At that moment the German was beginning a left turn Into the Fortress.  Myers kept the German In his sights. 

Now Myers was still diving almost vertically and at speed far beyond the margin of safety.  When he had closed to 300 yards the German was at the middle of his 90-degree turn, which meant he was “standing” on his left wing.  At that precise moment Myers pressed the triggers of his machine-gun and cannon.

Cannon Shells Hit

It was a shot in a thousand, but he hit the German squarely and more than once.  There were three distinct flash-blasts as three cannon shells hit – the first struck the ceiling, the second hit the pilot’s compartment, literally blowing the pilot out of the plane, the third blew most of the plane’s tail off.

The other two 109s fled.  Myers and Joel and the other two fliers then saw that the B-17 was still flying and apparently had not been hit by any of the 109s.

They climbed sharply back up then and Joel was just about to lead them over to check on the main formation when they saw four Germans going for straggling Liberators which were cruising several thousand feet below and to the rear of the main formation.

As the four Lightnings swooped down the four Nazis were making a turn in toward the bombers.  Two of the Germans flicked over and dived away but the other two continued their turn.

Major Joel fired a long burst at German Number Two, who did a rudder roll and went down, in flames.  Shortly afterwards one or the Lightning pilots saw a parachute come out of the diving, blazing plane. 

Rout Six Planes

Back up for altitude went the Lightnings again and this time they drove off a flight of six enemy planes which was attacking the formation from left front.

By this time more Germans were attacking the stragglers.  This time Joel and his flight maintained top cover while Hancock took his men down.  Hancock’s flight had made several attacks on Focke-Wulfs and Messerschmitts but the enemy always broke and fled before his approach. 

As his flight dove to aid the straggling bombers, four more enemy planes dove out of the sun.  Hancock saw them coming in time to turn his flight into them.  They broke and fled.  Then the four Lightnings proceeded to chase off Germans who were after crippled bombers.

By this lime the running fights had been on nearly an hour and the bombers were nearing the coast.  The other eight Lightnings had been just as busy as Joel’s section.  But that’s another story.

November 13, 1943

From Roger Freeman’s The Mighty Eighth

The 13th was certainly an unlucky day for the 55th.  In typical English November weather, damp and overcast, forty-eight P-38s set out to escort bombers on the target leg of a mission to Bremen; one turned back before the enemy coast was crossed and two more aborted later.  At 26,000 ft over Germany pilots shivered in bitterly cold cockpits; flying conditions were unusually bad, and the probability of mechanical troubles at that temperature did not help.  Again outnumbered, the 55th was heavily engaged near the target as it strove to defend the bombers, for which it paid dearly.  Seven P-38s fell, five to enemy fighters and the others to unknown causes; it was suspected that engine troubles might have made some of the P-38s lost easy prey for enemy fighters.  Sixteen returned with battle damage: one, pitted with over a hundred small calibre bullet holes and ripped from five cannon shell bursts, came back on one engine.  The Group had sustained grievous losses, but there was some consolation to be found in the protection they had afforded the bombers which, after all, was their object.  Worse was to follow.

One Ju-88 destroyed (Bremen)
One Ju-88 probable (Bremen)
One Me-109 probable (Bremen)
One Me-109 damaged (shared with Lt. Stacker) (Bremen)

Mission Report

Extract from Mission Report

Mission: Over English Coast at 1049.  Landfall over Dutch Coast at 1110 at 20,000 feet.  Bombers first observed at 1127 at 24,500 feet on vector 150, 30 miles NW of target, fighters at that time 3 o’clock position 20 miles away, joined bomber formation 10 miles NW of target.  Over target at 1130 at about 27,000 feet, tanks dropped at R.V.  Out over Dutch Coast at 1330.  One flight escorted bombers over channel leaving them around 1245.  13 A/C landed at home at 1350. 

Action: One flight returned ahead of the bombers without incident until they reached Dutch Coast in area of Amsterdam-Ijmiuden, where intense flak was encountered, all four ships of the flight were hit with varying degrees of damage, but returned to base, one piloted by Lt. Col. Jenkins crash landed at Debden.

E/A apparently arrived at the same time as our fighter escort in target area.  A group of JU-88’s were observed towards the rear of the bombers, Major Joel closed in from the rear, fired just as JU 88 discharged his rockets.  Major Joel closed to about 100 yards and saw both engines on fire as JU 88 broke, climbing out he observed a group of ME-109’s at side of bombers, and with wing man, Lt. Stacker attacked one ME-109 then pulled into the sun, observed 3 JU-88’s in strength at the tail of B-17’s, Major Joel and his wingman attacked the last of the JU-88’s, as he fired he looked back and saw his wingman, also intent on E/A, being attacked by a twin-engine A/C, presumably JU-88 or possibly ME-410.  Major Joel called wingman to break, the P-38 turned over and spun down smoking.  Major Joel believes he saw parachute open.  Major was then out of ammunition and streaked for home being pursued for some ten minutes by a ME-109 who he was able to outrun.  Blue Flight reports E/A all over the sky in the sun in front of the bombers.  Just after target, one FW-190 at 3 o’clock to the bombers driven off, flight moved back to B-24’s at 24,000 feet.  Attacked FW-190, were in turn attacked by the E/A, broke and rejoined the bombers and observed about 15 E/A under bombers.  These E/A were kept below the bombers by repeated bounces.  Just after target Red Flight No. 3, Lt. Brown, had out engine knocked out by E/A.  They were diving from 29,000 feet at JU-8 at about 25,000 feet, and as they were attacked another JU-88 came in on Red leaders tail, he was in turn attacked by Lt. Brown, element leader, who saw him smoking.  Flight turned up to left.  During this attack an ME-109 had dived out on Lt. Brown after attacking him from the rear breaking off at about 50 yards, attaining numerous bursts.  Capt. Myers shot this E/A down in flames.  Lt. Brown returned from target area on one engine.  One other P-38 engine feathered joined formation.  There was a B-17 straggler at about 19,000 feet.  Lt. Brown and the other crippled P-38 joined in with this bomber and Capt. Myers escorted the 3 A/C from the target area to the coast.  On the way out there were continuous attacks for about ten minutes from 8 ME-109’s.

They made alternating attacks on the B-17 and on the two damaged P-38’s.  Capt. Myers maneuvered behind the E/A and kept chasing them off by repeated passes, until the Dutch Coast and then escorted Lt. Brown home.  Lt. Maloney separated from his Red flight at R/V due to inability to drop belly tanks, and in individual encounters, before joining an element from yellow flight shot down one FW 190 and damaged one other FW 190.  It is estimated that there were a total of 300 E/A involved in the encounters, they were extremely aggressive towards fighters.  Among the types observed were ME-109’s, FW-190’s, Do-217’s, JU-88’s, and ME-210’s, these later ships appeared to be exceptionally maneuverable and may be an ME-410.

Weather: Scattered to broken cumulus clouds over the channel.  7 to 8/10th cloud cover at target and cirrostratus at 20,000 feet over target.  R/T was good.

Claims: 1 JU-88 destroyed – Major Joel, 1 JU-88 probably destroyed, 1 ME 109 damaged, shared with Lt. Stacker, and 1 ME-109 damaged.  1 FW-190 damaged – Capt. Beaird.  1 ME-109 destroyed – Capt. Myers, and 1 JU-88 probably destroyed – Capt. Myers.  1 JU-88 damaged – Lt. Brown.  1 FW-190 destroyed and 1 FW-190 damaged – Lt. Maloney.

Pilot’s Personal Encounter Report – Major Milton Joel

Transcript of Pilot’s Personal Encounter Report – Major Milton Joel

I was leading the second section of Swindle Squadron as Swindle Yellow Leader, when we crossed the top of the bombers just prior to reaching the target.  About _____ thousand feet above the top of the second box of bombers, vapor trails were very heavy.  As we crossed on the port side, on which side we were supposed to pro- vide close support, I saw my second flight, led by Captain Myers, being attacked by many ME 109’s.  He was about 500 feet below.  As he went down to turn into the attack, I went over to cover him and saw about 8 ME 109’s coming down on us from 2 o’clock.  I turned into the attack and the 190’s seemed to overshoot us.  However, one ME 109 approached me on the same level from 5 o’clock.  I took about 15 degrees deflection and followed him, firing all of the time as he passed.  I believe that Lt. Stacker, who was flying on my wing, and firing also.  I saw strikes, smoke, and flame.  The E/A seemed to fall over on one wing and go into a dive.  I broke immediately upward. 

In the course of the engagement my second element became separated.  I then noted a twin-engined aircraft coming down from above, closing in on the rear of the middle box of B-17’s, turning in behind them.  I held my fire until I had closed within 300 yards, and fired from dead astern.  I saw two great flashes of flame and pieces flying off, and what appeared to be the JU 88, now smoking, heavily, did a very slow half turn and began to spin to the right. 

I broke upward and saw some ME 190’s coming down on us from two o’clock.  I turned into them and fired a deflection shot from about 300 yards at 10 degrees, at the last plane as he passed, noting strikes, but no further results. 

I then realized that I had lost my second element and found myself and my wingman toward the rear of the bombers.  We started to head across the bombers path to the forward section of the formation in an attempt to join up with someone, when I noted three twin-engined fighters coming down from above on the tail of the bomber formation to attack.  All three of them appeared to be carrying rockets.  I looked around, and I saw nothing above.  I decided to attack the last one, and closed in to about 250 yards.  Began firing and noted strikes on engine and rudder. 

I then looked in my rear vision mirror and saw a twin-engine fighter coming down from 7 o’clock and about half a mile away, apparently intent on attacking my wingman.  I called to him several times, telling him to break, but he apparently didn’t hear.  I wanted him to break first in order to get the enemy aircraft between him and myself.  As he did not break, I pulled up to the left in a Chandelle, hoping he would follow me.  The JU 88 that we had been firing at by this time had broken to the left and headed down in a steep dive, smoke and flames coming from one engine.  Lt. Stacker apparently tried to follow the first EA down further, because when I got to the top of my Chandelle, I saw that he had not followed me, but was in a dive with a twin-engine fighter closing on his tail.  Still calling to him to break, I turned to try to close on the twin-engine fighter.  At that moment Lt. Stacker pulled up, turning to the left at the same time.  At the same time I was able to pull my turn tighter and close within 300 yards of the twin-engine fighter.  I fired with about ten degree deflection, but my guns fired only about five or ten rounds and stopped.  I saw Lt. Stacker’s airplane turn over on its back at the top of his climb, smoke coming out from both engines with pieces falling off.  A large black object came out of the cockpit, which I assumed was the pilot. 

I looked behind me and saw five 190’s about to attack me from out of the sun.  I gave it full throttle and broke downward in an attempt to run away and join up with the other ships in the area.  The ME 109’s seemed to be closing on me so pulling about 55 inches I pulled upward in a very steep climb, and after about 5,000 feet they seemed to give up as they were falling back all the time. 

Before I could join any other P-38’s, I noticed one ME 109 coming out of the sun (this was at 30,000 feet from about 5 o’clock about 500 yards behind me).  With throttle full open and my nose slightly down, I finally managed to out-distance him after about 10 minutes.  I lost 5,000 feet, and the ME 109 had closed within range of me, and at one time managed to get a it on my propeller with 20 MM.  I finally lost him flying straight and level at 26,000 feet, pulling 60 inches, and indicating 300 miles per hour.  Each time that the E/A fired I skidded the plane violently and corckscrewed.  I could not do anything else as I was out of ammunition, and was afraid that if I turned into him, I wouldn’t have enough gas to get back home, even if I did evade him. 

I joined six P-38’s at the Dutch Coast.  Upon landing I found that I had had stoppages in two machine guns and also in the cannon.  My right prop had been pierced by a 20 MM shell about one-half the distance from tip to hub. 

Missing Air Crew Report for 2 Lt. John A. Stacker

The centrality of Missing Air Crew Reports (MACRs) in chronicling combat losses in the Army Air Force of WW II, and their secondary use in genealogy, have been evident since these documents were declassified in the mid-1980s.  They’re available in digital format via Fold3 at varying degrees of quality.  It’s unfortunate that the original paper documents – as such – have not been scanned and made available to the public, in the way that equally valuable archival records of other countries (such as Australia – the National Archives of Australia; such as England – the Commonwealth War Graves Commission; such as others) have been made freely available to the public at relatively high levels of resolution.

During a visit to NARA some time ago (in the era before the great COVID Coup of 2020) I was able to scan the MACR (# 1438) for Lt. Stacker.  As such, an image of Major Joel’s original account of his wingman’s loss appears below. 

Transcript of Missing Air Crew Report for 2 Lt. John A. Stacker

My wingman and I had already become separated from the other elements of the flight in previous encounters, and had fallen back towards the rear of the last box of bombers.  I observed three JU 88’s coming in for an attack on the rear of the bombers.

My wingman and I attacked the last JU 88 of the three.  As I closed in and fired, I chanced to look back and saw a twin-engine fighter coming in from 5 o’clock about half a mile away.  I called to Lieutenant Stacker, my wingman, telling him to break first with the idea that I could then break and possibly get behind the E/A.  My wingman was apparently intent on pressing home his attack on the E/A which had winged over with engine smoking. 

I must have called him about five times without result.  Meanwhile, the E/A was closing.  I made a definite break to the left and up, hoping my wingman would follow.  At the top of my break, I saw the E/A on my wingman’s tail at about 300 yards and firing.  I pulled my turn short to close in on the E/A, and at that time my wingman apparently saw him for he pulled straight up.  The E/A pulled up inside.  I closed to three or four hundred yards of the E/A and tried to fire.  I got only a few rounds out when my guns stopped.  My wingman at that time had pulled up steeply.  I saw pieces fly off the aircraft.  He rolled on his back with both engines smoking, and I saw some dark object leave the cockpit.  I was then attacked by four ME 109’s from behind and had to break.  Later, while still pursued by E/A, I looked back and saw what could have been a parachute or a burst of white smoke.

You can read about photographs in MACRs, and more, at my brother blog ThePastPresented, within the post The Missing Photos – Five Among the Missing.

This photograph, date and location, from the J Cook Photo Collection & Archives (image UPL29593), at the American Air Museum in Britain, shows Lt. Stacker (full name John Arthur Stacker) seated in the cockpit of a P-38.  He appears to be performing a ground test of his oxygen mask.  Text with the photo states, “Best friend of Col Bud Anderson 357th FG ace”.   

Alas, Lt. Stacker did not survive what was his fourth combat mission.  Flying P-38H 42-67059, his aircraft crashed at Klein-Mimmelage, Germany. He is buried at the Ardennes American Cemetery and Memorial at Neuville-en-Condroz, Belgium

Here are two articles from the Richmond Times-Dispatch reporting on Major Joel’s experiences on November 13, as published in that newspaper on the 14th. 

A transcript of the article…

Major Joel Reports Running Into Heavy German Opposition

The first of the returning flyers from a United States attack on Northern Germany today reported they had run into the heaviest of recent German fighter opposition, according to an Associated Press dispatch.  The contingent of airmen included a Richmonder who distinguished himself.

“The Germans had hundreds of fighters in the sky,” said Major Milton Joel, of 5 Greenway Lane, Richmond, a pilot of one of the escorting Lightning fighters.

“They had everything from ME-109s to JU-88s, and all the JU-88s were firing rocket shells,” he said.  “Wherever you turned there was an enemy plane at your side.  That’s how I got shots at so many.”

He was credited with one destroyed, two probables and one damaged.

And, another article, also published on November 14.

A transcript of the article…

Richmonder Blasts Nazis Over Bremen

Major Joel Leads Lightning Squadron

Major Milton Joel, 23-year-old Richmond leader of a Lighting squadron, was credited in an Associated Press dispatch with destroying a JU-88 and probably destroying another, as well as a ME-109, in yesterday’s raid on Bremen by the United States Eighth Air Force.

“The Germans had hundreds of fighters in the sky,” the dispatched quoted the major, who was among the first of the fliers to return to London from the raid.

“They had everything from ME-109s to JU-88s and all the JU-88s were firing rocket shells,” he said.  “Wherever you turned, there was an enemy plane at your side.  That’s how I got shots at so many.”

Yesterday’s attack on the great German industrial and shipping port results in the biggest American loss since the great daylight raid on Schweinfurt, October 14.  Nine fighters and 15 heavy bombers were lost in yesterday’s attack.

Major Joel, one of the contingent of airmen to distinguish themselves yesterday has been a pilot since 1939, having completed the pilot’s course at Richmond University, where he graduated with a B.S. degree.  He also attended the University of Virginia.  Major Joel received his second lieutenant’s commission in May, 1941, and his major’s commission and appointment in commander of a fighter squadron in October, 1942.

Before going overseas, Major Joel was stationed at Pendleton Field, Oreg., where he had the distinction of being the youngest major.

Major Joel is the only child of Mr. and Mrs. Joseph Joel, of Greenway Lane.

This article about the November 13 mission appeared in the Burlington Free Press on December 10.  Captain Eugene E. Ryan, referred to in the last paragraph, served in the 343rd Fighter Squadron.  According to USAF Credits for the Destruction of Enemy Aircraft, World War II, he was credited with one aerial victory for the mission.

Bombers Do Escort Duty For Fighter Planes
Usual Procedure Reversed After Raid on Bremen
By FRANKLIN BANKER

AT A U.S. FIGHTER BASE IN ENGLAND, Nov. 23.  (By Mail)  (AP) – It’s the job of American fighter planes to escort bombers to their targets – but sometimes it works in reverse.

Suck an incident was described by Lt. Col. Jack S. Jenkins of Levelland, Tex., who led a group of P-38 fighters escorting Flying Fortresses and Liberators during a raid on Bremen.

The twin – engined Lightnings, running into plenty of German fighter opposition on the Nov. 13 mission, had a tough day.  Several got back on one engine.  A number of others were shot down over Germany.

Two Lightnings with one engine shot out had Fortresses to thank for escorting them home.  Without their normal speed they would have been easy targets for German fighters.  The Lightnings were piloted by Lts. Peter Dempsey of Tacoma, Wash., and Fleming W. Suiter of Chesapeake, Ohio.

Stuck Close To B-17s

“They just stuck close to some B-17’s, who protected them all the way home,” said Col. Jenkins.  “The Fortresses did a good job bringing them around rain-clouds and showers.

“When a B-17 straggles, we help it.  When a fighter plane is knocked out of formation, the B-17s help it.  We work closely together.

“When a fighter pilot sees one of those big, queenly B-17s go down in flames, it gives him a terrific desire to get in there and do his job.”

The fighter pilots also must be quick at assisting fellow fighters.

Heroic Action

During another part of the aerial battle, Dempsey and Lt. Gerald Brown of East Ashland St., Phoenix, Ariz., were saved from German fighters by Capt. Joseph Myers of Canton, Ohio, a P-38 pilot.  One of Brown’s engines was shot out and his plane was peppered with bullet holes.

“Capt. Myers did a heroic thing,” said Jenkins, air executive officer of this base.  “He tucked them (Dempsey and Brown) in close together and shepherded them away from the target.  He probably warded off 20 fighter attacks in all.  Joe shot down an Me 109 which would have gotten Brown in another second or so.

“I don’t know how he ever got them out of there.  I recommended him for a decoration.”

Jenkins, whose Lightning was named the “Texas Ranger”, went to the defense of Lt. Morris Leve of 1,420 Cortelyou road, Brooklyn, N.Y., but wound up with Leve helping him out.

A Long Way Home

Heading back over the English Channel on one good engine, Jenkins ran into a 140 miles-an-hour headwind.  It took him an hour and a half to fly what normally would have taken 20 minutes.  Running low on gas and with his hydraulic brake system shot up, he had to make a belly landing at an away-from-base airfield.

During the homeward trip, the crippled P-38s of Jenkins and Capt. Jerry H. Avers of Haley, Tenn, were escorted by two Lightning pilots.

One of the day’s high “scorers” at this base was Capt. Eugene E. Ryan of Box 502, Darien, Conn., formerly of Lake Ave., Greenwich, Conn.  It was the first raid on which he got a good shot at enemy planes.  He destroyed two of them. 

Next: Part IV (2) – Autumn Over Europe – The “Flying Wolf” Identified

 

A Missing Man: Major Milton Joel, Fighter Pilot, 38th Fighter Squadron, 55th Fighter Group, 8th Air Force: I – A Fate Unknown

A Fate Unknown

War, whether in terms of international politics, economics, strategy, tactics, or the actual conduct of military campaigns, is by nature a collage of uncertainties.  However, there is another uncertainty inherent to war: one that can occur within the immediacy of battle, or, persist after (sometimes, long after) a conflict has actually ended, and the attention of men and nations has moved on. 

That uncertainty revolves around the fate of those who have not returned:

The missing.

Ever since the long-forgotten advent of organized human conflict, it has been inevitable that the fate of each and every soldier who fails to return from battle cannot be resolved with certainty.  This can be attributable to a number of factors: The physical setting of a battle; the circumstances – specifically, the nature of the weapons, ordnance, craft, or vehicles – by which a soldier has become a casualty and “missing”; the geographic remoteness of a clash with the enemy; the loss of military records, or, the inability to actually record the history of a battle in the first place; the faulty and fleeting memory of witnesses to a soldier’s fate, or, the not infrequent absence of such witnesses – whether immediate or long surviving – to begin with; a society’s desire – from the combined effects of psychological and spiritual exhaustion, economic prosperity, and simple apathy – to put the memory of the past to rest. *

All these factors – and more – in varying combination and degree, can stand in the way of definitively establishing the ultimate fate of a missing soldier. 

In terms of the historical memory of the American public, the central conflict in terms of collective memory – though that memory is steadily withering in the face of time, cultural change, and the oxymoron of “information technology” – during recent decades has been the Second World War.  Perhaps the collective memory of that war among the other Allied nations that participated in the conflict is undergoing a parallel transformation – albeit for factors unique to those societies. 

In terms of American servicemen Missing in Action (MIA) from the Second World War, Wikipedia’s entry states, “As of October 9, 2020, according to the U.S. Department of Defense POW/MIA Accounting Agency, there were still 72,562 U.S. servicemen and civilians still unaccounted for from World War II.”  State by state lists of the names of these men can be found at the Defense POW/MIA Accounting Agency.

Though I don’t have precise figures at the moment, a significant proportion of these missing servicemen is, I think, comprised of naval personnel and aviators who were lost at sea, the chances of their physical recovery and identification probably being miniscule.  Other MIAs, however – army ground forces personnel as well as aviators – lost, or presumed to have been lost among the islands of the Pacific, Continental Europe, and perhaps other theatres of war, may in time still be found. 

One such man was Major Milton Joel of Richmond, Virginia.  A P-38 Lightning fighter pilot and squadron commander in the United States Army Air Force – specifically the English-based 8th Air Force – he was lost during aerial combat with the German Luftwaffe during a bomber escort mission over northern Europe on Monday, November 29, 1943. 

He was one of some 750 Jews who served as fighter pilots during the Second World War.  Roughly 500 of these men were Americans – primarily in the United States Army Air Force, and secondarily in the Navy and Marine Corps – while some 250 others served in the air arms of other Allied nations.  Since these numbers are mainly based upon documents pertaining to casualties, per se, there were doubtless others whose names are unknown.  

________________________________________

Major Joel has never been found.  

This series of posts presents his story.

________________________________________

Milton Joel as a Lieutenant or Captain, during his service with the 27th Fighter Squadron of the 1st Fighter Group.

____________________

A Lockheed P-38 Lighting (Same aircraft in both pictures.)

The aircraft illustrated in this pair of photos (P-38H 42-67079) was not Major Joel’s “personal” fighter plane.  Rather, these are excellent representative images, in that they very clearly display the P-38’s twin-engine / twin-boom / twin-tail / central fuselage pod / in-line-engine configuration, the design of which was a remarkably successful blend of function, performance, and dare I say? (yes, absolutely I say!) aesthetics. 

The black & white picture is from the P-38 Lightning History at TheWorldWars, while the color photo is a postcard (remember those?) that was manufactured some decades back by “John Fry Productions” of San Diego, California, the actual card having been printed by MCA Color Graphics of Kansas City.  The postcard’s very simple caption states “LOCKHEED P-38H “Lightning” (Lockheed Photo)”, thus verifying the origin of the image. 

On close examination of the pictures, you can see that the pictures display the P-38 from slightly different angles.  The relative position of the mountain (in the black and white image, you cans see that it’s receded behind the plane) shows that upper (color) image was taken first, followed by the black & white photo.

The absence of any unit insignia on this aircraft – implying that it had not yet been transferred to the Army Air Force – and the mountainous terrain over which the plane’s flying, suggest that the photographs were taken during a post-manufacture test / publicity flight over southern California.  The light-colored (red) surround to the national insignia verifies that the pair of images were taken between late June and mid-August of 1943.

P-38H 42-67079 would eventually be assigned to the 338th Fighter Squadron of the 55th Fighter Group, where it would bear the squadron code “CL * T” of the 338th Fighter Squadron, coincidentally a brother squadron of the 55th Fighter Group’s 38th Fighter Squadron, the latter having been commanded by Major Joel.  Given the absence of a Missing Air Crew Report, or, Accident Report for “CL * T”, the warplane presumably survived its combat missions, probably having eventually been salvaged for parts, or scrapped.  Its components – aluminum and steel; pleixglass and bakelite; and more – perhaps in a small way eventually became became part of the postwar world. 

And, even if the memory of that “world” and the era before it is now vanishing, we can still remember it.  At least, for a little while.

____________________ ____________________

*And now, as we’re experiencing in the “West” during the early decades of the twenty-first century, an antinomian, secularized religious frenzy, paralleling the millennarian social unrest that persisted in central and western Europe from the eleventh through the sixteenth centuries, as described in great depth and tremendous insight by Norman Cohn in The Pursuit of the Millennium.  The ultimate outcome of this phenomenon (it’s far more than a mere phenomenon!) – partially arising from the intellectual, social, and physical detachment from “reality” of much of the atrophying Wests’s secularized, credentialed, “professional” classes – is thus far unknown.

Well, for the moment. 

Now, that could be the subject of interesting post!  But, since that topic continues to be addressed elsewhere, back to the subject at hand…

Next: Part II – From Proskurov to Richmond

Soldiers from New York: Jewish Soldiers in The New York Times, in World War Two: Hospital Apprentice 1st Class Stuart E. Adler – March 15, 1945 [Revised post…]

History does not end: It persists.   

An ongoing aspect of this blog has been the presentation of information about American Jewish WW II military casualties in the context of news items about Jewish servicemen that appeared in The New York Times between 1941 and 1945.  As such, I’ve created and organized such posts in the simplest manner possible – alphabetically, by the soldier’s surname – the posts thus far encompassing servicemen whose surnames began with the letters “A” through “J”. 

This information emerged from my research into identifying relevant articles and news items found by manually scrolling through every issue of The New York Times published between 1941 and 1946, on 35mm microfilm.  (Microfilm, you ask?  Well, this was a few years ago.) 

I focused on Times because I initially assumed that the combination of the newspaper’s status, scope of news coverage, and especially its geographic setting in the New York metropolitan area (sort of the symbolic and demographic center of American Jewish life) would have resulted in its featuring information about the role of American Jewish soldiers to a greater degree than other national publications, and this specifically in the context of the Second World War having been – even if it was unrecognized, denied, or ignored at the time – parallel battles for the survival of the Jewish people, and, the Allied nations.

In the process, I discovered I was half right. 

Certainly the paper featured many, many (many) such items, as well as – alas, inevitably – many obituaries (particularly from 1944 through 1946) for Jewish soldiers, sailors, marines, and airmen who lost their lives in the conflict. 

In the same process, I learned I was half wrong. 

I was soon disabused of my assumptions about the Times’ coverage of Jewish military service, for Jewish participation in the war never seemed to have been perceived or recognized as such by the newspaper, to begin with.  Every article, news item, and (yes, too) obituary about or alluding to Jewish servicemen was absent of any mention of the war’s ideological underpinnings – at least in the European Theater – and its implications in terms of the collective survival of the Jewish people.  Then again, among WW II issues of other American newspapers I’ve reviewed (not as thoroughly as the Times, but deeply enough), I found this to have been equally so, and really no differently perceived by Jewish newspapers, as well.

Here’s how this subject was approached by The Jewish Exponent in its issue of August 4, 1944, in which the newspaper began to specifically focus on coverage of the military service of Jewish soldiers from the Philadelphia metropolitan area.  In light of the era, that the Exponent attempted to cover this topic in a comprehensive manner to begin with, stands to its credit. 

The text of this article follows below.  I’ve italicized some key passages….

Our Sons and Daughters In the Armed Forces

The Day-to-Day Story of Their Valor and Heroism

Please Note

We want to tell the entire community about the heroism, sacrifices and contributions of our Jewish men and women of Philadelphia serving in the armed forces at home and abroad.  Mail letters, photographs, citations, communications from the War Department and other items of interest about your son or daughter, husband, relative or friend in the service to the Jewish Exponent, Widener Building, Philadelphia, 7, Pa.

All such data will be documented by the Jewish Welfare Board, and within the uncontrollable limitations of space, will be published in these columns each week.

Today, thousands of Philadelphia’s sons and daughters of Jewish faith are making an imperishable record of American heroism and sacrifice, following in the tradition of their fathers who served with courage, loyalty and devotion in every crisis that has confronted our Nation – a glorious tradition that began with Chyam Solomon and reaffirmed with Meyer Levin.

To them, we respectfully dedicate these columns.  Not merely to show the undying patriotism of the Jews of Philadelphia, but that in doing so they are emphasizing their Americanism and the inestimable value of this great country’s heritage of racial and religious freedom.

KILLED IN ACTION

Until entering the service in October, 1942, Private Wallace Jay Epstein, 5034 “D” St., was associated with his father’s business, the Regal Corrugated Box Co.  Since March, 1943, he served overseas, and earlier this month, his parents, Mr. and Mrs. Abraham Epstein, were notified that their 19-year-old son died of wounds in France.

Also entering service in October, 1942, was Private First Class Morris Cherry, 100 East Meehan Street, in Germantown.  A well-known amateur photographer, he was sent overseas last February.  His parents, Mr. and Mrs. B. Cherry, were informed by the War Department that he was killed in France.

Killed in action in France was 10-year-old Private Harold G. Miltenberger, 2208 Bainbridge Street, who first took up arms in September, 1943, and went overseas in April.

WEST POINT GRADUATE

The youngest member of his graduating class at the U.S. Military Academy at West Point in June, 1943, Lieutenant Colonel Paul H. Berkowitz, 31, son of Mr. and Mrs. William F. Berkowitz of 434 West Ellett Street, Mt. Airy, has been reported missing since July 26 in the Southwest Pacific area while returning to his base in Australia from a mission in this country.

Nine months after his marriage to the former Jeanne Grandy, of Portland, Me., in April, 1942, he went overseas to command a topographical battalion of Army engineers.  He did not return to this country until last June on a mission from the Pacific, where his wife joined him on the West Coast to mark their third wedding anniversary, the first they had been able to celebrate.

His sister, Sylvia, is the husband [sic] of Major Charles S. Morrow, Newark, N.J., heart specialist, serving with the Medical Corps in Panama.

Also “missing in action” is First Class Seaman Raphael Weinstein, 18-year-old hospital attendant, of 621 Parrish Street.  A Graduate of Northeast High School, he has a brother, Corporal Joseph, 21 years old, serving in the Army.

FLAME OF HOPE

This is the story of the type of faith to which thousands of parents of sons reported killed or missing in action are clinging.  Ordinarily, Samuel Gross and his wife, Freda, 3026 West Susquehanna Avenue, place little credence in “second-hand news”.  But a bit of “second-hand news” relayed to them over thousands of miles has kept their spirits buoyed up since July 17.

It was back in January that they received word their 22-year-old son, Technical Sergeant Joseph Gross, was missing in action over France, when the Flying Fortress on which he was a gunner and radio operator was shot down, over Bordeaux.  But the flame of hope for their son, one of two in the armed forces, burned feebly.

Then a letter received from the mother of Lt. James Bradley, of Lido, N.M., fanned the flame of hope into a burning conviction that their son was alive.  She revealed that she had received a letter from a French woman who told how her son and three other members of the crew of the plane, including Gross, had been picked up by a Frenchman, hidden and smuggled out of France.  An then the other day a cable from Sgt. Gross to his parents.  It read: “All well and safe.”

Sgt. Gross, an honor graduate of West Philadelphia High School, class of 1939, joined the Air Force in September, 1942.  His 18-year-old brother, Morris, is an aviation cadet at San Antonio, Tex., and his wife, Martha, 21, lives at 5405 Walnut Street.

The same flame of hope now burns brightly for Mrs. Rae W. Fleishman, 4600 North Marvine Street, who was officially notified this week that her 20-year-old son, Second Lieutenant Milton H. Fleishman, a navigator on a B-24, who was missing over France, is safe.  He has two other brothers in the service, William, a signalman in the Navy, and Leon, a sergeant in the Army Transport Command.

Reported missing in June, Mr. and Mrs. S. Finkelstein, 5814 Montrose Street, were informed this week by the War Department that their 19-year-old son, Private Morris M. Finkelstein, is a prisoner of the German government.  A brother, Alex F., is also an Army private.

(Portrait of Morris M. (Martin) Finkelstein, from the Honoree Page at the WW II Memorial created in his honor by his daughter.  A member of H Company, 505th Parachute Infantry Regiment, 82nd Airborne Division, he was captured on D-Day, and spent the remainder of the war at Stalag 4B (Muhlberg).  The son of Samuel and Mollie Finkelstein, his name never appeared in American Jews in World War II.)

THE MARINES ARE IN

The largest group of First Division Marines to be returned from combat duty in the South Pacific landed by transport at San Diego.  These were all men from the famous First Division, that fighting group which started America’s offensive against the Japs on August 7, 1942.  Among this group was Private First Class Martin S. Rothstein, 24 years of age, husband of Megan Rothstein and son of Mr. and Mrs. Samnuel Rothstein, 6116 Castor Avenue.

WITH THE LADIES

The welcome mat is getting a special dusting at 4550 “D” Street, where Mr. and Mrs. Harry Applebaum are eagerly awaiting the homecoming this week of Corporal Zelda Applenbaum, her first furlough since joining the U.S. Women’s Marine Corps 17 months ago, and stationed at San Francisco.  Zelda’s sister, Apprentice Seaman Betty B. Applebaum, is in the WAVES, stationed at Hunters College, New York.

Proud parents are Mr. and Mrs. Nathan Lazar, 424 Tree Street, whose daughter, Seaman First Class Bettye Lazar, graduated this week from the WAVES Naval Training School at Stillwater, Okla.

WOUNDED IN ACTION

Private Gilbert B. Shapiro, 24, husband of Mrs. Claire B. Shapiro, 3864 Poplar Street, was wounded in France.  An infantryman, he attended Overbrook and Central High Schools and worked in the fur business until joining the service in October, 1942.  He has been overseas since last January.  A brother, Milton, is a captain in the Army.

Private Irving I. Bleiman, 17, son of Harry B. Bleiman, 494 North 3rd Street, was wounded on Saipan Island in the Pacific while fighting with the Marine Corps.

Staff Sergeant Morris Krivitsky, husband of Mrs. Charlotte Krivitsky, 5009 “B” Street, was reported wounded in action.

Technical Sergeant Arnold Miller, son of Mrs. Fannie Miller, 2518 South Marshall Street, in the European Theatre.

Private Armand F. Eiseman, son of Mrs. Rose Weiss, 1594 North 52nd Street, in the European theatre.

Private Herman S. Hershman, 19, son of Mr. and Mrs. Joseph Hershman, 4515 North 13th Street, was wounded in France.

Private David Polnerow
, son of Mr. and Mrs. Morris Polnerow, 4822 North 9th Street, is recuperating in a hospital in England from wounds received in action in France.

Private Aaron Leibowitz, 5383 Columbia Avenue, was wounded in France, his brother Philip was notified.

Private Alexander Glick, 33, husband of Mrs. Lena Glick, 524 South 60th Street, in the European theatre.  Before joining the Army in April, 1943, he worked as a salesman, and went overseas last November.

Staff Sergeant Martin Glickman, son of Boris Glickman, 7919 Harley Avenue.

________________________________________

Anyway, regarding the Times, only over time (accidental pun…) did I arrive at an appreciation of the evolution and ideological orientation of the newspaper, in terms of the collective identity and survival of the Jewish people as a people (not merely a religious group).  This was through such works as Laurel Leff’s Buried By the Times, which revealed how strongly the Times’ ethos influenced wartime coverage of the Shoah by the news media, in general.  Does this perhaps irrevocably ingrained attitude continue to animate that newspaper’s news reporting concerning the Jewish people and especially the nation-state of Israel?  Well,…

Not merely a sign of the Times, but an ongoing sign of our “times”…

________________________________________

In any event, my first post about this topic appeared on April 30, 2017 and pertained to Navy Hospital Apprentice First Class Stuart Adler, who was killed on Okinawa on March 15, 1945. 

The post was limited in scope, only covering Jewish naval personnel and Marines who were casualties on that March day.  Nearly three years having passed since April of 2017, I thought it worthwhile to revisit the post to correct a few inaccuracies, and of far greater importance, add records about some of that day’s other Jewish military casualties.

As a result, the post is now a little longer than it was three years ago.

________________________________________

Finally, more than a little “off-topic” but very much “on time” (that is, time past): An artifact from March of 1945:  That month’s issue of Astounding Science Fiction

And herewith, back to the post…

________________________________________

________________________________________

Notice about Hospital Apprentice Stuart Emanuel Adler (7124266) appeared in a Casualty List published in The New York Times on May 17, 1945.  Stuart was attached to the 1st Marine Battalion, 21st Marine Regiment, 3rd Marine Division when he was killed on Iwo Jima by a sniper, while attempting to render medical aid to a wounded Marine.  Born on May 2, 1926, he is buried at the Washington Cemetery in Brooklyn, N.Y. (Chevra Anshe Ragole, Section 4, Post 440)

His obituary, transcribed below, was published on August 9, 1945.

__________

Slain Hospital Apprentice Honored by His Comrades

Hospital Apprentice Stuart Adler, 18 years old, who was killed on March 15 on Iwo Island by a Japanese sniper’s bullet, has been honored by his comrades, who have named a company street on Iwo in his memory.

In a recent letter to his mother, Mrs. Betty Lee Adler of 245 East Gunhill Road, Maj. Gen. G.B. Erskine, Marine Corps, praised the youth’s “devotion to duty”.

Enlisting in the Navy on Feb. 8, 1944, shortly after his graduation from DeWitt Clinton High School, he was attached to the First Battalion, Twenty-First Marines, during the Iwo Campaign.  He was killed when he went to the aid of a wounded marine.

A younger brother, Robert; a sister, Faith, and his father, David Adler, also survive.

These are contemporary (2010-ish) views – from apartments.com – of the Adler family’s wartime residence: 245 East Gunhill Road, in the Bronx.

________________________________________

Saperstein, Charles (Yekutiel ben Hayyim), MoMM1C, 6425696, Motor Machinist’s Mate
Born 1921
United States Navy, Probably crew member of LCT(6) – #36
Mr. Herman Saperstein (father), 32 Lakeview Drive, Silvermine, Norwalk, Ct.
Memorialized on Tablets of the Missing at Manila American Cemetery, Manila, Philippines
Memorial matzeva at Beth Israel Cemetery, Norwalk, Ct.
Casualty List 5/27/45
American Jews in World War II – 69

Finkelstein, Albert Jacob, HA1C, 7109973, Hospital Apprentice
United States Navy, 5th Marine Division, 31st Replacement Battalion (attached)
Mr. Samuel Finkelstein (father), 1445 Saint Marks Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Place of burial unknown
Casualty List 6/30/45
American Jews in World War II – not listed

Photograph via ShaneO

Wounded in Action

Percoff, Manuel, PFC, 884682
United States Marine Corps, 5th Marine Division, 28th Marine Regiment, 2nd Battalion, Headquarters Company
Mr. Sam Percoff (father), Laurel, Mississippi
Casualty List 6/6/45
American Jews in World War II – 206

Swarts, John Leonard, Cpl. 863329
United States Marine Corps, 2nd Armored Amphibious Division, C Company
Mrs. Rosalind M. Swarts (wife), 225 West End Ave., New York, N.Y.
Born New York, N.Y. 1/14/12, Died 8/17/03
American Jews in World War II – 459

________________________________________

Some other Jewish military casualties on Thursday, March 15, 1945 (1 Nisan 5705) include…

Killed in Action

– .ת.נ.צ.ב.ה. –

United States Army (Ground Forces)

Amira, Ralph (“Robert”?), S/Sgt., 32398826, Silver Star, Purple Heart
11th Airborne Division, 188th Glider Infantry Regiment, B Company
Mr. and Mrs. Isaac Becky (Rebecca?) Amira (parents), 1920 24th Ave., Astoria, Long Island, N.Y.
Mount Hebron Cemetery, Flushing, N.Y. – (Possibly Block 12, Reference 3, Section A, Line E/F, Grave 12, Society Life & Charity / Source of Life); Buried 4/12/49
Casualty List 4/14/45
Long Island Star Journal 9/23/48
American Jews in World War II – 265

Auerbach
, Robert, PFC, 12219224, Infantry, Purple Heart, 1 Oak Leaf Cluster

(Wounded previously, on 12/3/44)
103rd Infantry Division, 410th Infantry Regiment, K Company
Born 1924
Mrs. Mildred Auerbach (mother), 1132 Fulton St., Woodmere, N.Y.
Long Island National Cemetery, Farmingdale, N.Y. – Section J, Grave 16229
Casualty List 4/10/45
American Jews in World War II – 267

Bass, Solomon, M/Sgt., 6667553, Infantry
United States Army, 45th Infantry Division, 157th Infantry Regiment
Born 1922
Mrs. Adelle Bass (wife), 916 Parkwood Drive, Cleveland, Oh.
Pvt. Jack Bass and Mrs. Ann Falcone (brother and sister)
Zachary Taylor National Cemetery, Louisville, Ky. – Section I, Grave 231
Cleveland Press & Plain Dealer 9/10/45
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

________________________________________

Bernstein, Louis (Levi bar Levi), PFC, 32876996, Infantry, Purple Heart, 1 Oak Leaf Cluster
3rd Infantry Division, 30th Infantry Regiment
(Wounded previously, around 2/25/44 and 10/20/44)
Born 1910
Mrs. Beatrice Bernstein (wife), 1163 President St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Beth David Cemetery, Elmont, N.Y.
Casualty Lists 3/25/44, 12/20/44, and 4/10/45
American Jews in World War II – 276

Photograph of matzeva by Lainie Cat

________________________________________

Cantor, Alvin D., PFC, 42108329, Infantry, Purple Heart
100th Infantry Division, 397th Infantry Regiment
39 North Park Ave., Buffalo, N.Y.
Lorraine American Cemetery, St. Avold, France – Plot B, Row 18, Grave 56
Buffalo Courier-Express 12/31/44, 5/8/45
American Jews in World War II – 287

________________________________________

Cohn, Jack B. (Yakov Benymain bar David Haayim), PFC, 32923274, Infantry, Purple Heart, on Luzon Island, Philippines
25th Infantry Division, 161st Infantry Regiment
Born 2/19/23
Mrs. Anna Cohn (mother), New Brunswick, N.J.
Poile Zedek Cemetery, New Brunswick, N.J.
Casualty List 5/5/45
American Jews in World War II – 230

Photograph of matzeva by F Priam

________________________________________

Cohn, Jack L., T/5, 37604995, Signal Corps, Purple Heart
103rd Infantry Division, 103rd Signal Company
Born 1913
Mrs. Ida Cohn (mother), 5883 Maffitt Ave., St. Louis, Mo.
Chevra Kadisha Adas B’Nai Israel Vyeshurun, University City, St. Louis, Mo.
Saint Louis Post Dispatch 3/28/45 and 3/29/45
American Jews in World War II – 208

Drucker, Simon, PFC, 32882827, Infantry, Purple Heart
3rd Infantry Division, 7th Infantry Regiment, Headquarters Company, 3rd Battalion
Born 3/30/20
Mrs. Fanny Drucker (mother) and Mr. Morris Drucker (brother), 721 Van Sicklen Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Mount Hebron Cemetery, Flushing, N.Y. – Block 25, Reference 12, Section I, Line 6, Grave 14, Society 1st Toporower S&B
Casualty List 4/14/45
American Jews in World War II – 299

Farash, Solomon, Pvt., 32420791, Infantry, Purple Heart
36th Infantry Division, 142nd Infantry Regiment, Headquarters Company
Born 1921
Mr. Hyman Farash (father), 250 New Lots Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Also Pittsburgh, Pa.
Cemetery unknown
Casualty List 4/14/45
American Jews in World War II – 305

Finer, Morris L., 2 Lt., 0-2005368, Infantry, Purple Heart
99th Infantry Division, 393rd Infantry Regiment
Born 1920
Mr. Miller Finer (father), Greene and Johnson Streets, Philadelphia, Pa.
Mount Sinai Cemetery, Philadelphia, Pa.
The Jewish Exponent 4/20/45
The Philadelphia Record 4/12/45
American Jews in World War II – 520

________________________________________

Fleck, Jack (Yakov bar Pesach HaLevi), Cpl., 35510000, Purple Heart, in Germany
290th Field Artillery Observation Battalion
Born Youngtown, Oh., 7/7/22
Mr. and Mrs. Peter and Getrude (Sachs) Fleck (parents), 741 Kenilworth SE, Niles, Oh.
Also Warren, Oh.
Bernard and Irwin (brothers), Mrs. M. Reisman (sister)
Ohio State University Class of 1945
Beth Israel Cemetery, Warren, Oh.; Buried 11/19/47
Warren Tribune Chronicle 11/17/47
American Jews in World War II – 486

This is Corporal Fleck’s obituary from the Warren Tribune Chronicle of November 17, 1947, provided by FindAGrave contributor Rick Nelson

________________________________________

Geller, Seymour L., 2 Lt., 0-1329107, Infantry, Purple Heart
36th Infantry Division, 142nd Infantry Regiment, F Company
Born 1921
Mrs. Seymour L. Geller (wife), c/o H. Cohen, 85 McClellan St., Bronx, N.Y.
Also 1727 Walton Ave., New York, N.Y.
Cemetery unknown
Casualty List 4/14/45
The New York Times – Obituary Page (In Memoriam Section) 3/15/46
American Jews in World War II – 319

Gold
, Louis, Pvt., 16185802, Infantry, Purple Heart
36th Infantry Division, 142nd Infantry Regiment, G Company
Mr. Charles Gold (father), 6632 South Troy St., Chicago, Il.
Lorraine American Cemetery, St. Avold, France – Plot K, Row 14, Grave 10
Casualty List 6/10/45
American Jews in World War II – 100

Horowitz, Bernard L., 2 Lt., 0-534380, Bronze Star Medal, 2 Oak Leaf Clusters, Purple Heart
9th Infantry Division, 746th Tank Battalion
(Wounded previously, around 12/16/44 and 1/15/45)
Born 2/8/23
Mr. Isaac M. Horowitz (father), 2-12 Sickles St., New York, N.Y.
Mr. Gilbert Horowitz (?), 1155 Walton Ave., c/o Kessler, Bronx, N.Y.
City College of New York Class of 1943
Cedar Park Cemetery, New York, N.Y.
Casualty Lists 2/28/45 and 4/12/45
American Jews in World War II – 348

Klein, Bernard, PFC, 32249842, Infantry, Purple Heart
3rd Infantry Division, 7th Infantry Regiment
Born 3/6/15
Bronx, N.Y.
Long Island National Cemetery, Farmingdale, N.Y. – Section J, Grave 15567
American Jews in World War II – 363

________________________________________

Lebrecht, Alfred W., PFC, 32897544, Infantry, Purple Heart
3rd Infantry Division, 15th Infantry Regiment
Mr. and Mrs. William and Emma F. Lebrecht (parents), 920 Riverside Drive, New York, N.Y.
Lorraine American Cemetery, St. Avold, France – Plot B, Row 31, Grave 13
Casualty List 4/17/45
New York Post 1/21/51
Jewish Criterion (Pittsburgh) 9/20/46 – “Double Gold Stars”, by Helen Kantzler
American Jews in World War II – 373

 

Photograph of Alfred’s matzeva by Marc Burba

Among the many families who lost multiple sons during the war – profiled in Helen Kantzler’s 1946 Jewish Criterion article “Double Gold Stars” – was that of William and Emma Lebrecht, German refugees who arrived in the United States in 1939.  Alfred’s older brother Ferdinand was killed on February 20, 1945, while serving in the 10th Mountain Division. 

The brothers (Alfred’s matzeva shown above and Ferdinand’s below) are buried adjacent to one another at the Lorraine American Cemetery in Saint Avold, France.

Lebrecht, Ferdinand, PFC, 32695706, Bronze Star Medal, Silver Star, Purple Heart
10th Mountain Division, 85th Mountain Infantry Regiment, L Company
KIA 2/20/45
Lorraine American Cemetery, St. Avold, France – Plot B, Row 31, Grave 14

Jewish Criterion (Pittsburgh) 9/20/46 – “Double Gold Stars”, by Helen Kantzler
New York Post 1/19/51, 1/21/51
American Jews in World War II
– 573
Casualty List 3/20/45
Lorraine American Cemetery, St. Avold, France – Plot B, Row 31, Grave 14

 

Photograph of Ferdinand’s matzeva by Marc Burba

The incident in which Ferdinand was killed in action is described at Next Exit History:

18 Feb 45 • On the evening of the 18th, 700 men of the 86th Regiment make a daring night climb and successful assault on Riva Ridge, which rises steeply 1700-2000 feet above the rushing Dardagna River.  Using five carefully prepared climbing routes, including two that require fixed ropes, the attack takes the enemy by complete surprise.

American casualties result from fierce counterattacks that occur over the next four days.  For their heroism on Riva Ridge, three soldiers receive Silver Stars posthumously:

Pvt. Michael G. Bostonia (33938591, Washington County, Pa.)

Pfc. Ferdinand Lebrecht, and

1st Lt. John A. McCown II (0-1305285, Philadelphia, Pa.)

Eight other Silver Stars are awarded to: Pfc. Jack A. Booh [?], Pfc. Franklyn C. Fairweather, 1st Lt. Frank D. Gorham, Jr., 2nd Lt. Floyd P. Hallett, Lt. Col. Henry J. Hampton, 1st Lt. James W. Loose, Jr., Pfc. Roy Steen, and S/Sgt. Robert P. Thompson.

Two days later, engineers from D. Company of the 126th Engineers complete an aerial tramway to a point near the top of one of Riva’s peaks, Mt. Cappel Buso.  On the first day of operation, 30 wounded are evacuated and 5 tons of supplies delivered.

Just before midnight, without artillery preparation, five other battalions of the 10th Mountain Division begin their attack of Mt. Belvedere and its sister peak, Mt. Gorgolesco.  Orders are to use only grenades and bayonets until first light.  By dawn the positions have been taken.

____________________

Here is another account of Ferdinand’s last battle, from Charles J. Sanders’ The Boys of Winter – Life and Death in the U.S. Ski Troops During the Second World War:

Fortuitously obscured by a dense fog, the climbers attacked the stunned Nazi defenders at dawn.  The Germans fell back in confusion as the Tenth Mountaineers charged out of the mist, firing and hurling grenades, and screaming demands for surrender.  A number of the enemy capitulated, but the rest quickly regrouped.  The Americans then endured fierce counterattacks throughout the following days, as the enemy desperately and unsuccessfully tried to stave off the main attack on Belvedere and its sister peaks by attempting to recapture the heights of Riva.  Among the many who would give their lives holding this precious ground was Private Ferdinand Lebrecht of 86 C.  He was a big Austrian-born mountaineer who had knelt in prayer with Jacques Parker and the others in the tiny attic at the base of Rive prior to the climb.

____________________

The story of the Lebrecht brothers appeared as two articles in The New York Post in January of 1951.  The first article follows (transcribed below)…

Dad Receives 10 Hero Awards For GI Killed in Italy in 1945

The New York Post
January 19, 1951

The father of an Upper Manhattan soldiers killed in World War II near Mt. Sarrasiccia, Italy, on Feb. 20, 1945, today received belated recognition for the heroic feats of his son.

A Silver Star, Bronze Star Medal and eight other awards were presented to William Lebrecht, 920 Riverside Dr., father of PFC Ferdinand Lebrecht, who was 26 at the time of death, by 1st Army officials at a quiet ceremony in his home.

Official notification of the outstanding role played by young Lebrecht was received by the father a month ago in the form of a letter from the Army Dept., office of the Adjutant General, St. Louis, Mo.  The letter said that, after five years of search, missing copies of general Army orders had been located, disclosing Lebrecht’s courageous record under fire.

First word of his son’s bravery came to Lebrecht from young men who kept dropping into his home during the past five years.  Each said that, “Ferdie helped to save my life.”

The official message, signed by Col. John J. Donovan, said: “During a recent examination of the retained records of the 10th Mountain Division, the missing copies of General Orders announcing the award of the Silver Star to your son, service number 32,695,706, were located.

“Your pride in the gallantry displayed by your son in rendering aid to his wounded comrades while subjected to intense fire, will no doubt alleviate to some extent the grief caused by your great loss and the delay in receiving evidence of his heroism.

“It is hoped that these mementoes of your son’s outstanding service will be a source of comfort to you.  They are tangible evidence of his country’s gratitude for the gallantry and devotion to duty that your son so courageously and heroically displayed.”

The general order itself, dated Nov. 21, 1945, specifying the posthumous award of the Silver Star, told of the uptown soldier’s care for his wounded comrades and how he died in the act of aiding his squad leader and several other men unable to move because of severe wounds suffered during fighting in a “most forward area.”

…while here is the second article, accompanied by a photograph of William, seated with Emma, holding his sons’ portraits.  Their sons’ Purple Hearts are on the right, and Ferdinand’s Silver and Bronze Stars on the left.

Father Has 10 Medals For Son Slain in War

The New York Post
January 21, 1951

It’s official now. 

William Lebrecht, 920 Riverside Dr., has 10 medals, including a posthumous Silver Star, to prove that his son, Ferdinand, 26, a private, first class, died a hero on Mt. Sarrasiccia in Italy five years ago.

But the grieving exporter, who fled to this country from Nazi Germany in 1939, also had the sad memory of another son lost in World War II.  Both sons had given their lives for the country in which he had hoped they would live in freedom.

The uptown man yesterday told the story of his sons, after an Army major and a captain came to his home last week from First Army Headquarters on Governor’s Island to bring him Ferdinand’s hero citation, which had been lost in heaps of Army records since Feb. 20, 1945.

And in recalling his sorrows, he revealed that the second son, Pfc. Alfred Lebrecht, 21, had been killed by Nazis while fighting on the Metz front in France – just 20 days after the older brother fell in action.

“Within a few short weeks,” the father said yesterday, speaking for himself and for his wife, Emma, “we lost everything we lived for.”

The death of Alfred was an especially bitter blow, since his parents had tried in vain to save him.

Soon after they learned of Ferdinand’s death, they went to Washington and begged that Alfred be withdrawn from the fighting front.  War Dept. officials told them, however, that such measures were taken only after two fatal casualties in a family.

The Lebrechts returned home, only to receive word a week later that Alfred too had been killed.

A sergeant in Alfred’s outfit later told the father than the younger brother had been grieving about Ferdinand’s death at the time he was killed.

“He was so downcast,” the sergeant said, “that he just moved about in a daze.”

Told of Son’s Heroism.

The elder Lebrecht might never have known of Ferdinand’s posthumous citation had it not been for one of the beneficiaries of his son’s heroism. One of the eight men the young soldier saved in the action which cost his life visited the father and told him of the citation.

The War Dept., however, at that time reported it had no record of the citation, indicating that the records were lost.  But after years of searching, they were turned up a month ago.

I don’t know if the Post reported any further stories about the Lebrecht family. 

Then again, what more could be said?

________________________________________

Salus, Joseph W., PFC, 42057443, Infantry, Purple Heart
100th Infantry Division, 399th Infantry Regiment
Mr. Joseph Salus (father)
Mr. Francois Salus, Mr. Harry Salus, and Mr. William Salus (sons), 3560 Rochambeau Ave., New York, N.Y.
Harriet Hammer Minde (cousin); Gerson and Miriam Goldman (niece and nephew)
Cemetery unknown; Buried 9/28/48
Casualty List 4/19/45
Long Island Star Journal 4/7/45
The New York Times – Obituary Pages 9/27/48 and 9/28/48
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

________________________________________

Semansky, Jack, Pvt., 36914179, Infantry, Purple Heart
78th Infantry Division, 311th Infantry Regiment, L Company
Born Detroit, Mi., 3/4/26
Mr. and Mrs. Louis [1891-8/2/60] and Nettie [1895-7/15/69] Semansky (parents), Elmhurst Ave., Detroit, Mi.
Mrs. Ann Gertrude (Semansky) Golden and Clare (Semansky) Tierman (sisters)
Machpelah Cemetery, Ferndale, Mi. – Section 6, Lot 18, Grave 151D; Buried 11/23/47
Detroit Jewish Chronicle 10/31/47
The Jewish News (Detroit) 6/15/45
American Jews in World War II – 195

An article about Private Semansky from the Detroit Jewish Chronicle of October 31, 1947…

Though genealogical information about soldiers is not difficult to find, locating images of their next of kin is much more problematic.  The case of Private Semansky is an exception: The lady below is his mother Nettie, as she appeared in an article in the Detroit Jewish Chronicle of May 7, 1943, at the age of forty-eight. 

________________________________________

Sweet, Albert, S/Sgt., 36715694, Infantry, Purple Heart, in France
103rd Infantry Division, 411th Infantry Regiment, A Company
Born 10/21/05
Mrs. Judy Sweet (daughter)
Mr. and Mrs. Fishel and Rose Swislowsky (parents), Mrs. Annie Lohn (sister), 1542 S. Drake Ave., Chicago, Il.
Waldheim Jewish Cemetery (Ticktin Cemetery), Forest Park, Il.
American Jews in World War II – 118

Photograph of matzeva by Bernie_L

________________________________________

Theodore, Julius (Yehuda bar Kasriel), Sgt., 31142262, Medical Corps, Purple Heart
100th Infantry Division, 397th Infantry Regiment, Medical Detachment
Born 1908
Mrs. Fanny Theodore (wife), 6 Vine St., Hartford, Ct.
Beth Alom Cemetery, New Britain, Ct. – Section DB
American Jews in World War II – 71

Photograph of matzeva by Jan Franco

Killed Non-Battle

Beckenstein, Charles J., T/5, 33119096, Passenger (Infantry)
40th Infantry Division, Headquarters Company

Flight of C-46D 44-77360 from Elmore Field, Mindoro, to Tarauan, Leyte
Aircraft crashed 4 miles northwest of San Roque, Philippines.  Loss covered in Missing Air Crew Report 15996.

The plane’s crew consisted of…

Pilot: 1 Lt. Wilson B. Haslan
Co-Pilot: 2 Lt. Myles V. Reed
Flight Engineer: S/Sgt. Arthur T. Poillucci
Radio Operator: Samuel A. Bruno

  …and the aircraft carried 21 passengers, members of the Army ground forces and Army Air Force.  There were no survivors.

As reported in MACR 15996: “C-46 (Commando) Transport plane which departed from Elmore Field, Mindoro, P.I., about 1630, 15 March 1945, with intended destination Tarauan, Leyte, P.I.  Plane crashed into a mountain approximately 4 miles northwest of San Roque, Leyte, P.I.  Accident was apparently due to weather conditions.  All members of the crew and passengers were killed.”

An online memorial for 23 of the 25 crew and passengers of C-46D 44-77360 can be viewed at FindAGrave.

Corporal Beckenstein’s parents were Harry and Bella, of 949 Ridgemont Road, Charleston, in West Virginia.

Buried at Manila American Cemetery, Manila, Philippines – Plot F, Row 7, Grave 67
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

Prisoner of War

Cohen, Jacob, S/Sgt., 33794401, Purple Heart, 1 Oak Leaf Cluster
3rd Infantry Division, 7th Infantry Regiment
(Wounded previously, around 6/6/44)
Born Salonika, Greece, 9/5/19
Mrs. Gertrude Cohen (wife), 412 Monroe St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Mrs. Esther Cohen [Magriso] (mother), 1515 S. 6th St., Philadelphia, Pa.
POW Camp unknown
The Jewish Exponent 4/27/45
The Philadelphia Inquirer 4/17/45
The Philadelphia Record 7/6/44 and 4/7/45
American Jews in World War II – 515

Wounded in Action

Abrahams, Henry G., 0-1328211, 2 Lt., Purple Heart, in France
Born East Orange, N.J., 1920
Mrs. Lola Ruth (Waldman) Abrahams (wife), 36-08 29th St., Astoria, N.Y.
Major Herbert Waldman (brother in law), 29-11 36th Ave., Long Island City, N.Y.
Casualty List 4/10/45
Long Island Star Journal 4/10/45
American Jews in World War II – 262

Pearl, James, S/Sgt., 33050971, Purple Heart, France
Born Philadelphia, Pa., 5/28/13
Mr. Harry Pearl (father), 1014 North 63rd St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Mrs. Elizabeth B. Pearl (mother), Deborah Rose and Rebecca (daughters), 1615 Robinson Ave., Philadelphia, Pa.
The Philadelphia Record 4/12/45
American Jews in World War II – 543

Zlotnick, Leon, Sgt., 33805527, Purple Heart, Germany
Born Philadelphia, Pa., 9/11/26
Mr. and Mrs. Gersin and Anna Zlotnick (parents), 619 Porter St., Philadelphia, Pa.
The Jewish Exponent April 20, 1945
The Philadelphia Inquirer 4/10/45
The Philadelphia Record 4/11/45
American Jews in World War II – 561

 

United States Army Air Force

8th Air Force

Eighth Air Force losses on March 15, 1945 (8th Air Force Mission 889) occurred during heavy bomber strikes against 1) German Army headquarters at Zossen, 2) marshalling yards at Oranienburg, Stendal, and Birkendwerder, 3) rail sidings and centers at Gardelegen, Wittenberge, and 4) targets at Gusen and Havelburg.

303rd Bomb Group, 427th Bomb Squadron: B-17G 43-39220, “GN * G
MACR 13568, Pilot 2 Lt. Thomas W. Richardson, 8 crew members – all survived

Grossman, Howard Alvin, S/Sgt., 36035598, Radio Operator
Returned to Molesworth with crew after aircraft landed at Okecie Airfield, near Warsaw
Born Chicago, Il., 2/21/19
Mr. and Mrs. Morris and Anna (Marks) Grossman (parents), Chicago, Il.
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

Tractman, Bernard Lawrence, F/O, T-133026, Navigator, 35 missions
Born Philadelphia, Pa., 6/9/22 (Died 9/15/97)
Mr. and Mrs. Morris and Betty (Saltzman) Tractman (parents), 1515 Elbridge St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Within MACR 13568, listed as a witness to the loss of B-17G 43-39220
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

____________________

Four B-17G Flying Fortresses of the 447th Bomb Group, comprising one plane of the 709th Bomb Squadron and three of the 711th Bomb Squadron, were lost to flak on this mission.  These aircraft were:

709th Bomb Squadron

42-97836, “Bugs Bunny Jr.”, “IE * P”, piloted by 1 Lt. Ralph D. Putnam and hit by flak near Wittenburg.  The 447th Bomb Group Battle Damage Report mentions that the aircraft was seen by fighter pilots to have belly-landed in the Steinhuder Lake area.  The entire crew of nine survived.

711th Bomb Squadron

44-6016, “TNT KATIE”, “IR * P”, piloted by 1 Lt. Henry M. Chandler, also struck by flak in the vicinity of Wittenburg.  Of TNT KATIE’s nine crew members, three survived.

43-38731, “Blythe Spirit”, “IR * Q”.  Piloted by 1 Lt. Harluf T. Jessen, the plane exploded after being hit by flak near the I.P. (I.P. – an acronym for “Initial Point”:  “…some identifiable land mark about 20 miles more of less from the target.  The formation flew there and at that point had to fly straight and level, no evasive action, to the target with the bomb bay doors open, usually under autopilot for the bombardier to do his job.  This was sweating time. [Contributed by Wally Blackwell, B-17 pilot, at 398th Bomb Group website].)  Only two of Blythe Spirit’s crew of ten survived.

43-38849, “IR * O”, piloted by 2 Lt. Lloyd L. Karst.  Also hit by flak in the vicinity of the I.P, seven of the aircraft’s nine crewmen suvived the bomber’s “shoot-down”, but only five actually returned. 

More detailed information about these aircraft and their crews is given below.

____________________

711th Bomb Squadron: B-17G 43-38731, “Blythe Spirit”, “IR * Q
MACR 13044, Pilot: 1 Lt. Harluf T. Jessen, 10 crew members – 2 survivors

Hoffman, Walter Samuel, 2 Lt., 0-2065557, Navigator, Air Medal, Purple Heart
Captured: Wounded and Prisoner of War (Name of POW camp unknown)
Mr. Morris Hoffman (father), 673 Avenue D, Rochester, N.Y.
New York Sun 4/19/45
Rochester Times-Union 2/15/44, 10/13/44
Rome Daily Sentinel 4/18/45
American Jews in World War II – 347

“Blythe Spirit” was struck by flak in the aircraft’s bomb-bay, and, between its #3 and #4 engines.  The aircraft fell straight down out of control and exploded.  Though no parachutes were observed to emerge from the falling plane, miraculously there were two survivors: co-pilot 2 Lt. Robert P. Dwight (son of Mrs. Isabel Dwight, residing at 1787 Granville Ave., in West Los Angeles, California) and navigator Walter Samuel Hoffman, of Rochester, New York, who both – being shot down over central Germany – were inevitably captured. 

The MACR includes Individual Casualty Questionnaires and Casualty Interrogation Forms covering the eight crewmen who did not survive, all these documents having been completed by Lt. Hoffman in late July of 1945, probably while at his home in Rochester.  There are no documents in the MACR by Lt. Dwight. 

With the exception of togglier S/Sgt. Hary E. Pfautz (probably already injured by flak, and not wearing a parachute) Lt. Hoffman’s comments about his fellow crewmen were all essentially the same:  “Plane was hit by flak and went into a spin.  The co-pilot and I were thrown out, and the plane broke into pieces.  Neither of us [Lt. Dwight] saw any more parachutes.  Later a German interrogation officer at Stendal POW Camp, Germany, told us that all eight men had been killed in the crash.  He had a correct list of their names.”

According to Lt. Hoffman, the plane crashed approximately 30 nautical miles due west of Oranienburg.  Fortunate in already wearing his parachute (he didn’t specify if it was a chest-chute or back-pack – probably the latter), he was thrown out of the B-17 through its shattered plexiglass nose (“after” S/Sgt. Pfautz), while Lt. Dwight, who was wearing a back-pack parachute (about which, see more below…) was also thrown to safety through the bomber’s nose. 

Concerning his month in German captivity, there is no information. 

____________________

711th Bomb Squadron: B-17G 44-6016, “TNT KATIE”, “IR * P
MACR 13045, Pilot 1 Lt. Henry M. Chandler, 9 crew members – 3 survivors

The nose art of “TNT Katie”, displaying at least 53 mission symbols.  (Image UPL 24300, from the Hutchinson & Cortright collection at the American Air Museum in Britain)

Murachver, Sidney Albert, 2 Lt., 0-788410, Bombardier, Air Medal, 3 Oak Leaf Clusters, Purple Heart
Captured: Wounded and Prisoner of War (Name of POW camp unknown)
Born 10/30/22 – Died 8/26/05
Mrs. Rose Murachver (mother), 85 Francis St., Everett, Ma.
David, Joanne, and Roberta (children)
https://447bg.smugmug.com
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

Skalka, David W., 2 Lt., 0-2000413, Navigator, Air Medal, 4 Oak Leaf Clusters, Purple Heart
Captured: Wounded and Prisoner of War (Name of POW camp unknown)
Born 1919
Mrs. Frances Skalka (mother), 265 E. 176th St., New York, N.Y. / Bronx, N.Y.
https://447bg.smugmug.com
American Jews in World War II – 447

The fate of TNT KATIE and her crew was to a degree similar to that which befell Blythe Spirit: The plane was directly struck by flak.  Hit under the cockpit and nose, the plane was seen to break apart at the top turret.  Airmen in nearby aircraft witnessed between three and four parachutes emerge from the falling plane. 

Full information as to the fate of the bomber and its crew would would arrive after the war from the plane’s three survivors: First Lieutenant Henry M. Chandler (pilot), and Second Lieutenants Sidnay A. Murachver (bombardier) and David W. Skalka (navigator), all of whom succinctly and vividly recounted the events of their last mission in Individual Casualty Questionnaires or Casualty Interrogation Forms.

In sum, the flak burst blew the B-17’s bombardier / navigator (nose) compartment directly off the aircraft.  Both Sidney Murachver and David Skalka, temporarily rendered unconscious and still within this falling section of the plane, in turn fell away or were blown free, and awakening in mid-air, parachuted to safety.  The same flak burst tore away the B-17’s instrument panel, control columns, rudder pedals, throttle controls, and right wing, leaving (what was left) of the falling plane completely uncontrollable and in a near-vertical dive.  After vainly attempting to assist co-pilot Velmer Diefe, pilot Henry Chandler was left with no choice but to drop through the wreckage into empty space, to land by parachute. 

Notably, the three surviving crewmen specifically attributed their survival to back-pack type parachutes (probably of the “B-8” type; see the photograph below from The Rigger Depot), which by design and form they were already wearing when the plane was struck by flak.  As such, unlike Lt. Diefe and their five fellow crewmen, they did not have to rely on chest-type parachutes, which an airman had – in case of emergency – to lift and then attach to double clips on his parachute harness.  You can view this design of harness in the photo of Lt. Chandler’s crew (as worn by all five men in the front row) and, in the individual photos of Sergeants Ivos, Swem, Stephens, and Reinartson.

The photo shows a group of American fighter pilots, probably of the 8th or 9th Air Force, standing before the tail of a wrecked Focke-Wulfe FW-190 in the winter of 1944-45.  The man on the left wears a back-pack (B-8) parachute, while the pilot on the right is wearing a seat parachute, to which is attached a one-man life-raft. 

Text accompanying photo:  “Originally designed by the Pioneer Parachute Company as their Model B-3-B, the USAAF’s copy (B-8) was standardized on October 1942.  …  The B-8 saw operational use in the ETO around late 1943, replacing the rigid B-7 and serving well into the postwar era.  It was the standard rig for bomber pilots as well as operational fighter pilots of the P-38 and P-51.”

Here’s David Skalka’s statement in Missing Air Crew Report 13035 (not 13045), in reply to an inquiry from the Casualty Branch of January 11, 1946, concerning the loss of his crew:

“The nose and right wing of the plane were torn away, as the bombardier and myself were blown clear, and the pilot, unlatching his safety belt, dropped out.  Having been knocked unconscious, I woke up after falling through the air a few seconds and pulled my chute.  I looked around and noticed pieces of the plane falling about me.”

And, here are Sidney Murachver’s comments, from his Casualty Questionnaire in Missing Air Crew Report 13045…

“The reason I know so little of my crew is that I was unconscious when I left my plane.  I was probably knocked out by the concussion of the flak, which struck at the point where the nose of the B-17 joins the fuselage.  I know only of the pilot, Lt. Henry Chandler, who bailed out, and the navigator, Lt. David Skalka, who was also blown out.  We have never seen or heard any information as to the remaining six members of my crew.  We presumed that they never left the plane because we were told that it fell about 1,000 ft & then exploded.”

…while Murachver also replied to the Casualty Branch inquiry of January 11, 1946:

“The nose of the plane was blown off and I was blown out of the nose, or through it, unconscious.  I had on the new type back-pack parachute, fortunately.  I came to while falling through the air and opened my chute.  As for the rest of the crew, they all had chest pack chutes.  We never heard of or saw them again.  We were told that the plane fell a thousand feet and exploded.”

Likewise, Henry Chandler’s reply to the Casualty Branch, in MACR 13035:

“The action took place over Pearlburg, Germany, on March 15, 1945 at about 3:40 p.m. at which time our group was flying west following the bombing of a railroad yard at Oranianburg, north of Berlin.  As out group passed over the same (flak) battery we received at least one direct hit between the nose and cockpit on the right side, completely demolishing the nose section, destroying the instrument panel and the glass enclosure of the cockpit and removing both sets of controls including the throttle quadrant.  At the moment we were hit I was knocked unconscious.  When I recovered the ship seemed to be in a vertical dive and the condition of the cockpit was as described above.  My co-pilot, Lt. Diefe, was still in his seat and as soon as I realized there was no way in which to regain control of the airplane, I attempted to attract his attention and reach his chest pack which was hanging at his side of the seat.  However, I was unable to get his attention nor to move far enough to reach his chute and left the wreckage before it crashed.  I left the wreckage by releasing my safety belt and falling through the hole in front of me.  I was wearing a back pack.”

____________________

1 Lt. Henry M. Chandler and his crew in a happier time:  The men gather for an undated (but certainly Winter of 1944-45) group photo before B-17G 42-97836, Bugs Bunny Jr. (IE * P), of the 709th Bomb Squadron, mentioned above as having been lost to flak on March 15.  (Image UPL 24298, from the Hutchinson & Cortright collection)

As I was unable to identify this photograph at Fold3’s collection of WW II USAAF photographs, I suppose it was taken and archivally retained at the level of the 711th Bomb Squadron, and thus never went “further” into the main holdings of the Army Air Force.  Notably, the unknown photographer – he had a good photographic eye – took individual portraits of eight of the crewmen, with each man standing near (or for the pilots, sitting within) his crew station.  Thus, in the evocative images below, Ivos and Swem stand by a waist gun position, Stephens by the dorsal turret, Reinartson by the ball turret, Chandler and Diefe sit in the pilot’s seat, and Murachver and Skalka by the nose compartment entry / exit hatch.         

Front row, left to right…

Sgt. Costas A. Ivos (Radio Operator) (Image UPL 24289, from the Hutchinson & Cortright collection
Mr. and Mrs. Anthony and Garifelia Ivos (parents), Lowell, Ma.

Westlawn Cemetery, Lowell, Ma.

____________________

Sgt. Allan B. Swem (Waist Gunner) (Image UPL 24297, from the Hutchinson & Cortright collection
Mrs. Bella M. Swem (mother), 1006 East Grand Boulevard, Detroit, Mi.
Ardennes American Cemetery and Memorial, Neuville-en-Condroz, Belgium

____________________

S/Sgt. Robert M. Stephens (Flight Engineer) (Image UPL 24295, from the Hutchinson & Cortright collection
Mrs. Clara Wilkins Stephens (mother), 3rd Street, Manchester, Ga.
Ardennes American Cemetery and Memorial, Neuville-en-Condroz, Belgium

____________________

Sgt. Robert C. Reinartson (Ball Turret Gunner) (Image UPL 24296, from the Hutchinson & Cortright collection
Mrs. Verna M. Reinartson (mother), 1620 12th Avenue South West, Fort Dodge, Ia.
Ardennes American Cemetery and Memorial, Neuville-en-Condroz, Belgium

____________________

Sgt. Rouse (?) (Not in this crew when aircraft shot down, and, going by records at Fold3.com, probably not a casualty)

____________________

Rear row, left to right:

1 Lt. Henry D. Chandler (Pilot) (Image UPL 24290, from the Hutchinson & Cortright collection) – Survived
Mrs. Marie Chandler (mother), 361 Gates Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.

____________________

2 Lt. Velmer M. Diefe (Co-Pilot) (Image UPL 24294, from the Hutchinson & Cortright collection
Mr. and Mrs. Frederick and Leontina Diefe (parents), Marlin, Wa.
Odessa Cemetery, Odessa, Wa.
____________________

2 Lt. David Skalka (Navigator) (Image UPL 24291, from the Hutchinson & Cortright collection) – Survived

____________________

2 Lt. Sidney A. Murachver (Bombardier) (Image UPL 24292, from the Hutchinson & Cortright collection) – Survived

Not in photo:

Sgt. John R. Piccardo (Tail Gunner)
Mr. Peter J. Piccardo (father), 1701 West Acacia St., Stockton, Ca.
Casa Bonita Mausoleum, Stockton, Ca.

____________________

711th Bomb Squadron: B-17G 43-38849, “IR *O
MACR 13030, Pilot 2 Lt. Lloyd L. Karst, 9 crew members – 5 survivors

Wiseman, Frank, 2 Lt., 0-926665, Navigator, Purple Heart, First mission
Apparently murdered upon capture.  According to statements by fellow crew members and a captured B-24 crew member, he was beaten to death by civilians after safely landing by parachute near the city of Tangerhütte.
Born Lowell, Ma., 5/20/22
City College of New York Class of 1944
Mrs. Evelyn R. Wiseman (wife), 301 West 20th St., New York, N.Y.
Mr. and Mrs. Samuel Solomon [Died 8/4/00] and Anne Wiseman (parents); Ruth (sister); Rifka (sister; 6/20/21-6/29/21), 548 West 164th St., New York, N.Y.
Wellwood Cemetery, Farmingdale, N.Y. – Block 45, Row 4, Section B, Grave 8R; Buried 12/4/49
Casualty List 4/19/45
American Jews in World War II – 473

The crew of IR * Q

Pilot: Karst, Lloyd L., 2 Lt. – Survived (POW)
Co-Pilot: Courtney, Samuel E., F/O – Survived (POW)
Navigator: Wiseman, Frank, 2 Lt. – Murdered upon capture
Bombardier: Corr, Raymond F., Sgt. – Survived (POW)
Radio Operator: O’Connor, William M., Sgt. – Survived (POW)
Flight Engineer: Isham, James M., Jr., Sgt. – Murdered upon capture
Mrs. Florence Isham (mother), Route Number One, Box 13, Buena Park, Ca.
Ardennes American Cemetery, Neupre (Neuville-en-Condroz), Belgium, Plot A, Row 15, Grave 16
Awards: Purple Heart
Gunner (Ball Turret): Hannah, Cecil W., Sgt. – Survived (POW)
Gunner (Waist): Dove, Clyde Sherwood, Jr., Sgt. – Killed in action
Gunner (Tail): Huschka, Bernard F., Sgt. – Killed in action

Though it was assumed by other crews that this B-17 was headed to Russian-occupied territory, the crew, with the plane’s #4 engine feathered and the pilot and co-pilot reportedly wounded, experienced a very sad fate.

As revealed by co-pilot Courtney in post-war documentation, the aircraft never reached the Russian lines, for in reality, the aircraft lost power in all four engines and then caught fire. 

Pilot Karst, co-pilot Courtney, navigator Wiseman, togglier Corr, flight engineer Isham, and waist gunner Dove parachuted from the aircraft.  Dove, who had been calling for tail-gunner Huschka to parachute, remained too long in the aircraft, and was killed when he jumped at too low an altitude for parachute to fully open.  Radio operator O’Connor, ball turret gunner Hannah, and tail gunner Huschka (probably wounded or already dead) “rode the plane in”, the former two when they realized that the plane was already at too low an altitude for a safe parachute jump.  Remarkably, they survived the crash of the unpiloted bomber near Tangerhütte, Germany, albeit O’Connor’s back was fractured.

As for Frank Wiseman and Harry Isham? 

Though they made successful parachute jumps (Wiseman from 12,000 feet), they did not live to become prisoners of war.  According to statements in the MACR, both men were apparently murdered – beaten to death – by civilians upon landing.  They were seen lying near one another by an American POW from another aircrew, whose name in the MACR is listed as “Jack Smith”.  This man was probably Corporal Jack E. Smith, a radio countermeasures operator in the 565th Bomb Squadron of the 389th Bomb Group, who parachuted north of Magdeburg (52-40 N, 11-33 E) from B-24J 44-10510 (“You Cawn’t Miss It”, “YO * Q”) during a mission to Zossen, after his plane’s #2 engine caught fire from flak.  Ironically, pilot 1 Lt. Harold G. Chamberlain flew the bomber back to base.

Based on Individual Casualty Questionnaires in the Missing Air Crew Report, this seems to have been the Karst’s crew’s first mission.

There’s no Case File in NARA Records Group 153 (Records of the Office of the Judge Advocate General) concerning Frank Wiseman, probably because the location of the aircraft’s loss – in what would become the Soviet Zone of Occupation of Germany, during the (first) Cold War – prevented American and Allied military investigators from investigating this incident, and identifying and prosecuting the murderers.

Frank Wisemen was one of a number of Jewish WW II servicemen in both the European and Pacific theaters who did not survive their initial capture, and / or their eventual captivity.  This was either because of the grim chances of fate that potentially befall all prisoners of war, or – in the European theater, in some cases – calculation: Because they were Jews.

This map shows the location of Tangerhütte in relation to Berlin….

…and here’s a map view of Tangerhütte and nearby towns at a larger scale…

…while this is an air photo view of the above map, at the same scale.

____________________

487th Bomb Group, 838th Bomb Squadron: B-17G 43-38028, “High Tailed Lady”, “2C * O”
Pilot: 2 Lt. William C. Sylvernal.  9 crew members – all survived.  Aircraft crash-landed in Russian-occupied Poland; Entire crew eventually returned to squadron. 

Forgotson, Donald, T/Sgt., 32992703, Flight Engineer, Distinguished Flying Cross, Air Medal, 2 Oak Leaf Clusters, Purple Heart
487th Bomb Group, 838th Bomb Squadron
Injured in crash-landing. 
No Missing Air Crew Report
Born 1917
Mrs. Roslin Forgotson (wife), 2055 Anthony Ave., Bronx, N.Y.

Mr. Jerry Garavuso (son-in-law)
487th Bomb Group.org – Photo – High Tailed Lady
487th Bomb Group.org – Aircraft Roster
487th Bomb Group.org – 838th Bomb Squadron Roster
American Jews in World War II – 311

This is the probable loading list (crew roster) for mission of March 15, 1945, based on information at 487th Bomb Group wesbite:

Sylvernal, William C., 2 Lt. – Pilot
Peachey, Jim L., 2 Lt. – Co-Pilot
Personette, Chester A., 1 Lt. – Navigator
Forgotson, Donald, S/Sgt. – Flight Engineer
Taylor, Harold F., Cpl. – Radio Operator
Montague, Paul M., Cpl. – Gunner (Ball Turret) (and, Hughey, Henry W., S/Sgt.?)
Kennedy, Harold L., Cpl. – Gunner (Waist)
Payne, Harold L., Cpl. (or) Walsh, George P., Cpl. – Gunner (Tail)

____________________

The High-Tailed Lady amidst flak bursts over Germany.  (Image FRE 8544, from the Roger Freeman collection)

The rather fragmented wreck of the High-Tailed Lady, behind Soviet lines in Poland.  (Photo from 487th Bomb Group wesbite.) 

____________________

The following account of the High Tailed Lady’s final mission and the return of her crew was written by ball turret gunner Paul M. Montague (this was his 17th mission), and appears Martin Bowman’s Castles in the Air – The Story of the B-17 Flying Fortress Crews of the US 8th Air Force.

“This mission was another long haul into and out of Germany.  Our crew in the High Tailed Lady had made it before.  All went well until we approached the turning point toward the IP west of Berlin.  We were flying at 24,000 feet when, suddenly, an accurate burst of flak hit our ship.  The co-pilot was seriously wounded, one engine quit, the intercom only functioned sporadically and all the control cables on the port side, except the rudder, were severed.  This caused us to bank to starboard at about 30 degrees.  We dropped from formation, apparently unseen, lost altitude and turned toward Berlin.  At only 12,000 feet over Berlin a second flak burst smashed part of the Plexiglas nose, stopped a second engine, ruptured the oxygen system and started a fire in the bomb bay.  Twelve 500 pounders stuck there would neither jettison or toggle.  Several crew members were hit by shrapnel.  Our pilot gave us the alternative of baling out or staying while he attempted to ride the Lady down to a crash landing in Poland.  As we gazed directly down at the Tiergarten, no-one had the nerve to jump!  The fire in the bomb bay was finally extinguished and we managed to jettison our bombs into a lake below.  Thankfully, we were alone.  No German fighters appeared.  As we crossed the Oder River at only a few thousand feet, our Russian allies fired on us but no hits were sustained.

“Our pilot did a magnificent job of approach to what appeared to be a level field enclosed on three sides by woods.  We had no flaps, gear, air speed indicator and many other vital instruments but all the crew survived the crash landing.  The co-pilot and the engineer were later placed in a hospital for Russian wounded and the seven remaining crew were ‘looked after’ by their Russian army hosts.  The crew were disrobed by some Russian army women who then proceeded to wash them with cloths and basins of water.  Their uniforms were taken away and replaced with ‘pyjamas’ (the type worn in concentration and prison camps).  Paul Montague continues.  Little did we seven suspect that everything would be pantomime for two ensuing weeks and these pyjamas would be our clothes.  We were under constant guard.  We were prisoners – not guests of our ‘allies’.  Just as we were falling asleep several of us heard the unmistakable click of the lock in our door.

“Next morning we had our first breakfast.  I recall being very thirsty and I spotted a large cut-glass container of water in the centre of the oval breakfast table.  After pouring a glass-full, I took a large swallow and my breath was whisked away!  Pure vodka at 05:30!  I tried to warn the crew members but was speechless.  A few others made the same error.  The Russians roared with laughter.  For the next two weeks we used vodka in our cigarette lighters; it worked marvelously – like an acetylene torch!”

Montague and his fellow crew members were finally transported to Poznan and on through Poland to Lodz where they continued to Kiev.  They finally reached a Russian fighter base near Poltava where a Lend-Lease C-46 flew them nearer freedom.  Paul Montague recalls.  ‘After flying for quite a time we noticed the co-pilot coming back to the area where the wing joins the fuselage.  He unscrewed a cap of some sort, removed a rubber siphon from his jacket and proceeded to drink something.  Could this possibly be de-icer fluid?  Our pilot, his head still bandaged from our crash, remarked, ‘My God!  I may have to end up flying this plane’.  After flying some hours at high altitude over some mountain ranges, we began our descent and finally made a very rough landing in Tehran, Persia.  This was the last we were to see of any Russians.  After spending a few days at the American base in Tehran we were flown on to Abadan by an American pilot in a C-47 transport.  From then on it was shuttle hops by American pilots to Cairo, a nearly deserted base in the Libyan desert, on to Athens, Paris and finally to Lavenham.  Since we were due for “R&R” about this time, we were granted a week’s leave and spent a most pleasant time in Girvan, Scotland, before returning to base to fly two more missions.”

“Crew of the High Tailed Lady pose with their Russian hosts.  Paul Montague, the ball turret gunner, is second from left in the back row.  (Montague)”

________________________________________

Dressler, Jacob (“Jack”) Harry, 2 Lt., 0-824608, Fighter Pilot, Air Medal
355th Fighter Group, 357th Fighter Squadron
“Lieutenant Dressler on this mission ran short of gas and was last seen heading toward the Russian lines.  He wasn’t heard for two weeks and was given up as missing in action.  Then on the 30th of March the report came in that he was safe and was on his way back to the squadron.”
No MACR; Aircraft P-51D 44-14314 “Sexless Stella / One More Time”, “OS * L
Born Brooklyn, N.Y., 4/25/23, Died 11/2/17
Mr. and Mrs. Morris [12/27/95] and Anna (Braunfeld) Dressler (parents), 81-21 20th Ave., New York, N.Y.
Jack, Miriam [8/22/26-3/19/06], and Paul (sister and brothers)
American Jews in World War II – 299
Information about Jack Dressler – identical to the record above – appears in an earlier blog post, concerning the experiences of Lieutenant William Stanley Lyons as a fighter pilot, both having served in the 357th Fighter Squadron of the 355th Fighter Group.

________________________________________

15th Air Force

Dobkin, Joseph, F/O, T-129423, Bombardier, Air Medal, Purple Heart
98th Bomb Group, 415th Bomb Squadron
MACR 12998, Aircraft B-24L 44-50225, “red T”, Pilot 1 Lt. Charles H. Estes, 11 crew members – all survived
WIA; Returned with crew (presumably after parachuting over, or landing in, Yugoslavia)
Mrs. Rose Dobkin (mother), 3054 Pingree, Detroit, Mi.
American Jews in World War II – 189

Koty, Gerald, T/Sgt., 20251634, Radio Operator
463rd Bomb Group, 772nd Bomb Squadron
MACR 12999, Aircraft B-17G 44-6555, Pilot 1 Lt. Walter R. Griffith, 11 crew members – all survived
Returned with crew (possibly after presumably parachuting over, or landing in, Yugoslavia)
Mr. and Mrs. Morris and Florence Koty (parents), 465 National Blvd., Long Beach, N.Y.
Lew Koty and Helen (Koty) Globus (brother and sister)
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

Polish People’s Army [Ludowe Wojsko Polskie]

Broch, Aleksander, WO, in Poland, at Zachodniopomorskie, Kolobrzeg
Born Sosnowiec, Poland, 1923
Mr. Stanislaw Broch (father)
Kolobrzeg Military Cemetery, Kolobrzeg, Poland
Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: Vol I, p 73

Chuszycer, Szaul, Pvt., during Operation Pomeranian Wall
4th Infantry Regiment
Mr. Jakub Chuszycer (father)
Place of burial unknown
Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: Vol I, p 13

Gotszalek, Wlodzimierz, WO, in Poland, at Pomorskie, Reda, during Operation Pomeranian Wall
1st Tank Brigade
Born Brodniki, Kujawsko-Pomorskie, Poland, 1912
Mr. Stefan Gotszalek (father)
Place of burial unknown
Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: Vol I, p 25

Lelkowski, A., Sergeant Major, in Poland, at Zachodniopomorskie, Walcz (died at Walcz Hospital)
11th Infantry Regiment
Kochanowka, Poland, 1922
Mr. Szmuel Lelkowski (father)
Place of burial unknown
Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: Vol I, p 44

Rad, Ben Zion, Cpl., in Poland, at Zachodniopomorskie, Kolobrzeg
11th Infantry Regiment
Born Lodz, Poland, 1909
Mr. Michael Rad (father)
Place of burial unknown
Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: Vol I, p 95

Sajort, Icek, Pvt., in Poland, at Zachodniopomorskie, Gryfice
Kamien Pomorski Military Cemetery, Kamien Pomorski, Poland
Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: Vol IV, p 103

Suchopar, Jozef, Pvt., in Germany, at Kolberg
Born Milkiewicze (d. Nowogrodek), Poland, 1924
Mr. Seymour Suchopar (father)
Kolobrzeg Military Cemetery, Kolobrzeg, Poland
Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: Vol I, p 64

Widomlawski, Nachum, at Field Hospital 45, during Operation Pomeranian Wall
Born 1913
Mr. Icchak Widomlawski (father)
Place of burial unknown
Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: Vol I, p 74

Soviet Union

Army Ground Forces / Red Army

Killed in Action

Gekhtman, llya Natanovich (Гехтман, Илья Натанович), Junior Sergeant (Младший Сержант)
Cannon Commander (Командир Орудия)
55th Guards Rifle Division, 213th Tank Battalion
Wounded 3/15/45; Died of wounds (умер от ран) 3/20/45
Born: 1914
Wife: Sofya Aleksandrovna Valoshina
Memorial Book of Jewish Soldiers Who Died in Battles Against Nazism – 1941-1945 – Volume V – 452 [Книги Памяти евреев-воинов, павших в боях с нацизхмом в 1941-1945 гг – Том V – 452]

Gerber, Abram Kelmanovich (Герберь, Абрам Кельманович), Guards Lieutenant (Гвардии Лейтенант)
Tank Platoon Commander (Командира Танкового Взвода)
31st Tank Corps, 237th Tank Brigade, 3rd Tank Battalion
Killed in action (убит в бою)
Born: 1912; Wife: Frida Markovna Gerber
Memorial Book of Jewish Soldiers Who Died in Battles Against Nazism – 1941-1945 – Volume V – 443 [Книги Памяти евреев-воинов, павших в боях с нацизхмом в 1941-1945 гг – Том V – 443]

Krolik, Iosif Peysakhovich (Кролик, Иосиф Пейсахович), Guards Junior Lieutenant (Гвардии Младший Лейтенант)
Rifle Platoon Commander (Командир Стрелкового Взвода)
18th Guards Rifle Division, 53rd Guards Rifle Regiment
Killed (убит)
Born 1922, Tolochinskiy raion, Vitebsk oblast
Friend / Acquaintance: Nina Mikhaylovna Savinich

Levin, Boris Mikhaylovich (Левин, Борис Михайлович) Guards Junior Lieutenant (Гвардии Младший Лейтенант)
Rifle Platoon Commander (Командир Стрелкового Взвода]
1st Guards Tank Army, 19th Guards Motorized Brigade
Died of wounds (умер от ран), at Mobile Field Hospital 470 (Полевой Подвижной Госпиталь (ППГ) 470)
Born 1925, city of Omsk
Father: Mikhail Iosifovich Levin

Levin, Solomon Iosifovich (Левин, Соломон Иосифович), Lieutenant (Лейтенант)
Rifle Platoon Commander (Командира Взвода)
313th Rifle Division, 1072nd Rifle Regiment
Killed (убит)
Born 1908, city of Borisov, Minsk oblast, Belorussian SSR
Sister: Anna Iosifovna Levin

Magid, Leonid Moiseevich (Магид, Леонид Моисеевич), Junior Lieutenant (Младший Лейтенант)
Rifle Platoon Commander (Командир Стрелкового Взвода)
5th Rifle Division, 190th Rifle Regiment
Killed (убит)
Born 1923, city of Simferopol
Mother: Juliya Magid

Milner, Zinoviy Abramovich (Мильнер, Зиновий Абрамович), Guards Senior Lieutenant (Гвардии Старший Лейтенант)
Rifle Platoon Commander (Командир Стрелкового Взвода)
60th Guards Rifle Division, 180th Guards Rifle Regiment
Killed (убит)
Born 1912, City of Polotsk, Vitebsk oblast

Pritsman, Isaak Samuilovich (Прицман, Исаак Самуилович), Junior Lieutenant (Младший Лейтенант)
Self-Propelled Gun Commander (Командир Самоходной Установии) SU-100 (СУ-100)
17th Guards Tank Brigade, 1st Tank Battalion
Killed (убит)
Born: 1922
Father: Samuil Borisovich Polikarpov
Memorial Book of Jewish Soldiers Who Died in Battles Against Nazism – 1941-1945 – Volume III – 168 [Книги Памяти евреев-воинов, павших в боях с нацизхмом в 1941-1945 гг – Том III – 168]

Reytburg (or) Roytburd, Boris Avisheevich (Рейтбург (или) Ройтбурд, Борис Авишеевич), Guards Lieutenant (Гвардии Лейтенант)
Company Commander (Командир Танковой Роты)
10th Guards Tank Corps, 62nd Guards Tank Brigade, 3rd Tank Battalion
Killed (убит), in Lower Silesia, Gross Brizen, Germany (Германия, Гросс Бризен, Нижняя Силезия)

Born: 1922 or 1924
Father: Avishim Berkovich Reytburg (or) Roytburd, Vinnitskaya Oblast, Bershad, Uritskiy Street, Building 1
Memorial Book of Jewish Soldiers Who Died in Battles Against Nazism – 1941-1945 – Volume VI – 248; Volume XI – 282 [Книги Памяти еврееввоинов, павших в боях с нацизхмом в 1941-1945 гг – Том VI – 248, Том XI – 282]

Military Air Forces – VVS

Beylin, Sakhno Ayzikovich (Бейлин, Сахно Айзикович), Senior Technician-Lieutenant (Старший Техник-Лейтенант) Senior Technician / Construction (Старший Техник по Строительству)
2nd Air Army, 26th Air Base Area, 83rd Airfield Engineer Battalion
Killed in plane crash (Погиб при Катастрофе самолета)
Born: 1920
Sister: Anna Ayzikovna Beylin
Passenger in Po-2 (По-2) piloted by Junior Lieutenant Dmitriy Fedorovich Popov (Младший Лейтенант Дмитрий Федорович Попов); Both Killed
Memorial Book of Jewish Soldiers Who Died in Battles Against Nazism – 1941-1945 – Volume V – 160 [Книги Памяти евреев-воинов, павших в боях с нацизхмом в 1941-1945 гг – Том V – 160]

Images of the Po-2 / U-2 are abundant, which is hardly surprising given the aircraft’s long history, versatility, and lengthy production run, over 33,500 having been constructed between 1928 and 1954.  However, one of the better representations of the aircraft is actually plastic-model “box-art” painting for the ICM Model Company’s 1/72 kit of the U-2 / Po-2VS.  The painting clearly shows significant features of the aircraft (the depicted example, aircraft “white 19” of the 889th Night Light Bomber “Novorossiysk” Regiment (former 889th Composite / Aviation Attack Regiment, 654th Night Light Bomber Regiment) flown by a female crew) – like its five-cylinder Shvetsov M-11 engine – more clearly than many photographs.  While the camouflage and markings of the plane crewed by Beylin and Popov are unknown, the painting nonetheless gives a nice depiction of the aircraft’s general appearance. 

United Kingdom

Died of Illness

Ohrenstein, Edward, LAC, 3003850
Royal Air Force Volunteer Reserve (probably stationed at RAF Stornoway)
Died of illness in Yishuv
Born 1926
Mr. and Mrs. Isaac and Bluma Ohrenstein (parents), Petach Tikva, Israel
Miss S. Ohrenstein (sister), 20 Charles Ave., Thornbury, Bradford, England
Bradford (Scholemoor) Jewish Cemetery, Yorkshire, England – Grave 166
The Jewish Chronicle – 3/30/45
We Will Remember Them Volume I, p 218

“VICTIM OF GERMAN FASCISM – DEEPLY MOURNED BY PARENTS AND SISTERS”

Photograph of matzeva by Bob the Greenacre Cat

Killed in Action

Martin, Felix Mondschein, Trooper, 13053492
Royal Armoured Corps, 3rd Carabiniers (POW Dragoon Guards)
Born 1920
Mr. and Mrs. Max and Eugenia Mondschein (parents)
Taukkyan War Cemetery, Taukkyan, Rangoon, Myanmar – 19,J,19
We Will Remember Them Volume I, p 218

“HE GAVE HIS LIFE FOR THE SALVATION OF HIS OPPRESSED PEOPLE”

Finkelstein, Hans, Sapper, PAL/13194
Royal Engineers
Died in Yishuv
WWRT I as “Finkelstein (Funkel), Hans”; CWGC as “Funkenstein, Hans”
Heliopolis War Cemetery, Heliopolis, Cairo, Egypt – 4,A,27
We Will Remember Them Volume I, p 243

________________________________________

________________________________________

References

Bowman, Martin W., Castles in the Air – The Story of the B-17 Flying Fortress Crews of the US 8th Air Force, Patrick Stephens, Wellingborough, Northants, England, 1985

Dublin, Louis I., and Kohs, Samuel C., American Jews in World War II – The Story of 550,000 Fighters for Freedom, The Dial Press, New York, N.Y., 1947

Meirtchak, Benjamin, Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: I – Jewish Soldiers and Officers of the Polish People’s Army Killed and Missing in Action 1943-1945, World Federation of Jewish Fighters Partisans and Camp Inmates: Association of Jewish War Veterans of the Polish Armies in Israel, Tel Aviv, Israel, 1994

Meirtchak, Benjamin, Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: IV – Jewish Officers, Prisoners-of-War, Murdered in Katyn Crime; Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Resistance Movement; An Addendum, World Federation of Jewish Fighters Partisans and Camp Inmates: Association of Jewish War Veterans of the Polish Armies in Israel, Tel Aviv, Israel, 1997

Morris, Henry, Edited by Gerald Smith, We Will Remember Them – A Record of the Jews Who Died in the Armed Forces of the Crown 1939 – 1945, Brassey’s, United Kingdom, London, 1989

Rottman, Gordon (Colour plates by Frances Chinn), US Army Air Force: 1 (Elite Series), Osprey Publishing Ltd., London, England, 1993

Sanders, Charles J., The Boys of Winter – Life and Death in the U.S. Ski Troops During the Second World War, University Press of Colorado, Boulder, Co., December, 2004

Memorial Book of Jewish Soldiers Who Died in Battles Against Nazism – 1941-1945 – Volume III [Surnames beginning with О (O), П (P), Р (R), С (S)], Maryanovskiy, M.F., Pivovarova, N.A., Sobol, I.S. (editors), Union of Jewish War Invalids and Veterans, Moscow, Russia, 1996

Memorial Book of Jewish Soldiers Who Died in Battles Against Nazism – 1941-1945 – Volume V [Surnames beginning with А (A), Б (B), В (V), Г (G), Д (D), Е (E), Ж (Zh), З (Z), И (I), К (K)], Maryanovskiy, M.F., Pivovarova, N.A., Sobol, I.S. (editors), Union of Jewish War Invalids and Veterans, Moscow, Russia, 1998

Memorial Book of Jewish Soldiers Who Died in Battles Against Nazism – 1941-1945 – Volume VI [Surnames beginning with Л (L), М (M), Н (N), О (O), П (P), Р (R), С (S), Т (T), У (U), Ф (F), Х (Kh), Ц (Ts), Ч (Ch), Ш (Sh), Щ (Shch), Э (E), Ю (Yoo), Я (Ya)], Maryanovskiy, M.F., Pivovarova, N.A., Sobol, I.S. (editors), Union of Jewish War Invalids and Veterans, Moscow, Russia, 1999

Memorial Book of Jewish Soldiers Who Died in Battles Against Nazism – 1941-1945 – Volume IX [Surnames beginning with all letters of the alphabet], Maryanovskiy, M.F., Pivovarova, N.A., Sobol, I.S. (editors), Union of Jewish War Invalids and Veterans, Moscow, Russia, 2006

Websites

447th Bomb Group Documents and Photos, at 447th BG Smug Mug

East Pomeranian Offensive, at Wikipedia

WW II Parachute and Flight Gear Reproductions, at The Rigger Depot – Reproductions of United States Army, United States Army Air Force, United States Navy, and Royal Air Force WW II Flight Gear and related equipment

USAAF B-8 Backpack Parachute, at The Rigger Depot

119

Measures of  Valor: American Jewish Military Service in World War One – Part Three

My prior posts, Measures of  Valor: American Jewish Military Service in World War One – Part One, and Measures of Valor: American Jewish Military Service in World War One – Part Two, focus on efforts by the American Jewish Committee to create a historical record of the military service of American Jews during the First World War, efforts which resulted in the 1919 publication of the 50-page pamphlet The War Record of American Jews.  

This post focuses on the same topic, but its focus shifts to the late 1930s through the mid-40s.

By this time, a second variation on a theme of The War Record of American Jews had emerged.  This appeared within the two editions of The Jewish Legion of Valor, which were authored and privately published by Sydney G. Gumpertz, who was awarded the Medal of Honor for his actions on September 26, 1918, while a First Sergeant in E Company, 132nd Infantry Regiment, 33rd Infantry Division. 

The first edition of his book was published in 1936 and reissued in 1941.  The book was evidently republished in 1944 (albeit the year does not appear in the title page), for my copy includes a large section about Jewish soldiers in the American military in the Second World War.  The 1946 “second” edition has the same cover as the first, albeit the content naturally differs from the initial edition.

Here’s the cover (1946 edition)…

…and, the title page (1941 edition).

And, here’s a portrait of Sydney Gumpertz.  I don’t know if his rank of Captain reflects service in the Reserves, or a symbolic, honorary rank.  In any event, Sydney’s Medal of Honor is readily visible around his collar.

Here’s the book’s table of contents…

If one can sometimes learn more about a thing from its absence than its presence., then this is solidly so for both editions of The Jewish Legion of Valor.  If you examine the above two images, you’ll notice something most revealing: 

In the first edition (498 pages), there’s absolutely no mention of the military service of Jews in the armed forces of Imperial Germany and Austria-Hungary, while information about the service of Jews in the armed forces of America’s WW I Allies is limited to France, England, and Australia, to a total of five pages. 

As for the service of Jews in the armies of Canada, Italy, Imperial Russia, New Zealand, and South Africa?  That, remains entirely unmentioned.

In terms of the first book’s contents, it commences with sections about Jewish military service in the American military, leading up to the Great War.  This is followed, within pages 153 through 360, by an account of the military service of Jews in the United States’ armed forces during that conflict.  Then, after a general overview of the military, sociological, and psychological aspects of combat in WW I, the reader is presented with statistics from the The War Record of American Jews about Jewish service in the American military.  These data are interspersed with accounts of and citations for the actions of Medal of Honor Winners Sergeant William Sawelson (killed in action on October 26, 1918), author Gumpertz, and First Sergeant Benjamin Kaufman, who, like Gumpertz, survived the war.  This is followed by a brief section about recipients of the Navy Cross.

Material on the military service of individual Jewish soldiers – citations – is found on pages 248 through 328.  Here the reader finds an alphabetized list of soldiers who were awarded the Distinguished Service Cross, Distinguished Service Medal, and Soldier’s Medal, each name being accompanied by the soldier’s rank, military unit date of incident(s), and in some cases, the name of the soldier’s next of kin and residential address.

Within this section, one of challenges of Jewish genealogical reseach (or any genealogical research, for that matter) arises:  The inclusion of some names in this section seems to be based on the “sound” or ethnic characterization of the soldier’s surname, a criterion that – taken in isolation – can be quite unreliable.  (Like that for Captain Carl Frederick Falkenberg in the British Jewry Book of Honour.)  So, not all of the men listed therein (like Corporal Henry Emil Zax) are Jews. 

The latter portion of both editions of The Jewish Legion of Honor is devoted to American Jews in the (then) current war: The Second World War.  This section is comprised of very brief citations about the military service of Jews in all branches of the United States’ military – Army ground forces, Army Air Force, Coast Guard, Marine Corps, and Navy – albeit the actual source of the citations is not listed. 

This section is invaluable through the inclusion photographic portraits for a few of these men, images which I’ve not seen elsewhere. 

The names of all the men so “pictured” are listed below, with biographical information for each man whose portrait appears in the book(s). 

As far as the actual images go, I’ve included some from each edition.  These show (first edition) Sol Bauer, David Senft, and Sidney Slotoroff, and (second edition) J. Gene Hochfelder and David Spatz.  The pictures are accompanied by a few of my “own” illustrations, obtained from other sources.

And, so…

1 Lt. Sol Bauer, 0-1169857, United States Army, Artillery Observer
90th Infantry Division, 344th Field Artillery Battalion
Killed in action March 16, 1945, while flying as observer in L-4H piloted by 1 Lt. Jack Hester – also killed (shot down by Luftwaffe aircraft over Halsenbach, Germany)
Born in New Jersey, 1/31/19
Mr. Ben Bauer (father), 525 Elizabeth Ave., Newark, N.J.
Casualty List 4/10/45
Mount Lebanon Cemetery, Iselin, N.J.
American Jews in World War II – p 226

__________

T/Sgt. Martin J. Caine, 32422574, United States Army Air Force, Aerial Gunner, 15th Air Force, 485th Bomb Group, 831st Bomb Squadron
Wounded in action June 28, 1944
Pilot: Lt. Volney Wiggins
Born 1920
Mrs. R. Shirley Laufer (mother), 158-18 Riverside Drive (also 50 Riverside Drive), New York, N.Y.
Casualty Lists 8/9/44, 2/20/45
American Jews in World War II – p 287
This Is How It Was: 485th Bomb Group (Heavy) Unit History, by Sam Schneiderp 313

1 Lt. Morton A. Dubelier, United States Army Air Force, Co-Pilot
9th Air Force, 322nd Bomb Group, 451st Bomb Squadron
Severely injured when aircraft crash-landed at base during training mission on evening of 5/25/44 (B-26C 42-107586, “The Nude Prune IV”, (or, “The Nude Prude IV”?) “SS* N”, Piloted by Colonel Frederick E. Fair)
Born 1920
Mr. Morris Dubelier (father), 137-60 71st Ave., Kew Gardens, Flushing, L.I., N.Y.
Long Island Star Journal 9/2/42, 9/5/42, 7/20/44
American Jews in World War II – p 299

Lt. JG Jacques Rodney Eisner, 0-98230, United States Navy
Killed in sinking of USS San Francisco on November 13, 1942
Born Red Bank, New Jersey, 7/25/18
Mr. and Mrs. Sigmund and Bertha (Weis) Eisner (parents), Gerald and J. Lester (brothers), 84 West Front St., Red Bank, N.J.
Tablets of the Missing at Manila American Cemetery, Manila, Philippines
The American Hebrew – December 25, 1942
American Jews in World War II – p 231

Sgt. Jerome Goshin, 32861279, United States Army Air Force
8th Air Force, 100th Bomb Group, 349th Bomb Squadron
Born 1924
From New York, N.Y.
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

1 Lt. Maxwell H. Levy, 0-694388, United States Army Air Force, Navigator
15th Air Force, 301st Bomb Group, 32nd Bomb Squadron
Name in Missing Air Crew Report 6175 as witness to loss of B-17F 42-30106, piloted by 2 Lt. Hugh H. McGee, Jr. (9 crew members – 2 survivors), on 6/27/44
From New York, N.Y.
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

S/Sgt. Myron R. Mendel, 12154701, United States Army Air Force, Radio Operator
8th Air Force, 303rd Bomb Group, 359th Bomb Squadron
65 E. 96th St., New York, N.Y.
American Jews in World War II – p 391

__________

Lt. David V. Senft, 0-104694, United States Navy, F4F Wildcat Fighter Pilot
Naval Fighter Squadron VF-71
Survived sinking of USS WASP on 9/15/42
Born 1920
Mr. and Mrs. Albert A. and Annette Senft (parents), 23 West End Ave., New York, N.Y.
The Knickerbocker News – 10/28/42 “Wasp Blew Up Like Keg of Dynamite, Naval Pilot Reveals in Graphic Account” (as told to Gerald Frank, INS)
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

__________

1 Lt. Sidney Slotoroff, 0-659194, United States Army Air Force
12th Air Force, 60th Troop Carrier Group, 12th Troop Carrier Squadron
Killed in action 7/13/43, while piloting C-47 41-18418 “61 / M” (4 crew – no survivors)
Born New York, N.Y., 9/8/14
Mrs. Sidney Slotoroff (wife), 425 East 72nd St., New York, N.Y.            
Mr. Irving J. Slotoroff (father?)
Sicily-Rome American Cemetery, Nettuno, Italy – Plot J, Row 8, Grave 44
Casualty List 10/5/43
American Jews in World War II – p 447

The above picture of Lieutenant Slotoroff, as an Aviation Cadet at Kelly Field, is from the United States National Archives collection “Photographic Prints of Air Cadets and Officers, Air Crew, and Notables in the History of Aviation (NARA RG 18-PU)”.  You can read more about this collection at my brother blog, The Past Presented, in the post Five Pilots in December – Photographic Portraits of American Fighter Pilots Who Lost Their Lives at Pearl Harbor. 

The below picture is from The Jewish Legion of Valor

__________

The Zuckerman brothers:
Major Seymour Zuckerman, USMC
Capt. Jeremiah W. Zuckerman, United States Army Air Force
PFC Aaron L. Zuckerman, US Army

Finally, in the table of contents, a section headed “Registry” (on page xiii) presents the names of soldiers and an associated page number.  However (!) – examining this section reveals that several of the given page numbers are incorrect, while information about Jewish WW II military service is absent.  (Where’s an editor when you need one?!)

________________________________________

Moving ahead five years, here’s the title page of the 1946 edition, which is accompanied by Sydney’s dedicatory signature of December, 1947, to Jewish War Veterans Post #72 of Brooklyn (does it exist seventy-three years later? – I doubt it) on the opposing page.  Note that the layout of the title page is identical to that of the first edition.

Here’s the second edition’s table of contents.  It’s only two pages long.

In this edition, the section about Jewish military service in World War One is repeated from the first edition, but while the names of WW I citation awardees listed in the first edition are present, the text accompanying their names is missing.  Thus, this part of the book is much shorter. 

This is reflective of the book’s publication a year after the Second World War’s end, for over half of this edition’s contents are “now” devoted to Jewish military service in that just-ended war.  Akin to the first volume, this section is comprised of citations of varying length about soldiers from all branches of the military, and includes high-quality photographic portraits (again, that I’ve not seen elsewhere) of some of these servicemen. 

And, as in the first edition, the names of these men (so photographed) are listed below.  Also (as I did above), I’ve included biographical information for them, as well as some photographs, from my own records.

T/Sgt. Martin L. Caine, United States Army Air Force (once again)

Lt. Jacques Rodney Eisner (once again)

1 Lt. Hirschel L. Gutman, 0-743238, United States Army Air Force, Bomber Pilot
8th Air Force, 93rd Bomb Group, 328th Bomb Squadron
Killed 4/20/44 while piloting B-24D 42-63972 (“The Flying Cock II”, “GO &* E”)
No Missing Air Crew Report
Born Bristol, Tn., 5/1/15
Mrs. Herman Hecht (mother), 708 Euclid Ave., Bristol, Va.

Temple Israel Cemetery, Wakefield, Ma.
War Department News Release 5/27/44
The Jewish Advocate 7/20/44
American Jews in World War II – p 163

Sgt. Abram R. Gennet, United States Army
30th Infantry Division, 120th Infantry Regiment

__________

1 Lt. J. Gene Hochfelder, 0-24259, United States Marine Corps
5th Marine Division
Silver Star for action on Iwo Jima on 2/22/45
Mr. Jack Hochfelder (father), 29 Woodmere Boulevard, Woodmere, N.Y.
The Wave – Rockaway Beach, N.Y. 8/19/43
The Nassau Daily Review-Star 6/9/43, 8/13/45
American Jews in World War II – p 346

__________

1 Lt. Lee Jaffe, United States Army
67th Anti-Aircraft Artillery Battalion

Capt. Mortimer K. Karten, 0-1283441, United States Army
Wounded on Okinawa 5/11/45
Born New York, N.Y., 12/18/15
Mr. Samuel A. Karten (father), 400 West End Ave., New York, N.Y.
Casualty List 6/25/45
American Jews in World War II – p 357

Major Clarence Levin, 0-247523, United States Army
1st Infantry Division, 7th Field Artillery Battalion
Killed in action 1/31/43
Born Lewiston, Me., 11/30/06
447 Beacon St., Boston, Ma.
North African American Cemetery, Carthage, Tunisia – Plot D, Row 15, Grave 5
Chicago Jewish Chronicle 5/21/43
American Jews in World War II – p 169

__________

2 Lt. Stanley S. Spatz, 0-2058031, United States Army Air Force, Navigator
20th Air Force, 498th Bomb Group, 875th Bomb Squadron
Died 5/5/45 during loss of B-29 42-63416 (“T square 46”) piloted by 1 Lt. Stephen E. Davis (11 crew – 4 survivors).  Survived ditching, but not rescued.  Incident covered in Missing Air Crew Report 14366.
Mr. Samuel Spatz (father), 1416 Granada Place, Far Rockaway, N.Y.
Mr. David L. Sverdlik (uncle)
Tablets of the Missing at Honolulu Memorial, Honolulu, Hawaii
Casualty List 6/23/45
The Wave – Rockaway Beach, N.Y. 10/1/42
Long Island Daily Press
6/23/45

New York Times – Obituary Page Memorial Section – 5/5/46
American Jews in World War II – p 451

The below picture is from The Jewish Legion of Valor

The document below is a “Record of Casualty” sheet pertaining to Lt. Spatz’s Killed in Action status, one of 78 such records for Jewish casualties in the 20th Air Force compiled by Major David I. Cedarbaum. 

Throughout and especially after (decades after, in some cases…*) the Second World War, the “In Memoriam” section of the New York Times obituary page included messages in honor of fallen soldiers.  This brief note, by Lt. Spatz’s uncle David L. Sverdlik, comprising six lines from Rudyard Kipling’s 1897 poem Recessional, appeared in the Times on May 5, 1946, one year after his nephew’s death.   

__________

PFC David Leigh Spector, 31309002, United States Army
75th Infantry Division, 289th Infantry Regiment, Headquarters Company (?)
Killed in action 4/25/45, at Arnsburg, Germany
Born in Jamaica Plains, N.Y., 5/2/24
Arlington National Cemetery, Arlington, Va. – Section 13, Grave 516
American Jews in World War II – p 181

2 Lt. Raymond Zussman, 0-1014997, United States Army, Recipient of Medal of Honor
756th Tank Battalion
Killed in action 9/21/44
Born in Hamtramack, Michigan, 7/23/17
Mr. Nathan Zussman (father), 2913 Sturtevant Ave., Detroit, Mi.
Abraham, Betty, and David (brothers and sister), Donald Shea (friend)
Machpelah Cemetery, Ferndale, Mi. – Section 6, Lot 17, Grave 298D; Buried 6/6/48
The Jewish News (Detroit) 6/15/45
Aufbau 7/27/45
The Jewish Veteran November-December, 1983
American Jews in World War II – p 198

*For Second Lieutenant Stanley Alan Hecker – a co-pilot killed in the crash of a B-26 Marauder bomber in Tampa Bay on September 2, 1942, his parents – Benjamin and Ruth (Berek) Hecker of 62 West 174th Street in the Washington Heights section of Manhattan – would place a notice in the Times’ “In Memoriam” section on every anniversary of that date, for the thirty-two years from 1943 through 1975. 

Readings, References, Writings and What-Not

Books

Adler, Michael, and Freeman, Max R.G., British Jewry Book of Honour, Caxton Publishing Company, London, England, 1922 (Republished in 2006 by Naval & Military Press, Uckfield, East Sussex)

Dublin, Louis I., and Kohs, Samuel C., American Jews in World War II – The Story of 550,000 Fighters for Freedom, The Dial Press, New York, N.Y., 1947

Gumpertz, Sydney G., Capt., The Jewish Legion of Valor – The Story of Jewish Heroes in the Wars of the Republic – And a General History of the Military Exploits of the Jews Through the Ages, Sydney G. Gumpertz, New York, N.Y., 1934, 1941

Gumpertz, Sydney G., Capt., The Jewish Legion of Valor – The Story of Americans of the Jewish Faith Who Distinguished Themselves in the Armed Forces in All the Wars of the Republic – And a General History of the Military Exploits of the Jews Through the Ages, Sydney G. Gumpertz, New York, N.Y., 1934, 1946

The War Record of American Jews – First Report of The Office of War Records, American Jewish Committee, January 1, 1919, The American Jewish Committee, New York, N.Y., 1919

Other Publications

The Universal Jewish Encyclopedia, New York, N.Y., 1942

Websites

Guide to the Records of the American Jewish Committee – Office of Jewish War Records, undated, 1918-1921, 1962, processed by David Solomon, at Center for Jewish History

Sydney G. Gumpertz, at Wikipedia

Measures of Valor: American Jewish Military Service in World War One – Part Two

My prior post, Measures of Valor: American Jewish Military Service in World War One – Part One, focused on the absence of a substantive historical record of the military service of American Jews during the First World War, with a specific eye towards the creation of the American Jewish Committee’s 1919 pamphlet, The War Record of American Jews.  I also mused about the reasons why – unlike in Europe – no substantive book (or, books) covering the military service of American Jewish soldiers in WW I was ever created.

And, this post?

It’s an illustration (in words and images) of how The War Record of American Jews was presented in the Jewish press; in this case, in The Jewish Exponent of February 28, 1919, through which the “core” of the AJC’s pamphlet was brought before the public in newspaper format. 

And, to a lesser extent, this post is an exploration of the pamphlet’s actual content.

To that end, the entirety of the Exponent’s text is presented below, the “original” in Times New Roman font and my own comments in Arial font.  The original item being nearly one and a half pages long, it’s pretty substantial even by the size of the newsprint font used in 1919, and undisputably gargantuan by the standards of newspapers now, in 2020.

The names of all 128 soldiers listed in the AJC pamphlet – all of whom were cited in official correspondence, or, who received military awards associated with such citations – appear in the Exponent’s article.  However, the Exponent’s editors left out out the few lengthy sections of descriptive text that variously appear in The War Record of American Jews, for example for DSC winner Abraham Krotoshinsky of “The Lost Battalion“, and some other soldiers.  Otherwise, for this post, I’ve added commentary, images, links, and – where needed – corrections.  My own comments are taken from information I’ve accumulated in an endeavor to identify all American Jewish military casualties of WW I, which I mentioned in the previous post. 

Oh…  Be prepared for a measure of scrolling.  (Just sayin’.)

Next post?  The War Record of American Jews, in the “next” war – the Second World War.

________________________________________

American Jews Have Glorious War Record

The Jewish Exponent
February 28, 1919

REMARKABLE DATA ISSUED BY AMERICAN JEWISH COMMITTEE

[FIRST REPORT OF OFFICE OF WAR RECORDS, AMERICAN JEWISH COMMITTEE]

That the Jews of America have contributed more than their proportionate quota to the armed forces of the United States in the war is shown in the official “War Record of American Jews”, which has just been issued by the American Jewish Committee, through its Office of War Records, at 31 Union Square, New York City.

The outstanding facts developed by the course of the inquiry to date may be summarized as follows:

(1) The total number of individual records collected to December 31, 1918, is well in excess of 100,000.  Many of these records have been forwarded directly from the camps and trenches by the soldiers themselves.  Others have been sent in by their friends and relatives, by agents of the Jewish Welfare Board at the camps, or by local branches of the Board.  The great bulk of the material, however, has been obtained through the unstinted co-operation of the Rabbis of the country and through the leading Jewish organizations, national, fraternal, and local.

(2) Of the 100,000 records at hand about 80,000 have been tabulated and classified.  The exact figures as to the distributions of these men, according to the branches of the service, rank, states and cities of origin, etc., will be found in the appended tables.  Briefly, they show that of the 80,000 men whose records have been tabulated, about 69,000 are in the Army, 8800 in the Navy, 1700 in the Marine Corps.

Of the 69,000 Army records, 12,458 are known to be in the infantry, 4,751 in the Artillery, 4,438 in the Medical Corps, 2,866 in the Signal and Aviation Corps, 1,373 in the Engineer Corps, 877 in the Cavalry, 735 in Ordnance, and 1,472 in other branches.  Men whose branches of service are as yet unknown, but the greatest majority of whom will probably be found in the Infantry, number 29,969.

As the rank, there are so far recorded 5,162 Jewish commissioned officers in the Army, of whom 24 are Colonels, 202 Majors, 782 Captains and 4,007 Lieutenants.  In the Navy there are 206 commissioned officers, including one Rear Admiral, and in the Marine Corps 40 Commissioned Officers, including one Brigadier-General.

As to States and Cities of origin: – The largest centers of Jewish population have, of course, supplied the greatest number of Jews in the service.  New York State and city, have supplied more than one-third, the total for the state being 26,866, of which 22,210 are from New York City.  Pennsylvania follows with 9,643 of which 7,098 are from Philadelphia.  Illinois is credited with 3,459, of which 2,670 are from Chicago, and Massachusetts with 3,377, of which 830 are from Boston.  Other states will be found pro-rated accordingly.  The class “States not known” comprises 15,685 of which probably ___ty per cent will ultimately be traceable to New York.

As the full significance of these figures may be grasped only in their relation to certain questions that are, of necessity, uppermost in the minds of those interested in this subject it may be well to present the information developed so far in the course of the inquiry directly in the form of questions and answers – it being understood, however, that as these figures are not final any deductions drawn from them must also lack finality.

Number and Percentage of the Jews
in the Army and Navy of the
United States

The best available evidence indicates that there are from 150,000 to 200,000 Jews in the Service, or from four to five per cent of the total forces of the United States, which at this date number approximately four million.

These estimates are based upon two independent calculations which tend strongly to confirm one another.  One is a study of the Casualty Lists.  The total number of casualties in the American Expeditionary Forces to November 1, 1918, was 64,157.  The total number of Jewish casualties noted to that date was 2,502 or 3.9 per cent of the total.  If the Jewish casualties are not excessive and there is no reason to assume that they are (at least for the earlier period of American participation; the later fighting in which the 77th, Camp Upton Division, was engaged, will probably raise the proportions, this would indicate that the Jews constitute about four per cent of the Army and Marine Corps.  As these two arms of the service at present number about 3,700,000 men this would make the total of Jewish soldiers and Marines about 145,000; and as the same ratio probably applies to the Navy, its present personnel of 500,000 would furnish approximately 20,000 Jews.  The total for all branches of the services would therefore, by this method of calculation, approximate 165,000.

The other possible method of estimating the total is based upon observations made in the process of collecting the records of the Marine Corps.  It may be assumed as axiomatic that in order to secure entirely complete lists of the Jews in the service it will be necessary to combine a search of the official records at Washington together with the collection of extra official records from purely Jewish sources.  In practice it has been found possible to make this thorough search in only one office in Washington, that of the Adjutant and Inspector of the Marine Corps.  By comparing the results obtained by the use of both methods of search it was found that the unofficial methods of search would have furnished only 532 names, while the official search furnished 1,172 names or approximately twice as many.  As the 80,000 names at present classified were practically all obtained from unofficial sources, this would indicate that we have at present only one-third of the total of all Jews now in the service.  On the basis of this estimate the aggregate should be nearly 250,000.  It is obvious, however, that this is an over-estimate, due to the fact that the Marine Corps is not a typical corps, concentrated for training purposes in large cantonments, where they can easily be checked up and reported by agents of the Jewish Welfare Board or by the local Jewish papers, as in most camps.  In other words, the unofficial method of search is somewhat more defective in the case of the Marines than in most branches of the service.  But even if a full discount of twenty or twenty-five per cent be written off for this one factor there would remain an approximate total of 200,000 Jews in the service, according to this estimate.  It is probably safe to infer, therefore, that the final figures will be found somewhere between the minimum of 150,000 indicated by the first method of calculation, and the maximum of 200,00 indicated by the second method.

Percentage of Jews in the Service

The entire Jewish population of the country, according to the latest estimates, is about three per cent of the total population.  The Jews in the military and naval forces of the United States , however, constitute from four to five per cent.  On the face of these figures it would seem that the Jews of America have contributed more than their share to the armed strength of the United States.  There is reason to believe, however, that the final figures, when available, will demonstrate that the Jewish contribution has been ever greater than this.  It is well known that the selective service system has operated more effectively in the North and East than in the South and West, and in the urban than in the rural districts – that is, in the large centres of population, which happen also to be the centres of Jewish population.  Moreover, the number of industrial exemptions has been greatest in agriculture, mining and the metal industries, where the Jews are least extensively employed.  It has therefore developed, as an unavoidable and incidental feature of the draft system, that the Jewish elements of the population have perhaps been drawn upon more heavily, in proportion to their numbers, than any other elements.

But the principal reason for the high percentage of Jews in the armed service rests elsewhere.  It is to be found in the remarkable number of Jewish volunteers.  The evidence as to this is definite and conclusive.  The great majority of the records in our files state the exact ages of the men reported.  By actual count is has been ascertained that of all the men whose ages were known fully ten per cent were well outside the draft ages at the time that the count was made – before the registration of September 12.  If, in addition to this number there be added the 10,536 sailors and marines who are all volunteers, the total of such volunteers at present recorded rises to more than twenty per cent of the total in our files.  Should this ratio represent fairly the proportion of Jewish volunteers in all the arms of the service, and at present there is no reason to believe otherwise – this would indicated that there are from 30,000 to 40,000 Jewish volunteers in the service today.  In other words, the normal Jewish quota of three per cent, seems to have been contributed through the draft, and the excess to have been supplied by volunteers.

Jewish Soldiers Distributed Among the
Combatant and Non-Combatant
Branches of the Service

Although distinctions of this nature have become, in the organization of modern warfare, almost meaningless, and are therefore not to be over-emphasized, certain comparisons that have been noted in this connection are so striking as to compel instant attention.

According to the latest official figures available as to the strength of the army as a whole and of each of its component branches, the total strength was, in November, 1918, about 3,700,000, of which Infantry, Artillery, Cavalry, Engineers and Signal Aviation branches together constituted 60 per cent, and the other branches, such as Ordnance, Quartermaster, etc., constituted 40 per cent.  But among the 80,000 army records in our possession the distribution among the first named branches is fully 72 per cent, or 12 per cent greater than in the entire army.  The infantry branch constitutes 26.6 per cent of the entire army, while of the Jewish total it constitutes 51.7 per cent.  Artillery is 14 per cent of the U.S. Army, 10 per cent of the Jewish total.  In Cavalry the rate for the entire army is 2 per cent, for the Jews only 1 per cent.  The Engineer Corps constitute 11 per cent of the army strength, and but 3 per cent among the Jewish records.  The Signal and Aviation Corps represent 7 per cent of the United States total, and 6 per cent of the Jewish total.  The Medical Corps is 8 per cent of the army total, 9 per cent of the Jewish total.  The Quartermaster Corps is 6.2 per cent of the army total, 5.1 per cent of the Jewish total.  Ordnance is 1.7 per cent of the army total, 1.5 per cent of the Jewish total.

If, therefore, such distributions are still held valid it may be said truthfully that the relative proportion of Jews in the combatant branches is far greater than in the non-combatant branches.

If additional evidence as to this point is desired it may be found in a comparative study of two branches of the service differing so widely in their functions as the Quartermaster Corps and the Marine Corps.  In view of the fact that the Quartermaster Corps is essentially the business organization of the army, and that the Jewish recruits, as a class, undoubtedly possess greater business training and greater capacity for organization than their non-Jewish comrades, it may reasonably have been expected that this branch of the service would possess a far higher percentage of Jews than all other branches.  The evidence at hand, however, points definitely to the contrary.  While the personnel in the Q.M.C. constitutes 6.2 per cent of the army as a whole, it constitutes only 5.1 per cent of the Jewish total.

The Marine Corps, on the other hand, is essentially a fighting organization.  Every man in this corps is a volunteer, enlisted with the full knowledge that the corps would be sent wherever the fighting was thickest.  Now of the 60,000 Marine Corps records examined to date about 1,700, or three per cent, proved to be Jewish, while probably an additional 200 were Jewish, but not definitely traceable by our methods.  And of these 1,700 Jewish Marines, fully thirty per cent joined immediately after June 5, the day when it was published to the world that the Marines were the American “shock troops” at Chateau-Thierry.

Total Number and Percentage of Jewish Casualties

At this writing the official casualty lists are still far from complete, and it is therefore impossible to state, with any assurance of accuracy, the total number of Jewish casualties.  A reasonable conservative estimate, however, would place the total deaths from all causes at about 2,500 (of which about 1,500 were killed in action or died of wounds) and the total number of all Jewish casualties of every description at about 10,000.

The total number recorded to November, 1918, is 2,502 or 3.9 per cent of the total in the Army and Marine Corps.  Of these 451 were killed in action and 142 died from wounds, 96 died from disease, 73 died from accidents and other causes.  The total number of deaths is 882, or 4.1 per cent of the total in the American Expeditionary Forces.  The total number of wounded is 1,397, or 3.8 per cent of the American forces.

Honor and Citations

The report of citations for gallantry in action, and of other honors and decorations, are too belated to provide sufficient data for the purpose of the present report.  It is known, however, that the number of Jewish soldiers who have received American and French decorations is considerable.  It was the 77th (Upton) Division – largely Jewish – that was in the thick of the fighting at Argonne Forest and it was practically a Jewish battalion – belonging to the famous 308th – that distinguished itself for extraordinary valor in the Argonne.  The list of all citations will therefore be prepared for publication as soon as sufficient information with respect to these honors shall be available.  In the meantime the following tentative list of official citations noted to date, although manifestly incomplete, will serve to give an idea of the valor of the Jewish soldiers in action.

Adler, Julius O., Major, 306th Infantry. – “During the relief on the night of August 11-12, 1918, the 2nd Battalion, 306th Infantry, suddenly came under heavy shell fire of the enemy and the companies were ordered to dig in.  This officer showed coolness, special devotion, and care of his men, calmly walking up and down in front of the men, preventing panic, and indicating to individual men where best to seek shelter, and preventing bunching and grouping.  During this critical time this officer gave little thought to personal danger, and his action undoubtedly reduced the number of casualties suffered by the battalion.”

Aperstein, Sam, Company D, 302nd Engineers. – Cited November 3, 1918, for gallant and meritorious conduct in the course of bridge building operations across the Vesle north of Villesavoye, while exposed to heavy shell fire for a period of three and one half hours.

Aronson, Joe, United States Marines. – Aworded Croix de Guerre, after having suffered a leg wound in the fighting around Chateau Thierry.

Asher, David L., 103rd Infantry. – Cited for bravery.

Baer, Clarence A., of Detroit, Mich. – First American to receive medal of the Raconaisance France.

Baer, Sanford, Lietenant, of Murphyboro, Ill. – Awarded the Croix de Guerre for bravery in action.  The award was made in the hospital.

Belson, Samuel L., Boston, Massachusetts, 104th Infantry. – Entire regiment cited.

Bemonwski, Joseph G., 104th Infantry. – Cited for Bravery.

Benjamin, William, Sergeant of Portland, Oregon. – Awarded Distinguished Service Cross for extraordinary heroism in action at Chateau Diable, near Fiammes, on August 27.

Berg, Joseph, Company G, 167th Infantry. – Distinguished Service Medal for extraordinary heroism in action near Croix Rouge Farm, northeast of Chateau Thierry, on July 27.

Bergman, Axel H., First Class Private, Company E, 302nd Engineers. – Cited November 3, 1918, for gallant and meritorious conduct in the course of bridge building operations across the Vesle north of Villesavoye, while exposed to heavy shell fire for a period of three and one half hours.

Bergstein, Alfred N., First Lieutenant, Medical Corps, 18th Infantry. – For extraordinary heroism in action near Exermont, France October 8, 1918.  Under heavy shell fire, Lieut. Bergstein cared for the wounded, although he had been severely wounded and was suffering great pain.  He refused to be evacuated until all the wounded had been treated.  Home address, Samuel Bergstein, 624 Minersville Street, Pottsville, Pa.

Bergman, Raymond, Second Lieutenant, 306th Infantry. – “Throughout the advance through the Argonne Forest made by G and E companies, 306th Infantry, under intense enemy artillery and machine-gun fire, this officer displayed extraordinary courage and devotion to duty.”

Bernheimer, Louis G., First Lieutenant, Air Service, pilot, 88th Aero Squadron.  “For the following act of extraordinary heroism in action near Tailley, France, November 2, 1918:  Lieutenant Bernheimer and First Lieutenant Ralph P. Bagby, observer, on their own initiative went on a reconnaissance mission, flying fifteen kilometers behind the German lines, securing valuable information on the condition of the bridges across the Meuse River and enemy activity in the back areas and harassing enemy troops.”  Home address, Sidney Bernheimer, father, 138 East Seventy-second Street, New York City.”

Bernstein, Isidore H., 5 West 111th Street, New York City, 104th Infantry. – Entire regiment cited.

Bloch, Harry, Worcester, Massachusetts, 104th Infantry. – Entire regiment cited.

Block, Raymond A., Newark, New Jersey, 104th Infantry – Entire regiment cited.

Block, Samuel M., Private, Company A, 102nd Infantry. – Distinguished Service Cross for extraordinary heroism in action at Marcheville, France, September 26, 1918.  After several other runners had failed, Private Block volunteered and was successful in carrying a message through an intense machine-gun and artillery barrage.

Blohm, John, Sergeant, Company B, 305th Infantry.  “On September was a member of a patrol operating in daylight out of St. Thibaut across the Vesle River to Bazoches, which patrol, having accomplished its mission, was returning to our lines.  Due to heavy fire the patrol had taken refuge in shell holes.  Sergeant Blohm saw Corporal Catalina, Co. C, 305th Infantry, a member of this patrol, dragging himself through the grass toward the river and bleeding profusely from a wound in the back.  Sergeant Blohm left his cover, carried the wounded Corporal to shelter behind a tree near the river bank, and there bound his wounds.  He then slipped into the river and with the assistance of the boughs of a tree fallen from the opposite bank drew Catalina after him to the south side of the river.  He then carried him across the open some 200 yards to our outpost line.  During this action the enemy fire had been continuous, both rifle and machine-gun.

Blomberg, Henry S., First Lieutenant, 127th Infantry. – Distinguished Service Cross for extraordinary heroism in action near Juvigny north of Soissons, France, August 30, 1918.

Bloomberg, Louis, 2426 East 59th Street, Cleveland, Ohio.  Cited for bravery in the Battle of the Marne.

Blum, Harvey H., Sergeant, 37 MM Cannon Platoon, Headquarters Co., 307th Infantry. – “During the advance in the Argonne Forest, from September 25 to October 16, 1918, was continually with the advance line despite the fact that the several sections of his platoon periodically relieved one another, and on several occasions he did display great bravery and coolness under fire.”

______________________________

Brown, Henry, Lieutenant, of Detroit, Mich. – Won distinction in the service in different ways.  In his service under fire he was repeatedly cited for bravery.  He died in France, October 29, twelve days before the end of the war.

A Second Lieutenant in K Company, 118th Infantry Regiment, 30th Infantry Division, he was actually killed in action on 11 October. The son of Charles H. (3/11/59-11/6/90) and Pauline (Robinson) Brown (later Rose) (3/10/66-5/23/46) and brother of Edith, of 115 West Euclid Ave., Detroit, he was born in that city on January 7, 1888.   Henry is buried at the Somme American Cemetery, in Bony, France, at Plot A, Row 28, Grave 12.  A memorial cenotaph was erected in his memory at Woodmere Cemetery, Detroit.   His name appears on page 73, Volume 2, of Soldiers of the Great War.

______________________________

Calmen, B., 104th Infantry. – Entire regiment cited.

Cohen, Abraham, 103rd Infantry. – Cited for bravery.

Cohen, David, of Battery F, 65th Coast Artillery Corps. – Awarded the Croix de Guerre.

Cohen, David, Worcester, Mass., 104th Infantry. – Entire regiment cited.

Cohen, Meyer, Webster, Mass., 104th Infantry. – Entire regiment cited.

______________________________

Cohen, Simon L. Bloch, Sergeant, Philadelphia, Pa., Company B, 1st Prov. M.G. Battalion. – Decorated while in hospital with Croix de Guerre by Marshall Foch.

You can read Simon’s sad story at Amy B. Cohen’s Brotmanblog, in Amy’s nicely researched 2014 post Simon L.B. Cohen 1898-1934: A Story about the Horrors of War.  His portrait below appeared in The Jewish Exponent on July 26, 1918, and is one of the only two portraits of Jewish soldiers to have appeared in that publication during the war, the other having been of pursuit pilot (fighter pilot, in today’s parlance) Jacques M. Swaab, whose story is summarized below.

Simon passed away in 1934 at the young age of 36.  He is buried at the Cold Spring Presbyterian Cemetery, in Cape May, New Jersey.

I hope to create a post with more information about Simon’s story in the future.

______________________________

Cohen, Theodore Lewi, Sprakers, N.Y., 104th Infantry – Entire regiment cited.

Cohn, Eugene S., Captain, 364th Infantry. – For extraordinary heroism in action near Exmorieux Farm, France, October 2, 1918. “After being painfully wounded by shrapnel, Captain Cohn refused to go to the rear and remained on duty with his company in the front line without medical attention for 34 hours.”  Home address, Mrs. Morthena R. Cohn, wife, R.F.D. No. 6, Seattle, Wash.

Cohn, Louis Henry, of Brooklyn, Artillery. – Twice decorated for especial bravery in the battle on Ourecq, July 20 to 25.

Davies, Joseph J., of Bridgeport, Conn. – Cited for bravery during the battle of the Marne.  Also awarded the Croix de Guerre shortly before he was wounded.

Davis, Ezra, 103rd Infantry. – Cited for bravery.

Dreben, Sam, El Paso, Tex. – Awarded Distinguished Service Cross.

Feder, Walter J., 878 Hutchins Avenue, Cincinnati. – Decorated with Medal of Valor for extreme bravery.

Fells, Isidor. – Decorated with the Distinguished Service Medal for bravery.

Flexner, Simon, New York, Major, Medical Corps, Officer of the Legion of Merit.

Fulda, Walter J., Sergeant, of San Francisco. – Awarded the Distinguished Service Medal for maintaining field kitchen service intact under heavy bombardment, his unit being the only one to serve a hot meal to the men of his division on October 3 last.

Gerrig, Jacob., 101st Infantry. – Cited for bravery.

______________________________

Gerstein, Louis (Azriel Leyb ben Meir HaCohane), 286 Walnut Avenue, Roxbury, Mass. – Killed in action September 6, 1918.  Previously decorated for valor displayed in action in carrying a wounded comrade out of the firing zone on August 27.  Member of Company E, 307th Infantrry.

Born in Russia in 1895, Louis was a Private (serial number 1,680,770) in E Company, 307th Infantry Regiment, 77th Infantry Division, and the son of M. Gerstein of 103 Bedford Street in Boston.  He was buried – on June 14, 1921 – in Beth Joseph Cemetery #1, at Woburn, Massachusetts (Section 1, Left, Grave 6).  This above image of his matzeva is by FindAGrave contributor Joan F. Byington. His name does not appear in Soldiers of the Great War

Thanks to Avi, here is the Hebew text on the matzeva, followed by an English translation:

פנ
תנצבה

יפה נוף בחור נחמד
עזריאל ליב בר מאיר הכהן
במעשיו התגבר בנעריו
כי זך וישר מעשהו
אך הה פתאום
אבדה תקוה הזרי[ח]
עזרנו באבו קטפהו המות
ביום כט אלול תרעה
נקבר ה סיון תרפא

The top two letter acronym stands for “Here is buried”

The second line (with priestly hands in the middle) is an acronym for “May his soul be bound in the bundle of life”.  (Based on I Samuel 25:29)

The English translation?

“Handsome in appearance, a pleasant fellow
Azriel Leyb son of Meir the Kohen
In his deeds he excelled in his youth,
for pure and upright were his actions.
But woe!  Suddenly
hope was lost!  (As) our helper shone,
he was cut in his prime by death
on the 29th of Elul 5675
Buried the 5th of Sivan 5681

The composer of the epitaph had a flair for Hebrew poetry.

Elul having only 29 days, Louis fell in battle the day before Rosh Hashana.
The 6th of Sivan being Shavuot, his burial was the day before Shavuot.

______________________________

Gilbert, Max. – Awarded Distinguished Service Cross. – “At great personal danger while under heavy fire carried a wounded fellow soldier to shelter and administered first aid, thereby saving his life.”

Girier, Morris, 101st Infantry. – Cited for bravery.

Gold, Benjamin, First Sergeant, Company D, 306th Infantry. – On September 7, 1918 while his company was holding a position in the front line, during intense shelling by the enemy, this soldier exhibited high courage, initiative and coolness by taking charge of, controlling and helping care for the wounded, directing them to points of safety, without regard to his own personal danger, until he himself was severely wounded.  Cited November 18, 1918.

Goldberg, David A., 103rd Infantry. – Cited for bravery.

Goldstein, Julius, Sergeant, of Philadelphia, Company E, 307th Infantry. – “At Chateau Drable, near Fismes, on August 27, 1918 displayed unusual coolness and great bravery in the face of terrific enemy machine-gun fire.  A party from Company E had become lost in the woods and he took out a patrol of four men and led it through the enemy’s lines under terrific fire at all times, found the party, and brought it back to safety around the flank of the enemy’s position.”

Goldstone, Max, Sergeant, Headquarters Company, 397th Infantry. – “For running a line, to Grand Pre in the darkest of nights, through unknown territory under heavy artillery and machine-gun fire.  When temporarily stopped by the darkness he stayed with the end of the line and completed it at dawn.”  Date, October 15, 1918.

Grossman, A.A., Lieutenant, attached to the 62nd Batallion, Machine Gun Corps. – Won British Military Cross for gallantry and devotion to duty while serving in the fighting at Cambrai.

Hahn, Frederick, Second Lieutenant, Field Artillery. – “Near Cantigny, May 28-30, he unhesitatingly went into heavy shell fire to supervise the repairs of telephone lines and to act as runner when the further maintenance of the wires became an impossibility.”  Cited September 6, 1918.

Heineman, Julie, of San Francisco. – Decorated with the Queen Elizabeth Medal by King Albert of Belgium for her work on behalf of French wounded and blind.

Herscovits, Isie J., Color Sergeant, San Francisco. – Cited for valor.

Hirsch, Isaac C., Company E, 306th Infantry. – “On August 27, 1918, voluntarily acted as stretcher bearer, showed great heroism, determination and courage by carrying wounded in an area which was swept by shell, machine-gun and rifle fire.” Cited November 16, 1918.

Hoffman, Edward A., Company H, 306th Infantry. – “Being on duty as observer, remained at his post during violent shell fire on the night of August 27-28, 1918, thus showing great courage and determination.”  Cited November 16, 1918.

______________________________

Joseph, S.C., Lieutenant of the Sea Patrol. – Awarded Distinguished Flying Cross for downing eight enemy aircraft.

Now, this is interesting…

Here’s where the AJC made a flat-out error. 

Lieutenant S.C. Joseph – Solomon Clifford Joseph – was not a member of the United States Army Air Service, for he was British, and served in Number 210 Squadron of the Royal Air Force.  The son of Morris and Jenny Solomon of 14 Spradwell Road in Birmingham, he was an aerial “ace”, attaining 13 aerial victories against the Deutsche Luftstreitkräfte, the air arm of Imperial Germany, two of which were Albatross D.V and five of which were Fokker D.VII fighters.   

The following article, from The Jewish Chronicle of September 27, 1918, notes his receipt of the Distinguished Flying Cross. 

MILITARY HONOURS

Distinguished Flying Cross

Lieut. S.C. Joseph (Sea Patrol)

A gallant pilot who has accounted for eight enemy aircraft within the past four months.  On many occasions the enemy was numerically superior to Lieut. Joseph’s patrol, but this did not prevent his attaining success.

You can read more about his military career in his biography, at The Aerodrome.   

______________________________

Kantrowitz, Silas, Albany, N.Y., 104th Infantry – Entire regiment cited.

Kaplan, Jacob, Sergeant, Stokes Mortar Platoon, Headquarters Co., 307th Infantry. – “On October 9, 1918, during the advance in the Argonne Forest, crawled out in advance of the front line to within 100 yards of an enemy machine-gun post, under heavy fire, to observe the effects of our Stokes fire, and did succeed in directing fire so as to cause the enemy machine gunners to withdraw.”

Kauffman, Abraham – “He refused to leave his gun after he had lost a finger during the enemy encounter at Cantigny, May 28, but continued to perform his duty until so severely wounded as to be unable to assist in serving his piece.”

Kessler, Jacob – Cited for bravery in action.

Klick, Albert W., 108th Infantry. – Cited for bravery.

Klosenberg, Samuel, 1560 Southern Boulevard, New York, N.Y.  Awarded Distinguished Service Cross.

King, Edward J., 101st Infantry. – Cited for bravery.

Koppel, Harry, of Revere, Mass. – Commended by Secretary Daniels for bravery displayed is rescuing men overboard at sea.

______________________________

Krotoshinky, Abraham. – “Distinguished Service Cross for extraordinary heroism in action in Argonne Forest on October 6.  He was on liaison duty with a battalion of the 308th Infantry, which was surrounded by the enemy north of the Forest de la Boironne in Argonne Forest.  After patrols and runners had been repeatedly shot down while attempting to carry back word of the battalion’s position and condition, he volunteered for the mission and successfully accomplished it.”  Home address, 7 Ritter Place, Bronx, New York City.

This photograph of Private Krotoshinsky appeared in the 1942 edition of The Universal Jewish Encyclopedia, within a section covering Jews in the military.  Upon the edge of his left-hand uniform pocket, his DSC is the farthest “left” of the four medals in the image.

____________________

Here’s Abraham’s Draft Registration Card, from Ancestry.com (also available through Fold3.com).

____________________

And, here’s Abraham’s New York State Abstract of Military Service card, available, as above, through Ancestry.com and Fold3.com. 

____________________

Here’s a transcript of Abraham’s DSC citation, transmitted from the General Headquarters of the A.E.F., dated November 28, 1918:  “Private Abraham Krotoshinsky, Company K, 307 Infantry (AS number 1,706,855)  For extraordinary heroim in action in Argonne Forest, France, 6 October 1918.  Private Krotoshinsky was on liaison duty with a battalion of the 308 Infantry which was surrounded by the enemy North of the Foret De La Buinonne in Argonne Forest.  After patrols and runners had been repeatedly shot down while attempting to carry back word of the Battalion’s position and condition, Private Krotoshinsky volunteered for the mission and successfully accomplished it.  Home address: M. Newman, 811 Ritter Place, Bronx, New York City.”

Private Krotoshinsky’s DFC citation was published in The War Record of American Jews, where it’s followed by a transcript of a lengthy New York Times editorial of December 19, 1918, entitled “The Private From the Bronx”. 

The military action for which Private Krotoshinky was awarded the DSC – communicating the location and status of the “Lost Battalion” (in reality, two companies of the 306th Machine Gun Battalion, one company of the 307th Infantry Regiment, and six companies of the 308th Infantry Regiment and to American troops, all components of the 77th Infantry Division) to American forces, thus eventuating in the relief and rescue of the “Battalion’s” survivors – was the subject of a 2001 television movie in which Ricky Schroder played the role of Major Charles W. Whittlesey, and Private Krotoshinsky was played by Arthur Kremer.  Unsurprisingly and perhaps inevitably – typical to a greater or lesser degree of all “war films” – the movie has a number of historical discrepancies, which are delineated here.  Still, I find it rather remarkable that in 2001 a television film was simply made – “period” – about a battle and war with which the overwhelming majority of viewers would have had little to no familiarity. 

Even more remarkable is the 1919 70-minute-long silent film production of The Lost Battalion (yes, the same title as the 2001 film) the cast of which included numerous participants of the actual battle, who – well! – played themselves.  Thus, Major Whittlesey was played by (then) Colonel Whittlesey, and Private Krotoshinsky was played by – uh – himself.  You can read a number of comments about the film, here.  

More importantly, you can view the film on YouTube, below.

Private (by then, very much civilian) Krotoshinsky appears – I think – at the 58 minute mark, and most definitely at 4:16, 1:01:15, and 1:05:15. 

Other information about the military service and postwar life of Abraham Krotoshinky, which included an effort at aliyah to the Yishuv (from which he’d eventually return to the United States with his wife Abigail and daughters Anna and Judith) is readily available in print and digital format, and might appear in a future blog post.       

______________________________

Lederman, Harold P., Second Lieutenant, 30th Infantry, Kansas City, Mo. – Awarded Croix de Guerre for valor at Chetaeu-Thierry.

Leonie, Max, Gardner, Mass., 104th Infantry – Awarded war cross.

Lerner, Philip, Pittsfield, Mass., 104th Infantry. –  Entire regiment cited.

Levine, George A., 102nd Machine Gun Battalion. – Cited for bravery.

Levingson, Abe, Private, Company G, 107th Infantry. – Distinguished Service Medal for extraordinary heroism in action near Croix Rouge Farm, northeast of Chateau-Thierry, on July 27.

Levy, Alcan, New York city, 104th Infantry. – Entire regiment cited

Levy, Leon C., Birmingham, Ala. – Awarded Distinguished Service Cross for valor in action at Soissons.

Lewine, Archie. – Awarded Croix de Guerre for extraordinary conscientiousness and remarkable sang froid in performance of his duties during a long and violent gas bombardment.

Lieberman, Nathan, Corporal, Company C., 131st Infantry. – Distinguished Service Cross for extraordinary heroism in action at Chipilly Ridge on August 9.  He displayed unusual gallantry in rushing a machine-gun nest whose fire was checking the advance.  With the assistance of a man in his squad he put the machine-gun out of action and took four prisoners.  Home address, 1426 Birchwood Avenue, Chicago, Ill.

Liner, Irving, Sergeant Major, 308th Infantry. – Awarded Distinguished Service Cross for valor in action.

Linsky, William. – Awarded the Distinguished Service Cross.

Lipsett, Joseph D., 103rd Infantry. – Cited for bravery.

Lipsie, Leo. – Received Croix de Guerre and Distinguished Service Cross.

______________________________

Paralleling the British Jewry Book of Honour’s discrepancy concerning Captain Carl Frederick Falkenberg (mis-spelled as “Falkenburg”) of the Royal Flying Corps, three similar observations can be made for The War Record of American Jews, one example being the entry for Major Kenneth P. Littauer, about whom genealogical information is available through Fold3.com and FindAGrave.

Littauer, K.P., Major, Air Service. – Awarded Distinguished Service Cross for repeated acts of heroism in action near Conflans, on September 14, and near Doulcon, on October 30.  He volunteered on a mission to protect a photographic plane for another squadron on September 14 and continued toward the objective at Conflans after three other protecting planes had failed to start.  In an encounter with five enemy planes he completely protected the photographic plane by skillful maneuvering, although his observer was wounded and his machine seriously damaged.  Home address, Alfred Littauer, father, 100th Street and Fifth Avenue, New York City.

______________________________

So for Colonel Littauer, the same for Lieutenant Roy Luther Manzer, who – in addition – was not an American, having served in the Royal Flying Corps, where he was a 12-victory aerial “ace”

Manzer, Roy, Lieutenant. – Awarded cross for downing eight hostile aircraft.  “Lieutenant Manzer was carrying out a solitary patrol when he observed a two-seater below him.  He dived, opening fire, at the same time, and when he had followed the enemy down to a height of 1,000 feet drove it to land outside the airdrome.  On his return to our lines he attacked a hostile kite balloon, which, upon reaching earth, burst into flames.  Lieutenant Manzer has in addition to these recent victories, downed seven other enemy machines.”

______________________________

Marcus, Herman, of New York. – Cited for bravery in rescuing a drowning child in French port.

Marks, Ben, dispatch rider. – Awarded Cross of Merit by the King of Italy for conspicuous bravery in the Italian theatre of war.  Last year the Croix de Guerre with star, was awarded him for gallant and meritorious services on the western front.

Mayer, George B., of Cleveland, O. – An ambulance driver. – Cited in division orders of the French army and awarded the Croix de Guerre with silver star for coolness and bravery on numerous occasions.

Mindheim, Edward N. – An infantryman of New York.  Awarded a Distinguished Service Cross for bravery at Chateau-Thierry.

Morton, Samuel J., Sergeant, 132nd Infantry, Prairie Division. – Awarded the Croix de Guerre for bravery.

Moskowitz, Daniel, Company F, 108th Infantry. – “Distinguished Service Cross for extraordinary heroism in action near Ronssoy on September 28.  He exhibited exceptional bravery by leaving shelter and going into an open field under heavy machine-gun and shell fire to rescue wounded soldiers.”  Home address, 411 Sixteenth Street, Brooklyn.

Muhr, Allen Henry, of Philadelphia. – Awarded War Cross for distinguished service with the American Field Ambulance around Moronvilliers, in Champaigne, northeast of Rheims.

Neuman, Ralph. – Awarded Croix de Guerre for distinguished service and bravery while driving an ambulance.

Ney, Leonard, Harrisburg, Virginia, 104th Infantry. – Entire regiment cited.

Nussbaum, William, 214 East Eighty-second Street, New York City, N.Y., 104th Infantry.  Entire regiment cited.

Rafalsky, Nizel, Sergeant, of Baltimore, Md. – Awarded the Distinguished Service War Cross.

Rappaport, Private. – Cited for splendid courage with forces while capturing Argonne Wood and neighboring villages.

Resnick, Mark, Worcester, Mass., 104th Infantry. – Entire regiment cited.

Rose, Maurice, Lieutenant, of Denver. – Officially commended for bravery in action during September and November.

Rosenfeld, Albert, Worcester, Massachusetts, 104th Infantry. – Entire regiment cited.

______________________________

Rosenfeld, Merrill, First Lieutenant, deceased, 115th Infantry. – “Distinguished War Service Cross for extraordinary heroism in action near Verdun.  During the various offensives of this regiment in the vicinity of the Meuse River, he displayed the greatest bravery and coolness.  He met his death while leading a group that silenced an enemy machine-gun menacing his right flank.”  Home address, 2221 Eutaw Place, Baltimore, Md.

Lieutenant Rosenfeld, killed in action on October 16, 1918, served in G Company of the 115th Infantry Regiment, 29th Infantry Division.  The son of Israel (1853-10/10/25) and Rebecca (Stern) (1861-12/28/20) Rosenfeld, he was born in Baltimore on May 18, 1883.  Buried at Baltimore Hebrew Congregation Cemetery, in Baltimore, Division 3 (Section 10, Lot 130), his name appears in Volume 1 of Soldiers of the Great War.

______________________________

Rosenfield, Harry H., Corporal. – Commended for splendid bravery and coolness.  Met his death while keeping telephone lines in continual repair under constant shell fire.

This entry for this man in The War Record of American Jews is ambiguous.  I’ve not identified a “Corporal Harry H. Rosenfield”, but there was (?) a Private Harry Rosenfield (146,529) who, while serving in the Headquarters Company, 151st Field Artillery Regiment, 42nd Infantry Division, was killed in action on August 9, 1918.  The son of Louis and Sophia Rosenfield, his family resided at 616 James Ave., in Minneapolis.  His name appears in Volume 1 of Soldiers of the Great War.  His place of burial is unknown. 

______________________________

Samuels, Max, Worcester, Massachusetts, 104th Infantry – Entire regiment cited.

Schwartz, Morris C., 3608 Irving Park Boulevard, Chicago, Ill. – Cited by Secretary Daniels for daring accomplishments.

Shapiro, Benjamin, 104th Infantry. – Entire regiment cited.

______________________________

Sharf, Jacob, 82 Malden Street, Everett, Mass., 104th Infantry. – Killed in action March 17, 1918.  Entire regiment cited.

______________________________

Shaw, Benedict, New York City, New York, 104th Infantry. – Entire regiment cited.

______________________________

Shefrin, William [Sergeant; 1,701,301] Cook, deceased, Company C, 306th Infantry. – “Distinguished Service Cross for extraordinary heroism in action in the Ravine de L’Homme Mort, near Vauxcere, between the vesle and the Aisne Rivers, September 5, 1918.  After both of his feet had been blown off by a bursting shell, Cook Shefrin, although mortally wounded, coolly directed the work of rescuing and saving the other wounded men of the kitchen detachment who had been wounded when his transport was struck.”  Cited November 12, 1918.”  Home address: 210 Seventeenth Street, Brooklyn, N.Y.

Here is Cook Shefrin’s Abstract Military Service Card (both sides)…

…and here is his photographic portrait, from Soldiers of The Great War (his name appearing on page 345 of Volume 2), by FindAGrave contributor Eric Baker.

The following three images of Cook Shefrin’s matzeva are by FindAGrave contributor S. Daino.

Cook Shefrin’s Abstract card reveals that he had already been wounded – on August 19 – less than a month before his death in combat on September 5, 1918.

Born in New York City on July 4, 1888, he was the son of Naton Shefrin, his family residing at 210 17th Street in Brooklyn.  He is buried at the Shifrin Family Plot at Mount Lebanon Cemetery, Glendale, N.Y.  (Block U, Section 3, Line 1, Grave 8, in the Shefrin Family Plot)

______________________________

Sidler, Isadore, 101st Infantry. – Cited for bravery.

Silnutzer, Mayer, Corporal, of Philadelphia. – Decorated for bravery by General Pershing.  “He was commanding a machine-gun crew in a dangerous position, and it was his gallant conduct which inspired his men to remain at their post.  He was wounded in action on July 16, but recovered in the hospital at Viehy, France.”

______________________________

Silverberg, Morris, Private, Company G, 108th Infantry. – “Distinguished Service Cross for extraordinary heroism in action near Ronssoy on September 29.  Private Silverberg, a stretcher bearer, displayed extreme courage by repeatedly leaving shelter and advancing over an area swept by machine-gun and shell fire to rescue wounded comrades.  Hearing that his company commander had been wounded he voluntarily went forward alone, and upon finding that his officer had been killed brought back his body.”  Home address, 800 East Ninety-Ninth Street, New York City.

This portrait of Private Silverberg appears in the 1942 edition of The Universal Jewish Encyclopedia

Private Silverberg (2,671,459) was wounded on November 6, five days before the war’s end, but survived.  Residing at 309 East 99th Street in Manhattan, he was born in Warsaw in 1896.   

______________________________

Silverman, Harry, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 104th Infantry. – Gassed.  Entire regiment cited.

Simon, Louis C., Jr., Second Lieutenant, 147th Aero Squadron of Columbus, Ohio. – Cited for extraordinary heroism in action in the region of Hadonville Les Lochausse, on September 18.

Simons, Samuel, 6 Day Street, Webster, Mass., 104th Infantry. – Entire regiment cited.

Solomon, David, Sergeant, Company F, 302nd Engineers. – “Cited for gallant conduct in reentering the Ravin Profund, Argonne Forest, in front of the advance elements of our division and in the face of machine-gun and sniper’s fire, to search for Private Seaman, who was found to be missing from the detachment after a skirmish for enemy snipers a few minutes previously.  This occurred on September 26, 1918.”

______________________________

Solomon, Nathan, Corporal, 6th Machine Gun Battalion, Marine Corps. – Cited for valor in Battle of the Marne.  Killed in action, October 11, 1918.

Born in New York on June 3, 1895, Corporal Solomon, son of Abraham, resided at 1875 Dean Street in Brooklyn.  He is buried at Washington Cemetery, in Brooklyn.

______________________________

Sorrow, Louis, Corporal, Company B, 307th Field Signal Battalion. – “Distinguished Service Cross for extraordinary heroism in action near Fleville, between October 13 and 21.  After being on duty continuously for thirty-six hours on October 13 he volunteered to repair telephone lines which had been cut by shell fire.  Under extremely heavy bombardment he worked all night repairing breaks to lines and thereby making possible constant communication with one of the advanced regiments.  On October 21, after one of his helpers had been killed by shell fire, he continued on alone and repaired the telephone lines, displaying unusual bravery and devotion to duty.”  Home address: 835 Beck Street, New York.

Spiegel, Frederick. – Awarded War Cross for bravery in the first Piave drive.

Stein, Samuel A., 913 North Marshall Street, Philadelphia, Pa., 104th Infantry. – Entire regiment cited.

Stein, William. – Cited for bravery in action.

Stern, Arthur M., 57 West Eighty-sixth Street, New York. – Awarded the Croix de Guerre for rescuing many wounded during a severe barrage, fire and gas attack.

Stomersky, Isaac, Private, Company B, 306th Infantry. – “On September 6, 1918, while his battalion was advancing to the attack through heavy barrage of high explosives and gas shells, this soldier showed exceptional bravery and devotion to duty as company runner by voluntarily running from place to place in the line, relaying orders and maintaining liaison.  He was invariably the first to respond when a runner was needed or when a volunteer was called for to carry a message to the company in front, all of which was beyond his regular duty.  During this time he showed the utmost bravery and total disregard to his own personal danger.” – Cited November 16, 1918.

Studinski, Isidore, 104th Infantry. – Entire regiment cited.

______________________________

Swaab, Jacques M., Lieutenant, of New York. – “On September 12, while flying over the battle lines, engaged a German Fokker in combat and dropped it, defeated, to earth.  Finding himself approached by a squadron of enemy planes, engaged the first, which met its fate when it fell burning as a result of his gunfire, and then took on one more of these German airships and succeeded in destroying that too, before returning.”

One of the 122 World War One aerial aces of the United States (individuals who specifically served in American – as opposed to British or French – aviation units), Jacques Michael Swaab attained ten confirmed aerial victories against the Germans while assigned to the 22nd Aero Squadron.  Akin to Private Abraham Krotoshinsky, information is readily available about him in both digital and print formats, such that “this” post only glancingly scratches the surface – very lightly, at that! – of his story.  However, as a general account of his military experiences, here’s his wartime story by Major Falk Harmel, which appeared in the October, 1938 issue of The Jewish Veteran:

A Jewish World War Ace
Introducing Capt. Jacques M. Swaab

In our series of articles on great Jewish military figures we have not dealt with any airmen.  This article, reprinted from ‘Post-Scripts,’ which is published by Washington Post No. 58, of which the author is adjutant, introduces us to one of the greatest American wartime aces.

One of the leading “Aces” in American war-time aviation was Captain Jacques M. Swaab, a native of Philadelphia, where he was born on April 21, 1894.

Now in this case the term “Ace,” while retaining the same meaning of superiority as in a card game, was applied during the War to aviators who shot down in aerial combat five or more enemy airplanes.  Captain Swaab just doubled the minimum number and ranked sixth among the American “Aces.”

He enlisted in the Aviation Section, Signal Corps, on June 11, 1917 just a year after he graduated from the University of Pennsylvania, where he took a commercial course.  During the War, men enlisting for service as flyers were required to go to a ground school for an approximately two months’ course in various subjects with which a flying officer was required to be familiar, and then follow this up with the flying training; so Captain Swaab was sent to the Ohio State University at Columbus, Ohio, for his ground schooling, and graduated in August.  He was then sent to Wilbur Wright Field, near Dayton, Ohio, for his flying training.  He passed the required test for the flying rating of “Reserve Military Aviator,” and was commissioned a first lieutenant on November 26, 1917.  Shortly thereafter he was assigned to duty as Assistant Supply Officer with the 801st Repair Squadron and ordered to France, where he arrived during the latter part of December.

Early in March, 1918, he was transferred to the 3rd Aviation Instruction Center at Issoudun, France, for advanced flying instruction.  After completing his training there, he became a test pilot, and in that capacity did remarkable work as a tester of airplanes and as an exhibition flyer.  In June, 1918, he was sent to Furbara, Italy, for aerial gunnery training, and on September 1st he joined the 22nd Pursuit Squadron of the 2nd Pursuit Group, which was operating at the front in France.  He became deputy flight commander and later flight commander in that Squadron.  When the Armistice was signed he was not only the highest ranking “Ace” of the 22nd Squadron, but also of the 2nd Pursuit Group.  (A Group consists of three or more squadrons).

Captain Swaab was considered a cool, courageous and able pilot.  One officer said of him: “His record of ten German planes in the 65 hours he flew over the lines is probably unexcelled in either the American or Allied Armies.”  The Commanding Officer of the 2nd Pursuit Group stated: “Captain Swaab’s career has shown an utter disregard of his own life whenever he could enter in combat with an enemy plane or help a comrade who was hard pressed.”

Captain Swaab, who was promoted to that rank on March 2, 1919, was recommended both for the Medal of Honor and the Distinguished Service Cross for having accomplished the remarkable record of destroying in combat ten enemy planes in a series of six engagements from September 8 to October 31, 1918.  These six engagements are summarized below, as follows:

Captain Swaab, on September 8, 1918, exhibited astonishing and consummate gallantry beyond the call of duty in destroying officially three enemy planes while lost in the rear of the German lines from Metz to LaBresse (Vosges).  The last of the three he destroyed while wounded and in a fainting condition.

Despite the harrying experience during his second flight over enemy territory, Captain Swaab returned to his duty to participate in the Meuse-Argonne offensive, during which he was consistently loyal and successful in his missions, and in at least one instance he saved the life of a comrade by shooting an enemy plane down from a position favorable for the latter to shoot down the American plane.

On September 8th, Captain Swaab was a member of a voluntary patrol starting from the Toul airdrome to sweep the enemy positions above the region of Pont-a-Mousson.  The day was not propitious for a clear view of the territory, and between Pont-a-Mousson and Metz the patrol was split and the various members returned to the airdrome with the exception of Captain Swaab who, for the time losing his bearings owing to his unfamiliarity with the terrain, turned East and went well into the enemy lines and prepared to land at an airdrome in the vicinity of Morhange.

As he was about to descend he observed a German plane rising from the ground.  Quickly realizing his predicament, he attacked the enemy and shot down the craft in flames.

Hotly pursued by “flaming onions,” low-angle and anti-aircraft fire, and machine gun bullets, he headed westward, having maneuvered a clear passage.  Ten enemy Fokkers appeared in pursuit.  Captain Swaab attacked them without further ado, shot one down in flames and received wounds in the top of his head from three machine gun bullets during his flight.

In a fainting condition he continued the attack, with the result that another of the enemy went down out of control.  At this stage both of his machine guns became jammed, and he escaped the remaining enemy planes by diving into a cloud bank, coming out some moments later and crashing on a mountainside near LaBresse (Vosges).

Still suffering from his wounds and from injuries sustained in the crash, Captain Swaab resumed active duty at Belrain (Meuse) on September 28th, and in a “dog fight” in the region between Montfaucon and Verdun engaged 12 enemy Fokkers and 3 Rumplers with his eight comrades.  In the course of this encounter he was about to go into combat with a picked enemy Pursuit pilot when he observed another of the adversaries pursuing 2nd Lieut. Clinton Jones.  With an utter disregard of his own predicament he gave chase to this Fokker plane and, in spite of the fact that two other enemy flyers were firing upon him, he forced Lieut. Jones’ pursuer to withdraw and he then proceeded to destroy it.

On October 23, 1918 in the region of Thenergues, Captain Swaab gave chase to a Fokker which had destroyed one of the American balloons.  He brought this plane down in flames.  While returning to the American lines from this victorious combat, he attacked an enemy Rumpler plane and, although he was pursued from above by a formation of 12 Fokkers, he succeeded in wounding or killing the observer and destroying the observation plane by causing it to fall out of control, prior to escaping the avenging pursuit of the 12 Fokkers.

On October 27th, Captain Swaab attacked a formation of 7 enemy planes (Fokkers) with 2nd Lt. Clinton Jones and, after having destroyed one of the enemy with Lieut. Jones, he dove to engage an enemy D.F.W. biplane.  Despite the fact that he was pursued by another German formation of 9 Fokkers, and with his windshield shattered by machine gun fire, he continued the attack until he had destroyed the enemy D.F.W., which crashed to the ground in a vertical nose dive.

On October 29th, Captain Swaab’s patrol of five was attacked by 8 enemy Fokkers, near Bantheville.  Lieut. Beane, leading the patrol, dived into their midst with Captain Swaab and shot down one of the Fokkers, following the defeated enemy pilot to within 50 meters of the ground over enemy soil.

On October 31st, in the region of Triaucourt, Captain Swaab left his patrol, after signaling, in order to attack a fast enemy L.V.G. biplane which was reconnoitering the American lines between the Argonne forest and Verdun.  Although forced to follow it for more than 20 miles, climbing from 2,000 to 3,300 meters and being continually exposed to the fire of the enemy observed, he persisted in forcing the issue until his own machine gun caused the enemy plane to explode in mid-air, thus bringing his official victories up to ten.

By General Orders of the War Department, dated 1920, Captain Swaab was awarded the Distinguished Service Cross, the citation therefor covering the aerial combats of September 28th and October 27th, mentioned above.

Here are the two New York State Abstract cards covering Lieutenant Swaab’s military service, photoshopped into a single image.

Jacques M. Swaab before he was Lieutenant Swaab:  His graduation portrait from The Recordthe undergraduate student yearbook of the University of Pennsylvania – for the class of 1916…

…and somewhat later – after the war? – a portrait of Lieutenant Swaab from World War One Delco.

Here’s a list of Lieutenant Swaab’s confirmed aerial victories, from his biographical profile at TheAerodrome.  Listed are the date, time of day, and type of enemy plane.  While Lieutenant Swaab piloted SPAD XIII aircraft on all these missions, the serial number of the specific SPAD he piloted is known only for the mission of 23 October: S7640.

1 – 08 Sep 1918 – 1235-1305 – Two-seater, at Cirey-Saarburg
2 – 08 Sep 1918 – 1235-1305 – Fokker D.VII, at Cirey-Saarburg
3 – 08 Sep 1918 – 1235-1305 – Fokker D.VII, at Cirey-Saarburg
4 – 28 Sep 1918 – 0840 – Fokker D.VII, at Ivoiry
5 – 23 Oct 1918 – 1140 – Fokker D.VII, at Thernogues
6 – 23 Oct 1918 – 1210 – Rumpler C, at Thernogues
7 – 27 Oct 1918 – 1540 – Fokker D.VII, at Sommerance
8 – 27 Oct 1918 – 1540 – DFW C, at Champiegneulle
9 – 29 Oct 1918 – 1620 – Fokker D.VII, at Aincreville
10 – 31 Oct 1918 – 1555 – LVG C, east of Verdun

Lt. Swaab’s victories of September 28 and October 29 were shared with Lieutenant James Dudley Beane (six victories; killed in action on October 30), and his DFW victory of October 27 with Lieutenant Clinton L. Jones, Jr., (eight victories) who survived the war. 

Notably, various sources relate that the Fokker D.VII shot down by Lieutenant Swaab on 23 October was probably piloted by German 26-victory ace Leutnant Max Näther, who – by that date – had already attained 23 victories against Allied balloons (very dangerous targets; always heavily defended) and aircraft.  Näther claimed three more aerial victories on October 29.  He died on January 8, 1919.

The painting below by aviation artist Iain Wylie, which appears on the cover of Jon Guttman’s SPAD XII / XIII Aces of World War 1 (Aircraft of the Aces) (Osprey Publishing), depicts Swaab’s victory over Näther,  Note that Lieutenant Swaab’s SPAD bears the nickname “Mayer”, after his father. 

The caption: “On 23 October 1918, 1 Lt. Jacques Michael Swaab of the 22nd Aero Squadron was conducting a patrol of the front when he spotted a burning Allied balloon.  Breaking formation to give chase to the Fokker D VII that had just set the blimp alight, he finally brought his quarry down in flames behind German lines near Thenorgues.  His opponent was Leutnant Max Nather of Jagdstaffel 62, who miraculously survived uninjured and added the balloon to his eventual wartime total of 26 victories.  While trying to rejoin his formation, Swaab encountered a Rumpler two-seater and shot it down as well, taking his tally to six.  The American was flying Kellner-built SPAD XIII S7640, which bore the number “7” and the legend MAYER II under the cockpit, the latter being applied in honour of his father.  Swaab’s final score of ten kills made him the “Shooting Star” of the 22nd Aero Squadron.”

You can view a painting, by Ronny Bar, of Max Näther’s Fokker D.VII at Wingut Wings.  Being that the artwork is copyrighted (oh, well…) I’m linking to it here, rather than copying the image into this post.  You can see Max Näther in this image (at far left) with fellow Jasta 62 pilots Hans Joachim Hagen and (possibly) Karl Gerster.

This other image from World War One Delco shows of one of Jacques’ later SPADs:  In this case, serial number S.18869, nicknamed “MAYER III”.  The 22nd Aero Squadron’s “shooting star” emblem is surrounded by 10 Balkenkreuz symbols, denoting his aerial victories. 

______________________________

Digressing (well, just a little) listed below are the names of four other American Jewish aviators who, as pursuit pilots (when did the specific phrase “fighter pilot” enter the world’s lexicon? – I don’t know!), were casualties during World War One.  Two were SPAD XIII pilots, and two (in Royal Air Force service) were S.E.5a pilots.

Brody, Alton Alexander, 1 Lt., United States Army Air Service, 13th Pursuit Squadron
Prisoner of War / Wounded in Action 9/14/18
Combat (with Fokker DVIIs?) at 8:05 A.M.; Shot down by Leutnant Günther von Büren of Jasta 18 while flying SPAD XIII 15145, “12
Interned at Camp Landshut, Karlsrushe, Germany
Born New York, N.Y., 6/27/96
Student at New York University
Mr. and Mrs. Joseph M. and Rose (Wimpie) Brody (parents)
Mrs. Antoinette (Brody) Marcus (sister)
Mr. Philip M. Brody (brother)
62 West 92nd St., New York, N.Y.
Mrs. Gloria Ann Dworetz (wife), 22 East 89th St., New York, N.Y.
Casualty List 10/23/18
The Evening Telegram (New York) 10/22/18
New York Herald 10/16/18
New York Times 10/16/18, 9/5/30 (marriage), 9/6/40, 9/8/40 (father’s obituary), 10/6/46 (wedding)
The Sky Their Battlefield, pp. 465, 541
Final Report of the U.S. Military Mission on American Prisoners of War – August 10, 1919 – p 58 (Address listed as “6 West 32nd St.”)

The below article about Lt. Brody, found at Fulton History, is from the New York Evening Telegram of October 22, 1918.  A transcript follows.

Old Newspapers

Lt. Brody Held Prisoner in Hun Camp at Karlsruhe

New York Aviator Reported Missing Several Days Ago, Located – Enlisted When College Student

WROTE HOW SHELL BROKE UP SPEECH

Lieutenant Alton Alexander Brody, Thirteenth Aero Squadron, was making a speech before a crowd of American aviators in a little town in France when a German shell fell and stopped the party.

“Oh, dear, it was awfully disconcerting, especially for my speech,” wrote the Lieutenant to Mr. and Mrs. J.M. Brody, of the Brunswick Hotel, at Madison Avenue and Eighty-Sixth Street.  That was the last heard of him until he was reported missing in action is the casualty list a few days ago.

In to-day’s list of American prisoners in German prison camp Lieutenant Brody’s name appears again.  According to the list he is a prisoner at Karlsruhe.

The New York aviator in his last letter to his mother and father wrote that Lieutenant Charles Biddle, of Philadelphia, was his commanding offider.  Brody was taking a course in applied science at New York University when he enlisted in the air service.  He has been overseas more than a year.

__________

Rosenbleet, Aaron Maurice, Lt., Royal Air Force, No. 84 Squadron
Prisoner of War 11/10/18
Offensive patrol; left 2:25 P.M.; Shot down west of Marienburg; seen landing under control
Flying S.E.5a F5515
Born Russia, 12/1/96
Mr. Harry Rosenbleet (father), 72 Royalston Ave., North, Minneapolis, Mn.
The Sky Their Battlefield, pp. 455, 564

Simon, Herbert Jerome, 1 Lt., United States Army Air Service, 13th Pursuit Squadron
Killed accidentally 11/14/18 at Louilly, Meuse, France, while flying SPAD XIII
Born San Francisco, Ca., 10/8/95
Mr. and Mrs. Henry and Bertha R. (Limon) Simon (parents), 3020 (3007?) Jackson St., San Francisco, Ca.        
Bertram, Godfrey I., J. Sydney, and E.H. Simon (brothers)
Mrs. A. Friedlander and Mrs. Eola (sp?) Berg (sisters)
Buried at San Francisco National Cemetery, San Francisco, Ca. Berkeley Gazette 12/11/18
New York Times 12/29/18
San Diego Union 12/15/18
San Francisco Call 12/11/18
San Francisco Chronicle 12/11/18
“The Great War: A Pictorial History of the 1914-1919 Fight for Freedom” gives date as 10/14/18
Other sources give date as 11/14/18

Winkler, Moses Harry, Lt., Royal Air Force, No. 56 Squadron
Prisoner of War 10/21/18
Low bombing patrol; last seen out of control 12 miles east of Le Cateau at 3:00 P.M., while flying S.E.5a F5463
Interned at Camp Villingen, Karlsrushe, Germany
Born Meridian, Ms., 1/12/96
119 South 12th St., Baton Rouge, La. (11-12-39) / Box 114, Meridian, Ms.
Casualty List 11/27/18
Final Report of the U.S. Military Mission on American Prisoners of War – August 10, 1919 – p 584 (gives name as “Moses”)
The Sky Their Battlefield, p. 441, 572
British Jewry Book of Honour, p. 536

______________________________

Teitelbaum, Bernard, Private, Sanitary Detachment, 306th Infantry,. – “This soldier, with extraordinary heroism and devotion to duty, continued to give first aid to five wounded men under severe shell fire of shrapnel and high explosives, to the utter disregard of his own personal danger, until he was himself hit by shrapnel and severely wounded.  At the time he was attached to the Third and Fourth Platoons, Company D, 306th Infantry, holding a position in the front line.”  Cited November 16, 1918.

Toelken, Julius W., Second Lieutenant, 104th Infantry. – “Distinguished Service Cross for extraordinary heroism in action near Douresches, France, July 20, 1918.  When the advance of his platoon was checked by enemy machine-gun fire Lieutenant Toelken crawled forward alone to a position from which he could fire, and killed three of the machine-gun crew, after which, with his platoon, he captured the gun and turned it on the foe.”  Home address, 145 Union Street, Springfield, Mass.  Cited November 12, 1918.

Weichmann, Walter, 103rd Infantry. – Cited for bravery.

Westzenberg, George, Sergeant, of the Medical Detachment, Company A, 2nd Anti-Aircraft Machine Gun Battalion. – Cited for bravery in action at Neuvilly.  “He voluntarily ran through enemy shell-fire to aid two soldiers who had been wounded.  He found one dead but administered anaesthetics to the living and remained with him till an ambulance came to the scene”

Wetzler, Albert E., 101st Infantry. – Cited for bravery.

Wise, Henry E., Lieutenant, an American Red Cross canteen officer, of Long Branch, N.J. – Cited a second time for the French Red Cross.

______________________________

Wise, Sol., Lieutenant, of Cincinnati. – Was awarded the Croix de Guerre for sending down a Boche flyer on August 11.

You can read much more about Lieutenant Wise in my blog posts Flight in The Great War: Lieutenant Sol Wise, Aerial Observer, Armée de l’air – I: A Letter Home, and, Lieutenant Sol Wise, Aerial Observer, Armée de l’air – II: Biography, Briefly.

______________________________

Zion, Peter P., Lieutenant, of New York City. – Awarded the Distinguished Service Cross and recommended for promotion to captain.  “Though his arm was badly slashed by a German sword bayonet, he refused to go to a dressing station, but remained in command of his platoon until the day’s objective had been obtained.”

In conclusion, it has become apparent from the information now available that the record of Jewish War Service, when fully developed, will demonstrate incontestably that the Jews of America have contributed their full quota to the winning of the war, and a generous margin beyond their quota; that they have enlisted cheerfully, fought gallantly and died bravely for the United States.  Those who knew the quality of Jewish loyalty needed no proof of this.  They knew that the qualities which had enabled the Jew to survive through the centuries – his capacity to endure, without breaking, prolonged and intense nerve strain; his qualities of initiative, his elasticity of mind, his capacity for organization, and above all, his idealism – would enable him to fit himself successfully into a democratic army fighting for world democracy.  In this they have not been disappointed.  But to communicate this knowledge to the outside world it becomes necessary to establish the known facts on the soundest possible foundations.  This the present record promises to accomplish. 

______________________________

______________________________

Next, The War Record of American Jews during the “next” war: The Second World War.

Readings, References, Writings and What-Not

Books

Adler, Michael, and Freeman, Max R.G., British Jewry Book of Honour, Caxton Publishing Company, London, England, 1922 (Republished in 2006 by Naval & Military Press, Uckfield, East Sussex)

Franks, Norman, Bailey, Frank, and Duiven, Rick, Casualties of the German Air Service – 1914-1920, Grub Street, London, 1999

Guttman, Jon (Author), Dempsey, Harry (Illustrator), SPAD XII / XIII Aces of World War 1 (Aircraft of the Aces), Osprey Publishing, Oxford, England, 2002

Haulsee, William Mitchell; Howe, Frank George; Doyle, Alfred Cyril, Soldiers of the Great War – Memorial Edition: Volume I (Alabama through Maryland), Washington, D.C., Soldiers Record Publishing Association, 1920

Haulsee, William Mitchell; Howe, Frank George; Doyle, Alfred Cyril, Soldiers of the Great War – Memorial Edition: Volume II (Massachusetts through Ohio), Washington, D.C., Soldiers Record Publishing Association, 1920

Haulsee, William Mitchell; Howe, Frank George; Doyle, Alfred Cyril, Soldiers of the Great War – Memorial Edition: Volume III (Oklahoma through Wyoming), Washington, D.C., Soldiers Record Publishing Association, 1920

Henshaw, Trevor, The Sky Their Battlefield – Air Fighting and The Complete List of Allied Air Casulties from Enemy Action in the First War, Grub Street, London, 1995

The War Record of American Jews – First Report of The Office of War Records, American Jewish Committee, January 1, 1919, The American Jewish Committee, New York, N.Y., 1919

Periodicals

Harmel, Folk, A Jewish World War Ace, The Jewish Veteran, October, 1938, p. 13

Other Publications

The Universal Jewish Encyclopedia, New York, N.Y., 1942

Websites

Guide to the Records of the American Jewish Committee – Office of Jewish War Records, undated, 1918-1921, 1962, processed by David Solomon, at Center for Jewish History

Simon L. Bloch Cohen (“A Story about the Horrors of War”), at Brotman Blog

Solomon Clifford Joseph, at The Aerodrome

Roy Manzer, at The Aerodrome

Max Näther, at The Aerodrome

Max Näther, at Wikipedia

Jacques Michael Swaab, at The Aerodrome

Iain Wyllie‘s painting of Jacques Swaab shooting down Max Nather, as featured on cover of SPAD XII / XIII Aces of World War 1, at Pinterest

SPAD S.XIII “15” (“MAYER III”) Number S.18869 of 22nd Aero Squadron, assigned to Lieutenant Jacques M. Swaab, France, Winter of 1918-19, from Gary L. Smith Collection, at 1000 Aircraft Photos.com

Max Näther’s Fokker D.VII (OAW) 6441 / 18, of Jasta 62, by Ronny Bar, at Wingnut Wings

Measures of  Valor: American Jewish Military Service in World War One – Part One

“His old man had plunged into America.”

________________________________________

This post – “Measures of  Valor: American Jewish Military Service in World War One – Part One” – is the first of three discussions focusing upon the military service of American Jews in the First World War.  Ironically, however, matters of fact are often best understood through the lens of fiction, which not uncommonly lends insight into the character of men and the spirit of an age.  So, let’s begin with a passage from Saul Bellow’s 1973 novel Humboldt’s Gift, describing the writer “Von Humboldt Fleisher”, who was loosely modeled after the poet, essayist, short story writer, and editor Delmore Schwartz , whose extremely creative yet sadly turbulent life, spanning the mid-part of the twentieth centry, ended all too early.

“…He said that history was a nightmare during which he was trying to get a good night’s rest. …  When he spoke of wealth he was in a position to compare Roman luxus with American Protestant riches.  He generally got around to the Jews – Joyce’s silk-hatted Jews outside the Bourse.”

“His father, a Jewish Hungarian immigrant, had ridden with Pershing’s cavalry in Chihuahua, chasing Pancho Villa in a Mexico of whores and horses (very different from my own father, a small gallant person who shunned such things).  His old man had plunged into America.”

This depiction of Fleisher, mentioned in the Tikvah Fund Podcast of April 3, 2019, “Daniel Gordis (in a conversation with Jonathan Silver on the Rift Between American and Israeli Jews” (specifically at 13:20-13:57), sheds light upon an intriguing void within the annals of American Jewish history.  That is, why, in the decades immediately following the First World War’s end, was no comprehensive, detailed, and substantive account of the military service of American Jews during that just-ended conflict created, published, and distributed? 

Well, okay…  That question’s a bit of a “set-up”, for a nominal account of the World War One military service of American Jews was created, and, was made available to the public.

This was in 1919, only one year after the war’s end. 

This publication took the form of the 50-page-long pamphlet The War Record of American Jews – The First Report of War Records of the American Jewish Committee.  However, this work, which merely scratched the surface of a topic vast, was mightily dwarfed in length and content by several publications – books, actually – covering the Great War military service of the Jews of Australia, England, France, Italy, New Zealand (and Germany, albeit not Austria-Hungary) which were published in those countries from the 1920s through the 1930s.

Information about the genesis of The War Record of American Jews is available in the “Guide to the Records of the American Jewish Committee – Office of Jewish War Records, undated, 1918-1921, 1962”, a finding aid of the American Jewish Historical Society (at the Center for Jewish History in New York).  The text below, about the pamphlet’s creation, is summarized from this document.

There, in a “Historical Note”, it’s reported that, “At the 11th Annual Meeting of the American Jewish Committee (AJC) on 11 November 1917, … members discussed “The matter of collecting complete and accurate statistics of Jews in the military and naval service of the United States…” and resolved that “…the Bureau of Statistics be directed to make every effort to secure data of this character.”  This effort was set to be placed under the direction of Julian Leavitt. 

This enterprise was reflective of the “longstanding concern of Jewish leadership” to record and publicize accounts of Jewish participation in the armed forces of the United States.  This had already resulted in three prior studies:

1) The American Jew as Patriot, Soldier and Citizen, by Simon Wolf (1895), which covered Jewish military service in the United States from the American Revolution through the Civil War;

2) A “Preliminary List of Jews Serving in the Spanish American War”, in the American Jewish Year Book for 5661 (1900-01);

3) “Jews in the United States Army and Navy”, also in the American Jewish Year Book; in the year 5677 (1916-17)).

At the AJC’s 12th Annual Meeting in mid-November of 1918, the organization’s Executive Committee reported that during its meeting of nearly a year before (in mid-December of 1917) the Committee’s bureau of statistics was directed to undertake the task of data collection about American Jewish WW I military service, with American Jewish organizations being contacted for assistance in this task.  The work resulted, within the AJC’s Twelfth Annual Report for the year 1918 (issued in 1919), in the creation of the The War Record of American Jews – First Report of the Office of Jewish War Records (OJWR), which was issued on January 1, 1919.

The 13th Annual Report of the AJC contained the Second Report of the OJWR, which was dated 19 October 1919.  The number of records collected pertaining to individual servicemen had by then reached 175,000, of which 150,000 were unduplicated from the first effort.  Quoting from the Report: “… The present figures tend to strongly confirm the estimate…that the Jews of America have probably contributed, numerically, from thirty-three to fifty per cent more than their quota.”

And, of particular interest (for this purpose of this post!), is this startling statement [My italics.]  “The Second Report estimated that if funds were available to complete the full project, the results of which when published, it would comprise three volumes of text and analysis and 12-15 volumes of individual war records.”

“The names and service data of individual Jewish servicemen were obtained from various sources: the JWB (Jewish Welfare Board); national Jewish organizations; local congregations, fraternal organizations, labor unions, and Zionist organizations; newspaper reports; information solicited from servicemen, their families and relatives; and War Department and Draft Board lists.”

“In addition to the collection of basic service data on Jews in the military from these sources, the OJWR sent out 16,000 detailed questionnaires to Jews whom it believed had served as Commissioned Officers and to servicemen, both Officer and the Ranks, or their next of kin, whom it believed had been wounded or killed, and/or were cited for honors.  As of the date of the Second Report, 5000 replies had been received.”

The 14th Annual Report of the AJC contained the Third Report of the OJWR, dated 14 November 1920.  This edition of Third Report anticipated the publication of a Fourth and final report, “now in preparation.” 

“The Third Report increased the total number of Jews who had served from 200,000 to 225,000.  The Report also confirmed a 4 per cent Jewish participation in military service in comparison to the 3 per cent Jewish population of the U.S., and a volunteer rate of 20 per cent, “…unexcelled, as far as known, by any other element of the American population.”  The OJWR estimated that approximately 2,800 Jews had died in service.”     

________________________________________

Here’s an article about the Third Report of the OJWR, as it appeared in The Jewish Exponent on February 18, 1921.  A transcript follows…

LATEST FIGURES UPON THE RECORD OF AMERICAN JEWS IN THE WAR

From all present indications the record of Jewish service in the war appears to have been remarkable in these respects:

1. The total number of Jews in the service during the war may be conservatively estimated on the basis of available evidence, at from 200,000 to 225,000.

2. Proportionately, although they constituted but three per cent of the total population of the United States, they appear to have contributed more than four per cent of the armed forces of the United States which, on Armistice Day, numbered 4,800,000.

3. The volunteer spirit appears to have been the principal factor in the contribution.  According to the best evidence there were nearly 40,000 Jewish volunteers in the service, or practically twenty per cent of the total Jewish contingent.  This is a record unexcelled, as far as now known, by any other element of the American population. 

4. The record of honors conferred upon Jewish soldiers for valor in action is notable.  No less than 1100 citations for valor are on file in the office of Jewish War Records.  Of these 723 were conferred by the American command, 287 by the French, 33 by the British and 46 by various other allied commands.  Of the most valued Congressional Medical of Honor – of which only 78 have been conferred to date – at least three were awarded to Jewish soldiers.  The Distinguished Service Cross is worn by at least 150 American Jews, the rare French Medaille Militaire by four American Jews and the Croix de Guerre by 174 Jews in the A.E.F.

5. There were nearly 10,000 Jewish commissioned officers in the several branches of the service.  In the army there were more than 100 colonels and lieutenant colonels, more than 500 majors, 1500 captains and over 6000 lieutenants.  In the navy there were over 900 Jewish commissioned officers, the highest rank reached being that of rear admiral.  In the Marine Corps there were over 100 Jewish commissioned officers, including one brigadier general.

6. The total of Jewish casualties, according to the latest estimates, was from 13,000 to 14,000, including about 2800 who made the supreme sacrifice.

________________________________________

But, there would be no further reports, for the OJWR closed on 31 July 1921, Leavitt having remained director throughout its existence.  Whether a “paper trail” concerning the creation of The War Record of American Jews, and the eventual abandonment of the project, still exists (let alone if such documents can be accessed now in 2020) is unknown.

In any event, what happened?

I don’t know.  But, I can offer conjecture…

As discussed by Harold Brackman in his recent Algemeiner essay, Dreyfus’ Long Shadow for American Jews, literary and social antisemitism became increasingly explicit and open within the United States through the 1920s.  And, if politics and culture reflect and reinforce one another – as they’ve done in the past; as they do in today 2020; as they always shall – this was doubtless true a century ago: during the decade immediately following the First World War

In relation to the above, it’s worth nothing that on September 25, 1919, less than a year after the war ended, President Woodrow Wilson presented his Final Address in Support of the League of Nations (mentioned in the Tikvah-Fund podcast at 5:30 to 6:00).  Therein, he stated, “I find, moreover, that there is an organized propaganda against the League of Nations and against the treaty proceeding from exactly the same sources that the organized propaganda proceeded from which threatened this country here and there with disloyalty, and I want to say – I cannot say too often – any man who carries a hyphen about with him carries a dagger that he is ready to plunge into the vitals of this Republic whenever he gets ready.”

And: “If I can catch any man with a hyphen in this great contest I will know that I have got an enemy of the Republic.”

So, amidst overlapping currents of openly expressed antisemitism, and the natural desire of the Jews of the United States – like any community of newly arrived and nauralized immigrants, let alone their descendants – to become fully Americanized, perhaps it was felt better in senses both individual and collective not to call attention to oneself “as a Jew” – as a member of a distinct and collective people, even in the most genuinely patriotic context – instead defining and viewing one’s identity solely in religious and individualistic terms, and even then, solely within the larger context of American history and society. 

As discussed in the podcast, this mindset could be viewed as an illustration of different concepts of Jewish identity manifested by the Jews of the United States (let alone, in a historical sense, any diaspora community) versus a setting where Jews would be politically autonomous.  Such, as the pre-1948 Yishuv, and, the post-May 1948 nation state of Israel.  There, by virtue of a “return” to active political, social, and military autonomy, even if that autonomy has often been ambiguous and uncertain, the ethos was different.  The reason being, that the re-emergence of active Jewish nationalism (well, it never really went away) and the re-establishment of the state of Israel confronted the Jewish people with the implications of returning to and acting within history, with all the challenges, complexities, and compromises – let alone sorrows and joys – implicit to nationhood.

(Certainly these categories of thought and identity can painted in very broad and many-hued strokes.  There has always been enormous variation in political, ideological, and religious opinion among the Jewish people, whether in Israel, the United States, or elsewhere.  Alas, “geography” alone – being a little euphemistic, there – has never been a guarantee of common sense, political wisdom, ethics, or a grasp of history, as explained here, here, and especially in Daniel Gordis’ Times of Israel Essay of March 23, “We will guard and protect you’: Our forgotten promise to Israel“.  In any event, I think Gordis and Silver’s discussion of this topic offers a profound grasp of how history is perceived and acted upon – knowingly and unknowingly; by decision and default – by groups and individuals alike.) 

In sum, America offered – ostensibly, in theory, and typically in reality (whether that reality emerged from indifference, calculation, or a place of uneasy compromise between the two) a refuge from history. 

So with that refuge from history, came a release from history.  Not, of course, American history, but Jewish history.

Well, maybe.  Well, thus far.  Or, to paraphrase an adage about military conflict, “You may not be interested in history, but history may be interested in you.”  Put it another way (here once again fiction illuminates fact!): As science-fiction writer Philip K. Dick explained in his short story, “We Can Remember It For You Wholesale”, “…an illusion, no matter how convincing, remained nothing more than an illusion.  At least objectively.  But subjectively, quite the opposite, entirely.” 

(And there I’ll leave the matter.)

For a greater understanding of the complexities this subject, you might want to read Are We One? – Jewish Identity in the United States and Israel, by Dr. Jerold S. Auerbach (Rutgers University Press, 2001), Assimilation and Its Discontents (1995) by the late Barry M. Rubin, and, America, Its Jews, and The Rise of Nazism, by Dr. Gulie Ne’eman Arad (Indiana University Press, 2000).  The latter places the events discussed in David S. Wyman’s well-known The Abandonment of the Jews in a deeper, clearer, and disconcerting historical context.  Particularly interesting in Dr. Arad’s book is the chapter “Hard Times in the Golden Medine – The Jewish Question in the American Context”, which covers American Jewry during the the decade in question for “this” post: the 20s and 30s.  On a different nore, for a candid sociological picture of Jews of the United States – neither lachrymose nor indulging in Spielbergian hagiography – I suggest Charles S. Liebman’s The Ambivalent American Jew – Politics, Religion, and Family in American Jewish Life, the observations of which, though published in 1973, remain as valid in 2020 as they did forty-seven years ago.

So, returning to our subject…  In the context of the 1920s, by the time the American Jewish Committee had amassed sufficient information to create one or more (and probably several) volumes about the military service of American Jews during the just-ended conflict, it would not be surprising if the motivation, desire, and confidence to pursue the project had simply evaporated.  The only publication that emerged from the AJC’s well-intended efforts was entirely incommensurate with the scope of the military service of American Jews during that conflict, let alone the range of historical memory and archival information that awaited collection, contemplation, analysis, and presentation. 

And there, the effort ended.

In any event…  Two decades later after the Great War’s end, the absence of comprehensive information about the WW I military service of American Jews was discussed in the April 2, 1943 issue of Pittsburgh’s Jewish Criterion.  This appeared in a brief article which presented the thoughts of Dr. Joshua Bloch, chief librarian of the Jewish Division (now the Dorot Jewish Division) of The New York Public Library.  Dr. Bloch’s comments about the absence of an account of Jewish military participation in the First World War were elicited in the context discussing the imperative of chronicling Jewish military service in the Second World War, which – for the United States – had commenced two and a half years previously.  

A transcript of the Criterion’s article appears below this image; the italics are my own.

Jewish Record in Last War Never Revealed, Charge

NEW YORK – Dr. Joshua Bloch, head of the Jewish Department of the New York Public Library and noted authority in the field of Jewish research, charges in the Congress Weekly that “The Jews of America, acting in good faith, placed in the custody of the American Jewish Committee the records of their patriotism during the first World War,” but that the, “full record of American Jewish participation has not been made public.”

“Whether the appalling manner in which this undertaking was bungled is due to bureaucratic arrogance or inefficiency or to a well-known theory of the Jewish self-effacement and the negation of our historic identity,” he declares, the Committee has never released a complete record of the contribution made by 150,000 Jews to the winning of the last conflict.”

Pointing out that “the American Jews were required to provide the required funds, a total close to $150,000,” Dr. Bloch asks the fate of the records, of which he says, “it is rumored that a good many are no longer in existence.”  [In this he seems to have been fortunately incorrect, though he may have not known so at the time.]

The article concludes, “Fated to share in another world-wide ordeal of mankind, at the greatest cost to out people, we now again face the task of assembling the records of our service and sacrifice, not alone to satisfy our sense of pride and dignity, but to preserve a moral historic claim with which our future welfare is closely bound up.  The undertaking of a quarter of a century ago should serve as an example of pitfalls to be avoided.  Obviously the organizations and the people connected with the American Jewish Committee and agencies under its control can no longer be entrusted with an enterprise which proved to be far beyond their capacity or sense of responsibility.  It is high time that new and more responsive persons be brought in to this and similar public activities.”

________________________________________

Well, what about The War Record of American Jews?  As mentioned in the Center for Jewish History’s finding aid, “The First Report documented the creation of 100,000 records of individuals identified as Jews and estimated that a total of 150,000 to 200,000 Jews had served in the American armed forces,” and noted that, “the percentage of Jews serving in the military exceeded their percentage of the U.S. population, especially in the combat arms.”  Book director Julian Leavitt concluded that “The Jews of America have contributed their full quota to the winning of the war, and a generous margin beyond their quota; that they have enlisted cheerfully, fought gallantly and died bravely for the United States.”

In terms of content, the book is divided into three major sections.

The first section (pages 7 through 15), a, “Report on the Collection of Jewish War Records,” presents the numbers of Jews serving in different branches of the military, a comparison of the number of Jews in the military against the overall Jewish population in the United States, and the distribution of Jews in combatant and non-combatant branches of the armed forces, concluding with the numbers – as then definitively known, and as estimated – of Jewish military casualties.

The second section (pages 15 through 29) is a, “…tentative list of official citations noted to date, although manifestly incomplete, [which] will serve to give an idea of the valor of Jewish soldiers in action.”  Notably, the book states, “The list of all citations will therefore be prepared for publication as soon as sufficient information with respect to these honors shall be available.”  However, the book neither presents the criteria by which these soldiers were selected, nor does it specify the award(s) for which the soldiers received citations.  (More about these men, below.)

Finally, the third section of the book (pages 30 through 50) – the Appendix – is a “Note on Methods of Search”, actually a, “Reprint of an article “The Collection of Jewish War Statistics,” from the American Jewish Year Book 5679 (1918-19).”  Obviously rather “dry” and not amendable for publication in a newspaper (!), this section includes eight tables presenting the actual counts of Jews serving in all branches of the military, by such criteria as state and city of residence, within branches of service in the army, and – for officers – by rank in the Army, Navy, and Marine Corps.  The final table lists the “Ratio of Jewish Casualties to Total Casualties with the American Expeditionary Forces Recorded to November 1, 1918.

That’s lots of data.

So, some thoughts and questions.

The AJC’s pamphlet is an important starting point, but it seems that the whole endeavor was undergirded by the need – a need so deeply internalized that its presence may have been simply taken a priori for granted – to validate and legitimize the “place” of American Jews within the larger context of American society, rather than the simple, nominal motivation to record, preserve, and present official history and personal memory.  So, while thirty of the book’s fifty pages are devoted to the presentation and discussion of statistics, only 15 pages actually comprise – in abbreviated form; in perfunctory form – information about the soldiers themselves, as people; as individuals; as men.  This manner of chronicling Jewish military service, and thereby refuting animosity against Jews and validating Jewish citizenship and patriotism – through statistics; through objective fact – similarly appeared in the context of documenting (during World War One and after) the military service of German Jews, and manifested itself in reporting about American Jewish military service twenty years later, during the Second World War.  But, however historically worthwhile and well intended, I can’t help be reminded of Maurice Samuel’s observation in The Gentleman and The Jew, to the effect that, “The argument was sound in theory, but rather shaky in practical application.  It neglected, first, to ask whether anti-Semites would look when Jews pointed.”

Anyway, for the AJC’s researchers, compilers, and editors, what was book’s intended audience?  The Jews of the United States, with the book being a historical record and symbol of collective pride and self-assurance?  Or nebulously, American society “in general” – however viewed and imagined; however aspired to; however viewed with a combination of respect, devotion, and patriotism, let alone trepidation, fear, and awe  – with the book being a literary form of social propitiation, during a time of ambivalence and uncertainty?

The answer, probably, was both.

Anyway…

Though I’ve primarily focused on the Jewish military experience during the Second World War (and still do), I’ve also been attempting to identify American Jewish military casualties of WW I (killed, wounded, and POWs).  Inspiration for this project has arisen from many sources, in particular some news items published by the Jewish Telegraphic Agency in the early 2000s. 

This project has proven to be a little challenging, primarily because there’s no single, pre-existing source of such information that can be entered (albeit with lots of digitizing and / or typing!) into a database, unlike Les Israelites dans l’Armée Française (for WW I French Jewish military casualties), or Die Jüdischen Gefallenen Des Deutschen Heeres, Deutschen Marine Und Der Deutschen Schutztruppen 1914-1918 – Ein Gedenkbuch (for German Jewish military casualties in the same war), where the information – a lot of it – is already “there”.

So, I’ve investigated a wide variety of digital, textual, and microfilm records from the years of WW I, which sometimes contradict one another. 

Perhaps in time I’ll finish the work.  At the same time, I wouldn’t be surprised if upon the yet-unknown date of the project’s completion, “that” world will differ greatly from the world today, in 2020.

The way things are going, it probably will.  But, that’s the subject of a different sort of essay.

So, anyway… 

…for now, here’s a random “sample” of the information I’ve acquired in this endeavor: A list of American Jewish soldiers who were casualties on the 12th of October in the year 1918 (or, 6 Cheshvan 5679).

Of the men listed below, two, Pvt. Samuel Goldstein and 2 Lt. David Hochstein, were never found.  Perhaps they’re among the 1,673 unknowns buried at American Battle Monuments Commission Cemeteries in Europe.  The number of unknowns at each such cemetery, derived from downloading and analyzing records from the ABMC website, is listed below:

Aisne-Marne – 249
Brookwood – 41
Flanders – 21
Meuse-Argonne – 486
Oise-Aisne – 601
Saint Mihiel – 137
Somme – 132
Suresnes – 6

So, some names.

Killed in Action

– .ת. נ. צ. ב. ה
תהא

נפשו
צרורה
בצרור
החיים

Bereznitzki, Benjamin, PFC, 1,900,127
82nd Infantry Division, 325th Infantry Regiment, M Company
Mr. Julius Miller (friend), 126 Charles St., Fitchburg, Ma.
61 B Valley St., Lawrence, Ma.
Born Grodno, Russia, 4/24/90
Vocation: Junkman (self-employed), Lawrence, Ma.
Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery, Romagne-sous-Montfaucon, France – Plot D, Row 29, Grave 2

________________________________________

Blick, David, Pvt., 1,281,849
29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, K Company
Wounded 10/12/18; died of Wounds 10/21/18
Mr. Samuel Blick (father), 549 Livingston St., Elizabeth, N.J.
Miss Lillian Blick (sister), 1056 Elizabeth Ave., Elizabeth, N.J.
Born Odessa, Russia, 1894
Oheb Shalom Cemetery, Hillside, N.J. – Buried 7/17/21

Portrait c/o FindAGrave contributor Robert

________________________________________

Cohen, Samuel, Cpl., 1,278,184
29th Infantry Division, 113th Infantry Regiment, D Company
Mrs. Lena Cohen (mother), 207 16th Ave., Newark, N.J.
232 Seymour Ave., Newark, N.J.
Born Newark, N.J., 1899
Place of burial unknown

Cohn
, Oscar, Pvt., 368,930

29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, K Company
Mrs. Regina Cohen (mother), 210 West 109th St., New York, N.Y.
403 Avenue C, West Brooklyn, N.Y.
Mrs. Theresa Doctor, Mrs. Jennie Galluber, Mrs. Martha Pincus, Joseph, and Walter (sisters and brothers)
Born New York, N.Y., 4/13/96
Brooklyn Eagle 8/28/21
Union Field Cemetery, Ridgewood, N.Y. – Buried 8/28/21

Eisenberg
, David, Pvt., 482,350

4th Infantry Division, 39th Infantry Regiment, B Company
Died of Wounds
Mrs. Rose Eisenberg (mother), 3147 Carlisle Place, Chicago, Il.
Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery, Romagne-sous-Montfaucon, France – Plot C, Row 45, Grave 12

________________________________________

Felbel, Frank J., 2 Lt.
1st Infantry Division, 28th Infantry Regiment, I Company
Mr. Jacob Felbel (father), 216 W. 89th St., New York, N.Y.
Born New York, N.Y., 12/29/89
Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery, Romagne-sous-Montfaucon, France – Plot A, Row 42, Grave 36

Portrait c/o FindAGrave contributor Jim Craig

________________________________________

Feldberg, Harry, PFC, 2,672,238
82nd Infantry Division, 325th Infantry Regiment, B Company
Mr. Isadore Feldberg (brother), 345 Georgia Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.
21 East 117th St. / 105 Henry St., New York, N.Y.
Born Kiev, Russia, 2/15/91
Vocation: Salesman, Bird-Ston Dress Co., 114 E. Broadway, New York, N.Y.
Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery, Romagne-sous-Montfaucon, France – Plot B, Row 19, Grave 30

Frank
, Max, Pvt., 366,741

29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, M Company
Mrs. Pauline Frank (mother), 109 Cole St., Jersey City, N.J.
23 Arch St., New Haven, Ct.
Born New York, N.Y., 6/21/93
Vocation: Building Clerk, Sperry & Barnes, New Haven, Ct.
North Arlington Jewish Cemetery, North Arlington, N.J.

Gerson
, Raoul, Pvt., 52,801

1st Infantry Division, 26th Infantry Regiment, B Company
Died of Wounds
Mr. Milton T. Levy (friend), 233 Broadway, New York, N.Y.
Born Constantinople, Turkey, 1893
Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery, Romagne-sous-Montfaucon, France – Plot A, Row 34, Grave 31

Goldstein, Hyman, Pvt., 369,024
29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, B Company
Mr. Samuel Goldstein (father), 663 Fox St., New York, N.Y.
Born N.Y., New York, 1893
Place of burial unknown

Goldstein
, Ray D., Pvt., 962,305

United States Army Air Service – General Sup. Depot Fairfield, Oh., 678th Aero Squadron
Died of Illness
Mr. and Mrs. Benjamin and Leah J. [1874-1921] Goldstein (parents), 2205 Atlantic Ave., Atlantic City, N.J.
Born Pemberton, N.J., 10/10/95
Vocation: Clerk (Auto Supplies), Reliable Auto Tire Supply Co., Atlantic City, N.J.
Rodef Sholom Cemetery, Cardiff, N.J.

Goldstein, Samuel, Pvt., 1,280,559
29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, E Company
Mrs. Esther Goldstein (mother), 1102 Heck Ave., Asbury Park, N.J.
19 Prospect St., West Grove, N.J.
Born Russia, 4/10/96
Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery, Romagne-sous-Montfaucon, France – Tablets of the Missing

________________________________________

Hochstein, David, 2 Lt.
5th Infantry Division, 60th Infantry Regiment, E Company
Mrs. Helene Hochstein (mother), 421 Joseph Ave., Rochester, N.Y.
Born Rochester, N.Y., 2/16/92
Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery, Romagne-sous-Montfaucon, France – Tablets of the Missing

A vast amount of information is available concerning the life and legacy of David Hochstein, a virtuoso violinist of immense talent and promise.  The best start might be the David Hochstein Memorial Music School, which was created in his honor and memory.

________________________________________

Kaplan, Zorach, Pvt., 368,834
29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, D Company
Mr. Morris Resnick (brother in law), 724 Bedford Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.
232 South 1st St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Born Minsk, Russia, 3/15/93
Vocation: Tailor, New York City
Other reference(s) give first name as “Zorak” or “Zorch”, while he wrote the name “Zorach” on his Draft Registration Card
Place of burial unknown

Kaufman, Reuben, PFC, 1,280,355
29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, D Company
Mr. Max Kaufman (father), 20 Oxford St., Paterson, N.J.
Born West Hartley Pool, England, 1898
Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery, Romagne-sous-Montfaucon, France – Plot D, Row 13, Grave 29

________________________________________

Krinsky, Louis (Aharon Lev ben Eliyahu), Pvt., 367,710
29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, E Company
(Also slightly wounded 9/17/18)
Mrs. Anna Krinsky (mother), 214 Levonia Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.
678 Westchester Ave., New York, N.Y.
Born Prusnia, Krona, Russia, 7/15/90
Vocation: Tailor, Joseph Lunz, 31 East 32nd St., New York, N.Y.
Mount Judah Cemetery, Ridgewood, N.Y. – Map 383, Section 2, Block 12, Gate 5, Path R18, Grave 38 (Horodetz & Antip. Society)

Photographs of matzeva by FindAGrave contributor FOIA

________________________________________

Levin, Morris, Pvt., 368,377
29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, E Company
(Also slightly wounded 9/16/18)
Mrs. May Levin (mother), 321 Vernon Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Born Korne, Russia, 1888
Place of burial unknown

Levine
, Philip, Cpl.

17th Infantry Division, 83rd Infantry Regiment, A Company
Died of illness in Brooklyn, N.Y.
Place of burial unknown

Lewis, Morse, Sgt., 749,132
3rd Infantry Division, E Company, 3rd Supply Train
Mrs. Ida Newmark (mother), 105 Waumbeck St., Roxbury, Ma.
1 Lt. Bernhard Shalit (cousin), 105 Waumbeck St., Roxbury, Ma.
Born 3/2/96
Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery, Romagne-sous-Montfaucon, France – Plot H, Row 2, Grave 8

Lewis
, Moses, Pvt., 368,105

29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, D Company
Miss Ida Lewis (sister), 860 East 161st St., New York, N.Y.
Born New York, N.Y.,10/31/93
Vocation: Superintendent, Central Tuppee, 28 South William St., New York, N.Y.
Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery, Romagne-sous-Montfaucon, France – Plot F, Row 10, Grave 1

Linet
, William, Pvt., 4,155,165

88th Infantry Division, 350th Infantry Regiment, G Company
Died of illness
Mrs. Rose Linet (mother), 753 DeKalb Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Born Odessa, Russia, 12/20/95
Place of burial unknown

Markowitz
, Samuel, Pvt., 2,428,764

33rd Infantry Division, 132nd Infantry Regiment, M Company
Mrs. Sarah Markowitz (mother), 5608 Quincy Ave., Cleveland, Oh.
Born “Koono Komo”, Russia, 1892
Place of burial unknown

Mestezky
, Josel, PFC, 1,897,750

82nd Infantry Division, 325th Infantry Regiment, B Company
Mrs. Josel Mestezky (wife), 619 Porter St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Born Kosna, Russia, 1892
Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery, Romagne-sous-Montfaucon, France – Plot B, Row 15, Grave 39 (ABMC incorrectly lists surname as “Nestezsky”)

________________________________________

Milhiser, Harry Joseph, Pvt., 1,290,873
29th Infantry Division, 112th Machine-Gun Battalion, A Company
Mr. and Mrs. Joseph W. [10/17/56-5/24/31] and Rachel [6/22/53-9/28/28] Milhiser (parents), 1632 North Appleton St., Baltimore, Md.
Carrie, Edna, and Max (sisters and brother)
Born Millersburg, Pa., 6/7/86
Hebrew Friendship Cemetery, Baltimore, Md.

Photograph of matzeva by FindAGrave contributor Michelle

________________________________________

Nedlin, Max, Pvt., 482,769
7th Infantry Division, 55th Infantry Regiment, Machine-Gun Company
Mr. Morris Nedlin (brother), 1068 South Trumbull Ave., Chicago, Il.
Born Vilna, Russia, 4/26/91
Vocation: Tailor (unemployed)
Waldheim Jewish Cemetery, Chicago, Il.

Pariser
, Harry, Cpl., 1,707,038

77th Infantry Division, 307th Infantry Regiment, L Company
Mr. Abraham N. Pariser (brother), 51 Chambers St., New York, N.Y.
1827 Clinton Ave., New York, N.Y.
Born New York, N.Y., 1892
Mount Hebron Cemetery, Flushing, N.Y. – Block 1, Section C, Lot 7 & 8, Grave 11

Robenovitz
, Benjamin Alberts “Ben”, PFC, 1,978,350

33rd Infantry Division, 130th Infantry Regiment, M Company
Killed in action at Boise de Chaume, France
Mr. and Mrs. Eli and Bessie (Alberts) Robenovitz (parents), 2725 East Washington St., Indianapolis, In.
Brevort Hotel, Indianapolis, In.
Born “Hussi” (?), Romania, 5/20/92
Vocation: Salesman, L. Strauss and Company, 33 West Washington St., Indianapolis, In.
Congregation Esras Achem Cenetery, Marion County, In.

Rosen
, Israel, Pvt., 367,913

29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, B Company
Mr. William Rosen (father), 770 East 165th St., New York, N.Y.
1072 Union Place, Bronx, N.Y.
Born Odessa, Russia, 1892
Place of burial unknown

Rosenberg
, Sam, PFC, 1,709,354

77th Infantry Division, 308th Infantry Regiment, H Company
Died of Wounds
Mrs. Rose Rosenberg (mother), 88 Rivington St., New York, N.Y.
Born New York, N.Y., 2/26/95
Vocation: Clothes Dealer (with father), 88 Rivington St., New York, N.Y.
Possibly buried at Washington Cemetery, Brooklyn, N.Y.

Straus, Raymond, Pvt., 368,062
29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, B Company
Mrs. Rebecca Straus (mother), 1908 Crotona Ave., New York, N.Y.
Born Samsonville, Vt., 11/4/95
Vocation: Clerk, New York, N.Y.
Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery, Romagne-sous-Montfaucon, France – Plot H, Row 4, Grave 13

Swerdloff
, Benjamin P., Pvt.

152nd Depot Brigade, 40th Company
Died of illness
45 Norway Park, Buffalo, N.Y.
Place of burial unknown

Wiener
, Harry, PFC, 369,620

29th Infantry Division, 116th Infantry Regiment, D Company
Died of illness
Mr. Leo Frederick (uncle), 23 East 26th St., New York, N.Y.
650 Cleveland St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Born Galicia, Austria, Galicia, 1/15/92
Vocation: Cutter, L. Friederich, 23 East 26th St., New York, N.Y.
Union Field Cemetery, Ridgewood, Queens, N.Y.

Zalkin
, Harry, Cpl.

Quartermaster Corps, Florida, Camp Johnston, Mt. Student Co. 1
Died of illness
36 Broadway, Marlborough Hotel, New York, N.Y.
Montefiore Cemetery, Springfield Gardens, N.Y. – Gate 347/N, Block 16, Row 006L, Grave 3 – Society Louis Damaszek Lodge, Inc.; Buried 10/16/18

  ________________________________________

Wounded in Action

Brody, Jacob, PFC, 366,994
29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, L Company
Severely Wounded in Action
Mrs. Jennie Brody (mother), 402 Ferry St., New Haven, Ct.
Born New Haven, Ct., 5/28/92
Vocation: Butcher, Harry Brody, 3239 Poplar St., New Haven, Ct.

Cohen
, Tobias B., Pvt., 368,058

29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, C Company
Slightly Wounded in Action
Mrs. Katie Cohen (wife), 457 East 124th St., New York, N.Y.
Mr. Charley Cohen (brother), 560 Mark St., New York, N.Y.
Born Warsaw, Poland, 8/20/89
Machinist (unemployed)

Ghelberg
, Abraham, Pvt., 368,044

29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, B Company
Severely Wounded in Action
Mr. Isaac Berger (uncle), 232 South 2nd St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
1525 Washington Ave., New York, N.Y.
Born “Yose”, Romania, 1/1/94
Vocation: Clerk, Samuel Gang, 1498 1st Ave., New York, N.Y.

Ginsberg
, Joseph Abraham, PFC, 3,106,656

79th Infantry Division, 313th Infantry Regiment, D Company
Severely Wounded in Action
Mr. Morris Ginsberg (father), Queenstown, Queen Anne’s County, Md.
Vocation: Merchant, Morris Ginsberg, (Queenstown?), Md.
Born Baltimore, Md., 8/15/91

Hockman
, Jacob, Pvt., 368,074

29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, B Company
Slightly Wounded in Action
Mrs. Esther Hockman (mother), 1054 Simpson St., New York, N.Y.
Born Warsaw, Poland, 1891

Kaufman
, Woolf, PFC, 366,388

29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, M Company
Wounded in action (degree undetermined)
Miss Jennie Kaufman (sister), 21 Bradley St., New Haven, Ct.
Born Urovichi, Minsky Goderni, Russia,7/15/91
Vocation: Hebrew Teacher, Jewish Board of Education, 16 Bradley St., New Haven, Ct.

Moskowitz, Morris, Pvt., 368,833
29th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment, E Company
Severely Wounded in Action
Mrs. Fannie Moskowitz (mother), 146 South 2nd St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Born “Yassy” (probably meaning Jassy or Iassy) Romania, 6/2/92
Vocation: Salesman, New York, N.Y.

Rothenberg
, Irving Nathan, Pvt., 2,337,734

3rd Infantry Division, 4th Infantry Regiment, Machine-Gun Company
Severely Wounded in Action
Mrs. Rose Oppenheimer (mother), 2 West 89th St., New York, N.Y.
Born Leavenworth, Ks., 11/4/90
Vocation: Wholesaler (cheese) (self employed), 189 Franklin St., New York, N.Y.

Rothman
, David, Pvt., 2,672,427

27th Infantry Division, 107th Infantry Regiment, I Company
Wounded (Degree Undetermined)
Miss Eva Rothman (sister), 63 East 104th St., New York, N.Y.
51 East 108th St., New York, N.Y.
Born Odessa, Russia, 1891

Sokoloff
, Irving, Pvt., 3,197,058

33rd Infantry Division, 131st Infantry Regiment, A Company
Severely Wounded in Action
Mrs. Martha Sokoloff (mother), 545 Lancaster St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
388 Bradford St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Born Minsk, Russia, 8/5/95
Vocation: Manager, Mr. Leselbauer, 747 Sutter Ave., New York, N.Y.

Stair
, David, Pvt., 2,671,489

82nd Infantry Division, 326th Infantry Regiment, L Company
Wounded (Degree Undetermined)
Mrs. Mollie Epstein (sister), 909 Beck St., New York, N.Y.
12 West 121st St., New York, N.Y.
Born Kiev, Russia, 8/5/91
Vocation: Salesman, Ames Brothers, 630 Fifth Ave., New York, N.Y.

Wasserman
, Charles, First Sergeant, 3,356,383

4th Infantry Division, 39th Infantry Regiment, Headquarters Company
Slightly wounded in action
Mrs. Fanny Wasserman (mother), 214 Johnson St., Dayton, Oh.
Born Dayton, Oh., @ 1891

Weinberg
, Louis, Pvt., 1,390,291

33rd Infantry Division, 132nd Infantry Regiment, L Company
Slightly wounded in action
Mrs. Mollie Gordon (sister), 2008 Fairmont Ave., Baltimore, Md.
1914 East Fayette St., Baltimore, Md.
Born Russia, @ 1896

These are military casualties (killed in action or died of wounds) among Jewish soldiers who served in other armies, on the same date…

British Army

Alexander, Alec, Pvt., 61316, Middlesex Regiment, 4th Battalion
Mr. and Mrs. Israel and Amelia Alexander (parents), 237 Brunswick Buildings, Hailstone St., Aldgate, London, E, England
Born 1900
The Jewish Chronicle 1/3/19, 2/28/19 (2/28/19 lists serial as “18531”)
British Jewish Book of Honour – 77
Romeries Communal Cemetery Extension, Nord, France – III,C,10

Marks
, Leonard George, Pvt., G/26028, Royal Sussex Regiment, 17th Battalion

Mr. and Mrs. Simon and Henrietta Marks (parents), 38 Grainger St., Newcastle-on-Tyne, England
(also) Hazelhurst, Akenside Terrace, Newcastle-on-Tyne, England
Born 1894
The Jewish Chronicle 11/29/18
The Jewish Chronicle (Obituary Section) 10/25/18
British Jewish Book of Honour – 107
Ration Farm Military Cemetery, La Chapelle-d’Armentieres, Nord, France – VIII,A,31

Mendelssohn, Max, Gunner, 172375, Royal Horse Artillery, 18th Brigade Ammunition
(parents) 5 Causeway Side, Edinburgh, Scotland
Born 1897
Veterinary Surgeon
British Jewish Book of Honour – 108
Jerusalem War Cemetery, Jerusalem, Israel – J,S,14

Nathan, Charles, Pvt., 254176, London Regiment (Royal Fusiliers), 1st/1st Battalion
Mr. and Mrs. Isidore and Sarah Nathan (parents), 57 Jane St., London, E, England
Pvt. Joe Nathan (brother)
Born 1895
British Jewish Book of Honour – 110
Terlincthun British Cemetery, Wimille, Pas de Calais, France – V,D,33

Stibbe, Mark, Pvt., 39396, Northumberland Fusiliers, 2nd Battalion, C Company
Mr. and Mrs. David and Leah Stibbe (parents), 5 Cleveland Grove, Mile End, London, E, England
The Jewish Chronicle 11/8/18
British Jewish Book of Honour – 120
Highland Cemetery, Le Cateau, Nord, France – X,C,7

Trachtenberg, Mendel Isidore, L/Cpl., J/2716, Royal Fusiliers, 39th Battalion (Jewish Legion)
Died of malaria
Mrs. Jennie Pauline (Luxenberg) Trachtenberg (wife), 2 Somali Road, London, NW2, England
Mr. and Mrs. Isidore Mendel and Eva Trachtenberg (parents)
Henry and Max (brothers), 139 Fordwych Road, Cricklewood, London, England
Born 1882
The Jewish Chronicle 10/25/18, 12/20/18 (lists serial number as J/4716)
The Jewish Chronicle (Obituary Section) 10/25/18
New York Times 12/28/18
British Jewish Book of Honour – 121
Jerusalem War Cemetery, Jerusalem, Israel – JS,13

Wallach, Maurice, Pvt., 54211, West Yorkshire Regiment (Prince of Wales’ Own), 1st/6th Battalion
(parents) 6 Church Crescent, South Hackney, London, England
5 Holme’s Ave., London, E, England
Born 1899
The Jewish Chronicle 12/13/18 (lists surname as “Wallack”)
British Jewish Book of Honour – 122
Vis-en-Artois British Cemetery, Haucourt, Pas de Calais, France – Panel 4

French Army (Armée de Terre)

Benaim, Lucien Abraham, Soldat de 2eme Classe
Zouaves, 16eme Bataillon Territorial de Zouaves
Died after contracting illness in the army [Suité d’une maladie contractée dans l’armée] – l’Hopital Temporaire No. 9, Salonique, Grece
Born Inkermann, Oran, Algerie, 11/21/91
Place of burial unknown
Les Israelites dans l’Armée Française (Israelites [Jews] in the French Army) – pp. 9, 11
Le Livre d’Or du Judaisme Algérien (The Gold Book of Algerian Jewry) – 201

Karsenty, Maurice, Conducteur de 2eme Classe
Service Automobile, 8eme Escadron du Train
Disease contracted on duty [Maladie contractée en service commandé] – l’Hopital Complimentaire No. 38, Beauvais, Oise
Born Marseilles, Bouches-du-Rhone, France, 4/7/96
Place of burial unknown
Les Israelites dans l’Armée Française (Israelites [Jews] in the French Army) – Not Listed

Nathan, Isaac, Soldat de 2eme Classe
173eme Regiment d’Infanterie
Killed by the enemy [Tué a l’ennemi] – Bellecourt Foste Soloncourt, Aisne
Born Tlemcen, Oran, Algerie, 8/15/97
Necropole Nationale “Saint-Quentin”, Saint-Quentin, Aisne, France – Tombe Individuelle, No. 3467
Les Israelites dans l’Armée Française (Israelites [Jews] in the French Army) – Not Listed

German Army (Deutsches Heer)

Alexander, Kurt, Pvt. [Soldat]
Reserve Infanterie Regiment 269, 3rd Battalion, 11th Kompagnie
From Ortsleburg, Germany
Born Bartenstein, Germany, 9/23/98
Casualty Message (Verlustmeldung) 1358
Die Jüdischen Gefallenen Des Deutschen Heeres, Deutschen Marine Und Der Deutschen Schutztruppen 1914-1918 – Ein Gedenkbuch – 312
Place of burial unknown

Beyer, Rudolf, Pvt. [Soldat], Musketier
Infanterie Regiment 163, Ersatz Bataillon , Garnison Kompagnie
From Hamburg, Germany
Born Lissa, Germany, 10/3/97
Casualty Message (Verlustmeldung) 1315
Die Jüdischen Gefallenen Des Deutschen Heeres, Deutschen Marine Und Der Deutschen Schutztruppen 1914-1918 – Ein Gedenkbuch – 369
Kriegsgräberstätte in Hamburg-Ohlsdorf-Jüdischer Friedhof (Bundesrepublik Deutschland), Block B, Reihe 12, Grab 203

Blum, Hans, Pvt. (Wartime Volunteer) [Kriegsfreiwilliger]
Died of wounds at Reserve-Lazarett Mariendorf, Berlin
Mr. and Mrs. Hermann and Johanna (Unger) Blum (parents), Ritterstrasze 4/5, Berlin, Germany
Born 3/21/97
Die Jüdischen Gefallenen Des Deutschen Heeres, Deutschen Marine Und Der Deutschen Schutztruppen 1914-1918 – Ein Gedenkbuch – Not Listed
Judischen Friedhof zu Weissensee, Berlzu, Germany

Blumenthal, Heinrich, Cpl. [Unteroffizier]
Infanterie Regiment 137, Ersatz Bataillon, Genesungheim Kompagnie
From Berlin, Germany
Born Dt. Krone, Germany, 7/27/96
Casualty Message (Verlustmeldung) 1293
Die Jüdischen Gefallenen Des Deutschen Heeres, Deutschen Marine Und Der Deutschen Schutztruppen 1914-1918 – Ein Gedenkbuch – 133
Place of burial unknown

Kaufmann, Benjamin-Jonas, Pvt. [Soldat]
Arm. Ersatz Bataillon VIII / 46, 3rd Kompagnie
From Frechem (b. Koln), Germany
Born French, Germany, 8/30/75
Casualty Message (Verlustmeldung) 1371
Die Jüdischen Gefallenen Des Deutschen Heeres, Deutschen Marine Und Der Deutschen Schutztruppen 1914-1918 – Ein Gedenkbuch – 217
Place of burial unknown

Ludwig, Siegfried, L/Cpl. [Gerfriter]
Infanterie Regiment 442, 3rd Battalion, 11th Kompagnie
From Muhlhausen (Els.), Elsass-Lothringen, Germany
Born Themar, Germany, 6/17/79
Casualty Message (Verlustmeldung) 1441
Die Jüdischen Gefallenen Des Deutschen Heeres, Deutschen Marine Und Der Deutschen Schutztruppen 1914-1918 – Ein Gedenkbuch – 390
Place of burial unknown

Magnuss, Albert, L/Cpl. [Gerfriter]
Fusilier Regiment 40, 3rd Bataillon, 9th Kompagnie
From Mannheim, Germany
Born Berlin, Germany, 3/28/86
Casualty Message (Verlustmeldung) 1332
Die Jüdischen Gefallenen Des Deutschen Heeres, Deutschen Marine Und Der Deutschen Schutztruppen 1914-1918 – Ein Gedenkbuch – 282
Place of burial unknown

Marburg, Robert, 2 Lt. [Leutnant], Fliegertruppen des deutschen Kaiserreiches, Aviator (Balloon Service) [Ballon-Service], Ballon Zug 1
At Capelle
From Frankfurt / Main, Germany
Born Frankfurt / Main, Germany, 6/10/81
Casualty Message (Verlustmeldung) 1310
Die Jüdischen Gefallenen Des Deutschen Heeres, Deutschen Marine Und Der Deutschen Schutztruppen 1914-1918 – Ein Gedenkbuch Nachtrag (Addendum) 2 – 427
Casualties of the German Air Service – pp. 97, 315
Place of burial unknown

Meyerheim, Fritz, L/Cpl. [Gerfriter], Fliegertruppen des deutschen Kaiserreiches, Aviator (Balloon Service) [Ballon-Service], Ballon Zug 50
DOW, Reserve-Lazarett Charlottenburg, Berlin
Mr. and Mrs. Bernhard and Betti (Davidsohn) Meyerheim (parents), Uhlandstrasze 194, Berlin, Germany
From Frankfurt a.O., Germany
Born Massow, Germany, 11/16/86
Casualty Message (Verlustmeldung) 1307
Die Jüdischen Gefallenen Des Deutschen Heeres, Deutschen Marine Und Der Deutschen Schutztruppen 1914-1918 – Ein Gedenkbuch – 217
Casualties of the German Air Service – pp. 102, 315
Judischen Friedhof zu Weissensee, Berlzu, Germany

Simon, Adolf, Sergent Major Lieutenant (Warrant Officer) [Feldwebel Leutnant]
Reserve Feldartillerie Regiment 68, 2nd Battalion, 6th Kompagnie
From Berlin, Germany
Born Striegau, Germany, 12/16/96
Casualty Message (Verlustmeldung) 1440
Die Jüdischen Gefallenen Des Deutschen Heeres, Deutschen Marine Und Der Deutschen Schutztruppen 1914-1918 – Ein Gedenkbuch Nachtrag (Addendum) 1 – 423
Place of burial unknown

Wollenberg, Adolf, Dr., 1 Lt. (Medical Staff Officer) [Oberstabsarzt], Festungs Hilflazarett V Konigsberg
From Konigsberg (Pr.), Germany
Born Riesenburg, Germany, 6/30/61
Casualty Message (Verlustmeldung) N.V.L. 117 / 31
Die Jüdischen Gefallenen Des Deutschen Heeres, Deutschen Marine Und Der Deutschen Schutztruppen 1914-1918 – Ein Gedenkbuch – 264
Place of burial unknown

________________________________________

In my next two posts, you’ll be able to read the Jewish Exponent’s version of The War Record of American Jews as it appeared in February of 1919, and, as it was incorporated within the two editions of WW I Medal of Honor winner Sydney Gumpertz’s privately published The Jewish Legion of Valor in the late 1930s and early 1940s.

Note: Regarding the military service of the Jews of England, Reverend Michael Adler’s the British Jewry Book of Honour (1922), while a monumental achievement and utterly central to the study of the military service of Jews of England and the British Commonwealth during the Great War, isn’t – for each and every name recorded within its pages – completely reliable.  An example?  In the section listing the names of Jews who served in the Royal Flying Corps / Royal Air Force, one finds on page 535 an entry for Captain Carl Frederick Falkenberg (mis-spelled as “Falkenburg”), a 17 victory “ace” in the Royal Flying Corps.  Like some biographical entries in The War Record of American Jews of 1919, this was in error.  More about this in the next two posts…

Readings, References, Writings and What-Not

Books

Adler, Michael, and Freeman, Max R.G., British Jewry Book of Honour, Caxton Publishing Company, London, England, 1922 (Republished in 2006 by Naval & Military Press, Uckfield, East Sussex)

Arad, Gulie Ne’eman, America, Its Jews, and The Rise of Nazism, Indiana University Press, Bloomington, In., 2000

Auerbach, Jerald S., Are We One? – Jewish Identity in the United States and Israel, Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, N.J., 2001

Bellow, Saul, Humboldt’s Gift, The Viking Press, New York, N.Y, 1973

Franks, Norman; Bailey, Frank; Duiven, Rick, Casualties of the German Air Service – 1914-1920, Grub Street, London, England, 1999

Liebman, Charles S., The Ambivalent American Jew – Politics, Religion, and Family in American Jewish Life, The Jewish Publication Society of America, Philadelphia, Pa., 1973

Michael, Robert, A Concise History of American Antisemitism, Rowan & Littlefield Publishers, Inc., Lanham, Md., 2005

Rubin, Barry, Assimilation and Its Discontents, Random House, New York, N.Y., 1997

Samuel, Maurice, The Gentleman and The Jew, Alfred A. Knopf, New York, N.Y., 1950

Die Jüdischen Gefallenen Des Deutschen Heeres, Deutschen Marine Und Der Deutschen Schutztruppen 1914-1918 – Ein Gedenkbuch, Reichsbund Jüdischer Frontsoldaten, Forward by Dr. Leo Löwenstein, Berlin, Germany, 1932

Les Israelites dans l’Armée Française (Israelites [Jews] in the French Army), Angers, 1921 – Avant-Propos de la Deuxième Épreuve [Forward to the Second Edition], Albert Manuel, Paris, Juillet, 1921 – (Réédité par le Cercle de Généalogie juive [Reissued by the Circle for Jewish Genealogy], Paris, 2000)

Le Livre d’or du Judaïsme Algérien (1914-1918) (The Gold Book of Algerian Jewry (1914-1918), 1919 – Pubication du Comiée Algérien d’Études Sociales 1er fascicule septembre 1919 ((Réédité par le Cercle de Généalogie juive [Reissued by the Circle for Jewish Genealogy], Paris, 2000) – Avec la collaboration de Georges Teboul et de Jean-Pierre Bernard.

The War Record of American Jews – First Report of The Office of War Records, American Jewish Committee, January 1, 1919, The American Jewish Committee, New York, N.Y., 1919

Podcast

Daniel Gordis, on the Rift Between American and Israeli Jews, Tikvah Fund podcast, April 3, 2019

Periodicals

Dick, Philip K., “We Can Remember It For You Wholesale”, The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, April, 1966 (The story was, quite flimsily, the basis for the 1990 film Total Recall, which featured Arnold Schwarzenegger in the lead role, as well as its 2012 Colin Farrell remake.)

Hertzberg, Arthur, The Emancipation: A Reassessment After Two Centuries, Modern Judaism, V 1, N 1, May, 1981

Other Publications

The Universal Jewish Encyclopedia, New York, N.Y., 1942

Websites

Guide to the Records of the American Jewish Committee – Office of Jewish War Records, undated, 1918-1921, 1962, processed by David Solomon, at Center for Jewish History

President Woodrow Wilson – Final Address in Support of the League of Nations, at American Rhetoric

Humboldt’s Gift, at GoodReads

German-Jewish Soldiers at War: An Unusual Account in The New York Times – August 22, 1915

Anonymity is an interesting thing.

Case in point?  The item below, published in The New York Times on the 22nd of August, 1915.  Ostensibly a news item about the military service of Jewish soldiers in the German, a cursory glance and closer reading reveal the “article” – for lack of a better word – to be curiously different from the typical article carried in the Times, let alone most any newspaper.

Though the “article” includes a title – “War Pictured by Jewish Soldiers” – and subtitle – “Some of the Many in the German and Austrian Armies Tell of Thrilling or Amusing Adventures” – the absence of a byline, date of composition or publication, and name of originating news agency (Associated Press or United Press International) suggests that this article may not have been an “article” at all.  Rather, given the item’s publication nearly two years before America’s declaration of war against Imperial Germany on April 6, 1917, perhaps – perhaps? – it was created by a branch of the German Government as a form of propaganda.  As such, the intent, through a variety of accounts covering the integration and military service of Jews in both the Western and Eastern war zones, may have been to present American readers with a mental image Germany as an enlightened and tolerant nation.  Thus, the article would have served as a counterweight to Allied propaganda.

In any event, there are some interesting facets to the article, which I’ve embedded within the text, in the form of “this” – Arial font, while the original text is in this” – Times New Roman font.

By the way, the article was discovered purely by chance, while reviewing the Times on 35mm microfilm. 

(Remember microfilm?)

________________________________________

WAR PICTURED BY JEWISH SOLDIERS
Some of the Many in the German and Austrian Armies Tell of Thrilling or Amusing Adventures

The New York Times
August 22, 1915

In the huge armies arrayed by Germany and Austria-Hungary against their foes Jews are well represented both among officers and soldiers, and many of them are listed among the winners of the coveted Iron Cross and other rewards for bravery in the field.  A collection of letters written by German and Austrian Jews at the front, which has just appeared in Berlin, paints the life of these men in thrilling and vivid fashion.  The letter writers tell relatives and friends at home of tragic moments of battle, of amusing experiences during hours of relaxation, of religious services held while shells screamed through the air, of cheery evening spent with coreligionists in France or Poland who forget for the time being that their guests were invaders of their native soil.  Throughout the book there are countless little touches, bits of reflective phrase, that bring clearly before the reader how war reacts on the minds of those waging it.

________________________________________

I’ve not yet identified this collection of letters (several such books were published after the war, but the date of publication would, by definition, have been in 1915.

________________________________________

One of the most interesting letters of all is from Private Werner of the 104th Infantry, describing the death of his brother Walter in a fight in Belgium.  He writes:

In the morning we were taken over the Meuse and lay in reserve until darkness fell.  About eight in the evening we received the order to advance.  Under fearful artillery fire my company advanced toward the village, already entirely in flames (for our artillery had done some preliminary work).  The village shone blood-red against the horizon.

While we lay in the corner of some bushes for a moment, Walter and I happened to find ourselves kneeling side by side by the flag.  Both of us had the same thought.  We caught hold of the flag with one hand, clasped our other hands, and in silence swore once again to be faithful to the flag and to ourselves.

“Forward!”  We advanced at full speed.  Rifle bullets whistled about us, shrapnel shrieked and burst in the air.  We kept beside each other, shouting encouraging words, each thinking of the other, seeking not to lose him in the storm of battle.  ***

When we had about reached the village the enemy had already withdrawn and begun an attack from the flank.  Now came the order: “Left, march!”  We were under the best of cover, but now we had to plunge into the worst hell of bullets.  Many a man hesitated, but when we saw our officers rush on, Walter and I jumped up and ran forward.

We charged for five minutes with fixed bayonets.  I heard Walter call to me.  While I was answering, a bullet struck my forearm.  It was only a glancing wound, but a second shot struck my upper arm and threw me to the ground.

Next afternoon the company officers sent me Walter’s pocket-book and diary, with the news that my good brother had just been buried.  After the battle he had set out to find me and had been shot dead.  Death has robbed me of my best comrade. ***

________________________________________

The brothers referred to were the Heidenheims.  Werner survived the war, while his fallen brother was Unteroffizier Walter.  From Chemnitz, Walter Heidenheim was born on May 31, 1889, and was a member of 3rd Company, 2nd Battalion, 104th Infantry Regiment.  Killed in action on August 23, 1914, he is buried at the Kriegsgräberstätte in Vladslo (Belgium), in Block 7, Grave 2293.

________________________________________

A very different picture if painted by another soldier, who describes how the town of Kolomea, in South Galicia, turned out to welcome the Austrian troops passing through on their way to fight the Russians.  He says:

You should have seen how the Jewish families, who constitute the majority of the population here, had put all their eatables and drinkables on long tables right in the middle of the street in order to regale the soldiers marching through.  Everywhere stood women and children in their Sunday best, cutting pieces of cake and bread, while the men brought barrels and jugs full of water from the houses. 

It was a strange sight to see a group of elderly Jews, in their silken caftans, sleeves rolled up, standing around a barrel, one of them hacking ice into small bits, others cutting sugar.  An old and worthy Jew with a white beard was in the meantime stirring the refreshing lemonade with a long spoon.  It was easy to see that all these people, of the better business element every one of them, would have given everything they owned most willingly to relieve the tired soldiers.

From a side alley an old Jewish woman appeared with a dish full of roasted apples; she, too, wished to give her share.  At one table there was an especially gay time.  Young Jewish girls stood by it in their best street garments, making small packages, each containing two pieces of bread (such gigantic war chunks!) spread with butter, two pickles, a piece of cake, and ten cigarettes.  I saw one heap of about _____ of these packages, and still they were making more and bringing more supplies.

“Walter C. of Cologne” tells in a letter to his parents how he won the Iron Cross in Northern France.  After describing days of desperate fighting, on one of which he lay for an hour under a dead horse, unable to extricate himself, he writes:

In the evening it was learned that one-fourth of our company was missing.  I believed there could be nothing worse than that day, but there was worse ahead.

We pursued the enemy, who had received strong reinforcements.  Then began a tremendous struggle that lasted seven days – 40,000 French against 30,000 Germans. 

The worst was on the 7th of the month (September, 1914).  All day we had lain under frightful shell fire, perfectly helpless because our artillery could not get the range of the enemy.  At 7 in the evening my Captain got orders to send a patrol to the top of a hill, which was literally covered all over with bursting shells, from where the enemy’s position could be described. 

“Eight volunteers step forward!”

I stepped forward.  Nobody else did.  The Captain clasped my hand.

I crawl back to our artillery, which im- _____ succeeded in getting to the top of the hill, but there I was discovered and subjected to fire that absolutely beggars description.

A fragment of a shell about as bit as a fist smashed my helmet; a piece of shrapnel tore my knapsack to pieces; another the cartridge box on my left side.  In the meantime I quietly observed the enemy’s position through my field glass and noted it on a map. 

I crawl back to our artillery which immediately turns its fire in that direction.  Exactly seven minutes later the French guns are silenced.  Once more I crawl back up the hill.  Every French gun has been overturned.  The gunners are dead. 

A French battalion comes along to save the pieces.  After a prearranged signal (white light-bullets, which I fire into the air) our artillery gives them a round.  More than half the battalion fall dead or wounded, the other runs off in a panic, and for that day there are no more Frenchmen to be seen. 

Next morning 200 dead and wounded are found, 82 torn by shells.  I receive the Iron Cross.

________________________________________

Jewish soldiers in the German army who lost their lives on September 7, 1914, include…

– .ת. נ. צ. ב. ה
תהא

נפשו
צרורה
בצרור
החיים

Adler, Friedrich Jean, Soldat
Cussel, Hans, Soldat
Dannenbaum, Sally, Gerfreiter
Freudenthal, Otto, Soldat
Goldstein, Georg, Unteroffizier
Hermann, Georg, Soldat
Herzberg, Max, Gerfreiter
Jacobsohn, Heinrich, Unteroffizier
Josephthal, Anton, Unteroffizier
Kohn, Justin, Gerfreiter
Loeb, Siegfried, Soldat
Lowenstein, Max, Gerfreiter
Lustig, Fritz, Unteroffizier
Mayer, Leopold, Soldat
Meinstein, Siegfried, Soldat
Metzger, Wilhelm, Soldat
Neugass, Willy,Gerfreiter
Oppenheimer, Heli, Soldat
Rosenberger, Felix, Dr., Soldat
Rosenthal, Isaak, Soldat
Rosenthal, Leopold, Soldat
Schreiner, Nathan, Soldat
Simon, Julius, Unteroffizier
Tobias, Julius, Soldat
Weil, Leo, Soldat
Weil, Salomon, Soldat
Winter, Josef, Soldat
Wolf, Marcel, Soldat

…however, though the 1932 book Die Jüdischen Gefallenen Des Deutschen Heeres, Deutschen Marine Und Der Deutschen Schutztruppen 1914-1918 – Ein Gedenkbuch (from which these name were extracted) lists the military units to which these soldiers were assigned, the specific geographic locations where the casualties occurred are not given.  Thus, I don’t know if any of these men, all members of infantry regiments, were actually assigned to “Walter C’s” company, and were thus among the casualties referred to in his letter.

________________________________________

An interesting human touch is that in a letter written home from near Rheims by another winner of the Iron Cross.  “Enclosed I send you the Iron Cross,” he says – and then, on the same line: “No, I have decided otherwise.  I will wear it.”

Another, a non-commissioned officer of artillery, begs his “dear old folks” at home to send him frequently “little packages of chocolate, bonbons, sausage, and other edibles.”

“You have no idea how much we need such things,” he adds.

“I was so glad to get your letter that I lighted a candle under my tent in order to read it, though this is strictly forbidden,” writes Lieutenant Alfred Kraus of the Austrian Army to a friend.  “We know what hay or straw looks like only from hearsay,” he adds further along in the same latter, “and, as for the mud, we have to wade through it knee-high.”

The writer bewails the hard fate that sent him to be mired in Serbia as one of the guardians of the Austrian lines of communication instead of letting him take part in real battles against the Russians.  But from a note attached to the letter – one of the most light-hearted of the lot – we learn that the Lieutenant not only got his wish to see a real fight but was killed in Bosnia.

“It was my sad duty to lay him in his grave,” says the writer of the note.

Another soldier tells of attending a religious service “in the midst of thundering cannon and pouring rain.  Yet I think we were all as devout as if we had been at home,” he remarks.  Another, also describing his devotions in the field, tells how all present thought of their homes until the tears came to their eyes.

“No, no, we must not have such thoughts!” he goes on.  “We must stay strong.  We grit out teeth together.”  And then:

The services are over.  Before the church, laughing sunshine welcomes us.  Once more we are soldiers, laughing like the sunlight, chattering, telling each other stories.  Four Jews with Iron Crosses among us.  They tell of many Jewish comrades who also have it, but could not come to the services.

Whew, how the shells whistle!

One letter is from the son of the widow Levi, in the district of Cassel, in Germany, whose six sons are fighting.  When she lent it and another to the compiler of this book of soldiers’ letters she wrote:  “Herewith are two letters from my son, but for God’s sake return them to me, as I am a very poor widow and the letters of my sons are my only fortune.”  Writing from Russian Poland, one of the six tried to cheer up his “dear, good little mother” thus:

Judging from all your letters, you cannot get over the fact that you have six sons in the field.  To be sure, it is no trifle for a woman of 70 to see all her sons, her only hope, her only support, in the field.  But, dear, good mother, do not let your heart get too heavy in this manner.  Remember how often God has stood by you in the direst days – do you think He would abandon you now?  No; I don’t believe he would.

Think of your joy when we all come back victorious; think of all the things we’ll have to tell you!  Why, we could write whole books about our adventures!  It must be a joy and honor to you that we are all fighting for the fatherland.

One moonlight night Martin Feist of Frankfurt, private in an infantry regiment, leaning against the front of his trench in France, let his thoughts travel to his relatives and friends, especially to one comrade killed a short time before by a French bullet.  In a letter he sets down these nocturnal meditations in the following poignant lines:

I got thinking of all my friends and relatives, and above all of him, the faithful one, with the warm heart and the glowing ideals.  His aim was to fight ever higher toward truth, beauty, and goodness.

He was fated not to reach his goal; far from his home the bullet of the foe struck him down and brought him to an untimely end.  Nothing of him remains to me but the memory of the happy and troubled days of our youth which we spent together.  God’s ways are inscrutable.

Thus ran my thoughts for hours.  They stopped when I thought of the awful sights on which my eyes have gazed.  You stay-at-homes, you cannot be too grateful for the good fortune that has spared you from the horrors of war.  Oh, you rich people, if you but knew what they are, you would open with your hands and hearts to relieve suffering and misery, you would show yourselves great as men, greater in your duties as Jews.  You would understand that it is doubly right in these times to spend and give.  Sources of revenue, to be sure, are cut off this year; perhaps you have suffered losses – yet God gave you so many years of prosperity!

On my thoughts ran:  May these times tend to cleanse us in Frankfurt; may we learn to understand that heretofore we have thought too much of who was rich, who poor.

Away with the worship of wealth!  Let us thrust that idol from our hearts, and our Frankfurt will see that there is something higher than riches.  It is this: To be human!

Then came the rattle of rifle fire, the thunder of cannon.  The thoughtful man from Frankfurt was compelled to do his share in warding off the enemy.

________________________________________

Coincidentally or not, my prior blog posts, “God’s Decree is Unsearchable: One of 12,000 – Thoughts of A German Jewish Soldier in the Great War”, Part I and Part II, present Martin Feist’s letter in the original German, and my own (with a little help from Google Translate) English-language translation of the two letters.  Given that Martin tragically was killed in action on January 7, 1915, it’s notable (and presumably intentional) that this article makes no reference to his death in combat. 

________________________________________

Another writer tells how, in a French village, he and his comrades were ordered suddenly to round up all the inhabitants who had not fled and imprison them until further orders in the village schoolhouse.  Some indignantly protested, and it took all the young soldier’s slender stock of French – he alone among the Germans knew a bit of that language – to persuade them that resistance was useless.  Finally all were cooped up in the schoolhouse and then began a torrent of requests from the indignant prisoners.  The soldier writes:

They had a thousand desires, and every time that one or another of the villagers left the schoolhouse, the sentinel had to report it, so that I might ask each what he wanted.

This one wished to feed his cattle; another to milk her cows in order to have milk for her little children; some required more bedding, others had forgotten plates, knives, forks, etc.  And each time one was allowed to go to his home one of the guards had to go along with a fixed bayonet.

Things were not easy for the interpreter.  He managed to find out what most of the villagers wanted, but when the members of one family excitedly informed him that they had a rabbit stew cooking at their home and wanted to go back to ear it before it was burned he was helpless.

They repeated it over and over again.  Finally he understood.  Off went the family to their rabbit stew – accompanied by a German soldier with fixed bayonet.

“You sleep at night fully clothed, boots on, and electric lamp clasped at your breast, your revolver by your side,” writes a soldier from somewhere in Russia, adding, “but I soon got accustomed to it.”

________________________________________

The following passage describes the interaction of a Jewish soldier with a Jewish family in Olkusz, a city in southern Poland.  You can view contemporary images pertaining to the history of the Jews of Olkusz – alas, primarily of the city’s Jewish cemetery – at Virtual Shtetl, and, learn about the fate of the city’s Jews during the Shoah at the the Zchor memorial web page, “We Remember Jewish Olkusz!

Notably – I wasn’t aware of this until creating this post – a quarter-century later, Olkusz was the setting of a well-known photographic image from the Shoah: That of Rabbi and dayan (religious judge) Mosze Ben Icchak Hagerman being tormented by German soldiers in the town’s market on June or July 31, 1940.  You can view the image and a related photo (via Yad Vashem, reproduced below) at the blog of Marie-Pierre and Didier Long, under the title “Le Kiddoush Ashem dans l’histoire” (“Kiddush Hashem in History”)

The text accompanying the photographs states:

Rabbin Moshe Hagerman, ZAL, le Rabbi et dayan (juge rabbinique) de Olkusz en Pologne.  Il a été amené le 31 juin 1940 sur la place centrale de la ville pour y être exécuté.  Avant d’être tué, il a demandé qu’on le laisse réciter le Kadish pour ses frères assassinés.  Les soldats allemands ont ri en le laissant faire et l’ont tué.  Des 4097 juifs d’Olkuz listés par les nazis on pense que 250 ont survécu.

Translation?

Rabbi Moshe Hagerman, Z”L, Rabbi and dayan (rabbinical judge) of Olkusz in Poland.  He was brought on June 31, 1940 to the central square of the city to be executed.  Before he was killed, he asked to be allowed to recite the Kadish for his murdered brothers.  The German soldiers laughed at him and let him do it.  Of the 4,097 Jews in Olkuz listed by the Nazis, 250 are believed to have survived.

_______________________________________

Another, also in Russia, writes amusedly of what occurred after he stopped a wagon driven by a Russian peasant and bought two geese:

The news ran like wildfire along our column.  “A. has cabbaged two geese!”  In a few minutes I heard my First Lieutenant riding up at a gallop.  Thirty yards away he called out: “Where are the birds?”  I held them up before him by the feet, and he joyfully asked to be the third in our party.  I and our “Wachtmeister,” [a non-commissioned officer] were the other two.

At the next stop we found a Jew and had the geese killed according to ritual.  When we marched into Olkusz, our destination, quarters were prepared for me by order of the First Lieutenant, and I was commissioned to look after roasting the geese.

Soon I found a good Jewish family, who were pleased to find that I also was a Jew; and when I said that seven others would also be there, we at once formed a friendly alliance.

But, my God, what a kitchen it was! – parlor, living room, bedroom, tailor shop, kitchen, all in one.  One other room with a bed was rented.  I soon cleaned up things on the hearth, which was no easy matter, as the family consisted of fourteen persons; the youngest was five months old, and so upward to 21 years old.  The wife had the reputation of being an excellent cook.

Dinner was set for nine.  We got together punctually – eight non-commissioned officers, five privates, and the First Lieutenant.  The rented room was cleared out and table put in it, grandly decorated.

Our First Lieutenant was quite flabbergasted when he saw me getting up all this splendor and went from one fit of astonishment to another.  He could find no words to express himself; simply muttered, “Ah!  Ah!” and wagged his head.  He contributed thirty bottles of beer to the festivities; the “Wachtmeister” ten.

Everything went beautifully and we were all in the best of spirits.  The side dishes were salted potatoes, covered with hot goose-fat and some pickles.

In short, it was a good peace dinner in the midst of the most violent warfare in the enemy’s country, for, almost three miles from our dining place, a patrol of Cossacks had been beaten off only the day before.

“Yesterday my acetylene lamp went out, so I am finishing this letter today,” writes another soldier from “Skodnicki Dune near Lodz.”  Another observes: “Having no pen or ink, I had to write my letter with a pencil, for which please pardon me.  Moreover, I have no table, but must use the ground for one.”

Hugo Henle, non-commissioned officer in a Landwehr Regiment, observes: “I have repeatedly found that one must not underestimate the Russians, especially when it comes to digging themselves in.”

Turning again to the Western Front, we have this exciting narrative of a soldier’s adventures at Souain in France:

________________________________________

I don’t know if “exciting” is the proper word for the awful events described below.  A variety of other adjectives would have vastly greater relevancy, but, well, I’m presenting the article verbatim.

________________________________________

God be thanked, I am still alive and uninjured,while many, many of our men, especially those who were near me during yesterday’s attack, are dead or wounded. ***

The tale is really too awful to tell; how I alone escaped alive and unhurt is incomprehensible to me.

It was 10 o’clock in the morning and the company was being paid.  I had as usual taken the money which the men send home, when suddenly the French attacked us amid terrific artillery and rifle fire.

I darted back along the trench to my post, snatched my rifle and put my other rifle in its place.  We could not stay long where we were crouching, but edged away more to the left, where there was better cover.  Ten minutes later we had to move toward the right again to where we had been before in order to shoot at the French, who were advancing.

At the same moment a hail of shells and shrapnel burst upon us.  I was hurled to the ground by the air pressure and buried by the earth falling upon me until only my head remained above.  I was in this awful position for an hour while shells burst roundabout me, wounding several men.  I yelled to soldiers, who camp up and tried to dig me out, to get away and think of their own safety. 

When they finally dug me out I felt and touched myself all over; no damage.  The only sufferers were my spectacles, which I was carrying in my pocket; one of the glasses was broken.

But what a spectacle there was around me!  I shall never forget it!  Everywhere they are saying that this day was the most terrible of all experienced by the regiment since the war began.

References

Die Jüdischen Gefallenen Des Deutschen Heeres, Deutschen Marine Und Der Deutschen Schutztruppen 1914-1918 – Ein Gedenkbuch, Reichsbund Jüdischer Frontsoldaten, Forward by Dr. Leo Löwenstein, Berlin, Germany, 1932

Zchor memorial page for the Jews of Olkusz, at “We Remember Jewish Olkusz!

Marie-Pierre and Didier Long’s blog, at didierlong.com

Soldiers from New York: Jewish Soldiers in The New York Times, in World War Two: 2 Lt. George Greenfield – January 9, 1945 [Updated post…]

Originally created on April 3, 2018, this post includes information about several casualties in the Army Air Force on January 9, 1945, among whom was Second Lieutenant Murray Karron, flight engineer on the B-29 “Wugged Wascal”.  I’ve now updated the post to include two images of the “Wascal”, one from Steve Birdsall’s 1981 book Saga of the Superfortress, and another from Prentice Burkett’s The Unofficial History of the 499th Bomb Group (VH).  These are the only images I’ve thus far found of this B-29 (42-24658).  Scroll down…

________________________________________

By its very nature, military activity – even when limited to action such as instruction and training; even when geographically distant from engagement with enemy forces in actual combat – has always entailed a solid element of risk and danger.  One example of this appeared in The New York Times on February 15, 1945, through the publication of an obituary for Second Lieutenant George Greenfield (0-2070016), an Army Air Force navigator from the Bronx. 

Killed in Bomber Crash Last Jan. 9 in England

Lieut. George Greenfield, navigator on a B-24, was killed when his bomber crashed in England on Jan. 9, the War Department has notified his family here.  Lieutenant Greenfield was 22 years old.

Born in this city, he was graduated from Stuyvesant High School in 1941 and then attended the University of Indiana for two years, majoring in languages.  He enlisted two years ago and was qualified as a pilot in the Air Corps, but later was transferred and graduated as a navigator at Selman Field, La.  He went overseas at the end of November.

His parents, Mr. and Mrs. Philip Greenfield of 1180 Anderson Avenue, the Bronx; a twin sister, Jeanette; and two other sisters, Mrs. Paul Bergman and Margaret Greenfield, survive.

This Google Street view image shows a contemporary (2014) view of 1180 Anderson Ave.

Though there’s no Missing Air Crew Report for Lt. Greenfield and his crew (his MACR index card carries the simple notation “No MACR”), his record at the American Battle Monuments Commission provides the “clue” by which the incident of January 9, 1945, can be identified: He was a member of the 706th Bomb Squadron of the 446th Bomb Group, with the Aviation Archeology database revealing that a B-24H Liberator of that squadron (42-95306, “RT * S”, nicknamed “Dragon Lady” and piloted by 2 Lt. Andrew J. Puschock, Jr.) was lost in an accident at Whittlesford, England on that date. 

Though the records of the 706th Bomb Squadron, and, any Accident Report filed after the incident would certainly list the plane’s crew, only limited information is currently available about the other casualties in this incident.  Aside from Lt. Puschock, who is buried at Arlington National Cemetery, another fatality is known to have been 2 Lt. Robert Wallace Allen, presumably the bomber’s co-pilot, who is buried at the Cambridge American Cemetery, in Cambridge, England (Plot B, Row 5, Grave 54). 

Lieutenant Greenfield’s name appeared in the “In Memoriam” section of The New York Times on December 1, 1945.  Born on December 1, 1922, his name appears on page 335 of American Jews in World War II.  His sole award is the Purple Heart, suggesting that the Puschock crew – perhaps a newly arrived crew, as implied by his November arrival in England – may have flown fewer than five combat missions prior to the accident on January 9.  He is buried in the Cambridge American Cemetery, near Lt. Allen, at Plot B, Row 6, Grave 54. His matzeva, photographed by Skip Farrow, is show below:

Another aspect of this news item is more subtle, almost “hiding in plain sight”:  The single-bladed propeller on Lt. Greenfield’s cap was the emblem of World War Two Army Air Force aviation cadets, suggesting that his portrait (a very good portrait) was an image in his family’s possession which was donated to the Times

Some other Jewish military casualties on Tuesday, January 9, 1945, include…

Killed in Action
– .ת.נ.צ.ב.ה. –

Boyaner, Frank, Major
Canadian Dental Corps
Mrs. Hazel Olive Boyaner (wife)
Mr. and Mrs. Don and Kaylia Boyaner (parents)
Born Saint John’s, New Brunswick, Canada, 3/23/25
Brookwood Military Cemetery, Surrey, England – 56,D,9
Canadian Jews in World War II – Part II: Casualties – 12

Carp, Paul Iban, Lt. JG, 0-184815, Purple Heart
United States Navy
Possibly lost while serving as a member of a liaison team aboard a French escort vessel
Mr. Joseph Shepard Carp (father), 2738 SW 20th St., Miami, Fl.
Miss Clare Schwartz and Mrs. Ruth C. Rosow (sisters)
Graduate of Harvard University
Tablets of the Missing at North African American Cemetery, Carthage, Tunisia
WW II Memorial Honoree Record by Ruth C. Rosow (sister)
Jewish Floridian 3/2/45
American Jews in World War II – 82

______________________________

Cohen, Clarence, Cpl., 36895289, Gunner (Central Fire Control), Air Medal, Purple Heart, 2 missions
United States Army Air Force, 20th Air Force, 500th Bomb Group, 883rd Bomb Squadron
Mrs. Bettie (Nettie?) Romanoff (sister), 7454 Wykes St., Detroit, Mi.
Also 693 Alabama Ave., Brooklyn, 7, N.Y.
MACR 10903; Aircraft: B-29 42-24657 (“Mustn’t Touch”; “Z square 45”), Pilot: Capt. John J. Charters; 11 crewmen
Aircraft presumably ditched; no survivors

Corporal Cohen’s Superfortress, Mustn’t Touch, was lost during a mission to the Musashino Aircraft Works and Nakajima Aircraft Engine Factory near Tokyo.  There is little (and will forever be little) definitive information about the plane’s loss, seemingly attributable to mechanical problems with the plane’s engines necessitating ditching in the Pacific Ocean roughly half-way between Saipan and Japan.  As summarized in Missing Air Crew Report 10903:

Shortly after take-off, his aircraft developed mechanical problems.  During climb-out the #1 engine was leaking oil, and puffs of black smoke were coming from the #4 engine.  At 16,000 feet his aircraft feathered the #1 engine propeller and began to abort the sortie.  Last visual contact was at a geographic location of 28 degrees 10 minutes north and 137 degrees 30 minutes east, at 0315Z.  Last radio contact, at 0410Z, stated they had lost an engine and were going to ditch in the ocean, approximately 900 nautical miles north of Saipan.  No survivors were ever found, and he was declared killed in action one year later. 


Corporal Cohen and his fellow crewmen are memorialized on the Tablets of the Missing at the Honolulu Memorial, in Honolulu.  His name appears on page 290 of American Jews in World War II

This below image of the nose art of Mustn’t Touch is from Tom McNamara’s flickr photostream, while the second image – Army Air Force photograph 64276AC / A39219 – taken on Saipan in November, 1944, shows the aircraft before the application of nose art.  (The soldiers in the foreground, from an engineer battalion, are drilling holes for dynamite charges during construction of an airstrip at Isley Field.)  Of technical interest, the image clearly shows the tail cannon characteristic of early B-29s, which weapon would eventually be deleted from the Superfortress due to its slow rate of fire, and, the difference between the trajectories of its 20mm shells, and, those of the twin tail-mounted co-axial 50 caliber Browning machine guns. 

______________________________

Cohen, Louis, PFC, 39558749
United States Army Air Force, 77th Air Service Group, Headquarters Squadron
Died (non-battle) on Tinian Island
Mrs. Betty G. Cohen (wife), 1318 S. Cochran Ave., Los Angeles, Ca.
Born 1911
No number on MACR index name card
National Memorial Cemetery of the Pacific, Honolulu, Hawaii – Section Q, Grave 662
American Jews in World War II – 41

Frenkel, Boris Mikhailovich (Френкель, Борис Михаилович) Senior Sergeant [Старший Сержант]
U.S.S.R., Red Army, 63rd Cavalry Division
Radio Operator in Valentine Mk IX tank
Born 1925
Probably buried at Zámoly Village, Fejér County, Hungary
Memorial Book of Jewish Soldiers Who Died in Battles Against Nazism – 1941-1945 – Volume IX – 307 [Книги Памяти еврееввоинов, павших в боях с нацизхмом в 1941-1945 гг – Том IX – 307]

______________________________

Hertz, Joseph, Cpl., 32794422, Tail Gunner, Air Medal, Purple Heart
United States Army Air Force, 5th Air Force, 345th (“Air Apaches”) Bomb Group, 500th Bomb Squadron
Mr. and Mrs. Haney and Selma L. Hertz (parents), Arnold (brother), 120 Hopkins St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Born Austria, 1920
MACR 16290; Aircraft: B-25J 43-36187 (“Man of War”, or, “Man-O-War”); Pilot: 2 Lt. James O. Buffington, and five crew members

Man-O-War
was struck by anti-aircraft fire during bombing and strafing mission over Luzon, crash-landing south of the city of Angeles.

Cpl. Hertz, Lt. Buffington (Peru, Indiana), and, Bombardier / Navigator 2 Lt. Vernon C. Buchanan (Indianapolis) were killed in the immediate crash of the aircraft, while three crew members survived the loss of the plane.  The latter were Co-pilot Capt. Richard T. Thompson (Delta, Michigan), Flight Engineer Cpl. Bernard R. Dunnavant (Victoria, Virginia), and Radio Operator T/Sgt. Walter J. Nelson (Union City, N.J.)

Thompson and Dunnavant, both very seriously injured and unable to move, remained at the site of the wrecked plane.  T/Sgt. Nelson, less seriously hurt, aided them to the best of his ability, and then attempted to reach Filipino civilians for further help. 

During his absence, Japanese troops arrived at the scene of the wreck and murdered his surviving comrades.

Concealed by Filipino civilians from discovery by the Japanese – in the village of Delores Mabalacat – Sgt. Nelson was turned over to a band of Filipino guerillas, and, eventually joined by Sgt. Nolan W. Huddleston of the 387th Bomb Squadron, 312th Bomb Group, returned to American forces by January 23. 

The five casualties from Man-O-War are are listed as having been awarded the Air Medal and Purple Heart, with Lt. Buffington having received two Oak Leaf Clusters, suggesting that they had flown between five and ten combat missions prior to January 9.  They are listed on the Tablets of the Missing at the Manila American at Fort Bonifacio, Manila.   

FindAGrave includes a record for WW II Army Air Force veteran “Walter John Nelson”, who died in 2013 and is buried at the Brigadier General William C. Doyle Veterans Memorial Cemetery in Wrightstown, New Jersey.  This biographical record seems (?) to “fit” information about T/Sgt. Nelson of Man-O-War, with the exception that the record is for a Corporal – and not T/Sgt. – Nelson.

The 500th Bomb Squadron Mission Report for the 9 January mission (extracted from the 500th Bomb Squadron’s Mission Reports encompassing August 1944 through August 1945, at the 345th Bomb Group) is shown below, with sections pertaining to the loss of Man-O-War outlined in red.  This is followed by a series of Google Maps showing – at successively larger scales – the probable area (as denoted by the red oval) where Man-O-War crash-landed.  This location was identified through information in Lawrence Hickey’s Warpath Across the Pacific, MACR 16290, and a map of Clark Field and Vicinity, at Pacific Wrecks

Mission Objective; Mission Description.

______________________________

Details of the Mission: “Lt. Buffington executed an unexplained 180 turn from South to North and has not been heard of since.” 

But, as recounted in Warpath Across the Pacific

“Eight miles below Tarlac, 2 Lt. James O. Buffington pulled his plane from a loose formation and doubled back to hit a pair of trucks bypassed on the adjacent highway.  Minutes later, hastening to catch up with his flight, Buffington and his co-pilot, Capt. Richard T. Thompson, saw two trucks sitting on the tracks just north of Dau Junction.  Their initial attack was made from fifty feet and left three box cars blazing.  But as they pulled off their run, a flak battery found thee range.

T/Sgt. Walter J. Nelson was in the radio compartment when the plane jerked suddenly.  Glancing forward, he saw a fire blazing in the cockpit.  “This is it.  We’re going down!” his mind screamed at him.  Only seconds separated Nelson from possible death and he used them well.  He released the emergency escape hatch, then braced himself against the transmitter, using a parachute for a head cushion.  The plane jarred violently as the belly furrowed a rice paddy.  A low earthen mound ripped off a wing and spun the plane into a tight loop, pitching Nelson through the open hatch.

When he awoke, the radio operator found himself on the ground next to the burning aircraft.  Near the right nacelle lay Cpl. Bernard Dunnavant, the turret gunner, with one leg almost severed.  Five hundred yards away sat two camouflaged bombers bearing the blood-red Japanese hinomaru on their fuselages.  The ill-fated crew had come to grief on the very edge of Angeles South, one of the satellite airfields in the Clark Field complex.”

______________________________

The crew of Man-O-War.

______________________________

Luzon.

______________________________

Luzon, with Angeles and Mabalacat in the center of the map.

______________________________

The possible – general – crash location of Man-O-War: South of Angeles.

______________________________

A closer view of the possible crash site: An area bounded by the Angeles-Porac-Floridablanca-Dinaluphin Road (to the west), the Pasig-Potrero River (to the south), and MacArthur Highway / Manila North Road (to the east).

______________________________

Ioffe, Abel Abramovich [Иоффе, Абель Абрамович] (at Priekule, Latvia)
16th Lithuanian Rifle Division, 156th Rifle Brigade

Mr. Avraham Yofe (father)
Born 1922
Probably buried at Kuldiga County, Latvia
Road to Victory – 281 (Name given as Yofe, Abel, Sgt.)

______________________________

Karron, Murray, 2 Lt., 0-868393, Flight Engineer, Air Medal, Purple Heart
United States Army Air Force, 20th Air Force, 499th Bomb Group, 877th Bomb Squadron
Mrs. Alyse (Cohen) Karron (wife), 1163 East 27th St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Mr. and Mrs. Louis and Tillie [11/10/53] Karron (parents); Evelyn and Jack (siblings)
MACR: 10911; Aircraft: B-29 42-24658 (“Wugged Wascal”; “V square 3”) Pilot: Capt. Kimmel Parker Murphy; 11 crewmen
Aircraft presumably ditched; no survivors
Brooklyn Eagle 1/16/42
American Jews in World War II – 357
New York Times Obituary “In Memoriam” Section – 11/12/53

Old Newspapers

I’ve not been able to find a photograph of Murray Karron, but this is an image (not the best, but still it’s an image) of Murray’s fiancee and future wife, Alyce (Alyse?) Cohen, as published in the Brooklyn Eagle on January 16, 1942.

________________________________________

The loss of Lt. Karron’s crew in Wugged Wascal, piloted by Captain Kimmel Murphy, parallels that of Corporal Cohen’s:  Target: Musashino Aircraft Works and Nakajima Aircraft Engine Factory.  Reason for loss: “Operational difficulties”.  Action: Ditching.  Result: No survivors. 

Oddly, the Missing Air Crew Report for Captain Murphy’s plane – lost after successfully completing its bombing-run – contains no statement specifically describing what actually befell the aircraft.  Instead, information about the missing bomber is found in a document dated January 10, 1946 within MACR 10907, which covers the losses of six B-29s (recorded in MACRs 10903, 10904, 10907 itself, 10908, 10911, and 11220) from the mission of January 9, 1945. 

The statement covering 42-24658 is as brief as it is enigmatic, simply stating:

The plane was last contacted by radio at 0908Z by Sergeant Irving R. Wirth, at 25-30 N, 146-30E.  The report states that the aircraft is believed to have been ditched in the ocean as a result of operational difficulties [nature unspecified]. 

The coordinates 25-30 N – 146-30 E mark a location about 250 miles east of Iwo Jima, Volcano Isles. 

Another statement notes the search for the missing crew:

Search started 1000 K 10 Jan 1945, to be continued until darkness or limited endurance of aircraft.  Search will continue on subsequent days for as long as the 73rd Bomb Wing permits.

Like Corporal Cohen, Lt. Karron and his fellow crewmen are memorialized on the Tablets of the Missing at the Honolulu Memorial, in Honolulu.  As for 2 Lt. Jack M. Danowitz (mentioned in the blog post covering 1 Lt. Arthur S. Goldstein), Major David I. Cedarbaum preserved a record (recorded by W.D. Bray) about Lt. Karron’s last flight – actually, far more informative than the MACR, albeit with the plane’s final location being incorrect – to which nothing further could ever be added:

The Airplane Commander was K.P. Murphy.  They flew to the Jap homeland, dropped their bombs, and an hour away began to have engine trouble.  They radioed the fire spread and they had to ditch, the plane being out of control.  They were about 100 miles north of Iwo presumably when they hit the water.  No rescue facility was ever able to locate anything of them.

________________________________________ 

From The Unofficial History of the 499th Bomb Group (VH), this picture shows the crew of Prentice Burkett standing before “Wugged Wascal”.  Unfortunately, like all crew photos in the book, the men’s names are not given, but the five men standing at rear are likely Burkett and the crew’s other officers, while the six men in front are presumably NCOs.

________________________________________ 

Printed as a full-page image on page 138 of Steve Birdsall’s Saga of the Superfortress, this photograph, from the collection of Lawrence F. Reineke, is captioned, “The 499th Group’s Wugged Wascal near Fuji on January 9, with Captain Kimmel Murphy and his crew.  A few hours after this photo was taken she crashed into the sea, less than seven hundred miles from Saipan.”  This image also appears (in smaller size) in The Unofficial History of the 499th Bomb Group (VH).

______________________________

This is a very-high-resolution (600 dpi) scan of the “Wascal”, as seen in the above image.  Even at this magnification the clarity of the image is remarkable, with structural details and the last four digits of the B-29’s serial clearly visible.  More important, of course, are the eleven men inside the plane..   

______________________________

Katz, Wolf, Sgt. (at Ginkunai, Lita)
U.S.S.R., Red Army, 16th Lithuanian Rifle Division, 224th Artillery Brigade
Mr. Chone Katz (father)
Place of burial unknown
Road to Victory – 290

Mirvis, Mikhail Borisovich (Мирвис, Михаил Борисович) Private [Рядовой]
U.S.S.R., Red Army, 58th Rifle Division, 20th Tank Brigade, 45th Autonomous Motor Rifle Battalion
Rifleman
Died of wounds at Medical Facility of 45th Medical Battalion, 53rd Rifle Division
Born 1924
Buried at Cemetery Number 80, Grave 1, Muzhla Village, Komarom-Estergom, Hungary
Memorial Book of Jewish Soldiers Who Died in Battles Against Nazism – 1941-1945 – Volume II – 547 [Книги Памяти евреев-воинов, павших в боях с нацизхмом в 1941-1945 гг – Том II – 547]

Ples, Josef, WO 2C, W-336 (at Dunkirk, France)
Czechoslovakia, 1st Czechoslovak Army Corps, 1st Armored Brigade
Czechoslovakia, Lipník nad Bečvou, okres Přerov; 8/12/19
Cassel Communal Cemetery Extension, Nord, France – D,15
Zide v Ceskoslovenskem Vojsku na Zapade – 247

______________________________

Rifas, Leonard, 1 Lt., 0-771802, Bomber Pilot, Air Medal, 4 Oak Leaf Clusters, Purple Heart, 27 missions
United States Army Air Force, 8th Air Force, 385th Bomb Group, 549th Bomb Squadron
Mrs. Jeanette R. Miller (sister), 5125 N. Capitol St., Washington, D.C.
(Also Chicago, Il.)
MACR 11718; Aircraft: B-17G 44-6100 (“Miss “D” Day”) 10 crewmen – no survivors
Tablets of the Missing at Cambridge American Cemetery, Cambridge, England
American Jews in World War II – 113

Half-way ‘round the world from Mustn’t Touch and Wugged Wascal, another bomber – 8th Air Force Flying Fortress Miss “D” Day, piloted by Lieutenant Leonard Rifas – was lost in circumstances equally enigmatic:  The aircraft vanished during a short flight from an emergency landing strip in France, to the 385th Bomb Group’s base at Great Ashfield, England.  Though the bodies of two crewmen were found by Air/Sea Rescue, the other eight crewmen remained (still remain) missing.  There were no survivors. 

As stated in the Missing Air Crew Report:

Aircraft 44-6100, returning from operational mission to Frankfurt, Germany on 8 January 1945, landed at emergency landing strip, A-70, Laon-Couvron, France.  Radio message was received at station 155, that this aircraft had been given clearance on the afternoon of 9 January 1945, but due to weather conditions on the continent it was believed that clearance had been cancelled, as no further contact was made by either A-70 or station 155.

The bodies of two of the crew frozen together in a life raft [2 Lt. John W. Skoff, bombardier, and S/Sgt. Lowey I. Boyd, ball turret gunner] were picked up at 50 – 40 N, 00 – 20 E, 13 January 1945, by Air/Sea Rescue and taken to New Haven Mortuary.  [New Haven is located just east of Brighton, in southern England.]


What happened aboard the plane will never be known, but based on the above statements, no emergency calls seem to have been radioed from the aircraft during its brief flight (or, if they were, such signals were not received).  The fact that the bombardier (from the front of the aircraft) and ball turret gunner (from the plane’s aft fuselage) survived for a time in one of the plane’s two rafts, suggests that there may have been adequate time for the crew to at least gather in the radio room for a controlled ditching, probably somewhere between Boulgone, France, and Beachy Head, England.  Though Lt. Skoff and S/Sgt. Boyd were found roughly – only – fifteen miles south of Eastbourne, in the English Channel (the location designated by the red circle in the below map), in mid-winter, in an open raft, those fifteen miles might just as well have been one thousand…

Lt. Skoff, from Will County, Illinois, is buried at Camp Butler National Cemetery, Springfield, Il. (Section 4, Grave 26), while Sergeant Boyd, from Buchanan County, Virginia, is buried at the Cambridge American Cemetery, in Cambridge, England (Plot F, Row 6, Grave 110). 

According to records at the 385th Bomb Group, Lieutenant Rifas completed 27 missions.  For his first twelve missions, he served as co-pilot to Ted C. Findeiss.  Commencing with the Hannover mission of October 26, 1944 he served as pilot, with nine of his fifteen missions in this capacity being flown in Miss D Day.

______________________________

Rosenberg, Jacob Joseph, EM3c, 2425767, Electrician’s Mate, Purple Heart
United States Navy, USS John D. Henley (DD553)
“0821: Two men [EM3c Jacob J. Rosenberg and F1c Kenneth Dowd Russell] fell overboard and were not recovered after a thorough search of the area.” (11-34 N, 159-14 E)
Mrs. Sophia Anna (Rosenberg) Zitzer (sister), 16 Greenock St., Boston, Ma.
Tablets of the Missing at Honolulu Memorial, Honolulu, Hawaii
American Jews in World War II – 176

Rubin, Harold, S 2C, 8625065, Seaman, Purple Heart
United States Navy, USS Mississippi
Mr. Able Rubin (father), 1659 W. Euclid Ave., Detroit, Mi.
Tablets of the Missing at Manila American Cemetery, Manila, Philippines
American Jews in World War II – 195

References

Birdsall, Steve, Saga of the Superfortress, Sidgwick & Jackson, London, England, 1981

Burkett, Prentiss M., Capt., The Unofficial History of the 499th Bomb Group (VH), Historical Aviation Album, Temple City, Ca., 1981

Dublin, Louis I., and Kohs, Samuel C., American Jews in World War II – The Story of 550,000 Fighters for Freedom, The Dial Press, New York, N.Y., 1947

Hickey, Lawrence J., Warpath Across the Pacific – The Illustrated History of the 345th Bombardment Group During World War II, International Research and Publishing Corporation, Boulder, Co., 1984

Leivers, Dorothy (Editing and Revisions), Road to Victory – Jewish Soldiers of the 16th Lithuanian Division, 1941-1945, Avotaynu, Bergenfield, N.J., 2009

Kulka, Erich, Zide Československém Vojsku na Západé, Naše Vojsko, Praha, Czechoslovakia, 1992

Loyd, Alwyn T., B-29 Superfortress in detail & scale – Production Version – Part 1, Aero Publishers, Inc., Fallbrook, Ca., 1983. 

Sturzbecker, Russell L., The Roarin’ 20s: A History of the 312th Bombardment Group, U.S. Army Air Force – World War II, Russell L. Sturzbecker, Westchester, Pa., 1976

Canadian Jews in World War II – Part II: Casualties, Canadian Jewish Congress, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, 1948

Memorial Book of Jewish Soldiers Who Died in Battles Against Nazism – 1941-1945 – Volume II [Surnames beginning with К (K), Л (L), М (M), Н (N)], Maryanovskiy, M.F., Pivovarova, N.A., Sobol, I.S. (editors), Union of Jewish War Invalids and Veterans, Moscow, Russia, 1995


Memorial Book of Jewish Soldiers Who Died in Battles Against Nazism – 1941-1945 – Volume IX [Surnames beginning with all letters of the alphabet], Maryanovskiy, M.F., Pivovarova, N.A., Sobol, I.S. (editors), Union of Jewish War Invalids and Veterans, Moscow, Russia, 2006

B-29 42-24657 (Tom McNamara photostream, at flickr.com)

Soldiers from New York: Jewish Soldiers in The New York Times, in World War Two: PFC Warren W. Jacobs (May 22, 1945)

This post marks a return to an ongoing theme (one of several) at this blog: A survey of Jewish military service during the Second World War, based upon obituaries for Second World War Jewish military casualties from the New York Metropolitan area, which appeared in The New York Times, particularly during 1945. 

Given the demographic characteristics of American Jews during the mid-twentieth century, it was perhaps inevitable that a vast amount of information about the military service of American Jews during that war would be presented in the Times.  Yet, given the ideology and identity – such as it was, is, and continues to be – of the owners and editors of the Times regarding the perception of the Jewish people as a people – an ethnos – the subject of a vast amount of academic and popular literature, the most outstanding example being Laurel Leff’s Buried By The Times, virtually no Second World War era news item in the Times touching upon the military service of Jewish soldiers, ever placed the latter within the larger context of the collective survival of the Jewish people.  (Well, truth be told, one did, in language as tangential as it was guarded.  But, that will be the subject of a future post.)

Given the tenor of the times and the nature of the Times – and by any stretch of the imagination not only the Times! – it would probably have been futile to have expected otherwise.

So…  Having thus far covered surnames commencing with the letters “A” though “H”, this post is centered upon Private First Class Warren W. Jacobs of the United States Army Air Force, whose death was reported upon in the Times on May 31, 1945. 

Notably, given that there is no Missing Air Crew Report pertaining to him, information about the circumstances of his death is probably limited to the historical records of the 11th Bomb Squadron.

Bronx Radio Operator Killed on China Flight

May 31, 1945

Pfc. Warren W. Jacobs, son of Mr. and Mrs. Dave Jacobs of 1694 Clay Avenue, the Bronx, was killed in action over China on May 22, his parents have been notified.  A member of the Eleventh Combat Squadron of the Tenth Air Force, he had 725 flying hours to his credit.

Private Jacobs, 24 years old, had received the Distinguished Flying Cross with two Oak Leaf clusters and the Air Medal with three clusters.  He was a radio operator in a B-29 [sic].

The soldier was a graduate of DeWitt Clinton High School and left Long Island University to join the armed forces.  He was studying to be an engineer.  In addition to his parents he is survived by a sister, Mrs. Edward Flegler of Yonkers.

Warren Jacobs’ portrait in the Times.

 __________________________

Contemporary view of 1694 Clay Ave., the Bronx, the wartime residence of the Jacobs family.

 __________________________

Jacobs, Warren W. (Zeev bar David), PFC, 32425076, Radio Operator, Distinguished Flying Cross, Air Medal, 5 Oak Leaf Clusters, Purple Heart
United States Army Air Force, 10th Air Force, 341st Bomb Group, 11th Bomb Squadron
Born 5/2/21
Mr. Dave Jacobs (father), 1694 Clay Ave., Bronx, N.Y.
Mrs. Edward Fliegler (sister), Yonkers, N.Y.
No Missing Air Crew Report; Circumstances unknown
Bayside Cemetery, Ozone Park, N.Y.
Casualty List 5/31/45
The New York Times (Obituary Section) 5/22/46, 5/22/48
American Jews in World War II – 351

Matzeva of PFC Jacobs (Zeev bar David), from FindAGrave contributor ntatap.

 __________________________

______________________________

Other Jewish military casualties on May 22, 1945 (10 Sivan 5705), include the following…

Killed in Action

– .ת. נ. צ. ב. ה
תהא

נפשו
צרורה
בצרור
החיים

United States Army Air Force

The end of the war in Europe did not mean the end of the war.  S/Sgt. Leonard Orloff and T/Sgt. Marvin Schaefer, both members of the Pacific-based 5th Air Force of the United States Army Air Force, were lost during combat missions in Pacific Theater, albeit not immediately and specifically due to enemy action.

As recorded in John Alcorn’s The Jolly Rogers, “The heavy operational schedule was plagued by a distressing series of losses.  …a similar tragedy occurred when the 319th B-24L of Lt. Roy E. Hurd failed to gain altitude after takeoff from Mindoro.  The right wing was seen to hit the water, and the stricken craft burst into flames as it smashed into the water.  Two injured crewmen survived, [2 Lt.] Lt. Hershell Miller [0-700513], the co-pilot, and T/Sgt. Lawrence Cote [11070352], the radio operator.”

And, as recorded in the diary of 90th Bomb Group pilot Lt. Merle B. Winne, “22 May 1945 Today we were assigned to go to Kiirun Formosa carrying 5- 1000 lb. Demos.  Due to weather however, we could not reach the target.  We used our second alternate of military barracks and installations at Toshien Formosa.  Due to a C-1 failure in our lead ship, we had to make two runs over the target getting very light flak both times.  We flew #3 in the #3 squadron. Joe flew the run.  On take off here at the field before daylight, Lt. Hurd and his crew crashed into the sea just off the end of the runway.  The Co-pilot and one gunner were saved after the ship exploded.  The Co-pilot was unscratched but the gunner had a broken back.  I was pallbearer today for the three bodies that were recovered.”

Orloff, Leonard R., S/Sgt., 33789646, Gunner, Air Medal, Purple Heart
90th Bomb Group, 319th Bomb Squadron
Born 1921
Mr. and Mrs. Aaron [?-1/11/41] and Rose [1895-5/6/68] Orloff (parents), 2138 Arch St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Mr. Albert P. Orloff (brother), 710 Brown St., Philadelphia, Pa.
MACR 15378, Aircraft B-24L 44-41552, Pilot 1 Lt. Roy E. Hurd, 10 crew members – 2 survivors
Golden Gate National Cemetery, San Bruno, Ca. – Section B, Grave 373; Buried 11/3/48
Philadelphia Inquirer 6/16/45
Philadelphia Bulletin 6/16/45
American Jews in World War II – 542

Born in 1917, Hershell L. Miller died in 1972, and is buried at Fort Logan National Cemetery, in Denver.  Born in 1922, Lawrence R. Cote died in 1993 and is buried at Atascadero, California.

______________________________

The crew roster for B-24 44-41552 and information about the aircraft’s loss on the mission of May 22, 1945, appear in this “first” page of MACR 15378. 

______________________________

The Philippine archipelago.  San Jose Airfield, then the base of the 90th Bomb Group, is located at the southern tip of Mindoro Island, which is located just to the left of the center of this (Goggle) map view. 

______________________________

A large-scale view of the location of San Jose Airfield (now San Jose Airport)…

______________________________

…and, an equivalently oriented satellite view of the above map, with the single runway of San Jose Airfield (now San Jose Airport) readily visible in the center of the image. 

______________________________

Akin to Private Jacobs, no Missing Air Crew Report actually exists for the loss of T/Sgt. Schaefer’s aircraft, albeit like many airmen, an index card was filed in his name and incorporated within the MACR name card index. 

Information about the incident instead comes from a variety of links at the website of The Flying Circus – the 380th Bomb Group.  By consulting the Group’s abbreviated roster of personnel and list of aircraft by serial numbers, his plane was identified as B-24L 44-42487.  Piloted by Harry B. Trimble, the bomber was abandoned 35 miles off coast of Mindoro, in the Philippine archipelago, after a strike against Kiirun Stores on Formosa.  The crew’s bombardier – 2 Lt. Ralph J. Walsh, from Denver, Colorado – was also killed (buried at Manila American Cemetery, Fort Bonifacio, Manila, Philippines), while the other crew members were presumably rescued and survived.

Schaefer, Marvin, T/Sgt., 15133790, Flight Engineer, Air Medal, 2 Oak Leaf Clusters, Purple Heart, 35 missions
380th Bomb Group, 529th Bomb Squadron
Born 1921
Mr. and Mrs. Harry N. [?-8/16/66] and Sophia [?-2/9/87] Schaefer (parents), 17725 Crestland Road, Cleveland, Oh.
Capt. Leonard Schaefer and Ruth Jean Schaefer (brother and sister)
Tablets of the Missing at Manila American Cemetery, Manila, Philippines
Cleveland Press & Plain Dealer, June 14 & 15, 1945
American Jews in World War II – 498

Though the actual composition of Schaefer’s crew is uncertain, based on records at the Flying Circus website, the men p r o b a b l y were:

Definite crew members
Trimble, Harry B., Pilot / Aircraft Commander, 0-421379 (also in Harry E. Rollings, Jr.’s, Crew)

Walsh, Ralph Joseph, 2 Lt., Bombardier, 0-696289 (also in Henry H. Day’s Crew)

Probable crew members
Steil, Robert J., Pilot / Aircraft Commander, T-764600 / 0-2024055

Lowell, Joseph F., Navigator, 0-807261
Richards, George W., III, Flight Engineer, 13107493
Rinoldo, Anthony C., Flight Engineer, 32934641
Warzecha, Stanley J., Gunner, 36861232
Smart, George J., Gunner, 36308822
Fox, George W., 15118322, Gunner / Photographer (also in other crews)

Possible crew member
Melton, Thomas I., Bombardier, 0-731176

______________________________

An in-flight view of the actual aircraft flown by the Trimble crew on May 22, 1945 (though the date of the image is unknown): Un-nicknamed B-24L 44-42487, from the Robert Chandler collection

______________________________

Casualties in other theaters of war

Cohen, Ephraim, Driver, T/183391, Mentioned in Despatches, Gazette 7/19/45
England, Royal Army Service Corps
Born 1917
Mr. P. Cohen (father), Newcastle-on-Tyne, England
Died on active service
Udine War Cemetery, Udine, Italy – III,B,1
The Jewish Chronicle 7/13/45
We Will Remember Them – A Record of the Jews Who Died in the Armed Forces of the Crown 1939 – 1945 – 74
We Will Remember Them – A Record of the Jews Who Died in the Armed Forces of the Crown 1939 – 1945 – An Addendum – 61

Gash
, Robert W., PFC, 36219819, Purple Heart, in Luzon, Philippines

United States Army, 40th Infantry Division, 160th Infantry Regiment, Headquarters Company, 1st Battalion
Born 9/27/19
Mrs. Rose W. Gash (mother), 1812 East Belleview Place, Milwaukee, Wi.
Temple Menorah Ever-Rest Cemetery, Milwaukee, Wi. – SEBA,L13,G6
American Jews in World War II – 584

Greenberg, Jerome H., Sgt., 36579605
United States Army, 106th Infantry Division, 424th Infantry Regiment
Non-Battle, in Germany
Born 1918
Mrs. Anne R. Greenberg (wife), 9360 Genesee St., Detroit, Mi.
Mr. Herman H. Greenberg (father)
Graduate of Detroit College of Law
Machpelah Cemetery, Ferndale, Mi. – Section Z, Lot 15, Grave 439D; Buried 1/5/49
WW II Honoree page by Mrs. Anne Radner, daughter
The Jewish News (Detroit) 6/8/45
American Jews in World War II – 191

Photograph of Sergeant Greenberg at the WW II Honoree page created by his daughter, Anna Radner

______________________________

Koslovitz, Mattathiahu, Cpl., PAL/17467
Yishuv, Jewish Brigade Group, Palestine Regiment, 1st Battalion
Caserta War Cemetery, Italy – V,B,14
Name in Commonwealth War Graves Commission database is “Kozlowicz, M.”
We Will Remember Them – A Record of the Jews Who Died in the Armed Forces of the Crown 1939 – 1945 – 249 (as “Koslovitz, Mattathiahu”)
The Book of the Jewish Brigade: The History of the Jewish Brigade Fighting and Rescuing [in] the Diaspora (Sefer ha-Brigadah ha-Yehudit: ḳorot ha-ḥaṭivah ha-Yehudit ha-loḥemet ṿeha-matsilah et ha-golah ((גולהה קורות החטיבה היהודית הלוחמת והמצילה אתספר הבריגדה היהודית)) – 292

Portrait of Corporal Koslovitz from The Book of the Jewish Brigade: The History of the Jewish Brigade Fighting and Rescuing [in] the Diaspora

Biography, in Hebrew, of Corporal Koslovitz in The Book of the Jewish Brigade: The History of the Jewish Brigade Fighting and Rescuing [in] the Diaspora

Translation of the above…

Corporal Koslovitz Mattathiahu – God rest his soul

Died on 6th of Sivan 22.5.1945

He was hit in the chest by a shell as his regiment (the First Regiment) passed the Senio River.  His wound seemed slight: he was moved from one military hospital to another, recovered, and managed to walk.  But when he underwent surgery on 22.5.1945, he died suddenly during the operation.

He came to Israel as a child.  He went to elementary school and later to the “Max Fine” professional school and was also occupied in youth jobs.  He enlisted into the No. 20 infantry unit and like thousands of his comrades, tolerated inaction and guard duty.  When the Jewish Brigade was formed, and especially during the training period in Fuji [sic] he was happy and proud of himself.  He would say: “we have a real army”.  He was promoted to the rank of Corporal at the front line for his dedication and diligence.

Even as a child he was diligent and loved working, and was also loyal and dedicated to his friends and ideals.  He was loved by his friends in his platoon for his kindness, good spirit, cheerfulness, friendly attitude and willingness to help.  At the front line he demonstrated courage and willingness to do any job.  In the many letters he sent to his friends from the hospitals he was in, he expressed his desire to go back to the front lines.

______________________________

Miedzinski, Hersz, Pvt. (Germany, Saxony, Forstgen (During Operation Brand Berlin)) (Died of wounds?)
Poland, Polish People’s Army, 5th Infantry Division
Born Ukraine, Zloczow (d. Tarnopol); 9/28/18
Mr. Majer Miedzinski (father)
Place of burial unknown
Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: I – Jewish Soldiers and Officers of the Polish People’s Army Killed and Missing in Action 1943-1945 – 49

Sierczyk, Daniel, Sergeant Major (Poland, Janow), Died of wounds
Poland, Polish People’s Army, Infantry Officer’s School
Born Chelm, Lubelskie, Poland, 5/16/25
Mr. Jakub Sierczyk (father)
Biala Street Community Cemetery, Lublin, Poland
Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: IV – Jewish Officers, Prisoners-of-War, Murdered in Katyn Crime; Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Resistance Movement, An Addendum – 103

Yonis, Ralph (Rafael bar Rachmim), Pvt., 11131585, Purple Heart, in Mindanao, Philippines
United States Army, 24th Infantry Division, 21st Infantry Regiment
Born 1926
Mr. and Mrs. Rachamim [8/9/90-10/11/63] and Sophie (Pappos) [5/15/00-10/15/60] Yonis (parents), 133 Main St., Peabody, Ma.
John, Samuel, and Sara (brothers and sister)
Buried at Sons of Jacob Cemetery, Danvers, Ma.
Casualty List 6/26/45
American Jews in World War II – 185

Matzeva of Private Yonis, from FindAGrave contributor Pamela Filbotte-Hollabaugh

______________________________

Wounded in Action

Epstein, Albert, Pvt., Purple Heart, in Luzon, Philippines
United States Army
Born 1926
Mr. Michael Epstein (father), 103 Durfor St., Philadelphia, Pa.
The Jewish Exponent 7/6/45
Philadelphia Bulletin 6/26/45
Philadelphia Record 6/26/45
American Jews in World War II – 519

Rubin, Irving Thomas, PFC, 896700, Purple Heart
United States Marine Corps, 6th Marine Division, 4th Marine Regiment, 1st Battalion, B Company
Born 1918
Mrs. Lydia B. Rubin (wife), 283 Beach St. (or) 94 Walnut Ave., Revere, Ma.
American Jews in World War II – 177

Silver, Solomon Saul, PFC, 502669, Purple Heart
United States Marine Corps, 1st Marine Division, 1st Marine Regiment, 1st Battalion, C Company
Mr. Abraham Silver (father), 471 Neptune Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Mrs. Thelma S. Brown (sister)
WW II Memorial Honoree Page
Casualty List 7/13/45
American Jews in World War II – 443

References

Alcorn, John S., The Jolly Rogers – History of the 90th Bomb Group During World War II, Historical Aviation Album, Temple City, Ca., 1981

Dublin, Louis I., and Kohs, Samuel C., American Jews in World War II – The Story of 550,000 Fighters for Freedom, The Dial Press, New York, N.Y., 1947

Lifshitz, Jacob (יעקב, ליפשיץ), The Book of the Jewish Brigade: The History of the Jewish Brigade Fighting and Rescuing [in] the Diaspora (Sefer ha-Brigadah ha-Yehudit: ḳorot ha-ḥaṭivah ha-Yehudit ha-loḥemet ṿeha-matsilah et hagolah ((גולהה קורות החטיבה היהודית הלוחמת והמצילה אתספר הבריגדה היהודית)), Shim’oni (שמעוני), Tel-Aviv, 1950

Meirtchak, Benjamin, Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: I – Jewish Soldiers and Officers of the Polish People’s Army Killed and Missing in Action 1943-1945, World Federation of Jewish Fighters Partisans and Camp Inmates: Association of Jewish War Veterans of the Polish Armies in Israel, Tel Aviv, Israel, 1994

Meirtchak, Benjamin, Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: IV – Jewish Officers, Prisoners-of-War, Murdered in Katyn Crime; Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Resistance Movement; An Addendum, World Federation of Jewish Fighters Partisans and Camp Inmates: Association of Jewish War Veterans of the Polish Armies in Israel, Tel Aviv, Israel, 1997

Morris, Henry, Edited by Gerald Smith, We Will Remember Them – A Record of the Jews Who Died in the Armed Forces of the Crown 1939 – 1945, Brassey’s, United Kingdom, London, 1989

Morris, Henry, Edited by Hilary Halter, We Will Remember Them – A Record of the Jews Who Died in the Armed Forces of the Crown 1939 – 1945 – An Addendum, AJEX, United Kingdom, London, 1994

McGuire Airdrome / McGuire Airfield (San Jose Airport), at Pacific Wrecks

1 Lt. Roy E Hurd, at FindAGrave

Diary of Merle B. Winne, at 90th Bomb Group

Plus, special thanks to Ari for help with the Hebrew-to-English translation. 

The Ambivalence of Acceptance – The Acceptance of Ambivalence III: “The Jews and The War”, by Maurice Barres – Correspondence from French Jewish Soldiers

To have a “place” can mean different things: A place can be a physical location; it can be a relationship to others, be they family, friends, or strangers; it can imply a sense of familiarity with and belonging to the zeitgeist of a particular age.  And sometimes, it can be all these definitions – changing in degree and intensity – at once.

For the French writer, journalist, and politician Auguste-Maurice Barrès’, the “place” of the Jews of France during that nation’s hour of crisis in the First World War was addressed by the chapter “The Israelites” in his 1917 book Les Diverses Families Spirituelles de la France (The Various Spiritual Families of France), the full text of which you can read in English, and, the (original) French.

While the above-mentioned chapter (one of eleven within his book) comprises 23 pages, his monograph includes a “Notes and Appendix” section of 41 pages (page 268 through page 309).  For chapter Five – “The Israelites” – relevant material can be found on pages 282 through 292, correlating to footnotes #12 through #14 in chapter Five.

As a supplement to my earlier posts covering the “The Israelites”, and to fully appreciate Barrès’ writings Jews in the French Army, you can read a translation of the relevant pages of the Notes and Appendix section, below.  And, (yet!) further below, near the end of the post) you can read the text in the original French. 

Intriguingly, from the Notes and Appendix section of the book, it can be seen that despite his attitude towards French Jewry during the Dreyfus affair, by 1917 Barrès’ had been engaging in correspondence with Jewish soldiers serving in the French Army, and, some representatives of the Jewish community of France.  Similarly, paralleling the contents of Chapter Five, in the Notes and Appendix Barrès alludes to three Jewish soldiers who fell for France:

The first (anonymous) soldier –  Aged 33, sergeant to the 360th Infantry Regiment, this Jewish soldier took part in the fighting of Reméreville, Crévic, Bois Saint-Paul, Velaine-sôus-Ainance, from August 25 to September 14, 1914.”  The second soldier – mentioned by name – Charles Halphen, who served in the 39th Artillery Regiment, and was killed in action on May 15, 1915.  The third soldier – also mentioned by name – Captain Raoul Bloch, killed on May 12, 1916, near Verdun.  The information about the anonymous 33-year-old sergeant was of such accuracy that I was immediately able to identify him, based on his archival record from the SGA, and, information in Les Israelites dans l’Armée Française.  He was Sergent-Major Max Jean Francois Claude Levy.

It’s particularly notable that the biographical backgrounds of Bloch, Halphen, and Levy, all deeply patriotic, encompass a wide spectrum of religious belief (particularly represented by Max Levy) and represent different levls of acculturation. 

Paralleling my post aboutThe Israelites, this post presents “PARTIE À REMPLIR PAR LE CORPS (‘PART TO BE COMPLETED BY THE CORPS’)” Cards for Levy, Halphen, and Bloch, and includes biographical information about each soldier as derived from both the Cards and other sources, such as l’Univers Israélite (reviewed at the Dorot Jewish Division of the New York Public Library), and the above-mentioned Les Israelites dans l’Armée Française.  And…just like my prior post…to enable you to distinguish between my additions and the original text more easily, “my” information is presented in maroon-colored text, like this.  (Refer to my earlier post, Three Soldiers – Three Brothers? – Fallen for France: Hermann, Jules, and Max Boers) for a longer discussion about information in “PARTIE À REMPLIR PAR LE CORPS (‘PART TO BE COMPLETED BY THE CORPS’)” Cards.)

In addition, this post lists the names of French Jewish soldiers who lost their lives on the same dates as Levy, Halphen, and Bloch.  The record for each of the soldiers comprises that soldier’s 1) rank, 2) country or land of birth, and, 3) the geographic location where he was killed.  All these names were obtained from the SGA’s Base des Morts pour la France de la Première Guerre mondiale (Database of Killed for France in the First World War) database.

So, to begin, the title and table-of-contents of Les Diverses Families Spirituelles de la France…

______________________________

______________________________

MAURICE BARRÈS

OF THE FRENCH ACADEMY
PRESIDENT OF THE LEAGUE OF PATRIOTS

THE VARIOUS SPIRITUAL FAMILIES OF FRANCE

PARIS
EMILE-PAUL FRÈRES, EDITORS
100, RUE DE FAIBOURG-SAINT-HONORÉ. 100
PLACE BEAUVAU
1917
______________________________

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Chapters.                                                                                                   Pages.

I          Our diversities disappear on August 4, 1914                        1
II        … And reappear in the army                                                       9
III       The Catholics                                                                                  19
IV       The Protestants                                                                              51
V        The Israelites                                                                                   67
VI      The Socialists                                                                                   90
VII    The Traditionalists                                                                       137
VIII   Catholics, Protestants, Socialists, all defending France, defend their particular faith                                                                                                                193
IX      An already legendary night (Christmas 1914)                   205
X       Twenty-year-old soldiers devote themselves to creating a more beautiful France                                                                                                            215
XI    This profound unanimity, we will continue to live it     259

Notes and Appendix                                                                               269

PRINTING CHAIX, RUE BERGERE, 20, PARIS – 842-1-17. (Lucre Lurilleux)

______________________________

NOTES AND APPENDIX

(12) NOTE FROM PAGE 74. – “I would like to know more about the war activity of the Israelites in Algeria than I could have obtained …”

Someone authorized to speak in their names writes [to] me:

“They serve, for the most part, in the Zouaves and were there (until lately) in the proportion of a quarter.  They took part in the battles of Belgium, the Marne (particularly at Chambry), Soissons, Arras, Yser, Champagne, Verdun, the Somme, Dardanelles, Serbia.  It is especially the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th and 8th Zouaves, constituted in Algeria, who set them at the beginning.  The 45th division, formed at Oran of reservists and territorials, was the one that crossed Paris in the first days of September, and was immediately sent by Gallieni to the vicinity of Meaux, to carry the blow which was decisive.”

______________________________

(13) NOTE FROM PAGE 78. – “The documents which I possess on the moral elite of the Israelites only make known to me consciences which seem emptied of their religious tradition …”

On this subject, a young Jewish, industrial, Lorraine officer, who was the object of a beautiful citation by the order of the army, writes me an interesting letter which begins with these words: “I am a Jew, sincerely believing and attached to my religion …”  I leave some fragments:

“Let us take as an example,” said the officer, “an Israelite of what is called the good bourgeoisie, that is, the second lieutenant who writes to you …  I had a medium education (classical studies to Carnot, then beginning of right).  My parents are from Alsace, and under Louis-Philippe, one of my grandparents was Mayor of Altkirch.  For my part, I did my military service, like all the young people I knew, without much pleasure or enthusiasm, and only thought of the war when my father told me about his campaign of 1870.

Suddenly comes the period of tension in 1914, then mobilization.  I would have liked you to see our joy, to we Jews who, according to you, sir, do not have real love of their country or have it only by gratitude for a country where they have not been martyred …  I remember that Saturday night, when my parents accompanied me to Paris-Lyon-Méditerranée.  My mother was crying and my father laughed with joy despite having tears in the corner of his eye.  For my part, I give you my word of honor and [as a] soldier; I was happy without calculation, happy to fight for my country that I loved …  All my friends to whom I said goodbye, without doubt that it was goodbye to me, had the joy at heart of the idea of taking over Alsace, of which we for the most part are native.

I insist on this instinctive sentiment of patriotism; I would like us to know each other better, we other Jews, who are not ashamed of our race and who do not use our fortune to offer hunts to people ruined by fragments.  I believe you only see two kinds of Jews:

First of all, the little aristocracy, with enormous fortunes, and which is not very interesting (characterized by its platitudes toward the great names of Catholicism).

Then, there are the Polish Jews who clutter our country and who, to eat, do all the trades (the latter are only interesting by the misfortunes they have endured in Russia).

But there are also the believing Jews, sincere, profoundly fond of their country, not seeking to dazzle others by their fortune and their luxury of bad taste: in short, the good bourgeoisie.  You believe too much that Jews are beings apart, who have a special mentality.  Between the “Nucingen” and the “Gobseck”, there is something else.

I had a hard time at the front because during the first winter we were not yet used to this war of “moles” and in the Vosges (col de Sainte-Marie) we suffered a lot from the cold.  For men, physical suffering alone counted; but as an officer I had painful days.  This inaction weighed on me.  The loneliness in our wooded mountains breeds melancholy, bad feelings; in short weariness.  It was then that my faith intervened and saved me morally.  I remembered the prayer I was making at night, before kissing my mother and who is very similar to your “Pater noster”.  I prayed and the Lord supported me; gave me calm.  Whenever I had a decision to make, I thought of Him and I was quiet.

At the moment of the attack itself, the duty imposes on you enough work so that one can think only of the orders received and the means to execute them for the best.  But before!  The half hour preceding the offensive attack or reconnaissance has a tragic grandeur.  Every one, Catholic, Protestant, or Jew, collects himself, and the true believers recognize themselves in their calm, which at this moment can not be feigned.

I write to you in all sincerity.  Whenever I saw that I had to go to death, I thought of “Him,” and my duty seemed natural, without merit.  When I was buried, I thought myself wounded to death and my first thought was still for my God.

The Jewish religion is not made for the people, because it is not composed of small external practices, but only of the idea of God and the survival of the soul.  That’s why there are few true believers.

It happened to me, wanting to gather me, to go to a church and I do not think I committed sacrilege.

This is my state of affairs, which I am simply exposing to you, feeling sympathy for you.”

(Letter from Second Lieutenant L., December 29, 1916.)

______________________________

On the same subject a letter signed by an important name in Parisian society:

I do not want to let you believe that the consciences of the Israelites who died for France with love “are emptied of their religious tradition”.  However, I can only bring you “texts” by formally asking you to take them only as anonymous.  By modesty first, and by justice also for unknown heroes, I desire that the name of my son be piously guarded by you without being published …

I regretfully conform to this desire; I will not mention the name of the hero, who held a high office; I limit myself to analyzing the small file that is communicated to me.

Aged 33, sergeant to the 360th Infantry Regiment, this Jewish soldier took part in the fighting of Reméreville, Crévic, Bois Saint-Paul, Velaine-sôus-Ainance, from August 25 to September 14, 1914.  [Max Jean Francois Claude Levy]  At this date, he writes to his parents a letter that will be the last:

Papa, adored mama.  Thank you for your tender cards and letters that I receive very well, but in package.  Last night those of August 31st and September 1st.  You are, I am sure, an admirable nurse, but I will not need your care for this time.  We are now held back for a long time from the line of fire where we have been since August 26, especially since September 2.  I did not have an attack, not a scratch, and yet I felt almost sure, so much I had the powerful feeling of God’s protection that he granted me for all and by you my admirable parents.  So that I had no merit in feeling no hesitation in throwing myself between bullets and shells; I saw them veer around me.  I did not commit any act of valor, at all, I hasten to say it, I just went where I was told to go.

Three days later, having proposed to conduct a reconnaissance, he enters the village of Bezange-la-Grande.  A young peasant advises him to “turn around”.  He answers: “I am charged with a reconnaissance, one must go farther …”, and almost immediately he falls, hit in the head by an explosive bullet.  He had said to his father on leaving him: “I will bring you back Lorraine, or I will stay there.”  The inhabitants buried him and the mayor was able to send the parents the medal of piety found on their son; it bore the traditional inscription: “You shall love the LORD.”  [This is a reference to the Shema Yisrael prayer, in Deuteronomy 6, Verses 4-5 The full text: 

4) Hear, O Israel: the LORD our God, the LORD is one.
שְׁמַע, יִשְׂרָאֵל: יְהוָה אֱלֹהֵינוּ, יְהוָה אֶחָד.
5) And thou shalt love the LORD thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy might.
וְאָהַבְתָּ, אֵת יְהוָה אֱלֹהֶיךָ, בְּכָל-לְבָבְךָ וּבְכָל-נַפְשְׁךָ, וּבְכָל-מְאֹדֶךָ.]

On the paper he had prepared before his departure and where he expressed his last wishes, he invoked the sacred word: He walked with God all the days of his life.  Suddenly we no longer saw him because God had taken him.”  [A reference to Chapter 5, Verse 24, in GenesisThe actual text: And Enoch walked with God, and he was not; for God took him.  וַיִּתְהַלֵּךְ חֲנוֹךְ, אֶת-הָאֱלֹהִים; וְאֵינֶנּוּ, כִּי-לָקַח אֹתוֹ אֱלֹהִים.]

And again: “For myself, I know that my Redeemer lives and that He will raise me up from the earth, and that when my flesh is destroyed, I will see God.  I will see Him with my eyes.”  [A reference to Verses 25 through 27, in Chapter 19 of the Book of Job The actual text:

25) But as for me, I know that my Redeemer liveth, and that He will witness at the last upon the dust;
וַאֲנִי יָדַעְתִּי, גֹּאֲלִי חָי; וְאַחֲרוֹן, עַל-עָפָר יָקוּם.
26) And when after my skin this is destroyed, then without my flesh shall I see God;
וְאַחַר עוֹרִי, נִקְּפוּ-זֹאת; וּמִבְּשָׂרִי, אֶחֱזֶה אֱלוֹהַּ.
27) Whom I, even I, shall see for myself, and mine eyes shall behold, and not another’s. My reins are consumed within me.]
אֲשֶׁר אֲנִי, אֶחֱזֶה-לִּי–וְעֵינַי רָאוּ וְלֹא-זָר: כָּלוּ כִלְיֹתַי בְּחֵקִי.]

[Perhaps Max Levy’s “medal of piety” referred to by Barrès’ was a Mezuzah in the form of an amulet…?]

Max Jean Francois Claude Levy

Sergent Major, 16063 / 16635, France, Armée de Terre, Infanterie, 360eme Regiment d’Infanterie, 22eme Compagnie
Killed by the enemy [Tué a l’ennemi] at Carency, Pas-de-Calais, France, May 9, 1915
Born August 9, 1887, 10eme Arrondissement, Paris, France

Les Israelites dans l’Armée Française, p. 56
Les Israelites dans l’Armée Française lists name as “Levy, Max”, and gives date and location as May 5, 1915, Villers-aux-Bois”

Buried at Necropole Nationale “Notre-Dame-de-Lorette”, Ablain-Saint-Nazaire, Pas-de-Calais, France – Tombe Individuelle, Carre 87, Rang 4, No. 17468
SGA burial record gives name as “Levy, Max”

______________________________

On Israel believing, still this document of the sacred union.  M. Lancrenion, priest, medical aide-major in the 1st group of the 39th artillery, writes to the mother of the young Charles Halphen, lieutenant of the 39th artillery, fallen on the field of honor on May 15, 1915, a letter of which here is the end:

The friendship, linked by me with your son, has turned into respect and admiration for his heroic death.  And I want to tell you too, the infinitely powerful and merciful God, in whom we all believe, though different from religion, in which your son believed (he told me), took from him, I hope, the right and loyal soul, who sacrificed himself for duty, and he took it for immortality …  I prayed from the bottom of my heart yesterday, today, this God of mercy, to receive your son to him, and to gather you to him, when the time will come for an eternal and happy meeting …  May this word of a minister of God not calm your pain, but bring you hope, support your courage, help you bear the sacrifice.

Charles Nathan Halphen

Lieutenant, 65, France, Armée de Terre, Artillerie
39eme Regiment d’Artillerie de Campagne
Killed by the enemy [Tué a l’ennemi], at Neuville-Saint-Vaast, Pas-de-Calais, France, May 15, 1915
Mr. Georges Halpen (father)
Born December 3, 1885, 17eme Arrondissement, Paris, France

l’Univers Israélite 10/8/15, 1/26/17
The Jewish Chronicle 7/30/15
Les Israelites dans l’Armée Française, p. 41
Les Israelites dans l’Armée Française gives name as “Halphen, Charles” and date as May 12, 1915

l’Univers Israélite: “Professeur au college Chaptal; Cite a l’ordre de l’armee; Il etait fils de feu Georges Halphen, membre de l’Academie des sciences”

Buried at Cimetiere Militaire “Ecoivres Milit. Cemetery”, Ecoivres – Mount Saint Eloi, Pas-de-Calais, France – Tombe Individuelle, Rang 23, No. 731, 65

______________________________

(14) NOTE FROM PAGE 92. – I am told: “You have seen exceptional Israelites, newly arrived among us or great intellectuals”, and I am given to read the correspondence of Captain Raoul Bloch, killed on May 12, 1916 before Verdun, who belonged to the business world.  His letters, in a firm tone, exude the most salutary patriotic and family feeling.

Raoul Bloch

Capitaine, France, Armée de Terre, Infanterie
306eme Regiment d’Infanterie
Killed [Tué], May 12, 1916, at Mort Homme, Fromerville, Meuse, France
Born April 11, 1872, Auxerre, Yonne, France

Les Israelites dans l’Armée Française 1921, p. 17
American Jewish Yearbook V 21, p. 38

Place of burial unknown (None?…)

Aged forty, assigned to the service of the [reserves], he asks to go into active [service].  “I am anxiously waiting to do my duty as I desire and understand it; as French and Jew, I have to do it twice.  The country is at this moment in need of all its men valid for defense, arms in hand; – I am in a service that can be done very well with men of age and less nimble, my duty is to offer my services elsewhere …»

On the 6th of January, 1915, he sends to his wife this page full of the earthly piety of an Alsatian Israelite:

With what joy I will go to the side of Alsace and what memories by penetrating into uniform in this country of our dreams!  Our poor fathers would flinch in their graves!  Finally, the “revenge” of which they spoke so much, whose heart overflowed! and my brave brother, my old under the hood, and in what tragic moments! with what pleasure I will avenge him and Robert my brother too soon disappeared!  What a note to pay the Bandits and how I will be fierce creditor!

Tell them all, brothers and sisters, that never can our hearts have vibrated so much in unison and have so intensely communicated.  I often think of all those who surround you at this moment with such tender affection, and help you to bear valiantly the heavy contribution of the country that I imposed on you as well as myself.  To be one of those who have contributed directly to your home birthplace will be for me a sweet joy and a complement to our life so united and so tender.  What a beautiful anniversary of our twenty years of cleaning, the “rue de la Mésange” once again French! what more beautiful gift can I dream to bring you!  And Lauterbourg, Niederbronn, Bionville, all in our three colors!  You must understand why I wanted and had to leave, the whole family tradition is not with me?  To be able to take you and our darlings to Alsace-Lorraine and tell them: Papa has helped in the measure of his strength to return these two beautiful countries to France, what a better reward for me?

 __________________________

______________________________

– .ת. נ. צ. ב. ה
תהא

נפשו
צרורה
בצרור
החיים

May 9, 1915 – Max Jean Francois Claude Levy

The books Les Israelites dans l’Armée Française (in combination with the SGA database) and Die Jüdischen Gefallenen Des Deutschen Heeres, Deutschen Marine Und Der Deutschen Schutztruppen 1914-1918 – Ein Gedenkbuch, reveal the names of approximately 90 French Jewish soldiers, and 27 German Jewish soldiers – killed in action or died of wounds – for the above date.

May 15, 1915 – Charles Nathan Halphen

Freyberg, France, Seine-Maritime; Rouen; l’Hopital (“Partie a Remplir par le Corps” card could not be found or identified in SGA database; name from Les Israelites dans l’Armée Française
Koskach, Isaac, Soldat de 2eme Classe, France (Algérie), 16850, Belgique; Het Sas
Midowitch, Kiel, Soldat de 2eme Classe, France (Russie), 20493, Pas-de-Calais; Berthonval
Zerbib, Messim Emile, Soldat de 2eme Classe, France (Algérie), 10859, Pas-de-Calais; Roclincourt

The names of Midowitch and Zerbib do not appear in Les Israelites dans l’Armée Française.

May 12, 1916 – Raoul Bloch

Bernheim, Lucien Germain Edouard, Aspirant, France, 6473, Meuse; Vauquois
Darmon, Mimoun, Soldat de 2eme Classe, France (Algérie), 17288, Meuse
Walter, Stephan, Soldat de 2eme Classe, France (Pologne – Lodz), Meuse; Thierville; 1600 m a l’ouest de

Walter’s name does not appear in Les Israelites dans l’Armée Française.

______________________________

______________________________

NOTES ET APPENDICE

(12) NOTE DE LA PAGE 74. — «J’aimerais avoir sur l’activité guerrière des Israélites d’Algérie des précisions que je n’ai pu me procurer…»

Quelqu’un d’autorisé à parler en leurs noms m’écrit:

«Ils servent, pour la plupart, dans les zouaves et s’y trouvaient (jusqu’à ces derniers temps) dans la proportion d’un quart.  Ils ont pris part aux combats de Belgique, de la Marne (particulièrement à Chambry), devant Soissons, à Arras, sur l’Yser, en Champagne, sous Verdun, dans la Somme, aux Dardanelles, en Serbie.  Ce sont surtout les 1er, 2e, 3e, 4e et 8e zouaves, constitués en Algérie, qui les ont encadrés à l’origine.  La 45e division, formée à Oran de réservistes et de territoriaux, est celle qui a traversé Paris dans les premiers jours de septembre et qui a tout de suite été expédiée par Galliéni dans les environs de Meaux, pour y porter le coup qui fut décisif.»

(13) NOTE DE LA PAGE 78. — « Les documents que je possède sur l’élite morale des israélites ne me font connaître que des consciences qui paraissent vidées de leur tradition religieuse…»

Là-dessus, un jeune officier israélite, industriel lorrain, qui a été l’objet d’une belle citation à l’ordre de l’armée, m’écrit une lettre intéressante qui commence par ces mots: «Je suis juif, sincèrement croyant et attaché à ma religion…»  J’en détache quelques fragments:

«Prenons comme exemple, me dit cet officier, un israélite de ce que l’on appelle la bonne bourgeoisie, c’est-à-dire le sous-lieutenant qui vous écrit…  J’ai eu une instruction moyenne (études classiques à Carnot, puis commencement de droit).  Mes parents sont originaires d’Alsace, et, sous Louis-Philippe, un de mes grands-parents était maire d’Altkirch.  Pour ma part, j’ai fait mon service militaire, comme tous les jeunes gens que je connaissais, sans grand plaisir ni enthousiasme, et ne pensais à la guerre que lorsque mon père me racontait sa campagne de 1870.

»Tout à coup arrive en 1914 la période de tension, puis la mobilisation.  J’aurais voulu que vous puissiez voir notre joie, à nous juifs qui, d’après vous, Monsieur, n’ont pas l’amour réel de leur patrie ou ne l’ont que par reconnaissance pour un pays où ils n’ont pas été martyrisés…  Je me souviens de ce samedi soir, lorsque mes parents m’ont accompagné au Paris-Lyon-Méditerranée.  Ma mère pleurait et mon père riait de joie en ayant malgré tout use larme au coin de l’œil.  Pour ma part, je vous en donne ma parole d’honneur et de soldat, j’étais heureux sans calcul, heureux de me battre pour mon pays que j’aimais…  Tous mes amis à qui j’ai dit au revoir, sans me douter que c’était un adieu, avaient la joie au cœur à l’idée de reprendre cette Alsace dont nous sommes pour la plupart originaires.

»J’insiste sur ce sentiment instinctif de patriotisme; je voudrais que I’on nous connaisse mieux, nous autre juifs, qui n’avons pas honte de notre race et qui n’usons pas de notre fortune pour offrir de chasses aux gens ruinés à particule.  Je crois que vous ne voyez que deux sortes de juifs :

»D’abord la petite aristocratie, aux fortunes énormes, et qui est peu intéressante (caractérisée par sa platitude envers les grands noms du catholicisme).

»Ensuite, les juifs polonais qui encombrent notre pays et qui, pour manger, font tous les métiers (ces derniers ne sont intéressants que par les malheurs qu’ils ont endurés en Russie).

»Mais il y a aussi les juifs croyants, sincères, aimant profondément leur pays, ne cherchant pas à éblouir les autres par leur fortune et leur luxe de mauvais goût: bref, la bonne bourgeoisie.  Vous croyez trop que les juifs sont des êtres à part, qui ont une mentalité spéciale.  Entre le «Nucingen» et le «Gobseck», il y a autre chose.

»J’ai passé au front de durs moments, car pendant le premier hiver nous n’avions pas encore l’habitude de cette guerre de «taupes» et dans les Vosges (col de Sainte-Marie) nous souffrions beaucoup du froid.  Pour les hommes, la souffrance physique seule comptait; mais, comme officier, j’avais de pénibles journées.  Cette inaction me pesait.  La solitude dans nos montagnes boisées engendre la mélancolie, les mauvais sentiments, bref la lassitude.  C’est alors que ma foi est intervenue et m’a sauvé moralement.  Je me suis souvenu de la prière que je faisais tout petit, le soir avant d’embrasser ma maman et qui ressemble beaucoup à votre «Pater noster».  J’ai prié et le Seigneur m’a soutenu, m’a donné le calme.  Chaque fois que j’avais une décision à prendre, je pensais à Lui et j’étais tranquille.

»Au moment de l’attaque même, le devoir vous impose suffisamment de travail pour que l’on ne puisse penser qu’aux ordres reçus et aux moyens de les exécuter pour le mieux.  Mais avant!  La demi-heure qui précède l’attaque ou la reconnaissance offensive, possède une grandeur tragique.  Chacun, catholique, protestant ou juif se recueille, et les véritables croyants se reconnaissent à leur calme, qui, à ce moment, ne peut être feint.

»Je vous écris en toute sincérité.  Chaque fois que je voyais qu’il fallait aller à la mort, je pensais à «Lui», et mon devoir m’apparaissait naturel, sans mérite.  Lorsque j’ai été enseveli, je me suis cru blessé à mort el ma première pensée a été encore pour mon Dieu.

»La religion juive n’est pas faite pour le peuple, car elle n’est pas composée de petites pratiques extérieures, mais uniquement de l’idée de Dieu et de la survie de l’âime.  C’est pourquoi il y a peu de véritables croyants.

»Il m’est arrivé, voulant me recueillir, d’aller m’agenouiller dans une église et je ne crois pas avoir commis un sacrilège.

»Voilà mon état dame que je vous expose simplement, sentant chez vous une sympathie.»

(Lettre du sous-lieutenant L., 29 décembre 1916.)

Sur le même sujet une lettre signée d’un nom important dans la société parisienne:

Je ne voudrais pas vous laisser croire que les consciences des Israélites morts pour la France avec amour «sont vidées de leur tradition religieuse».  Je ne peux cependant vous apporter des «textes» qu’en vous demandant formellement de ne les prendre que comme anonymes.  Par modestie d’abord, et par justice aussi pour les héros inconnus, je désire que le nom de mon fils soit par vous pieusement gardé sans être publié …

Je me conforme à regret à cette volonté; je tairai le nom du héros, qui occupait une haute charge; je me borne à analyser le petit dossier que l’on me communique.

Agé de 33 ans, sergent au 360e régiment d’infanterie, ce soldat israélite a pris part aux combats de Réméreville, Crévic, Bois Saint-Paul, Velaine-sôus-Ainance, du 25 août au 14 septembre 1914.  A cette date, il écrit à ses parents une lettre qui va être la dernière:

Papa, maman adorés.  Merci de vos tendres cartes et lettres que je reçois très bien, mais en paquet.  Hier soir celles du 31 août el du 1er septembre.  Vous êtes, j’en suis sur, une infirmière admirable, mais je n’aurai pas pour celle fois besoin de vos soins.  Nous sommes aujourd’hui retenus en arrière pour longtemps de la ligne de feu où nous sommes depuis le 26 août, surtout depuis le 2 septembre.  Je n’ai pas eu une atteinte, pas une égratignure, et pourtant je me sentais presque sûr, tellement j’avais sur moi la sensation puissante de le protection de Dieu qu’il m’accorda pour tous et par vous mes admirables parents.  De sorte que je n’ai eu aucun mérite à n’éprouver aucune hésitation à me jeter entre les balles et les obus; je les voyais dévier autour de moi.  Je n’ai d’ailleurs commis aucun acte de valeur, du tout, je m’empresse de le dire, je me suis contenté d’aller là où l’on me disait d’aller.

Trois jours plus tard, s’étant proposé pour conduire une reconnaissance, il pénètre dans le village de Bezange-la-Grande.  Un jeune paysan lui conseille «de faire demi-tour».  Il répond: «Je suis chargé d’une reconnaissance, il faut aller plus loin…», et presque aussitôt il tombe frappé à la tête d’une balle explosible.  Il avait dit à son père en le quittant: «La Lorraine, je vous la rapporterai ou j’y resterai.»  Les habitants l’ensevelirent et le maire a pu faire parvenir aux parents la médaille de piété trouvée sur leur fils; elle portait l’inscription traditionnelle: «Tu aimeras l’Éternel.»  Sur le papier qu’il avait préparé avant son départ et où il exprimait ses dernières volontés, il invoquait la parole sacrée: Il chemina avec Dieu tous les jours de sa vie.  Tout à coup on ne le vit plus parce que Dieu l’avait pris.»  Et encore: «Pour moi, je sais que mon Rédempteur est vivant et qu’il me ressuscitera de la terre, et que lorsque ma chair aura été détruite, je verrai Dieu.  Je le verrai de mes yeux.».

Sur Israël croyant, encore ce document d’union sacrée.  M. Lancrenion, prêtre, médecin aide-major au 1er groupe du 39e d’artillerie, écrit à la mère du jeune Charles Halphen, lieutenant au 39e d’artillerie, tombé au champ d’honneur le 15 mai 1915, une lettre dont voici la fin:

L’amitié, liée par moi avec votre fils, s’est transformée en respect et en admiration devant sa mort héroïque.  Et je veux vous le dire aussi, le Dieu infiniment puissant et miséricordieux, dans lequel nous croyons tous, quoique différents de religion, dans lequel votre fils croyait (il me l’a dit), a pris auprès de lui, je l’espère, l’âme droite et loyale, qui s’est sacrifiée pour le devoir, el il l’a prise pour l’immortalité …  J’ai prié du fond de mon cœur hier, aujourd’hui, ce Dieu de miséricorde, de recevoir votre fils auprès de lui, et de vous réunir à lui, quand le temps sera venu pour une réunion éternelle et heureuse…  Puisse cette parole d’un ministre de Dieu, non pas calmer votre douleur, mais vous apporter l’espérance, soutenir votre courage, vous aider à supporter la sacrifice.

(14) NOTE DE LA PAGE 92. — On me dit:  «Vous avez fait voir des israélites d’exception, nouvellement venus parmi nous ou bien grands intellectuels», et l’on me donne à lire la correspondance du capitaine Raoul Bloch, tué le 12 mai 1916 devant Verdun, qui appartenait au monde des affaires.  Ses lettres, d’un ton ferme, respirent le plus salubre sentiment patriotique et familial.

Agé de quarante ans, affecté au service des étapes, il demande à passer dans l’active.  «J’attends impatiemment de faire mon devoir comme je le désire et le comprends; comme Français et Juif, je dois le faire doublement.  Il faut au pays en ce moment tous ses hommes valides pour la défense les armes à la main; — je suis dans un service qui peut se faire fort bien avec des hommes d’âge et moins ingambes, mon devoir est d’offrir mes services ailleurs…»

En date du 6 janvier 1915, il envoie à sa femme celte page toute pleine de la piété terrienne d’un Israélite alsacien :

Avec quelle joie je m’en irai du côté de l’Alsace et quels souvenirs en pénétrant en uniforme dans ce pays de nos rêves!  Nos pauvres papas en tressailleraient dans leurs tombes!  Enfin, la «revanche» dont ils ont tant parlé, dont leur cœur débordait! et mon brave frère, mon ancien sous la capote, et dans quels tragiques moments ! avec quel plaisir je le vengerai ainsi que Robert mon frère trop tôt disparu!  Quelle note à faire payer aux Bandits et combien je serai féroce créancier!

Dis-leur à tous, aux frères et sœurs, que jamais peut être nos cœurs n’ont tant vibré à l’unisson et n’ont communie d’une façon aussi intense.  Je pense souvent à tous ceux qui t’entourent en ce moment d’une affection si tendre et t’aident à supporter vaillamment la lourde contribution du pays que je t’ai imposée ainsi qu’a moimème.  Être de ceux qui auront contribué directement à te rendre ton berceau natal sera pour moi une bien douce joie et comme un complément à notre vie si unie et si tendre.  Quel bel anniversaire de nos vingt ans de ménage, la «rue de la Mésange» redevenue française ! quel plus beau cadeau pourrai-je rêver de t’apporter!  Et Lauterbourg, Niederbronn, Bionville, tout cela sous nos trois couleurs!  Tu dois comprendre pourquoi je voulais et devais partir, toute la tradition familiale n’est-elle pas avec moi?  Pouvoir emmener toi et nos chéris en AIsace-Lorraine et leur dire: Papa a aidé dans la mesure de ses forces à rendre ces deux beaux pays à la France, quelle plus belle récompense pour moi?

References and Suggested Readings

Barrès, Maurice, Les diverses familles spirituelles de la France, Paris, Émile-Paul frères, Paris, France, 1917, at Archive.org

Maurice Barrès, at Wikipedia

Maurice Barrès, at For and Against Dreyfus

Maurice Barrès, at Radical Right Analysis

Englund, Steven, An Affair As We Don’t Know It (Book Review of An Officer and A Spy, by Robert Harris), at Jewish Review of Books, Spring, 2015

Die Jüdischen Gefallenen Des Deutschen Heeres, Deutschen Marine Und Der Deutschen Schutztruppen 1914-1918 – Ein Gedenkbuch, Reichsbund Jüdischer Frontsoldaten, Forward by Dr. Leo Löwenstein, Berlin, Germany, 1932

Les Israelites dans l’Armée Française (Israelites [Jews] in the French Army), Angers, 1921 – Avant-Propos de la Deuxième Épreuve [Forward to the Second Edition], Albert Manuel, Paris, Juillet, 1921 – (Réédité par le Cercle de Généalogie juive [Reissued by the Circle for Jewish Genealogy], Paris, 2000)

“Died for France in the First World War” “PARTIE À REMPLIR PAR LE CORPS (‘PART TO BE COMPLETED BY THE CORPS’)” forms, at Morts pour la France de la Première Guerre mondiale

French Military War Graves, at Sépultures de Guerre

Mechon Mamre, at Mechon-Mamre.org