Major Milton Joel, eighty-one years later…

I recently received the following comment from Jim Rubin, concerning Major Milton Joel, commander of the 38th Fighter Squadron of the 55th Fighter Group until his death in combat over Holland with Me 109s of Jagdgeschwader 1 on November 29, 1943.  (Among the posts about Major Joel, see here and here in particular.)

Being that – for a reason presently unresolved! (&$#@^&* (!?!)) – comments to this blog are not displayed in my sidebar, I thought I’d share Jim’s comment by turning it into a post.  (Extraordinarily brief, by the standards of my blog!)  So, herewith:

Maj. Milton Joel was my cousin (my dad’s contemporary, although eight years Pop’s senior).  When Pop (now 96 y.o. and going strong) was in the U.S. Army of Occupation in Germany (1945-47), he spent a lot of time trying to track down cousin Milton’s remains, but was unsuccessful.  Cousin Milton called my Pop “Little Buddy” and Pop loved and revered him.  The Joels, Weinstein’s and the Rubin families were all heart broken over the loss of Milton.  By all accounts he was a warm, kind and witty man.

My reply: Thanks very much for your insightful and moving comment, Jim.  Trying to ascertain Major Joel’s fate was a noble effort on the part of your father, but given the time-frame – the immediate post-WW II years – such an endeavor would have been utterly daunting, and well-high impossible.  For one thing, MACRs (Missing Air Crew Reports) were not declassified until the 1980s, while then-relatively-recently captured German Luftgaukommando Reports were – I think? – in a transitional stage of custody among & between American and British Forces.  

In human terms, the only survivor among the P-38 pilots shot down on November 29, 1943 was 2 Lt. John J. Carroll, and the possibility of even identifying him – as a returned POW, in 1945, as a person to interview, as one would do in “our” world of the twenty-first century – would have been miniscule, due to confidentiality of military and other records, unless one previously had an “in” among and familiarity with 38th Fighter Squadron personnel.  

As I explained in my series of posts about Major Joel and the other 38th Fighter Pilots lost over eight decades ago in the late November sky over Holland, I believe that Major Joel was shot down over the Netherlands, within or very near the area between Hoogeveen and Zwartsluis, as denoted by the blue oval.  

I do not believe his “Flying Wolf” ever (ever) reached a point anywhere near the Ijsselmeer or North Sea. 

I base this conclusion on the description of the sequence of events encompassing the shooting down of Lieutenants Albert A. Albino and Carroll, and, the arrival of Captain Rufus R.C. Franklin and 2 Lt. James W. Gilbride (of the 343rd Fighter Squadron, which by then, after having gone into two Lufberry Circles, was heading back to Nuthampstead under the command of a pilot who shall remain anonymous…) over Meppel and Hoogeveen, after they broke from their squadron to come to the aid of Major Joel and Lt. Carroll. 

If this is so, certainly a central and entirely valid question is why the wreckage of 42-67020 was never found in this area of the Netherlands – which certainly has hardly been devoid of human habitation! – and reported upon by either the Germans, or, Dutch authorities.  To this I can offer no answer.  I can only suppose that like Lt. Albino’s Spirit of Aberdeen, Major Joel’s P-38H impacted so very deeply into the Dutch earth, perhaps unwitnessed in an uninhabited locale, as to have obliterated its point of impact, let alone the aircraft itself.  

On an unrelated note, I’ve often wondered about the eventual fate of Major Joel’s correspondence – letters and V-Mails – with his parents and family members, let alone documents of an official nature, such as his pilot’s log-book.  (His widow Elaine having destroyed their personal correspondence before she passed away many years ago.)  Alas, I suppose this invaluable material has been lost to the randomness of time.      

Anyway, thanks for remembering Major Joel, and thanks for your comment.

Here are two views of CG * A, Major Joel’s un-named “Flying Wolf”…

                                                                 

Here are my blog posts about Major Joel…

A Missing Man: Major Milton Joel, Fighter Pilot, 38th Fighter Squadron, 55th Fighter Group, 8th Air Force: I – A Fate Unknown

A Missing Man: Major Milton Joel, Fighter Pilot, 38th Fighter Squadron, 55th Fighter Group, 8th Air Force: II – From Proskurov to Richmond

A Missing Man: Major Milton Joel, Fighter Pilot, 38th Fighter Squadron, 55th Fighter Group, 8th Air Force: III – On Course [Revised post! … December 18, 2023]

A Missing Man: Major Milton Joel, Fighter Pilot, 38th Fighter Squadron, 55th Fighter Group, 8th Air Force: IV (1) – Autumn Over Europe

A Missing Man: Major Milton Joel, Fighter Pilot, 38th Fighter Squadron, 55th Fighter Group, 8th Air Force: IV (2) – Autumn Over Europe – The “Flying Wolf” Identified [Updated post…]

A Missing Man: Major Milton Joel, Fighter Pilot, 38th Fighter Squadron, 55th Fighter Group, 8th Air Force: V – A Monday in November: Major Joel’s Last Mission [Updated Post! – January 14, 2021]

A Missing Man: Major Milton Joel, Fighter Pilot, 38th Fighter Squadron, 55th Fighter Group, 8th Air Force: VI – The Missing Years

A Missing Man: Major Milton Joel, Fighter Pilot, 38th Fighter Squadron, 55th Fighter Group, 8th Air Force: VII – A Battle in The Air [Updated post! – January 14, 2021]

A Missing Man: Major Milton Joel, Fighter Pilot, 38th Fighter Squadron, 55th Fighter Group, 8th Air Force: VIII – A Postwar Search: The Missing of November [Updated Post! – January 14, 2021]

A Missing Man: Major Milton Joel, Fighter Pilot, 38th Fighter Squadron, 55th Fighter Group, 8th Air Force: IX – The Major, Still Missing  [Updated]

A Missing Man: Major Milton Joel, Fighter Pilot, 38th Fighter Squadron, 55th Fighter Group, 8th Air Force: X – Fragments of Memory

Next: Part XI – References  (No pictures, just lots of citations and links.)

And, these related posts…

The Names of Others: Jewish Military Casualties on November 29, 1943

An Echo of His Final Mission: 2 Lieutenant James M. Garvin, KIA November 29, 1943

 

A Missing Man: Major Milton Joel, Fighter Pilot, 38th Fighter Squadron, 55th Fighter Group, 8th Air Force: II – From Proskurov to Richmond [Updated Post! … Jan. 13, 2021 and December 18, 2023]

(Update II – December 18, 2023: This year, I received an interesting message from P-38 historian John Clements. Specifically: “I stumbled on your websites the other day doing a semi-regular troll for P-38 information on the web. I am working on a book on the P-38, trying to present the most accurate information possible. I was stunned when I came across the two photos of Milton Joel standing in front of a P-38D during the Carolina Maneuvers in the articles from 2020.  #96 has all of the characteristics of a YP-38, not a P-38D.  It could also be a straight P-38, but I have never seen any model of the early aircraft with a YP-38 style lower cowling.”

Upon receiving John’s message, I consulted Volume I of Bert Kinzey’s two-part series on the P-38 – specifically, the set of 1/72 line drawings of the YP-38 on pages 23 through 25 – and immediately verified John’s observation: In YP-38s, the oil cooler inlets are less circular than those of the D version, featuring a vertical double-divider in the center. This is entirely consistent with the appearance of the inlets of the aircraft behind Major Joel.  As related by John, “I haven’t found evidence of any kind that this style was on any other model. I’m including another photo of the YP that was used in wind tunnel tests in Virginia. It’s the best photo of the engine nacelle of the YP’s that I have found so far.”

Thanks, John!  More information and photos appear below…!)

(Update I – January 13, 2021: Originally created on November 12, 2020, this post has been updated to include three new images.  These comprise a portrait of Milton Joel standing before a Stearman PT-17, taken while be was in Primary pilot training, and, two images from the U.S. School Yearbook database at Ancestry.com.  The latter are specifically from the 1940 Yearbook for the University of Richmond, Milton Joel’s alma mater.  These two images comprise a group photo of the University of Richmond Aviation Club, and, Milton’s graduation portrait.  Scroll on down to take a look…)

 

________________________________________

Part II: From Proskurov to Richmond

Let’s start at a man’s beginning…

Milton Joel was born in Richmond, Virginia, on July 12, 1919, to Joseph and Minnie (Weinstein) Joel.  Characterized as a “change of life baby” due to his parents’ then relatively advanced ages (in the context of that era) of 38 and 32, respectively, he would be their only child. 

Joseph, described by Sara F, Markham (the best friend of Milton’s (eventual!) wife Elaine Ebenstein) as, “…a Judaica scholar and a homespun philosopher who was always writings letters to the Op-Ed page of our reactionary gazette, the Richmond Times-Dispatch,” owned and operated the Virginia Jewelry Store, following – to a minor extent – the footsteps of his own father, Salomon.

________________________________________

Fortunately; remarkably, Joseph’s literary and historical bent led him, towards the end of his life in 1960, to compose – with Myron Berman (then rabbi of Temple Beth-El in Richmond) – an essay covering his family’s genealogy and history.  This appeared in the July 1979, issue of The Virginia Magazine of History and Biography, under the title “My Recollections and Experiences of Richmond, Virginia, 1884-1892.” 

Though focused on his father, Joseph’s essay enables us to place Milton’s life in a deeper, multi-generational historical context.

The introduction to the essay (there’s far more to it!) follows below.  (References to the Ukrainian SSR should be understood in terms of the essay’s 1979 publication.)

THESE memoirs constitute a small portion of the autobiographical manuscripts written by Joseph Joel (1882-1960) near the end of his life.  They display a panorama of Jewish civilization at the turn of the century as well as the reflections of an East European immigrant upon life in Europe America.  The narrative, which focuses mainly upon the experiences Joseph Joel’s father, Salomon Czaczkes (Joel) (1853-1934), constitutes both the epitome and antithesis of an immigrant’s odyssey from Galicia in the Austro-Hungarian empire to America in the period immediately prior to World War I.  What is perhaps unique about Salomon Joel’s peregrinations is that unlike the majority of his East European compatriots whose transatlantic passages were paid by prosperous relatives from America, Salomon Joel and his family eventually returned to Europe on a prepaid ticket provided by the European branch of his family. (1)

Brought to these shores while yet an infant, Joseph Joel years later pieced together the poignant details of his parents’ migration from Proskurov, originally part of Poland but through annexation in the eighteenth century incorporated into the Russian empire. (2)   Because Salomon Joel had lived within the borders of Galicia, he was looked upon with suspicion by the Russian government.  With ten growing children to provide for, Salomon’s father earlier had decided to move from Tarnopol (3) to Podwoloczyska (4) as the railroad had been extended to that border outpost between Russia Austria-Hungary and afforded economic advantages for merchants dealing in agricultural products.

When his mother died, Salomon Joel was subject to the vagaries of his stepmother.  It was she who was responsible for his enrollment in a yeshiva or Jewish parochial school away from home and for his early marital alliance with a cousin of hers in Proskurov. (5)  Eventually he was himself the father of ten children, three of whom, including Joseph, were born in Europe.  The untenability of his legal status, the precarious nature of his livelihood, and, finally, the pull of a brother and a sister already residing in America were primary factors motivating the emigration of Salomon Joel with his family. (6)

Joel had a difficult time adjusting to the American economy.  Although he had been a grain merchant in Europe, he opened a jewelry store in Richmond, which proved a fiasco.  Never having learned the business, he was always dependent upon the services of trained technicians whom he had to employ.  Devoting himself more to communal pursuits than to his livelihood, Joel moved frequently within the city of Richmond and finally to Chicago to try his luck during the World’s Fair of 1893.  When economic conditions in the United States worsened shortly thereafter, Salomon Joel returned with his family to Podwoloczyska. 

In Europe, Joel was assisted by his stepbrother but never fared well.  He typified a large segment of immigrants who could not adjust to the American environment and to a certain extent may be categorized as Luftmenschen, trying to subsist on air.  Salomon Joel died in Europe, and tragically a large number of his family were later massacred by the Nazis. (7) 

Joseph Joel, however, returned to America in 1914 and, after a brief sojourn in Deming, New Mexico, became a jewelry merchant in Richmond.  More successful than his father, he wrote nostalgically about the good old days of strong religious and family ties, which contrasted rather starkly with the environment of the ‘fifties.  Joseph married Minnie Weinstein, the daughter of a Landtsmann or compatriot from Tarnopol, whose family’s voyage to America had been facilitated by Salomon Joel.  Their only son, Captain [sic] Milton Joel, was killed during World War II.  In later years, Joseph Joel, despite certain eccentricities, became a patriarch to his family. 

1) Joseph Czaczkes, a banker, Salomon Joel’s stepbrother, was the family’s benefactor.
2) Proskurov today is in the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic.  The population of the city was forty percent Jewish until World War II when it was occupied by the Germans.
3) Tarnopol, Galicia, today is called Ternopol and is in the Ukrainian SSR.
4) Podwoloczyska, Galicia, is called Podvolochisk and is in the Ukrainian SSR.
5) Salomon Josel first married Yetta Bernstein and upon her death, her sister Bertha.
6) The children of Salomon Joel were as follows:
Fannie (1873-1891), buried at the Sir Moses Montefiore Cemetery in Richmond
Moses (1877-1904), buried in Podwoloczyska
Yetta died in infancy and was buried in Podwoloczyska
Joseph (1882-1960), buried at Beth Ahabah’s Hebrew Cemetery in Richmond
Israel (1886-1930), buried in Wiener Neustadt
Esther (1980-ca.-1940), exterminated by the Nazis
Herman (1890-1965), buried at Sir Moses Montefiore Cemetery
Efraim (1893-1977), buried at Sir Moses Montefiore Cemetery
Mushke or Moses (1904-1930), buried at Sir Moses Montefiore Cemetery
Robert (1898 –      ), a resident of Miami
and Clara (1912 –      ), a physician in Baltimore
(7) Members of his family from America visited him just prior to his death in 1934.

________________________________________

But how did “Czaczkes” become “Joel”?

As noted elsewhere in the essay, Joseph’s, “…father [was] Salomon Czaczkes, who changed his name on arrival at Richmond, Va. to Salomon Joel.  This changing of name was due to the fact that there were few foreigners here and the people just couldn’t pronounce the “Cz” as “Ch” as in Chicken,” etc.”

________________________________________

A 1930s view of the Joel family home in Richmond. (c/o Harold Winston)

This Oogle Street View shows that the now-nearly-century-old residence (it was constructed in 1922) looks much the same today. 

Milton’s bar mitzvah portrait. (c/o Harold Winston)

Though I don’t know the date of his bar mitzvah, Milton’s birth on Saturday, July 12, 1919, may (may…) have correlated to a Bar Mitzvah date of July 18, 1932 (Tammuz 14, 5692).  If so, his Haftorah would have been Parshat Pinchas, concerning which there is a vast amount of commentary, such as these examples from…

The late Rabbi Jonathan Sacks (z”l)

Torah.org

My Jewish Learning

Wikipedia (well, inevitably Wikipedia!)

Chabad

Though, unsurprisingly, there’s little information about Milton’s childhood and adolescence, it is known that he graduated in 1936 from Thomas Jefferson High School in Richmond.  There, he was active in the school’s newspaper, aptly titled The Jeffersonian, as reported in Richmond Times-Dispatch article of February 16, 1936.


In the photo, Milton is among the group of students in the right-hand image, where he stands second from right in the second row.

Caption: “The staff of editors of The Jeffersonian, pictured above, includes those who served last term and their successors for editorial positions this term.  They are: Front row, left to right, Norman Robinson, Grant Morton, Adelaide Rose, Constance Strailmann, Watson James, Jr., and Thurman Day.  Second row, Shirley Sheain, Rosa Ellis, Mary Elizabeth Alvis, Ruth Keppel, James Harris, Milton Joel and Jane Obermeyer.  Back row, William Franch, Elizabeth Johnson, Charlotte Nance, Kathering Priddy, Robert Howard and Austin Gribb.”

________________________________________

Milton’s father Joseph, at the family home in the 1930s or 40s. (c/o Harold Winston)

________________________________________

Though the source of his aeronautical inspiration is unknown, Milton’s interest in flying was apparent by the time he attended the University of Richmond (he first attended the University of Virginia), his enrollment commencing in 1936.  There, he participated in a pilot training program sponsored by the CAA (Civil Aeronautics Authority; later the Civil Aeronautics Board), which was covered in the following three Richmond Times-Dispatch news items.

____________________

Students Are Taught to Use Parachutes – – – on the Ground

Richmond Times-Dispatch
December 19, 1939

University of Richmond flying students received their first instruction in parachute jumping yesterday, but, to the relief of many, the training was given on the ground.

Instructor J.H. Preissner pointed out the correct method of opening the ‘chute and delved into technical details for the benefit of the class of 17 students at Byrd Airport.

The group has been receiving the flight instruction, sponsored by the Civil Aeronautics Authority, since October 18, in two classes of two hours’ duration each week.  The course, consisting of 72 hours of class work, will be completed in June.

10 Are Active Pupils

Prior to the beginning of actual flying instruction 10 days ago, the students were taught civil air regulations and aerodynamics.  Ten member of the class are active pupils while the others are alternates.

Examinations will be given by the Federal Government.  The training is being given the students by the Government at approximately one-tenth what would be charged at private fields in order to raise the number of civilian pilots in the United States.

The students are in no way obligated to the Government, however, it was pointed out.  In all probability an advanced course will be given next year.

Caption: COLLEGE PUPILS STUDY ‘CHUTES – University of Richmond students who are taking a flying course under the Civil Aeronautics Authority, got their first instructions yesterday in taking to the air via a parachute.  Members of the class are shown above with Instructor J.H. Preissner.  Left to right, are Milton Joel, Parke Starke, Harvey Chapman, Ernest Taylor, Clyde Ford, Donald Murrill, Mr. Preissner, Samuel George, Thomas Bruno and Tom Wiley.

____________________

In this Richmond Times-Dispatch news article of February 28, 1940, covering CAA pilot training of University of Richmond Students, Milton stands at the far right.  (c/o Congregation Beth Ahabah Archives)

A nearly similar image – below – appeared in the University of Richmond 1940 yearbook, which specifies that the fourteen men in the photo are actually members or associates of the University of Richmond Aviation Club. 

A close inspection reveals that these are actually two different photographs, albeit taken by the same photographer: S.L. Baird.  The giveaway?  While the men are standing in the same relative locations in the pictures, there are minor differences in their poses and facial expressions.  

The aircraft is a Rearwin Cloudster, a, “…two or three-seat civil utility aircraft produced by the Rearwin Aircraft & Engines Company of Kansas City, Missouri beginning in 1939.  It was a strut-braced, high-wing monoplane of conventional design with an enclosed cabin and fixed, taildragger undercarriage.”  You can view a restored Cloudster in this 2010 video narrated by owner Ed McKeown, from the Aero-News Network. 

____________________

This photo published (I think?) in the Richmond Times-Dispatch on July 7, 1940 illustrates CAA student pilots.  With hands on the controls – I think this is a Cloudster – Milton sits adjacent to the aircraft’s entry door. (c/o Congregation Beth Ahabah Archives)

________________________________________

Milton’s graduation portrait.

________________________________________

After his university graduation, Milton pursued flying in a military vein:  Here is notification received by his parents concerning his enlistment in the Regular Army on October 12, 1940, and, his departure for the Alabama Institute of Aeronautics at Tuscaloosa.  (c/o Congregation Beth Ahabah Archives)

The following three images show the Alabama Institute of Aeronautics as it appeared in the 1940s. 

This photo shows classrooms, dormitories, a hangar, and numerous (Boeing Stearman?) biplanes.

A barracks room.  Simple and spartan, but it does the job.

Flying cadets return from training. 

From the Archives of Congregation Beth Ahabah in Richmond, Virginia, this image shows Milton Joel standing before a Stearman PT-17, presumably at Tuscaloosa. 

Very (very!) close examination of the photograph (it’s actually a paper photocopy, thus accounting for its graininess and low resolution) reveals that the Stearman’s serial number is 40-1841.  According to the Aviation Archeology database, this aircraft was involved in a landing accident at Albany Field, Georgia, on October 29, 1941, while piloted by Donald P. Chapman.

The date of the photograph is unknown, but from crispness of shadows and bright illumination, it was certainly a very sunny day.

________________________________________

Having completed his Basic Flying School at Gunter Field, Alabama, in March of 1941, Milton next attended Advanced Flying School at Maxwell Field, Alabama, from which he graduated the following May.  Along with six other Aviation Cadets from Virginia, Milton appeared in this Richmond Times-Dispatch photograph on April 27, 1941.  Here, the seven cadets and flight instructor Lieutenant Neener stand before a North American AT-6 Texan advanced trainer.

Caption: YOUNG PILOTS TRAIN – Seven Virginians are shown here checking final flight plans with Lieutenant E.H. Neener at Maxwelll Field, Ala., where they are in training.  They are (left to right) Cadets Glassel Stringfellow of Culpepper, Charles R. Mallory Jr. of Richmond, Milton Joel of Richmond, Lieutenant Neener, Cadets George L.J. Newton of Powhatan County, Roy L. Reeve of Arlington, R.L. Tribble of South Boston and Thomas Campbell of Franklin.  The cadets will graduate next month with more than 200 hours’ air training at the Advanced Flying Field.  They will be commissioned second lieutenants and sent on extended active duty with regular Air Corps units. 

________________________________________

A review of National Archives Records covering Honor Rolls of WW II Army Dead (via the National WW II Memorial website) reveals that all the above (then) Cadets, as well as Lt. Neener, survived the war.  Milton was the only member of this group who did not return.

________________________________________

This news item of May 2, 1941 from “The Richmond Daybook” section of the Richmond Times-Dispatch, reports on Milton’s final stages of Advanced Flying Training at Maxwell Field, Alabama.

FLYING Cadet Milton Joel, son of Mr. and Mrs. Joseph Joel of Greenway Lane, Richmond, has begun the final phases of his flying training at the Air Corps Advanced Flying School, Maxwell Field, Montgomery, Ala.  On May 29 he will be graduated into the status of second lieutenant, Air Corps Reserve, receive military aeronautical status of “pilot” and be assigned to extended duty training with a regular squadron for a period of one year.  Cadet Joel finished his basic training at Gunter Field, Montgomery, last March.

________________________________________

This photographic portrait of Milton as a Flying Cadet, from the United States National Archives’ collection “Photographic Prints of Air Cadets and Officers, Air Crew, and Notables in the History of Aviation”, in NARA Records Group 18-PU.  Notation on the photo (not visible in this image) states “Graduated 5/29/41”.  This image is only one of the collection’s many thousands of portraits and related photos, which – spanning the very late 1930s through approximately 1944 and having heaviest coverage from 1941 through 1943 – includes a small number of photos from WW I and the twenties, and, a few pictures of foreign aviators from the 20s and 30s.  You can read much more about the this collection in Five Pilots in December (which displays images of the five Army Air Corps fighter pilots who lost their lives during the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor), at my brother blog, ThePastPresented.  (Milton’s portrait, serial number “P-8000”, is located in Box 47 of RG 18 PU’s 105 archival storage boxes.) 

On May 30, 1941, Milton’s high-school newspaper the Jeffersonian reported his graduation from Maxwell Field.

Flying Cadet Milton Joel ’36, who was business manager at the Jeffersonian in 1935-36, was graduated into the status of second lieutenant, Air Corps Reserve, at the Air Corps Advanced Flying School, Maxwell Field, Montgomery, Ala., yesterday.  He also received the military aeronautical status of “pilot” and was assigned to extended active duty training with a regular squadron for a year. 

A little over a month later, on July 21, the Times-Dispatch reported Milton’s assignment to the 27th Pursuit Squadron of the 1st Pursuit Group, then at Selfridge Army Airfield, Michigan.

Richmond Aviator Goes to Michigan

SELFRIDGE FIELD, Mich., July 21 – Milton Joel, son of Mr. and Mrs. Joseph Joel, Greenway Lane, Richmond, and recent graduate of the Air Corps Flying School, Maxwell Field, Ala., has been assigned as a second lieutenant with the World War famous First Pursuit Group at Selfridge Field, and has taken over his flying duties with the Twenty-Seventh Pursuit Squadron, Major Robert S. Israel, Jr., commanding officer of the “P-38” Fighter Group, revealed today.

Joel, who has attended both the University of Virginia and the University of Richmond, is required to accomplish a minimum of fifty hours’ flying monthly.
Beside the regular aerial flights, Joel must undergo intensive ground flying.  Key to the paradox is the Link trainer, an ingenious and complex device which makes it possible to simulate the conditions of blind flying.

In November of 1941, Milton’s assignment to the 27th Pursuit Squadron involved participation in the Army’s Carolina Maneuvers, with the 1st Pursuit Group (a component of the 6th Fighter Wing) taking part in all four Maneuver phases: Louisiana Phases 1 and 2, and Carolina phases 1 and 2, from September 15 through 27, and November 16 through 27, respectively. 

These two images show Milton standing before a P-38D YP-38 Lightning bearing aircraft-in-squadron number “96”.  The aircraft carries temporary (water-based-paint) Maneuver markings, consisting of a red cross upon its nose, and, (rather fading) white paint on the bottom of its gondola and wings.  (c/o Sarah F. Markham)

In this image, the crest of the 1st Fighter Group is visible on Milton’s service cap, while the Army Air Corp’s pre-war “triple-pinwheel” orange and blue emblem is visible on his left shoulder. (c/o Sara F. Markham)

Here’s an example of the pre-war art-deco-ish shoulder Army Air Force patch, worn from July 20, 1937, through March 19, 1942, when it was replaced by the more well-known winged star. 

Continuing with John Clements’ identification of this plane as a YP-38, here the list of all YP-38s – but one – compiled by Joe Baugher:

MSN 122-2202/2214.  Model 122-62-02 service test aircraft.

689 crashed during high-speed dive Nov 4, 1941 over Glendale, CA, killing test pilot Ralph Virden.
690 assigned to NACA Langley Memorial Aeronautical Laboratory, Virginia Nov 27, 1941 to Feb 4, 1942. To Parks Air College, St Louis, MO Feb 26, 1942.
691 assigned to NACA Langley Memorial Aeronautical Laboratory, Virginia  Nov 27, 1941. Scrapped at Sacramento Air Depot Dec 17, 1945.
692 scrapped at Lowry Field, Denver, CO Jul 5, 1945.
693 relegated to class CL-26 maintenance trainer at Chanute, AK Jul 24, 1942.
694 relegated to class CL-26 maintenance trainer Jan 5, 1943, Granite Falls, WA.
695 w/o Jul 23, 1941, Alpena, MI.?
697 used as class CL-26 maintenance trainer Jan 5, 1943 at Lockheed
698 scrapped Mar 20, 1946 San Bernardino, CA.
699 crashed Jun 23, 1941, Atlanta, MI.  Pilot Lt Guy Leland Putnam killed.
700 relegated to class CL-26 maintenance trainer Jan 27, 1943 at Brookley Field, Mobile, AL.
701 relegated to class CL-26 maintenance trainer Jan 5, 1943 at Lockheed

On discussing the above list, John noted that aircraft “696” is missing.  Being that the plane-in-squadron (tail) number of Major Joel’s plane is “96” (as seen in the photo on page 81 of Dana Bell’s Air Force Colors), John suggests that the plane could be the absent “696”, or specifically, “39-696”.  Makes sense to me!

The photo below, provided by John, is of, “…the YP that was used in wind tunnel tests in Virginia.  It’s the best photo of the engine nacelle of the YP’s that I have found so far.”  The front of the nacelle is identical to that of Major Joel’s plane.

Interestingly, Bert Kinzey’s book states that for YP-38, “Armament was to be two .50-caliber machine guns, two .30-caliber machine guns, and a single 37-mm cannon.  However, this was not fitted, and the gun ports were faired over.”  In that context, perhaps 696’s armament of two machine guns, the muzzles of which are covered with streamlined cylindrical fairings, represents a modification carried out after the plane was assigned to the 1st Fighter Group.

The specific P-38D YP-38 serving as a backdrop to Major Joel can be seen (a very tiny portion of it can be seen) in Army Air Corps Photo “A 20599AC / 342-3B-41009”, dated November 3, 1941:  The number on its port fin and rudder is visible immediately to the left of the port fin and rudder of P-38 “67”, the latter in the right center of the image.  This picture can be found on page 81 of Dana Bell’s Air Force Colors, Vol. I.

Another photo provided by John: 1st Fighter Group P-38s – #54 and #51 – at the Carolina Maneuvers.

From Air Force Colors, Vol. I, here’s an illustration of a P-38D in “red force” markings:

________________________________________

Two images of Milton in the United States.  Date unknown; location unknown.

(c/o Ida Joel Kaplan)

(c/o Harold Winston)

________________________________________

While assigned to the 27th Fighter Squadron, Milton was promoted to 1st Lieutenant in February or March of 1942, and then Captain in June.  It was at the latter rank that on October 3, 1942, he took command of the 38th Fighter Squadron at Paine Field, Washington.  This photo, showing Milton wearing a flight jacket with the insignia of the 27th Fighter Squadron, can therefore be dated as having been taken before that date.  (c/o Harold Winston)

________________________________________

The circumstances – random luck? – a mutual acquaintance? – by which Milton and his future wife, Elaine Ebenstein of Beverly Hills, California, met one another, are unknown.  However, most definitely known is that they were married at Paine Field in June of 1943, as reported in the Richmond Times-Disptach on June 25, of that year.

Miss Ebenstein Will Marry Major Milton Joel, USAAF

Mr. and Mrs. Herbert R. Ebenstein, of New York and Beverley Hills, Calif., announce the engagement of their daughter, Elaine, to Major Milton Joel, United States Army Air Force, son of Mr. and Mrs. Joseph Joel, of Richmond.

The wedding will take place June 29 [Tuesday] at Paine Field, Everette, Wash.
The groom is a graduate of the University of Richmond in the class of 1940.

Characterized by her friend Sarah Markham as “tall, thin, and regal”, here is Elaine’s portrait. (c/o Harold Winston)…

…and, here’s a view of Minnie, Joseph, and their beaming daughter-in-law in Richmond.  (c/o Ida Joel Kaplan)

Next: Part III – On Course

1,507 – November 12, 2020

A Missing Man: Major Milton Joel, Fighter Pilot, 38th Fighter Squadron, 55th Fighter Group, 8th Air Force: III – On Course [Revised post! … December 18, 2023]

[Update: Created in November of 2020, this post has been updated to reflect information provided by Andrew Garcia, pertaining to the P-38 that serves as a backdrop for the image of Major Joel and Capt. Joseph Myers, Jr.  The picture can be seen towards the (very) bottom of the post.]

Part III: On Course

Now in command of the 38th Fighter Squadron, Milton’s promotion to Major was announced in the Richmond Times-Dispatch, on February 2, 1943. 

MAJOR AT 23 – Milton Joel (above) son of Mr. and Mrs. Joseph Joel, 5 Greenway Lane, is believed to be one of the army’s youngest majors.  He completed his civilian pilot’s course at the University of Richmond in 1939 after attending the University of Virginia.  He later trained at Tuscaloosa Field, Ala.  He was commissioned a second lieutenant in May, 1941, promoted to first lieutenant in February, 1942, and a captain in June.  He is now commanding officer of a fighter squadron at Pendleton Field, Ore.

Flying-battle-axe emblem of the 38th Fighter Squadron, digital…

…and physical, as a patch, available from EBay seller EZ.Collect.  (Not a “plug” – I simply found this image via duckduckgo!)

________________________________________

Three and a half months after taking command of the 38th Fighter Squadron, on February 19, 1943, Milton and several of his squadron’s pilots gathered for this group photograph, under what seems (?) to have been an overcast sky.

Interestingly, at least four pilots in the rear row (thus all perhaps in the rear row?) were members of the 27th Fighter Squadron (Milton’s former squadron) and attained aerial victories in the Mediterranean Theater.

Though this image is present in the squadron’s historical records (specifically, in AFHRA Microfilm Roll AO 136) inquiries to the National Archives revealed that it’s absent from the WW II U.S. Army Air Force Photo Collection.  Thus, it seems to have remained at squadron level, never having been bureaucratically passed “upwards” to any higher organizational level.

From a technical point of view, the photograph clearly illustrates the counter-rotating propellers used in all P-38 Lightnings commencing with the XP-38, with the exception of 22 of the 143 P-38s which had been ordered by the Royal Air Force as Lightning Mark 1s.  As such, viewed from the “front”, it can be seen that the propellers rotate outwards, away from the aircraft’s central gondola and toward the wings.  

Another point: It appears that the aircraft’s nose has been painted, perhaps as a form of squadron identification. 

The text on the photograph states…

“(G868A – 22M – 33AB) (2-19-43) FLYING OFFICERS, 38TH FIGHTER SQUADRON, PN FLD, WN. (RES)”

…while the back of the image bears the notation…

Restricted Photograph

Do not use without permission U.S. Army Air Force

Air Base

Photo Laboratory

…and includes the pilots’ surnames – and their surnames only.  However, this clue enables identification of most of these men.  They are:

Front row, left to right (All members of the 38th Fighter Squadron)

Wyche, Wilton E., 0-729407
Ayers, Jerry H., 0-659441
Leinweber, Gerald F., 0-659473
Joel, Milton, 0-416308  (KIA 11/29/43 – MACR 1429 – P-38H 42-67020; No Luftgaukommando Report)
Hancock, James H., 0-659122
“Meyer” (Myers?), Joseph, Jr., 0-659166
Leve, Morris, 0-791127 (KIA 1/31/44 – MACR 2110 – P-38J 42-67768; Luftgaukommando Report AV 641/44)

Rear row, left to right (The four identified men were members of the 27th Fighter Squadron)

Ellerbee
Conn, David M., 0-732171
Meikle, James B.
Connors
Dickie
Crane, Edwin R., 0-728980
McIntosh, Robert L., 0-802054
Harris
Smoot
Hammond
Purvis

Here’s another 38th Fighter Squadron photo, from Robert M. Littlefield’s Double Nickel, Double Trouble.  Taken on June 4, 1943 at McChord Field, Washington, these seven men comprise the original squadron commanders of the 38th Fighter Squadron, and, the four officers heading the 55th Fighter Group.  Akin to the preceding photograph, an inquiry to NARA revealed that this photograph is absent from the WW II U.S. Army Air Force Photo Collection.  Also paralleling the above photo, this P-38’s nose (the plane is a P-38G-15) has been painted – probably – in white or yellow, and bears a (plane-in-squadron?) identification number.  Unusually for a stateside warplane, this aircraft bears nose art.  This takes the form of Walt Disney’s “Thumper” holding a machine gun, and the appropos nickname “WABBIT”.  (Albeit no relation to Elmer Fudd…)

The men are…

…left to right:

Major Richard W. (“R. Dick”) Busching, 0-427516, Commanding Officer of the 338th Fighter Squadron
Major Milton Joel, 0-416308, Commanding Officer of the 38th Fighter Squadron
Wendell Kelly, Group Operations Officer
Colonel Frank A. James, Commanding Officer of the 55th Fighter Group
Lt. Colonel Jack S. Jenkins, 0-22606, Group Executive Officer
George Crowell, Group Operation Officer
Major Dallas W. (“Spider”) Webb, Commanding Officer of the 343rd Fighter Squadron

________________________________________

This third image, from the collection of 38th Fighter Squadron pilot (and only survivor among the four 38th Fighter Squadron pilots shot down on November 29, 1943 – but we’ll get to that in a subsequent post) John J. Carroll, was taken on July 20, 1943.  From The American Air Museum in Britain (image UPL 40377) the photo shows the original members of the 38th Fighter Squadron sent to England in late summer of 1943.  (This picture also appears in Double Nickel, Double Trouble.)

Paralleling the above pictures, this photograph is absent from the WW II U.S. Army Air Force Photo Collection.  The text on the image as published in Double Nickel, Double Trouble (but not visible on this web image) states:

“(G1067 – 22M – 33AB) (7-20-43) FLYING OFFICERS, 38TH FTR. SQDN. (RES)”

The men are:

Front, left to right

Shipman, Mark K., 0-431166
Wyche, Wilton E., 0-729407
Ayers, Jerry H., 0-659441
“Meyers” (Myers?), Joseph, Jr., 0-659166
Joel, Milton, 0-416308 (KIA 11/29/43 – MACR 1429 – P-38H 42-67020; No Luftgaukommando Report)
Meyer, Robert J.
Leinweber, Gerald F., 0-659473
Hancock, James H., 0-659122
Unknown

Rear, left to right

Albino, Albert A., 0-743330 (KIA 11/29/43 – MACR 1428 – P-38H 42-67051; Luftgaukommando Report J 307?)
Fisher, D., (“David D.”), (T-1046) (KIA 1/31/44 – MACR 2106 – P-38J 42-67757; Luftgaukommando Report Unknown)
Brown, Gerald, 0-740139
Unknown
Kreft, Willard L., 0-740219
Erickson, Wilton G., 0-748934 (KIA 12/1/43 – MACR 1430 – P-38H 42-67033; Luftgaukommando Report Unknown)
Erickson, Robert E., 0-743324
Gillette, Hugh E., 2 Lt., 0-740169 (KIA 10/18/43 – MACR 1040 – P-38H 42-66719; No Luftgaukommando Report)
Steiner, Delorn L., 0-740297 (KIA 1/31/44 – MACR 2105 – P-38J 42-67711; Luftgaukommando Report Unknown)
Fisher, (Paul, Jr.), (0-740149)
Peters, Edward F., 0-746168
Peters, Allen R., 0-743368
Carroll, John J., 0-743313 (POW 11/29/43 – MACR 1431 – P-38H 42-67090; Luftgaukommando Report Unknown)
Unknown
Garvin, James M., 0-740164 (KIA 11/29/43 – MACR 1427 – P-38H 42-67046; Luftgaukommando Reports J 338 and AV 513 / 44)
Forsblad, Richard W., 0-740153
Des Voignes, Clair W., 0-743425 (KIA 7/13/44 – MACR 6709, 6717 – P-38J 42-28279; Luftgaukommando Report J 1635)

________________________________________

The 55th Fighter Group departed McChord Field, Washington, for England on 23 August 1943.  The Group reached Camp Kilmer, New Jersey, on August 27, remaining there until September 4, when the Group boarded the H.M.T. Orion (a 24,000 ton ocean liner launched in 1934) in New York Harbor, the burned-out wreck of the SS Normandie – renamed the USS Lafayette – visible nearby.  The Orion departed the next day, reaching its English base at Nuthampstead on September 14.  Milton’s diary verifies these dates and locations.

In this image (U.S. Navy National Museum of Naval Aviation photo No. 2009.006.096) a Coast Guard J4F Widgeon flies near the wreckage of the Lafayette, with the Empire State Building faintly visible in the distance.  This area is probably the location of the Orion’s departure for England.  

________________________________________

During this hectic interval, Milton kept a diary covering the 18-day trans-Atlantic journey, in which he recorded observations and impressions of people, places, and events, noting the controlled chaos associated with the rapid movement of his squadron and group to a foreign shores.  Specifically mentioned (albeit not including first names!) are pilots Willard L. Kreft, Gerald F. Leinweber, Mark K. Shipman, Albert A. Albino, Colonel Frank A. James, and ground officers Octavian R. Tuckerman (Ordnance), and Arthur S. Weinberger (Personnel). 

The first two pages of Milton’s diary are shown below, followed by a transcript of all diary entries.  Milton’s penmanship was not (!) the best, so the text includes some “gaps” (thus [“_____”]).  But, enough of his writing is legible such that the sequence of events, his impressions of people (one observation of human behavior is quite frank by the standards of the 1940s) and sense of activity emerge from the document’s pages, as do his pride in his squadron. 

Aug 23-1943 En Route Paine Field to NY P of E

This first entry in the daily record of events and sidelights of my participation in the action toward victory is made with the hope that it will not suffer the ignominity of becoming merely another bit of evidence of slovenly performance & tasks undertaken.  At 08:30 AM left Mukilteo Washington in command of the 38th Fighter Squadron.  Everyone eager and straining at the bit just as I am.  Feel sure we can do a good job of it since I know we are better in a hundred ways than any outfit that has previously left the cont. for foreign duty both in efficiency and spirit.  Wish Elaine could have been there to see us off but that would have been an anticlimax.  Then too make it a first not to see her after the men were placed incommunicado.  What’s good enough for them is good enough for me. 

Aug 24 ’43

Trip so far completely uneventful, train shakes so cannot write. 

Aug 25th ’43 No change.  All serene. 

All the men really on the ball – violent bridge game constantly in progress involving _____ _____ [Willard L.] Kreft & [Gerald F.] Leinweber.  They have screamed themselves hoarse.  Particularly Leinweber now sounds like a fog horn.  Sporadic poker games continue on.  [Mark K.] Shipman is like a kid just bubbles over with enthusiasm.  He wrangled a ride on the engine & stayed there some four or five hours.

Aug 26th Everyone thoroughly encrusted in soot. 

We look like miners not soldiers.  [Albert A.] Albino & his _____ _____ _____ _____.  Shipman worried about poker games _____ as though we should see that pilots learn to take care of their money.  Losses haven’t been heavy.  _____ (_____) & I talk him out of it.  Is indignant when we try to explain that paternalism should not be carried that far.  Am proud as pink over the conduct & appearance of the outfit at exercise time at stop by the wayside.  Even though they are grimy they are sharp.  Leinweber spends waking hour looking for a spoon from his mess kit – 200 pounds of almost _____ _____. 

Aug 27th Camp Kilmer, N.J.

– arrived here at 08:05 from then on it was nit & tuck – nip a breath & tuck it away to last for an hour or two when you may or may not be able to catch another.  Was met at the station with everything but the brass band. 
I.F. a billeting officer, a supply officer, a medical man, a rail transportation man & truck transport man and two or three others for good measure.  We whisked the men off the train & marched them off to their barracks.  I stayed behind with _____ (Exec. Off) & went through the train with a rail officer & train Rep. & a Pullman Rep. to check for damage.  There was none.  Dashed madly to new quarters while the rain started to pour.  Have a piece of paper shoved at me telling me that I and the whole staff report at 9:00 AM for instruction –  Do not have time to even wash off the weeks soot & grime or change clothes. 

We report, Larry (_____) S-2, _____ S-1, Shipman S-3 & _____ S-4 & I _____ _____ officer _____ who gives us 2 hours instruction & a thousand sheets of paper (S.O.P. – Standard Operating Procedures). 

We receive a schedule for the day which is a killer.  Return to barracks Four & officers are just settling down.  Tuckerman & Weinberger have just returned with the baggage detail & the baggage and it is all stowed away in our building –  Rush away to lunch.  Return & going to quit as too tired to continue. 

Sept 1 Have decided that war is hell. 

If the battling will be as rough as the getting to it.  We’ve had at least 6 countermanding orders on our load list, we pack them then unpack.  Then pack.  Then unpack.  That’s the way it goes.  Everyone is beginning to get thoroughly disgusted but that’s the way they said it would be. 

This camp is tremendous place thousands & 10’s of thousands of men pour through here each week.  They are practically re-equipped.  It’s amazing really.  We had a meeting today and there were at least 300 unit commanders and adjutants.  This is going to be a tremendous deal, but big rumors are rampant.  Morale however is getting very low.  Pilots like a bunch of race horses.  They’re tense & at each others throats practically.  Mainly due to hanging around with nothing to do & hangovers, everyone having gone to New York last night & night before.  I went in.  Had a big lobster dinner & a fried chicken but was too tired to stay late. 

Sept 14 Haven’t had a moment to do more than write a few words to Elaine. 

Left Camp Kilmer on the 4th in the morning for Embarkation.  Our B-4 bags & packs were so damned heavy don’t know how we made it.  Rode the train to ferry & thence off the harbor to the pier and boarded H.M.T. Orion.  Saw the Normandie still lying serenely on her side like some tired old man refusing to get up & go to work.  As soon as all the men were aboard I managed to drag my raincoat, briefcase, blanket roll, mussette bag, gas mask, pistol, web belt and canteen aboard half carrying & half falling over my B-4 bag to my stateroom.   This was pleasantly surprised by a Staff Sergeant Symanoff who brought me four letters from Elaine.  She had a hunch – the _____ _____ _____ that I would come to New York and had contacted Gene Symanoff who worked in the port.  That was to prove the greatest treat to date aboard this tub. 

No sooner did I get on board ship then was I summoned to Col. James’ [Frank James] room – where I found a great stir & dither.  I was informed that I was to be Deck Commander of “E” Deck, which at this time didn’t seem so bad.  Was soon to find out just what a rough deal it really turned out to be.  Col. James was the senior line officer slated to come aboard and was then made troop commander.  We were informed that there had never previously been American troops board ship and in addition there were 2000 more of them than the British had ever conceived of placing aboard.  I.E. We had 7000 troops placed helter skelter on the ship and no one with us had ever had any experience of either handling troops aboard ship or _____ _____ any permanent _____.  Men had been loaded helter skelter like sardines thrown into the can and then lid forced down.  There were not even any set instructions orders or the like.  This looks like the goddamnedest mess the brass hats could dream up & was.  Went below & found my deck was “double loaded” I.E. 1500 men eat & sleep below deck & 1500 sleep & two above on another deck for 24 hours.  All eat below in double shifts of 2 sittings each man shifting the _____ _____ for each of the 2 meals and again in the middle of the day.  At night there wasn’t room either below or above to move an inch without stepping on someone’s face 1/2 _____ staying below slept on mattresses on the floor and tables the other half in hammocks.  Those above decks slept on blankets on hard decks rain or shine – oh rough –  To add to it all compartments on all decks had to pass through my deck to go to & from the galley also the twice daily canteen details also went through all the latrines for EMs aboard ship were also located _____.  At meal times shift it looked like 42nd & Broadway on New Year’s Eve.  How we ever got any organization is still a mystery to me.

To add to it all men consisted of the raunchiest crew I had ever seen.  A larger proportion was criminals most of whom had 2 to 3 court martials against them some of whom even brought on board by armed guard.  It was utter chaos.  For first 3 days there was utter chaos and it took some days to eliminate the confusion.  Many groups had one unexperienced 2nd Lt. in command who had just picked them up the day before.  There was a group of 80 officers all _____ aboard who much like the men here were as motley as Joseph’s Coat and had an equivalent record.  We found the total officers straight aboard to be 700 including eighty very recently commissioned and very eager nurses.  These turned out to be as big a problem the 2nd Lts went after them like hound-dogs after a bitch in heat.  I believe most of these girls were actually in heat because it seemed they were very cooperative.  Ended up by picking a staff from the staff of the squadron & assigning each squadron officer a job with the men.  Had about 150 officers assigned me and to other deck commander and took them down into Compartment Commanders and watch officers so that officer would be with the men 24 hours a day. 

Morale for the first four days was the lowest I’ve ever seen it.  The confusion was unimaginable.  At meal time the corridor looked like 42nd & Broadway on New Year Eve.  Only thing that made it satisfactory were boat drills weren’t always went over in first order.

There is a Moving Picture version of a British Colonel aboard as permanent Liaison Officer.  Had been troop C.O. for two years aboard same ship.  Knows every knook and cranny.  Knows every argument that comes up with ships company before it comes up.  Without his help this tub would have sunk in this chaos.  He is one of the shrewdest men I have ever met & just as humorous.  Whenever an argument in Staff Meeting is going the wrong way he can draw a red herring through the conversation so fast that it makes your head swim or tell some fantastic typical statement.  “Ships officers are dead from 2 PM til’ four.  If you attempted to wake one up the ruddy funnel will fall off.” 

Took about seven days to get things afoot so that trip became very pleasant U.S.O. shows helped immensely.  Billy Gilbert the Hollywood _____ artist is aboard with a troop and his shows have done wonders for morale.  After the first three days the men’s spirits raised and remained amazingly high considering the hardships of sleeping in stinking holds & open but cold decks.

No excitement yet other than an incident the seventh night out.  A Swedish ship blasted through the entire convoy at perpendicular courses & all ships had to make a sweeping torn to avoid her she was completely lighted & must have completely silhouetted us also made sub contact at the same time & depth charges were dropped well over the place which sit up a “ruddy din”.

About 1/3 of the men were thoroughly sick the second & third day out when it got fairly rough out water has been like a mild pond ever since.

Units were so spilt up _____ Lord knows how we will debark them.  Tuckerman has been made garbage disposal officer and has taken a hell of a beating.  Trash & garbage has to be disposed of only at a _____ _____ prior to black out to prevent causing a trail so it’s a hell of a job.  Carroll is official announcer on P.A. system and as _____ that an official ____ for everyone aboard when he announces _____ time.  Typical crack “Dumping time tonight will be at _ _ o’clock.  Stick out your cans for the scrounger man.  Tuckerman the garbage man.” 

Cards & crap games fill every deck & latrine.  Officers and men at it 24 hours a day.  One EM cleared $ 1300 one day.  Some even have set up boards with numbers on them carnival fashion & have this game in the canteen. 

________________________________________

The 55th Fighter Group, the first P-38 equipped 8th Air Force Fighter Group to enter combat with the Luftwaffe, moved to Wormingford, England, on April 16, 1944.

________________________________________

During the 55th’s movement to England Milton managed to send a single V-Mail letter to his parents in Richmond, in which he commented on the hectic nature of the Group’s inter-continental journey, a sea-food dinner in Manhattan, and expressed pride in his wife, Elaine. 

In light of Milton’s then as-yet-unknown future, the letter closes with the unintentionally (or not?…) prophetic statement, “It will probably be some time until you hear from me again so don’t worry.  This is my real opportunity.  Think of it in that light.  I’m really on my way home in a way that this is what I had to get under my belt before I could do that.” 

Mr. and Mrs. Joseph Joel
1119 Hull Street
Richmond, 21, Va.

Milton Joel, Major AC
38 Fighter Sq 55th Fighter Group
APO #4833 c/o Postmaster New York
Sept. 3, 1943

Dear Folks,

Have been here “somewhere” in New Jersey.  Have never had such an exasperating or busy few days in my life.  It’s just like recruit camp all over again.  Quite an experience.  We’ve been held incommunicado so didn’t have time to call anyone in N.Y.  Managed to get in one evening long enough for a lobster and a drink.  Wonderful to eat Eastern sea food again.

Elaine is in L.A.  Got a letter from her yesterday.  She’s done a swell job of taking care of our affairs and getting home.  Her attitude about this whole thing, I tried to give you a hint about two weeks ago but you couldn’t catch on evidently.

Did Elaine send you some pictures that we took?  I’m proud of them particularly the ones taken in the house.  Got a swell letter from Elaine’s father.  Our two weeks of living together you know showed Elaine to be every thing that I thought her to be plus a great deal.

It will probably be some time until you hear from me again so don’t worry.  This is my real opportunity.  Think of it in that light.  I’m really on my way home in a way that this is what I had to get under my belt before I could do that.  Don’t send any thing until I ask for it.  Use “V” mail.

Love to all
Milton

________________________________________

This Oogle map below shows the location of Nuthampstead (indicated by Oogle’s emblematic red pointer) in relation to London. 

This British Government Royal Ordnance Survey aerial photo shows Nuthampstead Airfield as it appeared on July 9, 1946.  Annotations on the photo are from Roger Freeman’s 1978 Airfields Of The Eighth, Then And Now.  The original image has been photoshopifically “rotated” from its original orientation such that the north arrow points “up”.  As such, the orientation of the airfield is congruent with the area as seen in the contemporary Oogle Earth photo, below.

Here’s a contemporary Oogle air photo view of the area of Nuthampstead airfield and its surrounding terrain.  Practically all the land upon which the air base was situated has been turned over to agricultural use.

________________________________________

Newly arrived at Nuthampstead, the 55th Fighter Group’s Commanders are visited by Major General William E. Kepner (far left), then head of the Eighth Fighter Command. 

To General Kepner’s own left in the photo (left to right) are:

Col. Frank B. James
Lt. Col. Jack S. Jenkins, 0-22606
Major Dallas W. Webb
Major Milton Joel, 0-416308
Major Richard W. (Dick) Busching, 0-427516

Though I don’t recall the specific source of this image as used “here” in this post, this picture can also be viewed at the 55th Fighter Group website.  It also appeared in print in the October, 1997, issue of Wings magazine (V 7, N 5, p. 13), where it’s noted as having been part of Jack Jenkins’ photo collection, from which the names above are taken.  There, Milton’s name is incorrectly listed as “Walton”.  Wings mentions that General Kepner, then in his 50s “…flew his personal P-47D everywhere, including an occasional sortie into combat.  Kepner was a strong and successful commander.” 

________________________________________

The following Army Air Force photographs, taken some time between the 55th Fighter Group’s arrival at Nuthampstead in September of 1943, and November 29, 1943 (that sad day will be covered in detail in subsequent posts…) may be well known to those with an interest in the history of Eighth Air Force fighter operations, and, the P-38 Lightning.  But, for those newly acquainted with this story: 

First, image A1 79829 AC / A14144 1A.  The photo caption states:

“Flight leaders of the 38th Fighter Squadron, based at Nuthampstead, England, gather for an informal briefing by Major Milton Joel of Richmond, Virginia just before a mission over enemy territory.  They are, left to right: 1st Lt. James Hancock of Sebring, Fla., 1st Lt. Gerald Leinweber of Houston, Texas, 1st Lt. Joseph Myers of Canton, Ohio, and 1st Lt. Jerry Ayers of Shelbyville, Tenn.” 

Obviously posed (Lt. Ayers and Major Joel have wry smiles) it’s still a great photo.   Notice that Lt. Hancock and Major Joel are – gadzooks! – smoking!  (In the world of 2020, how … er … uh … um … ironically, dare I say “refreshing ”… as it were?)

Second, image: B1 79830AC / A14145 1A. 

The caption?

“Lt. Albert A. Albino of Aberdeen, Wash., and Lt. John J. Carroll of Detroit, Mich., both members of the 38th Fighter Squadron stationed at Nuthampstead, England, discuss the map of a future target in the squadron pilot room.”

Like the above image, this photo is almost certainly posed, but it’s still an excellent study.  While Lt. Albino wears a classic leather flight jacket, it looks as if Lt. Carroll sports a home-made (?) sweater.   

By day’s end on November 29, 1943, Lt. Albino would no longer be among the living, and Lt. Carroll would be a prisoner of war. 

________________________________________

After Major Joel failed to return from the mission of November 29, Captain Mark K. Shipman of Fresno, California, took command of the 38th, until replaced in that role by Capt. Joseph Myers. 

The below portrait of Major Shipman (long before he became a Major!) is from the United States National Archives’ collection “Photographic Prints of Air Cadets and Officers, Air Crew, and Notables in the History of Aviation”, in NARA Records Group 18-PU, which also includes (see prior post) a Flying Cadet portrait of Major Joel.  Major Shipman’s photo is from Box 84 of the collection.  You can read about the collection at The Past Presented.

This image, from The American Air Museum in Britain, shows Captain Shipman in front of his personal P-38, 42-67080, “Skylark IV”, “CG * S”.  This photograph appears on page 93 of Roger Freeman’s The Mighty Eighth, albeit in cropped form, and transposed (a mirror-image) from the actual print.  Major Shipman was officially credited with 2.5 aerial victories:  One in North Africa, and two in Europe.

This image of the aircraft and ground crew was photographed by Sgt. Robert T. Sand, who not-so-coincidentally completed Skylark IV’s nose art.  Note that the 20mm cannon has been removed from the plane’s nose.

The below article about Major Shipman appeared in the Pittsburgh Press on February 6, 1943, and pertains to his experience on January 23, 1943, while he was serving as a lieutenant in the 48th Fighter Squadron of the 14th Fighter Group.  Accounts of this mission, in which the 48th lost six pilots – of whom Lt. Shipman turned out to be the sole survivor – can be found at emedals.com  and Rob Brown’s RAF 112 Squadron.org.

U.S. Flier Walks 2 Days Through Italian Positions

Pilot’s Clothes Stolen, So He Wraps Feet in Rags; Brings Back Valuable Information

By the United Press

ALLIED HEADQUARTERS, North Africa.  Feb. 6 – For two days Lt. Mark K. Shipman, 22, Fresno, Cal., wandered over desert and mountains, his feet bound with shreds of his uniform, but when he finally reached an American outpost he brought with him valuable reconnaissance information.

The lieutenant told about his experience today.

His Lightning fighter plane was shot down on the morning of Jan 23 when he left formation to help a comrade fighting a cluster of Messerschmitts.  Lieut. Shipman said he made a belly landing.

“The ship was practically undamaged,” he said.  “I ran about 40 yards away because I knew the Messerschmitts would strafe me.  Three of them riddled the plane with three dives.  Then I went back to it and took out a helmet, canteen and pistol and started hiking for the mountains.”

Clothes Stolen

Lieut. Shipman said all his clothes except his trousers and undershirt were stolen from him, although he managed to retain a wedding ring and Crucifix which were presents from his wife.  (The dispatch did not say who did the looting.)

“I found I couldn’t walk in my bare feet,” Lieut. Shipman continued.  “So I cut off my trousers below the knees and wrapped the cloth around my feet.  I walked over a mountain knowing by the sun I was traveling toward the American lines.  I found a narrow dirt road and started making better time but my feet were getting sore.

Fixes Crude Bed

“So I took off mv trousers and managed to cut off more cloth above the knees, which I added to the strips I already had tied about, my feet.  I turned off the trail and went over to a creek bed and fixed a crude bed in a hole. I got kind of warm and rested.

“After a while the moon came up and I got out and started down the creek bed.  About 10 o’clock I passed what I believed were some Italian tents and snaked along silently, finally getting into the open.

“I ran along a dirt road for a while and was hiding in a ditch when a motorcyclist came along.  He was Italian.  I decided it was safer to keep off the road.  My feet were so sore I could scarcely stand so I made a sort of fox hole about a hundred yards from the road.

Crosses Road

“When daylight came I positively identified other passing vehicles as Italian.  I crossed the road and crept along, finally reaching three Italian road blocks.  I took off my white cotton undershirt so I wouldn’t be conspicuous.

“By that time I was getting desperate and I decided on a break.  I got into ravines and at times I saw Italian sentries on both sides.  After I sneaked along for about five miles I didn’t see any more Italians.   About 5 p.m. I approached an American outpost.  They recognized me.”

________________________________________

Capt. Joseph Myers, Jr. and Major Joel stand before a P-38.  The date and location of the image are unknown.  Thanks to information from Andrew Garcia in November of 2023, I’ve been able to correlate the four-digit Lockheed Aircraft Company factory production number “1526” on the fighter’s nose to its Army Air Force serial: The aircraft is P-38H 42-67015.  Being that this aircraft isn’t listed at the Aviation Archeology database and there is no Missing Air Crew Report for it, it seems that it survived the war, I assume to be turned into aluminum siding or pots & pans after 1945.  (Photo c/o Harold Winston)  

Another image of Capt. Myers, this time in front of his personal aircraft, P-38J 42-67685 “Journey’s End’ / “CG * O”, with ground crew members Sergeants K.P. Bartozeck and J. D. “Dee Dee” Durnin.  The image presumably dates from very late 1943, as “Journey’s End” was destroyed during a single-engine crash-landing on January 4, 1944. 

This image, from The American Air Museum in Britain, can also be found on page 93 of Roger Freeman’s The Mighty Eighth.

This image shows Lt. Col. Joseph Myers, seated in a P-51D Mustang, to which the 55th Fighter Group began converting in July, 1944.  He commanded the 38th Fighter Squadron between February 10 and April 22 of that year.  This image is from the collection of Dave Jewell.

________________________________________

Another pilot whose P-38 sports distinctive nose art: Capt. Jerry H. Ayers and ground crew in front of his personal aircraft, P-38J 42-67077, “Mountain Ayers” / “CG * Q.  Like many examples of 55th Fighter Group nose art, this painting was completed by Sergeant Robert T. Sand. 

Just One Reference!

Maloney, Edwatd T., Lockheed P-38 “Lightning”, Aero Publishers, Inc., Fallbrook, Ca., 1968 (The book includes a table correlating Lockheed Aircraft Company serials to Army Air Force serials.)

Next: Part IV (1) – Autumn Over Europe

11/13/20 – 1,634

A Very Long Mission: First Lieutenant Henry Irving Wood, Fighter Pilot, Prisoner of War of the Japanese, 1943-1945

Many posts at TheyWereSoldiers specifically pertain to the military service of Jewish soldiers in the Second World War.  Inevitably, one of the themes that follows is the experience of Jewish prisoners of war in the European and Mediterranean Theaters of War, given the nature, ideology, and aims of Germany during that conflict.  Such posts as…

January 14, 1945 – A Bad Day Over Derben

An Unintended Return:  The Tale of S/Sgt. Walter Bonne, a German-Born Jewish Soldier’s Experiences as a Prisoner of War, in Aufbau, May 18, 1945

Eighteen Days from Home: Corporal Jack Bartman (April 20, 1945)

Double Jeopardy Remembered – The Reminiscences of a Jewish Prisoner of War

The Reconstruction of Memory: Soldiers of Aufbau – Jewish Prisoners of War

The One That Got Away!…  “I Was A Prisoner of War of the Nazis” – “Ich war ein Kriegsgefangener der Nazis,” in Aufbau, October 15, 22, and 29, 1943

… focus on this topic directly, while many of my other posts – particularly those specifically covering Jewish military casualties in WW II, some of which mention American POWs at Berga-am-Elster, Germany – touch upon this in passing.

What of the experience of Jewish servicemen captured in combat against Japan, whether in the Pacific, or, the CBI (China-Burma-India) Theaters of War?  In the United States armed forces, the total number of Jewish military personnel captured in the Pacific Theater – soldiers, Marines, and sailors captured during the war’s opening months during the fall of Corregidor and Bataan, and later on, aviators in the Army Air Force, Navy, and Marine Corps – was vastly fewer than those captured by Germany, Italy, Hungary, Rumania, and Bulgaria.  This is an indirect reflection of the greater magnitude of the Allied war effort against Germany and its European allies, relative to that against Japan.

Based on my investigation of a very wide variety of documents and sources, I’ve determined that a total of 686 Allied aviators – from the air arms of all Allied nations – survived Japanese captivity.  (See this post, albeit the numbers therein need revising…)  This number indirectly reflects several factors inherent to the Pacific air war, and over all, indicates the hauntingly low probability of an Allied flier – once captured – actually surviving Japanese captivity through and specifically beyond Emperor Hirohito’s announcement on August 15, 1945 of Japan’s surrender.

Of the thirty-five Jewish aviators captured by the Japanese during combat missions from among all branches of the American armed forces between 1942 and August 7, 1945 (…information about the latter date here…), First Lieutenant Henry Irving Wood (0-789035), was one of the nineteen who survived the war.  A fighter pilot, he was shot down on October 1, 1943 during a bomber escort mission to Haiphong, French Indochina, a regular destination for American combat aircraft in a war that that began some two decades later. 

Though I mentioned his name some five years ago (2018) in a post about the experiences of 1 Lt. William S. Lyons – Revenge of the Tiger – only very recently did I discover that there has long existed a complete account of his experiences.  This comprises a full chapter – a revealing chapter – in Wanda Cornelius’ and Thayne R. Short’s 1980 book DING HAO – America’s Air War in China -1937-1945.  As described by Short in the book’s introduction, “Of dramatic importance was Henry I. Wood, who chose Wanda and me to reveal his 36-year-old secret by walking into the 1978 [November 18, to be specific] reunion of the Seventy-fifth in Nashville, Tennessee, when everybody had thought him dead in flames over war-torn China in 1944.  An entire chapter tells his story.”  Here, the by-1978 civilian Henry I. Wood relates the events of his last mission, his capture, imprisonment, mistreatment, and eventual return to American military control.

Lt. Wood’s story is presented in full, below.  It begins with a portrait (from DING HAO) of him sitting in his P-40, and is accompanied by maps, images of Missing Air Crew Reports, and, War Crimes Case File Index Cards from NARA Records Group 153 (Records of the Judge Advocate General’s Office) which pertain to postwar depositions or reports about his experiences.  In these, Lt. Wood mentions the names of several American (and one Chinese) military personnel, and these are accompanied in dark red text, like this – by insertions giving the full names and serial numbers of these people. 

I have absolutely no idea if the account in DING HAO was written by Mr. Wood and provided to Cornelius and Short, or, if it’s a transcription of either a cassette recording (this was in the ancient, pre-digital world 1978, after all) or a one-on-one interview.  Such information isn’t given in the book. 

What about Henry I. Wood, the person?  He was born on July 11, 1918, in Jacksonville, Florida, the son of Isadore Raymond (1883-1945) and Josephine Harris (Hughes) (1890-1979) Wood, and had two brothers, one of whom was Bernard Bear Wood (10/6/21-12/26/85).  The family’s wartime address was 2217 Herschel Street, in Jacksonville.  His paternal grandmother was Adaline Silverberg Wood.

Information about his MIA status appeared in the Jacksonville Commentator on October 21, 1943, and in an official Casualty List released by the War Department on November 5 of that year.  His name does appear in American Jews in World War II; it’s on page 86.

His loss in combat is covered in Missing Air Crew Report 759, which indicates that he was missing in P-40K 42-46250. 

Henry Irving Wood died on October 28, 1986.  I have no information about his postwar life, or, his place of burial.

Isadore and Bernard were two of Isadore and Josephine Wood’s three sons.  Their third son, RM 2C David Robert Wood (5519400), born on Oct. 6, 1921, did not survive the Second World War.  A crew member of the USS Albacore (SS-218), commanded by Lt. Cdr. Hugh Raynor Rimmer, he was one of eighty-five men killed when their submarine struck a mine and sank on November 7, 1944, just off Cape Esan (east of Hakodate), Hokkaido, Japan.  (See also…)  There were no survivors.  His name is memorialized on the Tablets of the Missing at the Honolulu Memorial in Hawaii. 

Henry I. Wood was one of eight 23rd Fighter Group pilots who survived as POWs.  The names of the seven others are listed below, along with their serial numbers, squadrons, date of capture, type of aircraft flown upon their “last” mission (and when known, the aircraft serial number and pertinent MACR number), the location of the POW camp where they were interned, and, their state of residence.  Of those USAAF Fighter Groups from among whom men survived as POWs of the Japanese, only the 311th Fighter Group had more men who returned from Japanese captivity, with ten POWs surviving the war.  And so, the names:  

Lucia
, Raymond W., 1 Lt., 0-427755

74th Fighter Squadron
POW 3/19/43; P-40; No MACR
Omori Headquarters (Ofuna) – From Glendale, New York
Reported in News Media 4/12/1943

Pike, Harry M., Lt. Col., 0-024110
Headquarters Squadron
POW 9/15/43; P-40; MACR 15584
Omori Headquarters (Ofuna) – From Westbury, New York
Reported in News Media 10/19/1943

Quigley, Donald L., Maj., 0-432207
74th Fighter Squadron
POW 8/10/44; P-40N 43-23400; MACR 7349
Shanghai POW Camp, Kiawgwan – From Ohio

Bennett, Gordon F., 1 Lt., 0-797926
74th Fighter Squadron
8/29/44; P-40N 42-106318; MACR 8017
Shinjku, Tokyo – From Massachusetts

Thomas, James E., 2 Lt., 0-812174
118th Fighter Squadron
POW 9/4/44; P-40N 43-22800; MACR 8115
Shanghai POW Camp, Kiawgwan – From Kentucky

Taylor, James M., Jr., 2 Lt., 0-817130
75th Fighter Squadron
POW 11/11/44; P-51C 43-24947; MACR 10078
Shanghai POW Camp, Kiawgwan

Parnell, Max L., 2 Lt., 0-686010
118th Fighter Squadron
POW 12/24/44; P-51C 43-24984; MACR 10967
Shinjku, Tokyo – From Georgia

Neither the War Crimes Case Files nor Wood’s story in DING HAO make any reference to the implications of his being a Jew, in terms of his experiences as a POW, probably because there simply weren’t any, this almost certainly never having been focus of interest by his captors to begin with.  Of course, this would presume a nominal awareness on their part about Jews and Judaism beforehand, which I doubt was manifest in the rank and file of the Japanese military at that time. 

Admittedly conjecture on my part…!  I think that during the 1930s, while there was likely some familiarity with Christianity among the Japanese people, knowledge about Jews was essentially limited to the very few who were members of economic or social elites residing in the United States as college or university students, or, military attaches and diplomatic personnel.  In that context and setting, any awareness that emerged “about” Jews would probably have been a sort-of-caricature derived from popular culture, rather than a result of direct interpersonal interactions.

This was a definite aspect of what befell Second Lieutenant Joseph Finkenstein (0-730433), a fighter pilot in the 339th Fighter Squadron of the 347th Fighter Group, 13th Air Force.  Born in Denver on April 20, 1921, he was the only son of Frank Israel (9/27/88-2/4/66) and Dora R. (Goalstone / Udelson) (10/29/92-1/9/67) Finkenstein, and the half-brother Joe Louis and Rita Pellish, Dora’s children from a prior marriage.  The family resided at 718 ½ South Ridgeley Drive in Los Angeles.

The insignia of the 339th Fighter Squadron insignia, from a2jacketpatches.

✡                                 ✡

These two photos of Lt. Finkenstein are via Rita Pellish Diamond.  First, his graduation portrait…

…and second, here he’s standing on the wing of a PT-17 Stearman (probably 41-8959) during Primary Training.  If I have the serial correct, based on the Aviation Archeology database, the photo may have been taken in 1942, at Ocala, Florida.

– .ת.נ.צ.ב.ה. –
…Tehé Nafshó Tzrurá Bitzrór Haḥayím
May his soul be bound up in the bond of everlasting life.

✡                                 ✡

Joseph Finkenstein did not survive the war.  He was missing in action on his eighth combat mission, during the “Saint Valentine’s Day Massacre” of February 14, 1943, P-38G “21”.  Though the MACR covering his loss (#585), his IDPF (Individual Deceased Personnel File), and, NARA Records Group 153 are devoid of any information about his ultimate fate, a Japanese propaganda broadcast transmitted to the American West Coast on November 24, 1943, and recorded by the Foreign Broadcast Intelligence Service (NARA Records Group 262) – the text of which was never incorporated into his IDPF – definitively confirms that he was captured. 

The text of the broadcast, almost certainly abstracted from a transcript of his interrogation, reveals that his interrogator (or interrogators?) took particular note of Finkenstein having been a Jew, with Joseph’s residence in Los Angeles implying that the interrogator (a member of the Japanese military? – the Kempei Tai?) subscribed to antisemitic caricatures about Jews prevailing in the American entertainment media, likely from pre-war residence in the West Coast. 

Joseph Finkenstein’s name appears in a War Department Casualty List that was issued to the news media on March 11, 1943, and also in the records of the National Jewish Welfare Board, but most definitely not in the 1947 compilation American Jews in World War II.  The records of the American Battle Monuments Commission – which indicate that his name is commemorated on the Tablets of the Missing at Manila American Cemetery – note that he was awarded the Air Medal and Purple Heart.

Though Joseph Finkenstein’s fate will never be known among men, based on the general location where he was lost, I believe that he was imprisoned at Shortland Island.  Later, he may well have been transported to Rabaul, New Britain, the latter being the location where 2 Lt. Wellman H. Huey – also of the 339th; also lost on February 14, 1943; who also never returned – is definitely known to have been held captive.

Here’s Lt. Huey’s Class 42-I graduation portrait, from the United States National Archives collection “Photographic Prints of Air Cadets and Officers, Air Crew, and Notables in the History of Aviation – NARA RG 18-PU”.

The body of literature pertaining to the experience of Jewish POWs of the Japanese is – unsurprisingly – extraordinarily small, but what does exist is utterly compelling.  I know of four books in this limited genre.  They are:

Barbed-Wire Surgeon, by Alfred A. Weinstein, M.D., MacMillan, 1956

Chaplain on the River Kwai – Story of a Prisoner of War, by Chaim Nussbaum, Shapolsky Publishers, 1988

These two were penned by members of the Army Air Force:

They Can’t Take That Away From Me – The Odyssey of an American POW, by Ralph M. Rentz, Michigan State University Press, 2003

ETA Target 1400 Hours or Hi Ma, I’m Home, by Irving S. Newman, 1946 (unpublished manuscript)

I’m sure that there exist other yet-unpublished manuscripts, collections of letters, and diaries, but whether these will reach publication by now, nearly eight decades after the war’s end, is problematic.

Also problematic is the question of whether, in the “fundamentally transformed” America of 2023, there remains – and will remain? – an interest in history. 

Truly, the past is a very different country. 

And what of the future?

✡                                 ✡

So, onward to Lt. Wood…

Here’s his Craig Field (Alabama) graduation portrait, also from the Photographic Prints of Air Cadets and Officers, Air Crew, and Notables in the History of Aviation – NARA RG 18-PU. (Specifically, Box 102.)

xx

And now, his story from DING HAO

Introduction

Of dramatic importance was Henry I. Wood, who chose Wanda and me to reveal his 36-year-old secret by walking into the 1978 reunion of the Seventy-fifth in Nashville, Tennessee, when everybody had thought him dead in flames over war-torn China in 1944.  An entire chapter tells his story.

Lt. Henry I. Wood, Prisoner of War

Lt. Wood, in the cockpit of what is presumably his “personal” P-40 Warhawk, at the 23rd Fighter Group’s base at Kweilin, China

Insignia of the CBI (China-Burma-India) Theater, which appears on the left shoulder of Lt. Wood’s jacket.

On October 1, 1943, sixteen P-40s of the Seventy-fifth escorted bombers over Haiphong.  Over the target the bombers made direct hits on installations and upon completing their runs turned the formation for home.  Suddenly enemy Zeroes struck and in the battle, four Zeroes crashed to destruction.  Lt. Henry I. Wood, pilot of one of the P-40s, disappeared in the brief interval of fighting.  So read the record of that fateful day.  The men believed Wood to be gone forever since he did not return to base.  He arrived in China early in March of that year, a few days before the Fourteenth Air Force was activated.  This was his thirtieth mission.  He had downed a bomber the previous June or July in combat.  Years afterward, Wood recalled all that had happened to him after he was shot down on October 1, 1943.

This example of the 75th Fighter Squadron insignia is from Flying Tiger Antiques.

The October 1 mission had been postponed three separate limes due to bad weather, and finally, instead of taking off during the morning, we took off shortly after noon.  The mission was uneventful until we got over the target at Haiphong when the B-24s dropped their bombs.  I had been scheduled to lead the right rear flight and Don Brookfield [1 Lt. Donald S. Brookfield, 0-430778, 75th FS, 23rd FG, 4 victories], who already had orders to go home, elected to go with us.  He took the flight and I look the echelon as the clement leader.  Of the eighteen fighters who were doing the escort, two didn’t join up.  One was my wingman and one was Brookfield’s.  So I flew wingman for Brookfield and only two of us were guarding the right rear.  We were at about twenty-one thousand feet and the bombers at twenty thousand when we went over the target.

After the bombers dropped their bombs and turned northeast, instead of heading back to base, Brookfield for some reason kept staying over the target.  But at twenty thousand feet we couldn’t see much but smoke, so we got quite a bit behind the main formation, about one and a half miles behind to be precise.  Antiaircraft fire was hitting us all around.  I took a severe hit from “AA” fire and was picking up my microphone to call Brookfield, when we were hopped by about thirty fighters.  Brookfield peeled off to the left and I peeled off to the right.  I dove down approximately five thousand feet, picking up considerable speed, and turned up into the last part of the bomber formation.

The last Zero had left the fighters and had gone to the bombers and it began a half roll through the tail bombers.  And as I pulled up to the loop, one of the Zeroes came out in front of me, and I fired my guns.  He still hadn’t dropped his bamboo wing tanks, and he flamed immediately.  I flew within fifty feet of him and saw his wing disintegrating as he went down.  My own engine seemed to quit but I didn’t think much of it, because often in a high angle of attack and after firing six .50s, the airplane tends to stall out.  So it didn’t immediately dawn on me that it had stopped.  I just nosed over to pick up airspeed, and then I realized that I didn’t have a working engine.

The antiaircraft fire had hit the tail section of my airplane.  At that time the P-40’s control surfaces were fabric, but the rest was metal.  I could see most all of my right aileron and most all of my right elevator.  The rudder was pretty badly damaged, and I didn’t have good control of the aircraft.  I leveled off and looked around to see if anybody was following me.

Then I dropped down to see if there were any more Zeroes.  I couldn’t jump because I knew they would shoot at me in midair.  Next I tried everything I could think of to get the airplane engine going again, but I couldn’t get it to come to life.  I turned off and on all of the switches, even doing the ridiculous thing of turning off and on the gun switch.

I theorized that I had taken a hit earlier from the “ack ack” or possibly from the fighter that first fired at me, before pulling away when I dove.  It must have nicked the gas line and when I fired my guns, the vibration shook it where it wouldn’t feed.

Many years later Wood learned about a similar incident from another Seventy-Fifth Fighter Squadron member, Charlie Olsen [1 Lt. Charles J. Olsen, 0-789937, 1 victory].  Olsen said that his plane engine once quit and restarted at twenty-five hundred feet, and when he got it back to the base they found several aircraft with belly tanks full of some sort of green slime.  The belly tanks had been shipped over from the United States and were not properly cleaned out before being put to use.  The slime moved up to the carburetor and caused the engine to cut out.  Therefore, Wood came to the conclusion that perhaps it was green slime which killed his engine rather than a hit in the carburetor.

I got low to about eleven hundred feet as indicated, and I knew I was near a small village northeast of Hanoi, probably about thirty miles from the city.  And I jumped.  What I did to make sure my plane was destroyed was to trim it up nose heavy, crouch down in the seat, and when I was ready to go, I was in a stooping position.  I just pushed the stick forward.  In theory, if you did that you would do a back flip out of the airplane.  I didn’t do a back flip.  I did sort of an angle flip over the side.  I used to dive in high school, so I just tipped my body naturally, instinctively, and it is a good thing that I did because as I turned and went by the horizontal stabilizer, it was just about two inches in front of my nose.  And my feet just cleared the vertical stabilizer.  As soon as I realized I was clear of the airplane, I counted two and pulled the ripcord.  It is a good thing I pulled it when I did because I was almost too low to jump.  I was in some low foothills, and I fell backward, forward, and backward again and on my back swing, or my third one, I hit the ground.

A wind caught the chute dragging me until it collapsed up the hill about fifty feet.  My face was scratched a little.  I disengaged the chute.  This was about 4:30 in the afternoon and there was still considerable daylight in Indochina at the time.  So I took the chute down the hill with me into a rice paddy, because I knew I was too deep into enemy territory.

Missing Air Crew Report 759

Lt. Wood was flying on my wing when the bombers went into their run.  I last saw him when the escort made a turn following the bombers from the target.  Major Brady (B-24, Flight Commander) states that he saw a P-40 and a zero make a head-on pass; the zero exploded and the P-40 went straight down smoking badly.  This was probably Lt. Wood.  Other bomber crews reported a pilot parachuting from a P-40 shortly after leaving the target.

DONALD S. BROOKFIELD,
1ST Lt., Air Corps

From Carl Molesworth’s book 23rd Fighter Group – ‘Chenault’s Sharks’ , this painting by Jim Laurier – of Lt. James L. Lee’s P-40M number 179 in late summer of 1943 – is a representative view of a 75th Fighter Squadron Warhawk during the time-frame of Lt. Wood’s service in the squadron.  Note that the squadron insignia appears on the fin, over the painted-out serial number.  Unfortunately, MACR doesn’t list the side number of the aircraft Lt. Wood was flying on his last mission. 

I got into the paddy and laid down between the growing rice there.  In about twenty minutes I could see activity come into the rice paddy, coolies, natives, and later men in uniform.  I just laid real still and several times within twenty or thirty feet of me they would come by, but they didn’t see me.  The parachute was wadded down beside me in the water.  After dark, about nine o’clock, I decided I could move.  I got up cautiously.  My parachute was soaked but there was a little fishing paraphernalia in there, and I took it out along with a machete, some C-rations, and a chocolate bar from the pack.  I look them with me toward the little village I had seen as I was coming down in the parachute.  About a quarter until ten, I came to the edge of this village, which was a compound composed of mud huts arranged in a circle.  I worked my way all around the wall until I came to the entrance.  Entering, I saw several people standing by a fire.  Immediately a dog began to bark.  And I said in Chinese, “I am your very good friend.”  I was hoping I was anyway.

And as I started over to these natives at the fireplace, there was an elderly man of about sixty there.  He held up his hands to indicate to the rest of them to be quiet, and I walked over to him, reaching for my little booklet called a pointee-talkee.  I turned my leather jacket inside out to show I had a Chinese-American flag, and I pointed to the place in the book which said I was an American pilot, to help me, that my government would pay him well.  This happened the day after payday and I had a good bit of Chinese yen which I did not know was any good to them or not, but I pulled it out anyway.  I gave it to him indicating that be would get much more if he could hide me and work me back into China.

He apparently knew no English but motioned to me, indicating that things were all right and took me into one of the little mud huts.  They gave me some cold boiled water and scrambled eggs.  I was sitting on the floor by a little table eating the eggs and drinking the water when something caused me to be apprehensive.  It was a noise, a kind of dull thud.  It was probably a rifle butt striking the side of the mud hut.  What had happened to me was that a platoon of Japanese soldiers led by a lieutenant and a noncom who could speak some English had come to the village.  They had been brought there by the people I had talked to.  I had asked for the Chinese guerillas.  They had sent for the Japanese troops instead.

The locals were probably too scared to hide me because they were afraid they would be killed if they were caught.  I indicated from the book for them to hide me.  They took me to the next room, but there wasn’t any real place to hide because there wasn’t anything there besides thatch rugs on the floor and a small table in the corner.  I held up a couple of these rugs over me in the corner.  Then suddenly, the room lit up and I could hear these gruff voices which I presumed were saying “hands up” in Japanese.  I didn’t move.  Somebody snatched the rug.  I stood up with my hands up.

I was not treated rough initially, surprisingly enough, as I had been led to expect I would be.  They did take my jacket off and search me thoroughly, and the one which could speak some English said, “Never mind.  Never mind.”

He took me to the other room where I had been eating and motioned for me to finish.  I had suddenly lost my appetite.  In fact I was so confused (and even though I had fairly good intelligence – later I graduated with honors from college) by being treated nice, that I asked them through the pointee-talkee what Chinese troops were doing in this area?  And there was an uproar – a sound of laughter when one of them read it to the others.  Finally the tall one who kept saying.  “Never mind.  Never mind,” said, “Ha.  Ha.  You think we Chinese.  We Japanese.”

It was a big joke to them, but not to me.  They then tied my hands behind my back and put some of the troops in front of me.  They had cattails which had been dumped in kerosene which were lit and we started traipsing through the rice paddies, with troops in front and back of me.  And it was pretty slippery trying to walk through the rice fields and every once in a while I would start to go down.  I was afraid that somebody would shoot me in the back thinking I was trying to escape.  I had no such ideas at the time, being in the middle of a bunch of Jap soldiers.

After about forty-five minutes or an hour we reached a road where they sent up some flares and indicated to me to sit down.  While we were sitting there one of the soldiers took the chocolate bar they had taken from me and offered me some.  And I said thank you to him.  They all laughed.  They thought it was funny since they had taken me prisoner and confiscated my food and here I was thanking them for offering me something to eat.  In about thirty minutes, a big truck came down the road and we all piled into it.  It had an open bed with low sides.  I stood in the middle with the rest of them hovering around me.  My hands were still tied.  We came to a compound which was apparently a troop training area because there was a number of barracks.  I was taken inside one of the buildings with an extremely mean-looking Japanese.  The only other Japanese I had seen like him was when I had shot down a bomber on another mission and flew almost into the nose of his plane before I cut under it.  And I could see the pilot’s face there.  I had apparently killed the copilot and the pilot was just staring at me through the canopy.

This mean-looking fellow had on a kimono, not a uniform, and he apparently was the man in charge.  I found out the next morning he was a captain, and he was definitely in charge of the outfit.  The man glared at me, and through one of his subordinates, he told me to answer his questions or he would cut off my head.

And I nodded my still intact head that I understood.  He then asked me what my rank was and I told him first lieutenant.  He then asked me how many planes were in my formation.  I said to ask one of his pilots who was up there on the mission.  He must not have liked my answer because he became even more enraged.  And he had someone tie my hands behind my back, to the back of the chair and my feet to the runner of the chair.  Then he took out some paper towels and took his own neck and wiped it and removed his sabre from its sheath, indicating to me that he was going to cut my bead off.

He then had someone tell me to answer his questions and I nodded that I understood and be asked the same questions again.  I told him that I did not have to answer questions of this nature.  He then ordered his soldiers to carry me outside where there was a big bonfire.  They set the chair down with me in it, and at that moment I was convinced I was going to be killed.

I had always been told that one’s life flashed before you if you were going to die.  Mine didn’t flash before me.  But I had already done some thinking along these lines during the afternoon.  I had been very apprehensive.  Then I went to the compound and met the natives, and I got a glimmer of hope that they were going to hide me.

And I thought, “This is going to be rough on my mother as she has six boys in service, and I am going to be the first to go.”  And the last thing I thought about as he started to bring down the sword was how I used to have to wring chickens in the neck, and my mother plucked them afterwards when I was a kid.  I could see me squirming around with the reflexes going and I thought to myself, “I’m not going to give him the satisfaction of seeing me squirm.’’  So all I could think of was to stick my neck way back as far as possible so he could have a good clean whack.

Down came the sabre, stopping just an inch above my neck.  He did that twice and then he said something in Japanese and untied my legs.  He untied my hands from the chair but left them tied behind my back, took me over to a tree, tied my hands to the tree, and wound the rope around my whole body and the tree.

He apparently gave them instructions, “Ready!  Aim!  Fire!” in Japanese because they all brought their rifles up to bear and they all clicked on empty magazines.  He did that twice.  Then it began to dawn upon me that he was apparently just trying to scare me, that they were stiff wanting the information or I would already be dead.

They took me to a guard compound or jail and put me on the floor and took off all my clothes except my shorts.  My hands were tied behind my back and hands tied to my feet.  They laid me on the concrete floor and put a hard bag of cement under my head.  I would have been much more comfortable lying flat.  And then they proceeded to beat me with long sticks which looked like broom handles.  Some of the officers took off their boots and began beating me too.  And I lapsed into unconsciousness.  Several hours later, I awakened and all of them had gone.

NARA Records Group 153 Case File 56-41 (August, 1946)

1st Lt. Henry Irving Wood states that he received a beating following his capture at Luc Nahm, Indo China, by a roving detail of Jap soldiers, but does not know their names or any unit designation.

This document, from NARA, is a summation of Case Files 56-41 (above), and both 58-132 and 61-47 (see both below), and is based on an interview of Lt. Wood that occurred at Letterman General Hospital in San Francisco on October 9, 1945.  Due to the circumstances and nature of his treatment by the Japanese, as well as the near-impossibility of specifically identifying any of his captors, let alone locating them postwar, further investigation was fruitless.   

This map shows the location of “Luc Nahm” (actually, Luc Nam) then French Indo China, and now, Vietnam…

…while this map, at a smaller scale than above, shows Luc Nahm to the southwest, and Guilin (Kweilin) China – the 23rd Fighter Group’s base during the time frame of Lt. Wood’s service – to the northeast.

In this guard compound the guards were sitting along a bench with a noncom in charge, and one of them had apparently brought some incense because I had been bitten badly by mosquitoes and didn’t realize it until I came into consciousness.  As my awareness came back and the mosquitoes were still chewing on me, that was really the worst part so far because I couldn’t scratch the bites.

Shortly before dawn, I noted the noncom in charge kept reading a big heavy book, which was probably a Japanese-English dictionary.  He came over to me showing a little paper with writing on it.  Looking at it he said, “You are very brave man.  My maundy you go to New York.”  My maundy is a Chinese term meaning “later.”  Why a Japanese would use a Chinese word, I don’t know.  But that is what he said.

I had never heard of a prisoner being expatriated from Japan so I was very skeptical of what be said.  And then a humorous thing happened.  Just as he finished saying the words, the paper still in his hand, an officer walked in and the Japanese soldier jumped to attention.  He said something which sounded like Jejugius and presented arms, even though they were indoors.  And I could see what he had in his hand was carefully camouflaged so that the officer could not see it.  I am sure he would have caught hell if indeed he had written there what he said to me and somebody bad seen it.

The next morning about ten o’clock, my uniform was given back to me and I was told to dress and put the jacket on with the flag outside.  I was paraded in front of a large formation of Japanese troops while the captain in charge was speaking lo them.  I didn’t know what he was saying about me.

NARA Records Group 153 Case File 61-67 (August, 1946)

Lt. Henry Irving Wood states they were marched through the streets of Canton and Hanoi, China, in a ceremony exhibition before the Jap Army during Oct. 1943.

Later in the afternoon I was put in a truck again and taken to Hanoi.  I recognized the town when we got there to the suburbs because there were a good many signs in French and English which the Japanese had not obliterated.  I was taken to a beautiful occidental type building in the heart of Hanoi, led inside, and the ropes were taken off my hands.  Shortly later.  I was seated in a nice dining hall with china and silverware.

A very nicely dressed man in Western style clothing, a Japanese, came in speaking with an Oxford accent and told me he was sorry I had been mistreated the night before and wished to assure me this was not the Japanese’ nature.  But I should realize that there was a war going on and sometimes troops from the field got upset.  He said I would be treated well in the future, and he just wanted to talk to me a little.  He didn’t often get a chance to talk with an American.  I didn’t believe that.

It turned out that his name was Ariaa and he was the Japanese premier for French Indochina at the time.  It became obvious in a very short time with him trying to converse with me, that he was trying to discuss military information with me through seemingly irrelevant conversation.  First he asked me where I was born.  Where did I live?  Did I have brothers and sisters?  Apparently these questions were innocuous.

Then he said, “How did you like the place you were flying out of in China?  Where was that?”

Of course I refused to answer the questions.  And I told him in a nice manner that I didn’t mind talking with him, but there were things of obvious military significance and he must realize it.  After he understood he wasn’t making any headway, he apologized, said he had to leave and that I would be served a nice meal right at the table I was sitting at.  And again he apologized for the behavior of the Japanese.  As he left the room other Japanese came into another door and immediately tied me up and hustled me down to a basement where they had made some cells by taking a large room and segregating them with four-by-fours from the floor to ceiling with an inch space between each board.  They stripped me of all my clothes except my shorts, made me get down through a little door like an animal cage into one of the cells where there were four native Vietnamese, I presume.  They indicated for me to sit on the floor like the others were doing with knees crossed and with my hands folded across my knees.  So I sat there for a while and naturally that got tiring, so I leaned back and when I did, I was yelled at in Japanese, and a long thin stick came through the bars and I was knocked in the bead.

So I learned that I was supposed to be sitting and not lying down.  I was kept in this room for five days without food.  I was allowed to have water twice a day.  They got us up in the morning and put us to bed at six at night and allowed us water and took us to the ben jo as they called it, which was the bathroom, consisting of a little slit in the floor.

At the end of the fifth day, they brought me a big fish head which was supposed to be a delicacy in that area.  I still wasn’t hungry enough to cat a fish head, but later on during my incarceration, I would have gladly eaten it.

The next morning after offering me the fish head in the middle of the morning, they took me out of the cell and into a room where there were a number of Japanese in a big ring on the floor and others sitting behind them in chairs.  And that is where they started pressuring me in earnest about intelligence.  I let them know that all I would tell them was my rank, name, and serial number.  They tried to talk me into the information by being innocuous in their questioning like Ariaa had done.  They felt that if I talked they would get their information.  After they questioned me about an hour and a half, they put me back into the cell.  That afternoon about three o’clock, they took me out again and told me that I had to talk.  They were tired of talking to me in this manner, and they expected me to answer the questions.  When I refused to answer, they locked the windows.  There was this little device I called a windlass.  They put wires on your wrists and put it around your finger and tightened it gradually, pulling the finger back until it broke.  They didn’t break my finger but it was very painful.  And they also took a hammer and you can still see the scars on my hand where they broke the bones.  This went on for several days, and after the second day, they initiated a new procedure where they had a ladder which was inclined at about a forty-five-degree angle to the wall.  Then they tied me to the ladder with my head low, and they put water-laden heavy towels over my face where I would choke and gasp and eventually pass out.  Then they would bring me to and ask the questions again.  This went on for about three weeks.

NARA Records Group 153 Case File 58-132 (August, 1946)

1st Lt. Henry Irving Wood, states he was imprisoned at Nanking, China, and placed in solitary confinement for about 21 days.  Received severe treatment.

Then they took me to an airfield where I had been on an escort mission a time or two when the B-24s had bombed them.  While I was at the airfield up in a high room, but not in a control tower, there was an air raid alarm.  Everybody became very excited and they were bustling me out of the building and into a truck.  There were a number of trucks trying to leave the field with troops on them.  No pilots were trying to take off because they apparently felt that the American planes were imminent which they were.  They had not received the alarm in time.  But there was a road which paralleled the runway.  And as we were leaving I looked up and I could see the B-24s at a high altitude and barely make out the fighters with them.

I knew that the bombs bad already been dropped and were on their way and sure enough in a matter of seconds, the bombs were dropping all around us.  I had extremely mixed feelings – I was hoping that they would blast the hell out of the Japanese, but I sure didn’t want to get hit It was a real terrifying feeling to be in that situation.  We continued on down the highway for several miles, got into ditches on the side of the road, and stayed there for an hour.  Then we got back into the trucks and went back to the airfield.  Unfortunately the bombing had not been accurate, almost all of the bombs had gone off parallel to the runway about three hundred yards from the road we had traveled.  A couple of the bombs had hit the field, and one bad hit a large hangar where a number of airplanes were housed, and there was considerable damage to the planes as I could see fires still burning.  I could see the damaged airplanes.

Later on during the day I was put on this airplane, a Lockheed Lodestar, along with some Japanese passengers, and there were four guards with rifles and bayonets accompanying me and a Japanese captain in charge of the troops.  In the course of the flight it was very pleasant.  This particular officer was very courteous, and he indicated he understood English but he could not speak it well though he could write it.  He showed me pictures of his children and said he had been away from home five years.  He made no attempt to interrogate me for information.  He also offered me some of his chow because they apparently didn’t have any box lunch for me on the plane.  He gave me some cheese and a sandwich and I could tell from the course of the sun that we were flying along the southern China coast over towards Taiwan.  And sure enough we landed on the island.

For the first time in several weeks I had an enjoyable couple of hours, apparently while the plane was being refueled.  I got to lie outside in the open on the grass near the runway.  It was a beautiful sunny day and in no way was the captain in charge attempting to hamper me.  I had come through some pretty difficult times in the course of the flight, from a mental condition.  Several times I felt that I might have had the opportunity to get out of the seat in a hurry, run up to the front of the plane.  There was a “stepover” in the Lodestar which was approximately two and a half feet high, separating the cockpit from the area for the passengers.  I kept thinking that if I could realty get up there and grab bold of the pilot’s wheel, I could spin that plane in with everybody on board and accomplish something besides being a prisoner.

I could never bring myself to do it, but I would have never reached the cockpit if I had tried.  I’d have been stabbed in the back or shot.  But I bad some real tough times worrying whether I should try or not.  I had been in excellent health at the time I went down.  My main activity in Kunming – I wasn’t a gambler or a player of bridge – was working out with weights and doing a little running and push-ups and reading a good many books.  My health was good at age twenty-five and I was in top physical condition before my capture.  My health had not deteriorated rapidly in their hands.  After the first five days I had a fair diet with rice in the morning with some sort of Chinese vegetables and the same thing in the evening.  I was getting an adequate diet even though it wasn’t the most palatable one.

We eventually landed again, and I ascertained that I was in Nanking.  What made me realize that was I was again in solitary but not made to sit on the floor this time.  I was allowed to walk around all I wanted to.  The room was approximately eleven feet long and five feet wide, so I paced up and down that room most of the day.  It was right near the entrance of a large compound, and I could see into a large courtyard.

The second day I was there a big black car came up with general’s flags on it and a man got out.  I am sure it was the man they called “The Tiger of the Orient.”  He was the Japanese general in charge of that area.  He simply came over and looked at me through the bars, didn’t say anything, looked at me for about thirty seconds, and turned around and walked away.

Again I stayed in this cell for approximately three weeks because I was making marks with my fingernails on the wooden bars, four-by-fours, but wider spaces between them than the ones before, about two and a half inches.  One day they came in and said I would be moved that day.  They had not tried to interrogate me at all in Nanking and this morning they told me why they had stopped questioning me.

They told me they had captured a Chinese pilot named Chen [2 Lt. Ping-Ching Chen – Survived as POW] who was in my unit and that he had been badly wounded and they had been able to get all the information they wanted.  And I found out later that what they said was true because I was taken to a prison camp with him and he said he had been wounded – his leg bad been broken and he was shot in the arm.  Apparently under the severe mistreatment he had and the painful conditions, be told them things they wanted to know.

Missing Air Crew Report 759

Lt. Chen was flying on my wing when the formation left the target area. He remained in his position for approximately fifteen (15) minutes. When my flight turned back to protect two straggling bombers, Lt. Chen was missing.

THOMAS W. COTTON,
1st Lt., Air Corps

From Nanking we traveled to Shanghai where I was put into a large prison camp.  At that time, it held Italian prisoners from a ship that had been scuttled in the harbor at Shanghai.  It also contained some civilians from Wake Island, Marines from Wake Island, and the North China Embassy Guard.  It was a well-formed prison camp, and I simply was put into a cell by myself for approximately one week and then released with the general prisoners.  I remained in this camp from December of 1943 until late May 1945.

Other than two bad personal experiences in the long stay at the prison camp, it was not particularly bad other than the lack of communication with the outside, poor diet, and very little recreation.  We normally worked nine days and then were off one day.

My first bad experience was when I was asked to work by Maj. Luther Brown [Major Luther A. Brown, 0-3815, POW Dec. 8, 1941], who was a Marine major acting as executive officer for Colonel Ashhurst [Colonel William A. Ashurst, 0-000028, POW Dec. 8, 1941], who was the senior American officer in charge of the camp.  Brown had ordered me to go to work in a garden with other Americans which stood within the compound.  I told him I didn’t feel like I or any other prisoner should work.

He attempted to reason with me, saying that he was in charge and this work was not of any particular help to the Japanese.  It helped get us our own food and was of some value.  It was up to him to make a decision like that, and it was not up to me as an individual to decline or accept.

I still felt it was my own individual decision and I told him so.  He went over to a Japanese noncom named Neasaki [Lt. Myasaki], who was in charge of this particular detail.  Neasaki walked up to another prisoner who had a shovel, grabbed it, and hit me on the side of the head with it as hard as he could.  It knocked me to the ground.  I was stunned.  And when I got back up Major Brown told me he was sorry, but if I didn’t work, I would get similar treatment.  That was my first experience with any collaboration by an American with the Japanese.  I later found out that within a small group there was considerable collaboration.

NARA Records Group 153 Case File 58-108 (January, 1946)

1st Lt. Henry Irving Wood states on or about 10 Nov 1943, while a PsW at the Shanghai War Prison Camp, he was engaged in a detail of hauling dirt within the camp compound area.  Lt. Myasaki seized the shovel which he was working with and struck him a heavy blow in the face; he then turned and struck 2nd Lt. Robert E. Greeley, M.C., also in the face.  Myasaki was involved in torture treatments, such as water treatment, breaking fingers with a windlass contraption and numerous beatings.  Col. Otera was Jap commanding officer. 

In fact volumes of information on it were filled out in Manila at the end of the war, but nothing was done by the psychiatrists or attorneys.  They felt that a lot of what we said, due to living under such bad conditions for such a long time and to our mental health, was imagined.  But that wasn’t so.  It wasn’t until the Korean War that they realized that we were brainwashed and that there were Americans who collaborated with the enemy after they became prisoners.

I decided I had better go to work, that I didn’t want to get whacked anymore since I was a lone individual in the crowd.  Life was bearable except for the dairy drudgery of going out to work on days when it was cold and sleeping in a building that wasn’t heated and observing some American prisoners, including Major Brown, sleeping on innerspring mattresses with big trunks full of canned food from the Marine ship stores which they had been able to salvage in Peking.  They were treated differently from the rest of the prisoners too.  The reason why they were being treated differently, I found out, was they surrendered lo the enemy.  You can’t blame them for surrendering.  They were the embassy guards when the war broke out, and these people were the ones who had been fraternizing with the locals on a daily basis, the Japanese who occupied Peking at the lime.  And as the embassy guards, they were good friends with them, drank with them, danced with them, fraternized with them, and the Japanese gave them twenty-four hours to surrender.  For doing this, they were rewarded.  There was no attempt to dispose of the military hardware they had, which consisted of guns and bayonets and food.  Anyway, whatever arrangements were made, the former guards kept their personal clothing, watches, trunk loads of food, and it was shipped from Peking to the prison camp in Shanghai.  Their goods were maintained in a separate warehouse, and they were allowed to use it and no one else.

I found out that before I came to the camp, the Wake Island Marines, the ones that defended Wake Island, were put into the camp and Major Brown would not allow them to associate with the Peking Marines.  Here was a group of Marines who had been undergoing harsh mental treatment and some of whom were wounded, and they weren’t even allowed to associate with other Marines, who were the former embassy guards.  It took months before Major Devereaux, who after the war became a brigadier general, was able to resolve the situation with Major Brown and get him to share some of the clothes with the other prisoners.

Besides Brown, there must have been between sixty and eighty people from the embassy guard, including several officers, a number of captains who enjoyed the favors.  Major Brown allowed everybody from the former guard better treatment than the rest.  It may not have been the others’ nature to take advantage of the situation while fellow Americans were deprived, but Colonel Ashhurst apparently made the decision and Major Brown implemented it because Ashhurst said he was a sick man and put his executive officer in charge.  Finally Devereaux apparently overcame the situation.  He had been the commander at Wake Island.

Otherwise there was just minor ill-treatment when they would call a shakedown, like trying to find out why so much electricity was being used at the camp.  Some of the men had been taken to town to build a rifle range on “front days.”  They called it Mt. Fuji, but it was just a hill.  On a “front day” the Japanese would take us and mistreat us, telling us that there were severe conditions on the front.  We were well protected, so we should be mistreated because our [sic] comrades were having a rough day at the front.  There was a song we made up.  “With a front day every day out of nine / They run a short load (we’d push cars up this hill and we’d push a light load if we thought the Japanese weren’t watching) / Then Yaza day is a day of rest / Yaza day …  Yaza day.  …”

Eventually, in May of 1945, treatment wasn’t as harsh as usual and we received two Red Cross boxes.

Then Colonel Otaru, who was the Japanese commander at the camp, indicated we would be moved.  We were transported in boxcars from Shanghai beginning in late May of 1945, on up through Manchuria down through Korea to Pusan on the southern tip, where we were put into a large encampment with one water spigot for the entire camp.

We were kept in the camp mostly out in the open for four days, and we didn’t know what we were waiting for.  But apparently they were waiting to put us on a ship to take us up by rail to Hokkaido, the northern island, where they had in mind to put us to work in the mines.  It was a real rough trip, and the only time any prisoners escaped en route was a time when five escaped by cutting barbed wires late at night.  We were separated in two ends of the boxcar with barbed wire, and in the center of the car was the Japanese guard.  There was a small window in each end with wire over it.  They were able to cut the wire by putting a little commode there and placing a blanket up for a screen and fooling the guard by making him think they were just going to the bathroom there.  And they were able to work the barbed wire loose and five slipped out into the night before they were discovered.

Then we left Pusan on a ship.  We were crowded into the hold where we stood up.  I don’t know how many hours we were on there.  But it must have been between thirty-six and seventy-two hours on board, and there was no room between the bodies.  Then we were moved across the Tsushima Straits, into Japan proper onto Honshu island, put on small Japanese railroad cars, eighty to a hundred of us on each car, lying on the floor, under the seats, on the seats, up in the baggage baskets.  They had heavy opaque screens over the windows so you couldn’t see what was going on outside.  But we were so tightly packed in there that there were several places we cut the screens and could see the vast devastation of the countryside that the B-29s had wrought It was just at ground level for blocks on end close to the railroad tracks.  In one place we saw hundreds of railroad cars which had been destroyed.  And every now and then there was a B-29 raid and we would huddle up in the cars in some subterranean chamber.  They were really trying to protect us at that time.

We finally reached the island of Hokkaido, the northern island and were taken to a small mining town called Ashamitzabetsu.  At that time they separated the officers and the civilians and the airmen for the first time.  I felt they were trying to protect us and give us more consideration than they ever had before, or they wouldn’t have done that.

So on the third day they ordered us to go to the mines and I refused to go.  I was the only one out of eighty-three of us (among them were Marines, an orderly, two Navy medics, and several enlisted men who had been put in with the officers).  Brown was still in charge of the camp.  I refused to go out.  I was ordered to stand at attention by the Japanese this time.  Brown finally lost all of his friends he had in the move, and he had been mistreated several times himself for the first time since his incarceration.  So I stood at attention all day long, from when they first went out at seven o’clock in the morning, and I was still standing at attention when they returned at five o’clock in the afternoon.

They ate and I was still at attention at ten o’clock that night.  Every time I moved, and I couldn’t help but move, I was beaten by a particular guard standing over me at the lime.  He hit me with a rifle butt

But I must have accomplished something by my tenacity at that late stage in July of 1945 because the next day, instead of standing at attention again, and instead of taking me out to the mines, they put me lo work at a pookey party.  Pookey was a plant very much like an elephant ear, edible if you did a lot of boiling.  I was taken out with several Japanese and two other Americans, and we went out to the forest.  There were streams and low mountains, and it was beautiful country.  There we cut pookey.  It was carried back to camp and boiled for our food.  And for the rest of the time I went on pookey parties, and they made me the rice cook for the camp.  So I never did work in the mines with the rest of the prisoners.

On August 14, the commandant of the camp, the first lieutenant did not come to the camp.  No one was taken out to work.  No one was taken out to pookey parties, and we realized something must be going on.  Three days later some lieutenant colonel whom we had never seen before came in and told us the story that the Americans had some horrendous bombs but the Japanese would never surrender.  They also kidded us about being cowards for surrendering and said the Japanese would always commit hari-kari before surrendering

But the Japanese people as a whole had given in due to the horrendous weapons, he said.  And we were to wait there and see what was going to happen to us.  Well, I didn’t want to wait, even though I was urged by Colonel Ashhurst and Major Brown, whom I had no use for, to wait and see what would happen.  I felt we should be fed better and have better care, and I talked another officer, Lieutenant Rouse, into leaving with me.  We simply walked out of the camp.

We ignored the guards who hollered something to us and kept walking.  They didn’t do anything.  We went down to the center of the little town to the railroad station and kept saying, “Sapporo!  Sapporo!”

We ended up on a railroad train car, were transferred to another one and onto a third, and by the time we got to Sapporo on the third train, there was a Japanese noncom who spoke very good English and who asked us why we left camp.  We told him we understood there were some American Air Force officers in Sapporo and we wanted to be taken to them.  And sure enough, we were taken to a place where there were eleven men under Maj. Don Quigley, who turned out to be a squad commander of the Seventy-Fifth Fighter Squadron of which I bad been a member.  He came to China after I did and became squad commander before he was shot down.  For the next few days, we lived like kings.  Quigley got on the ball and got us on tours of the farms, universities, and even a small group to church.  Instead of being treated like prisoners, we were treated like tourists.  And we had plenty to eat, eggs, all sorts of vegetables, good meat, things we had been told earlier weren’t available.  I was real glad that I had the nerve to walk out of camp along with Lieutenant Rouse, who was a bomber pilot.  [1 Lt. Richard R. Rouse, 0-735669.  Member of 11th Bomb Squadron, 341st Bomb Group, 14th Air Force, captured November 11, 1943, during mission to Yochow, China, in B-25G 42-64757.  Aircraft shot down by anti-aircraft fire and crashed with all six crew members surviving.  Five of the six eventually survived war as POWs, being interned at Shanghai POW Camp.  Loss covered in MACR 1106.]

After a few days, one of the Japanese soldiers said the Americans would be coming in and they would be dropping supplies first and for us to go out and mark an area where they could drop them.  And they did.  They dropped big fifty-five-gallon drums from parachutes with clothes and food in them.  We had good food, good shoes, and uniforms again.

But some unfortunate things happened, too.  I remember when I was in the Shanghai camp there was an enlisted man, a Marine who was always in good humor even though in terrible health.  He almost died several times.  A Captain White, a Marine non-flying officer, had marked the drop for the camp where this Marine was, and he didn’t make the people stay far enough from the area.  And this sick Marine and two others were standing close to where the drum came in.  The parachute slipped off it, and it killed all three of them standing together.  This man had been captured at the outbreak of the war, the first day of the war, and he was killed by one of our own air drops at the end of it.

Several days later we were taken to an airfield where Americans had flown in some DC-3s and some P-51s.  And we were flown to the Philippines.  Army Air Corps men were flown to the Philippines and the Navy-Marines were flown to Guam.  We arrived at the Philippines September 12, 1945.  There we were plainly told after we revealed all of the tales of the Shanghai prison camp personnel, not to talk about it again.  We were interrogated several days by psychiatrists and by American attorneys, who were members of the armed forces and civilians, and we had to sign statements that we would not relate any of this when we got home or else we could not be taken home before we were cleared.

They didn’t want any of this information in the newspapers.  And they didn’t want to believe us, and they didn’t want us knocking any other Americans.  It was all right to tell about any atrocities of the Japanese, but with Americans we were supposed to show our patriotism.  Luther Brown had gone through the Naval Academy and was promoted to colonel before he retired.  And nothing was ever done to him.  They wouldn’t believe that an American officer would do what he did.  He was such a party boy at Shanghai that he had become real stout, but after getting in prison camp, he decided to take care of himself, and he slept in a private room with an innerspring mattress and worked out with weights.

I returned to the States October 8, 1945.

Notes

Crew members of B-25G 42-64757

Pilot: Rouse, Richard R., 1 Lt., 0-735669 (California)

Co-Pilot: Townsend, Alton Lloyd, 2 Lt., 0-672253 (Louisiana)

“On November 10, 1943, as a co-pilot on a low altitude mission over Yochow, China, Alton and a crew of 5 others were shot down and captured by Japanese and held in a Chinese prison camp for 10 days.  Because of the treatment the Chinese received, Alton and the crew were grateful to be Americans!  The six American prisoners were taken down the Yangtze River by boat at which time the Americans bombed the boat, not knowing Americans were on board; 2 of the 6 member crew escaped the boat—one drowned and one was picked up by a fishing boat and returned to the Japanese who had to move the prisoners to another boat to continue down river.  They were interred at the Allied Prisoner of War Camp at Shanghai, China.  Later the Japanese transferred Alton and his remaining crew with 1000 to 1100 other prisoners of war packed in rail cars through Manchuria to Korea and then in the hull of a boat crossing the Sea of Japan from China to the Northern Island of Japan, Okido.”

Navigator-Bombardier: Walsh, George T., 2 Lt., 0-741817 (Missouri)

Flight Engineer: Penka, Carl Steven, S/Sgt., 38165009 (New Mexico)

Radio Operator / Gunner: Hogue, Harold Franklin, S/Sgt., 18166447 (Arkansas)

Gunner: O’Brien, David J., Sgt., 32471178 (Died during escape attempt) (New York)

Sino-Japanese air operations on October 1, 1943
from
Sino-Japanese Air War 1937 – 1945 (by Håkan Gustavsson)

20 P-40s and P-38 escorting 22 B-24s pounded Haiphong warehouses and harbour.  Some 40 Japanese interceptor rose to meet them in an air battle lasting some 40 minutes.  30 Japanese aircraft were claimed to be shot down (!) for the loss of three P-40s.

2nd Lieutenant Chen Ping-Ching from 75th FS, 23rd FG, was shot down at 15:30 over Haiphong and he bailed out of P-40 42-45906 (MACR 758).  1st Lieutenant Thomas Cotton reported:

“Lt. Chen was flying on my wing when the formation left the target area.  He remained in his position for approximately fifteen (15) minute.  When my flight turned back to protect two straggling bombers, Lt. Chen was missing.”

1st Lieutenant Henry L. Wood (0-789035) from 75th FS, 23rd FG, was also shot down at 15:30 over Haiphong in P-40K-1 42-46250 and was missing (MACR 759).  1st Lieutenant Donald Brookfield reported:

“Lt. Wood was flying on my wing when the bombers went into their run.  I last saw him when the escort made a turn following the bombers from the target. Major Brady (B-24, Flight Commander) states that he saw a P-40 and a zero make a head-on pass; the zero exploded and the P-40 went straight down smoking badly.  This was probably Lt. Wood.  Other bomber crews reported a pilot parachuting from a P-40 shortly after leaving the target.”

The third P-40 crashed-landed and the pilot, Wang Te-Min, was killed.  [Sharks Over China: Lt. Te-Min Wang, CAF, Oct. 1, 1943, “KIFA engine trouble; en route to Haiphong; P-40”]

2nd Lieutenant Akihiko Nishidome (NCO79) of the 25th Sentai and Sergeant Major Yasuo Hasegawa (NCO86) of the 33rd Sentai were killed over Haiphong.

Other References – Books

Cornelius, Wanda, and Short, Thayne, DING HAO – America’s Air War in China – 1937-1945, Pelican Publishing Company, Greta, La., 1980

Jackson, Daniel, Fallen Tiger: The Fate of American’s Missing Airmen in China, Master’s Thesis presented to Faculty of Department of history, Sam Houston State University, Huntsville, Tx., December, 2017

Molesworth, Carl, Sharks over China: The 23rd Fighter Group in World War II, Castle, Edison, N.J., 2001

Molesworth, Carl, 23rd Fighter Group – ‘Chenault’s Sharks’ (Aviation Elite Units 31), Osprey Publishing, Oxford, England, 2009

In Baltic Skies: The Last Flight of Ensign Aleksander Broch, March 15, 1945

Within my ongoing series of posts about the military service of Jews in the Second World War, a frequent thread – specifically for events in 1945 – has been reference to the six reference works created by the late Benjamin Meirtchak, covering Jews in the armed forces of Poland.  Published in Tel-Aviv between 1995 and 2003, Meirtchak’s books encompass virtually every facet of Jewish military service – and Jewish casualties – in Poland’s armed forces, ranging from men who were officers, members of the Polish Resistance, service in the Polish armed forces in exile, POWs captured in the German campaign of late 1939, and, the over 400 Jewish officers murdered during the Katyn Massacre in April and May of 1940.

While Mr. Meirtchak’s works are as invaluable as they are unique, perhaps inevitably – due to the sheer number of names involved – the information within them is typically limited to a man’s name, rank, military unit (that is, for men who served in infantry and armor) year and place of birth, father’s name, and for those men killed in action or who were murdered as POWs – date of death, and if known, place of burial. 

However, there are some men in Meirtchak’s books whose stories – by absence of substantive information – are enigmatic. 

One such man is mentioned in my post covering Jewish military casualties on March 15, 1945: Warrant Officer Aleksander Broch (“Soldiers from New York: Jewish Soldiers in The New York Times, in World War Two: Hospital Apprentice 1st Class Stuart E. Adler – March 15, 1945.), which is limited to the following information:

Polish People’s Army [Ludowe Wojsko Polskie]

Broch, Aleksander, WO, in Poland, at Zachodniopomorskie, Kolobrzeg
Born Sosnowiec, Poland, 1923
Mr. Stanislaw Broch (father)
Kolobrzeg Military Cemetery, Kolobrzeg, Poland
Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: Vol I, p 73

This is how the record for WO Broch appears in Volume II of Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II, in a format and content consistent with other biographical entries…

…while here’s the book’s cover, the plain appearance of which is identical to that of Volumes I, III, and IV.

I’d long assumed that Broch’s story would remain unknown, but fortunately, that supposition has been proven to be incorrect.  The answer to the puzzle was discovered in a very unanticipated source:  The database of Yad Vashem, the Holocaust Remembrance Center of the nation of Israel. 

Though the central focus of Yad Vashem is upon the fate of the civilian Jews of Europe and North Africa during the Shoah, the Center’s archives, which are a historical repository as much as a museum (and far more than a simple museum, at that) comprise a tremendous variety of artifacts, documents, and photographs, that – hailing from the late 30s through the mid-40s – encompass a wide variety of facets of Jewish life, as a civilization, during that time period

In this sense, Yad Vashem possesses a trove of material relating to the military service of Jews in the Allied armed forces during the Second World War, which is accessible – akin to records directly pertaining to the Shoah – by entering search terms in the dark blue banner atop the Center’s home page.  Though the website’s search engine isn’t designed to allow the “Advanced Searches” typical of other digitized archives and repositories, the search records, once returned, can be displayed by order of Relevancy, person’s Name, Photos, the names of Righteous (Among the Nations), Testimonies, Movies and Books, and, Artifacts.  Simultaneously, search results can be filtered by Subject, Source, Rescue Mode, Religion, Profession, Collection, and Language, these seven fields being displayed within the web page’s left sidebar.  Examples are show below… 

✡                                 ✡

Here’s Yad Vashem’s home page.  The search field occupies the horizontal dark blue banner at the top of the page.  Clicking on the small magnifying glass symbol at the right end of the banner transforms it into a search box with text stating “Type and press enter…”

…and here are the 120,652 results generated (in November of 2023) by typing “Jewish Soldiers”.  As can be seen under “Refine and Filter” in the left sidebar, and, record types listed horizontally, results are filtered after searching.     

Here are the total “hits” returned for a variety of searches pertaining to Jews in the military in WW II:

“Jewish Partisans” > 10,600
“Jewish Prisoners of War” > 92,500
“Jewish POWs” > 4,400
“Jewish Brigade” > 3,780
“Jewish Women Soldiers” > 1,695
“Monte Cassino” > 137
“American Jewish Soldiers” > 750
“British Jewish Soldiers” > 2,080
“French Jewish Soldiers” > 880
“Greek Jewish Soldiers” > 145
“Polish Jewish Soldiers” > 13,100
“Russian Jewish Soldiers” > 3,700

An impressive and moving example of the nature of Yad Vashem’s holdings, and, the website’s design and ease directly relate to my June, 2021 post “The Jewish Brigade at War – The Palestine Post, April 13, 1945”, which includes biographical information about Private Asher (Uszer) Goldring [גולדרינג אשר] (PAL/16323).  Presumably captured by the Germans after a night-time battle in the Senin Valley of Italy on March 31, 1945, he was never seen again.  Seventy-eight years later, he is the only fallen member of the Jewish Brigade whose body has never been found.      

Yad Vashem possesses an enormous trove of documents about Asher, as described in this catalog entry:  “Letters related to Asher Goldring, born in Konstantinov, Poland in 1910, and other documentation related to him, his wife Hana (Schmuckler) Goldring, born in Strlishche, Poland in 1910, and their family members, dated 1938-1948”.  The full entry states: “Letters sent to Hana Goldring, regarding the fate of her husband Asher, who made aliya to Eretz Israel as a pioneer and enlisted in the Jewish Brigade.  Included in the letters is notification by the British Ministry of War, dated 13/01/1948, that the soldier Asher Goldring was killed in action; letters sent to Asher and Hana Goldring in the British Mandate for Palestine by their families in Poland in 1938; letters sent by Asher Goldring to his wife Hana while in service as a soldier in the Jewish Brigade, written during 13/01-31/03/1945; poems; a newspaper; drawings by Asher Goldring”. 

Comprised of over 200 items (!), a perusal of these documents reveals the magnitude of the Center’s efforts in processing documents for public access:  The quality of the scans is really excellent.  (I’d like to translate them, as they embody a story that merits telling.  But, they’re all in Hebrew.  Oh … well.)

A few other examples of Yad Vashem’s records about the military service of Jews in World War Two include documents pertaining to…

Juda Waterman (B-25 Mitchell pilot in No. 320 (Netherlands) Squadron, RAF)

Naum Naumovich Rabinovich (Yak fighter pilot and ace in 513th Fighter Aviation Regiment (see also), 331st Fighter Aviation Division, 2nd Air Army, Soviet Air Force), a “Refusenik” in the 1980s.  Possible future post.  (Who knows?)

Semion Yakovlevich Krivosheev (Il-2 Shturmovik aerial gunner in 810th Attack Aviation Regiment, 225th Attack Aviation Division, 15th Air Army, Soviet Air Force, who, having been shot down and captured on July 18, 1944, was one of the extraordinarily few Russian Jewish aviators to have survived the war as a POW of the Germans.)  Possible future post.  (Who knows?)

Testimony of Miroslav Sigut…  (Born in Dobratice, Czechoslovakia, 1917, regarding his experiences in Krakow, as a French Foreign Legion soldier in France and as a Czechoslovakian Army soldier in England.”  Includes comments about Squadron Leader Otto Smik of No. 312 and (later) 127 Squadrons, RAF.)

Those just scratch the surface, of the surface.  (Of, the surface.)

✡                                 ✡

And so, what of Aleksander Broch?

On a whim, I searched for information about “Jewish Pilots”, and was more than startled to find the following: “Confirmation of the service of Aleksander Broch as a pilot in the Polish Army and his having been declared missing during a campaign conducted 15 March 1945; excerpt from the “Polska Zbrojna” newspaper regarding the memoirs of Polish pilots, dated 18 March 1947”. 

Another document about Broch is the “Page of Testimony” that was filed in his memory by his father Stanislaus (Shmuel Barukh), on July 8, 1955, while the latter was residing in Israel.  The aforementioned web page for this document incorrectly lists Aleksander’s date of death as “13/3/1945” and status as “murdered”.

And then…  I remembered my post pertaining to the events of March 15, 1945. 

And then…  I duck-duck-goed “Aleksander Broch”, and was once again startled:  A biography of the pilot by Wojciech Zmyślony appears at Polish Air Force.pl, along with Broch’s portrait.  Zmyślony’s account being invaluable and unavailable elsewhere, I thought it merited presentation “here”, to make the story relevant to a wider audience. 

To that end, a the translation of follows below.  This is followed by two documents about Broch at from Yad Vashem, which are alluded to in Mr. Zmyślony’s list of references. 

One document is the article “Wings over Kołobrzeg – Memories of the fights of Polish pilots”, published in Polska Zbrojna (Armed Poland) on March 18, 1947, while the other is a letter by chaplain M. Rodzai to W/O Broch’s father Stanislaw.  For the purposes of this post, the English-language translation of each document appears first, and then, a transcript of the document in the original.  (Well, as best as I could transcribe them!)  

Accompanying the Polska Zbrojna article are four maps showing locations of places mentioned in Mr. Zmyślony’s story, and, the Polska Zbrojna article itself. 

✡                                 ✡

So to start, here’s Wojciech Zmyślony’s biography of Aleksander Broch, which includes a portrait of Broch – below – provided by fellow pilot Kazimierz Rutenberg; a fellow pilot in the 1st Fighter Aviation Regiment “Warszawa”; see The Direction Was Clear (Kierunek był Jasny), by Kazimierz Rutenberg.  Wojciech’s article in the original Polish can be viewed here, at Polish Air Force.  

The biography…

Aleksander Broch

– .ת.נ.צ.ב.ה. –
…Tehé Nafshó Tzrurá Bitzrór Haḥayím
May his soul be bound up in the bond of everlasting life.

Aleksander Broch was born on February 9, 1923 in Przemyśl.  His parents were Jews from Warsaw: his father, Samuel Broch, earned his living as a merchant, and his mother, Perla Lea née Pillersdorf, took care of the house.  Later, Samuel changed his name to Stanisław, and returned to its original Hebrew form – Szmuel – after emigrating to Israel after the war.  The mother later also Hebrewized her name to Pnina.  Aleksander, still as a child (at the age of 10 or earlier), moved with his family to Sosnowiec.  There he attended a primary school, and then the Jewish Co-educational Gymnasium of doctor Henryk Liberman.  The Brochs – parents, Aleksander and his younger sister – lived in a tenement house at the market square in Sosnowiec.  The friendship between two later aviators of the 1st Fighter Aviation Regiment “Warszawa”, raised in Sosnowiec, dates from this period: Broch and Kazimierz Rutenberg, a year younger than him.

When in September 1939 the Third Reich invaded Poland, the Brochs fled east.  After the September Campaign, they had no reason to return to Sosnowiec, incorporated by Hitler’s decree into the Third Reich.  Choosing between two evils, they stayed in Lviv, occupied by the Soviet Union, where at least they did not have to fear Nazi persecution on the basis of their nationality.  It is not known what Aleksander Broch did in Lwów; he probably attended school.  Less than two years later, he was once again forced to flee from the Germans, when on June 22, 1941, Germany attacked the USSR.  Persuaded by his father, he decided to go deep into Russia.  When Lviv was occupied by Wehrmacht troops on June 30, the 18-year-old boy was already somewhere else.  He was not imprisoned or repressed and presumably worked in kolkhozes.  For unknown reasons, he failed to join the Polish Army, formed from July 1941 under the orders of General Władysław Anders (perhaps he was rejected as a Jew).  This army finally left the Soviet Union in September 1942, also taking tens of thousands of civilians with it.

After the Polish troops were moved to Persia (i.e.  today’s Iran), repressions were intensified against the Polish citizens remaining in the USSR, imposing, among other things, Soviet citizenship and making it impossible to leave Soviet territories.  So Broch decided to get to the Polish Armed Forces in the West on his own.  He hoped to reach British-controlled India by way of Afghanistan.  He failed to implement this idea.  He crossed the border of Afghanistan, but was injured by wild animals there and turned back west to the Turkmen Soviet Socialist Republic.

A few months after the departure of General Anders’ troops to Persia, the formation of the Polish Army began once again.  Commanded by General Zygmunt Berling, who was loyal to the Soviets, it was soon to go to the front in accordance with Stalin’s plans.  In response to the recruitment to the army, Broch volunteered in the first months of 1943 at the recruitment commission in the city of Jolotan, in the Marian district, on the edge of the Karakum desert.  Like all recruits, he was sent to Sielce nad Oką, about 30 km north-west of Ryazan, where the 1st Infantry Division of Tadeusz Kosciuszko.  To reach his destination, Broch had to cover a distance of nearly 4,000 kilometers.  During the journey he made with a couple of companions, he got rid of the rest of his possessions, replacing, among others, clothes for salt, which he managed to sell at a large profit elsewhere, where it was considered a luxury item.  This provided him with the funds needed to reach his destination.

In Sielce, Broch initially joined the infantry.  There, he unexpectedly met a friend from his youth, Kazimierz Rutenberg.  Their paths parted again, but this time for a short time: Rutenberg was assigned to the anti-tank artillery, and Broch (who could ride a motorcycle) was assigned to the communications service in the 1st Tank Regiment.  When the air force recruitment was announced in Sielce, both Broch and Rutenberg applied.  After a successful medical examinations, at the beginning of August 1943 they were transferred to the nearby Grigoriewskoje, where the Air Squadron of the 1st Infantry Division named after Tadeusz Kosciuszko.  On August 20, the Polish squadron was expanded to a full-time regiment, and on October 6, 1943, it officially adopted the name: 1st Fighter Aviation Regiment “Warszawa”.

In Grigorievskoye, students began pilot training in difficult conditions.  The pace was very fast – training (including theory) in the field of basic pilotage and fighter specialization was planned for only ten months.  Theoretical lectures were conducted in Russian, and the list of subjects included: air navigation, airframe construction, engine construction, theory of flight, aerial shooting, aviation tactics, radio communication and parachute training.  After theory, it was time for practice.  Basic pilotage was trained on light UT-2 training aircraft.  The next step was training on twin-steered Yak-7Vs (similar in construction to the target fighter on which the pilots of “Warszawa” were to fly), and finally launching and training in air combat, shooting and aerobatics on the Yak-1b.

On May 28, 1944, Broch was promoted to ensign, which was the first officer rank in the Polish People’s Army.  In August 1944, the regiment was moved to the Gostomel airport near Kiev (now the airport of the capital of Ukraine), and at the beginning of June 1944 to the village of Dys near Lublin.  It was the regiment’s first airport in Poland.  In Dysa, several more experienced pilots joined the unit, and on August 18, 1944, the planes flew to Zadybie Stary, from which combat flights finally began.  When the regiment left for the front, Broch was assigned to the position of the pilot of the 2nd squadron.

On August 23, 1944, the pilots of the 1st Regiment were baptized by fire.  Broch had to wait nearly a month for his first combat assignment.  On September 19, his plane took off from Zadybie Stary together with five other Yaks to cover eight Il-2s from the 611th Air Assault Regiment, attacking targets in the area of the south-eastern outskirts of Warsaw.  The next flight, exactly 10 days later, consisted in the escort of a single Il-2 reconnaissance over the left-bank Warsaw by a pair of Yaks.  On this assignment, Broch used his on-board weapons the enemy for the first time, firing at ground targets.  It was one of the few tasks that the pilots of the 1st Regiment could perform over the insurgent capital…  Unfortunately, it was already dying at the time, as providing effective help to the insurgents was definitely prevented by Stalin’s cynical decisions.

Broch performed another task on October 15, escorting with three other Yaks a group of six Il-2s attacking targets in the area of Nowodwory, Winnica and Jabłonna.  During this flight, Focke-Wulf 190s were spotted flying in the distance, but no combat took place.  A similar flight – an escort of a pair of Il-2s for reconnaissance of the Poniatów-Suchocin-Jabłonna-Legionowo area – Broch made on October 27, firing again on the ground targets he encountered.  On November 8, he flew for reconnaissance north of Warsaw, in the area of Jabłonna, Modlin and Olszewnica.  Two Messerschmitt 109s were encountered in the air, but there was no combat as the fighters moved away.  Broch, however, dived and strafed the ground targets he spotted.  On 20, 22 and 25 November, he flew for visual reconnaissance, respectively: Jabłonna-Nowy Dwór-Leszna-Grądowa, Jabłonna-Nasielska-Kroczewa-Leszna-Warszawy-Błonia and Mokotów-Grodziska-Błonia-Piaseczno.  During the second of these flights, he attacked air defense positions, and during the third – German motor vehicles.  It was Broch’s last combat task in 1944.  The longer break was related to the stopping of the front near Warsaw on the Vistula River.

Broch completed the next three tasks only in 1945, on January 19-20, after the capture of Warsaw.  The first was to cover the parade of the 1st Polish Army, which marched along the ruined Aleje Jerozolimskie.  Broch flew in a formation of six planes, led by the regiment commander, Lt. Col. Ivan Taldykin.  On the same day, he flew to the air cover of his own troops in the area of Warsaw-Błonie and crossing the Vistula north of Warsaw.  The next day he conducted another patrol over the capital itself.

After this series of tasks, the regiment again had a break in combat tasks.  At that time, it was moved to the Sanniki airport near Gostynin, and then to Bydgoszcz, from where flights were started to support the 1st Army of the Polish Army fighting to break the Pomeranian Wall.  On February 20, Broch was covering a pair of Il-2s flying towards Złocieniec.  At the local railway station, four trains without steam locomotives were spotted.  Broch dived and strafed both the trains and the station.  Five days later, he flew for visual and photographic reconnaissance of railway traffic in the area of Szczecinek, Grzmiaca, Barwice, Połczyn Zdrój and Czaplinek.  During the task, he attacked trains at Dalęcino and Grzmiąc stations, and two cars near Czaplinek, which were damaged.  On February 27, he performed a similar task in the area of Drawsko Pomorskie and Złocieniec.  And this time he shot at the train at the station in Złocieniec, defended by a battery of anti-aircraft guns.

On March 1, Broch completed the last mission from Sanniki, escorting eight Il-2s to the Wierzchów area.  He himself also used on-board weapons, attacking infantry in the trenches near Żabin.  Two days later, the 1st Regiment was moved to the recently captured Mirosławiec airport, from which the unit took part in further flights to support the 1st Polish Army fighting to capture Kołobrzeg.  From there, on March 11, 1945, Broch flew in the cover of four Il-2s over “Festung Kolberg”, i.e. stubbornly defended by Wehrmacht troops (including navy and air force) and Waffen SS Kołobrzeg.  The ground guidance station warned that Focke-Wulfs might appear in the air, but the pilots saw no sign of enemy aircraft.

On March 15, 1945, Broch took off at 11:20 at the controls of Yak-9M No. 81 [serial number 3315381, via ARMA HOBBY News Blog] as side [wingman] to second lieutenant Vsevolod Bobrowski.  It was his 17th combat flight and – as it turned out – the last.  The task of the pair was to patrol the skies over Kołobrzeg in order to provide cover for Il-2 Shturmoviks, which were to attack ground targets.  Over the coast, Broch separated from Bobrowski and disappeared.  His leader circled for a long time looking for the wingman, returning to base on the last of the fuel after 2 hours and 45 minutes of flight.  To this day, it is not clear what happened to the pilot.  For years, it was reported in the literature that he was lost in the waves of the Baltic Sea, which, however, is not true, because his body was found and buried.

Ensign Aleksander Broch rests in a mass grave of soldiers of the Polish People’s Army at the War Cemetery in Kołobrzeg.

Wojciech Zmyślony

Sources:

Photo from the collection of Mr. Kazimierz Rutenberg
Documents from the Registry Office in Przemyśl
Documents from the Yad Vashem Institute in Jerusalem
Bulzacki Z., Logbook of flights and combat and reconnaissance reports of the 1st Regiment “Warszawa”, b.w., Poznań 1976
Sławiński K., The First Hunter, Publishing House MON, Warsaw 1980

✡                                 ✡

This representative image of Yak-1B fighters (not the Yak-which was piloted by Ensign Broch, though the general appearance is very similar) of “Warszawa” is from “Four Fours” at Arma Hobby’s News Blog.  Caption: “Jak-1b No 4, 1 eskadra (squadron) of the 1 Regiment piloted by chor. pil. Edward Chromy.  In the background is the aeroplane No 13 from 2 eskadra.  Artwork by Marcin Górecki.”

Here’s a translation of Polska Zbrojna’s 1947 article about Broch’s last mission.  The translation is followed by four maps, a transcript of the article in Polish, and then, an image of the article.

Wings over Kołobrzeg
Memories of the Fights of Polish Pilots

Armed Poland
March 18, 1947

For half an hour now, Bobrowski and Broch have been cruising over the rough waves, looking for enemy sea transports heading for Kolobrzeg, which is besieged by the First Army.  Strong winds and driving winds carrying fog make patrolling difficult.  At times the world becomes completely dark with clouds floating low over the horizon.  The sea is empty.  Don’t see any movement on it.  Pilots’ eyes, accustomed to the brightness of the landscape, become tired and tired from constant looking.  Second after second, builds into a long rosary of minutes.  No; no change.  Suddenly, Broch’s hawk-like gaze notices, beneath the dark, blurred horizon, several black, monotonous lines swinging on the perpetually wavering waves.

– Transport! – he shouts over the radio to Bobrowski.  In an instant, he notices the barely visible ships.  There’s three of them.  In the depths of the water, near the ships, the spindly shapes of two submarines escorting the transport glide.  Direction: Kolobrzeg.

And now let’s get to work, until they are spotted, until they can take a closer look at the German transports, until the on-board artillery responds.  They made their way through the fog and rain and went two stones [?] down, straight towards the steamships. – One larger one with a characteristic bulge in the hull – a tanker; two smaller ones, full of equipment and combat reinforcements, filled to the decks – he calculates quickly.  Bobrowski and pulls the [control] stick slightly so as not to fall into the ship’s large, smoking stack.  And Broch is already playing with his “machines” [machine guns] on the decks; on the sides, on the stacks – a hurricane is breaking through the sky after the Germans who were not expecting an attack.  A few more series – a faint flash down below.

The fire smolders for a while; twitches awkwardly.  Will it go off?  [Will it explode?]  As if in response, a terrible shock shook the air; the air heaved and vibrated with smoke and fire.  It’s getting hot.  The middle ship carrying gasoline disappeared from the sea surface.  It sank into the depths.  Only in the place where the ship was swinging in front of the waves in the waves, the sea was strangely luminous, full of long spots burning with luxuriant flame.  A strange and terrible, unforgettable image of the burning sea.

That’s enough for today! – Bobrowski shouts with joy and, under heavy fire from the artillery of the remaining ships [?], they return to the shore to submit a report to the command.

Sending shturmoviks now! – he says to Broch, strangely unenthusiastic about the success he has just achieved.  Bobrowski, concerned about his friend’s silence, exhorts on the radio:

Did the eagle become so silent as if he had drunk German gasoline?  But Broch is silent.  Only after a while, when they reach the coast, his voice is heard in the host’s headphones:  Listen, if something happens to me, write home to [?] parents, okay?

Bobrowski suffers.  He thinks for a moment; his thoughts come together.  Then he bursts out: Whatever comes to mind, don’t stop the _____! – and listen to the _____.  But Broch is silent.

The weather is deteriorating with every moment. Immediately after passing the coastal strip, they fall into such fog that they lose themselves completely.  Conscious, attentive to everything, the patrol commander takes a sharp 180-degree turn, trying to turn around and avoid the fog sideways.  Broch flies on.  Bobrowski, terrified by his friend’s absence, constantly calls on him to change course like he did.  The pilot hears him, faintly at first, but he does not respond.  And the fog grows and then disappears.  Just a moment and you won’t be able to turn back.  When this difficult moment passes, Broch is gone.

This is Bobrowski…  This is Bobrowski…  I’m going to pick up… – Broch…  Broch…  Where are you? – a dramatic question flies into space.  Out of nowhere, as if out of this world, the answer comes back.

No, I can’t see!  I don’t know where I am!  Light!…

Keep to the seashore! – advises the concerned friend, because in the meantime he is losing his orientation, unable to find any point of support on the ground covered with spring snow.  Not a single river down there, but full of ash-covered railway junctions and forests.  Forest everywhere.  Minute by minute passes.  Broch no longer responds to the radio signal at all.

Apparently he went over the sea – Bobrowski thought and, afraid of the tentacles of fog that were covering him more and more and unable to determine exactly where he was – he was heading south.

After ten minutes of flight in difficult weather conditions, he suddenly jumped out of the clouds over a German city, next to which there was a lake.  Following the characteristic, broken shoreline of the lake, which he knew from the flight routes in this area, he realized that he was over Walcz, located at the intersection of large roads, 30 km away from the home airport in Frydland [Pravdinsk].

After reporting to the headquarters of the unit and reporting on the flight, attack aircraft of the 3rd Assault Aviation Regiment accompanied by fighters were immediately sent over Kolobrzeg.  They destroyed the German sea transport, which sank at the very entrance of the port.

And Broch?  He left his combat flight for Poland on Saturday, March 15, 1945, and did not return.  And the Baltic Sea jealously guards its secrets.

Five days later, after this combat flight, Kolobrzeg fell and was captured by the soldiers of the First Polish Army.

K. Gozdziewki, second lieutenant

The Baltic Sea relative to Poland, Russia, Latvia, Sweden, Denmark, and Germany, with Kolobrzeg in the map’s lower center.

A “close-up” of Kolobrzeg and nearby Polish coastline.

Kolobrzeg, showing Walcz to the south-southeast.

Kolobrzeg, with Walcz denoted by the circle to the south-southeast, and the location of Frydland (Pravdinsk), southeast of Kaliningrad, to the east.  Though the Polska Zbrojna article indicates that the latter two locations are 30 kilometers from one another, in reality, they’re much (much) farther apart.

Skrzydła nad Kołobrzegiem
Wspomnienia z walk polskich pilotów

Polska Zbrojna
March 18, 1947

Już od pól godziny kraża Bobrowski i Broch nad wzburzonymi falami w poszukiwaniu nieprzyjacielskich transportów morskich dażacych do oblężonego przez l Armie – Kolobrzegu.  Silny wiatr i zacinajacy, niosacy ze soba mgle wiatr ultrudniaja patrolowanie.  Chwilami na świecie robi sie zupelnie ciemno od sunacych nisko nad horzyontem – chmur.  Morze jest puste.  Nie wiadę na nim zadnego ruchu.  Oczy pilotów przyzwyczajene od zrólany krajobrazow nuża sie i mecza od ciaglego wypatrywania.  Sekunda uplywa za sekunda narastajac w dlugi różaniec minut.  Nie, żadnej zmainy.  Nagle sokoli wrzok Brocha sposlrzega hen pod ciemna, zamazana linia horyzontu kilka czarnych, jednostajnych kresek rozhuśtanych na wieczystej chwiejbie fal.

– Transport! – krzyczy przez radio do Bobrowskiego.  Ten w jednej chwili dostrzega, ledwie widocżene statki.  Jest ich trzy.  W glebi wody, w poblizu statków suna wrzecionowete ksztnity dwóch lodzi podwodnych eskortujacych transport.  Kiorunek: Kolobrzeg.

A teraz do dziela, póki ich nie spostrzezono, póki moga przyjrzeć sie dokladniej, z bliska, niemieckim transportowcom, poki nie odezwie sie artyleria pokladowa.  Przerżneli sie przez mgly i deszcz i poszli jak dwa kamienie w dól, prosto na sunace parowce. – Jeden wiekszy z charakterystycznym wybrzuszeniem kadluba – cysterna, dwa mniejsze, pelne sprzetu i posilków bojowych, zapelnione aż po pklady – oblicza szybko.  Bobrowski i sciaga lekko drazek na siebie azeby nie wpakować sie na wielki, dymiacy komin statku.  A Broch już gra ze swoich „maszynek“ po pokladach; po burtach, po kominach – przewala sie pak nuragan po niesposdziewajacych sie ataku szwabach.  Jeszece kilka serii – nikly blysk w dole.

Ogień tli sie chwile, pelza niezdarnie drga.  Zgaśnie?  Jakby w ódpowiedzi powietrzem targa potworny wstrzas powietme laluje i drga od dymu j zara.  Robi sie goraco.  Środkowy statek wiozacy benzyne – znikl z powierzchni morza.  Zapadl sie w glab.  Tylko na mieiscu, gdzie przedtyni huśtal sie w przyplywach fal statek, morze bylo dziwnie świetliste, pelne dlustych plam palacych sie bujnyn piomieniem.  Dziwny i straszny, mezapomnlany obraz palacego sie morza.

Na dzisiaj wyzarczy! – wrzeszczy z radoni Bobrowski i pod silnym obstnalem artyleril pozostalych okreów zawracajo do brzegu, ażeb zlożyć raport dowództwu.

Zaraz wyśla szurmowców! – mówi do Brocha, dóry dziwnie nie entuzjazmuje sie odniesionym przed chwila sukcesem.  Bobrowski zaniepokoony milczeniem kolegi nalega przez radio:

Cos tak zamilkl ragle jakbyś napil sie benzyny nienieckiej?  Lecz Broch milczy.  Dopiero po chwili, gdy dolatuja uż do wybrzeża odzywa sie jego glos w sluchawkach prowadzicego: Sluchajl Gdyby _e ze mna cós stalo napisz do domu, do rodżicow, dobrze?

Bobrowski cierpnie.  Chwile zastanawia sie, zbiena myśli.  Po tym wybucha: Co_i_do glowy przyszlo nie zawrazaj gitary!  – i nadsluchuje pinie.  Lecz Broch milczy.

Pogoda psuje sie z każda chwila Zaraz po minec u pasa nadbrzeznego wpadaja w takamgle, że traca siebie z oezu zupelnie Przytomny baczny n wszystko dowodea patrolu kiadze sie w ostry skreto 180 st. próbujac zawrócić i ominać mgle bokiem.  Broch leci dalej.  Bobrowski przerażony nieobecnościa kolegi nawoluje go bez przerwy, ażeby zmienil tak jak i on kurs.  Pilot sluszy go, wptawdzie slabo, ale slyszy i nie odpowida.  A mgla rośnie, poteż nieje.  Jeszcze chwila i nie bedzie można już zawrocic.  Gdy mija ta ciezka chwila, Broche nie ma.

Ja Bobrowski… ja Bobrowski… przechodze na odbiór… – Broch… Broch… gdzie jesteś? – leci w przestrzeń dramatyezne pytanie.  Skadś z daieka, jakby juz nie z tego świata wraca odpowiedż.

Nie nie widze!  Nie wiem, gdzie jestem!  Bladze!

Trzymaj sie brzegu morskiego morza! – radzi zatroskany kolega, bo w miedzyczasie sam traci orientacje, nie mogac znależć na zasnutej wiosenna sazruga ziemi żadnego punktu oparcia.   Ani jednej rzeki, tam w dole, pelno zato popiatanych wezlów kolejowych i lasy.  Wszedzie las.  Mija minuta za minuta.  Broch nie odpowiada juz wcale na sygnal radia.

Widocznie poszedi nad morze – mysil Bobrowski i rainiac sie przed zalewajacymi go coraz bardziej mackami mgly i nie mogac ustalić dokladnie gdzie sie znajudje – bierze kurs na poludnie.

Po dziesieciu minutach lotu w cieżkich warunkach atmosferycznych wyskoczyi nagle z chmur nad jakims miastem niemieckim, obok ktorego znajdowalo sie jezioro.  Po charakterystycznej, lamanej linii brzegow jeziora, ktore znat z poprze laieb przelotow w tym rejonie uzmyslowil sobie, że znajduje sie nad Walczem leżacym na skrzyzowaniu wielkich dróg w odlegiośei 30 km. od [błąd!] macierzystgo iotniska we Frydladzie [Pravdinsk].

Po zameldowaniu sie w sztabie jednosiki i zadniu relacji z lotu, wyslano natychmiast nad Kolobrzeg szturmowce 3 Pulku Lotnictwa Szturmowego w asyśnie mysliwców.  Dokonaly one dziela zniszczenia niemieckiego transportu morskiego, który zatonal u samego wejścia portu.

A Broch?  Wylecial do swego lotu bojovego dla Polski w sebote dnia 15 marca 1945 r. i nie wrócil.  A Baltyk strzeże zazdrośnie swoich tajemnic.

W pieć dni póżniej po tym locie bojowym padl Kolobrzeg zdobyty przez żolnierzy I Armi W.P.

K. Gożdziewki, ppor.

The article, from Yad Vashem…

✡                                 ✡

Here’s Chaplain Rozdai’s letter to Aleksander father Stanislaus…

For
Citizen Stanislaw Broch

in Sosnowiec, 20 Targowa Street

According to the letter of the 1st Fighter Aviation Regiment No. 898/I of August 10, 1945 I will inform you that the son of the citizen, ensign pilot Broch Aleksander, took an active part in the fight against the Germans in the 1st Belarusian Front and on March 15, 1945, he flew on reconnaissance and disappeared without a trace.

At the same time, I am enclosing a certificate attesting to the amount of monthly salaries received by warrant officer Aleksander, issued by Lieutenant Myśliwski.

1 enclosure

Supplementary District Commandant

M. RODZAI
Chaplain

…and, the document in the original Polish.

Do
Ob. [Obywatel] Brocha Stanisława

w Sosnowcu, ul. [ulica] Targowa 20

Zgndnie z pismem l Pulku Lotnictwa Myśliwskiego Nr 898/I z dnia 10 sierpnia 1945 Pr. zawiadsmiem, że syn Obywatela chorazy pilot Broch Aleksander brał czynny udział w walce z Niemcami na l-szym Białoruskim Froncie i w dniu 15 marca 1945 r. poleciał na wywiad i przepad ł ben wieści.

Równocześnie przesyłam w załaczeniu zaświadczenie atwierd za jace wysokość pobiernayc_ poborów miesioczynch przez chor. proc__ Aleksandra, wystawione przez l p. Letn-Myśliwskiego.

1 zał. [załącznik]

Rejenowy Komedant Uzupełnienie

M. RODZAI
Kaplian

The original document, from Yad Vashem…

One reference…

Meirtchak, Benjamin, Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: I – Jewish Soldiers and Officers of the Polish People’s Army Killed and Missing in Action 1943-1945, World Federation of Jewish Fighters Partisans and Camp Inmates: Association of Jewish War Veterans of the Polish Armies in Israel, Tel Aviv, Israel, 1994

The Invisible Airmen – The Invisible Jews: Captain Seymour M. Malakoff and the Crew of C-47 “Butchski II”, 1944

“…the fact that its entire crew of five are all from New York.”

_______________

Definitions of the phrase “New Yorker”…

… at Wordnik:
“a native or resident of New York (especially of New York City)”


… at Cambridge Dictionary:
“someone from the US city of New York”

“someone from the US state of New York”

…at Collins Dictionary:
1. a.  “of the state of New York”

1. b.  “of the city of New York”
2. a.  “a person born or living in the state of New York”
2. b. ” a person born or living in the city of New York”

______________________________

My prior post, The Invisible Sailor – The Invisible Jew?, concerning Warner Brothers’ 1943 film about the United States submarine service, Destination Tokyo, focuses on a fascinating scene that arrives at the film’s halfway point.  After “Mike”, one of the sub’s crew, is murdered – quite literally stabbed in the back – by a Japanese fighter pilot ostensibly in the act of surrender, the Greek-American sailor “Tin-Can” (played by Dane Clark, actual name Bernard Elliot Zanville) is unwilling and unable to attend the former’s funeral.  Tin-Can’s absence from the ceremony sparks anger and shock from his fellow crew members, who take deep offense at his detached and seemingly passive reaction to the death of a fellow crewman.  Then, with great and increasing intensity, Tin-Can explains the reason for his absence.  He relates how the suffering of his family in German-occupied Greece – particularly the murder of his kindly philosopher uncle – has become the central motivation for his military service, which is a form of patriotism and deeply personal – if not familial and ethnic – revenge against the Axis.  In a story otherwise devoted to action, adventure, drama, and occasional moments of levity (what, with Alan Hale, Sr.!), Tin-Can’s speech grounds the film upon a plane of seriousness and depth.

But, I believe there was a story behind Tin-Can’s story.  As I explain fully in the post, given the ownership of the studio that produced the film, as well as identity of some of the writers, producers, and actors involved in the movie’s creation – let alone the time-frame of the film’s release – I believe that the writers and producers of Destination Tokyo used Tin-Can’s speech as a disguised soliloquy about the fate of of the Jews of Europe.  The proviso being of course, that unapologetically and explicitly drawing attention to the fate of the Jews of Europe in the context of fighting the Axis powers, in a form of popular entertainment created for a nationwide audience, was – in the Hollywood of 1943 – perceived as being anathema, in terms of cultural, social, and professional acceptability.

Anyway, Destination Tokyo was a movie; a story; fiction, in which reality lay behind a cloak of invisibility.  

In the world of life; of fact; of literature and journalism, there are other forms of invisibility; even if unintentional; even if benign.  But, just as in Destination Tokyo, the absence of a fact can “speak” far more loudly and leave a far deeper impression, than if it is mentioned … even if briefly, even if fleetingly, even if in passing.  This will reveal more about the writer, publisher, and tenor of the times, than the story itself.  Such was the case of a news item published in The New York Times in early 1944…  

But first, by way of explanation:

Many of my posts on this blog – an ongoing series as it were?! – focus on the military service of Jewish soldiers during the Second World War.  These are centered around news items about Jewish military casualties from the New York metropolitan area, which were published in The New York Times, in the final two years – 1944 and 1945 – of that global conflict. 

Appearing under the heading “Jewish Soldiers in The New York Times in WW II”, I’ve created about forty such posts as of the completion of “this” post in mid-July of 2023.  As explained more fully at Soldiers from New York: Jewish Soldiers in The New York Times, in World War Two, the now-distant impetus for this effort was my review of every issue (seriously!) of the Times published between late 1940 and 1946 for any news item related to the military service of Jewish soldiers during that time.  (I did this in the 1990s by reviewing the Times on 35mm microfilm.  Lots and lots of microfilm.  Did I say lots?  Lots!The goal of this endeavor was to learn about the experience and thoughts of Jewish soldiers in the Armed forces of the Allies in the context of the Shoah, and, the historical experience of the Jewish people during that awful, complex, and transformative time.

I thought – when I began this research three now-seemingly-distant decades ago – given the Times being a newspaper headquartered in Manhattan, with the New York metro area then being the demographic “center” of Jewish life in the United States, that the newspaper would occasionally feature news items about the implications or aspects of Jewish military service during the war, even if in passing: even if tangentially; even only hesitantly.  Well, was I wrong about that.  Very wrong.  Completely wrong; completely-upending-your-assumptions and jaw-droppingly kind of wrong. 

Certainly news about American Jewish servicemen (and on vanishingly rare occasions, Jewish soldiers in the armies of other Allied nations) appeared in the Times, but this facet … or central aspect? … of their identity was never a focus of the paper’s reporting, assuming it fell into the awareness of the paper’s journalists and editors to begin with.  Well…  Given the history of the Times, the prevailing self-perception of the Jews of America at that time, and, the nature of the times (pun entirely intended), perhaps this was inevitable.  An example of this, from early 1944, follows…

On February 4 of that year, this article, by an anonymous Times correspondent, appear in the first section of the newspaper:

FIVE NEW YORKERS ON INVASION PLANE

Crew of Butchski Plan to Run ‘Overseas Branch of the Bronx Express’

By Cable to THE NEW YORK TIMES.

AT A UNITED STATES TROOP CARRIER COMMAND STATION in Britain, Feb. 3 – All the twin-engined transport planes on this station look alike in their grubby green-brown war paint, but one is really different.  Its two chief points of difference are the white lettered name Butchski on the nose and the fact that its entire crew of five are all from New York.

When the invasion starts and the troop-carrier command begins shuttling combat soldiers from bases to actual fighting fronts Butchski will become an “overseas branch of the Bronx Express,” according to its crew.  Every member of the crew agrees the service will be strictly “express.”

The skipper of Butchski is quiet, youthful-looking Capt. E.M. Malakoff of 60 East Ninety-fourth Street, Manhattan.  A graduate of Penn State and New York University Law School, he passed the New York bar examination in 1941.

He is only 27 years old now, but handles the transport plane as if he had been flying it all his life.  The plane is named for his 9-year-old brother James, whose nickname is Butchski.

Co-Pilot “Typical New Yorker”

Lieut. James P. Wilt of 538 East Sixteenth Street is co-pilot.  He maintains he is the most typical New Yorker because he was born in Dayton, Ohio, twenty-five years ago and moved to New York to attend New York University after having gone to the University of Cincinnati.  After finishing school he worked in radio before joining the Army.  His father and mother, Mr. and Mrs. Noble Wilt, now live in Troy, Ohio, with his younger brother and sister.

Flight Officer Saul Bush, who is 25 years old and lives at 1749 Grand Concourse, the Bronx, is the navigator of Butchski.  He insists his chef distinction is that he is the only married man in the crew and he feels sorry because the other members will never be able to marry a girl as incomparable as his wife, Beatrice, who lives in the Bronx.  He attended De Witt Clinton High School and City College in New York.

Staff Sgt. David Lifschutz, who says he “was born, reared and hopes to die” in New York, is the fourth member of the crew.  He is only 21.  His home is 32-17 Seventy-seventh Street, Jackson Heights, and for years before he joined the Army he used to hang around La Guardia Field hoping to be a flier one day.  He attended Long Island City High School and his parents still live at the Seventy-seventh Street address.

Youngest Member Is 20

Staff Sgt. Lester Leftkowitz [sic], who attended Morris High School and lived at 586 Southern Boulevard, the Bronx, with his parents, Mr. and Mrs. Samuel H. Lefkowitz, is the fifth and youngest member of the crew.  He is just 20 years old.

The job of Butchski is to haul paratroops and tow gliders loaded with airborne fighting men to fighting areas when the invasion starts.  They all realize it is a tough job, but one that has to be done, and they are just waiting until the time comes to do it.

Here’s how the article appeared in the paper:

______________________________

Biographical information about each of these men follows below.  (A minor caveat:  “Letfkowitz” is actually “Lefkowitz”.)  As will soon be evident as you scroll through this lengthy post, Captain Malakoff was killed in action, but every member of his crew survived the war.  With the significant caveat, that Staff Sergeant Lifschutz was shot down and taken prisoner of war in late December of 1944, during the Battle of the Bulge.

And so, Butchski’s crew:  

Pilot: Capt. Seymour M. Malakoff, 0-660774, Air Medal, Purple Heart
Mr. and Mrs. Jacob John (3/6/91-6/14/55) and Vera (Ida) (Partman) (7/12/90-11/18/43) Malakoff, 60 East 94th St., New York, N.Y.
James Leonard “Butchski” Malakoff (brother) (6/20/33-7/24/07)
Born New Haven, Ct., 10/24/16
The New York Times 2/4/44, 6/27/44
Casualty List 7/25/44
Forvarts 6/29/44

Co-Pilot: Lieutenant James Philip Wilt
Mr. and Mrs. Walter Noble (5/21/93-1984) and Katherine (Harper) (Folckemer) (1/4/93-12/29/61) Wilt (parents)
Robert N. Wilt (brother) (1/6/30-7/2/60), 234 South Plum St., Troy, Oh.
Wartime residence: 538 East 16th St., New York, N.Y.
Born Dayton, Oh., 4/2/18; Died 12/13/78
Riverside Cemetery, Troy, Oh. – Section 1, North West Corner

Navigator: Flight Officer Saul Bush
Mrs. Beatrice (Rosen) Bush (wife), 1749 Grand Concourse, Bronx, N.Y.
Mr. and Mrs. Alfred and Dora (Stein) Bush (parents), 2101 Morris St., New York, N.Y.
Born New York, N.Y., 6/29/19; Died 10/20/04
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

Radio Operator: S/Sgt. David Lifschutz, 12147259, Air Medal Three Oak Leaf Clusters, Purple Heart
Mr. and Mrs. Ephraim (“Frank”?) and Claire Lifschutz (parents), 32-17 77th St., Jackson Heights, N.Y.
Born New York, N.Y., 6/3/22
Casualty List 6/13/45
Long Island Star Journal 4/14/45, 6/14/45
American Jews in World War II – 381

Crew Chief: S/Sgt. Lester Lefkowitz (Hersch G’dali bar Shmuel), 12182071
Born Bronx, N.Y., 5/25/23; Died 10/3/00
Mr. and Mrs. Samuel H. and Etta Leftkowitz (parents), 586 Southern Boulevard, Bronx, N.Y.
Mount Ararat Cemetery, East Farmingdale, N.Y.
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

What about Seymour Malakoff? …  He received his pilot wings and was commissioned as a Second Lieutenant on May 20 1942.  His portrait appears below.  Taken when he was aviation cadet, it’s from the United States National Archives, where it’s one image among thousands of similar photos within 105 archival storage boxes encompassing the collection “RECORDS OF THE ARMY AIR FORCES – Photographic Prints of Air Cadets and Officers, Air Crew, and Notables in the History of Aviation”. 

Lt. Malakoff’s portrait, “P-14933”, is in box 57.

(Digression one: The overwhelming majority of these images were taken during the very late 1930s, and early 1940s; with a very small number from WW I and the twenties.  A few civilian flyers (like Amelia Earhart and Anthony Fokker) are also present, along with a few images of famous German WW I aviators.  Most of the portraits are of Flying Cadets, or, men who had just graduated as Second Lieutenants and received their “wings” from Army Air Force pilot, bombardier, and navigator schools.  The majority of the images seem to have been taken from 1941 through 1943, with some from 1944, and a very few thereafter.

Some pictures were taken outdoors, along an airfield flight-line, apparent from background scenery.  Some, with photographic back-drops of aircraft, clouds, or other aviation-related images, were obviously taken in studios.  Other were taken in simple, unadorned, indoor settings.  Some images are printed upon 8 ½” x 11” black & white glossy finish photographic paper, while others, of smaller dimensions, are mounted upon (glued to) heavy 8 ½” x 11” stock.  Typically, information such the date of the photograph, name and rank of subject, and the aviation school where the image was taken is recorded with the image; sometimes on the image itself.

Inevitably, given the coincidence between the timing of their graduation and the time-frame of the Second World War, many of these men were killed in action, while others lost their lives in training or operational accidents.  Similarly, it is notable that there are no photographs of aircrews; only individuals.  Notably, this collection of photographs comprises a limited number of the tens of thousands Army Air Force pilots, bombardiers, navigators who were Aviation Cadets, or were commissioned, during World War Two.)

______________________________

The Times article obviously attracted attention well beyond the confines of Manhattan, for it was referenced in Walter Winchell’s column three days later, in which S/Sgt. Lifschutz was mentioned in reply to comments by Mississippi Senator John E. Rankin concerning the latter’s remarks about the ethnic backgrounds of American servicemen.  Here are the first two paragraph’s from Winchell’s column:

By Walter Winchell

The Man on Broadway

NEW YORK, Feb. 7. – Man About Town:

     U.S. Senator Styles Bridges is helping his State Department heart trousseau shop …  Al Jolson is Jinx Falkenberg’s most constant visitor at her St. Luke’s Hospital bedside…  Dorothy Fox, the dance director, got a quiet melting down (from her Naval Intelligence bridegroom in Florida last week)…  Barbara Booth, who understudied Hepburn in “Without Love,” was secretly married last week in San Francisco to an Army lieutenant…  New Yorkers suspect that Wayne (wife-killer) Lonergan’s sudden coin (to hire a lawyer) came from men named in her diary…  Betty Hutton is Capt. C. Gable’s morale builder this week…  “Under Cover” author Carlson is 1-A and rarin’ to go.

     HERR RANKIN’S disparagement of certain war heroes is the consequent result of a defense mechanism.  He is Chairman of the House Veterans’ Affairs Committee.  Rankin is a World War I war vet – by virtue of 17 days’ service…  The AP reports that the first American ashore on the Anzio beaches (south of Rome) was Pvt. Walter P. Krysztofiak, a father, of Illinois.  Wonder what Rankin would say about this American whose name can hardly be pronounced? …  And then there’s the New York Times report of Feb. 4 (about New Yorkers making up the crew of a bomber) – one crew man being Staff Sgt. David Lifschutz…  You can tell Rep. Hoffman from the others in Congress.  While he talked about a march on Washington – his constituents were more interested in a March of Dimes…  Ralph Pearl says Hoffman is so unimpressive (haw!) he goes in one eye – and out the other.

Here’s how Winchell’s column actually appeared … as published in the Syracuse Herald-Journal:

______________________________

If the Times article of February 4 was (in its own way) enlightening, the following very small news item, published on June 27, three weeks after D-Day, was much sadder:  It reports that Captain Malakoff was missing in action. 

New York Flier Missing

On June 5, Capt. Seymour M. Malakoff of 60 East Ninety-fourth Street, skipper of “Butchski,” a twin-engined transport plane, wrote to his father, J.M. Malakoff, that “everything was fine”.  The next day air-borne troops invaded the coast of France, and Mr. Malakoff said yesterday he had received a War Department telegram saying his son had been reported “missing in action since June 6 over France.”

______________________________

What happened?

Missing Air Crew Report 8409 reveals that Captain Malakoff was the pilot of C-47A 43-30735 (otherwise known as “CK * P” / chalk # 37 / “Butchski II“), of the 75th Troop Carrier Squadron, 435th Troop Carrier Group, 9th Air Force.  His aircraft was one of nineteen 9th Air Force C-47s lost during D-Day (this number based on MACRs covering C-47 losses on June 6), with the 435th losing two other aircraft, both from the 77th Troop Carrier Squadron.  These planes were 42-24077, “IB * J”, piloted by 1 Lt. James J. Hamblin (MACR 7801), and 43-30734, piloted by Captain John H. Schaefers (MACR 8414).  Identical to Captain Malakoff’s “Butchski II” (as will be evident a few paragraphs down…), there were no survivors from the crew of either transport; four men in Lt. Hamblin’s crew, and 5 in Captain Schaefers’. 

(Digression two: Here’s the insignia of the 75th Troop Carrier Squadron.  (It’s from Ebay seller abqmetal.))

The fate of Butchski II is described in this excerpt from Ian Gardner’s Tonight We Die As Men, the story of the 3rd Battalion, 506th Parachute Infantry Regiment, 101st Airborne Division, encompassing the history of the Battalion’s from its creation through D-Day.  The excerpt describes the loss of the C-47 as seen from the ground.

The two men moved cautiously off along the line of the wall toward a hedge.  A few minutes later they discovered George Rosie hiding under a tree.  He was overjoyed to see them.  They remained hidden in the hedge for a while wondering what they should do.  Suddenly Rosie pointed in the direction of the farmhouse and muttered something through his broken teeth that sounded like, “Jesus Christ.  Look!”

A C-47 had been hit, its port engine was on fire and it was banking sharply to the right.  The men watched as the aircraft leveled out and its paratroopers started to jump.  As the last man left the aircraft it became totally engulfed in flames.  It was then that Gibson, Lee, and Rosie realized that it was heading directly toward them.  They flattened themselves against the ground and the stricken plane tore through power lines and swept 20 ft above their heads before exploding in a ball of flame at Clos des Brohiers.  Just moments later they were surprised to see four men, silhouetted by the inferno, sprinting toward them.  A water-filled ditch briefly interrupted their run, but they waded in and quickly scrambled out.  Watching in amazement, Gibson’s small group could not believe their eyes.  Before them, covered in mud and dripping wet, were Cyrus Swinson, Leo Krebs, Phil Abbey, and Francis Ronzani.  All four had jumped from the same plane as Gibson.  They had been hiding in a field and the burning plane forced them out.

Dr. Barney Ryan had landed in the flooded area close to L’Amont and could see something burning furiously on higher ground nearby.  He had met up with three other men and led them toward the fire.  Ryan recollects, “I couldn’t be sure what was burning at the time but thought it was an aircraft.  We were shot at by figures running around the flames.  As we weren’t supposed to open fire until daybreak we guessed they must be Germans.”  The figures were probably Mongolian soldiers who could see Ryan’s group illuminated in the flames.  Their firing forced Ryan and his men to dive under the water and swim away.

The burning plane had been carrying 18 men from H Co, 501st Bn.  They had been scheduled to jump on Drop Zone C, which was about 3 miles north of the crash site.  All the paratroopers got out safely but unfortunately the plane’s five-man crew perished in the inferno.  The aircraft was piloted by Capt. Malakoff from the 435th Troop Carrier Group’s 75th Troop Carrier Squadron, based at Welford in Berkshire.  It was probably hit shortly after crossing the French coast and fell back in the formation.  Losing altitude and unable to reach the drop zone, the pilot switched on the green light allowing the paratroopers to jump to safety before the plane crashed.

______________________________

Missing Air Crew Report 8409 includes thirteen (!) eyewitness accounts pertaining to the loss of Captain Malakoff’s C-47.  These comprise a total of ten statements from the eighteen paratroopers aboard the plane (all eighteen jumped successfully) and, statements from Captain Paul W. Dahl (C-47 42-92093), and First Lieutenants Charles P. Kearns, Jr. (C-47 42-100675) and Edgar H. Albers, Jr. (C-47 42-92099), fellow pilots in the 75th Troop Carrier Squadron.  Here’s Captain Dahl’s statement:  

I last saw Captain Malakoff as we entered the West Coast of the Cherbourg Peninsula. I was leading the second element of the 4th Squadron.  Captain Malakoff was leading the last squadron directly behind me.  Immediately after crossing the coast we went into an overcast laying over the coast directly on our course.  I turned out to the right a short distance to avoid collision with other ships in the overcast and then resumed course letting down until I broke out beneath the overcast.  If Captain Malakoff had continued straight on course he undoubtedly would have caught up with us out on our left.  A short time after breaking out of the overcast I was fired upon from the ground, guns firing all over the sky.  I saw two ships explode and go down in flames off to our left front about 300 to 500 feet above.  Approximately one-half a minute later I made a left turn into the D.Z. (my navigator recognizing it) and it was about this time I saw a violent explosion directly to our left and then saw the flames engulfing the remnants of the plane as it went down.  I would say this occurred about approximately one mile Northwest of the DZ according to my navigator’s calculations.  The exploding plane was at about the same altitude as we were which was 1000 ft indicated letting down.  I definitely saw tracers going into the explosion.  I had to make a left turn into the DZ because of the previous right turn I made in the overcast which is another fact that might indicate Captain Malakoff’s being off to my left.

I would estimate Captain Malakoff’s speed at 140 to 150 mph the last time I definitely saw him before we entered the overcast.

I was in the overcast approximately few and one half minutes.  We were under fire most of the time after breaking out of the overcast.

______________________________

This statement is by Pvt. Joe L. Cardenas, of (at the time) H Company:

I was the last man in my stick, the last to jump from the plane.  Because of my position near the radio compartment I couldn’t see out but 1 did notice the plane lurch a little possibly from wing hits.  Lt. Hoffmann [1 Lt. John W. Huffman] gave the order to “stand up”, “hook-up”.  The crew chief came out and said that he thought they were coning in south of the DZ.  He told us to hold it up and I passed this word down the line.  He then went back to the pilot.  He came out again and wanted to know why we were in the plane and went back into the pilot’s cabin.  He came out again, rather excited and said “we are coming over the DZ when you get the light.  “Go!  Go!  Go!”  The plane seemed to be OK.  I had no trouble getting out.  I never saw the plane again after I jumped.

______________________________

Missing Air Crew Report 8409 lists C-47 43-30735 as having last been seen west of Etienville, France.  In reality, the plane crashed on the ground of the Frigot Farm, about two miles north-northwest of Carentan.  Several images of Butchski II’s crash site can be seen at TAPA Talk (“Meehan Crash Site“), while Mark Bando has this account at The Carrington News:  

C-47 #43-30735 (pilot Seymour M. Malakoff) belonged to the 75th TCS and was shot down during mission Albany on D-day.  Butchski II came down near Frigot Farm on D-Night, just north of the road that runs straight east toward Basse Addeville [La Basse Addeville] from Dead Man’s Corner.  The plane was carrying the stick of 3rd platoon H/501.  Capt. Seymour Malakoff, pilot, 2nd Lt. Thomas Tucker, co-pilot, 1st Lt. Eugene Gaul, navigator, Sgt. Paul Jacoway flight engineer, S/Sgt. Robert Walsh, radio … were all killed in the crash.  

All the troopers on board including Harry Plisevich, Len Morris, Robert Niles, Paul Solea, and Clarence Felt jumped before the ship went in.  Solea’s reserve chute opened accidentally in the plane, causing a four minute delay in jumping.  Due to the cloud banks and ground fire which brought down two other planes of the same serial carrying G/501st personnel [42-24077 and 43-30734], the plane had strayed off-course.  Butchski II was actually hit somewhere south of Carentan and then began a route bringing her NE, on an angle that took her above Addeville.  She then turned back west bound and the occupants of the Frigot farm on the north side of the road just west of the A13 overpass heard it go over their house before she crashed a few fields over.  There was a AA battery on the high ground just north of Chateau Bel Enault [Château Bellenau], which was pumping rounds at the plane as it turned west, losing altitude all the while, one of the troopers [Pvt. Fred J. DiPietro, 15354752?] that jumped was KIA shortly after landing between Baupte and Raffoville, when he knocked on the door of a French farmhouse and a German answered, probably with a pistol in his hand.  From Mark Bando…

These two air photos show the Frigot Farm, which lies at the intersection of D913 and Rue du Bel Esnault, bounded by rows of trees adjacent to each road.  Based on photos at TAPA Talk, the aircraft crashed adjacent to one of the two northwest-southeast oriented rows of trees subdividing the property: the long row in the very center of the image, or, the diminutive row in the farm’s southwest corner. 

This photo, at a smaller scale, shows the setting of the Frigot Farm relative to Château Bellenau, which is just southwest of La Basse Addeville.  

______________________________

Words and maps can only convey so much.  The photo below, also from Gardner’s book (as is the caption), shows the burnt-out wreckage of Captain Malakoff’s C-47 a few days after D-Day.  Little is left of the aircraft except for the fin, an outer portion of one wing, and fragments of bent and burned aluminum.  

“Pvt. Walter Hendrix from E Company 506th stands beside the burnt-out remains of 75th Troop Carrier Squadron C-47 “Butchski II”, which crashed near Frigot Farm on D-Day.  The plane was carrying men from H Company 501st, who all jumped to safety before it crashed.  Unfortunately its crew were not so fortunate and Capt. Seymour Malakoff (pilot), 2 Lt. Thomas Tucker (co-pilot), 1st Lt. Eugene Gaul (navigator), Sgt. Paul Jacoway (flight engineer) and S/Sgt. Robert Walsh (radio operator) all perished in the inferno.  (Forrest Guth picture, Carnetan Historical Center)”

I do find it notable that whereas the Times gives the nickname of Captain Malakoff’s C-47 as “Butchski“, Missing Air Crew Report 8409 and other sources list the aircraft’s name as “Butchski II“.  Whether this reflects an error in the Times’ article, or, the fact that there was an original “Butchski (one)” replaced by a C-47 dubbed “Butchski II” … in the tradition of so many USAAF WW II aircraft … I’ve no idea.   

______________________________

Captain Malakoff’s crew on this mission – their first, last, and only mission – comprised:

Co-Pilot: 2 Lt. Thomas A. Tucker, 0-686291, Buffalo, N.Y. (Born 1918)
Forest Lawn Cemetery, Buffalo, N.Y.

Navigator: 1 Lt. Eugene Edward Gaul, 0-807185, Newark, N.J. (Born 7/4/20)
Long Island National Cemetery, East Farmingdale, N.Y. – Plot H, Grave 7930

Flight Engineer: Sgt. Paul B. Jacoway, 39097783, Fort Smith, Ak. (Born 5/22/18)
Fort Smith National Cemetery, Fort Smith, Ar. – Section 4, Grave 2163

Radio Operator: S/Sgt. Robert Donald “Donny” Walsh, 37397005, Saint Louis, Mo. (Born 4/6/21)
Jefferson Barracks National Cemetery, Lemay, Mo. – Section OPS3, Grave 2307E

I’d suppose that his original crew, as listed in the Times, was broken up as a unit prior to D-Day, and distributed among other crews in the 75th Troop Carrier Squadron.  In any event, as mentioned above, all of Captain Malakoff’s original crewmen survived the war.  

Captain Malakoff is buried at Normandy American Cemetery, St. Laurent-sur-Mer, France, Plot F, Row 18, Grave 18.  Like Flight Officer Bush and Sergeant Lefkowitz, his name is absent from American Jews in World War II.  

______________________________

Perhaps inspired by the Times, on June 29 the Forvarts published the following news item about Lieutenant Malakoff.  Given the formal nature of the portrait, what with the fluffy white scarf and jauntily placed cap and headphones, this picture was probably taken during his pilot training in the United States – possibly upon his graduation from pilot training and commissioning as an officer – and before his assignment to the 435th Troop Carrier Group.  I suppose the picture was sent to his parents, who then provided the image to the Forvarts

Though I don’t know Yiddish, I think the approximate translation of the title is rather straightforward: Something to the effect of “Jewish Pilot Flies Airplane with Parachutists”.  The word “Butchski“, phoneticized in Yiddish, definitely appears in the article.  It’s in quotes in the third line from the bottom.   

__________

_______________________

And now, submitted for your consideration:

The elephant in the living room.

…or…

The rhinoceros in the foyer.

_______________________

__________

Getting back to the Times’ article.

Well, yeah. 

Captain Malakoff’s crew were most definitely “New Yorkers” by either residence or birth.  That’s explicitly stated in the Time’s article’s first paragraph.  That all but one of the airmen in the crew were Jews was, however, entirely left unmentioned.  Perhaps this “silence” about the coincidence of four Jewish airmen assigned to the same aircrew, in the European Theater of War, arose because it wasn’t even noticed to begin with.  (That, I seriously doubt.)  Perhaps it was deemed irrelevant.  (That is surely possible.)  Perhaps it was left unmentioned because the story’s anonymous author and editor adhered to and tacitly accepted the Times’ deeply animating ideology which has continued to negate an acceptance of Jewish peoplehood.  (Surely that’s possible too.) 

But still, in the cultural context of the forties and the next few decades (not so much any more),the phrase “New Yorker” was a verbal shorthand that not always, but not uncommonly had a certain Jewish connotation or “ring” to it – on occasion positive; sometimes ambivalent; perhaps neutral; sometimes negative – whether in politics, popular culture, or comedy.

Walter Winchell’s column, published three days after the Times’ story, made mention of David Lifschutz as a way of refuting Congressman John E. Rankin’s statements about American Jews.  But, even accounting for the fact that Winchell was a gossip columnist, something’s clearly “off” with with his article just as much as there is in the Times’ original story.  On a minor point, Butchski was a transport, not a bomber.  On a major point, obviously having combed the article for details, why did Winchell not deign to mention Seymour Malakoff, Saul Bush, and Lester Lefkowitz?  Given the length of his very long column – of which the above image is only a beginning snippet – why the silence about these three men?  Though my knowledge of Winchell’s life only comes from Wikipedia, what stands out from his biography is that despite – or perhaps as a consequence; perhaps as a cause – of his all-too-fleeting fame and social prominence (in a personal life characterized by turbulence and tragedy); despite his father having been a part-time cantor – his only real connection to Judaism and the Jewish people was in his ancestry. 

Plus, the Magen David on his Matzeva.  

Yet, there could be another explanation for the nature of the Times’ article: Perhaps there were aspects of the Times’ reporter’s conversation with the crew of Butchski – then unrecorded and now unknown – that never reached the printed page.  In this, I’m reminded of comments made to me by a Jewish WW II veteran who flew B-17s in the 8th Air Force, several of whose crew members were Jews, and whose brother (a ball turret gunner) and cousin (1st Lieutenant Morris Levesee also…) were killed in action while serving in the 15th and 8th Air Forces, respectively.

As he related in a late 1993 interview:

Me: Can you recall any other Jewish guys who were in your squadron, besides the guys in your crew?
Veteran: Oh yeah. Yeah. We had a…we had a guy; he was a navigator. A fellow by the name of Bill L.  And Bill L.…  Bill L.…  He had worked for the…he worked for the Daily… He had some kind of a job with the Daily News. …  The fact that he had worked for the newspaper, I guess, you know… He was… Let me see, how can I say it? You know, he wanted…he wanted in the worst way, to publicize…the fact… He hung onto my crew…because we had so many Jews.  And he wanted…he wanted to…you know, to throw out a lot of publicity about it and I turned him down, while we were overseas. And I said, “No, no, no. I don’t want to do that.”
The one thing that he did, and it was printed in the Brooklyn Daily Times, or Times Union…I forget what the hell the name of the paper was… He had a picture taken of Irving S. and myself…at the airplane, glancing at a…at a map, and he had written a small article. He and some other guy… I forget what the hell his name was. He was our…he was our PR man. He was also Jewish. And he was the squadron PR man.
And…and they…they had this little article, and they titled it as, “Brooklyn Flak Dodgers”, you know, and he was showing me how we could dodge the flak and all this other bullshit!, but… But it was never printed that way, in the paper. It was just printed…and I have a copy of it…it was printed just as, “Two… You know, as “Two Brooklynites on the Same Crew”. That’s all. Just some little article in the… And I have it someplace. I don’t know where.
And I have that picture, too. I have a copy of the picture.
Me: But he tended to want to socialize with your crew?
Veteran: No, no no no no. No, he didn’t… No, there was…there was no socializing at all. He…the only thing that he wanted to do… He wanted to, you know… I guess, he wanted…he wanted to write, about “this Jewish crew, that were doing ‘this’ and were doing ‘this’ and were doing, you know. And he wanted to…he wanted some sort of notoriety about it, and I didn’t want…I didn’t want it. I said, “No, I don’t care for it.”
I came in…I…I had…I had my brakes shot out on one mission. I had the hydraulic system that was just… My whole hydraulic system went bad, you know, just the…the fluid leaked out. It was shot up? And, I made, what they called…referred to as a…”Stars and Stripes Landing”, using a parachute to…you know, to…to slow me down so that I could…
Me: Out the waist windows or something like that?
Veteran: No no, out the tail. And we used that parachute out the tail, and he wanted to make a big tzimmis [Yiddish for fuss] about it, and I said, “No, I don’t want it Bill.” I said, “I’ll tell you what you do. Write a nice article about my tail gunner, who’s”…what the hell is his name?…P., Henry P.… I said, “Write an article about Henry P.; that P. threw his parachute out the tail, to slow us down so that we didn’t run off the runway.” And that was…that was it.
I didn’t want… I was kind of… You know, I was…superstitious about it, you know.
Me: About the Jewish angle being played up.
Veteran: Well, about any angle… I was superstitious about any kind of, really, publicity. You know, trying to make a…trying to make a hero out of us, you know?
Me: That it would be tempting fate?
Veteran: I think so, yes. That was my feeling.         

__________

_______________________

As mentioned above, the only casualty among Captain Malakoff’s original crewmen would eventually be his radio operator, S/Sgt. David Lifschutz.  Here’s his photo, from the Long Island Star Journal of June 14, 1945.

Remaining in the 75th Troop Carrier Squadron, S/Sgt. Lifschutz was a crew member aboard C-47A 43-48718 (the un-nicknamed CK * A) when, during the re-supply mission to American troops in Bastogne, Belgium on mid-afternoon of December 26, 1944, his plane was shot down by anti-aircraft fire.  Coincidentally; ironically, S/Sgt. Lifschutz’s pilot this day was Captain Paul Warren Dahl, whose eyewitness account (see above) of the loss of Butchski II on D-Day figures so prominently in the Missing Air Crew Report for Captain Malakoff.  

This photo of the Dahl crew, dated June 17, 1944, is from Captain Paul Dahl, 75th TCS, 435th TCG, at Honouring IX Troop Carrier Command

Unfortunately, the only person actually identified in the photo is the Captain himself, at center rear.  This photo of Captain Dahl, from his biography at FindAGrave, was taken while he was a flying cadet.

Even if names can’t be correlated to faces, I think it’s possible to attach names to faces based on information in the relevant Missing Air Crew Report, number 11322. 

Along with Captain Dahl and S/Sgt. Lifschutz on the December mission were the following men:

Co-Pilot: 2 Lt. William L. Murtaugh, 0-809998
Navigator: 1 Lt. Zeno Hardy Rose, Jr., 0-807314
Flight Engineer: T/Sgt. George T. Gazarian, 31125533
Passenger: Sgt. John J. Walsh, 36321092, member of 3rd Air Cargo Resupply Squadron

Missing Air Crew Report 11322, covering the loss of this aircraft, includes accounts by three crewmen of a nearby C-47, as well as detailed reports by Captain Dahl and Lt. Murtaugh.  The latter two men, along with Lt. Rose and Sgt. Walsh, landed by parachute in no-man’s-land between German and American forces, but were immediately saved from death or capture by soldiers from the 318th Infantry Regiment of the 80th Infantry Division.  It turned out that Captain Dahl, Lt. Murtaugh, and Sergeant Walsh were wounded either when their plane was struck by anti-aircraft fire, or, injured when they landed by parachute, all having bailing out from an extremely low altitude.  Murtaugh was most seriously hurt, but Navigator Zeno Rose was much more fortunate, emerging from the ordeal unwounded.  

This report about the men’s rescue was filed by the Adjutant of the 435th Troop Carrier Group on January 2, 1945, when the status of the plane’s two other crewmen – S/Sgt. Lifschitz and T/Sgt. Gazarian – was still “Missing in Action”:

2 January 1945.

1st Lt Zeno H Rose, 0807314, 75th Troop Carrier Squadron, this organization, reported “Missing in Action” on “Missing Air Crew Report”, this headquarters, dared 28 December 1944, has returned to this organization.

The following is extracted from interrogation of Lt Rose and is submitted as supplemental to “Missing Air Crew Report”.

“We took off from Station 474 about 1211 BST, 26 December 1944, and flew as the lead ship of the right element of the 75th TC Squadron in the 435th formation.  About two end one half minutes before we reached the DZ at Bastogne, Belgium, we were subjected to enemy fire from both light machine gun and light flak.  Both types of fire were effectively hitting our airplane knocking out the instrument panel on the right side, and at that time, the co-pilot, Lt Murtaugh, was hit by both MG and AA fire that broke his right shoulder or collar bone.  This caused profuse bleeding and severe pain, however, Lt Murtaugh remained at his position and carried on his duties.  At this scene time, the flak burst hit me, although the injury was slight.

Our bundles both in the pararacks and the cabin were ejected over the DZ about 1525 BST.  We made a sharp right turn and were in formation on the ran out when about 2-1/2 minutes from the DZ light flak burst in the cockpit, most probably severing the fuel lines, knocking out the instruments, wounding Captain Dahl and starting fires in the forward part of the airplane.  Captain Dahl rolled the trim tab back checked the power which was already on full, and gave the order and signal for balling out.

I quickly proceeded to the cabin door and saw that the enlisted men had net yet jumped; they seemed to be hesitant possibly because of our altitude.  There was no hesitancy on my part so without further thought, I jumped and was followed by the enlisted men.  (I later learned that the enlisted men were followed by Lt Murtaugh and then Captain Dahl.)  It seemed that we were about three hundred and fifty feet above the ground at that time and my parachute opened instantly.  During my descent to the ground I could hear enemy bullets whizzing past.  I landed near some woods southwest of Bastogne and north of Assenois at approximately P325545, which at that time was between our lines and these of the enemy.  There was a great deal of fire coming toward me so I feinted dead until I could become oriented.

Captain Dahl, Lt Murtaugh and Sgt Walsh landed at a position about 100 yards southeast of my landing near or in the woods and they were picked up by the same organization that joined me.  Captain Dahl had a broken arm, some wounds and lacerations from flak and burns about the nape of his neck; Lt Murtaugh had the broken shoulder, several flak wounds about the face and a sprained ankle, and Sgt Walsh had a broken leg.  All three as well as myself were given medical aid at the Aid Station, then sent to a clearance station, then to a field hospital and then to the 103rd Hospital about forty miles south of Bastogne.

Before departing from the area in which we landed, we were told that the parachute of one of the men had not opened and that in the case of the sixth man, that he had landed closer to the enemy lines and that he had been taken prisoner or had been killed by the enemy.”

Lt Rose interrogated by Captain Clement A. Erb, Intelligence Officer, 75th Troop Carrier squadron, this organization.

The members of this air crew were flying in aircraft C-47A, No. 43-48713, organizations and present status indicated; crew position indicated:

Dahl, Paul W., Captain, 0 401 356, Pilot, 75th TC Sq “SWA”
Murtaugh, William L., 2d Lt., 0 809 998, Co-Pilot, 75th 7C Sq “SWA”
Rose, Zeno H., 1st Lt., 0 807 314, Navigat., 75th TC Sq “RTD”
Gazarian, George T., S/Sgt., 31 125 533, Aer Eng, 75th TC Sq “MIA”
Lifschutz, David., T/Sgt., 12 147 259, Rad Opr., 75th TC Sq “MIA“

Sgt John J. Walsh, 3rd Air Cargo Re-Supply Squadron, was flying on subject aircraft, and was reported as battle casualty by his organization.

MACR 11322 includes the following map, indicating that the C-47 crashed just west of what is today highway N4, north of Remonfosse and east of Assenois.  

This Apple air photo shows Assenois at lower left center, Remonfosse to the east, and Bastogne to the north.  The blue circle indicates the approximate area where the crew landed by parachute – as suggested by the MACR – while the black circle indicates the (again) approximate crash location of C-47A 43-48718.  

The status of Sergeants Lifschutz and Gazarian, like Captain Dahl on their 9th mission, was uncertain at least through March of 1945.  However, the fate of both Sergeants was established by the war’s end, as revealed in the Individual Casualty Questionnaires as completed by Lt. Rose and incorporated into MACR 11322.  (Rose’s are the only such Questionnaires in the MACR.)  

Sergeant Gazarian (31125533) was killed, either in an unsuccessful parachute jump, or due to ground fire from German troops.  Given that witnesses reported seeing five, and not six, parachutes, the cause was most likely the former.  Born on January 3, 1907, the thirty-seven year old sergeant from Waterbury Ct., is buried at Old Pine Grove Cemetery, Waterbury, Ct.

S/Sgt. Lifschutz was immediately captured on landing, as revealed in Lt. Rose’s Questionnaire.  Given that he and Lt. Rose met one another on May 12, 1945, perhaps he returned to the 75th Troop Carrier Squadron after his liberation, while en route back to the United States. 

The very fact that Lt. Rose was able to record a full list of S/Sgt. Lifschutz’s missions, which were completely identical in date and number to those flown by T/Sgt. Gazarian and Captain Dahl, suggests that Lifschutz, Gazarian, Rose, and Dahl had been members of the same crew commencing with the Normandy invasion.  Thus – following that logic – with the exception of Lt. Murtaugh, for whom the flight of December 26 was his first (and only?) mission – these are the men who appear in the photo of the Dahl crew: Gazarian and Lifschutz in front.      

The POW camp in which S/Sgt. Lifschutz was interned is unknown, but that he was a POW is solidly verified by the standard Luftgaukommando Report form “Meldung über den Abschuss eines US-amerikanischen Flugzueges“(“Report About the Shooting Down of a US Airplane”), in report KU 1214A.  The Report also includes a crew list for C-47 43-48718, which includes Captain Dahl’s serial number.  Oddly, an English-language transcription of this document can be found in MACR 11322, but the original sheet is missing from the actual Luftgaukommando Report.    

(Digressing…  The “A” suffix seems to have been used in Luftgaukommando Reports covering aircraft which had multiple crewmen – as opposed to single-seat fighters – in situations for which some crewmen were known to have evaded capture, or were otherwise unaccounted for, at the time the report was initially filed.)

Here’s S/Sgt. Lifschutz’s dog-tag. 

Yes, it bears the letter “H”.

The Long Island Star Journal reported upon the Sergeant’s liberation and impending return in its issue of June 14, 1945, in a brief article which featured his portrait.

Bastogne Captive Awaits Return

Staff Sergeant David Lifchutz of Jackson Heights, who was captured Dec. 24 after he bailed out from his burning plane over Bastogne, was liberated April 29 and is in England awaiting shipment home.

A radio operator on a C-47 transport plane, the 23-yeard-old airman had flown over Holland, France and Germany in the year and a half he had been overseas.  He wears the Air Medal with one cluster.

A graduate of Public School 126, Jackson Heights, Long Island City High School and the Hebrew Technical Institute, which is now a part of New York University, Sergeant Lifchutz worked in the Brooklyn Navy Yard as a shipfitter before entering the Army in 1943.

He is the only son of Mr. and Mrs. Ephraim Lifchutz of 32-17 77th Street.

OOOOOOOO

I don’t know anything at all about the subsequent course of David Lifschutz’s life, but I suppose that given the passage of time, following the way of all men, he has passed into history. 

But, it’s nice to remember a little bit longer.

Two Books.

Dublin, Louis I., and Kohs, Samuel C., American Jews in World War II – The Story of 550,000 Fighters for Freedom, The Dial Press, New York, N.Y., 1947

Gardner, Ian, and Day, Roger, Tonight We Die as Men: The Untold Story of Third Battalion 506 Parachute Infantry Regiment from Toccoa to D-Day, Osprey, Oxford, England, 2010 (see pages 153-155)

Digression Three…

In light of my post about Destination Tokyo, I’m contemplating a post about James Jones’ 1962 novel, The Thin Red Line, which was the basis of the 1964 film by Andrew Marton, and, the 1998 film by Terrence Malik.  I’ve not seen either film (!), but I’m particularly curious about the 1998 version in light of Malick – as touched upon in weirdly brief passing by Peter Biskind at Vanity Fair – having “…changed Stein [Captain Bugger Stein], a Jewish captain, to Staros, an officer of Greek extraction, thereby gutting Jones’s indictment of anti-Semitism in the military, which the novelist had observed close-up in his own company.”  This is in light of the many, many (did I say “many”?!) passages in the novel centered upon Captain Stein, by which Jones, a fantastic writer, with clear and obvious intent explored the officer’s experiences with tremendous perception, depth, and empathy.

So, in 1998, why was Captain Bugger Stein missing in action from The Thin Red Line?

A Controversy of Zion: Zionism and Its Foes, in The Jewish Exponent (Philadelphia) VI – January 15, 1943: The “Bogey” of Zionism, by Rabbi Simon Greenberg

A Controversy of Zion – VI

“Rabbi Schachtel claims that he does not know what Zionists mean
when they speak of the “historic homelessness of the Jews.”
Jewish tradition records that there were also some Israelites,
close to the ruling powers in Egypt,
who could not understand why Moses wanted to take them out of that land.
They were quite at home even in Egypt.”

***

“There is also in both articles the expressed or implied fear
that the existence of a Jewish homeland will encourage anti-Semites to persecute us
and force our expulsion from the countries in which we now live.
In that regard there is this simple historic fact to remember.
The absence of a Jewish homeland these 1800 years
never restricted the hands of our persecutors.”

***

“Why some Jews should be ready to join the enemies of their people
in open combat against the hope that has sustained their fathers through 1800 years of persecution
no one will ever be able to fully explain.
The phenomenon belong to those dark mysteries of the human soul
which under the cover of idealism and resounding phraseology
can turn a man to hate against himself, or the nearest of his kind.

The sixth and final of the Jewish Exponent’s series of articles about Zionism, and, Anti-Zionism, among American Rabbis in the early 1940s brings us to an essay by Rabbi Simon Greenberg, the President of the “Philadelphia Zionist Organization” (a local chapter of the Zionist Organization of America?), in response to Rabbi Hyman J. Schachtel’s essay in the Exponent’s prior issue. 

Rabbi Greenberg performs a thorough job of refuting Rabbi Schachtel’s arguments, touching upon issues such as the status of the remaining Jews of Europe subsequent to German’s surrender, and – I think this is important – the way Rabbi Schachtel in his denial of Jewish homelessness in the United States, England, Russia, and Poland (did the Jews of Poland genuinely feel so at home?; were they perceived as such by non-Jewish Poles?) completely and I think calculatedly glosses over the actual pre-WW II status of the Jews of Germany, the countries of Eastern Europe, and, Yemen.  

Then, Rabbi Greenberg discusses the concern, expressed or implied, that the reestablishment of a Jewish nation-state will engender antisemitism and cause the expulsion of Jews from countries in which they live.  His rejoinder is very astute: The absence of a Jewish homeland these 1800 years never restricted the hands of our persecutors. … The treatment we receive at the hands of our fellow citizens will and does depend exclusively upon the degree of humanity and democracy prevailing amongst them and not upon whether there is or is not a place to which they can send us.”

But, the central thrust of his essay addresses an issue touched upon by neither Rabbi Schachtel nor Exponent columnist Al Segal, an issue refreshingly unrelated to the idea the purpose for the re-establishment of a Jewish state would simply to be to provide a refuge for Jews suffering persecution. 

Rabbi Greenberg sees far beyond this, realizing that beyond political security lie aspects of human nature, whether individual or collective, that speak to facets of human experience that cannot be understood in a purely material sense.  Namely: “Hence, even though democracy were to be fully implemented all over the world, they [the Jewish people] would still want one spot where their own cultural and religious traditions would have an opportunity for normal development equal to that which all other spiritual and cultural traditions have in areas where they can claim the majority of the population.”

THE “BOGEY” OF ZIONISM

By RABBI SIMON GREENBERG

The Jewish Exponent
January 15, 1943

EDITOR’S NOTE: – The following article by the President of the Philadelphia Zionist Organization is in reply to an article by Rabbi Hyman J. Schachtel of New York, which appeared in last week’s issue of The Jewish Exponent.  Rabbi Schachtel is a member of the newly formed Council for American Judaism, who stated the position of his group in an article titled, “We Reject Zionism.”  Rabbi Greenberg’s article also contains an answer to last week’s “Plain Talk” column by Al Segal.

The recent activities of the handful of anti-Zionist rabbis and laymen have stirred the deepest passions and profoundest emotions.  It is not easy, therefore, to analyze their arguments of motives with a calm, intellectual objectivity.  But since they insist in pressing their views upon public attention, discussion with them, unfortunate as it may be in this tragic hour of Jewish history, cannot be avoided.

The Jewish Exponent and I presume many other Anglo-Jewish weeklies throughout the country, recently published two statements which attempted further to clarify the position of the anti-Zionist group.  One was written by Rabbi Hyman J. Schachtel, the other by a layman, Al Segal.

The original contribution to the discussion made by Rabbi Schachtel is summarized in the following paragraph:  “If Europe is emancipated, if Europe after the war has a new birth of freedom, there will be no need for artificial lands of refuge for forced migrants.  If Europe and the world are not so emancipated, then there is no refuge anywhere.”  Rabbi Schachtel thus apparently bases his opposition to a Jewish commonwealth on the proposition that no matter what happens the Jews of Europe will or should remain in Europe after the war.  If the Nazis win, Jews have “no refuge anywhere”.  If the Nazis lose “Europe will be emancipated” and there will be no need for Jews to leave it.  Since I cannot imagine a Nazi victory there is no point in discussing the first alternative.  But what will be the situation when the inevitable Nazi defeat occurs?  Zionists, like all democrats, of course, expect the Jews of Europe to have their full citizenship rights restored.  Moreover, Zionists have no desire to see Europe of any other part of the world become “Judenrein”; free of Jews.  If after the war there will be no Jews who will want to leave Europe, and no Jews anywhere else who will want or need to go to Palestine, then the whole problem will of itself be solved.  Certainly no Jewish commonwealth can be established in Palestine, if there are no Jews who want to go to live there.  And surely no Zionist will tolerate the thought that Jews should in any way be forced to migrate to any place.  Zionists were the first to denounce publicly the position taken by the Polish government in the pre-war days that Poland had a “surplus” of one million Jews.  But just as vigorously as we reject a policy of “forced migration”, would we also reject a policy of “forced fixation”.  Is Rabbi Schachtel’s thought that with Europe emancipated no Jew and no European should be permitted to migrate anywhere outside of Europe?  Or is his opinion that with political liberty restored to Europe no European will need or want to leave his native land?  Obviously neither of the two positions can be maintained.  The defeat of the Nazis should mean a world more widely open that ever before for the free flow of men and goods.  And obviously there will be a great outpouring of Europeans who will need and desire the opportunity to find physical and spiritual renewal in other parts of the globe.

In these matters the Zionists, the so-called “romantic dreamers”, attempt to be realists.  They heed the warnings of the best authoritative observers.  There seems to be practical unanimity of opinion that after the war a large percentage of the Jews remaining in Europe will for sociological, psychological, or economic reasons want to and have to find new homes for themselves.  As a matter of fact, many non-Zionist Jewish bodies are engaged even now in looking about for possible countries of immigration for the Jews of post-war Europe.

Rabbi Schachtel claims that he does not know what Zionists mean when they speak of the “historic homelessness of the Jews.”  Jewish tradition records that there were also some Israelites, close to the ruling powers in Egypt, who could not understand why Moses wanted to take them out of that land.  They were quite at home even in Egypt.  “American Jews,” the rabbi says, “are not homeless”.  Every American Zionist will heartily agree with him.  The same is true of the British Jews.  But I wonder whether Dr. Schachtel is on equally safe ground when he speaks of Polish Jews?  Even with minority rights granted them at the end of the last war, and with further constitutional guarantees provided for the Jews of other central and eastern European countries, there was never a year in which there were not four and five times as many Jews from these countries asking for admission to Palestine as were granted the much-sought-for vise!  Homelessness, the rabbi writes, is not “a mystical concept”… derived from an abstract philosophy but from the realty of persecution.  Quite right.  Ask the Jews of Yemen today, or of Poland and Roumania and Germany of yesterday.

We were quite aware in 1918 that a new era of human brotherhood has dawned.  We were sadly disappointed.  I pray fervently and daily that we may not be disappointed this time.  But while my religion teaches me to expect miracles it warns me against depending upon them, or even against expecting them when other avenues of help are available.  Hence through the restoration of equal political rights to the Jews of post-war Europe is the least we expect from the defeat of the Nazis.  I do not feel that we have the right to depend entirely upon that, and to neglect any other possibility which may be available for further securing the future of all or many of these, our grief-stricken brethren.

There is also in both articles the expressed or implied fear that the existence of a Jewish homeland will encourage anti-Semites to persecute us and force our expulsion from the countries in which we now live.  In that regard there is this simple historic fact to remember.  The absence of a Jewish homeland these 1800 years never restricted the hands of our persecutors.  It did not restrain Torquemada in 1492, nor the Czaristic government in the 19th century.  Nor the Nazis in the 20th.  Certainly then the argument that the existence of a Jewish commonwealth will increase Jewish persecution gets no corroboration from Jewish history.  Nor would my self-respect permit me to remain at ease even in America if for a moment I felt that the only reason I am permitted to live here is because my fellow citizens have no place to which to eject me.  Such a thought, I feel, is not merely a deep wound in my own dignity, but a grievous insult to my fellow citizens.  The treatment we receive at the hands of our fellow citizens will and does depend exclusively upon the degree of humanity and democracy prevailing amongst them and not upon whether there is or is not a place to which they can send us.

But there is a kind of “homelessness” which a rabbi in particular should be able to understand, even though he is not physically molested.  Physical and political and even economic security are not the whole sum and substance of life, important as these are.  Henry James and a goodly number of other 19th century American intellectuals did not feel at home in America in the 19th century.  Now, strange as it may appear to Rabbi Schachtel and others, there are some Jews, particularly among the much-harassed Jews of central and eastern Europe, who do not find in political and physical security all that they want in life.  They would, for example, like to speak Hebrew, and to have Hebrew as one of the world’s modern languages.  They want it to be a medium for the expression of a full cultural and spiritual life in every possible way.  There are Jews who would like to have one spot in the world where the Sabbath would have the same status that Sunday has in America, and where Passover, and Rosh Hashanna, and Hanukah fit as normally into the pattern of their lives as Christmas and Easter and Thanksgiving day fit into the normal pattern of our lives here.  There are many Jews who are as deeply concerned for the preservation and the further development of the Hebrew culture and the pattern of life developed in the Torah and in later Rabbinic literature, as they are for the preservation of the physical existence of the Jewish people as such.  Hence, even though democracy were to be fully implemented all over the world, they would still want one spot where their own cultural and religious traditions would have an opportunity for normal development equal to that which all other spiritual and cultural traditions have in areas where they can claim the majority of the population.  Nor does that in any way reflect upon the appreciation of the peoples among whom they live as equal citizens of the state, nor upon their while-hearted loyalty to the democratic government under which they live.  A normal human being’s desire to build his own home after he marries, even though his parents may offer him a part of their spacious home, is not considered a reflection upon his love for or his loyalty to his parents.

From Mr. Segal’s article we gather that the one thing which stirs the darkest forebodings in the minds of the anti-Zionists is the concept “Jewish Commonwealth” or “Jewish State”.  They dread the possibility of being accused of a double allegiance, of being “lumped together” with another political entity in the minds of their fellow citizens.  Let us examine this bogey, “Jewish State” or “Jewish Commonwealth” for a moment.  Do the anti-Zionists have a clear notion of what the concepts imply in the light of the actual situation in Palestine, or the new world conditions which will come after the war?  If they do, I would like to know their opinions.  They would, I am sure, be very helpful.  Mr. Segal and others may be interested in knowing that among Zionists themselves there has never been any unanimity of opinion on the definition of “Jewish State” or “Jewish Commonwealth”.  They only things on which there is unanimity of opinion among Zionists are: (1) Political conditions with Palestine and within the framework of international relations should be established which would make it possible for as many Jews to enter Palestine as freely desire to do so, and as the economic possibilities of the country could maintain.  (2) No artificial obstacles should prevent the Jews from ever becoming the majority population in Palestine.  (3) The Jewish majority in Palestine should have the right to govern itself, it being clearly understood that nothing would ever be done in any way to impair the political, the economic, and the cultural rights of any of the other inhabitants of Palestine.

There are all kinds of plans being worked on for the future political relationship between the Jews and the Arabs of Palestine.  There are schemes for a bi-national State, and plans for an International Commission that might act as the impartial arbitrator to all matters of dispute between the two populations.  No one at present can envision all of the details of the practical implementation either of the Zionist Basle Program, or of the Balfour Declaration.  Much, of course, will depend upon the nature of the international organization which will emerge after the war.  But does it seem fair for Jews in America because of a fear which has no basis in the experiences either of our people or of any other people now to insist that until the end of time the Jews of Palestine, no matter what their number, may never exercise those political powers and rights which any other group in the world, religious or non-religious, has always considered a normal, and inalienable right and privilege?  Is this a dignified and courageous attitude?

Mr. Segal is very explicit in expressing his fear that if there will be a “Jewish State,” the Jews of America will “be counted in, or counted out, as a people who are somehow of another nation and another country”.  Strange that no Irishman in the United States seems to worry because Eire has now practically become independent.  No American Pole fighting for Polish independence, or Czech, or Frenchman has that fear.  Mr. Segal has the same fear that the German Jew once had about being “lumped together” with “Ost Juden,” East European Jews.  What logical basis does Mr. Segal have for his fear that if there will be a self-governing Jewish group in Palestine, American – Jewish loyalty to America will then be under greater suspicion than the loyalty of the Englishman, or Frenchman, or Pole to America?

Moreover, Mr. Segal does not object to Jews building colonies or planting forests in Palestine.  He dreads only the thought that the Jews in Palestine may have the political power necessary to enlarge and develop and protect these forests and colonies.  Mr. Segal seems to imply that if the Jews of Palestine as a community do not have any of the rights and powers usually associated with a state or a commonwealth, they will have the good will and friendship of their neighbors.  Otherwise they will be ever beset by “hostile and resentful elements”.  Does Jewish or general human history bear out the assumption that the friendship of one’s neighbors increases in proportion to one’s weakness and defenseless?

Finally, may I say that what Zionists resent most deeply, and consider nothing less than a vicious traitorous libel, is the implication, as well as the explicit statement made by anti-Zionists, which question the sincerity and the wholeheartedness of a Zionist’s American patriotism.  Such a statement as the following, made by Mr. Segal, is what we have in mind.  He (Mr. Segal) “simply cannot think of any other national allegiance but American.  He is not of Palestine at all.”  With men like the late Justice Louis D. Brandeis, and the present Justice Felix Frankfurter, and Judge Julian W. Mack, and a vast host of other outstanding leaders in American civic and political life, having been so intimately and definitely identified with the Zionist movement, can Mr. Segal and his like still continue to talk even in the vaguest terms of the American Zionist as one who has “other national allegiance but American?”  It might be of interest to know that of all of the charges brought against Mr. Brandeis by his many enemies, when his career was so punctiliously scrutinized before his appointment to the Supreme Court was ratified by the Senate, no one thought of accusing him of a double allegiance because of his Zionism  That form of attack on Zionism, we repeat again, belongs to the meanest and lowest type of libel.
Zionists can very well agree with Rabbi Schachtel, when he says that, “what we want for the Jews after this war is what we want for all the people.  We want a world in which Jews, wherever they may be, are free citizens entitled to the same privileges and subject to the same responsibilities of all other free citizens.  Now one of the rights and privileges enjoyed by free citizens everywhere is to establish their own governments and to govern their own cultural, social and political life.  We want that right for the Jewish community of Palestine, just as surely as the American Czechs want it for the Czechs in Czecho-Slovakia, and the Poles want it for the Poles in Poland.

The governments of the world through the Balfour Declaration and the Palestine Mandate have recognized that by virtue of historic associations and present needs, the Jews have an inherent right to enjoy the privileges of self-government in Palestine.  Why some Jews should be ready to join the enemies of their people in open combat against the hope that has sustained their fathers through 1800 years of persecution no one will ever be able to fully explain.  The phenomenon belong to those dark mysteries of the human soul which under the cover of idealism and resounding phraseology can turn a man to hate against himself, or the nearest of his kind.  Where else are we to look for an explanation of the action of spiritual and lay leaders of a people who in the hour of its direst need seek to crush its fondest hope, and help to close the gates to the one spot on earth which can and does offer immediate refuge to their bruised and beaten bodies.

Life, and Fate, and Life Again – A Biography from the East: Karel BORSKÝ (“Kurt BIHELLER”) of the 1st Czechoslovak Army Corps, 1921-2001

My prior post, presenting the diary of Sergeant Alfred Elsner of the 1st Czechoslovak Brigade, 1st Czechoslovak Army Corps, who died of wounds during the The Second Battle of Kiev in early November of 1943, makes mention of and includes comments by two other Jewish soldiers who served in the same unit.  These men are Dr. Michal Stemmer (Stepanek), who served in a mortar company in the 1st Czechoslovak Independent Brigade, and Karel Borský, a career soldier in the Czech military who changed his name to “Kurt Biheller” after January, 1946, and eventually attained the rank of colonel.

By way of explanation, here’s a passage and photo from that post which touches upon Borský’s service in the Brigade:

“Borsky, in 1943 a Sergeant and deputy commander of the anti-tank company of the 1st field battalion, 1st Brigade, due to his skill in amateur photography – and under the suggestion of Sgt. Jaroslav Procházka – became a photographer for the brigade newspaper Naše vojsko v SSSR (Our Army in the USSR) because until then the Czech unit was dependent for battle photographs on Soviet photojournalists.  The photo below, from Rota Nazdar (“Hello Company”), shows him standing before a T-34 tank (early version, with 76mm gun and “mickey-mouse” appearing turret hatches) prior to the battle for Kiev. 

The caption: “Sergeant Karel Biheller-Borský (May 13, 1921–August 9, 2001), photographer 1. Czechoslovak brigade in the USSR before the attack on Kiev. On November 5, 1943, he was advancing directly in the first line of infantry of the 2nd Field Battalion and while taking documentary pictures of the battles, he was severely wounded by fragments of an artillery shell.  His camera disappeared, so no photograph is known directly from the brigade’s battles near Kiev.”  (Četař Karel Biheller-Borský (13. 5. 1921–9. 8. 2001), fotograf 1. čs. brigády v SSSR před útokem na Kyjev. Dne 5. 11. 1943 postupoval přímo v prvním sledu pěchoty 2. polního praporu a při pořizování dokumentárních snímků z bojů, byl těžce raněn střepinami dělostřeleckého granátu. Jeho fotoaparát zmizel a tak přímo z bojů brigády u Kyjeva není známa žádná fotografie.)”

But, there’s much more to Borský’s story.  This can be found in the 2005 publication Vojenské osobnosti československého odboje. 1939–1945 (Military Personalities of the Czechoslovak Resistance. 1939–1945), which was compiled as a cooperative effort of the Prague and Bratislava Military Historical Institutes, under the auspices of the Ministry of Defense of the Czech Republic – Military Information and Services Agency.  (Well, I think that’s the organizational hierarchy!)  Available in PDF, the near-350-page book is comprised of biographies of soldiers who served in Czechoslovakian military units – ground and air – in service of the Soviet Union and Western Allies during the Second World War, some of whom survived, and others – like Squadron Leader Otto Smik – who did not.  I haven’t counted the number of biographies in the book (!), but suffice to say that given there are 1 to 2 per page, there are very many. 

As a work of historical scholarship the book is superb.  Most of the biographies are accompanied by a photo of the pertinent soldier, and, all include bibliographical references.  The biography is enormous, and, the book also includes an appendix featuring Czech military acronyms and abbreviations.  (Which really helps, if you don’t speak Czech.)

It’s a fascinating book.  Download it.

Here’s the cover…

 

Karel Borsky / Kurt Biheller’s biography can be found on page 25 of Vojenské osobnosti československého odboje. 1939–1945.  To provide a greater understanding of his military service in the context of the Second Battle of Kiev, as well as the daunting challenges and subsequent successes of his postwar life, I’ve translated the text via Oogle Translate.  This follows below, accompanied by the original Czech text.  

But first (!)…

…here’s a 1984 interview of Borsky / Biheller at Moderni Dějiny (Modern History), entitled “CZ 1939 04 Nisko Karel Borsky”, I believe conducted by or under the supervision of the USC Shoah Foundation.  Though it’s in Czech and absent of translation, I believe it pertains to Czechoslovakian Jewry in April of 1939.  

Borsky / Biheller wrote a book of fiction based on his wartime experiences, entitled Zítra začne obyčejný den (Tomorrow Starts An Ordinary Day).  Published in 1984, it’s available through Antikvariát Avion.  

____________________

So, on to his biography. 

First, the English translation.

Then, the Czech original.

____________________

English

BIHELLER Kurt, BORSKÝ Karel – second lieutenant of infantry in reserve (retired brigadier general), commander of the 2nd infantry company of the 4th infantry battalion of the 3rd Czechoslovak Army separate brigade in the USSR, commander of the command battery of the 5th Corps Artillery Regiment.

* 13/5/1921 Fryštát, today Karviná
† 9/8/2001 Prague

Kurt Biheller (he applied for a name change in January 1946) grew up in the Silesian Free State.  Between 1933 and 1937 he graduated from a four-year grammar school in Ostrava and then two years at a business academy.

The German occupation hit Borský’s family immediately in the first days, when his father Josef, a Russian legionnaire who later died in a concentration camp, was arrested by the Gestapo.  Because of his origin, the 18-year-old Karel was also imprisoned in a concentration camp near the Polish city of Nisko, from where he managed to escape in October 1939, then cross the border and get to Lviv, then occupied by the Soviets.  In this city, he worked as a window-dresser for a chain of several large restaurants until, like many other refugees, he was detained by the NKVD authorities in the spring of 1940 and transported to a labor camp in Parsov (Ivanovsk region).

Here, Russian, Polish, but also Czechoslovak prisoners were so-called building socialism – the Volga-Don Canal – under harsh, even brutal, and often humiliating conditions.  Paradoxically, like several others, Borský and his friend from the Free State, Boris Fingar, were saved from the cruel environment of the camp by the amnesty announced for Polish citizens based on the convention between the Polish foreign government in London and the government of the USSR.  They managed to convince the camp commander that their birthplace, like the whole of Chisinau, now belonged to Poland and therefore they are Polish citizens.  The gate of the camp was therefore opened and the former prisoners were given, in addition to relative freedom, the opportunity to work in Makhachkala, the capital of the Dagestan ASSR, located on the shores of the Caspian Sea.

In Makhachkala, Borský, who was employed in a leather processing factory, learned from a Moscow radio broadcast about the formation of a Czechoslovak military unit in the USSR.  It was January 1942, after a series of administrative procedures, he received the necessary documents and a ticket to Buzuluk.  He left Makhachkala on May 11, 1942.

On June 29, he arrived in Buzuluk in the Urals for conscription.  In the currently forming 1st Czechoslovak separate field battalion was soldier Karel Borský (registration number 866) assigned to the 2nd platoon of the 3rd company.  The platoon was commanded by Captain Oldřich Kvapil and the company Lt. Vladimir Janko.  Understandably, he went through the demanding training of an ordinary soldier and, in addition, as an observer of his platoon, also a gas course.

In March 1943, he took part in the first performance of the Czech Republic soldiers on the Soviet-German front near Kharkiv.  In the battle for Sokolovo, he performed his task as a liaison officer with exemplary courage and in heavy fire penetrated forward positions several times with an important message, for which he received his first award – the Czechoslovak medal for bravery in the face of the enemy.

When in Novochopersk in May 1943, the 1st Czechoslovak Army independent brigade was formed, an officers’ school was set up at the unit, of which Private Borský also became a student, who completed the school with good grades and had so far been promoted to the rank of corporal, as the appointment of all graduates as second lieutenants was negotiated with the Ministers of National Defense in London at length.

Although Borský was now assigned the rank of sergeant as deputy commander of the anti-tank company of the 1st field battalion, armed with anti-tank rifles, his further fate was decided more or less by chance.  In his spare time, he devoted himself to amateur photography and also took several pictures of the life of Czechoslovak soldiers, which caught the attention of the head of the education department of the 1st Brigade, Sgt. Jaroslav Procházka.  He urgently needed a photographer for the brigade newspaper “Our Army in the USSR”, because until then the Czechoslovak unit was dependent on the shots of Soviet photojournalists.  Thanks to Borský, there are images from the training of the artillery section, the first armored vehicles of the tank battalion and especially a very successful photo report from the ceremonial handing over of the battle flag to the 1st Brigade on 12 September and from the parade before the departure of the brigade to the front on 30 September.

When on November 5, 1943, the capital of Ukraine, Kiev, was jointly attacked with the divisions of the 51st Rifle Corps and the 1st Czechoslovak Army independent brigade, he was advancing directly in the first line of infantry of the 2nd Field Battalion, while taking documentary pictures directly from the battles [and] was seriously injured in the back by shrapnel from an exploding artillery shell.  After the operation at the brigade infirmary, which was carried out by the chief physician of the unit, Lt. MD František Engel, he was evacuated to a sanatorium in Kazan (Tatar ASSR), where he recovered from his injuries until January 1944.  At that time, he ended treatment at his own request.  After the battle for Kiev, he was promoted to the rank of company officer and awarded the first Czechslovak 1939 War Cross 1939 (March 13, 1944).

Junior non-commissioed officer Borský did not return to the 1st Czechoslovak brigade, as he was appointed commander of the PT company of the accompanying weapons battalion of the replacement regiment of the Czechoslovak Republic then considered the germ of the 3rd Czechoslovak separate brigades in the USSR.  When the 3rd brigade was actually established in Sadagura, on 5/28 Karel Borský received the rank of Second Lieutenant of Infantry and shortly after he became the commander of the 2nd Company of the 4th Infantry Battalion.  The soldiers of the company mostly came from the ranks of the Volyn Czechs and were almost without exception complete novices.  The next three months were therefore devoted to their training.

In August 1944 in the Polish village of Wjackowice Lt. Borský met Anna Branková, after her mother Češka, whom he married at the beginning of September.  Anna joined the ranks of the 1st Czechoslovak Army army corps and served first with the corps liaison battalion.

On August 8 the Carpathian-Dukel operation began, in the beginning of which both infantry brigades suffered heavy losses, especially in the infantry.  The 2nd company was also not spared, and on September 10 its commander was wounded in the side by a fragment of an artillery shell or a mine, in the area behind Machnówka.

With his injury still unhealed, after three weeks at the turn of September and October, he took command of his company and took part in the advance through the Dukelský pass to Nižné Komarník.  On Czechoslovak territory on October 6 Lt. Borský was hit by three [fragments of] shrapnel from an anti-personnel mine and was again hospitalized in the field hospital in Poljanka, where he also received treatment for his injuries from September.  At Dukla, Karel Borský was nominated for his second Czechoslovak title, the 1939 War Cross.

After his recovery, he was appointed commander of the command battery of the 5th Corps Artillery Regiment, which was just being formed.  He completed the rest of his war journey with the regiment, the unit’s first major action having been the largest combat deployment of the Czech Republic artillerymen in history – a breakthrough in the German defense near the Polish city of Jaslo.  After that, the regiment advanced within the entire 1st Czechoslovak Army Corps through the Váh valley and supported the infantry in heavy battles near Liptovský Mikuláš.  Here, at the beginning of March, he commanded the successful defense of the settlement of Jamník, where the regimental staff was located and where a stronger German detachment penetrated across the front.  It happened in April that the 5th regiment was actively involved in the liberation of Ružomberok, Vrůtek, Strečno and advanced to Žilina and Považská Bystrica, where part of the command battery was seriously threatened by an enemy artillery ambush and Lt. Borský narrowly escaped death.  On May 8 the regiment crossed the Moravian border in the area of Němčice, where its members also celebrated the victorious end of the war.

On May 14 he was promoted to the rank of second lieutenant of infantry in reserve.  During a short visit to his birthplace, he found out that his mother and younger brother were taken to a concentration camp in 1942, so he was the only one of the family to survive the war.

Even the post-war years of 1945-1948 were not peaceful, although Karel Borský was gradually promoted to the rank of Senior Captain.  In 1946, from February to July, he attended a school for educational officers in Prague and graduated with a very good grade.  Educational activities of the clerk, focused especially on the presentation of the fates of the 1st Czechoslovak army corps to soldiers and the public, were then performed in the 2nd military area in Tábor.

At the end of 1948, he was transferred to the 1st military district in Prague and not long afterwards to the Ministers of National Defense.  For another period, as a major, he held the position of military and air attaché in Budapest.  In the spring of 1951, Minister of Defense Doctor of LawAlexejem Čepička dismissed him from his position and fired him from the army.  He only managed to get a job in construction.

In November 1951, he was arrested and imprisoned for several months in pre-trial detention in Prague-Ruzyn and in a temporary military prison in the barracks on Malostranské náměstí.  Although he was not officially informed of any charges, it was clear from the investigators’ questions that they were trying to connect his work in the diplomatic services with the ongoing trial of the “Rudolf Slánský anti-state conspiracy center” and with a similar trial involving László Rajko in Hungary, which took place a little earlier.

In April 1952, Karel Borský was released without any explanation.  He continued to work in the construction industry until October 1, 1956, when, by a decision of the Minister of National Defense Army General Bohumír Lomský, he was again called to active duty.  Lt. Col. Karel Borský then worked several times in the combat training department of the 30th fighter-bomber “Ostrava-Téšín” division in Čáslav.

In 1965 and 1966, thanks to his life experiences, diplomatic tact and language skills, he worked as a member of the Czechoslovak Republic [as an] attaché and later ambassador to the Neutral States Monitoring Commission at the UN in Korea.  He also worked in the foreign relations department at the General Staff.  He retired with the rank of colonel.

Even in the last years of his life, his work pace did not decrease, he continued to work in the Czech Union of Freedom Fighters and Czechoslovak Legionary Community; in both organizations he was elected vice-chairman; he participated substantially in the publication of several commemorative materials on the Czechoslovak Republic. foreign soldiers – e.g. Medallions of the brave, he himself became the author of the autobiographical books “Tomorrow Begins an Ordinary Day” and “Dawn Into Darkness”.

When the rank of brigadier general was restored in the Czech Army, he became one of the first to be awarded with it.

Brigadier General Karel Borský died on August 9, 2001 at the age of 80 after a long illness, with which he bravely fought until his last days.

Honors:

Czechoslovak Medal for Bravery in the Face of the Enemy (13/4/1943), twice Czechoslovak 1939 War Cross (13/3/1944, 1946), Czechoslovak Military Commemorative Medal with USSR label (7/3/1944), Czechoslovak Military Medal for Merit II Grade (1945), medal for victory over Germany, Krzyz Walecznych (1948), Medal of the Czech Republic Commander’s Order of Jan Žižka from Trocnov, Sokol Memorial Medal, Duke Memorial Medal, Memorial Medal for the 20th anniversary of the liberation of the Czechoslovakia.

Works: Tomorrow Begins an Ordinary Day; Dawn Into Darkness.  Co-author of the publication Medallions of the Brave.

Sources: Military Central Archive – Military Historical Archive, Qualification Sheet

Milan Kopecký

________________________________________

Czech

BIHELLER Kurt, BORSKÝ Karel – podporučík pěchoty v záloze (brigádní generál v.v.), velitel 2. pěší roty 4. pěšího praporu 3. čs. samostatné brigády v SSSR, velitel velitelské baterie sborového dělostřeleckého pluku 5

* 13.5.1921 Fryštát, dnes Karviná
† 9.8.2001 Praha

Kurt Biheller (o změnu jména zažádal v lednu 1946) vyrůstal ve slezském Fryštátu.  V letech 1933 až 1937 absolvoval čtyřleté gymnázium v Ostravě a poté dva ročníky obchodní akademie.

Německá okupace zasáhla Borského rodinu ihned v prvních dnech, kdy byl gestapem zatčen jeho otec Josef, ruský legionář, který později zahynul v koncentračním táboře.  Osmnáctiletého Karla pro jeho původ také uvěznili v koncentračním táboře u polského města Nisko, odkud se mu v říjnu 1939 podařilo uprchnout, následně překročit hranice a dostat se do Lvova, tehdy právě obsazeného Sověty.  V tomto městě pracoval jako aranžér pro síť několika velkých restaurací až do té doby, než byl na jaře 1940 podobně jako mnoho dalších uprchlíků zadržen orgány NKVD a odtransportován do pracovního tábora v Parsově (Ivanovská oblast).

Zde ruští, polští, ale i českoslovenští vězni za tvrdých až brutálních, mnohdy i pokořujících podmínek budovali tzv. stavbu socialismu – Volžsko-donský kanál.  Borského i jeho kamaráda z Fryštátu Borise Fingara z krutého prostředí tábora paradoxně, jako několik dalších, zachránila amnestie, vyhlášená pro polské občany na základě úmluvy mezi polskou zahraniční vládou v Londýně a vládou SSSR.  Podařilo se jim totiž přesvědčit velitele tábora, že jejich rodiště, podobně jako celé Těšínsko, nyní patří k Polsku a tudíž jsou polští občané.  Brána lágru se tedy otevřela a bývalí vězni dostali kromě relativní svobody i možnost pracovat v Machačkale, hlavním městě Dagestán-ské ASSR, ležícím na břehu Kaspického moře.

V Machačkale se Borský, který byl zaměstnán v továrně na zpracování kůže, z vysílání moskevského rozhlasu dověděl o formování československé vojenské jednotky v SSSR.  Byl leden 1942. Po řadě administrativních procedur obdržel potřebné doklady a jízdenku do Buzuluku.  Machačkalu opustil 11.5.1942.

29. 6. se dostavil v přiuralském v Buzuluku k odvodu.  V právě se formujícím 1. čs. [československý] samostatném polním praporu byl voj. Karel Borský (evidenční č. 866) zařazen do 2. čety 3. roty.  Četě velel rtm. [Rotmistr] Oldřich Kvapil a rotě npor. Vladimír Janko.  Prodělal pochopitelně náročný výcvik řadového vojáka a kromě toho jako pozorovatel své čety i plynový kurs.

V březnu 1943 ze zúčastnil prvního vystoupení čs. vojáků na sovětsko-německé frontě u Charkova.  V boji o Sokolovo jako spojka plnil svůj úkol s příkladnou odvahou a v husté palbě pronikl několikrát s důležitým hlášením do předsunutých postavení, za což získal své první vyznamenání – čs. medaili Za chrabrost před nepřítelem.

Když v Novochopersku v květnu 1943 vznikala 1. čs. [československý] samostatná brigáda, byla u jednotky zřízena důstojnická škola, jejímž posluchačem se stal i svobodník Borský, který školu dokončil s dobrým prospěchem a byl zatím povýšen do hodnosti desátníka, neboť o jmenování všech absolventů podporučíkem bylo zdlouhavě jednáno s MNO [Ministři národní obrany] v Londýně.

Ačkoli byl nyní Borský v hodnosti četaře zařazen jako zástupce velitele protitankové roty 1. polního praporu, vyzbrojené protitankovými puškami, rozhodla o jeho dalším osudu víceméně náhoda.  Ve volných chvílích se věnoval amatérské fotografii a pořídil i několik snímků ze života československých vojáků, které zaujaly vedoucího oddělení osvěty 1. brigády škpt. Jaroslava Procházku.  Ten naléhavě potřeboval fotografa pro brigádní noviny „Naše vojsko v SSSR”, protože do té doby byla čs. jednotka odkázána na záběry sovětských fotoreportérů.  Díky Borskému se tedy do dnešních dnů dochovaly snímky z výcviku dělostřeleckého oddílu, prvních obrněných vozidel tankového praporu a zejména velice zdařilá fotoreportáž ze slavnostního předání bojové zástavy 1. brigádě dne 12.9. a z přehlídky před odjezdem brigády na frontu 30.9.

Když 5.11.1943 zaútočila společné s divizemi 51. střeleckého sboru i 1. čs. samostatná brigáda na hlavní město Ukrajiny Kyjev, postupoval přímo v prvním sledu pěchoty 2. polního praporu, při pořizování dokumentárních snímků přímo z bojů jej těžce zranily do zad střepiny blízko vybuchnuvšího dělostřeleckého granátu.  Po operaci na brigádní ošetřovně, kterou provedl šéflékař jednotky npor. MUDr. František Engel, byl evakuován do sanatoria v Kazani (Tatarská ASSR), kde se ze zranění zotavoval do ledna 1944.  Tehdy na vlastní žádost léčení ukončil. Po bitvě o Kyjev byl povýšen do hodnosti rotného a vyznamenán prvním Čs. [československý] válečným křížem 1939 (13.3.1944).

K 1. čs. [československý] brigádě se rtn. [Rotný] Borský již nevrátil, neboť byl ustanoven velitelem PT roty u praporu doprovodných zbraní čs. [československý] náhradního pluku, tehdy považovaného za zárodek 3. čs. samostatné brigády v SSSR.  Když v Sadaguře 3. brigáda skutečně vznikla, obdržel 28. 5. Karel Borský hodnost ppor. pěch. [Podporuchik Pěchoty] v zál. a to krátce poté, co se stal velitelem 2. roty 4. pěšího praporu.  Vojáci roty pocházeli většinou z řad Volyňských Čechů a byli téměř bez výjimky úplnými nováčky.  Další tři měsíce byly proto věnovány jejich výcviku.

V srpnu 1944 poznal ppor. Borský v polské obci Wjackowice Annu Brankovou, po matce Češku, s níž se na počátku září oženil.  Anna vstoupila do řad 1. čs. armádního sboru a sloužila nejprve u sborového spojovacího praporu.

8.9. začala Karpatsko-dukelská operace, v jejímž úvodu utrpěly obě pěší brigády velké ztráty zejména na pěchotě.  Také 2. rota nebyla ušetřena, a její velitel byl 10. září v prostoru za Machnówkou raněn do boku střepinou dělostřeleckého granátu nebo miny.

S ještě nedoléčeným zraněním se ujal po třech týdnech na přelomu září a října velení nad svou rotou a zúčastnil se postupu přes Dukelský průsmyk do Nižného Komarníku.  Na československém území 6. 10. ppor. Borského zasáhla třemi střepinami protipěchotní mina a opět byl hospitalizován v polní nemocnic v Poljance, kde si doléčil i zranění ze září.  Na Dukle byl Karel Borský navržen na svůj druhý Čs. válečný kříž 1939.

Po vyléčení byl jmenován velitelem velitelské baterie právě se formujícího sborového dělostřeleckého pluku 5. S plukem absolvoval zbytek své válečné cesty, první velkou akcí jednotky bylo největší bojové nasazení čs. dělostřelců v dějinách – průlom německé obrany u polského města Jaslo.  Poté už pluk postupoval v rámci celého 1. čs. armádního sboru údolím Váhu a podporoval pěchotu v těžkých bojích u Liptovského Mikuláše.  Zde na začátku března velel úspěšné obraně osady Jamník, kde se nalézal štáb pluku a kam pronikl přes frontu silnější německý oddíl. V dubnu se děl. pluk 5 aktivně zapojil do osvobození Ružomberoku, Vrůtek, Strečna a potupoval na Žilinu a Povážskou Bystricu, kde byla část velitelská baterie vážné ohrožena nepřátelským dělostřeleckým přepadem a ppor. Borský o vlásek unikl smrti. 8.5. překročil pluk hranice Moravy v prostoru Němčic, kde jeho příslušníci oslavili i vítězný konec války.

14. 5. je povýšen do hodnosti por.pěch. v zál [podporučík pěchoty v záloze].  Při krátké návštěvě rodiště zjistil, že matka a mladší bratr byli v roce 1942 odvlečeni do koncentračního tábora a tak z celé rodiny přežil válku pouze on jediný.

Ani poválečná léta nebyla nijak klidná, byť byl Karel Borský v letech 1945-1948 postupně povyšován až do hodnosti škpt [Štábní kapitán].  V roce 1946 od února do července navštěvoval školu pro osvětové důstojníky v Praze a zakončil jí s velmi dobrým prospěchem.  Osvětovou činnost referenta, zaměřenou zejména na prezentaci osudů 1. čs. [československý] armádního sboru vojákům i veřejnosti pak vykonával ve 2. vojenské oblasti v Táboře.

Na konci roku 1948 byl přeložen k 1. VO [Vojenská oblasť] v Praze a za nedlouho potom na MNO [Ministři národní obrany].  Po další období již jako major zastával funkci vojenského a leteckého přidělence v Budapešti. N a jaře roku 1951 byl ministrem obrany JUDr. [juris utriusque doctor] Alexejem Čepičkou z funkce odvolán a vyhozen z armády.  Podařilo se mu získat pouze místo ve stavebnictví.

V listopadu 1951 následovalo zatčení a několik měsíců věznění ve vyšetřovací vazbě v Praze-Ruzyni a v provizorní vojenské věznici v kasárnách na Malostranském náměstí.  Přestože mu nebylo oficiálně sděleno žádné obvinění, bylo z otázek vyšetřovatelů zřejmé, že se snaží jeho působení v diplomatických službách spojit s probíhajícím procesem s „protistátním spikleneckým centrem Rudolfa Slánského” a s obdobným procesem okolo osoby László Rajka v Maďarsku, který proběhl o něco dříve.

V dubnu 1952 byl Karel Borský bez jakéhokoli vysvětlení propuštěn.  Pracoval nadále ve stavebnictví až do 1. října 1956, kdy byl z rozhodnutí ministra národní obrany arm.gen. [Armádní generál] Bohumíra Lomského opět povolán do činné služby. Pplk. Karel Borský pak několik pracoval na oddělení bojové přípravy 30. stíhací-bombardovací „Ostravsko-Téšínské” divize v Čáslavi.

V letech 1965 a 1966 působil díky svým životním zkušenostem, diplomatickému taktu a jazykovým schopnostem jako čs. přidělenec a později velvyslanec při Dozorčí komisi neutrálních států při OSN v Koreji. Pracoval i na oddělení zahraničních styků při generálním štábu.  Do důchodu odešel v plukovnické hodnosti.

Ani v posledních letech života se jeho pracovní tempo nesnížilo, pracoval nadále v ČSBS [Český svaz bojovníků za svobodu] a ČsOL [Československá obec legionářská], v obou organizacích byl zvolen místopředsedou, podílel se podstatnou měrou na vydání několika vzpomínkových materiálů na čs. zahraniční vojáky – např. Medailony statečných, sám se stal autorem autobiografických knih „Zítra začne obyčejný den” a „Svítání do tmy”.

Když byla v AČR obnovena hodnost brigádního generála, stal se jedním z prvních, jemuž byla udělena.

Brigádní generál Karel Borský zemřel 9. srpna 2001 ve věku 80 let po dlouhé nemoci, s níž statečně bojoval do posledních dní.

Vyznamenání:

Československá medaile Za chrabrost před nepřítelem (13.4.1943), 2 x Československý válečný křiž 1939 (13.3.1944,1946), Československá vojenská pamětní medaile se štítkem SSSR (7.3. 1944), Československá vojenská medaile Za zásluhy II. st. (1945), medal Za pobedu nad Germanijej, Krzyz Walecznych (1948), Medaile čs. velitelského řádu Jana Žižky z Trocnova, Sokolovská pamětní medaile, Dukelská pamětní medaile, Pamětní medaile k 20. výročí osvobození ČSSR.

Dílo: Zítra začne obyčejný den; Svítání do tmy.  Spoluautor publikace Medailony statečných.

Prameny:

Vojenský ústřední archiv – Vojenský historický archiv”, sb. Kvalifikační listina

Milan Kopecký

______________________________

Regaling You With References!

Websites

1st Czechoslovak Independent Brigade, at…

… CzechPatriots (via Archive.org (“Czechoslovak Military Units in the USSR (1942-1945)”)

1st Czechoslovak Army Corps, at…

… CzechPatriots (via Archive.org (“Czechoslovak Military Units in the USSR (1942-1945)”)

1st Czechoslovak Army Corps in the Soviet Union, at…

… Wikipedia

… ru.Wikipedia

Czechoslovak Independent Tank Brigade in the USSR [československá samostatná TANKOVÁ BRIGADA v SSSR], at…

… Model Forum

General Ludvik Svobda, at…

Karel Borský (Kurt Biheller), at…

… cs.wikipedia (“Karel Borský”)

… Valka.cz (“Biheller, Kurt (Borský, Karel)”)

… Rotanazdar.cz (“Četař Karel Biheller-Borský”)

Michal Štěpánek (Michal Stemmer), at…

… ArmedConflicts (“Stemmer (Štěpánek), Michal”)

… Yad Vashem (“Testimony of Michael Michal Stemmer-Stepanek, regarding his experiences in the Czechoslovakian regiment in the context of the Red Army in Bosoluk, Kiev, Czechoslovakia and Slovakia”)

Central Military Archive of the Czech Republic, at…

… Vuapraha.cz

The Second Battle of Kiev, at…

… Wikipedia

Jewish Soldiers in World War Two, at…

… Yad Vashem (Jewish Soldiers in the Allied Armies)

… Yad Vashem (Jews in the Red Army, 1941-1945)

Yad Vashem Archives, Jerusalem, Israel

Diary of Sergeant Alfred Elsner, Records Group O.59 / 204, File Number O.33 / 204

Expert’s Report Concerning “Factual Report and Documentation: Investigation of Jewish Soldiers in the Czechoslovak Army in the Soviet Union in the Years 1939 – 1945” – Author: Dr. Michal Stemmer – Stepanek; Arranged by: Erich Kulka
Deposited: Yad Vashem Archives, Act No. E / 10-2, 3030/267-e

Books

Kulka, Erich, Jews in Svoboda’s Army in the Soviet Union – Czechoslovak Jewry’s Fight Against the Nazis During World War II, University Press of America, Lanham, Md., 1987

[Vojenské osobnosti československého odboje. 1939–1945.  Vojenský historický ústav Praha.  Vojenský historický ústav Bratislava.  Praha, květen 2005 (Ministerstvo obrany České republiky – Agentura vojenských informací a služeb, 2005 ISBN 80-7278-233-9)]

Military Personalities of the Czechoslovak Resistance. 1939–1945.  Military Historical Institute Prague.  Military Historical Institute Bratislava.  Prague, May 2005 (Ministry of Defense of the Czech Republic – Military Information and Services Agency, 2005 ISBN 80-7278-233-9)

Zide v boji a odboji trojjazycne – Rezistence československých Židů v letech druhé světové války [The Jews in Battle and in The Resistance – The Resistance Efforts of the Czechoslovak Jews during World War II], An exhibition initiated by the Jewish Community in Prague under the leadership of Ing. Tomáš Jelínek, Held by the Association of Jewish Soldiers and Resistance Fighters, Maiselova 18, 110 00 Prague 1; Poprvé byla tato výstava představena v roce 2005 v prostorách Poslanecké sněmovny České republiky [This exhibition was first presented in 2005 in the premises of the Chamber of Deputies of the Czech Republic]

A Journal Article

Binar, Aleš, Participation of Czechoslovaks in The Battle of Kyiv 1943, Military Historical Bulletin (СТОРІНКАМИ ДРУГОЇ СВІТОВОЇ ВІЙНИ), 110-130, V 41, N 3, 2021 (DOI: 10.33099/2707-1383-2021-41-3-110-131 / УДК: 94(477)(-25)(1943))

Soldiers from New York: Jewish Soldiers in The New York Times, in World War Two: February 25, 1945 (In the Air…)

“Seguing” from the posts covering Jewish military casualties of February 25, 1945, in the ground forces of the Allies, United States Navy, and United States Marine Corps, this third post pertains to Jewish members of the United States Army Air Force….

______________________________

For those who lost their lives on this date…
Sunday, February 25, 1945 / Adar 13, 5705
– .ת.נ.צ.ב.ה. –
…Tehé Nafshó Tzrurá Bitzrór Haḥayím
May his soul be bound up in the bond of everlasting life.

______________________________

9th Air Force

323rd Bomb Group, 455th Bomb Squadron

“Sine Alis Volamus” – “We Fly Without Wings”

(Via Military Insignia Products, the emblem of the 455th Bomb Squadron.)

Diamond, Carl Hershman, Sgt., 32900336, Radio Operator
Killed in Action
Aircraft: B-26C 41-34952 “Ginny Lou / Anahuac Lion“ – “YU * Q”; Pilot: 2 Lt. Richard N. Brown; 6 crew members – no survivors
MACR 12733; Luftgaukommando Report KU 3759
Germany, Koln (20 km SW); Lechenich (3 km NW)
Born Brooklyn, N.Y. 3/15/24
Mr. and Mrs. Morris (10/15/87-9/74) and Anna (Wikitsky) (1887-?) Diamond (parents), 501 Wyona St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Mrs. Rose (Diamond) Glasser (sister); Sidney Glasser (brother in law)
Place of burial unknown
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

Ginny Lou / Anahuac Lion received a direct hit by flak in its left engine during a mission to “Germany” (that’s exactly how the destination is listed in MACR 12733) after crossing the “bomb line”.  The engine and port main fuel tank burst into flames, with bombardier Ernest Pierucci salvoeing the aircraft’s bomb-load a moment later.  The plane turned off on its left wing, going downward into a slow spin while on fire.  None of the bomber’s crew were able to escape from the aircraft, which exploded on impact.

The B-26’s crew consisted of:

Pilot – Brown, Richard Noyce, 2 Lt.
Co-Pilot – Hoffman, John C., 2 Lt.
Bombardier – Pierucci, Ernest J., 2 Lt.
Radio Operator – Conderman, Rollin J., Sgt.
Flight Engineer – Diamond, Carl, Sgt.
Gunner – Pegues, Robert Alton, Sgt.

According to Luftgaukommando Report KU 3769, Ginny Lou / Anahuac Lion crashed 3 km northwest of Lehenich, 10 km west of Bruehl, 20 km southwest of Koln.  Very little remained of the aircraft.

Sergeant Diamond has been an enigma.  His name is absent from American Jews in World War II, and similarly, doesn’t appear in any casualty list covering the New York Metropolitan area.  His family could only be identified via Ancestry.com, based on the name and address of his sister as listed in the next-of-kin sheet in MACR 12733.  Unlike his five fellow crewmen, his place of burial – I suppose somewhere in the environs of New York City? – is unknown. 

Ginny Lou” herself – or perhaps another B-26 with the same nickname? – can be seen in this official Army Air Force photograph (75310AC / A2771) taken at Meeks Field, Iceland, while en route to England, on May 27, 1943.  The aircraft is in the very center of the image, where it’s among several Marauders under care of the 2nd Service Group.  

15th Air Force

301st Bomb Group, 352nd Bomb Squadron

“Navigator – reported by bombardier as in ship with parachute on.”

Bernstein, Robert, 2 Lt., 0-2071497, Navigator, Air Medal, Purple Heart
Killed in Action
Aircraft: B-17G 43-38505; Pilot 1 Lt. Ralph W. Steuve; 10 crew members – 3 survivors
MACR 12474; Luftgaukommando Reports KSU 2928 (only one page) and ME 2928 (unavailable via NARA.com)
Born Brooklyn, N.Y. 5/6/22

Mrs. Alice C. Bernstein (wife), 1515 47th St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Mr. and Mrs. Harry “Henry S.” (6/7/92-11/21/63) and Anna (Halperin) (1901-8/67) Bernstein (parents)
Mrs. Marilyn Davis and Mr. Richard Bernstein (sister and brother)
Beth David Cemetery, Elmont, L.I., N.Y. – Section 1, Block 3, Bernstein Family Circle (corner of Sunset and Brandeis Avenues); Buried 10/17/48
Casualty List 2/24/46
New York Times Obituary Section 10/16/48, 10/17/48
American Jews in World War II – 276

During a mission to marshalling yards at Linz, Austria, un-nicknamed Flying Fortress 43-38505 – while over the target – was struck by flak directly in its #4 (right outboard) engine and wing a few seconds before bomb release.  Lt. Ralph Steuve pulled the bomber out of the 301st’s formation by dropping back and down, and moved off to the right, as flames streamed from the damaged engine to the trailing edge of the wing. 

After clearing the formation, the burning plane began a gentle turn to the right.  By the time the bomber had made a 180-degree turn, two men were seen to have bailed out from the plane.  Shortly afterwards the right wing exploded, and the plane began to spin, burning as it fell, by which time it had fallen 2,000 feet below the 301st’s other B-17s.  The plane was last seen to be spinning downwards, a moment before 1 o’clock in the afternoon, through a clear and cloudless Austrian sky.

Of the bombers ten crewmen there emerged three survivors:

Co-Pilot – Varns, William E., 2 Lt. (New Haven, Ct.)
Bombardier – Koch, William Eaton, 1 Lt. (Elmhurst, Il.)
Flight Engineer – Bernard, Albert Silvo, T/Sgt. (Chandler, Az.)

Luftgaukommando Report KSU / ME 2928 is vague about the location of the plane’s loss, only stating that the bomber crashed at “Linz / Danube”.  Of the three survivors, the only crew member to have returned a Casualty Questionnaire to the Army was the co-pilot, Lt. Varns.  His report verified the observations of eyewitnesses in the 301st’s formation, simply stating that the plane blew up over Linz (over the edge of the Danube River) and that of the nine other men on the plane, only the bombardier and flight engineer actually bailed out.  Presumably, they were the two men seen parachuting as the bomber turned away from the formation.  As for Lt. Varns himself, he wrote, “The ship blew up, and I fell free.”

Otherwise, he stated that:

Pilot – in seat when ship blew – no parachute on.  Navigator – reported by bombardier as in ship with parachute on.  Engineer salvoed bombs and bailed out when I got out of co-pilot seat (over)

The ship sustained 2 to 4 direct hits and was burning badly in the cockpit.  The bombs were salvoed after leaving formation while we were in a fairly steep dive.  When the pilot switched on the C1 [autopilot; see more about the use of the C-1 at Archive.org] I was thrown violently to the floor of the cockpit and the next instant I was free of the ship.  Though I did not have my leg straps fastened I did not fall out of my parachute leading me to believe there was not much pull on my arms and that I must have been falling very slowly when the ‘chute opened.  If this is correct I must have been slowed by an explosion and would also lead to the fact that the ship blew up pulling out of the dive.  The pilot, ball turret gunner, and tail gunner were not wearing ‘chutes.  I saw only one parachute coming down and that proved to be the engineer.  I did not see the plane but saw much debris around me i.e. engine cowlings, part of tail identified.   

An image of Lt. Varns’ Casualty Questionnaire appears below.  (The extremely poor quality of the Fold3 image, replete with scratches on microfiche, is plainly obvious.  And rather typical.)

It seems that Lt. Varns remained in the postwar Air Force, attaining the rank of captain.  He passed away at the young age of 35, in 1958.  Sgt. Bernard passed away in 1988.

450th Bomb Group, 721st Bomb Squadron

“It is hard for anyone to imagine what really did happen. 
The explosion was terrific and it all happened so fast. 
It is a miracle that any of us came through it alive,
and also so hard to understand just why three swell fellows had to give their lives.”

(This image of the 721st Bomb Squadron insignia is via Pinterest.)

Gordon, Seymour, 2 Lt., 0-776980, Bombardier, Air Medal, Purple Heart, 7 missions
Killed in Action
Aircraft: B-24J 44-41188 “35”; Pilot 1 Lt. Jeremiah P. O’Sullivan; 12 crew members – 9 survivors
MACR 12510; Luftgaukommando Report ME 2926
Born New York, N.Y. 3/9/20
Mrs. Shirley Frances Gordon (wife), 1144 Vista St., Los Angeles, Ca.
Mr. and Mrs. Max and Gertrude Gordon (parents), 2450 72nd St., New York, N.Y.
Also 2441 St. Paul St., Baltimore, Maryland
Tablets of the Missing at Epinal American Cemetery, Epinal, France
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

Another aircraft lost during a mission to the Linz marshalling yards…

B-24J Liberator 44-41188, squadron number “35”, received a direct flak hit in the nose just before “bombs away”.  The aircraft slid back within the formation, seemingly almost out of control, but Lieutenant O’Sullivan managed to regain control of the plane and peeled away to the left of the 450th Bomb Group’s formation.  A large hole had been blown in the left side of the aircraft’s nose section, immediately behind the nose turret and extending from the floor to roof of the fuselage, but the bomber’s four engines were still operating and the plane remained controllable.

Nine of the bomber’s twelve crew members parachuted from the damaged plane after the bomb load was dropped.  All these men landed safely, were captured, and survived the war as POWs. 

According to Luftgaukommando Report ME 2926 (just a single sheet of paper – that’s all there is) the plane crashed – like above-mentioned B-17G 43-38505 – in the very ambiguous location of “Linz / Danube”.  The three crew members in the nose – bombardier 2 Lt. Seymour Gordon, navigator 2 Lt. Frank Alfred Johnstone, and nose gunner Sgt. Kenneth Olen Dean – were killed instantly.  According to statements by T/Sgt. Eugene M. Winner (one of the bomber’s gunners) in his postwar Casualty Questionnaire, a German soldier – a member of the Luftwaffe – showed Lt. O’Sullivan the three men’s dog-tags, and reported that 44-41188 crashed into a mountainside near the crew’s place of capture, possibly in the vicinity of Styer, Austria.  However, of the three casualties, only Sgt. Dean actually has a place of burial.  Gordon and Johnstone are both commemorated on the Tablets of the Missing at Epinal American Cemetery and Memorial in France. 

This image, via Roy Heim, shows Sgt. Dean and – probably – five other members of the O’Sullivan crew, the crew’s four officers possibly in the group.  The photo is from Kenneth Dean’s biographical profile at FindAGrave.    

The events of February 25, 1945, are described in this letter from Charles L. Smith, co-pilot of “35“, to Mrs. Myrl Irene Dean, mother of nose-gunner Kenneth Olean Dean.  The letter, also via Roy Heim, is from the 450th Bomb Group Memorial Association Website.

1400 Morton Street, Apt. B
Lafayette, Indiana
January 21st, 1947

Dear Mrs. Dean:

I received your letter last week.  The reason I haven’t written you before now is because I thought it might be a little easier for you if I didn’t write.  I would like to keep in contact with you, and certainly want you to feel free to write me at any time you feel you would like to write.

I, too, cannot understand why the army would move Kenneth’s body ever five hundred miles when there must he thousands of our boys in cemeteries in Austria and Germany.

We had an extra engineer and a cameraman along the day we were shot down, and as I was not positive which one of the engineers was in the top turret at the time, I immediately wrote a letter to our regular engineer Carmen Labetti [Sgt. Carmine J. Labetti].  You probably remember Kenneth mentioning “Lab” in his letters home.  I received a special delivery airmail from “Lab” today, and he confirmed my belief that he was in the top turret.  It was Labetti who I had check on the men in the nose.  He too says that the turret was still hanging on the nose of the plane.  There were only the four of us (pilot, myself, the extra engineer and Labetti) on the flight deck and the rest of the crew that escaped with their lives were in the waist of the ship behind the bomb bays.  The boys in the waist and the tail bailed out the escape hatch in the waist and never came to the forward part of the plane.  To another plane in the formation I imagine it did look as though the nose was blown off as that is where the shell exploded and pieces of metal, glass, equipment, maps, etc. tore out of the nose section.  Others in the formation couldn’t have had more than a momentary view of our ship, as we sliced across the top of our formation and were left behind immediately.

It is hard for anyone to imagine what really did happen.  The explosion was terrific and it all happened so fast.  It is a miracle that any of us came through it alive, and also so hard to understand just why three swell fellows had to give their lives.  It may help a little to know that the boys were probably busy watching for the bombs to be released, and they never knew what happened or suffered any pain.

I was the last man to be picked up by the Germans, and that evening when I joined the rest of the crew, a German guard showed us Kenneth’s dog tags.  Labetti also remembers seeing Kenneth’s dog tags.  I also asked “Lab” about Kenneth’s crash bracelet, but he didn’t mention anything about it in his letter.  I would imagine that Kenneth was wearing it, if it didn’t come home with his other belongings.

Mrs. Dean, Kenneth didn’t join my crew until about the middle of our training at March Field and the pictures I took in Italy were not returned to me, so I thought perhaps you might have a negative from which I could have a picture of Kenneth made.

I have been out of the army for ever a year and a half now.  I tried going back to college (Purdue University), but that didn’t work out too well.

However, my wife, little boy and I are still living here in Lafayette, and I am now working at the Packard Garage here.  My little boy is two years old and he really keeps things lively at home.

I hope I have answered all your questions, and again — we’d like to hear from you.

Labetti’s address is:

1169 Bay Street
Staten Island, 5, New York

if you would like to write him.

sincerely yours,

Charles Smith

The document below is the single sheet comprising ME 2926, which lists the full names of eight of the plane’s crew members, and, partial to complete names for Gordon, Johnstone, and Dean.  Despite Gordon and Johnstone being listed on the Tablets of the Missing at Epinal American Cemetery, this document suggests that German investigators at the very least discovered the men’s dog-tags, leading to the possibility that their remains might (might) be buried in that cemetery as unknowns…

20th Air Force

497th Bomb Group, 871st Bomb Squadron

Even the most cursory review of WW II military aviation history will reveal the significant proportion of aircraft and aircrew losses that were not directly attributable to enemy action.  Such was the case for the loss of two B-29 Superfortresses of the 497th Bomb Group’s 871st Bomb Squadron, during the February 25th mission to urban areas in Tokyo. 

As recorded in Missing Air Crew Reports 12721 and 12722 (the two documents are effectively interchangeable, given the nature of the incident) the two bombers were approaching the Assembly Point of the 73rd Bomb Wing when the unnicknamed airplane A square 45 (42-24808 with 12 airmen aboard, piloted by 1 Lt. Jack S. Barnes) pulled into formation above A square 44 (42-63431 with a crew of 11, piloted by 1 Lt. Austin R. Keith and otherwise known as Ponderous Peg).  At an altitude of 1600 feet, the two bombers collided; it was impossible to determine which aircraft moved improperly.  A square 44 broke apart, while A square 45 entered a ninety-degree bank with both inboard engines dead, and descended to the sea.

A third B-29 (A square 51) remained in the area, searching the crash location of A square 45 at very low altitude for any signs of life.  Nothing was seen except for floating oxygen bottles, two inflated crew life rafts, and a single-man life raft. 

This photograph of Ponderous Peg (62609AC – A38499) was taken in on Saipan in November of 1944.  

Evidently, the aircraft’s nose art was revised subsequent to November of 1944, as seen in this photo.

Here’s a view of Ponderous Peg from another perspective.  In this image from the Athey Family, A square 45’s tail is barely visible in the middle of the left-center window of the bombardier’s station … it’s just to the left of the propeller on the #4 engine of the B-29 directly ahead. 

As noted in the MACR, weather conditions at the time of the accident were “ceiling and visibility unlimited”.  Though the cause of the accident will never be known (well, among men), I’d suggest that it was a case of distraction or complacency, and if so the latter ironically because of the ideal weather conditions. 

The bombardier of Lt. Barnes’ aircraft was 2 Lt. Roland Sheriff (0-928781), who was born in Manhattan on March 12, 1922.  The son of Barney (4/4/93-11/12/70) and Violet (Hutt) (8/2/01-11/76) Sheriff, and brother of Sonya, the family resided at 86 Concord Ave. in White Plains, New York, and possibly had a connection to Essex County, Massachusetts.  Given that Lt. Sheriff received the Air Medal and Purple Heart, the flight of February 25, 1945 was probably his fifth to ninth combat mission.

This is the only image of Roland Sheriff I’ve been able to locate.  He appears at lower right, in this photograph published in the Mount Vernon Daily Argus on October 27, 1942.  Notably, he was first interested in becoming a naval aviator.  

In a pattern (for lack of a better word!) seen many times before, Lt. Sheriff’s name is absent from American Jews in World War II, though news items about him did appear in the Mount Vernon Daily Argus on 10/27/42 and 3/3/45, and Yonkers Herald Statesman on 3/3/45 and 3/31/45.  His name is commemorated at the Tablets of the Missing, at the Honolulu Memorial, in Honolulu, Hawaii.  (Curiously, the MACR name index card for Lt. Sheriff states “No MACR”, however, the MACR for this crew – #12721 – obviously, very much exists.)

______________________________

____________________

______________________________

Whether as prisoners of war, internees, or evaders, the following men returned…

8th Air Force

92nd Bomb Group, 327th Bomb Squadron

As reported in MACR 12719, B-17G Flying Fortress 43-39026 (Reba Jane / UX * L) lost two engines to flak and caught fire during a mission to Munich.  The bomber’s crew of nine survived by parachuting from their damaged plane.  They all survived as POWs and returned to the United States a few months later. 

Luftgaukommando Report KU 3760 provides a substantive report about the crew’s capture, the identification of their bomber (or, what was left of it?!), and the determination of the squadron and group to which men and plane were assigned.  The report sheds a little insight onto the German perspective of obtaining military intelligence from captured airmen, paying an ironic tribute to three of Reba Jane’s crewmen – co-pilot Lt. Shabsin, flight engineer S/Sgt. Major, and gunner Sgt. Bruin – for their refusal to reveal information to their captors.  As stated in the “Angaben über Gefangennahme von feindlichen Luftwaffenangehörigen” (Report on Capture of Members of Enemy Air Forces) form for Lt. Shabsin, “Nähere Angaben wurden von dem Kgf. [Kriegsgefangen] verweigert.” – “More specific information was refused by the prisoner of war.”

Here’s a translation of a page in Luftgaukommando Report KU 3760: 

Subject: Preliminary interrogation of S/Sgt. Anthony, Radio operator, who parachuted from a B 17 G of the 92nd Bomb-Group, 327th Bombardment Squadron, stationed in Podington, 25 . February 1945 at midday.

Crew:
2nd Lt. Chase – Pilot – missing [2 Lt. Frank J. Chase]
2nd Lt. Shabsin – Co-pilot – prisoner [2 Lt. Edward Shabsin]
2ns Lt. Shumaker – Navigator – prisoner [2 Lt. Donald E. Shumaker]
S/Sgt. Major – Mechanic – prisoner [S/Sgt. Roydon D. Major]
S/Sgt. Anthony – Radio operator – prisoner [Sgt. Rudolph A. Anthony]
S/Sgt. Bastian – gunner – prisoner [S/Sgt. Raymond C. Bastian]
Sgt. Kellam, Jr. – gunner – prisoner [Sgt. William F. Kellam, Jr.]
Sgt. Johnson – gunner – prisoner [Sgt. Victor L. Johnson]
Sgt. Bruin – gunner – prisoner [Sgt. Stanley M. Bruin]

According to reports made by the population 11 or 12 parachutes were observed, whereas the plane flew on by itself, was then shot down by American fighters and crashed near Erolsheim, 15 km. NW of Memmingen.  The crew had already parachuted near Kempten.

The Squadron:

According to the report of Airbase Kaufbauren the plane’s identifications are : a blue L without frame on the tail, L-star U X / and the manufacturer’s number 339026 above the L on tail.  (on fuselage)

Interrogated prisoner gave the same manufacturer’s number …026, but claimed the letter on the tail-unit to be : B in triangle; his unit is 92nd Bomb Group, 337th Bomb-Squadron in Podington.  The 40th Group Baker (“Foxhole”), which appears in the records he claimed not to know anything of.

The order to bail out had been given because fire broke out in the engines from no apparent reasons.

The remainder of the crew, to judge by first impressions, seemed to be very well trained in resisting intelligence operations.  Shabsin, Major and Bruin will probably not be suitable for transfer to Evaluation Point West.

And…  Here’s the actual page in question:

And, what of 2 Lt. Edward Shabsin, otherwise “0-828552”?

Born in Chicago on January 25, 1921, he was the son of George (7/1/92-10/7/70) and Belle (Wolf) (5/14/95-11/1/74) Shabsin, the family residing at 3355 Potomac Ave. in that city.  The bomber’s co-pilot, he received the Air Medal, suggesting that the mission of February 25 was his fifth to tenth combat flight.  He passed away on April 13, 1993, and is buried at Greenwood Memorial Park, in San Diego, Ca.  His name does appear in American Jews in World War II – specifically, on page 116.  Otherwise and obvious by this account, he was most definitely a POW, but – not uncommonly for men captured in the European Theater towards the end of the war – the POW camp in which he was interned is unknown.

351st Bomb Group, 509th Bomb Squadron

The loss of Torchy Tess / RQ * V, a B-17G Flying Fortress of the 351st Bomb Group’s 509th Bomb Squadron, is covered in Missing Air Crew Report 12728, and in very great detail on pages 67 through 69 in Volume II of Hans-Heiri Stapfer’s Strangers In a Strange Land.  Struck by flak during a mission to Munich (the crew’s second mission), the bomber, 43-37854, was last seen at 7,000 feet near Lake Constance, Switzerland, being escorted by three fighters. 

As revealed in flight engineer Sgt. Clinton O. Norby’s account, flak severely damaged the left side of the fuselage, particularly the pilot’s windows, flight controls, and instruments, placing the burden of flying the aircraft on the co-pilot, 2 Lt. Harold V. Gividen.  The explosion had also wounded the nose gunner and navigator.  The escorting fighter planes turned out to be Swiss aircraft, as denoted by their white-cross-on-red-square national insignia. 

The aircraft gradually descended as it flew onwards, with Norby recollecting, “…I could see that we were going to crash, and not on a flat piece of ground. …  I looked at the air speed and it was indicating 140 mph.  This surprised me as we usually cruised at 130 mph indicating.  Three things came to my mind: this was going to be a bad crash, we still had over 1,000 gallons of gas onboard, and I was worried about fire.”

By the time the aircraft impacted, the engines had stopped running, the only noise coming from the aircraft hitting treetops.  As the aircraft slowed, the last tree it hit, “…was a very large one and we hit on the left side of the plane, wrapped around it and stopped.”  The front of the aircraft had been demolished, with pilot Abplanalp having been killed in the crash.  The seven other crew members survived, with the co-pilot, navigator, and two waist gunners, wounded by flak or injured in the landing, being taken to a hospital in Lucerne.

This mission was the first or second combat flight of the plane’s radio operator, Sergeant Paul Levinson (16168993).  The son of Benjamin G. and Jennie (Golden) Levinson and brother of Elaine, his family’s home address was 5959 Kenmore Ave., Chicago, though another address may have been 3143 Wilson Ave. in the same city.  His name appears on page 378 of American Jews in World War II, which – by the lack of any other information – suggests (?) that he received no medals or awards.  Born in Chicago on April 23, 1923, he passed away on March 7, 2007.   

351st Bomb Group, 508th Bomb Squadron

No Missing Air Crew Report exists for B-17G 42-97843 of the 351st Bomb Group’s 508th Bomb Squadron.  This is because the bomber (YB * C), which lost two engines to flak during a mission to Munich, and then a third after leaving that target, landed on its remaining engine at a French fighter airfield at Lunéville, with its co-pilot – Carl Stahl – seriously wounded in his right foot and leg by flak.  Thus, neither the plane nor crew were missing for the 48-hour time period allotted before a MACR would be filed. 

Also wounded, though the specifics are unknown, was the plane’s bombardier, 2 Lt. Norman Rosenblatt (0-1304955), who was awarded the Air Medal and one Oak Leaf Cluster, and of course the Purple Heart.  This was his 19th combat mission.  The husband of Rosalind Rosenblatt of 87 Woodruff Ave., Brooklyn, his name can be found on page 418 of American Jews in World War II, while this incident is noted on pages 67 and 130 of A Chronicle of the 351st Bomb Group (H).  A review of the MACR name index reveals the notation “No MACR” on the file card bearing his name.  

Other known crew members were YB * C’s pilot, 1 Lt. Robert A. Sandel, navigator 1 Lt. Edward H.L. Clarac, Jr. (also wounded: “A fragment of a German 88mm shell nicked Ed’s neck and tore through his throat mike, putting a hole in his scarf and tearing thru his B-10 jacket.”), and tail gunner Arthur Kemp.

486th Bomb Group, 835th Bomb Squadron

(This reproduction of the 835th Bomb Squadron’s strange yet colorful insignia was created by EBay seller abqMetal.)

Though a Missing Air Crew Report – # 12578 – was certainly filed for B-17G 43-38648 H8 * H of the 486th Bomb Group’s 835th Bomb Squadron, unfortunately, the document is not accessible through NARA (So, what else is new?  I can only surmise – ? – that this MACR – as copied in digital format from microfiche masters – is one of the many Missing Air Crew Reports, created by Fold3 which are of such abysmal quality as to be barely readable, or, completely illegible (out of focus, contrast ridiculously low or high, and heavily adorned with damage, scratches, and smudges that obscure individual frames of the MACR), to the point of being inaccessible when searching through NARA’s online catalog.) 

Fortunately, the story of the loss of this crew and plane can be reconstructed from other sources.  These include the American Air Museum in Britain, Jing Zhou’s B-17 Bomber Flying Fortress – The Queen of The Skies, Luftgaukommando Report KU 3738, and the 486th Bomb Group Association’s website.  The latter reveals that during the Group’s mission to Neuberg, Germany, the aircraft, piloted by 1 Lt. William C. Wiley, “…suffered a flak hit in the right wing, leaving a gaping hole.  The aircraft’s right inboard engine was feathered and no gasoline was getting to the #3 engine, which was feathered and #4 was smoking.  The aircraft was losing altitude and falling behind the formation.  Lt. Wiley managed to make a wheels up landing near Altstödten, Germany.”  The entire crew was captured and eventually returned to the United States. 

In terms of photos, Lt. Wiley can be seen here, while five of the crew’s six enlisted men can be seen here.  The crew list, below, has been reconstructed from data at the 486th Bomb Group’s website and the Luftgaukommando Report.  The formation plan for the mission is available here.  

Pilot – 1 Lt. William C. Wiley
Co-Pilot – 2 Lt. Donald J. Demerath
Navigator – F/O Demetrios G. Maurides
Gunner (Nose) – S/Sgt. Clarence M. Baugh
Flight Engineer – T/Sgt. Curtis L. Jessen
Radio Operator – S/Sgt. Donald Wilbur Brown
Gunner (Ball Turret) – S/Sgt. Keith G. Splude
Gunner (Waist) – S/Sgt. George Rubin
Gunner (Tail) – S/Sgt. James B. Manford

There are two great photos of H8 * H….  

This image, at the 486th Bombardment Group website, shows the aircraft in flight, viewed from above, with contrails behind.  This image is via George Rubin.  

Here’s a high-resolution close-up of the same photo, via the American Air Museum in Britain.  (Image UPL 37758.)  Clearly visible is the red and blue chevron on the plane’s right wing.  

This image, also at the 486th Bomb Group website, via George Rubin, shows H8 * H, draped by German soldiers with foliage for concealment from Allied fighters (good luck with that, given the yellow tail, triple-yellow striped fuselage, and color chevron on the starboard wing!) after its crash-landing. 

Luftgaukommando Report 3738 is remarkably comprehensive in its description of the condition, examination, and recovery of H8 * H.  The report states that the aircraft made an emergency landing 2 kilometers south of Sonthofen / Allgäu at 1255 hours. 

This Oogle map shows Sonthofen relative to Munich and the Swiss border.  The city is directly south of Kempten, which is in the center of the map.  The mountaintops south of these cities probably correspond to those seen at the left center of the above photo, in the distance beyond the B-17.  If so, this would indicate that the plane was heading south when it landed, suggesting that the crew had hoped to reach Switzerland.  

xxxxxxxxxxx

Oogling in, we can see Sonthofen, and, Burgberg im Allgäu in the map’s center.  The probably crash-landing location is denoted by the red circle. 

A map view at an even larger scale reveals the area – the Iller River valley – in greater detail.  

S/Sgt. George Rubin (32991833) was born in Brooklyn on May 7, 1925, the son of Dr. and Mrs. William and Rita Rubin, of 240 Utica Ave.  The recipient of the Air Medal with three Oak Leaf Clusters (thus suggesting he completed between fifteen and twenty combat missions), and Purple Heart, his name can be found on page 423 of American Jews in World War II

12th Air Force

340th Bomb Group, 489th Bomb Squadron

(Via Pinterest, and I think (?) designed by PzD501 and featured at TeePublic, here’s the insignia of the 489th Bomb Squadron.  For those with a bent towards literature and science fiction, this is the military unit in which Walter M. Miller, Jr., author of the acclaimed novel A Canticle for Liebowitz, served as a radio operator.) 

Bubbies / 9G, a B-25J Mitchell that officially went by the serial number 43-4062, was shot down by anti-aircraft fire during a mission to Vipiteno, Italy.  As described in MACR 12707, the aircraft, piloted by 1 Lt. Gayle C. Gearheart and leading an element of three 489th Bomb Squadron Mitchells, was seen by 2 Lt. Charles Huber, Jr. (piloting a B-25 in the number three position) was seen to be throwing fuel or oil from its port engine, which seemed to quit, and then was feathered.  When last seen, Bubbies was heading up a valley under escort by two fighters, apparently under control and maintaining its altitude.  Lt. Gearheart informed Lt. Huber that he was, “okay, and not to stay with him”.

Fortunately, the entire crew survived.  As reported by 2 Lt. Wendell H. Beverly (co-pilot), Sgt. Harold Schoenholtz (radio operator / gunner), and Sgt. Albert D. Taylor (tail gunner) in their postwar Casualty Questionnaires, the aircraft was crash-landed in the vicinity of “Glurn”, “Glurns”, or “Glorenza”, Italy, while Luftgaukommando Report ME 2923 lists 9G as having landed 200 meters northwest of “Graun” at 13:25 hours.  I believe this is in the Italian Tyrol. 

The pilots must have made an excellent landing, for the report states that the plane was only 10% damaged, and gives an extremely detailed breakdown of the aircraft’s radio equipment, as well as emergency equipment such as parachutes (obviously not used!), life jackets and life rafts, and flares.  The report also verifies Lt. Huber’s observation of 9G’s battle damage, a translation of the document stating, “Fuselage slightly damaged by bullets.  Propellers spoilt by bending.  Condition of the landing gear cannot be seen, because the belly landing was made with retracted landing gear.  Left motor slightly damaged by bullets, which caused its loss during the flight.”

As is typical for airmen and soldiers captured in 1945, there’s no specific information, directly via the National Archives, identifying the POW camps to which the crew members were sent.  However, this is answered in Sgt. Schoenholtz’s Casualty Questionnaire, which reveals that at least some (perhaps all?) of the crew were interned at Nuremberg by late March, and then at Moosburg, where they were liberated.

As for Sgt. Schoenholtz (32976723), he was born in Manhattan on August 6, 1918 to Dr. and Mrs. Adolph Israel (4/1/80-8/21/45) and Jane (Liebowitz) (1891-?) Schoenholtz, who during the war resided at 3204 Rochambeau Ave., in the Bronx.  His sister was Gertrude Evelyn (“Eve” / “Gotel Chava”?) (4/19/14-11/8/91).  Akin to other airmen listed in this (and many other) posts, his name never appeared in American Jews in World War II.  He passed away on April 16, 2017. 

By the way, though the MACR lists 9G’s nickname as “BUVVIES”, it’s actually “Bubbies”, as seen in this photo of Bubbies’ nose art, via the American Air Museum in England

451st Bomb Group, 727th Bomb Squadron

(The unit insignia of the 727th Bomb Squadron is colorful and symbolic: Two airmen sit atop a winged boxcar, one firing a machine gun, the other flying the contraption, or, dropping bombs.  This example, an original patch, is from US Wars Patches.)

2 Lt. Albert “Buddy” Sokol (0-2001534), a navigator, was one of the few survivors of B-24J 42-52054, an aircraft of the 727th Bomb Squadron, 451st Bomb Group.

The husband of Pauline “Polly” (Kaplan) Sokol (9/17/23-3/31/15), of 309 South 19th St., Bessemer, Alabama, he was born in Birmingham on November 4, 1923.  His parents were Isadore “Issie” (8/2/95-1/1/53) and Elisa (Yosovich) (2/28/99-1/29/62) Sokol, whose wartime address (residential or business – I don’t know which) was listed as 2105 Clarendon Ave. (or 2nd Ave.) also in Bessemer.  The recipient of the Air Medal with one Oak Leaf Cluster and Purple Heart, his name appears on page 36 of American Jews in World War IIHe passed away on December 10, 2008 and is buried at Elmwood Cemetery in Birmingham.  Akin to other servicemen captured in the European Theater by this point in the war, the POW camp where he was interned isn’t known. 

The loss (over Linz) of 42-52054, piloted by 2 Lt. David N. Compton, is covered in Missing Air Crew Report 12472, in a statement by 2 Lt. Philip K. Pohl.  Lt. Pohl reported that, “…when the formation was over Linz, Austria, at 1323 hours, and just before “bombs away”, a burst of flak struck [Lt. Compton’s] ship in the bomb-bays.  Almost at the same time, he dropped his bombs.  A fire spread from the wings back, and the plane slid away from the formation, losing altitude in a glide.  It was still under control when I last saw it.  It has been reported that four (4) chutes were seen to open, and that the plane was last seen at an altitude of about 10,000 feet.”

The reports were correct: There were four survivors from the 10 crewmen aboard the un-nicknamed Liberator.  Besides Lt. Sokol, the other three men were:

Right waist gunner – Sullivan, John W., Sgt. – Lynn, Ma.
Nose gunner – Rhoades, Lawrence J., Sgt. – Greenville, Oh.
Special radio (intercept) operator – Felderhoff, Alfred, S/Sgt. – Philadelphia, Pa.

The identification of the crew is covered in sparse detail in Luftgaukommando Report KSU / ME 2925, which simply indicates that Lt. Compton’s Liberator exploded in mid-air over in the vicinity of Linz. 

Otherwise, the Missing Air Crew Report is enigmatic, for – coincidentally or not – it’s entirely absent of any correspondence or completed Casualty Questionnaires from Felderhoff, Rhoades, Sokol, and Sullivan. 

Perhaps there was little that they could say.

Perhaps there was little that they wanted to say.

15th Air Force

459th Bomb Group, 758th Bomb Squadron

(This image of a replica patch of the 758th Bomb Squadron is from SdcRX4’s flickr page.)

One of my earliest posts, concerning the Prisoner of War experiences of 1 Lt. (and postwar Rabbi) Leonard Winograd of the 376th Bomb Group, mentions the remarkable coincidence of another 15th Air Force navigator by exactly the same name, who – too – was shot down during a combat mission.  This “other” Leonard Winograd had a rather different experience in occupied Europe:  With his entire crew, he was able to evade capture and return to military control. 

“This” Leonard Winograd (0-2066090), a Second Lieutenant, served in the 758th Bomb Squadron of the 459th Bomb Group.  Like other 15th Air Force bombers lost this day, his aircraft didn’t return from a mission to Linz, Austria.  As reported by Captain David R. Crockett in MACR 12360, Lowry’s aircraft, B-24J (probably un-nicknamed) 42-51382, piloted by 2 Lt. Lionel L. Lowry, Jr., failed to rally with the rest of the 459th after the Group dropped its bombs over the target, amidst heavy and accurate flak.  The aircraft was seen to be slowly losing altitude, and, “…seemingly “floating” towards the ground,” apparently under control.  The plane was last seen about 5 miles north of Linz.  Other than this statement, a very generic map showing the plane’s last plotted location, and a standard data crew and aircraft data form typical of other late-war 15th Air Force MACRs, the report is absent of other documents.  However, the penciled-in “RTD” notation by the name of each of the bomber’s ten crewman, and the lack of a corresponding Luftgaukommando Report, very strongly implies that the entire crew evaded capture. 

How?  With who assisting?  I don’t know, but I suppose a relevant account exists, somewhere.

As for Lt. Winograd, he was born in New York State on December 15, 1924 to Morris (5/20/95-10/74) and Miriam “Minnie” (Shrybman) (3/23/98-6/87) Winograd, of 106 Laburnum Crescent in the city of Rochester.  His brother Solomon served as a Private in the Army.  Though his missing in action and returned-to-duty status was reported upon in the Rochester Times Union on 4/18/45 and 4/19/45 respectively, his name (like that of so very many other servicemen) is absent from American Jews in World War II

Rochester Times-Union, April 18, 1945…

…same newspaper, April 19.

Leonard Winograd passed away on May 10, 1987, and is buried in a city known as Palo Alto, in a land once thought of as California.  But, it’s a different California now.  

Another Incident; Eyewitness to the loss of B-17

15th Air Force

463rd Bomb Group, 773rd Bomb Squadron

(This example of the 773rd Bomb Squadron insignia was found at US Wings.)

Togglier (enlisted bombardier) T/Sgt. Bernard Feldman (12063820) was one of three eyewitnesses to the loss of B-17G 43-38488, an aircraft of the 463rd Bomb Group’s 773rd Bomb Squadron, which was covered in Missing Air Crew Report 12468. 

Piloted by 1 Lt. Donald U. Bissonnette and 2 Lt. Ralph W. Bender, nine members of the un-nicknamed bomber’s crew of ten ultimately survived the loss of their aircraft, during a mission to (…once again…) Linz, Austria.  The crew parachuted from 2,000 feet near (as described by Lt. Bissonnette) Tetnang, Germany, or (as described by navigator 1 Lt. William C. Bister) 10 miles east of Lake Constance, landed uninjured, and were captured. 

Luftgaukommando Report KSU 2921 includes an English-language transcript of a (not-too-voluntary?!) statement by right waist gunner S/Sgt. Israel R. Phillips, who evaded capture for a brief while until he was arrested in Lindau.  Then, he escaped, only to be re-arrested in Sustenau.  Here’s his statement…

S T A T E M E N T

S/Sgt. of the U S A Air Force,
Phillips R. Israel, A S No. 38452531 A. S.W.
born: 24 February 1924 in Texas
made the following statement:

Sunday 25 February 1945 we flew into German territory with a 4 engined bomber.  (Crew of 10 men.)  We were forced to make an emergency landing because of a motor defect, caused by the German Air Defence.  I am unable to name the area where we landed, however, it was not very far away from the Swiss border.  Without caring for my other mates of the crew, I left the machine immediately after the landing and went away alone.

By means of a compass and a map I went by foot to Lindau where I was arrested by a Police-man.  After a short interrogation a guard of the Army was ordered to bring me away, I didn’t know where.

Again I tried to escape and ran away from the sentries, reached Sustenau, from where I intended to cross the border.  In Sustenau I was arrested a second time, carefully examined and escorted by two guards to the “Markt Pengau”.  At my first arrest in Lindau the compass, and maps and the amount of $48.00 was taken away from me.

N i e d e r s c h r i f t

S / Sgt. der U.S.A. Luftwaffe,
P h i l l i p s R. I s r a e l, Armee Nr. 38462531 A.S.W.
geb. am 24.2.1925 in Texas, gibt folgendes an.

Am Sonntag den 25.2.1945 flogen wir (10 Mann Besatzung) mit einin 4 motorigen Bomber in das Reichsgebiet ein.
Infolge eines Motordefektes, durch einen Treffer der deutschen Abwehr waren wir gezwungen eine Notlandung vorzunehmen.
Die Gegend wo wir landeten, weiss ich nicht zu nennen, allenfalls aber nicht sehr weit von der Schweizer Grenze enrfernt.
Ohne mich um meine anderen Kamerdan der Besatzung zu kümmern, verliess ich sofort nach der Landung die Maschiene und entfernte mich allein.
Mittels eines Kompasses und einer Karte ging ich zu Fuss bis nach Lindau wo ich durch ein Polizeiorgan verhaftet wurde.
Nach einen kurzen Verhör, hatte ein Wehrmachtsposten den Befehl mich wegzubringen, wohin ist mir unbekannt.
Abermals versuchte ich zu entkommen und lief den Posten davon, kam bis nach Lustenau, von we aus ich über die Grenze wollte.
In Lustenau wurde ich neuerlich festgenommen, eigehend verhört und in Begleitung zweier Posten nach Markt Pongau überstellt.
Kompass und Karte, sowie ein Betrag von Dolars 48, – wuden mir bei der ersten Festnahme in Lindau abgenommen.

… and here’s the original German document…


Left waist gunner S/Sgt. Leonard A. Strong never returned.  As found in documentation at FindAGrave, and, described by William Bister in his Casualty Questionnaire, the sergeant was with his fellow crewmen when the group was being taken to an interrogation center “just north of Frankfurt on Main”, on March 1, 1945.  Just after the ten men A.M. were taken to a German Red Cross center in Brucksal, a few blocks from the city’s railroad station.  About two in the afternoon, bombs began to fall upon the station, with the crew making for the building’s cellar.  The building received a direct hit, and then another bomb struck just outside, blowing in a wall, and causing many casualties among German soldiers already in the basement.  The crew searched for Strong among the debris but could not find him, and were forced to abandon their search upon the arrival of another wave of bombers.  Sergeant Strong remains missing, and is commemorated at the Hutchinson Eastside Cemetery, in Hutchinson, Kansas.

Though NARA’s Enlistment Record database confirms that T/Sgt. Feldman was born in New York State in 1920 and resided in Brooklyn, other information about him is unknown.  His name may (?) be found on page 307 of American Jews in World War II, but this is uncertain.  (A middle initial would help, but in his case, it’s lacking.) 

T/Sgt. Phillips, who seems to have remained in the postwar Air Force, died at the very young age of 28 in 1953.

References

Dublin, Louis I., and Kohs, Samuel C., American Jews in World War II – The Story of 550,000 Fighters for Freedom, The Dial Press, New York, N.Y., 1947

Harbour, Ken, and Harris, Peter, A Chronicle of the 351st Bomb Group (H), 1942-1945, B. Kennedy, St. Petersburg, Fl., 1980

Stapfer, Hans-Heiri, and Künzle, Gino, Strangers in a Strange Land Vol. II Escape to Neutrality, Squadron/Signal Publications, Inc., Carrollton, Tx., 1992

A Controversy of Zion: Zionism and Its Foes, in The Jewish Exponent (Philadelphia) V – January 8, 1943: We Reject Zionism, by Rabbi Hyman J. Schachtel

A Controversy of Zion – V

“The problem was the denial of fundamental human rights.
It was part and parcel of
the same onrushing forces of darkness
which sent hundreds of thousands of Catholic and Protestant faith out of their homes and countries,
and which finally precipitated the war.”

***

“The followers of Judaism look upon Palestine as the cradle of their faith,
but they regard the world as their domicile,
so that, together will all other God-revering men and women,
they may work out a way of life which shall bring justice and peace to all.
The Jews are essentially a religious community,
whose mission is to lead themselves towards,
and co-operate with others into, the way of righteousness.”

As the fifth of its series of six articles covering the opposition to Zionism – in the context of the late 1942 establishment of the American Council for Judaism, and, opposition to the Council by pro-Zionist Rabbis from across the religious spectrum of the Jews of the United States – on January 8, 1943 the Jewish Exponent granted the Council an opportunity to discuss and elaborate upon its beliefs and aims.  This came in the form of an essay by Rabbi Hyman J. Schachtel, who at the time was Rabbi at Congregation Shaaray Tefila in New York City.  

Rabbi Schachtel’s essay is well-written, sensibly laid out, and, clearly explains the ACJ’s attitude toward pro-Zionist activism, the perception of the place (for lack of a better word) of the Jewish people historically and theologically in Europe in particular and in Western civilization in general, the origin and nature of the unprecedented crisis then facing the Jews of Europe, and, ultimately, the postwar future of the Jewish people.  Yet, regardless of the quality and forcefulness of the Rabbi’s essay in literary and emotional terms – and yes, it is well written – several aspects of it are striking:  They kind of “jump out”, whether “now”, in the hindsight of eighty years, and I’d think even “then”, in early 1943.

First, I find it more than disconcerting that Rabbi Schachtel introduces the essay by describing pro-Zionist activity in terms of being a blitzkrieg.  The word can be understood as an ostensibly neutral term simply pertaining to military tactics – combined arms engaged in a rapid movement and force concentration designed to break through a foes defenses over a changing front, ultimately aimed at a decisive defeat (this is derived from Wikipedia).  But, it’s the very 1943 timing of Schactel’s essay, and the association of the term blitzkrieg with the Wehrmacht in the opening phases of WW II (though the word dates back to the 1920s) that disparages Zionism by indirectly and subtlely associating Jewish nationalism with the worst manifestation of nationalism then prevalent in the West.  (Though of course Nazism was foremost national socialism.)  It’s just one word. 

But, the symbolism of words can carry great weight.  

Of greater import, the essay reveals astonishing naivete and misunderstanding about the existing predicament of the Jews of Germany, and Europe in general, even as the Shoah was ongoing.  Schachtel’s, “…onrushing forces of darkness which sent hundreds of thousands of Catholic and Protestant faith out of their homes and countries,” were emphatically not identical to those prevailing against the Jews of Europe in origin, magnitude, and relentlessness.  To write so – as with other assertions in the essay – reveals a remarkable level of provinciality; a way perceiving the (then) present through the prism of the past, let alone a past that never genuinely existed; or a striking example of denial.

However, the essay is correct in respect of being consistent with the foundations of Reform (and now “Progressive”) Judaism:  Reflective of currents of thought prevailing with the advent of the Enlightenment and, Jewish political emancipation particularly as the latter emerged and spread from Napoleonic France, the Jews are seen – through the window of a kind of christological secularism – as a purely religious body, unmoored from place and time, fated to dissolve – a la Immanuel Kant’s “Euthanasia of Judaism” – into the hoped for and quietly nullifying comfort of a universalist future. 

History has shown differently.

It will continue to do so.

An Anti-Zionist Leader States the Position of His Group
WE REJECT ZIONISM

By RABBI HYMAN J. SCHACHTEL

The Jewish Exponent
January 8, 1943

In recent weeks a group of anti-Zionist Rabbis have formed an organization called the American Council for Judaism, whose purpose is to combat Zionism and to hinder the establishment of a Jewish Commonwealth in Palestine.  An opportunity is here afforded to Rabbi Schachtel of New York, a member of this group, to state its position.  As a background to this article, some sentences from the recent address of former President Herbert Hoover may be in point.  In reviewing the prospects for peace and stability, he said: “Idealism must have a balance wheel of realism – that is, if the day’s work is to be done.  We cannot ignore the wickedness of the human animal and the wickedness of some dynamic forces.  Every realist knows that the dynamic forces of nationalism, of economic interest, of ideologies, of militarism, of imperialism, of fear, hate, revenge and personal ambition have not died out in the world.”

American Jewry is being subjected to a blitzkrieg by the political Zionists.  They fill the press and platform.  They miss no opportunity to try to convince us that we are Jews by race and nationality.  Palestine is our hope and salvation, they insist.  Not until a Jewish State in Palestine is a fact, they declare, will we stop anti-Semitism and end what they call our tragic sense of homelessness.

But the blitzkrieg has failed.  Only fifty thousand are members of the Zionist Organization of America.  Even in this comparatively small number there are many who have given their support to developments in Palestine without by any means subscribing to the Zionist political platform.  Of course this does not stop the zealous political Zionist from making it seem as if this legitimate philanthropic concern embraces a completely defeatist pessimism for the Jews in the postwar world; makes acceptable a concept of mass immigration; approves political objectives unrelated to the strictly humanitarian considerations.

I, for one, differ from political Zionists in their historical appraisal of the Jews in Europe.  True, the last two decades have been bitter ones in some countries, but those decades were only part of a stream of history which in the last century and a half has shown enormous progress in the expansion of freedom.  The development and achievement of the Jews in Europe in the last 150 years are not to be measured only by a recapitulation of their disabilities and advantages.  It is no more accurate to make that stress than it is to describe the history of the Jews in Palestine only in terms of the tensions of the last 20 years, the friction between Arab and Jew, the outbreaks and pogroms against the Jews.  That is not history.  That is a partisan portrait.

There are in particular two points that seem to me to need emphasis.  The first relates to the political Zionist’s lack of faith.  For to maintain that postwar Europe will be eternally and unchangeably hostile to the Jew is to call the objectives of the United Nations so much poppycock and to imply that the world tomorrow will only carry on the evils of the world of yesterday.  It is to accept a barren philosophy of defeatism to believe that while the Axis will be defeated, the Axis ideology will be triumphant.  It is to grant Hitler NOW his victory in making Europe “Judenrein (without Jews)”.

In such a world it appears to me that it is a little naïve to assume that Jews who cannot be safe in Europe can be safe in Palestine.  By what flight of the imagination can we see a world where the climate of public opinion is so hostile to the Jews up to the Eastern Mediterranean as to force his emigration; but from that point on, the climate miraculously changes so as to offer a peaceful home for millions of Jews?

The second point that calls particularly for refutation is the so-called historic homelessness of the Jews which the political Zionist continually stresses.  Here I must confess I don’t know what they mean.  We American Jews are not homeless.  The British Jews fighting valiantly for Britain do not regard themselves as homeless.  Nor do the Russian Jews shedding their blood along the 2,000-mile-front.  Nor do the Polish Jews fighting with their Christian fellow-citizens in the ranks of the Polish army.  If there are Jews who feel homeless, that emotion derives not from an abstract philosophy but from the reality of persecution.  Palestine itself has had within the last 10 years a large increase in its Jewish population.  But it was no mystical concept of homelessness that brought them there.  Quite the contrary; it was lack of democracy, it was fascism that sent thousands of Jews to Palestine from Germany and neighboring countries, just as it sent thousands of them to other parts of the world.  The problem was the denial of fundamental human rights.  It was part and parcel of the same onrushing forces of darkness which sent hundreds of thousands of Catholic and Protestant faith out of their homes and countries, and which finally precipitated the war.

If Europe is emancipated – if Europe after the war has a new birth of freedom, there will be no need for artificial lands of refuge for forced migrants.  And if Europe and the world are not so emancipated then there is refuge nowhere.

The followers of Judaism look upon Palestine as the cradle of their faith, but they regard the world as their domicile, so that, together will all other God-revering men and women, they may work out a way of life which shall bring justice and peace to all.  The Jews are essentially a religious community, whose mission is to lead themselves towards, and co-operate with others into, the way of righteousness.

God bless the Jews who have settled in Palestine.  May they find there, and we shall help them to do so, the fullest development of their religious, economic and cultural aspirations.  After the war we hope that as many Jew who so desire may go to Palestine and there become free Palestinians whose religion is Judaism even as we here are, and shall continue to be, free Americans whose religion is Judaism.  But what we want for Jews after this war is what we want for all people.  We want a world in which Jews, wherever they live, are free citizens entitled to the same privileges and subject to the same responsibilities as all other free citizens.

It is because the majority of American Jews believe in this that they reject Political Zionism.  No amount of paid advertisement in the press with their long list of endorsements by well-meaning, yet misled Christians will change our mind.  Nor will the Zionist spokesmen, who claim to speak for all Jewry, persuade us.

The political Zionists have looked backwards too long.  Let them turn around and see the future: let them open their hearts to confidence and faith that this war of the United Nations will end in the triumph of the Atlantic Charter, and in the reassertion everywhere of the dignity of all human beings.

And to conclude: January 15, 1943: “The “Bogey” of Zionism”, by Rabbi Simon Greenberg

Rabbi Hyman Judah Schachtel, at…

Wikipedia

FindAGrave

Texas State Historical Association

This video, from Howard Mortman’s YouTube channel, shows Rabbi Schachtel at the inauguration of President Lyndon Johnson in 1965.