Soldiers from New York: Jewish Soldiers in The New York Times, in World War Two: March 19, 1945 – Allied Ground Forces [Updated – “New and improved!”…]

An editorial note…

Originally created on May 14, 2017, “this” post, one of an ongoing series pertaining to Jewish soldiers of the Second World War who were military casualties, or, who were involved in otherwise noteworthy incidents – and who were profiled in The New York Times – has now been completely revised.  Specifically pertaining to events of March 19, 1945, the 2017 post (seven years gone by already?!) originally was limited to Jewish soldiers in the ground forces of the United States Army.  However, when viewing that day in a larger context, it turns out that the sheer number of casualties and events on that now over almost eight-decades-distant Monday – whether on land, at sea, or in the air – and the sheer abundance of historical information available about what befell those men, merits the expansion of that original account into several posts: About Jewish sailors in the United States Navy (almost entirely relating to the ordeal and survival the aircraft carrier U.S.S. Franklin) and, Jewish flyers in the air forces of the Allies.

Yet, yet…  While I’d vastly prefer to limit myself to the straightforward topics of history and genealogy, the contemporary world – “the present” – has intruded upon the past, and has brought the larger and largely inescapable realization that:

You may not be interested in politics, but politics may be interested in you;

You may not be interested in current events, but current events will, in time, have an interest in you;

You may not be interested in war, but war and its attendant tragedies, sadness, and horror, may directly or indirectly – in the absence of wisdom, foresight, and the willingness to perceive the world as it actually is, unrefracted through darkly-fogged prisms of self-delusion, a lust for power, bureaucratic cant, opportunism, and cowardice – find an interest in you.  (Well, one hopes not.)

In that light, I may post some thoughts about the events of October 7, 2023 (22nd of Tishrei, 5784 / כ״ב בְּתִשְׁרֵי תשפ״ד), the reaction of many among the world’s supposed leadership classes (whether media, political, diplomatic, academic, or cultural – the players are interchangeable) to this event and Israel’s ongoing efforts to defend itself, and, the implications of both in terms of the survival of the Jewish people and by inevitable consequence the “West” in general. 

That is, of course, assuming that the West wants to survive.  One wonders…  

But for now, eight months after Hamas’ mass murder of Israeli Jews and the growing acceptance of open Jewhatred among the world’s alleged elites (from antiquity to the present, hatred of Jews typically arises, and is legitimized and promulgated by “intellectuals“, so its reemergence from academic institutions is unsurprising), perhaps we’re at Jack Williamson’s Jonbar Hinge: “The fictional concept of a crucial point of divergence between two outcomes, especially in time-travel stories.”.

Perhaps – unknown to us – the door to the future has been opened, but what lies beyond the threshold remains unknown.

Perhaps – like Schrodinger’s omnipresent Cat – possible futures are thus far mixed and indeterminate.

Perhaps – and certainly – for the Jews of the United States and the “West” as much as the Jews of Israel, and for all men and women of good and discerning will, everywhere, it is time to follow and act upon an adage of Charles Peguy:

“Il faut toujours dire ce que l’on voit;
surtout-il faut toujours, ce qui est plus difficile, voir ce que l’on voit.”

“We must always say what we see;
above all – we must always, which is more difficult, see what we see.”

And so, returning to Monday, March 19, 1945, here are biographical profiles of Jewish soldiers in the ground forces of the WW II Allies, commencing with the United States Army.  

                                                                  

Charles Blum, 0-1030447, a First Lieutenant in the 8th Reconnaissance Troop of the 8th Infantry Divison, was killed in Germany on March 19, 1945.  His name appeared in a War Department Casualty List published on April 17, while an obituary – transcribed below – was published in The New York Times on July 26 of that year.  

____________________

Bronx Officer Killed in Germany March 19

First Lieut. Charles Blum of 1057 Faile Street, the Bronx, was killed in action on the Cologne Plain, Germany, on March 19, according to word received here.  His age was 25.

Lieutenant Blum, who was born in this city, attended Benjamin Franklin High School and was graduated from Ursinus College in 1941.

He entered the Army in October, 1941, and was commissioned in Officer Candidate School at Fort Riley, Kan.  He had been a member of the Eighth Cavalry Reconnaissance Troop of the First Army’s Eighth Division overseas.

He leaves his parents, Mr. and Mrs. Solomon Blum; a widow, three brothers and two sisters.

Here’s Lieutenant Blum’s portrait…

…and here’s page 8 of the Times, where his obituary appeared.

____________________

Here’s the insignia of the 8th Infantry Division.  (My own patch.)

____________________

The Oogle Street View below, from 2017, shows the location (or, at least what I believe was the location) of the Blum family’s home at 1057 Faile Street in the Bronx.  If so, the address is now either a vacant lot or an apartment building.

Born in Manhattan on August 19, 1919, Charles Blum, the son of Solomon and Sarah Blum and brother of Beatrice, Leo, and Max, is one of many American Jewish soldiers whose names didn’t appear in the 1947 publication American Jews in World War Two.  As of 2024, the location of his grave is – as was when this post appeared in 2017 – unknown.

____________________

For those who lost their lives on this date…
Monday, March 19, 1945 / 5 Nisan 5705
– .ת.נ.צ.ב.ה. –
…Tehé Nafshó Tzrurá Bitzrór Haḥayím
May his soul be bound up in the bond of everlasting life.

Killed in Action

Axelrod, Herman Edward, T/4, 32639418, Purple Heart, Casualty in Europe
330th Cavalry Regiment
Mrs. Ethel (Morrison) Axelrod (wife), 74 Jackson Ave., Jersey City, N.J.
Mr. and Mrs. Joe and Bessie Axelrod (parents); Jack and Sol (brothers), 221 15 99th Ave., Queens Village, N.Y.
Born Bronx, N.Y., 7/22/16
Employee of New York Daily News
Long Island National Cemetery, Farmingdale, N.Y. – Section H, Grave 8139
Casualty List 4/10/45
American Jews in World War II – 226

______________________________

This image of the insignia of the 80th Infantry Division is from 6th June 1944

Dorf, Jerome Michael (Manuel), PFC, 36831303, Purple Heart, Casualty in Luxembourg
80th Infantry Division, 319th Infantry Regiment, A Company
Mr. and Mrs. Samuel Abraham (8/8/88-8/16/39) and Mollie (Lieberman) (11/12/01-3/28/48) Dorf (parents), Robert Philip Dorf (brother) (7/23/28-3/28/69), 4654 N. Central Park Ave., Chicago, Il.
Born Chicago, Il., 5/9/23
Waldheim Jewish Cemetery, Chicago, Il. – Gate 90, Temple Judea Section
American Jews in World War II – 97

These images of PFC Dorf’s matzeva are by FindAGrave contributor Bernie_L

______________________________

This image of the insignia of the 103rd Infantry Division is also via 6th June 1944

Mines, Rudolph, PFC, 32993385, Purple Heart, Casualty in Germany
103rd Infantry Division, 411th Infantry Regiment, A Company
Mr. and Mrs. Benjamin (9/15/88-3/17/50) and Sarah B. (1890-1/13/81) Mines (parents), 604 Crown St. / 763 Crown St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Born Brooklyn, N.Y., 3/30/25
City College of New York School of Technology;
Beth David Cemetery, Elmont, N.Y.
Casualty List 4/14/45
American Jews in World War II – 395

______________________________

…as is this image of the 9th Infantry Division should patch.

Murofchick, Edward, Pvt., 32897836, Purple Heart, Casualty in Europe
95th Infantry Division, 378th Infantry Regiment, E Company
Private Murofchick’s name also appeared in a casualty list published on January 21, 1945, the date implying that he was wounded approximately November 21, 1944.
Mr. and Mrs. Harry (9/1/84-2/66) and Gussie “Goldie” (1889-?) Murofchick (parents), c/o Jacob Murfochick (brother?), 254 Beach 141st St., Belle Harbor, N.Y. / 1596 Prospect Place, Brooklyn, N.Y.
Born New York, N.Y., 10/7/24
Long Island National Cemetery, East Farmingdale, N.Y. – Section J, Grave 16204
Casualty Lists 1/21/45, 4/14/45
The Wave (Rockaway Beach) 12/9/48
American Jews in World War II – 397

Private Murofchick’s name can be found upon the Rockaway Veterans Memorial (sculptor Joseph P. Pollia and architect William van Alen), which is located at Rockaway Beach Boulevard and B 94th Street.  The monument bears plaques on its four compass sides – north, south, east, and west – with the names of fallen servicemen from Rockaway, each plaque dedicated to the fallen of a specific war or time period.  Pvt. Murofchick’s name can be found on the western, which, bearing the largest number of names, commemorates the fallen of WW II.   

______________________________

This image of the 43rd Infantry Division insignia comes from Griffin Militaria

Rosenbaum, Samuel H., Cpl., 13156645, Purple Heart
43rd Infantry Division, 169th Infantry Regiment
Mr. and Mrs. Joseph and Dorothy (Harris) Rosenbaum (parents), 49 Lehigh Ave., Newark, N.J.
Ilene Estelle (sister)
Born Atlantic City, N.J., 8/11/25
Har Nebo Cemetery, Philadelphia, Pa.; Buried 6/25/48
Casualty List 5/8/45
American Jews in World War II – 250

______________________________

The shoulder patch of the 36th Infantry Division.  T – for Texas.  (My patch.)

Rubin, William (Velvel Bar Yits’khak), Pvt., 35314910, Purple Heart
36th Infantry Division, 142nd Infantry Regiment, Medical Detachment
Died of wounds 3/20/45
Mr. and Mrs. Isadore and Gertrude Rubin (parents), 10530 Clairdoan Ave., Cleveland, Oh.
Mr. George Rubin (brother), 10520 Earl St., Cleveland, Oh.
Born 10/4/22
(There’s a Draft Card for a “William Rubin”, son of Isidore, DOB 10/4/20, in Russia, address 10520 Earle Ave., Cleveland – the closest match)
Hollywood Forever Cemetery, Los Angeles, Ca.
(Matzeva lists date as 3/20/45, and rank as T/4)
Cleveland Veterans Memorial
Cleveland Press & Plain Dealer, April 17, 1945
American Jews in World War II – 498

______________________________

The insignia of the 53rd Infantry Division: Blood and Fire.

Schankman, Nathan, 1 Lt., 0-1289818, Distinguished Service Cross (DSC), Silver Star (SS), Bronze Star Medal (BSM), Purple Heart
63rd Infantry Division, 255th Infantry Regiment, B Company, 1st Battalion
Mr. and Mrs. Morris (? – 12/4/77) and Minnie (? – 3/26/54) Schankman (parents), 1856 (1555?) Grand Concourse, New York, N.Y.
Born 8/23/18
Mount Lebanon Cemetery, Glendale, N.Y. – Block D, Section 2, Line 6, Grave 13; Society Akiba Eger; Buried 1/16/49
Casualty List 5/3/45
American Jews in World War II – 428

Unfortunately, I’ve no information about the specific actions or circumstances for which Lieutenant Schankman received the DSC and Silver Star.

Staller, Bernard, PFC, 12227029, Purple Heart, Casualty in Germany
63rd Infantry Division, 255th Infantry Regiment, B Company
Mr. and Mrs. Adolf (Adolph) (5/15/83-3/14/65) and Pauline “Paulie” (7/4/85-5/67) Staller (parents), 2316 Lyons Ave., New York, N.Y.
Born 1926
(There’s a Draft Card for a “Bernard Staller”, son of Louis Schiller, DOB 4/25/22, North Wildwood, N.J., address 135 East Wildwood Ave., Wildwood- closest match)
Place of burial unknown

Myra Strachner Gershkoff Papers, 1941-1946
Returned, unopened”, by Telly Halkias, May 24, 2013
Jewish Data.com
Casualty Lists 4/21/45, 5/12/45
American Jews in World War II – 453

Via Ancestry.com, this image of PFC Staller appears in the Bernard Monroe High School Yearbook for 1943.

______________________________

Schiller, Louis (Leyb bar David HaLevi), PFC, 32695870, Purple Heart, Casualty in Europe
Mr. David Horowitz (father), 215 East 54th St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Born 1925
(There’s a Draft Card for a “Louis Schiller”, son of Jack Schiller, DOB 5/13/23, in Brooklyn, address 1440 East 14th St., in Brooklyn – closest match)
Mount Lebanon Cemetery, Glendale, N.Y. – Block WC, Section 5, Line 24, Grave 4

Casualty List 4/12/45
American Jews in World War II – 430

The engraving of a tank-within-a-wreath upon PFC Schiller’s matzeva indicates that he served – in some capacity – in an armored unit.  Since has name doesn’t appear in the casualty list of an Armored Division, I suppose that he served with an autonomous armored unit, perhaps in reconnaissance or tank destroyers. 

This image of PFC Schiller’s matzeva is by FindAGrave contributor S Daino

______________________________

Tuchinsky, Bernard (Baruch bar Yakov Meir), Pvt., 32017723, Armor (Tank “Bow Gunner”), Purple Heart, 1 Oak Leaf Cluster
Casualty in Germany
4th Armored Division, 37th Armored Tank Battalion, B Company, 2nd Platoon
Mrs. Lena Frieda (Chanchiske) Tuchinsky (wife) (1920-1990), 3033 Coney Island Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Rabbi Jacob J. (Yaakov Meir) (10/15/87-6/21/72) and Hannah Rose (Krolowitz) (2/10/87-3/15/73) Tuchinsky (parents)
Rabbi Nathan Tuchinsky, Reverend Herman Tuchinsky, Harry Tuchinsky (brothers); Fay Levitz (sister)
Born Zambrow, Lomza, Poland, 10/2/16
Place of burial unknown
Syracuse Herald American 12/19/43
American Jews in World War II – 462

The image below, from the Rome Daily Sentinel of July 2, 1941 (found via the fabulous Fulton History website), shows Private Tuchinsky and fellow soldiers of the 4th Armored Division at Pine Camp, New York.  According to an article published in the Brooklyn Eagle during early February, 1941, Bernard was inducted for an (assumed) year’s service at the star of that year.

______________________________

Weiner, Jack M. (Yakov Moshe bar Avraham), T/5, 20324118, Purple Heart, Casualty in Germany
177th Cavalry Reconnaissance Squadron, A Troop
Mrs. Florence Catherine Isabell Leitch (wife) (1922-2/26/18)
Mr. and Mrs. Abraham “Abe” M. (1/15/84-10/31/73) and Esther (Goldberg) (9/10/88-7/4/67) Weiner (parents)
5323 Arlington St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Mrs. Betty W. Sholder, Daniel, Mrs. Mary Handelsman, Mrs. Rose Poplow, Mrs. Sarah Alon (siblings)
Born Bronx, N.Y., 1/19/22
Enlisted January, 1941
Mount Sharon Cemetery, Springfield, Pa. – Section L, 450, 3; Buried 1/16/49
The Jewish Exponent 4/20/45, 1/10/49
Philadelphia Inquirer 1/15/49
American Jews in World War II – 558

The following two images, from FultonHistory, show Jack Weiner’s funeral notice as published in The Philadelphia Inquirer on January 15, 1949.  The first image gives a “whole” view of the paper, with the noticed outlined in red…

…and, here’s the notice itself:

Here’s Jack’s photo and biographical blurb from the Overbrook High School yearbook, presumably class of 1940…

…his portrait…

…and, my own photo of his matzeva, taken some fifty-one years later.

England

Killed in Action

Instone, David, Cpl., 10350719, Intelligence Corps
Captain and Mrs. Alfred and Phyllis Hilda Instone (parents), J.P. 4, Cottesmore Court, Kensington, London, W8, England
Born 1922
Cesena War Cemetery, Italy – II,H,13
The Jewish Chronicle 4/16/45
WWRT I – 106

Poland
Polish People’s Army – Ludowe Wojsko Polskie
(During Operation Pomeranian Wall)

Killed in Action

Landa, Tadeusz, WO
7th Infantry Regiment
Kolobrzeg, Zachodniopomorskie, Poland
Mr. Jan Landa (father)
Born Tarnopol, Ukraine, 1914
Kolobrzeg Military Cemetery, Kolobrzeg, Poland
JMCPAWW2 I – 43

Lenada, Boleslaw, 2 Lt.
28th Infantry Regiment
Kolobrzeg, Zachodniopomorskie, Poland
Mr. Stefan Lenada (father)
Born Warsaw, Mazowieckie, Poland, 1912
Kolobrzeg Military Cemetery, Kolobrzeg, Poland
JMCPAWW2 IV – 101

France – Armée de Terre

Killed in Action

Migdal, Joseph (SCA # AC-21P-90434)
Régiment de Marche de la Légion Etrangère (Foreign Legion)
“Tué par eclat d’obus”
Lauterbourg, Bas-Rhin, France
Born 5/2/18
Place of burial unknown
ASDLF – 142

The Yishuv

Killed in Action

This image of the Jewish Brigade shoulder flash is from Arnold Levinsky: A Soldier of the Jewish Brigade

Rusak (רוסק), Zeev (Volf) זאב [(וולף)], Pvt., PAL/17757
3rd Battalion, Jewish Brigade Group, Palestine Regiment
Mr. Moshe Rusak (father)
Born Kutno, Poland, 1914
Ravenna War Cemetery, Piangipane, Ravenna, Italy – IV,A,1
Haaretz 4/1/45, 4/5/45
Palestine Post 4/2/45
WWRT I – 152, 256
The Jewish Brigade – 299
CWGC as “Russak, Wolf”; Palestine Post as “Russak, Wolf”; WWRT I as “Rusak, Zeev (Wolf)”

Here’s Private Rusak’s biography from The Jewish Brigade, as it appears in the original Hebrew, and, with an English translation.  

נפל ביום הי בניסך תשייה, 19 במארס 1945, בשעת התקפת הגדוד השלישי לאור היום שבה נלקחו השבויים .הגרמנם הראשונים  .קרבן חזית ראשון של החיל

.למד בישיבה ואחר כד בבית-ספר של המזרחי .נולר בעיר קוטנו שבפולניה בשנת 1914
.משחר נעוריו נספח לתנועה הציונית והיה חבר פעיל בהסתדרות המזרחי בעירו
.נכנס לחות-הכשרה באחת מעיירות פולין, ומשם עלה ארצה בשנת 1934
.היה חרד לגורל הישוב והארץ וער לכל המתרחש בהם
.נענה לכל קריאה של המוסדות, וכשהופיע צר הגיוס, נתנדב לצבא

.חביב על פלוגתו, רע נאמן ומסיר .בדיחותיו הכניסר תםיד רוח-חיים בין חבריו .שקט וענו, פיקח ומבדח

He fell on the day of Ben Nisach Tishiya, March 19, 1945, during the daylight attack of the 3rd Battalion in which the first German prisoners were taken.  The first frontline casualty of the corps.

Studied at a yeshiva and later at a school of the Mizrachi Noler in the city of Kutno in Poland in 1914.  From the dawn of his youth he was attached to the Zionist movement and was an active member of the Mizrahi Histadrut in his city.  He entered a training camp in one of the Polish towns, and from there immigrated to Israel in 1934.  He was anxious for the fate of the settlement and the country and was aware of everything that was happening in them.  He responded to every call from the institutions, and when the need for recruitment appeared, he volunteered for the army.

Beloved by his company, loyal and giving.  His jokes were always a source of life among his friends.  Quiet and humble, smart and funny.

Soviet Union / U.S.S.R. (C.C.C.Р.)
Red Army [РККА (Рабоче-крестьянская Красная армия)]

Tank Forces and Self-Propelled Artillery [Танковые Войска и Самоходная Артиллерия]

Killed in Action or Died of Wounds

Finkelshteyn, Boris Davidovich (Финкельштейн, Борис Давидович), Guards Captain (Гвардии Капитан)
Armor (Head of Chemical Services) (Начальник Химической Службы)
7th Tank Corps, 384th Heavy Self-Propelled Artillery Regiment (7 ТК, 384 ТСАП)
Wounded 2/9/45; Died of wounds (умер от ран) 3/21/45 at 3665th Evacuation Hospital (Звакуационный Госпиталь)
Born 1905
Mrs. Rozaliya Ilinichna Finkelshteyn (wife), City of Kiev (Kyiv?)
Buried in Częstochowa, Poland, at Kule cemetery / St. Roch Cemetery, Collective Grave No. 19
(Польша, Катовицкое воев., пов. Ченстоховский, г. Ченстохова, кладбище Куле, братская могила № 19)

______________________________

Ginzburg, Tsalik Aronovich (Гинзбург, Цалик Аронович), Guards Junior Sergeant (Гвардии Младший Сержант)
Armor (Gunner) (Пулеметчик)
30th Autonomous Guards Heavy Tank Brigade (30 Отд. Гв. Тяж. Танк. Бр.)
Born 1925
Miss Donya Aronovna Ginzburg (sister), city of Belaya Tserkov, Ukraine

______________________________

Kantor (Kantar?), Ruvim Mordkovich (Кантoр (Кантaр?), Рувим Мордкович), Junior Lieutenant (Младший Лейтенант)
Armor (Self-Propelled Gun Commander) (Командир Самоходной Установка)

1st Belorussian Front, 1818th Self-Propelled Artillery Regiment (1 Белорусский Фронт, 1818 САП)
SU-85 (СУ-85)
Born 1924

Mr. Mark Vladimirovich Kantor (Kantar) (father), city of Kiev (Kyiv?)
KPVE-PBN (КПВЕПБН) – Volume V, Page 704; Volume VIII, Page 250

______________________________

Nakhamkes, Mikhail Vulfovich (Нахамкес, Михаил Вульфович), Junior Lieutenant (Младший Лейтенант)
Armor (Platoon Commander) (Командира Взвода)
1434th Self-Propelled Artillery Regiment (1434 САП)
“He was the commander of a platoon of self-propelled artillery.  Mikhail heroically died, saving the crew, on March 19, 1945 in battles near the city of Gdansk in Poland.  The family learned about this from a letter from his colleagues after the end of the war.”
Born 1919

______________________________

Teplitskiy, Isak Efimovich (Теплицкий, Исак Ефимович), Guards Junior Sergeant (Гвардии Младший Сержант)
Armor (Radio Operator – Gunner) (Радист-Пулеметчик)
14th Guards Tank Brigade (14 Гв. Танк. Бр.)
Born 1908
KPVE-PBN (КПВЕ-ПБН) – Volume IV, Page 64

______________________________

Tsepelevich, Isay Fayforovich (Цепелевич, Исай Файфорович), Junior Lieutenant (Младший Лейтенант)
Armor (Self-Propelled Gun Commander) (Командир Самоходной установка)
3rd Guards Tank Army, 1978th Self-Propelled Artillery Regiment (3 Гв. ТА, 1978 САП)
Died of wounds (умер от ран) at 2179th Mobile Surgical Field Hospital (Хирурический Полевой Подвижной Госпиталь)
Born 1923
Mr. Pavel Mikhaylovich Tsepelevich (father), city of Maykop, Krasnodar Krai

______________________________

Zolotovskiy, Khatskel Moiseevich (Золотовcкий, Хацкель Моисеевич), Guards Private (Гвардии Рядовой)
Armor (Machine Gunner) (Автоматчик)
10th Guards Tank Corps, 72nd Guards Autonomous Heavy Tank Regiment
(10 Гв. Танк Корпус, 72 Гв. Отд. Тяж. Танк Полк / 72 Гв. Отд. Тяж. ТП)
Born 1922

______________________________

Wounded and Evacuated (But survived…) [Раненый и эвакуированный (Но выживший…)]

Gershengorin, Naum Davidovich (Гершенгорин, Наум Давыдович), Lieutenant (Лейтенант)
Armor (Self-Propelled Gun Commander) (Командир Самоходной установка)
2nd Baltic Front, 78th Autonomous Tank Brigade
(2 Прибалтийский Фронт, 78 ОТБр)
SU-76 (СУ-76)
Born 1917

Mrs. Galina Stepanovna Voskoboynikova (wife), city of Samarkand, Uzbekistan
Killed in Action or Died of Wounds

______________________________

To conclude, the tale of United States Army soldier T/4 Edward Lazar.  He was wounded, but survived.

“It is now 50 years later and to this day, I keep asking myself a question:
Why they and not me?
Why me and not they?
Why were George Fetter and Andrew Hogg killed and I saved?
There is no answer.”

Lazar, Edward Leonard, T/4, 13155230, Purple Heart; Casualty in France
70th Infantry Division, 570th Signal Company
Mrs. Ida R. Lazar (wife), Marcie Ann (YOB 1944) and Joan Susan (YOB 1949) (daughters)
6204 Washington Ave., Philadelphia, Pa. / 817 Laurel Road, Yeadon Pa.
Mr. and Mrs. Joseph and Eva (Ethel) Lazar (parents), 1853 Champlost Ave., Philadelphia, Pa.
Also 1919 N. Stanley St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Born Philadelphia, Pa.; 2/28/16
The Jewish Exponent 4/20/45
Philadelphia Inquirer and Philadelphia Record 4/12/45
American Jews in World War II – 535

From B&B Militaria comes this image of the 70th Infantry Division’s shoulder patch.

Edward Leonard Lazar’s story is an example of the challenge of reconstructing the past from the vantage point of the present.  Given that he served in the military, the fact that T/4 Lazar was wounded in action is (alas!) not, in and of itself, unusual. 

What is very unusual is that – as related in this video, and, in his untitled memoir of February 8, 2005 (… see transcript below …) a specific calendar date – March 19, 1945 – can even be attached to his story.  This is because – unlike soldiers who were killed in action or taken prisoner – for those servicemen who specifically were wounded but survived, the date of that event instead typically remains within military archives, or, a soldier’s personal communications, both of which rarely become publicly available. 

For American servicemen, though Casualty Lists issued throughout WW II (and the Korean and Vietnam Wars) by the United States War (later Defense) Department did include lists of names of servicemen wounded in action, these tabulations – paralleling lists of soldiers killed in action, missing, or taken prisoner – never included the date on which such events occurred, I’m certain for reasons of length, and of vastly greater import, the fact that the release of such information would have been a tremendous boon to the intelligence services of the Axis.       

Mr. Lazar’s March 5, 2005 interview, by Lower Merion High School students Christine Prifti and Julia Terruso on March 5, 2005, is part of the Library of Congress Veterans History Project.

And so, here’s the transcript…

February 8, 2005

The date was March 14, 1945.  [sic]  We, the members of the 570th Signal Company of the 70th Division were stationed somewhere near Forbach, France.  At about midnight, we were awakened and informed that we were moving out.

We formed a six-truck weapon’s carrier convoy and our truck was in the middle.  The only people who knew where we were going were the people in the first truck, which contained our company commander Conrad Stahl, and the people in the last truck.

Driving black out on only dirt roads, our truck made a wrong turn, and around 3 a.m. of that morning, our truck was blown up by 2 landmines.  The explosion of the 15 pounds of dynamite killed George Fetter [T/5 George A. Fetter (8/16/22 – 3/19/45)] and Andrew Hogg [T/4 Andrew David Hogg (2/12/18-3/19/45)], who were in the front of the truck, and it wounded both Shulim Huber [Shulim Carl Huber (6/2/17-1/10/13)] and me, who were in the back of the truck.  When I regained my consciousness, my hair was on fire.  I jumped out of the truck and put the fire out.  As I looked in the hedgerow, on this dark night, there stood two GIs with their M1 rifles pointed directly at me.  I yelled, “What are you doing?  Don’t shoot!”  Later at the aid station, one of the GIs told me that my yells saved my life because his finger was on the trigger.

It is now 50 years later and to this day, I keep asking myself a question: Why they and not me?  Why me and not they?  Why were George Fetter and Andrew Hogg killed and I saved?  There is no answer.

So, when I awake every morning, in honor of their memory, I determine to do a good deed for someone else that particular day.

Here we are in the year 2005.  I have recently celebrated my 89th birthday.  My wife Ida and I are married 63 years and we have 3 married daughters and their husbands, 10 grandchildren and 2 great grandchildren.

This expression means, in Morse code, “I am finished with my transmission, it is now up to you.”

Sincerely,
Ed Lazar

References

Dublin, Louis I., and Kohs, Samuel C., American Jews in World War II – The Story of 550,000 Fighters for Freedom, The Dial Press, New York, N.Y., 1947

Lifshitz, Jacob (יעקב, ליפשיץ), The Book of the Jewish Brigade: The History of the Jewish Brigade Fighting and Rescuing [in] the Diaspora (Sefer ha-Brigadah ha-Yehudit: ḳorot ha-ḥaṭivah ha-Yehudit ha-loḥemet ṿeha-matsilah et ha-golah) ((גולהה קורות החטיבה היהודית הלוחמת והמצילה אתספר הבריגדה היהודית)), Shim’oni (שמעוני), Tel-Aviv, Israel, 1950 – (“The Jewish Brigade”)

Maryanovskiy, M.F., Pivovarova, N.A., Sobol, I.S. (editors), Memorial Book of Jewish Soldiers Who Died in Battles Against Nazism – 1941-1945 – Volume IV (Surnames beginning with Т (T), У (U), Ф (F), Х (Kh), Ц (Ts), Ч (Ch), Ш (Sh), Щ (Shch), Э  (E), Ю (Yoo), Я (Ya)), Union of Jewish War Invalids and Veterans, Moscow, Russian Federation, 1997 – (“KPVE-PBN (КПВЕ-ПБН) – IV”)

Maryanovskiy, M.F., Pivovarova, N.A., Sobol, I.S. (editors), Memorial Book of Jewish Soldiers Who Died in Battles Against Nazism – 1941-1945 – Volume V (Surnames beginning with А (A), Б (B), В (V), Г (G), Д (D), Е (E), Ж (Zh), З (Z), И (I), К (K)), Union of Jewish War Invalids and Veterans, Moscow, Russian Federation, 1998 – (“KPVE-PBN (КПВЕ-ПБН) – V”)

Maryanovskiy, M.F., Pivovarova, N.A., Sobol, I.S. (editors), Memorial Book of Jewish Soldiers Who Died in Battles Against Nazism – 1941-1945 – Volume VIII (Surnames beginning with all letters of the alphabet), Union of Jewish War Invalids and Veterans, Moscow, Russian Federation, 2005 – (“KPVE-PBN (КПВЕ-ПБН) – VIII”)

Meirtchak, Benjamin, Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: I – Jewish Soldiers and Officers of the Polish People’s Army Killed and Missing in Action 1943-1945 [“JMCPAWW2 I”], World Federation of Jewish Fighters Partisans and Camp Inmates: Association of Jewish War Veterans of the Polish Armies in Israel, Tel Aviv, Israel, 1994 – (“JMCPAWW2 I”)

Meirtchak, Benjamin, Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: IV – Jewish Officers, Prisoners-of-War Murdered in Katyn Crime – Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Resistance Movement – An Addendum [“JMCPAWW2 IV”], World Federation of Jewish Fighters Partisans and Camp Inmates: Association of Jewish War Veterans of the Polish Armies in Israel, Tel Aviv, Israel, 1997 – (“JMCPAWW2 IV”)

Morris, Henry, Edited by Gerald Smith, We Will Remember Them – A Record of the Jews Who Died in the Armed Forces of the Crown 1939 – 1945 – Volume I, Brassey’s, London, England, 1989 – (“WWRT I”)

No Author

Au Service de la France (Edité à l’occasion du 10ème anniversaire de l’Union des Engagés Volontaires et Anciens Combattants Juifs 1939-1945), l’Union Des Engagés Volontaires Et Anciens Combattants Juifs, Paris (?), France, 1955 – (“ASDLF”)

May 14, 2017 – 337

Soldiers from New York: Jewish Soldiers in The New York Times, in World War Two: Captain Arthur H. Bijur – January 14, 1945 [Part I – “New and improved…!]

My blog posts visit the past with an eye upon the present, and, this post is no different. 

Created in May of 2017 (six years ago … was it that long?!) as part of my ongoing series about Jewish military service and Jewish military casualties in the Second World War, based on articles in The New York Times, it’s now up for a “rewrite”. 

The impetus for this post is the Times’ news item of February 11, 1945, about Captain Arthur Henry Bijur of Long Branch, New Jersey.  A member of the 43rd Signal Company of the 43rd Infantry Division, he was killed in action on January 14, 1945, near Rosario, Luzon, in the Philippines.  Awarded the Purple Heart and Silver Star, his citation for the latter medal was published in the Times on August 22 of the same year, while news about his death in combat appeared in the Daily Record (of Long Branch) on February 13. 

Born in Manhattan on February 14, 1919, Captain Bijur’s parents were Nathan Isaac (7/2/75-12/7/69) and Eugenie (Blum) Bijur (4/1/86-2/80); his brothers were Herbert and Lt. William Bijur; his sister was Mrs. Jean Weiss.  The National World War Two Memorial Registry includes entries in his honor by Dr. John Wolf (his friend), and, classmate John Liebmann.

This portrait of Captain Bijur is via FindAGrave contributor and Vietnam veteran THR.

Captain Bijur is buried at the Manila American Cemetery, in the Philippines (Plot A, Row 9, Grave 104).

As you can read in the transcript of his obituary, Captain Bijur seems not to have had any direct residential or vocational connection to either Manhattan in particular or the New York Metropolitan area in general.  As such, the impetus for the Times news coverage of his death may have been his association with Brown University, and, the Horace Mann School.  Well…just an idea. 

So, here’s the article of February 11…

Word Received of Death in Action in Philippines

Capt. Arthur Henry Bijur, who served in the Army Signal Corps, was killed in action on Luzon in the Philippines on Jan. 14, according to word from the War Department received Friday by his parents, Mr. and Mrs. Nathan I. Bijur of Long Branch, N.J.  He would have been 26 years old on Feb. 14.

Born in New York City, Captain Bijur was an outstanding athlete at the Horace Mann School, winning four major letters.  He later attended Brown University, where he was captain of the soccer team.  He was graduated from the university in 1941 and enlisted in the Army shortly afterwards.

In March, 1942, he was appointed a second lieutenant and in August was shipped to the Pacific, where he took part in the Munda campaign, and the invasion of New Guinea and the Philippines.  Captain Bijur was the recipient of two citations.

In addition to his parents, he is survived by two brothers, Herbert Bijur and Lieut. William Bijur; and a sister, Mrs. Joseph D. Weiss.

This image shows page 30 of The New York Times of February 11, 1945, with Captain Bijur’s obituary at the upper left, set within that day’s War Department (Army, only) Casualty List, which was limited to coverage of the New York Metropolitan area, northern New Jersey, and Connecticut.  

____________________

And, here’s his award citation…

POSTHUMOUS AWARD

Silver Star for Captain Bijur of Army Signal Corps

The Silver Star Medal has been awarded posthumously to Capt. Arthur H. Bijur, 242 Bath Avenue, Long Branch, N.J., of the Army Signal Corps for gallantry in action against the Japanese on Luzon.  He lost his life when he crawled out of his foxhole to warn his men that enemy fire would soon run through their area.  He was killed by an enemy shell shortly after his last warning was given.

Captain Bijur’s citation praises his “keen devotion to duty, loyal consideration for his men and great courage.”  He was overseas for thirty-four months with the Forty-Third Division and was in action at Guadalcanal, in the Northern Solomons, in New Guinea and on Luzon.

A memorial plaque honoring Captain Bijur – seen in this image by FindAGrave contributor RPark – can be found at Beth Olom Cemetery, in Ridgewood, Queens, New York.

____________________

Paralleling my other posts about Jewish servicemen who were the subject of news coverage by The New York Times, here’s biographical information about some (not all…) other Jewish servicemen who were casualties on the same January day in 1945.  Actually, there’s such a massive amount of information available about the events of this day that another post will cover Jewish aviators in the Eighth Air Force, particularly focusing on the 390th Bomb Group, the entirety of one squadron of which was shot down during the Group’s mission to Derben, Germany.

________________________________________

For those who lost their lives on this date…
Sunday, January 14, 1945 / Tevet 29, 5705
– .ת.נ.צ.ב.ה. –
…Tehé Nafshó Tzrurá Bitzrór Haḥayím
May his soul be bound up in the bond of everlasting life.

________________________________________

United States Army

Killed in Action

Benenson, Irving, T/5, 32195917, Bronze Star Medal, Purple Heart, Casualty at Vielsalm, Belgium
3rd Armored Division, 32nd Armored Regiment
Casualty List 3/14/45
Born Brantville, Ma., 2/1/17
Mrs. Lillian Benenson (wife), 1659 President St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Mr. and Mrs. Reuben / Ruben J. (2/1/87-1963) and Ray (4/14/90-7/68) Benenson [Witkoff] (parents)), 1767 Union St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Oscar Benenson (brother)
Zachary Taylor National Cemetery, Louisville, Ky. – E, 268 (Collective grave with T/5 Dee E. Hobbs)
American Jews in World War II – 273

____________________

Chernoff, Alvin S., PFC, 32408380, Purple Heart; Casualty in Belgium (Died of wounds)
11th Armored Division, 55th Armored Infantry Battalion
Born New York, N.Y., 1/14/14
Mr. and Mrs. Herbert Louis (5/2/83-7/63) and Florence Rosalind (Danielovich) (4/15/95-9/28/35) Chernoff (parents), 115 W. 86th St., New York, N.Y.
Luxembourg American Cemetery, Luxembourg City, Luxembourg – Plot G, Row 11, Grave 19
Casualty List 3/12/45
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

This photo of PFC Chernoff is via FindAGrave contributor pjammetje.  

____________________

Coslite, Milton G., S/Sgt., 31051962, Purple Heart
11th Armored Division, 55th Armored Infantry Battalion; Casualty in Belgium
Born New York, N.Y., 12/17/18
Mrs. Eva Ginsberg (mother), 2168 63rd St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Luxembourg American Cemetery, Luxembourg City, Luxembourg – Plot C, Row 2, Grave 18
Casualty List 3/13/45
American Jews in World War II – 294

This photo of S/Sgt. Coslite is via FindAGrave contributor Andrew.  

____________________

Elpern, Ivan Isadore, 1 Lt., 0-385676, Purple Heart; Casualty in Belgium
6th Armored Division, 50th Armored Infantry Battalion
Born Uniontown, Pa., 3/8/17
Mr. and Mrs. Lewis Herman (3/3/86-1/4/41) and Margaret (Goldstone) (4/2/93-6/20/64) Elpern (parents), 101 Central Square, Pittsburgh, Pa.
Melvin H. Elpern (brother); Marvin Fortman (cousin)
Enlisted 1935
The official Casualty List of the 6th Armored Division (NARA Records Group 407), and Lt. Elpern’s 293 File list his military organization as “6th Armored Division, 50th Armored Infantry Battalion”, but his matzeva displays organization as “28th Infantry Division, 110th Infantry Regiment – 2/17/41-7/19/42”
Temple Emanuel Cemetery, Greensburg, Pa. – Section B, Row 25, Lot 2; Buried 12/20/48
Jewish Criterion (Pittsburgh) 9/7/45
The Pittsburgh Press 12/19/48
American Jews in World War II – 518

Ivan’s Elpern’s portrait – below – was published in Pittsburgh’s Jewish Criterion on September 7, 1945, in an extremely detailed – and quite accurate – article commemorating Jewish servicemen from the Pittsburgh metropolitan area who were killed or died during the just-ended war.  The article carries brief biographical profiles, and photographs, of 83 servicemen, and lists the names of 32 other servicemen for whom information and images – at the time of publication – were missing.  In terms of individual attention, communal memory, and foresight, the Criterion’s effort was as admirable as it was remarkable, for not all Jewish periodicals published such retrospectives.

____________________

Haberer, Martin, Pvt., 32962210, Purple Heart
101st Airborne Division, 327th Glider Infantry Regiment
Born Heidelberg, Germany, 2/5/25
Mr. and Mrs. Max and Laura (Wertheimer) Haberer (parents), 3810 Broadway, Apt. 4-A, / 550 West 158th St., New York, N.Y.
Long Island National Cemetery, Farmingdale, N.Y. – Section J, Grave 15963
Casualty List 3/13/45
Aufbau 2/16/45
American Jews in World War II – 339

____________________

Levine, Alfred, Pvt., 39015817, Purple Heart
26th Infantry Division, 101st Infantry Regiment
Born Los Angeles, Ca., 9/3/16
Mr. and Mrs. Jacob (Zusmanovich) (11/15/80-5/1/71) and Ida S. (5/15/82-7/8/67) Levine (parents), 1427 Levonia Ave., Los Angeles, Ca.
Luxembourg American Cemetery, Luxembourg City, Luxembourg – Plot H, Row 5, Grave 12
Casualty List 3/1/45
American Jews in World War II – 48

____________________

Rindsberg, Walter Josef, Pvt., 42071539, Purple Heart
84th Infantry Division, 335th Infantry Regiment
Born Germany, 9/20/25
Mr. and Mrs. Harry (Heinreich) (6/22/87-8/39) and Irma (Himmelreich) (12/12/99-2/94) Rindsberg (parents), 44 Bennett Ave., New York, N.Y.
Henri-Chapelle American Cemetery, Henri-Chapelle, Belgium – Plot D, Row 7, Grave 8
Casualty List 3/8/45
Aufbau 2/2/45, 2/16/45
American Jews in World War II – 413

____________________

Yusin, Irving, Pvt., 13153939, Purple Heart
11th Armored Division, 21st Armored Infantry Battalion
Born New York, N.Y., 4/1/22
Mrs. Celia Yusin (mother), 2853 Barker Ave., New York, N.Y.
Wellwood Cemetery, East Farmingdale, N.Y.
Casualty List 3/14/45
American Jews in World War II – 476

This image of Private Yusin’s Purple Heart is via FindAGrave contributor John Mercurio.  

____________________

On September 20, 1946, the Jewish Criterion published a moving and affecting article by Helen Kantzler entitled “Double Gold Stars”, which reported upon families of American Jewish soldiers who had lost two (and in one case, all three) sons in military service during the Second World War.  Aside from the completion and existence of such a story so shortly after the war’s end, was Ms. Kanlster’s level of detail and accuracy, her story probably having been based on information acquired by the National Jewish Welfare Board, and, her own dogged research. 

Among the numerous families discussed in her article was that of Max (1873-1/2/29) and Rose (Sankofsky) (1878-9/10/55) Zion, of 3738 East 139th St., in Cleveland, Ohio.  Their sons, PFC Morris Jack Zion (35289875) and Aviation Radio Technician 1st Class Joseph Manuel Zion (6153983), both born in Cleveland, were lost within the space of the same January week in 1945.  The family also included twin brothers Harry and Robert, and sisters Tillie, Mrs. Mildred Hershman, and Mrs. Sara (Zion) Oriti.  Morris and Joseph were members of the approximately fifty American Jewish families who lost both sons during the Second World War.  (The Liebfeld family of Milwaukee lost all three sons: Morris (USMC), Samuel (Army Air Force), and Sigmund (also Army Air Force), the latter on a domestic non-combat flight in October of 1945.  The brothers are buried at Chesed Shel Emeth Cemetery, in Saint Paul.) 

Along with Helen Kantzler’s Jewish Criterion article, the brothers’ names appeared in the Cleveland Press & Plain Dealer on February 2, and can be found on page 504 of American Jews in World War II.

PFC Zion, a member of the 330th Infantry Regiment, 83rd Infantry Division, was born in Cleveland on January 30, 1912.  He died of wounds on January 14, 1945, at the age of 33.  (Yes, 33.)  He’s buried at Henri-Chapelle American Cemetery, at Henri-Chapelle, Belgium, at Plot D, Row 13, Grave 12.

This portrait of Morris is via FindAGrave contributor Patti Johnson, a Volunteer Researcher studying the WW II Army Air Force’s Mediterranean-based 57th Bomb Wing.

Joseph’s picture, displayed below, is also via Patti Johnson.

 

Born in Cleveland on August 15, 1908, Joseph Manuel was serving in the Navy when he hitched a ride on a JM-1 Marauder (the Navy and Marine Corps version of the Martin B-26 Marauder) of Naval Squadron VJ-16, the tow target and utility services for the Atlantic Fleet in the Florida and Caribbean areas, in January 1945 based at Miami.  The bomber, Bureau Number 66724, piloted by Lt. Raymond Paul Mara, Jr. and carrying seven other crew and passengers, crashed at sea 15 miles west of San Juan, Puerto Rico, not long after take-off, from what was suggested to have been engine failure.  However, the definitive cause of the bomber’s loss – given the absence of survivors, lack of recovered debris, and nature of 1940s technology – probably could never have been definitively established.  

Here are two images of JMs, whose simple overall chrome yellow paint schemes lend them the appearance of winged bananas.  It’s my understanding that all JMs were finished similarly, or at least those serving as target tugs. 

These two image of JM-1 Marauders are from the flickriver photo collection of torinodave72.  

While Joseph Manuel Zion has no grave, his name does appear in the Tablets of the Missing at the East Coast Memorial, in Manhattan. 

____________________

Prisoners of War

Private Jack Bornkind (Yakov bar Nachum) (16150444), a member of 1st Battalion, B Company, 274th Infantry Regiment, 70th Infantry Division, was captured on January 14, 1945 and interned as a POW at Stalag 9B, in Bad Orb, Germany.  He was one of the 350 American POWs sent from that POW camp to the Berga am Elster slave labor camp as part of Arbeitskommando [labor detail] 625. 

The image below, scanned from a paper photocopy, shows the last of the 44 pages comprising the “master” list of the 350 POWs sent to Berga, with six names comprising the final entries.  From top to bottom, this page carries the names of Pvt. Alexander Weisberg (survived), Pvt. David Goldin (also survived), PFC Morton D. Brimberg (survived as well; surname changed to “Brooks” partially due to postwar experiences with antisemitism in academia), followed by the names of PFC Stanley Rubenstein, Sgt. Seymour Millstone, and finally Jack Bornkind.  

Data fields include the soldier’s German-assigned POW number, surname, first name, date of birth, parent’s surnames, residential address and name of “contact”, Army serial number, and place/date of capture.  Ironically, neither the soldier’s religion nor ethnicity are present. 

Private Bornkind himself was one of the 76 soldiers who died as a result of their imprisonment at Berga.  Of this number, twenty-six men died from the appalling conditions at the camp (one of whom – Pvt. Morton Goldstein – was murdered by camp commander Erwin Metz on March 20, 1945, after an escape attempt), while the remaining fifty succumbed to the forced march of POWs away from the camp, which commenced on April 6.  Of these fifty, Jack Bornkind died on the morning of April 23 in the company of a few fellow POWs (among whom was PFC Gerald M. Daub) literally minutes before the group was liberated by either the 11th Armored Division or 90th Infantry Division.  Pvt. Bornkind was the very last fatality “of” Berga while the war was still ongoing.  Private Aaron Teddy Rosenberg, who survived the ordeal and seemed to have returned to health, took ill not long after his return to the United States, and passed away in his home state of Florida on June 27, 1945, a little over two months after his liberation. 

Born in Flint Michigan, on January 31, 1924, Jack Bornkind’s parents were Nathan N. (12/25/79-9/17/52) and Rachel (Handelsman) (1888-7/17/61) Bornkind of 731 East Dartmouth Road, Flint, Michigan, while his sisters and brothers were Bessie, Celia, Hildah, Josephine, Llecca, Louis, and Sarah.  He was buried at Beth Olem Cemetery in Hamtramack (Section 3, Plot 344-5) on January 9, 1949, an event mentioned in the Detroit Jewish Chronicle on January 14 of that year.  His name can be found on page 188 of American Jews in World War II.

Information about what befell the 350 men assigned to Arbetiskommando [labor detail] 625 is readily available, both in book format  and, at numerous websites.  (See the 2005 books  Soldiers and Slaves : American POWs Trapped by the Nazis’ Final Gamble, by Roger Cohen and Michael Prichard, and, Given Up For Dead : American GIs in the Nazi Concentration Camp at Berga, by Flint Whitlock, and, Charles Guggenheim’s documentary, Berga: Soldiers of Another War.)  What’s especially appalling about the story, aside from the brutal treatment of the POWs per se, was how bureaucratic apathy in combination with rapidly changing political alliances in the context of the (first) Cold War rapidly and directly affected, hindered, and ultimately negated efforts to secure justice for the POWs and their families. 

The following two images of Jack Bornkind are from the Leibowitz Family Tree at Ancestry.com.   

The academic setting of this colorized picture – looks like a college campus, doesn’t it? – together with Private Bornkind’s uniform, suggests that the picture was taken while he was serving in ROTC, or, assigned to the ASTP (Army Specialized Training Program).  

This picture is a little more straightforward:  In the Army, Private Bornkind is wearing the shoulder sleeve insignia of the Army Service Forces. 

This image of Jack Bornkind’s matzeva is via FindAGrave contributor TraceyS.

____________________

Lippin, Robert, PFC, 32974463
26th Infantry Division, 328th Infantry Regiment
Stalag 12A (Limburg an der Lahn)
Born Boston, Ma., 6/7/23; Died 6/17/84
Mr. Bernard B. and Lillian (Scholl) Lippin (parents), Joseph (brother), 8020 Bay Parkway, Brooklyn, 14, N.Y.

NARA RG 242, 190/16/01/01, Entry 279, Box 41. # 96673
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Though I don’t have a photographic portrait of Robert Lippin, this image of his German Personalkarte, from Records Group 242 in the United States National Archives, will suffice.  Though Personalkarte forms include a specific “field” for a prisoner of war’s photograph on the sheet’s left center, the majority of such cards in RG 242 are absent of such images.  I think this is reflective of the very large number of American POWs captured during the Ardennes Offensive, and the consequent challenge in “processing” – informationally, that is – such a large number of men.  As I recall from examining the original document, the reverse was absent of any notations.  Otherwise, I would’ve scanned it.

____________________

Wounded in Action

Alper, Eugene, Pvt., 37642240, Purple Heart; Wounded in Germany
Born St. Louis, Mo., 9/7/25; Died 2/19/17
Mr. and Mrs. Nathan (1/12/88-9/67) and Annie (Shoenfeld) (1880-2/58) Alper (parents), 738 Interdrive, University City, St. Louis, Mo.
Saint Louis Post Dispatch 2/21/45
American Jews in World War II – 207

Hershfield, Jesse Louis, PFC
, 33810667, Purple Heart; Wounded in France

Born Albany, N.Y., 3/12/20; Died 4/26/09
Mrs. Lillian (Mantz) Hershfield (wife) Rachelle (daughter), / / 3320 W. Cumberland St. / Philadelphia, Pa.
Philadelphia addresses also 2323 North 33rd St. and 3345 Indian Queen Lane,
Mrs. Anna Hershfield (mother), 3112 Ridge Ave., Philadelphia, Pa.
NJWB card incorrectly gives surname as “Hershfeld”
The Jewish Exponent 2/23/45, 3/9/45
Philadelphia Inquirer 2/13/45
Philadelphia Record 2/13/45
American Jews in World War II – 528

____________________

Another Incident…

Schrag, Emil, PFC, 31336965, Medical Corps, Bronze Star Medal
30th Infantry Division, 120th Infantry Regiment
Born Baden, Germany, 11/9/24; Died 10/9/03
Mrs. Hilde Dorothee (Schrag) Heimann (sister), New York, N.Y.
Mr. and Mrs. Siegfried (5/19/82-?) and Lena Friedericks (Kahn) (7/27/97-6/74) Schrag (parents), 510 W. 184th St., Bridgeport, Ct.
Mr. Eugene Kahn (friend), 260 Maplewood Ave., Bridgeport, Ct.
Aufbau 2/9/45, 5/4/45
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

According to Aufbau, Private Schrag was involved in some kind of incident in Germany on January 14, but the details are unknown.  He returned to Military Control by April 12.

____________________

United States Army Air Force

Captain Sanford Saul Fineman

2115th Army Air Force Base Unit (Continental United States)

The loss of an RB-24E liberator (the “R” prefix indicating an aircraft utilized for aerial gunnery training) in Alabama on the evening of January 14, 1945, is representative of the near-daily loss of aircraft and airmen on missions – training and otherwise – that did not involve contact with the enemy.

Piloted by Captain Sanford Saul Fineman (Shmuel bar Yaacov Faynman; ASN 0-796353), the aircraft – assigned to the 2115th Army Air Force Base Unit – took off from Courtland Army Airfield, Courtland, Alabama, at 2100 on a routine night training mission.  The aircraft, 42-7113, entered the traffic pattern and Captain Fineman radioed the tower for permission to make a touch-and-go landing.  He was told to stay in the pattern because of numerous aircraft on end of runway waiting for takeoff, Captain Fineman acknowledging and going around.  There were no further communications between the pilot and the tower, and a few moments later, the bomber stalled and crashed in a turn to the left, one mile east of Town Creek, Alabama.  There were no survivors.  

The Liberator’s other three crewmen were:

Co-Pilot: 2 Lt. William Walter “Billy” Miller, Jr.
Co-Pilot: 2 Lt. Theophil Charles Polakiewicz 
Flight Engineer: Cpl. Irvin Earl Barrington 

A veteran of service in the 66th Bomb Squadron of the 44th Bomb Group, Captain Fineman previously received the Distinguished Flying Cross, Air Medal, and five Oak Leaf Clusters.  While serving in the 66th, he’s documented as having been a witness to the loss of B-24J 42-99996 (QK * I), piloted by 2 Lt. William M. Richardson (from which there were no survivors) during the 44th Bomb Group’s mission to Langenhagen Airdrome, Germany on April 8, 1944, during which the 44th Bomb Group lost eleven B-24s.  The plane’s loss is covered by Missing Air Crew Report 3763, which, due to the chaotic and intense nature of the air battle, simply states, “…that aircraft #996 apparently was hit by enemy aircraft at 1345 hours in the vicinity of Salzwedel and was seen to go down.  No chutes were observed.  At least five airplanes were lost within the three minutes near 1345 hours from one pass by enemy planes, as described by survivors from the other crews lost.”

The son of Jacob (1/1/84-5/21/29) and Annie (Garfinkle) Fineman (later Harriet) (4/15/85-1/24/50) of 77 Camp Street, Providence, Rhode Island, Sanford Fineman was born on March 25, 1921.  He’s buried at Lincoln Park Cemetery, Warwick, R.I. (Section 5C, Lot 1, Left side of Newman Avenue).  His name appears on page 562 of American Jews in World War II.

These images of Captain Fineman’s two matzevot are from FindAGrave contributor ddjohnsonri.  This image shows Sanford’s simple individual matzeva….   

…while in this group matzeva for the Fineman family Captain Fineman’s Hebrew name appears as the first four words on the second line of text.  The full English language translation is:

 A sweet flower of a boy plucked as a half open bloom.
Shmuel bar Yaacov Feinman died 1st of Shvat 5705 – May his soul be bound up in the bond of eternal life.
His dear mother, daughter of good people, Hannah Feinman bat Itshak Isaak died 6th of Shvat 5710 – May her soul be bound up in the bond of eternal life.

____________________

 1 Lt. Mitchell Earl Nussman

9th Air Force, 323rd Bomb Group, 453rd Bomb Squadron

This image of the 453rd Bomb Squadron insignia is via Flying Tiger Antiques.

During a mission to a communication center southeast of St. Vith, Belgium, B-26C Marauder 42-107588, the un-nicknamed VT * R, of the 453rd Bomb Squadron, 323rd Bomb Group, 9th Air Force, was lost due to anti-aircraft fire near St. Vith, as reported in Missing Air Crew Report 11926.  The entire crew of seven parachuted from their bomber, but only four men survived: Three were captured and sent to POW camps, the pilot managed to return to Allied military control, and three others (navigator, flight engineer Smith, and aerial gunner) never returned.  The Missing Air Crew Report contains no definitive information about the circumstances of their deaths.

This in-flight image of VT * R is via the American Air Museum in Britain.

The crew comprised:

Pilot: Adams, Robert H., Capt. – Survived (Killed in a flying accident in Germany on 8/16/45)
Co-Pilot / Gee Navigator: Yosick, Jerome S., 1 Lt. – KIA (probably last seen by radio operator Pippin as they were descending in parachutes)
Navigator: Burnett, George P., Jr., Capt. – Survived (POW)
Bombardier: Anderson, Warren W., Capt. – Survived (POW)
Flight Engineer: Smith, Virgil, T/Sgt. – KIA (last seen attempting to reach American lines in vicinity of Bovigny or Houffalize, Belgium, on 1/18/45)

Radio Operator: Pippin, Jack W., T/Sgt. – Survived (POW)
Gunner: Prejean, Louis H., S/Sgt. – KIA (last seen attempting to reach American lines in vicinity of Bovigny or Houffalize, Belgium, on 1/18/45)

Anderson, Prejean, and Smith were captured immediately after landing, upon which they were stripped of personal possessions and identification.  Taken by their captors in an easterly direction, they managed to escape at 2200 hours the same day: 1/14/45.  They then traveled by foot for three days and nights in a westerly direction in attempt to reach American lines.  On the evening of 1/17, after reaching a point about 1 ½ miles from American lines, the little group stopped to rest in a foxhole.  (By this time, they’d had no food for three days.)  At 0430 hours morning of 1/18, shelling by Americans or Germans commenced.  Anderson was wounded in the right thigh by artillery fire and could travel no further, and was left to remain in care of a Belgian farmer.  Prejean and Smith went on in an attempt to reach American lines.  They were never seen again.

Anderson was recaptured by the Germans on 1/19/45 and taken to Germany, where he survived as a POW.  The names of all crew members except for Smith and Prejean – even including Capt. Adams – can be found in Luftgaukommando Report KU1268A.  (I believe the “A” suffix in Luftgaukommando Reports designates reports covering crews known to have been incompletely accounted for at the time the document was filed, or, for which men were confirmed to have evaded capture.)

A witness to the loss of VT * R was 1 Lt. Mitchel Earl Nussman (0-755398), a bomber pilot, whose name appears on page 248 of American Jews in World War II, which indicates that he was awarded the Distinguished Flying Cross, Air Medal, and 12 Oak Leaf Clusters.  (His surname is incorrectly listed as “Mussman” at the American Air Museum in Britain’s photo of 42-107588.)  He was the husband of Phyllis J. (Tirk) Nussman, of 203 Park Drive, Brookline, Massachusetts, and the son of Jacob (5/21/84-1951) and Minnie (Wolpert) (3/13/94-11/10/56) Nussman, of 389 Bates St., Phillipsburg, New Jersey.  Born in Warren (Alpha), New Jersey on September 29, 1921, he passed away on December 7, 1989.  

An image of Lt. Nussman’s eyewitness account of the loss of VT * R in MACR 11926 appears below, followed by a transcript of the document:

16 January 1945

C E R T I F I C A T E

The following is a statement by 1st Lt. Mitchell E. Nussman, 0-755398, concerning action taking place on 14 January 1945.

I was flying number three position on the lead ship, number 42-107588, flown by Captain Robert H. Adams.  We were proceeding as scheduled to the target at approximately thirteen thousand (13,000) feet when we were encountered by flak.  Evasive action was taken by the lead ship, and as his bombay doors opened, we settled down for our bombing run.

Approximately two minutes before time over target, the lead ship released its bomb load.  At this time, I saw no outward damage on lead ship.  It appeared to be under control and intact.  Immediately after the bombs left the ship, I saw three figures bail out and pass from view.  These three figures appeared from the rear of the bombay.

Note: Staff Sergeant Michael Dobra, flying as Tail Gunner on my crew, saw those figures pass him, and saw four parachutes open and float earthward.

The lead ship then veered off to the right and dove.  At first it appeared out of control, but it then leveled out and flew straight.  I followed the snip as it continued out of the flak area, and noticed my compass beading which read zero degrees North.  The ship took a definite course for some time and seemed to be well under control.  During this time we remained about a quarter of a mile from the distressed ship.  I attempted to contact the aircraft by radio, but received no reply.

About six to seven minutes after bombs away, another figure left the ship.

Note: Technical Sergeant C.J. Schmitt noted the time as being 1326 hours and altitude as seven thousand one hundred (7,100) feet.

His parachute opened and the ship started a diving turn to the right.

Note:  Both Technical Sergeant Schmitt and Staff Sergeant Dobra saw the ship complete a one hundred eighty (180) degree turn and crash.  It exploded and flame burst from the wreckage.

After taking approximate location, we flew back to Base.

Mitchell E. Nussman
MITCHELL E. NUSSMAN,
1st Lt., Air Corps,
Pilot.

____________________

Staff Sergeant Harold Schwartz

13th Air Force, 5th Bomb Group, 72nd Bomb Squadron

This image of the 72nd Bomb Squadron insignia is via US Wars Patches.

A casualty in the 72nd Bomb Squadron of the 13th Air Force’s 5th Bomb Group (the “Bomber Barons”) was Staff Sergeant Harold Schwartz (33190448), who was killed during a combat mission over North Maluku, Indonesia.  However, being that a Missing Air Crew Report was not actually filed for him (the MACR name index card simply carries the enigmatic notation “No MACR”), the circumstances are – for the moment – unknown, though it can be assumed that he was a radio operator or aerial gunner.

The son of Dr. Martin Schwartz (2/2/93-12/8/41) and Mollie (Spigel) Schwartz (1899-4/18/25), and step-son of Rebecca B. Schwartz, his wartime address was 5420 Connecticut Ave., NW, in Washington, D.C.  Born in D.C. on July 12, 1919, he is buried at the Manila American Cemetery, Manila, Philippines (Plot D, Row 8, Grave 162).  His name appears on page 80 of American Jews in World War II, with the notation that he was awarded the Air Medal, one Oak Leaf Cluster and Purple Heart, suggesting that he completed between five and ten combat missions.

____________________

 Private Edwin G. Elefant

S/Sgt. Morris Backer

20th Air Force, 40th Bomb Group, 44th Bomb Squadron

This image shows a reproduction of the 44th Bomb Squadron’s insignia, via CHMetalcrafts’ ebay store.  

The names of Aviation Radio Technician 1st Class Joseph Manuel Zion and Captain Sanford Saul Fineman – lost in rather routine, non-combat circumstances – have been mentioned above.  Testifying to the inherently dangerous nature of military activity unrelated to enemy action are two more names: Private Edwin G. Elefant and S/Sgt. Morris Backer, both members of the 44th Bomb Squadron, the former among the nine men killed and the latter among eighteen men injured during an accident that befell the 40th Bomb Group on January 14.  Detailed and comprehensive information about this incident, which involved repetitively loading, unloading, and reloading bombs from B-29 bombers at Chakulia, India, can be found in two issues of the 40th Bomb Group Association’s publication Memories: issue 4, and, issue 18.

Rather than “copy and paste” the content of these publications here (there’s a lot there), this introduction and one account will suffice:

Perhaps no event in the history of the 40th Bomb Group is more widely remembered by our members than the tragic bomb-unloading accident in Chakulia, India, on January 14, 1945.  Many of us lost friends; we knew a few who laid their lives on the line to help others.  The event is seared into our memories as one that shows the best and the worst of war.  The accident occurred about noon when a weary armament crew was unloading dangerous M-47 cluster bombs from B-29 42-24582 [“Little Clambert” / “S”] in the 44th Bomb Squadron.

Neil W. Wemple was appointed Commander of the 44th Squadron on January 11, 1945, three days before the tragic accident.  His observations (written 1982):

My beginning as a new Squadron Commander was highly ignominious and inglorious to say the least.  Within three days of my appointment as Commander, the squadron had suffered what was to be the worst one-day disaster of its history from the standpoint of B-29s destroyed, and worse yet it was self inflicted.

It happened like this: We had been ordered to prepare for a bombing mission, possibly the one that was to take place January 17 against Formosa, first staging through our forward base near Chengtu, China, known as A-1.  An operations order from higher HQ called for 500-pound fragmentation bombs.  The operations officer, Major Eigenmann, directed this loading and it was done.  Then we received an operations order amendment to change the bomb loading to 500-pound general purpose demolition bombs; we did this.  Soon afterward we received another amendment to down load the demos and reload the frags again.

By now we were definitely wearing out the bombs and, worse than that, the men.  After we reloaded the frags, guess what.  You guessed it.  We were ordered to down load the frags and reload the demos!  At this point the Armament Officer, Capt. Redler, came in to see me.  He protested, saying his men were very tired.  Much conversation ensued with the Operations Officer also present.  In the end Capt. Redler was ordered to make the fourth change in bomb loading.  Otherwise the planes would not be ready in time for the forthcoming mission.  He departed disappointed, tired, exasperated.  The downloading of the frag bombs began.  All of this uploading and downloading of bombs brings to light the incompetence and inefficiency of higher HQ.  Unfortunately this was recognized only belatedly and a limitation was eventually placed upon the number of load changes within a given period of time.

That same day I was attending to squadron administrative duties at the squadron headquarters and orderly room when I heard what I knew to be a muffled, but large and ominous, explosion.  It seemed to come from the B-29 parking area.  I ran to my jeep, jumped in and drove fast to the flight line.  As I arrived it seemed that a major conflagration of several B-29s was in progress, and it was in my squadron area!  Additional explosions had occurred as I was driving to the area.  Everything was in total disorder.  B-29s were on fire, and some explosions occurred after my arrival.  People were running around in all directions.  I did not arrive in time to see or assist in the rescue of the first victims.  Fire trucks were fighting the fires, but as I remember there were not many ambulances remaining on the scene.  From there on it was a matter of fighting fires, mopping up and, the sad and worst part, the hospital visits and writing those letters of condolence to next of kin.

These images of the bomb loading accident at Chakulia are from 40th Bombardment Group: A Pictorial Record.  

From the Al Schutte collection at the 40th Bomb Group Association, this image shows the wrecked tail section of B-29 42-24582 “Little Clambert”, the only recognizable portion of the aircraft remaining after the explosions.  In the background is the still intact B-29 42-63394 “Last Resort” / “R”, so badly damaged as to have been written off after the accident.  

Two more images from 40th Bombardment Group: A Pictorial Record:  The upper photo shows an unexploded fragmentation bomb, while the lower image shows a funeral for one of the nine fatalities of January 14.  

The names of the personnel killed in the incident, via the 40th Bomb Group Association website, are listed below:

25th Bomb Squadron

Cpl. Elliott W. Beidler, Jr.

44th Bomb Squadron

Pvt. Edwin G. Elefant
Sgt. Edward J. Donnelly
Cpl. Theodore E. Houck
Pvt. John A. Scharli
Cpl. Aloysius M. Schumacher (died of injuries 1/22/45)

This portrait of Cp. Schumacher is via FindAGrave contributor DB6654.

(Fr. Bartholomew Adler, chaplain of the 40th Group, was on the line immediately after the explosion.  His account (written 1982): “Cpl. Aloysius M. Schumacher was quite a man.  Later that dreadful Sunday afternoon I found him at the Base Hospital, clutching his stomach where he had been struck by shrapnel, telling the medics to take care of another buddy of his, Pvt. Edwin Elefant, whom he considered was more seriously wounded than he.  Pvt. Elefant died later that night.  Cpl. Schumacher died the next day.” [Actually, 1/22/45])

Sgt. Robert “Tiny” Gunns

28th Air Service Group

Pvt. Paul W. Heard
Cpl. Charles C. Fulton

Though Pvt. Elefant (32785359) survived the initial explosion, he died of injuries the evening of the 14th, two days before his 21st birthday.  The son of Nathan (12/25/88-10/21/67) and Anna (4/8/99-2/14/82) Elefant, his family resided at 1516 Carroll St., in Brooklyn.  Born on January 16, 1924, he is buried at Mount Hebron Cemetery, in Flushing, N.Y. (Block 4, Reference 1, Section A-C, Line 11L, Grave 3).  His name can be found on page 302 of American Jews in World War II.

Among the wounded survivors of the explosion was Staff Sergeant Morris Backer (11050380), who received the Soldier’s Medal, among the nine men awarded for their actions that day.  His citation reads: “When a bomb explosion occurred in the aircraft on which he was working, [42-24582] S/Sgt. Backer, with no thought for his personal safety, immediately attempted to rescue those who had been seriously injured.  He was successful in removing a seriously injured man who was lying alongside the rear bomb bay, where the explosion took place.  He removed the injured man beyond the tail of the aircraft and remained with him until a stretcher bearer arrived and helped carry him to an adjacent ambulance.  During this time a series of explosions of gas tanks, bombs and ammunition occurred and S/Sgt. Backer was wounded in the left thigh.”

The only son of Jacob (1888-5/6/59) and Ida (1890-10/18/45) Backer (his sisters were Anne, Celia, Pauline, and Tilly) of 141 Homestead Street, Roxbury, Massachusetts, Sgt. Backer was born in that state on December 28, 1919.  He passed away on May 4, 2011, and is buried at the Independent Pride of Boston Cemetery, in West Roxbury.  His name is absent from American Jews in World War II. 

____________________

1 Lt. Jack Robert Ehrenberg 

20th Air Force, 497th Bomb Group, 869th Bomb Squadron

This image of the 869th Bomb Squadron insignia was found at Pinterest.

Several (many?!) of my posts include information about airmen who served as crew members of the Boeing B-29 Superfortress very heavy bomber, typically in the case of men who were lost of combat missions.

However, among these men are a tiny few who survived the loss of their aircraft, whether as POWs of the Japanese (2 Lt. Irving S. Newman), or, over the vast expanses of the Pacific Ocean, the latter by parachuting from mortally damaged aircraft (such as F/O Aldywn W. Fields), or, after their bombers were ditched (such as Capt. Bertram G. Lynch).  Another man who survived the ditching of his B-29 was Jack Ehrenberg, a crew member of the B-29 Pacific Union.  Of the eleven men aboard this aircraft, only four survived; of the four, one man was captured on a subsequent combat mission, and murdered while a prisoner of war, less than one month before the war’s end.

A navigator, 1 Lt. Jack Robert Ehrenberg (0-793992) and his crew were members of the 869th Bomb Squadron of the 497th Bomb Group.  His wife was Norma Constance (Loeb) Ehrenberg, who resided at 250 Passaic Ave., in Passaic, New Jersey.  Jack’s parents were Michael (1886-?) and Anna (Saltz) (9/20/87-1976) Ehrenberg, at 462 Brook Ave.; also Passaic.  Born in a place called Brooklyn on November 30, 1917, Jack passed away on May 12, 2005.  Listed on page 231 of American Jews in World War II, he was awarded the Distinguished Flying Cross, Air Medal with three Oak Leaf Clusters (suggesting that he completed between 15 and 20 combat missions), and, Purple Heart.  His name also appeared in War Department news releases on September 10, 1943, and March 22, 1945.

The incident in question – the loss of Pacific Union (42-24595, “A square 2”) – is covered in Missing Air Crew Report 11221, which, like some other MACRs pertaining to B-29 ditchings (at least, those of the 73rd Bomb Wing) and eventuated in the survival and rescue of crew members, incorporates a detailed report about the events behind and circumstances of the plane’s ditching, the escape of survivors from the plane, aspects of their survival and rescue, their suggestions for other crews faced with such situations in the future, and, comments and criticisms specifically pertaining to the loss of their plane, and, their crew’s actions.  The report concludes with a really (really!) lengthy distribution list.

____________________

Before 42-24595 became the Pacific Union – notice the absence of nose art in this image? – the aircraft was photographed while flying near Mount Fuji, in the company of other 497th Bomb Group B-29s.  This photo is from the 869th Bomb Squadron Scrapbook, via the 497th Bomb Group B-29 Memorial website, which contains histories of all 869th BS B-29s.  There, the image appears on page 35, where it’s appropriately titled “A-2 Over Fujiyama”.  

____________________

This image of December 5, 1944, showing the Pacific Union’s nose art, is from WorldWarPhotos.  

____________________

What happened?

The bomber, en-route with the 497th Bomb Group to Nagoya, experienced heavy smoke of unknown origin coming from its #3 engine.  When it became apparent that the aircraft couldn’t continue the mission, Captain Leonard Cox dropped out of the 497th’s formation and began a return to Saipan.  After it was decided that it would be necessary to ditch the bomber, the aircraft’s bombs were toggled out individually, exploding as they struck the sea.  The bomber by this time having descended to 900 feet, its wings and fuselage were struck by fragments from the bombs, and, a fire developed in the #3 engine and right wheel well.  The fire could not be extinguished, and spread rapidly.

But at this point, there was insufficient time for the crew to prepare for ditching.

All emergency exits were jettisoned from the front crew compartment, and, the men in that section of the fuselage braced themselves for the impending impact with the sea – some as best they could; some not well enough.  Lt. Erenberg remained at his crew position, and leaning over his desk, padded his abdomen with his parachute, at the same time giving the plane’s course, position, and ground speed to the radio operator, though he never knew if this information was actually transmitted.  The men in the rear fuselage received no communication concerning the planned ditching and so were not braced properly for impact.  In any event, they were forced to crowd against the port side of the fuselage, since the starboard side was too hot as a result of the fire, with the right gunner’s sighting blister becoming enveloped in flames, and flames also present in the rear unpressurized section of the fuselage.

The aircraft struck the sea at an estimated speed of 140 mph, impacting tail first.  Afterwards, Lt. Erenberg stated that he believed an explosion occurred in the mid-wing section at about the moment Pacific Union hit the water.  He then lost consciousness and – subsequently unaware of how he actually escaped – had no memory of any event until he found himself floating in the sea, still strapped to his seat.

These three Oogle Maps show the approximate location of the Pacific Union’s Central Pacific ditching (17-58 N, 144-03E) at successively larger scales.  The Northern Marianas were approximately 216 miles to the southeast, while Agrihan Island (unlabeled, best visible in the lowermost map) is about 108 miles to the east.  Very much water, very little land.        

Moving closer…

…and closer.

After the bomber’s motion stopped, it was realized that the ditched aircraft had broken in two, and what remained of the front fuselage was engulfed in flames.  The four crewmen in the rear fuselage exited through the escape hatch in what remained of the rear unpressurized section, bringing with them two one-man life rafts.  This action was both miraculous and very smartly planned, for the bomber’s two multi-place life rafts (stored in compartments in the upper section of the mid-fuselage), with full provisions and survival gear, were lost or destroyed in the ditching.

All survivors were burned as they swam away from the wreckage, with S/Sgt. George E. Wright and Lt. Erenberg suffering multiple lacerations, and the Lieutenant also having multiple fractures in both hands.  The radar operator, S/Sgt. William W. Roberts, also escaped from the tail section, but was seen only once and could not be rescued in time.  S/Sgt. William P. Stovall (probably the least severely injured, based on his 1996 obituary) secured the two one-man life rafts, placing Sgt. Lawrence W. Beecroft in one and S/Sgt. Wright in another, eventually – with very great difficulty – lashing the two rafts together.  Though the MACR is ambiguous on this point, it seems (?) that S/Sgt. Stovall and the other crewmen somehow placed Lt. Erenberg in (or upon?) the two rafts, with Stovall and Beecroft administering first aid as best they could to the navigator and right gunner, with the limited medical supplies on hand.

The two rafts were first spotted by Lt. Colonel Douglas C. Northrop (killed in action April 27, 1945, upon bailing out over Agrihan Island), Squadron Commander of the 877th Bomb Squadron, who circled the rafts until the arrival of a “Dumbo” air-sea rescue B-17G.  The Dumbo dropped a raft and emergency equipment, but the raft was faulty and could not be inflated (? – !) and as a result, the survivors couldn’t retrieve most of the survival gear.  Nevertheless, the Dumbo circled the men until about 1830K, when a destroyer arrived and rescued the four men.  They had been in the water for over twelve hours.

Further information about the loss of Pacific Union can be found in the essay The Ditching of Lt. McGregor’s B-29 Crew – 23 January 1945, where it’s stated, “… Capt. L.L. Cox and crew of A Square 2, 869 Squadron had to abort the mission less than an hour out of Saipan, due to a malfunctioning engine.  As Cox left the loose formation to return to base, he dropped down about 300 feet and salvoed his bombs.  It was established later that the bombardier had apparently pulled the pins on the bombs before takeoff; consequently they went off when they hit the water.  Since Cox’s ship was directly above the explosions, the bomb blasts caused the aircraft to crash.  All but 4 members were killed and when those four were rescued, two were so badly injured and burned that they were returned to the U.S. immediately.  This incident was included as part of the 73rd Bomb Wing debriefing after that mission, and directive was published warning all bombardiers not to pull the pins on the bombs until an altitude of at least 5000 feet had been reached.”

Notably, the MACR gives the B-29s altitude at the moment when it was struck by fragments from its own bombs as 900 feet, versus 300 feet in McGregor’s account.  Similarly, the MACR doesn’t make any reference to the bombs having been armed prior to being jettisoned.  The crewmen returned to the United States for medical treatment were Jack Ehrenberg and almost certainly George E. Wright.

You can download and read a verbatim transcript of the report about the crew’s ditching here.

A photo of the Cox crew can be found at the FindAGrave biographical profile of William P. Stovall, one of the Pacific Union’s four survivors.  The image was uploaded by Sam Pennartz, who has contributed much biographical information about veterans and military casualties to FindAGrave, and, the National WW II Memorial.  The men’s names are listed below the photo.    

Rear, left to right

1 Airplane Commander: Cox, Leonard Leronza, Capt., 0-422385, Duncan, Ok.
2 Unknown
3 Co-Pilot: Donham, Charles Comer, Jr., 2 Lt., 0-683665, Houston, Tx.
4 Navigator: Ehrenberg, Jack R., 1 Lt., 0-793992, Passaic, N.J. – Survived
5 Flight Engineer: Contos, Charles C., 2 Lt., 0-868100, Chicago, Il.

Front, left to right

1 Gunner (CFC): Crane, Frank Joseph, S/Sgt., 16007692, Oshkosh, Wi.
2 Gunner (RBG): Beecroft, Lawrence William, Sgt., 32069587, Newark, N.J. – Survived [Shot down and captured 6/1/45; Murdered 7/21/45]
3 Gunner (LBG): (Wright, George E., S/Sgt., 38043673) – Survived
4 Radio Operator: Griffith, Melvin L., S/Sgt., 15342793, University City, Mo.
5 Radar Operator: Roberts, Willard Wayne, S/Sgt., 37245181, Kirksville, Mo.
6 Gunner (Tail): Stovall, William Peter, S/Sgt., 6563342, Kansas City, Mo. – Survived

Here’s the same photo, as printed in a halftone format in The Long Haul: The Story of the 497th Bomb Group (VH).  Like all crew photos in that book, the only text associated with the image is the crew commander’s name, all other crewmen being anonymous.  Then again, even the identity of the crew commander (front row? back row? far left? kneeling? far right?) isn’t actually specified for any image.

Prior to being assigned to the 497th Bomb Group, Captain Cox was a First Lieutenant in the 324th Bomb Squadron of the 91st Bomb Group (8th Air Force), in which he piloted B-17F 42-29921, Oklahoma Okie.  The picture showing Lt. Cox and Okie is Army Air Force photograph 79288AC / A12688, and was taken at Bassingbourne, England, on June 16, 1943. 

William P. Stovall, born in 1918, died in 1996 at the age of 77.  According to his obituary in The Independent-Record (of Helena, Montana) of March 3 1996, he was the only crew member of the Pacific Union who was uninjured in the plane’s ditching; he ultimately completed approximately 25 missions. 

Sgt. Beecroft was infinitely less fortunate.  Eventually having recovered from his injuries, he resumed combat flying.  Almost six months later, he was shot down during the Osaka mission of June 1, 1945, while flying in the crew of 1 Lt. Franklin W. Crowe aboard B-29 42-65348 (A square 16).  Seven of the plane’s eleven crew members were killed in the bomber’s crash (at the foot of Mount Sanjogadake, in the Omine Mountains, Tenkawa-mura, Yoshino-gun, Nara-ken), and four were captured.  The latter were Sgt. Beecroft, Central Fire Control Gunner M/Sgt. Alvin R. Hart, Bombardier 1 Lt. Harrison K. Wittee, and Radar Operator S/Sgt. Russell W. Strong.  As immediately evident from biographical information at FindAGrave, as well as Doug’s extensive research and documentation concerning the 497th Bomb Group, and, 73rd Bomb Wing aviators who were captured by the Japanese, none of the four survived: They were murdered before the war’s end.    

Though not the immediate subject of this post, the awful fate of those four survivors of A square 16 pertains to the larger topic of the fate of Allied POWs of the Japanese in general, and the that of Allied aviators in Japanese captivity, in particular.  There’s an enormous (perhaps incalculably large?) body of historical information and literature on this topic, in print, on the Internet, in historical repositories such as the United States National Archives, and certainly in unpublished format among the personal records and memorabilia of the descendants of WW II servicemen.  Suffice to say that while several hundred Allied aviator POWs did survive Japanese captivity, a very significant proportion of men who were initially captured and could have survived, did not.

This portrait of Sgt. Beecroft – as a Corporal – is by FindAGrave contributor William Duffy.  

____________________

Lieutenant (JG) Milton Harold Thuna

United States Navy, Patrol Bomber Squadron VPB-110

Paralleling the loss of Captain Fineman and Private Elefant in incidents unrelated to enemy activity, Navy Lieutenant (JG) Milton Harold Thuna (0-145553), a co-pilot, was killed in yet another non-combat aviation accident.  The incident involved a PB4Y-1 Liberator (Bureau Number 63944) of Patrol Bomber Squadron 110 (VPB-110) in North Africa.

This image (via pinterest) is a very good representative view of a PB4Y-1.  

As described at VPNavy.com (from on November 22, 2001) the aircraft , “…took off from Marrakech, French Morocco, on a ferry flight to Dakar, Senegal.  No radio contact was made by plane after leaving vicinity of Marrakech Airport.  At about 0900 GMT, Arab natives saw the plane break through the overcast at 2000 ft, in a shallow normal glide in vicinity of Tazmint, French Morocco.  Witnesses reported the engines were not functioning properly.  Shortly after becoming visible, the plane was seen to catch fire and explode, detaching pieces of the aircraft.  It was seen to go out of control immediately following the explosion.  Examination of the wreckage at the scene of the crash showed that the portion of the port wing outboard of the aileron became detached in the air, landing three-hundred yards from the main body of the wreck.  It was also found that the plane’s rudders and vertical tail surfaces became detached in the air, being found in an area approximately three-hundred yards from the main body of the wreck.”

Besides Lt. Thuna, the bomber’s crew comprised:

Pilot: Lt Ralph David Spalding, Jr.
Ensign Milo Junior Jones
AOM 2C James Thomas Hagedorn
ARM 2C Norman H. Lowrey
ARM 1C F.W. Riffe
AOM 3C Robert W. Baker
AMMF 3C Frank Andrew Lutz
AMM 2C Milford Dewitt Merritt
ARM 3C E.M. Lingar
AOM(T) 3C William E. Burns

Born in Brooklyn, New York on March 22, 1918, Lt. Thuna was the son of Helena Mendelsohn (11/9/88-11/13/74), who resided a 106-24 97th Street in Ozone Park.  The origin of his surname is unknown.  Perhaps it was that of his father, who I’ve thus far been unable to identify.  The lieutenant is buried with six of his fellow crew members at Arlington National Cemetery, in Grave 16, Section 15

News articles about Lt. Thuna appeared in The Leader-Observer on 5/21/42, 3/11/43, 3/25/43, The New York Sun on 2/19/45, and The Record 2/22/45, while his name can be found on page 461 of American Jews in World War II.

____________________

Soviet Union / U.S.S.R. (C.C.C.Р.)
Red Army [РККА (Рабоче-крестьянская Красная армия)]

Bargman, Solomon Semenovich (Баргман, Соломон Семенович), Guards Junior Lieutenant (Гвардии Младший Лейтенант)
Machine Gun Platoon Commander (Командир Пулеметного Взвода)
16th Guards Mechanized Brigade
Born 1924
Killed in Action

Gofman
, Aleksandr Volfovich (Гофман, Александр Вольфович), Sergeant (Сержант)

Armor (Radio Operator – Gunner) (Радист-Пулеметчик) – T-34
68th Tank Brigade
Born 1924, city of Korets, Rovenskiy Raion
Killed in Action
Buried in Poland

Kofman, Shalim Shavelevich (Кофман, Шальим Шавельевич), Lieutenant (Лейтенант)
Rifle Company Commander (Командир Стрелковой Роты)
449th Rifle Regiment, 144th Rifle Division
Killed in Action
Born 1909

Layzer
, Peresh Yakovlevich (Лайзер, Переш Яковлевич), Private (Рядовой)

Armor (Miner) (Минер)
32nd Tank Brigade
Born 1914, Struzhenskiy Raion
Died of wounds (умер от ран) at Mobile Surgical Field Hospital 492 (Хирурический Полевой Подвижной Госпиталь 492)
Buried in Hungary

Lev
, Naum Aronovich (Лев, Наум Аронович), Captain (Капитан)

Chief, 1st Headquarters Staff (Начальник 1 Отделения Штаба)
5th Mountain Rifle Brigade
Born 1918
Killed in Action

Matskin
, Volf Abramovich (Мацкин, Вольф Абрамович) Senior Lieutenant (Старший Лейтенант)

Rifle Platoon Commander (Командир Стрелкового Взвода)
314th Rifle Regiment, 46th Rifle Division
Born 1912
Killed in Action

Mikheylis, Yooriy Aleksandrovich (Михейлис, Юрий Александрович), Senior Lieutenant (Старший Лейтенант)
Machine Gun Company Commander (Командир Роты Автоматчиков)
216th Guards Rifle Regiment, 79th Guards Rifle Division
Killed in Action
Born 1924

Nirkis, Meer Ayzikovich (Ниркис, Меер Айзикович) Lieutenant (Лейтенант)

Rifle Platoon Commander (Командир Стрелкового Взвода)
1210th Rifle Regiment, 362nd Rifle Division
Born 1916
Killed in Action

Presman, Semen Alekseevich (Пресман, Семен Алексеевич) Junior Lieutenant (Младший Лейтенант)

Rifle Platoon Commander (Командир Стрелкового Взвода)
717th Rifle Regiment, 170th Rifle Division
Born 1922
Killed in Action

Segelman, Moisey Abramovich (Сегельман, Моисей Абрамович), Guards Major (Гвардии Майор)

Deputy Chief of Staff, also, Chief of Headquarters Operational Intelligence
(Заместитель Начальника Штаба он-же Начальник Оперативного Разведывательного Отдела Штаба)
2nd Guards Motorized Assault Engineer-Sapper Brigade
Born 1917, city of Tomsk
Killed in Action
Buried in Lithuania

Shlafman, Girgoriy Khaskelevich (Шлафман, Григорий Хаскелевич), Guards Lieutenant (Гвардии Лейтенант)
Machine Gun Platoon Commander (Командир Пулеметного Взвода)
265th Guards Rifle Regiment, 86th Guards Rifle Division
Killed in Action
Born 1924

Shmidberg, Arkadiy Nikolaevich (Шмидберг, Аркадий Николаевич), Guards Senior Sergeant (Гвардии Старший Сержант)

Armor (Gun Charger) (Заряжающий) – T-34
213th Autonomous Tank Brigade
Born 1910, city of Tulya
Killed in Action
Buried in East Prussia

Slutsker, Abram Lazarevich (Слуцкер, Абрам Лазаревич), Lieutenant (Лейтенант)
Machine Gun Platoon Commander (Командир Пулеметного Взвода)
187th Guards Rifle Regiment, 47th Guards Rifle Division
Died of Wounds
Born 1925

Tsap, Abram Lvovich (Цап, Абрам Львович), Captain (Капитан)
Political Agitator (Агитатор)
216th Guards Rifle Regiment, 79th Guards Rifle Division, 8th Guards Army
Killed in Action
Born 1902

Vanshteyn / Vaynshteyn, Veniamin Abramovich (Ванштейн/ Вайнштейн, Вениамин Абрамович), Lieutenant (Лейтенант)

Rifle Platoon Commander (Командир Стрелкового Взвода)
291st Rifle Regiment, 63rd Rifle Division
Born 1904
Killed in Action

Yakuboshvili, Lev Mototeevich (Якубошвили, Лев Мототеевич), Senior Sergeant (Старший Сержант)

Armor (Gun Commander) (Командир Орудия) – T-34
213th Autonomous Tank Brigade
Born 1925, city of Baku
Killed in Action
Buried in East Prussia

____________________

Canada

Flight Officer Joseph Klatman

Royal Canadian Air Force, Number 1666 Heavy Conversion Unit

Flight Officer Joseph Klatman (J/39890), a navigator serving in No. 1666 Heavy Conversion Unit, Royal Air Force, was lost with his six fellow crewmen (all members of the RCAF) when their bomber, Lancaster I HK756, piloted by eighteen year old Flight Officer Victor Robert Adams, vanished during a “Sweepstake” mission on the evening of January 14-15, 1945.  As described on page 156 of W.R. Chorley’s Bomber Command Losses (covering Heavy Conversion Units, and, Miscellaneous Units), the aircraft, took off, “…from Wombleton as part of a force of one hundred and twenty-six aircraft, drawn from the training units, ordered to sweep across the North Sea in the hope of luring the Luftwaffe into the air.  Lost without trace.”

This document, from F/O Klatman’s Service File, found in “World War II Records and Service Files of War Dead (Canada), 1939-1947”, at Ancestry.com (not a plug; just stating the source), dated September 30, 1947, summarizes the extent of information available concerning the loss of Lancaster HK756: In effect and reality, none … whether in 1947 or 2023. 

Bomber Command Losses notes that, “…F/O Adams RCAF was amongst the youngest bomber pilots to lose his life in the Second World War.”  His RCAF Service File reveals that he was born in England on May 23, 1925.

Akin to all crew members of HK756, a letter verifying their son’s missing in action status was sent to F/O Klatman’s next of kin – in this case, his parents – by Squadron Leader Lewington at RCAF Station Wombleton.  (Spelling uncertain.)

Born in Blati, Romania, on August 13, 1923, Joseph was the son of Samuel (1892-9/8/70) and Tuba “Toby” (Tipleatsky / Teplitzky) (1895-5/8/33) Klatman, and brother of Pearl, the family residing at 23 Brunswick Ave. in Toronto, Ontario.  His civilian occupation prior to entering the RCAF was “shipper”.

These two photographic portraits of F/O Klatman are also present in his Service File.  A review of Service Files shows that such images are typically – but not always! – found in Service Files for aviators, but rarely in Files for non-commissioned officers. 

The upper photo was taken on February 17, 1943, but the lower photo is undated.   

F/O Klatman’s name is commemorated on Panel 279 of the Runnymede Memorial, in Surrey, England, while his biography is found on page 40 of Part II of Canadian Jews in World War Two.

On the ground…

Private Leo Smith (Shomomenko)

Loyal Edmonton Regiment

Born in Gomel, Belarus, on September 21, 1918; a cleaner and presser in civilian life, Private Leo Smith (original surname Shomomenko), M/11468, died of wounds in Italy while serving in the Loyal Edmonton Regiment.  He and his wife, Columba Gallina Smith (7/20/18-9/09), resided at 1117-5th Ave., in Calgary, Alberta, with their daughter Sylvia Susan, who was born on January 28, 1940.  His parents were Abraham (12/10/98-5/8/91) and Rose (Kagansky) (7/17/99-9/21/82) Smith, his brother Allan, and his sisters Mary Gofsky and Pauline (a.k.a. “Polly”).

Pvt. Smith is buried at the Argenta Gap War Cemetery, at Ferrara, Italy (IV,E,12).  His very brief biography appears on page 73 of Part II of Canadian Jews in World War Two.

Private Smith’s biographical profile at FindAGrave.com includes a transcript of a news article from The Calgary Herald of January 25, 1945, which concludes upon the statement, “A short time ago, Pte. Smith had cabled home that he was due to receive leave and expected to be home for the first time in nearly five years,” paralleling Canadian Jews in World War Two, which states, “A veteran of four and one-half years overseas, he was killed a few days before he was scheduled to return home on leave.”  Neither the newspaper article nor Canadian Jews in World War Two could have elaborated upon the impetus for Pvt. Smith’s anticipated return to Canada, for this information was unknown to the public.  However, with the passage of time, the advent of the internet, and the accessibility of World War II Records and Service Files of Canadian War Dead at Ancestry.com, more – much more, about a family during wartime – is revealed.

It turns out that Private Smith requested leave to visit his family, the result of a letter from his sister Polly of November 7, 1944.  The original letter – probably having been returned to Pvt. Smith – is absent from the File, a verbatim transcript taking its place.  Therein, Polly succinctly, frankly, and compellingly describes the effects of Leo’s absence upon his mother, daughter, and wife, notably (this is as revealing as it’s unsurprising, given the passage of almost five years of military service) intimating that her brother’s long absence had affected his marriage to Columba, suggesting that their marriage may have been under strain prior to his enlistment in the army.  The letter is persuasive, poignant (very poignant), and powerful, and seems to have been compelling enough for the Canadian military to grant leave to Private Smith.

In a war of innumerable tragedies and countless ironies (but is that not so of all wars?), his return to his wife and family – to have taken place in early in 1945 – would never happen.

Time has passed.  Private Smith’s parents, Abraham and Rose, passed away in 1991 and 1982, respectively; his wife Columba Smith in 2009.  His daughter Sylvia Susan, four years old when her aunt Polly composed the letter to her father, would now in the year 2023 be eighty-three years old.

Here’s an image of the letter, from his Service File, followed by a transcript:

Nov 7/44
     1610 – Scotland St.
          Calgary

Dear Leo:

     We received your air-mail letter to-day and I was sure happy to hear from you.

     Leo dear, you must come home, there’s so much you must know.  Mother is very ill and many a morning she can’t get out of bed.  The doctor’s in the city don’t know what is wrong with her.  She has been to every doctor and there is no cure, so we do not know how long she will hold out.  The only thing she wants now is to see you home again and if you were to try to come home, she would have something to live for.  But now she has nothing.  She says for you to try to come home as soon as you can.

     Sylvia does not quit talking about you every day and is waiting for the day her daddy is coming home.  Edna’s husband is coming home this week and Betty Anne doesn’t quit talking about him and Sylvia wants to know when her daddy is coming home.

     It is true of course that Columba has gone through very much but the only thing stopping her from telling you to come back is her pride.  But she’s told me she still loves you.  Leo, you just have to come back home and as soon as possible.  Mother won’t last much longer if she hasn’t get to see you soon. For Mother’s and Dad’s and Sylvia’s sake you must come home.  Leo dear, please try your hardest.

     You may think these are big words for a little girl but I’m more grown up than Mary.

     I am leaving for New York to the University June the end of June and hope to see you before I leave because I hardly know you.  Please try to come home soon as I can’t stand seeing Mother going to pieces.

Love,
          Polly

Mother sends all her love to you

Certified this is a true copy of a letter
dated 7 Nov 44 received by the petitioner
from his sister, Polly, 1610 Scotland St.,
Calgary Alta.

(R.R. Brown) Capt
Legal Officer
4 Cdn Rft Bn  1 CBRG

____________________

____________________

References

Books

Burkett, Prentice “Mick”, The Unofficial History of the 499th Bomb Group (VH), Historical Aviation Album, Temple City, Ca., 1981

Chorley, W.R., Royal Air Force Bomber Command Losses – Heavy Conversion Units and Miscellaneous Units, 1939-1947 (Volume 8), Midland Publishing, Hinckley, England, 2003

Dublin, Louis I., and Kohs, Samuel C., American Jews in World War II – The Story of 550,000 Fighters for Freedom, The Dial Press, New York, N.Y., 1947

Lundy, Will, 44th Bomb Group Roll of Honor and Casualties, 1987, 2004 (via Green Harbor Publications)

Mireles, Anthony J., Fatal Army Air Forces Aviation Accidents in the United States, 1941-1945 – Volume 3: August 1944 – December 1945, McFarland & Company Inc., Publishers, Jefferson, N.C., 2006

Morris, Henry, Edited by Gerald Smith, We Will Remember Them – A Record of the Jews Who Died in the Armed Forces of the Crown 1939 – 1945, Brassey’s, United Kingdom, London, 1989

Swanborough, Gordon, and Bowers, Peter M., United States Navy Aircraft Since 1911, Funk & Wagnals, New York, N.Y., 1968

Canadian Jews in World War II – Part II: Casualties, Canadian Jewish Congress, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, 1948

The Long Haul : The Story of the 497th Bomb Group (VH), Newsfoto Pub. Co., San Angelo, Tx., 1947

40th Bombardment Group: A pictorial record of events, places, and people in India, China and Tinian from April 1944 through October 1945. Included are a few aerial views of Nippon, Singapore, Formosa and other exotic, far-off places, Newsfoto Pub. Co., San Angelo, Tx., 1945 (via Bangor Public Library)

Acknowledgment

Special thanks to Ari Dale for her translation of the inscription on Captain Sanford S. Fineman’s matzeva: “Thanks, Ari!”

Websites

The B-26 Marauder in US Navy and Marine Corps Service, at B26.com

May 13, 2017 459

Soldiers from New York: Jewish Soldiers in The New York Times, in World War Two: February 6, 1945 (On the ground…)

This “second” post covering Jewish military casualties on February 6, 1945 (you can read the first post, covering aviators, here) pertains to soldiers who served in the ground forces of the Allied armies.  Also mentioned is the one (that I know of…) Jewish soldier who was captured by the Wehrmacht on this February Tuesday: PFC David Schneck of the United States Army. 

Following the format of my prior posts in this series, soldiers’ biographies present information in the following format:

Name, Hebrew name if known, rank, serial number, and awards or decorations (if any)
Military unit
Next of kin and wartime residential address.
Place and date of birth
Place and date of burial
Periodical or publication where a soldier’s name was mentioned or recorded.

For American Jewish soldiers, page number in the 1947 two-volume set American Jews in World War II (specifically, the “second” of the two-volumes) on which a soldier’s name is recorded.

And so, a list of names…

And so, some photos…

________________________________________

For those who lost their lives on this date…

Tuesday, February 6, 1945 / Shevat 23, 5705
– .ת.נ.צ.ב.ה. –
…Tehé Nafshó Tzrurá Bitzrór Haḥayím

May his soul be bound up in the bond of everlasting life.

________________________________________

Killed in Action

United States Army

Aronson, Max, T/4, 33117372, Purple Heart
37th Infantry Division, 148th Infantry Regiment
Mr. Jacob Aronson (father) (1883-?); Mrs. Fannie Myers (mother) (1891-?)
435 Boyles Ave., New Castle, Pa.
Born New Castle, Pa., 11/18/14
Tifereth Israel Cemetery, New Castle, Pa.; Buried 6/48
Casualty List 3/24/45
American Jews in World War II – 509

______________________________

Cohen, Kurt N., T/Sgt., 32797213, France, Colmar
75th Infantry Division, 289th Infantry Regiment
Mr. Robert Groger (friend), 150 West 91st St., New York, N.Y.
Born Vienna, Austria, 3/5/21
Golden Gate National Cemetery, San Bruno, Ca. – Section O, Grave 1240
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed (Both NJWB cards are marked “No Publicity”)

Here (via Ancestry.com) are the two National Jewish Welfare Board information cards for T/Sgt. Kurt Cohen, prominently stamped “NO PUBLICITY”.  Perhaps there was concern about the implications of his Austrian birth becoming known to the Wehrmacht or Gestapo in the eventuality of his capture, with repercussions for this upon Kurt Himself, or any family members still surviving in Europe.  Alas: By May 9, 1945, these concerns were sadly moot.  (A similar instance of requesting no publicity for a Jewish soldier occurred in the case of First Lieutenant Albert Frost, who was killed in action on December 14, 1944.)

______________________________

Epstein, Irwin (Yisrael Reuven bar Zelig ha Levi), PFC, 42135153, Medical Corps, Purple Heart, France, Alsace-Lorraine
70th Infantry Division, 27th Infantry Regiment, 3rd Battalion, Medical Detachment
Mr. and Joseph and Fannie Epstein (parents), Bernard and Morris (brothers),
1936 75th St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Born Bronx, N.Y., 3/7/26
Mount Lebanon Cemetery, Glendale, N.Y. – Block WC, Section 5, Line 26, Grave 15, Society Workmen’s Circle
American Jews in World War II – 303

This image of the matzeva of Irwin Epstein, at Mount Lebanon Cemetery in Glendale, New York, is via FindAGrave contributor S. Daino.

______________________________

The shoulder insignia of the 3rd Infantry Division

Gottschalk, Arthur Heinz, PFC, 35063350, Purple Heart
3rd Infantry Division, 7th Infantry Regiment
Mr. and Mrs. Bernard and Selma (Strauss) Gottschalk (brother and sister in law)
10802 Orville Ave., Cleveland, Oh.
Mr. and Mrs. Julius and Hilda (Gottschalk) Rothschild (sister and brother in law)
Mr. and Mrs. Oscar P. and Gussi (Feiner) Gottschalk (brother and sister in law)
Born Coblenz, Germany, 1/21/25
Epinal American Cemetery, Epinal, France – Plot A, Row 10, Grave 51
Cleveland Press & Plain Dealer, February 27, 1945
Aufbau 3/9/45, 3/16/45
American Jews in World War II – 488

From the March 9, 1945 issue of Aufbau, PFC Gottschalk’s obituary….


Here’s a transcript and translation of the obituary and memorial tribute to PFC Gottschalk, from Aufbau:

Für die Freiheit gefallen

Pfc. Arthur Heinz Gottschalk

ist am 6. Februar rim Alter von 20 Jahren bei Strassburg gefallen.  Er wurde in Koblenz geboren und lebte sieit seinem 11. Lebensjahr in Cleveland, Ohio.  Mit 16 Jahren, noch zu jüng fur die Armee oder die Flotte, ging er in die Rüstungsindustrie.  Als er sich 1942 freiwillig bei der Navy meldete, wurde er abgewiesen, weil er noch kien Bürgen war.  Endlich, im Mai 1943, wurde er in die Armee eingezogen und seun heissersehnter Wunsch, gegen die Nazis kämpfen zu konnen, ging in Erfüllung.

__________

Fallen for freedom

Pfc. Arthur Heinz Gottschalk

died near Strasbourg on February 6th at the age of 20.  He was born in Koblenz and has lived in Cleveland, Ohio since he was 11 years old.  At the age of 16, still too young for the army or the navy, he went into the armaments industry.  When he volunteered for the Navy in 1942, he was turned away because he [had] not yet a sponsor.  Finally, in May 1943, he was drafted into the army and his long-cherished wish to fight against the Nazis came true.

__________

…and, in the newspaper’s Memorial section, under the heading “Pro Libertate” – “For Freedom” – appear tributes to Arthur by his parents and brothers.  The aforementioned two-word heading typically appeared atop all such tributes in Aufbau.  Notice that the phrase is Latin, not Hebrew or Yiddish?  (Just sayin’!…)  This is a very small example of how the WW II content of Aufbau seems to indecisively straddle a secular enlightenment universalism on one hand, and, Jewish solidarity, nationhood, and Zionism on the other.  

Hey, what else is new?

____________________


FÜR SEINE NEUE HEIMAT GEFALLEN!

Wir erhielten vom War Department die traurige Nachricht, dass unser inningstgeliebter, unvergesslicher Sohn, Bruder, Schwager, Onkel, Neffe and Vetter.

Arthur H. Gottschalk

ausgezeichnet mit Infantry Men Combat Badge

am 6. Februa rim Alter von 20 Jahren den Heldentod für sein neues geliebtes Vetraland in Frankreich erlitten hat.  Nach fünfmonatiger Ausbildung kam er am Tage nach Jom Kippur 1943 overseas.  Er kämpfte mit der 7. Army 3. Division in Afrika und Italien.  Nach der Invasion in Südfrankreich war er stets in vorderster Linke kämpfend, bis er bei Strassburg gefallen ist.  Alle, die ihn gekannt haben, Wissen, was wir verloren haben.

In tiefster Trauer:

BERNHARD GOTTSCHALK und Frau Selma, geb. Strauss (früher Koblenz)
OSKAR GOTTSCHALK und Frau Gussi. Feiner
JULIUS ROTHSCHILD und Frau Hilde, geb. Gottschalk (früher Koblenz und Mainz)

10802 Orville Avenue
Cleveland 6, Ohio

__________

FALLEN FOR HIS NEW HOMELAND!

We received the sad news from the War Department that our dearest, unforgettable son, brother, brother-in-law, uncle, nephew and cousin.

Arthur H. Gottschalk

awarded the Infantry Combat Badge

suffered a heroic death for his new beloved fatherland in France on February 6th at the age of 20.  After five months of training, he came overseas the day after Yom Kippur 1943.  He fought with the 7th Army 3rd Division in Africa and Italy.  After the invasion of southern France, he was always on the front left until he fell near Strassburg.  All who knew him know what we lost.

In deepest sorrow:

BERNHARD GOTTSCHALK and his wife Selma, née Strauss (formerly Koblenz)
OSKAR GOTTSCHALK and his wife Gussi Feiner
JULIUS ROTHSCHILD
and his wife Hilde, née Gottschalk (formerly Koblenz and Mainz)

10802 Orville Avenue
Cleveland 6, Ohio

______________________________

Hoffer, Murray G., Pvt., 42017338, Medical Corps, Purple Heart
4th Infantry Division, 22nd Infantry Regiment, 4th Medical Battalion, C Company
Mr. and Mrs. Harry (1901-1986) and Gertie (Guss) (1904-1986) Hoffer (parents)
42 Wade St. / 295 Stegman Park Way, Jersey City, N.J.
Born Jersey City, N.J., 7/13/26
Baron De Hirsch Cemetery, Staten Island, N.Y.
Casualty List 3/27/45
American Jews in World War II – 239

______________________________

Loeb, Albert K., 2 Lt., 0-1329603, PH, France, Neuf-Brisach area (southeast of Colmar)
75th Infantry Division, 289th Infantry Regiment
Mr. and Mrs. Raphael J. (2/23/94-1/14/65) and Myrtle Catherine (Kaufman) (12/25/96-1/21/91) Loeb (parents)
405 Felder Ave., Montgomery, Al.
Born in Alabama, 1925
Epinal American Cemetery, Epinal, France – Plot A, Row 7, Grave 72
Casualty List 3/14/45
American Jews in World War II – 35

______________________________

Pearl, Sigmund Selig, PFC, 14172990, Purple Heart
78th Infantry Division, 309th Infantry Regiment, C Company
Mr. and Mrs. Charles (1/4/90-4/25/79) and Kate (Stadiem) (10/16/95-4/20/78) Pearl (parents)
1721 Madison Ave., Greensboro, N.C.
Martin Goldman (cousin)
Born Greensboro, N.C., 10/30/22
Greensboro Hebrew Cemetery, Greensboro, N.C.
American Jews in World War II – 479

This portrait of PFC Sigmund Selig Pearl is via FindAGrave contributor Mark Childrey, who records that the image is credited to Dorothy Hamburger, and is from the Duke University Center for Jewish Studies webpage titled, “We Are Soldiers”.

The shoulder patch of the 78th Infantry Division

______________________________

Rothwax, Harold (Tsvi bar Yosef ha Levi), PFC, 42068353, Purple Heart
102nd Infantry Division, 407th Infantry Regiment, I Company
Mr. and Mrs. Joseph and Anna Rothwax (parents)
Jack, Louis, Manny, and Marty (brothers)
1339 Noble Ave., New York, N.Y. / 1311 Commonwealth Ave., Bronx, N.Y.
Born in New York in 1926
Mount Hebron Cemetery, Flushing, N.Y. – Coretz Brith Bacherum Society, Block 9, Reference 15, Section F, Line 17, Grave 3; Buried 10/27/48
Casualty List 3/27/45
New York Times Obituary Section (“In Memoriam” column) 10/27/48
American Jews in World War II – 422 (Indicates that he served in the Army Air Force (incorrect!))

This picture of the matzeva of Pvt. Rothwax is by FindAGrave contributor DMC.

______________________________

The biographical profile of Captain Bernard Yolles and his family, at FindAGrave.com, is very extensive – and very moving – in terms of both photographs and information, and has internal links to information about his parents, brother, and especially his wife, Babette Armore “Bobbi” Rubel Aronson, who passed away in 2003. 

To very briefly summarize…  Captain Yolles volunteered for the Army in December of 1940, and received basic training at Camp Forrest, in Tennessee.  Commissioned as a Second Lieutenant after completing Officer’s Candidate School at Fort Benning, Georgia, and was eventually assigned command of F Company, 365th Infantry Regiment, 92nd Infantry Division, nicknamed the “Buffalo Soldiers Division”. 

Captain Yolles was killed in action – reportedly by a mortar shell – on the morning of February 6, while leading F Company in an attack to capture the Lama di Sotto Ridge and Hill 940.    

In January of 1948, according to the wishes of his widow Babette, Captain Yolles’ permanent place of burial was designated as the Florence American Cemetery. 

__________

Yolles, Bernard, Capt., 0-1285688, Purple Heart, Company Commander
92nd Infantry Division, 365th Infantry Regiment, F Company
Mrs. Babette Armore (Rubel) Yolles (wife) (6/12/17-8/3/03), 2952 Midvale, Los Angeles, Ca; Barbara (daughter; born 6/26/43)
Mr. and Mrs. David Leon (5/23/59-12/23/54) and Ray (Shapiro) (12/23/83-8/6/59) Yolles (parents)
Samuel S. Yolles (brother) (5/23/13-4/25/63)
Born in Mississippi, August 14, 1916
Florence American Cemetery, Florence, Italy – Plot F, Row 6, Grave 16
Winona Times 3/2/45, 6/22/45
American Jews in World War II – 206

__________

Captain Yolles in January, 1945.  (Photo via FindAGrave contributor 47604643.)

Another January, 1945 image of Captain Yolles.  (Via FindAGrave contributor 47604643.)

__________

On March 2, 1945, notice of Captain Yolles’ Missing in Action status appeared in the Winona Times

Captain Bernard Yolles, son of Mr. and Mrs. Leon Yolles of Winona, has been reported missing in action since February 6th in Italy.  He was one of the first three to volunteer from Montgomery County, the three leaving here together on December 5th, 1940.

__________

…while on June 22 of the sane year, the Times confirmed his death in combat.

Capt. Bernard Yolles was killed in action in Italy February 6, 1945, the War Department has wired his parents, Mr. and Mrs. Leon Yolles, after previously reporting him missing in action.  He was with the 92nd Infantry Division.

Entering service as one of this county’s first volunteers December 5, 1940, he was given basic training at Camp Forrest, Tenn., received his commission at Officers Candidate School, Fort Benning, Ga., and sailed overseas in October 1944.

His wife, Mrs. Babette Yolles, and daughter, Barbara, reside in Memphis.  Pfc Samuel S. Yolles, a brother, is in California.

__________

Babette and daughter Barbara in August of 1944.  (Photo via FindAGrave contributor Andy.)

______________________________

England

Schul, Pinkus, Pvt., 13117960, Royal Army
Royal Sussex Regiment
Burma
Born 1925, in Germany
Taukkyan War Cemetery, Taukkyan, Rangoon, Myanmar – 27,G,1
We Will Remember Them – Volume I – 156

Private Pinkus Schul of the Royal Sussex Regiment is buried at the Taukkyan War Cemetery, Taukkyan, in Rangoon, Myanmar.  This image of his matzeva is by FindAGrave contributor Mary Jo C. Martin.  Though Ancestry.com reveals that he was born in Germany in 1925, other information about him is unavailable.   

______________________________

France

Armée de Terre

Levy, Jacques, Armée de Terre, France (Maroc (Morocco)), AC-21P-76695
1ere Groupe, 2eme Compagnie du Génie
Tué par eclat d’obus (“Killed by shrapnel”)

______________________________

Soviet Union / U.S.S.R. [C.C.C.Р.]

Red Army [РККА / Рабоче-крестьянская Красная армия]

Biris (Birzh), Zelman Iosifovich (Бирис (Бирж), Зельман Иосифович), Captain (Капиитан)
Battery Commander – 76mm gun (Командир Батареи – 76-миллиметровая пушка)

271st Guards Rifle Regiment, 88th Guards Rifle Division
Born 1909, city of Tiraspol
Wounded in action 2/4/45; Died of wounds 2/6/45
Buried in Germany

Elkin, Samail Iosifovich (Элькин, Самаил Иосифович), Guards Lieutenant (Гвардии Лейтенант)
Rifle Platoon Commander (Командир Стрелкового Взвода)
47th Army, 77th Guards Rifle Division, 218th Guards Rifle Regiment
Born 1906, city of Novgorod-Severskiy, Chernigov Oblast
Killed in action
Buried in Germany

Farber (Forber), Benitsian Davidovich (Фарбер (Форбер), Бенициан Давидович), Captain (Капитан)
Deputy Commander (Заместитель Комагдира)
212 Rifle Regiment, 49th Rifle Division, 33rd Army
Born 1904, city of Mozir
Killed in action
Buried in Germany

Feldman, Leonid Filippovich (Фельдман, Леонид Филиппович), Lieutenant (Лейтенант) or Private (Рядовой)
Machine Gun Platoon Commander (Командир Взвода Автоматчик), or, Machine Gunner (Автоматчик)
297th Rifle Division
Born 1913, city of Kiev
Killed in action
Buried in Hungary

Frid
, Natan Moiseevich (Фрид, Натан Моисеевич), Junior Lieutenant (Младший Лейтенант)

Self-Propelled Gun Commander (Командир – Самоходной Установки)
1889th Self-Propelled Artillery Regiment
Born 1924, Minsk Oblast, Byelorussia
Killed in action
Buried in Poland

Genov, Khatskel Tankelevich (Генов, Хацкель Танкелевич), Lieutenant (Лейтенант)
Mortar Platoon Commander (Командир Минометного Взвода)
137th Guards Rifle Regiment, 47th Guards Rifle Division
Born 1923
Killed in action

Glikin, Vladimir Moiseevich (Гликин, Владимир Моисеевич), Major (Майор)
Editor, Magazine “For Defense of the Fatherland” (Редактор Газета “На защиту Отечества”)
Transcaucasian Front, 47th Аrmy, 339th Rifle Division
Born 1910, city of Baku
Died of wounds

Kagno, Isaak Moiseevich (Кагно, Исаак Моисеевич), Lieutenant (Лейтенант)
Rifle Platoon Commander (Командир Стрелкового Взвода)
212th Rifle Regiment, 49th Rifle Division
Born 1907
Killed in action

Latishev, David Moiseevich (Латышев, Давид Моисеевич), Guards Senior Lieutenant (Гвардии Старший Сержант)
Rifle Platoon Commander (Командир Стрелкового Взвода)
95th Guards Rifle Division, 287th Guards Rifle Regiment
Born 1911, Kurganskiy Raion
Killed in action

Livshits, Moisey Efremovich (Лившиц, Моисей Ефремович), Guards Captain (Veterinary Services) (Гвардии Капитан (Ветеринарной Службы))
Senior Regimental Veterinary Doctor (Старший полковой ветеринарный врач)

33rd Guards Artillery Regiment, 14th Guards Rifle Regiment
Born 1914, city of Proskurov
Killed in action
Buried in Poland

Lyakhovetskiy, Izer Iosifovich (Lyakhovitskiy, Ozer Iosifovich) (Ляховецкий, Изер Иосифович (Ляховицкий, Озер Иосифович)), Guards Lieutenant (Гвардий Лейтенант)
Battery Control Platoon Commander – 76 mm gun (Командир Взвода Управления Батареи – 76-миллиметровая пушка)
21st Guards Cavalry Regiment, 7th Guards Cavalry Division
Born 1923, Belorussia
Killed in action
Buried in Poland

Maerkovich, Vadlen Isaakovich (Маеркович, Вадлен Исаакович), Lieutenant (Лейтенант)
Mortar Platoon Commander
1064th Rifle Regiment, 281st Rifle Division
Born 1924, in city of Cherkasy
Killed in action
Buried in East Prussia

Mayzel, Pinya Geydalovich (Майзель, Пиня Гейдалович), Major (Майор)
Chief of Artillery Supply (Начальник Артиллерииского Снабжения)
Western Front, 57th Tank Division (147th Rifle Division), 115th Tank Regiment, Artillery-Technical Services
Born 1910, Kamenets-Podolsk Oblast, Ukraine
Missing in action
Buried in Poland

Nekhamkin, Matvey Abramovich (Нехамкин, Матвей Абрамович), Major (Майор)
Deputy Commander – Technical Section (Заместитель по Технической Части Командира)
271st Autonomous Special Purpose Motorized Rifle Brigade (271 Отдельная мотострелковая бригада особого назначения)
Born 1921, Kriovorozhskiy Raion
Killed in action
Buried in Russia

Reznikov, Boris Vulfovich (Резников, Борис Вульфович), Guards Senior Lieutenant (Гвардии Старший Лейтенант)
Rifle Platoon Commander (Командир Стрелкового Взвода)
323rd Rifle Division, 1090th Rifle Regiment
Born 1909, city of Borzna, Chernigov Oblast, Ukraine
Killed in action
Buried in Poland

Spevak, Leyb Mordukhovich (Спевак, Лейб Мордухович), Senior Lieutenant (Старший Лейтенант)
Machine Gun Platoon Commander (Командир Пулеметного Взвода)
1348th Rifle Regiment, 399th Rifle Division
Born 1908, Parichskiy Raion
Killed in action
Buried in East Prussia

Vulfeon (Vulfson?), Ilya Yakovlevich (Вульфеон (Вульфсон?), Илья Яковлевич), Senior Lieutenant (Старший Лейтенант)
Battery Commander (Командир Батареи)
596th Light Artillery Regiment
Born 1910, Shumyachskiy Raion
Killed in action

Yankelovich, Semen Ilyich (Янкелович, Семен Ильич), Guards Junior Lieutenant (Гвардии Младший Лейтенант)
Battalion Party Organizer (Парторг Батальона)
12th Guards Rifle Division, 37th Guards Rifle Regiment
Born in Leningrad
Killed in action
Buried in Germany

Zamanskiy, Isaak Samoylovich (Заманский, Исаак Самойлович), Captain (Капитан)
Regiment Engineer – Rifle Platoon (Полковой Инженер Стрелкового Взвода)
185th Rifle Division
Born 1918
Died of wounds

Zilberbord, Lazar Aronovich (Зильберборд, Лазарь Аронович) Senior Lieutenant (Старший Лейтенант)
Deputy Commander for Political affairs (Заместитель Командира по Политчасти)
271st Autonomous Special Purpose Motorized Rifle Brigade (271 Отдельная мотострелковая бригада особого назначения)
Born 1912, city of Kharkov
Killed in action
Buried in East Prussia

Zilberman, Izidor Leonovich (Зильберман, Изидор Леонович), Lieutenant (Лейтенант)
Rifle Platoon Commander (Командир Стрелкового Взвода)
1st Polish Army, 6th Polish Infantry Pomeranian Division, 16th Infantry Regiment (1-я армия Войска польского, 6-я Польская пехотная Померанская дивизия, 16-й пехотный полк)
Born 1913, city of Rapka
Killed in action
Buried in Poland

______________________________

Poland

Polish People’s Army

Apperman, Chaskiel, First Sergeant
10th Infantry Regiment
Poland, Wielkopolskie, Skorka
Mr. Salomon Apperman (father)
Born Zagorze, Poland, 1923
JMCPAWW2 I – 4

Bar, Herszel, Pvt.
16th Infantry Regiment
Poland, Wielkopolskie, Nadarzyce
Mr. Icchak Bar (father)
Born Wisnowiec (d. Krzemieniec), Poland, 2/2/19
JMCPAWW2 I – 5

Gruber, Grzegorz, Pvt.
Poland, Dobrzyce
Mr. Abram Gruber (father)
Born Mazowieckie, Warsaw, Poland, 1923
JMCPAWW2 I – 26

Kaplan, Ignacy, Pvt.
16th Infantry Regiment
Poland, Wielkopolskie, Nadarzyce
Mr. Aniel Kaplan (father)
Born Mazowieckie, Warsaw Poland, 8/20/03
JMCPAWW2 I – 34

Kozak, Aleksander, Pvt.
1st Infantry Division, Intelligence Company
Poland, Podgaje
Mr. Samuela Kozak (father)
Born Ukraine, Male Koskowce (d. Tarnopol), 1906
JMCPAWW2 I – 40

Kozlowski, Julian, W/O
11th Infantry Regiment
Poland, Dobrycza
Mr. Jakub Kozlowski (father)
Born Lodzkie, Lodz, Poland, 1921
JMCPAWW2 I – 40

* * * * *

Lipszyc, Marian, W/O
18th Infantry Regiment
Poland, Wielkopolskie, Nadarzyce
Mr. Maksymilian Lipszyc (father)
Born Czestochowa, Slaskie, Poland, 1896
JMCPAWW2 I – 46

Marian Lipszyc, a rifle platoon commander, is alternatively listed as “Lipshits, Maryan Maksimovich (in Russian “Липшиц, Марьян Максимович”), with the rank of “Junior Lieutenant (Младший Лейтенант)”.  While Volume 1 of Benjamin Meirtchak’s Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Army lists his unit as the “18th Infantry Regiment”, he’s alternatively listed as having served in the 118th Rifle Regiment of the 6th Infantry Division, in the 1st Polish Army.  The correct designation is indeed the former: the 18th Infantry Regiment, or, “18 Kołobrzeski Pułk Piechoty”.  

* * * * *

Majer, Jozef, Pvt.
Poland, Mazowieckie, Otwock, Field Hospital 2138
Andriolli Street Cemetery, Otwock, Mazowieckie, Poland
JMCPAWW2 I – 467

Szulklaper, Leon, W/O
14th Infantry Regiment
Poland, Ilowiec
Mr. Hersz Szulklaper (father)
Born Mazowieckie, Warsaw, Poland, 11/11/21
JMCPAWW2 I – 68

Wilk
, Edward, Pvt.

18th Infantry Regiment
Poland, Wielkopolskie, Nadarzyce
Mr. Lejb Wilk (father)
Born Switochlawice, Slaskie, Poland, 1926
JMCPAWW2 I – 74

Winner, Nisim, Cpl.
10th Infantry Regiment
Mr. Icchak Winner (father)
JMCPAWW2 I – 75

Zilberman
, Izidor Leonovich (Зильберман, Изидор Леонович) Lieutenant (Лейтенант)

Rifle Platoon Commander (Командир Стрелкового Взвода)
1st Polish Army, 6 Polish Infantry Division, 16th Polish Infantry Regiment
Born 1913
Buried in Poland

______________________________

Wounded in Action

France

Armée de Terre

Assous, Ange, 2ème Canonnier, Citation à l’ordre du Régiment
22ème Groupe de Forces Terrestres Anti Aeriennes, 2ème Batterie
Obersaasem
During the attack on Obersausem on February 6, 1945, his officer and two of his comrades were wounded and he immediately rescued them in spite of a violent artillery bombardment.
(Au cours de l’attaque d’Obersausem, le 6 février 1945, son officier et deux de ses camarades ayant été blesse, s’est porté immédiatement à leur secours malgré un violent bombardement d’artillerie.)
Livre d’Or et de Sang – 97

Though perhaps little known (I didn’t know about the book until some six years ago!), F. Chiche’s Livre d’Or et de Sang – Les Juifs au Combat: Citations 1939-1945 de Bir-Hakeim au Rhin et Danube (The Book of Gold and Blood – The Jews in Combat – Citations 1939-1945 from Bir-Hakeim to the Rhine and Danubeis an utterly invaluable reference concerning military service of Jews in the French armed forces in the Second World War.  The book contains many half-tone photos of Jewish soldiers, primarily men who were casualties, or, who received military awards…

…such as this image of 2ème Canonnier Ange Assous, upon whom was bestowed a Citation à l’ordre du Régiment.

______________________________

Prisoner of War

United States Army

Among the Jewish veterans who I’ve had the good fortune of interviewing has been Mr. David Schneck, originally of Long Island, and later of Bel Air, Maryland, who I met on April 13, 1991, forty-six years and two months after his capture by the Wehrmacht on February 6, 1945.  The result of the interview was a lengthy and detailed account of David’s experiences in the military, being a POW (specifically, at Stalag 12A – Lumburg an der Lahn), the genealogy of his family, his thoughts about such topics as German reunification (well, this was shortly after the end of the (first?!) Cold War), reflections on how being Jewish affected (or, did not directly affect) his experiences as a POW, as well as his musings about history, politics, and social issues.  Interestingly, after his retirement David undertook a project of identifying – through written correspondence; this was just before the advent of the Internet, after all! – other Ex-POWs who’d been interned in Stalag 12A. 

I don’t know the degree to which he completed his project which, three quickly-gone-by decades later, can ironically be done with a few keystrokes and an internet connection.  But, perhaps it doesn’t matter.  Oftimes the worth of an endeavor lies in the work itself, rather than the result.

Born at Bushwick Avenue, Brooklyn on March 30, 1925, David was the son of Harry and Clara (Schoenfeld) Schneck, his family residing at 99-01 97th Street, in Ozone Park.  A Private First Class (32974137) in C Company, 290th Infantry Regiment, 75th Infantry Division, David’s status as a liberated POW was reported in the Long Island Daily Press on May 4 and 16, 1945.    

A recipient of the Purple Heart, David’s name appears on page 431 of American Jews in World War II.

__________

A man who came back: PFC David Schneck, in a photo taken on July 23, 1943.

On May 4, 1945, the Long Island Daily Press published this brief news item about David’s liberation from Stalag 12A.  (This and the next article were found via FultonHistory.com)

New York State Digital library

Twelve days later, on May 16, the Daily Press published this additional news item about his liberation, specifically alluding to the conditions of his imprisonment. 

New York State Digital library

As part of David’s efforts to compile information about Ex-POWs of Stalag 12A, he acquired several photos of the POW camp taken, shortly after its liberation by American forces.  Given the visual style of these pictures, and, their captions, I believe that they’re actually official United States Army photographs.  However, these pictures – at least, the copies then in David’s possession – had no identifying serial numbers.  Regardless, they give a good impression of living conditions at the camp.

Three of these pictures, with transcriptions of original captions, follow below:

__________

U.S. TROOPS INSPECT GERMAN PRISON CAMP

Troops of the First U.S. Army are shown at the entrance to the German prisoner-of-war camp at Limburg, where American, Russian, and French prisoners were liberated.  Twenty miles east of the Rhine, Limburg was first entered by elements of the Ninth Armored Division.  The next day, First Army infantry units, following the armored spearheads, cleared the town.

__________

U.S. PRISONERS LIBERATED

The letters “P.O.W.” mark the roof of barracks at Nazi Stalag XIIA, a prisoner-of-war camp where American captives were liberated by their advancing countrymen.  Although the camp was made immune from Allied air attacks by the painted letters, prisoners received inadequate rations of a bowl of thin soup and a piece of bread each day, and hospital cases lay on wooden beds with little covering.

__________

U.S. PRISONERS LIBERATED

This is the straw-strewn floor of a barn at Nazi Stalag XIIA, where hundreds of American prisoners-of-war were forced to sleep.  Each man had only one blanket.  All the roofs leaked, half of the windows were out, and there was no heat.  The Americans were fed a bowl of thin soup and a piece of bread a day.

__________

The war is over.  (Long, long over!)  David Schneck and his wife Zita, at Bel Air, Maryland, on April 13, 1991.  (Photo by me.  (On Kodachrome.  Remember Kodachrome?))

References

Just Three Books

Dublin, Louis I., and Kohs, Samuel C., American Jews in World War II – The Story of 550,000 Fighters for Freedom, The Dial Press, New York, N.Y., 1947

Meirtchak, Benjamin, Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armies in World War II: I – Jewish Soldiers and Officers of the Polish People’s Army Killed and Missing in Action 1943-1945, World Federation of Jewish Fighters Partisans and Camp Inmates: Association of Jewish War Veterans of the Polish Armies in Israel, Tel Aviv, Israel, 1994 (“JMCPAWW2 I”)

Morris, Henry, Edited by Gerald Smith, We Will Remember Them – A Record of the Jews Who Died in the Armed Forces of the Crown 1939 – 1945, Brassey’s, United Kingdom, London, 1989

A research question:  Finding information about a WW II soldier’s military postings: T/5 Jack M. Weiner, 117th Cavalry Reconnaissance Squadron, United States Army, WW II … January 19, 1922 – March 19, 1945

[I’m working on a variety of posts of my usually (!) lengthy nature, for “this”, and my other two blogs.  In the meantime, here’s a brief post in answer to a comment I recently received from reader Kathleen, which I though might be of wider interest….]

Kathleen’s message:

Hello = I am looking for more information on the military records for Jack M. Weiner, who was profiled in your story.  [About First Lieutenant Charles Blum Do you know where I can find details of all of his postings while he was in the military?

Thanks very much,
Kathleen

________________________________________

So, I reviewed the biographical profile of T/5 Jack Weiner from the above-mentioned post.  Then – ! – I discovered I made a mistake in that post (now corrected).  I noted that Jack Weiner served in the “177th Cavalry Reconnaissance Squadron”, when in reality, he served in the 117th Cavalry Reconnaissance Squadron.  

Weiner, Jack M. (Yakov Moshe bar Avraham), T/5, 20324118, Purple Heart (Casualty in Germany)
United States Army, 117th Cavalry Reconnaissance Squadron, A Troop
Mr. and Mrs. Abraham “Abe” M. [1/15/84-10/31/73] and Esther (Goldberg) [9/10/88-7/4/67] Weiner (parents), 5323 Arlington St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Mrs. Betty W. Sholder, Daniel, Mrs. Mary Handelsman, Mrs. Rose Poplow, Mrs. Sarah Alon (siblings)
Born Bronx, New York, 1/19/22; Enlisted January, 1941
Mount Sharon Cemetery, Springfield, Pa. – Section L; Buried 1/16/49
The Jewish Exponent 4/20/45, 1/10/49
Philadelphia Inquirer 1/15/49
American Jews in World War Two – 558

____________________

The image below shows T/5 Weiner’s matzeva at Mount Sharon Cemetery, in Springfield, Pennsylvania.  He’s one of 64 military casualties of the Second World War (50 Army, 9 Army Air Force, and 5 Navy and Marine Corps) buried at that Delaware County cemetery.

__________

Here’s T/5 Weiner’s obituary as it appeared in two Philadelphia area newspapers:  

First, the Philadelphia Inquirer on 1/15/49, via FultonHistory

…and The Jewish Exponent on January 10 of the same year: 

It can be assumed that information about the locations of all of Jack Weiner’s specific military postings was almost certainly once in the possession of his family, but given the passage of nearly eight decades, it’s problematic if this material survived or can be located.  All that is known is that – according to the Philadelphia Inquirer – he graduated from Overbrook High School in February of 1941, went overseas in February of 1942, and served in North Africa and Italy.  

The document “117th Cavalry Reconnaissance Squadron (Mecz) in World War II – January 6, 1941 – May 18, 1945 & Occupation”, indirectly sheds a few hints about Jack’s military service.  The book reveals that 117th was actually formed from the 102nd Cavalry Regiment of the New Jersey National Guard, which itself was originally part of the 21st Cavalry Division.  The 102nd was ordered into Federal Service on January 6, 1941, and retained that designation until November 30, 1943, when it was reorganized and designated the 117th Cavalry Squadron Reconnaissance (Mecz).  The book recounts the early history of the 102nd as follows:      

The first week of December 1941 was a fateful one.  Maneuvers were over. The Regiment would be completing its year of Federal Service on January 5th.  December 7th fixed that!!  Training was accelerated, new equipment was issued, leaves were cancelled, troops were brought up to 100% combat strength and all preparations were intensified.

In mid January, the Regiment received orders to prepare for embarkation for overseas duty.  It was to board the French Luxury Liner “Normandy” on February 26th.  It had been tied up in N.Y. since 1939 when war broke out in Europe.

On the morning of February 18th, the “Normandy” burned and sank at her pier in New York.  Sabotage was suspected.

Meanwhile, the extensive and dramatic employment of mechanized units by the Germans in the war in Europe and our own experience during maneuvers had clearly indicated the diminished effectiveness of horse cavalry in the new mode of warfare.  So it was that on April 6, 1942; just 15 months to the day following its entry into Federal Service, that the 102nd Cavalry Regiment lost its horses and was reorganized into a fully mechanized Regiment.

The Regiment returned to its concentrated training regimen until early July when it again received orders to prepare for staging to Fort Dix in early September from whence it was to ship out for overseas duty.

September 25th 1942 the Troops boarded the H.M.S. Dempo, a Dutch passenger liner under British Army control, and sailed October 1st for England in a 96 ship convoy, plus escort, which left the Dempo behind when it developed engine problems two hours out to sea.  Repaired by its Dutch Engineers within a few hours, the ship resumed the trip on its own.  It landed in Liverpool on October 7th after an essentially uneventful crossing.

Most of the Regiment was billeted in Fairford, a beautiful little village in the Cotswold area of England. Our quarters were on the 1000 acre Palmer Estate nearly adjacent to the Village Square. The officers were housed in the Manor House, the enlisted men in Quonset Huts.

Training schedules were quickly implemented to maintain the high state of proficiency attained in the States.

The Tank/Artillery Troop drew its first Tanks; M5A1s weighing 25 tons and armed with a 37mm gun and two .30 caliber machine guns.  Few of the Troopers had ever seen a tank.  Fewer still ever sat in one.  The artillery platoon of the Tank Troop was equipped with four 75mm French Howitzers mounted on half-tracks.  They were capable of only a sixty-degree traverse. 

The training then initiated for Officers at the Royal Armored Tactical School was all based upon actual combat experience gained in combat with the Africa Corp.  The School was at Brasenow College, Oxford University.  The Instructors were all combat experienced Officers of the British Eighth Army.

In December 1942, the 2nd Squadron of the 102nd under the Command of Lt. Col. Hodge was detached from the Regiment and assigned to the Security Command of A.F.H.Q. (Allied Force Headquarters).  

Now stationed at Shrivingham Barracks, the Squadron commenced to draw its vehicles, weapons and other equipment.  Scout cars, halftracks, bantams, radio equipment etc. were drawn throughout November and December and delivered to Glasgow for loading aboard ship.

The Squadron, by then alerted to sail from Glasgow, Scotland on December 24th, for a destination only later learned to be Algiers, did so aboard the H.M.S. Straithaird and landed at Algiers on the morning of January 3rd 1943.  A little less than two months after the first Allied Forces had come ashore on November 8th, 1942.

After several days in the El Biar section of Algiers where we viewed the nightly bombing of the city by the Luftwaffe, the Squadron was billeted, on January 10th, in the small town of Douera, about 18 miles south of Algiers.

However…!  Given the timing of Jack’s arrival overseas (whatever / where-ever the Philadelphia Inquirer meant by “overseas”) in February of 1942, combat service in North Africa and Italy, and the 102nd (later 117th’s) arrival in England eight months later … in September of that year … it seems certain that he was not a member of the original cadre that formed the 102nd / 117th, and was only assigned to the Reconnaissance Squadron later on in the war.  In turn, his service in the North African and Italian campaigns suggests – well, it’s a possibility – that he was a member of the 1st, 3rd, 9th, or 34th Infantry Divisions, or the 1st Armored Division, all of which participated in Operation Torch, the Allied invasion of North Africa in November of 1942.  

So, in answer to the larger question of Jack’s military postings, I don’t know of any publicly accessible, single, comprehensive, reliable source of information which would list or delineate each and every assignment – whether combat, or, non-combat – of a randomly given serviceman.

In terms of casualties, military records (such as Army Air Force Missing Air Crew Reports, or, records covering the loss of Navy and Marine Corps aviators, or, officers and men on naval vessels) by definition and nature pertain to a serviceman’s military unit at the specific point in time when he was wounded, missing, or killed in action.

That being said, for American WW II servicemen who were killed in action, or who lost their lives on operational (not necessarily combat) activity, one source of the information might (might…) be a serviceman’s IDPF: His Individual Deceased Personnel File.  There are many (many) websites describing the nature and content of these documents (just search DuckDuckGo – you’ll see what I mean; you can find examples of IDPFS in the William L. Beigel Collection at the American Air Museum in Britain) so I won’t delve into a lengthy description of these records in “this” reply.

However, suffice to say that due to the depth and detail of the information in IDPFs, coupled with the fact that they not uncommonly include documents and correspondence – utterly, inevitably, and naturally frank;  often of a very sad nature – compiled in postwar investigations (typically including information used to confirm the identity of a fallen soldier, and, correspondence from his parents, siblings, or wife) one can sometimes – some times, but hardly all the time – find information by which a soldier’s assignments and postings can be identified and chronologically “pieced” together.  Again though, IDPFs most often and predictably indicate the unit to which a serviceman was assigned at the point in time when he was killed: His last military unit.  They’re not intended to recapitulate a serviceman’s entire military career.

In any event, the postal address for requesting IDPFs is presently:

National Archives & Records Administration
National Archives – St. Louis
ATTN: RL_SL
P.O. Box 38757 (or) 1 Archives Drive, Room 340
St. Louis, Mo. 63138-0757

Otherwise, it might be possible to at least partially reconstruct a WW II soldier’s military service by means of newspaper articles, in terms of the geographic locations and bases at which he was stationed over time.  However, unless you know the date and publication of these items beforehand, such research is (allegorically!) akin to searching for a near-infinitesimal grain of sand on a near-infinite beach, where you know neither the appearance of that particular grand of sand nor the location of the “beach”, beforehand.  In addition, this presumes that you have access to the newspaper of interest in either 35mm microfilm or digital formats beforehand!  (This being the year 2021, gadzooks, what’s microfilm?!)

So, if I’ve created some questions, I hope I’ve provided some answers and directions. 

 References

Dublin, Louis I., and Kohs, Samuel C., American Jews in World War II – The Story of 550,000 Fighters for Freedom, The Dial Press, New York, N.Y., 1947

The Operational History of the 117th Cavalry Reconnaissance Squadron (Mecz.) World War II

117th Cavalry Reconnaissance Squadron (Mecz) in World War II – January 6, 1941 – May 18, 1945 & Occupation

The Honor Roll of the 117th Cavalry Reconnaissance Squadron (Mecz) – Those who gave their lives for their Country in World War II

New Jersey Cavalry and Armor Association

Soldiers from New York: Jewish Soldiers in The New York Times, in World War Two: 1 Lt. Norman F. Hirsch (November 26, 1944) – I [Updated post…  “New and Improved!”]

[Created “way back when” – in August of 2018 – this post – focusing on November 26, 1944 – has now been updated, with additional information primarily pertaining to the 8th Air Force’s mission to the Deurag-Neurag oil refinery at Misburg, Germany.  New material comprises the following: 1) Crew lists for 8th Air Force B-24 losses, including airmen’s names, crew positions, serial numbers, home towns of residence, and indications about an airman’s ultimate fate (those who survived are denoted by a boldface surname), 2) Extracts from Luftgaukommando Reports pertaining to the location where an aircraft crashed, 3) Mapple Apps Apple Maps showing the locations of these crash sites, with the crash site denoted by a red oval, and – for reference – the target location at Misburg Nord denoted in blue, 4) For two lost B-24s – THE FIREBIRD and ARK ANGEL – images of pages from relevant Luftgaukommando Reports, from NARA, 5) Also from NARA, a few images of personal documents from B-24 crewmen who were casualties on the mission, 6) A few Army Air Force photographs from Fold3, 7) New images of B-24s Problem Child, and, ARK ANGEL.  Plus, a small amount of commentary.

I’m aware, that in the world of 2021; an age dominated by the civilizationally corrosive oxymoron otherwise known as “social media” (Gee, thanks, Jack!  Golly, thanks, Mark!), this post will appear to be extraordinarily long (hmmm…  most of my posts are that way) but, well, so be it. 

After all, the past is worthy of contemplation, and cannot be captured in a “Tweet”. 

Then again, neither can nor should the present.   

So, back to the post…!]

________________________________________

There is more to “the news” than mere news. 

Like a Matryoshka doll, the events of every age – whether of “man” in the abstract, or “men” as individuals – contain within themselves tales, within stories, within memories.  Often, stories can be understood only long after they occurred: when participants and witnesses are few, or longer exist. 

Such was the case on the 24th of February in the year 1945, when an obituary for Army Air Force aerial navigator 1 Lt. Norman F. Hirsch, killed in action over Germany on November 26, 1944, appeared in The New York Times

As situated within a list of names of wounded servicemen from the New York Metropolitan area and northern New Jersey (the Times’ list having been derived from combined Army and Navy nationwide casualty lists comprising over 4,300 names), the reader could not – then – have known what occurred over Germany three months before: On November 26, during Eighth Air Force mission number 725, over 1,100 B-17s and B-24s, escorted by over 730 P-47s and P-51s, were dispatched to attack rail viaducts, marshaling yards and oil installations in western Germany, the latter target being the Deurag-Nerag Synthetic Oil Refinery, in Misburg, a district of Hannover.  

Targets allocated to the heavy bombers on Mission 725 were as follows:

Altenbeken – Railroad viaduct: 118 B-17s
Bielefeld – Railroad marshalling yard: 36 B-17s
Bielefeld – Railroad viaduct: 240 B-24s
Gutersloh – Railroad marshalling yard: 37 B-17s
Hamm – Railroad marshalling yard: 266 B-17s
Hannover – Railroad marshalling yard: 26 B-24s
Herford – Railroad marshalling yard: 24 B-17s
Misburg – Deurag Industry oil refinery: 243 B-17s and 57 B-24s

…and…

Oosterhout, Netherlands – Leaflet drop: 8 B-17s and 6 B-24s

That day, American bombers were intercepted by approximately 500 Luftwaffe fighters.  The 8th Air Force lost over 30 B-17s and B-24s, and 9 fighters, in turn claiming the destruction of over 130 German aircraft.

While Missing Air Crew Reports (MACRs) record the loss of 9 fighters (among the 55th, 78th, 339th, 355th, and 364th Fighter Groups), 1 F-5E reconnaissance Lightning (43-28619, of the 7th Photographic Reconnaissance Group), and 14 B-17 Flying Fortresses (among the 91st, 303rd, 305th, 351st, 381st, 388th, 390th, 398th, and 487th Bomb Groups), strikingly, the loss of 21 B-24 Liberators occurred only among three Bomb Groups – the 389th “Sky Scorpions” (1 aircraft), 445th (5 aircraft), and 491st “Ringmasters”, which lost 15 Liberators.  Additionally, the 8th AF Historical Society notes the loss – for which there are no MACRs – of an additional three B-24s (among the 445th, 453rd, and 491st Bomb Groups) respectively through crash-landing, crashing, and abandonment by the bomber’s crew over Belgium. 

__________

The emblem of the Ringmasters, from the US Militaria forum.  The three-banded horizontal green-white-green pattern reflects the 491st’s group markings as displayed on their B-24s’ outer tails and rudders, following the Bomb Group marking system of the 8th Air Force’s 2nd Air Division. 

__________

This toll of men and planes represented one of the heaviest losses incurred by an Army Air Force Combat Group during the Second World War, with the worst such event – resulting in the loss of 26 Liberators – befalling the 445th Bomb Group during a mission to Kassel, Germany, on September 27, 1944.  (The initial cause of the 445th’s losses of September 27 was an error in radar navigation in the 445th’s lead Liberator, B-24J 42-51541, RN * H, piloted by Captain John H. Chilton, with Major Don W. McCoy as command pilot; neither man survived.)  Another such incident, perhaps less widely known, was the 483rd Bomb Group’s loss of 14 B-17s during a mission to Memmingen, Germany on July 18, 1944, which included seven B-17s of the 816th Bomb Squadron. 

The commonality of these incidents was that they were situations in which the German air defense network was able to detect, recognize, and exploit the absence of American escort fighters, directing its fighters to strike the temporarily undefended American Bombardment Groups, overwhelming the bombers’ combined defensive firepower through a succession of coordinated, tightly concentrated, and close attacks by multiple aircraft.

Thus, the loss of the Ringmaster’s 15 Liberators within the space of fifteen minutes, on November 26, 1944. 

As part of the 8th Air Force’s B-24-equipped 2nd Bombardment Wing, the Ringmasters were sequentially the “last” combat group (preceded by the 389th and 445th Bomb Groups) allocated to bomb the Deurag-Neurag oil refinery. 

____________________

This map gives a sense of the the location of Hannover relative to other cities in northern Germany, as well as the Netherlands, Belgium, and France…  

____________________

…while this map shows the locations of Hannover and Misburg Nord relative to one another.

____________________

Before the Misburg mission.  (Well, long before the Misburg mission.)  This photo – presumably taken by the Royal Air Force – shows the Deurag-Nerag Synthetic Oil Refinery as it appeared in 1942.  The channel running parallel to the bottom of the image is the Stichkanal Misburg.  For the purposes of this post, I’ve digitally “rotated” the photo (you can view the original at Fold3) such that its orientation is consistent with the refinery’s actual geography:  Thus, “up”, or the “top” of your screen, is north, and “down”, or the bottom of your screen, is south.

Caption:  “Synthetic plant at Misburg, Germany with monthly pre-attack capacity of 25,000 tons looked like this in 1942.”  Print received January 1945 from Pub. Sec., AC/AS Intel.  Used in January, 1945 issue of Impact.  (Photo 55774AC – A22022 (1942)

____________________

By the time the Group approached the target, the horizontal distance between the Ringmasters and the two preceding Groups had notably increased, diminishing the potential effectiveness of escort fighter coverage for all three Groups, as well as placing the 491st in a relatively isolated position relative to the remainder of the 2nd Bomb Wing as a whole.

At 1226 hours, the 491st had just turned at the I.P. (the “Initial Point”, an identifiable land mark about 20 miles more of less from a target, from which location a Group’s bomb-run would typically commence); in this case the Lower Saxon town of Wittingen, approximately 46 miles northeast of Hannover.  Just prior to reaching this location, a large number of Luftwaffe fighters – approximately 150 to 200 aircraft – was seen southeast of the 491st’s formation.  As stated in Ringmasters, “They [Luftwaffe fighters] made no move toward the Liberators but were “just playing around in the clouds” as if daring the Mustangs and Thunderbolts to come over and mix it up.  The chance seemed too good to miss and the entire close fighter escort, consisting of 197 P-51s and 48 P-47s, went storming after the Germans, estimated at from 150 to 200 strong.  In a matter of minutes they were fully engaged, leaving the B-24s on their own.  Area coverage fighters, as noted above, had already been diverted to meet an earlier appearance of the enemy.”   

The Group’s Air Commander (and Commanding Officer of the 854th Bomb Squadron) Lt. Col. Parmele – about whom possibly more in a future post – was immediately faced with the decision of whether to: “…uncover his three squadrons in the face of imminent enemy attack or to preserve the Group formation and meet the enemy with a united front.  Realizing that superior bombing results could only be achieved by uncovering, he unhesitatingly ordered this maneuver.”  The 491st thus commenced its bomb run.  Then, a mishap occurred in the lead B-24 of the “low” – 854th – Bomb Squadron (Lt. Haney’s plane, #735, 6X * Z –): Within the already crowded nose of the plane, the nose gunner accidentally tripped the bomb toggle switch, which caused the B-24 to release its bombs.  The rest of the 854th Bomb Squadron immediately followed suit, that entire squadron’s bomb load falling into open fields 15 miles from Misburg. 

____________________

After “a” Misburg mission.  (But which mission?!)  Dated as having been received on October 6, 1944 from the BPR (Bureau of Public Relations?) this reconnaissance photo shows the level of destruction incurred from aerial bombardment.  While damage is readily apparent across the facility, particularly among the storage tanks, it seems that other parts of the plant are still relatively intact.  Also, note the degree to which bombs have impacted on nearby farmland.  

Akin to the previous image, this image has been rotated to conform to geographic north.  As such, the very long southwest to northeast oriented shadows, particularly those projecting from infrastructure near the Stichkanal, suggest that the image was taken very late in the afternoon.  Well, an afternoon.       

Caption: “HITLER’S OIL PLANT AT MISBURG HIT HARD – Gutted installations and burned out storage tanks set the stage at the German synthetic oil plant at Misburg, near Hannover, after U.S. Army 8th Air Force heavy bombers had attacked it several times in the past few months.  It was last attacked on 12 September 1944.”  Negative received 10/6/44 from BPR, to accompany Press Release: “HITLER’S OIL PLANT AT MISBURG  (Photo +54123AC – A22017)

____________________

The image below, from Ringmasters, is captioned “The COs – Golf, Miller, Parmele”, but doesn’t specify “who” commanded “what”.  While I can’t identify “Golf” and am uncertain of “Miller’s” identity (could he be Group CO Colonel Frederic H. Miller, Jr.?), “Parmele” is definitely Lt. Col. Charles C. Parmele of the the 854th.  (In 2007, Edward Kamarainen, one of the six survivors of 853rd Bomb Squadron’s DORTY TREEK, wrote and published (via lulu.com) This Is War and We Are Prisoners of the Enemy, in which he states that the commander of the 853rd was Lt. Col. Harry Stephy.)

The German air defense network recognized the status and disposition of the 2nd Bomb Wing’s three trailing B-24 Groups, particularly the sudden vulnerability of the 491st.  Thus, flak stopped, a prelude to attack by Luftwaffe fighters.  As noted by Sal Leotta, Dead-Reckoning navigator in Lt. Haney’s crew (in a description and tone consistent with the above quote pertaining to the Group’s fighter escort), “After passing the Dummer Lake area we received many reports of enemy fighters.  The mission continued until about 20 minutes before the IP when a large force of enemy fighters was sighted.  Our fighter escort peeled off to intercept and stave off any attack on the bombers.  I recall the subsequent air battle drifting off in the distance.  Looking back later, it became obvious that this engagement was a ruse to strip us of our fighter escort.” 

The impression arising from these accounts is that the 491st was – in effect and reality – left on its own, the escort fighters having been drawn away off in the pursuit and attack of nearby concentrations of Luftwaffe interceptors.  Doubtless events could genuinely and sincerely have been perceived as such by the crews of the Ringmasters.  (This comes across in Edwin Kamarainen‘s book.)  However, it could be ventured that – given the sheer number of aircraft (American (732) and German) operating in a geographically limited airspace; the near-inevitable fluidity and complexity of aerial combat; the simple unpredictability inherent to any military engagement – a difference in perspective and priority vis-a-vis bomber crews and fighter pilots might well have been, and be, sadly inevitable.  So…  If you’re interested in more information about the 8th Air Force fighter engagements of November 26, 1944, you can find 38 combat reports for this mission (and 790 reports for other dates) at WW II Aircraft Performance.

In any event…  As described in the Group’s mission report, “At 1240 hours approximately 100 E/A attacked the formation just south of Hannover.  The attack was made by FW 190s in line astern formation mostly from 6 o’clock high and pressing attack to within 100 yards — Peeling off and coming in again from any angle — This attack lasted until 12:55 hrs.  The squadrons were in trail when the attack started and the last squadron [853rd] was attacked first — Then the middle [854th] and finally the lead [855th] — The attack on the lead squadron was not intense and no A/C were lost from the squadron.”  Again, Sal Leotta: “In what appeared to be seconds, the sky filled with enemy fighters and the high squadron (853rd BS) was literally blown out of the skies.  Without a pause, we (854th BS) were the next target.  They came at us about 10 to 20 abreast firing their cannons.  During the attack I felt useless with no gun to fire.  All I could do was to call out the positions of incoming bandits.  In retrospect, I am amazed at the intensity, speed and success of the attack.  It may have felt like an eternity but it actually was very swift, a matter of a few minutes.  It happened so quickly that there was not time to pray or be frightened.”

In an indirect and sad way, the nature of the tactic employed by Jagdgeschwader 301 against the 491st is verified by a review of Missing Air Crew Reports for Ringmaster B-24 losses that day:  These documents reveal that a slight preponderance (well, in a general sense) of aircrew casualties occurred among those airmen whose crew positions were situated in the rear of their aircraft – tail, waist, and ball turret gunners, while those situated in the front – pilots, navigators, bombardiers, and flight engineers – seem to have had a somewhat better chance of survival.  Of the 16 491st B-24s that were lost, there were no survivors on three planes (Problem Child, ARK ANGEL, and Blue Circle) while in the B-24s piloted by Lieutenants Ecklund (853rd) and Lanning (854th), all crewmen but one survived the mission.  In no case did a shot-down Ringmaster crew survive intact, though all crew members in two of the five 445th Bomb Group’s losses (both of the 703rd Bomb Squadron) survived the mission.  

The bombers were attacked by Jagdgeschwader 301, a Luftwaffe fighter wing based at Stendal (110 miles east of Hannover), at the time equipped with FW-190A-8 and A-9 fighters.  After the Wing’s three Gruppen downed 15 Ringmaster and then 5 445th B-24s (389th Bomb Group B-24J 44-10579 Pugnacious Princess Pat was shot down by flak), P-51s of the 2nd Scouting Force, followed by P-51s of the 339th, 355th, and 361st Fighter Groups, responding to radio calls, came to the defense of the Liberators, pilots of the three Fighter Groups respectively claiming 28, 21, and 23 enemy planes, these 72 aerial victories comprising FW-190s from JG 301, and, fighters from other Luftwaffe fighter wings.

____________________

Combat in real time:  This image, probably captured by a B-24’s automatic downward-facing camera, has photographically “captured” an FW-190 flying over Hannover.  Paralleling the two above images of the Deurag-Nerag Synthetic Oil Refinery, I’ve photoshopifically “rotated” this image such that geographic north is “up” towards the top of your screen.  This orientation was determined by comparing the layout of streets and other features in the photo (the original image at Fold3 has a typical horizontal format) to Apple Map views of Hannover.

The FW-190, flying south-southeast, is situated almost exactly halfway between the two puffy clouds in the left half of the image.  

Caption: “A Nazi FW-190 wings over the Misburg area as U.S. 8th Air Force heavies, high overhead drop their lethal load on the oil refinery there 26 Nov 44.”  Passed for publication 22 December 1944.  Negative received 12/29/44 from BPR.  (Photo 55593AC – A22019)

This’ll make it easier to see the FW-190:  It’s a cropped view of the above photo, with the FW-190 in the very center of the image.  Nothing on camouflage and markings, but hey, it’s an interesting and relevant picture.  

So, where exactly is – more accurately, where was – the plane in relation to Hannover?  This 2021 view reveals that the plane’s location – shown by the red circle – was directly over what appears to be the Stadtfriedhof (State Cemetery) Lindener Burg… 

…as shown in the map below.

____________________

The diagram below, from Ringmasters, illustrates the arrangement of the 491st’s formation as if viewed from above, with each aircraft identified by the pilot’s surname, the last three digits of its serial number, and its individual squadron code letter.  (Edward Kamarainen noted that one 853rd Liberator – #341 (T8 * – W) – turned back because of radio failure.)  Red boxes indicate aircraft shot down, with 1 Lt. Harold E. Lanning’s plane (blue box: Reluctant Dragon, 6X * I –, probably 42-95610) surviving the attack.  Mortally damaged and with one waist gunner (S/Sgt. Lee A. Taylor) dead, its nine survivors safely parachuted near Brussels.  Note that the lead (855th) squadron survived the mission intact.

______________________________

Lieutenant Hirsch was the navigator of an aircraft ironically named THE FIREBIRD (B-24J 42-110167; a camouflaged plane with squadron code T8 * – O), piloted by 1 Lt. Daniel C. Budd.  There were two survivors from the plane’s crew of ten: right waist gunner S/Sgt. Frank Verbosky and left waist gunner S/Sgt. Thaddeus C. Jarosz, for whom postwar Casualty Questionnaires are conspicuously absent from the Missing Air Crew Report (MACR 10768) covering their plane’s loss. 

Perhaps there was little for them to say. 

Crash location as listed Luftgaukommando Report KU 3452:
Bredenbeck near Bennigsen; 20 km northwest of Hildesheim.

Budd, Daniel C., 1 Lt. – (0-797459), Falls Church, Va. – Pilot
Oury, Noel A., 2 Lt. – (0-1998532), Richmond, Va. – Co-Pilot
Hirsch, Norman F., 1 Lt. – (0-709375), Brooklyn, N.Y. – Navigator
Walker, Floyd A., Jr., 2 Lt. – (0-2058592), Des Moines, Ia. – Navigator (Nose)
Phelps, William F., 1 Lt. – (0-706899), New London County, Ct. – Bombardier
Brock, Vernon R., T/Sgt. – (36458670), Albion, Mi. – Flight Engineer
Bemis, Elmer H., T/Sgt. – (31261913), Marlboro, Ma. – Radio Operator
Verbovsky, Frank, S/Sgt. – (32911685), North Bergen, N.J. – Gunner (Right Waist) (Survived)
Jarosz, Thaddeus C., S/Sgt. – (31362327), Laurence, Ma. – Gunner (Left Waist) (Survived)
Crane, Thomas R., S/Sgt. – (32757283), Salem, N.J. – Gunner (Tail)

As reported in the Luftgaukommando Report, the bomber crashed 20 kilometers northwest of the town of Hildehseim, at “Bradenback near Bemimgsen”.  (The correct spellings should be “Bredenbeck” and “Bennigsen”.)  Curiously, MACR 10768 lists aircraft as being assigned to the 853rd BS, as does “Ringmasters”, but B-24BestWeb designates plane as belonging to the 852nd BS.  (Perhaps the plane was assigned to 853rd BS prior to the mission of November 26.)

__________

Here are pages from Luftgaukommando Report KU 3452.  The degree of destruction of the plane is indicated by the near-complete absence of technical information about the wreckage, with the exception of one entry about radio equipment.  Apparently, there was very little left.    

__________

Lt. Hirsch, serial 0-709375, received the Air Medal and Purple Heart, and is buried in Section 24 of Arlington National Cemetery, in a collective burial with Lt. Budd, co-pilot 2 Lt. Noel A. Oury, flight engineer T/Sgt. Vernon R. Brock, and radio operator T/Sgt. Elmer H. Bemis.  They presumably had flown all their prior missions together, as mentioned in Ringmasters by 853rd Squadron bombardier Vince Cahill:  “It was a quiet hut that night.  Pilots Budd and Orley, Navigator Hirsh [sic] and Bombardier “Shorty” were gone.  I wondered if we would ever be lucky enough to complete our 35 missions.  This was Budd’s crew’s 26th mission, four more to go for 30 and a complete tour.” 

This photo of the mens’ collective grave is by FindAGrave contributor John Evans.

This photograph of THE FIREBIRD’s nose art is from B-24 Best Web

…while this image is from the 491st Bomb Group website, now available through Archive.org’s “Wayback Machine”.

…and this image, taken on May 13, 1944, is from the Flickr photostream of the San Diego Air and Space Museum.

______________________________

Lt. Hirsch’s obituary, as published in The New York Times on February 24 (and in the Brooklyn Eagle on February 21, 1945), follows:

Killed While in Action In Battle of Germany

First Lieut. Norman F. Hirsch of the Army Air Forces was killed in action over Germany on Nov. 26, the War Department informed his parents, Mr. and Mrs. Reuben [and Esther] Hirsch of 416 Ocean Avenue, Brooklyn, on Jan. 26, it was announced yesterday.  Twenty-three years old, Lieutenant Hirsch held the Air Medal, was a Liberator navigator with the Eighth Army Air Force in England and had flown thirty-five missions.

Born in Elizabeth, N.J., Lieutenant Hirsch attended Brooklyn College and City College and was a senior in the latter institution when he enlisted in 1942.  He began his air training in 1943 and received his wings in 1944.

His father is a lawyer.  Besides his parents, he leaves a brother, Second Lieut. William J. Hirsch of the Fifteenth Army Air Force in Italy.

The New York Times 2/24/45 (obituary), Casualty List 3/14/45
Brooklyn Eagle 2/21/45 (obituary), 5/16/46, 5/17/46, 6/6/46, 6/10/46
American Jews in World War II – 345

Here’s a contemporary view of 416 Ocean Parkway, from Jeff Reuben’s Flickr photostream.

Over a year later, the Brooklyn Eagle would carry two brief news items mentioning Lt. Hirsch, both mentioning a Jewish War Veterans Post named in his honor, which met at Congregation Ahavath Israel and Talmud Torah of East Midwood, at 2818 Avenue K in Brooklyn.    

May 16, 1946

Three years ago a certain Brooklyn College student left behind classroom and books to enlist in the army and did not return.  Tonight one of his former instructors, Prof. Louis A. Warsoff, will speak at an open meeting to be held by the Jewish War Veterans post named for the student, Norman F. Hirsch.  Professor Warsoff will speak on “The World of Tomorrow” at the session of the Lt. Norman F. Hirsch Post, Congregation Ahavath Israel, 2818 Avenue K.

June 6, 1946

Annual memorial services will be held at 8:30 p.m. Sunday in Congregation Ahavath Israel, 2818 Avenue K.  Participating will be members of Flatlands Post, American Legion, and Lt. Norman F. Hirsch Post, Jewish War Veterans.

This Flickr image, by Matthew X. Kiernan, is a 2012 view of the schul, now the home of Young Israel of Avenue K.

Some other Jewish military casualties on Sunday, November 26, 1944 (10 Kislev 5705), include…

Killed in Action
– .ת.נ.צ.ב.ה. –

United States Army Air Force

8th Air Force

445th Bomb Group, 701st Bomb Squadron

Bailey, Herbert Edward, 2 Lt., 0-712477, Navigator, Air Medal, Purple Heart
Mr. and Mrs. Meyer E. [7/22/97-10/10/65] and Marion T. [1902-2/12/60] Bailey (parents), Alan P. Bailey (brother), 100 Laurel Road, New Haven, 13, Ct.
Born Hartford, N.Y., 6/17/23
MACR 10754, Luftgaukommando Report KU 3366, Aircraft B-24H 42-94940 (The Green Hornet), Pilot 2 Lt. William K. Boykin, 9 crew – 3 survivors
Ardennes American Cemetery, Neupre, Belgium – Plot D, Row 24, Grave 21
American Jews in World War II – 61

Statement in MACR: “Ship #940 was jumped by fighters after bombs away and started going down.  Four (4) chutes were observed.  Plane was not on fire and seemed under control.”

Crash location:
In MACR: 15 miles southeast of Hannover
In Luftgaukommando Report: Sorsun, 10 km southwest of Hildesheim

Boykin, William L., Jr., 2 Lt. – (0-772784), Philadelphia, Pa. – Pilot
Tubergen, Gary V., Jr., 2 Lt. – (0-821812), Plymouth, Mi. – Co-Pilot
Bailey, Herbert E., 2 Lt. – (0-712477), New Haven, Ct. – Navigator
Price, Junius C., T/Sgt. – (34644499), Florence, S.C. – Flight Engineer (Survived)
Welch, Donald N., T/Sgt. – (35549094), Lima, Oh. – Radio Operator (Survived)
Gutowsky, Joe A., S/Sgt. – (36262079), Racine, Wi. – Gunner (Nose)
McFadden, Walter C., S/Sgt. – (33679986), Grove City, Pa. – Gunner (Waist) (Survived)
Crespolini, Americo A., S/Sgt. – (33609563), Old Forge, Pa. – Gunner (Waist)
Craig, Otis D., S/Sgt. – (32956491), Wilmington, De. – Gunner (Tail)

____________________

This is an image of Herbert Bailey before he became “Lieutenant” Bailey: It’s his graduation portrait from the Milford, Connecticut, (junior?) high school class yearbook of 1939, via Ancestry.com. 

Here’s Lt. Bailey’s Officer’s Identification Card.  Note that the card is designed to be twice folded, enabling it to fit inside a wallet. 

While certainly hardly every Luftgaukommando Report includes this type of document, in terms of the materials that can be found in these Reports, Officer’s Identification Cards tend to be among the more common items.  Note that information is limited to name, serial number, date of birth, height, weight, hair and eye color, and a set of fingerprints, and the card’s serial number – the latter not identical to the officer’s military serial number.  No information is present concerning next of kin or place-of-residence.

Herbert Bailey’s Army and Navy Officer’s Club (of Beverly Hills, California) dated March 25, 1944.  

____________________

____________________

And, a newspaper clipping, undated.  Crumpled and torn, but still intact.      

____________________

T/Sgt. Junius C. Price was one of the three survivors of The Green Hornet.  This is his Individual Issue Record of flying equipment, which appears to have been assigned to him on May 27, 1944.  Some of these items are described and illustrated in Gordon Rottman’s 1993 book (published by Osprey) US Army Air Force: 1.

____________________

Sgt. Price’s Merit Award, dated May 20, 1944.

____________________

And, his Class “A” Pass from Biggs Field, Texas, dated June 30 of that year.    

__________

Levy, Robert D., 2 Lt., 0-825915, Co-Pilot
Mrs. Gertrude Levy (mother), 4917 B Street, Philadelphia, Pa.
MACR 11214, Luftgaukommando Report KU 3386, Aircraft B-24J 42-50467, Pilot 1 Lt. John D. Barringer, 9 crew – no survivors
Possibly from Hamilton County, Tennessee
Nashville National Cemetery, South Madison, Tn. – Section MM, Graves 64-64A-65; Buried 4/24/50
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Statement in MACR: “Ship #467 was jumped by fighters and two (2) chutes were seen coming out of the plane.  This ship was under control at the time.”

Crash location:
In MACR: 15 miles southeast of Hannover
In Luftgaukommando Report: “Hammerswald” (probably Hämelerwald) near Peine / 6 km east of Lehrte

Barringer, John D., Jr., 1 Lt. – (0-763904), Nashville, Tn. – Pilot
Levy, Robert D., 2 Lt. – (0-825915), Philadelphia, Pa. – Co-Pilot
Juliano, Paul J., F/O – (T-126230), Niagara Falls, N.Y. – Navigator
Brunswig, Norman F., 2 Lt. – (0-722691), Rock Island, Il. – Bombardier
Black, Joseph F., S/Sgt. – (39414426), Fort Smith, Ar. – Flight Engineer
Sullivan, Eugene J., S/Sgt. – (11069588), North Cambridge, Ma. – Radio Operator
Lyons, Roland C., Jr., Sgt. – (33543987), Portsmouth, Va. – Gunner (Waist)
Personette, Eldon R., Sgt. – (37568985), Minneapolis, Mn. – Gunner (Waist)
Vance, William J., Jr., Sgt. – (34778642), Asheville, N.C. – Gunner (Tail)

__________

491st Bomb Group, 853rd Bomb Squadron

Negrin, Carl, Sgt., 32823090, Right Waist Gunner, Purple Heart
MACR 10762, Aircraft B-24H 41-28884 (T8 * – X / Problem Child), Pilot 2 Lt. John P. Hite, 9 crew – no survivors
Born 7/17/24, Rochester, N.Y.
Mr. and Mrs. Isaac Joseph [1895-?] and Esther [12/4/97-10/63] Negrin (parents)
Mrs. Sarah M. Lindenfeld (sister), 509 Hegeman Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Mr. Michael Negrin (brother) [5/5/34-12/22/00]
Labety and Zacharia Negrin (half-brothers)
Place of Burial unknown
American Jews in World War II – 398

Aircraft crash location unknown.

Hite, John P., 2 Lt. – (0-448833), Christiansburg, Va. – Pilot
Volden, Morris J., 2 Lt. – (0-689416), Cottonwood, Mn. – Co-Pilot
O’Brien, Thomas R., 2 Lt. – (0-2062692), Maspeth, N.Y. – Navigator
Sutton, Bill H., Jr., 2 Lt. – (0-780446), Little Rock, Ak. – Bombardier
Tykarsky, Edward B., Sgt. – (13108280), West Alliquippa, Pa. – Flight Engineer
Weible, Kenneth F., Sgt. – (37356037), Chappell, Ne. – Radio Operator
Negrin, Carl, Sgt. – (32823090), Brooklyn, N.Y. – Gunner (Right Waist)
Marko, Andrew, Sgt. – (31409763), Bridgeport, Ct. – Gunner (Left Waist)
Wagers, Harold R., Sgt. – (35872381), College Corner, Oh. – Gunner (Tail)

Two in-flight views of Problem Child (images UPL 17514 and UPL 17515, respectively) from the McCool collection, via the American Air Museum in England

…and the nose art of Problem Child, from the FindAGrave biography of S/Sgt. Harold R. Wagers, contributed by Jap Veermeer.

______________________________

Starr, Irving B., S/Sgt., 32995257, Nose Gunner, Air Medal, Purple Heart
MACR 10764, Luftgaukommando Report KU 3385, Aircraft B-24J 44-40073 (T8 * –  B / ARK ANGEL), Pilot 1 Lt. David N. Bennett, Jr.; 9 crew – no survivors
Mrs. Dora E. Starr (mother), 54 Lott Ave., Brooklyn, 12, N.Y.
Place of Burial unknown
American Jews in World War II – 453

Statement in MACR: “Aircraft came up from High Squadron and joined Lead Squadron after attack by enemy aircraft.  Martin turret was missing and there was large hole in right wing.  Last seen at 1258 hrs losing altitude.  No chutes were seen.”

Crash location:
In Luftgaukommando Report:
1) 3 km south of Oerrie
2) 15 km northwest of Hildesheim
Or, Between Jeinsen and Oerie, 5 km west of Sarstedt

Bennett, David N., Jr., 1 Lt. – (0-686214), Norwood, N.C. – Pilot
Blount, Jessie F., 2 Lt. – (0-710548), Gainesville, Tx. – Co-Pilot
Engel, George B., 2 Lt. – (0-723332), Pittsburgh, Pa. – Navigator
Warford, Norman G., T/Sgt. – (35703424), Frankfort, Ky. – Flight Engineer
Patrick, Peter, Jr., T/Sgt. – (33741746), East Point, Ky. – Radio Operator
Starr, Irving B., S/Sgt. – (32995257), Brooklyn, N.Y. – Gunner (Nose)
Hixson, Charles E., S/Sgt. – (34505462), Cleveland, Tn. – Gunner (Right Waist)
McKee, Raymond O., S/Sgt. – (38199681), East Baton Rouge, La. – Gunner (Left Waist)
Stovall, Henry P., S/Sgt. – (35869219), Beckley, W.V. – Gunner (Tail)

____________________

Here’s Luftgaukommano Report KU 3385.  It closely parallels that for THE FIREBIRD, in that virtually nothing remained of ARK ANGEL for evaluation and salvage.  

____________________

____________________

__________

1 Lt. David N. Bennett, Jr. and his crew, in an image from Ringmasters.  The crewmen are unidentified, but Lt. Bennett, co-pilot Lt. Jessie Blount, navigator Lt. George Engel, and flight engineer T/Sgt. Norman Warford, are probably standing at rear.  (The crew did not fly with a bombardier during the Misburg mission.)  This B-24 bears nose-art inspired by an Albert Vargas pin-up from Esquire.

__________

The Ark Angel, as depicted by artist Mark Rolfe, in Robert F. Dorr’s B-24 Liberator Units of the Eighth Air Force…

A color image of ARK ANGEL (via the American Air Museum in England) taken in the summer of 1944…


__________

The nose art of ARK ANGEL, from Ringmasters…

__________

An in-flight view of ARK ANGEL, also from the 491st Bomb Group website, now accessible via Archive.org’s “Wayback Machine”.  (On this aircraft, oddly, the 491st Bomb Group identification letter – a white “Z” within a black circle, atop the outer right wing – has been painted in reverse.)

__________

The story of the ARK ANGEL presents a mystery…

As is typical for MACRs covering aircraft lost in the European and Mediterranean Theatres of War (those for aircraft and airmen known to have been accounted for and identified by German investigators, which entailed the compilation of Luftgaukommando Reports), ARK ANGEL’s MACR (10764) includes the English-language translation of the above-illustrated Luftgaukommando Report (KU 3385).  This includes documentation for every airman determined or believed to have been aboard the plane.

As such (see above) KU 3385 lists the names of:

Blount, Jessie F., 2 Lt.
Engel, George B., 2 Lt.
Warford, Norman G., T/Sgt.
Patrick, Peter, Jr., T/Sgt.
Starr, Irving B., S/Sgt.
McKee, Raymond O., S/Sgt.

While the names of…

Bennett, David N., Jr., 1 Lt.
Hixson, Charles E., S/Sgt.
Stovall, Henry P., S/Sgt.

…are absent. 

But, one of the “Report of Capture of Member of Enemy Air Forces” forms in KU 3385 lists the name and serial number of a member of the United States Woman’s Army Corps: Her name: Ida Rosenfield, serial A-202639.

Here’s a translation of the above document, from MACR 10764.  

However!…  A check of all relevant historical databases reveals that while an Ida Rosenfield definitely existed and served in the Army (she was born in New York in 1924, and enlisted at Caspar, Wyoming in 1943), she probably never left the continental United States to begin with.

According to records at Ancestry.com, she seems (?) to have been the daughter of Fred and Elizabeth (Di Pillo) Rosenfield (and sister of Estelle, Leon, Nathaniel, Pearl, and Theresa), who owned a store at 2875 Butler Ave., in the Bronx.   

Who was Ida Rosenfield?  How did German investigators discover her name?  Was she the girlfriend or fiancée of a member of ARK ANGEL’s crew – perhaps S/Sgt. Starr, as he was from Brooklyn?  Might he have carried her dog-tag as a sign of friendship, affection, or much more?  I don’t know.  The answer has assuredly been lost to time.  

______________________________

Steinman, Elmer, S/Sgt., 32775794, Tail Gunner, Air Medal, 3 Oak Leaf Clusters, Purple Heart, 32 missions
MACR 10763, Luftgaukommando Report KU 3390, Aircraft B-24H 41-29464 (The Unlimited), Pilot 1 Lt. Charles W. Stevens, 9 crew – 5 survivors
Born 6/7/22, Bayonne, N.J.
Mr. and Mrs. Abraham / Abram (Yudel) [8/8/86-11/8/62] and Anna / “Annie” (Kronitz) [11/18/86-2/28/79] Steinman (parents), 18 Linden Ave., Bayonne, N.J.
Edith and Meyer (brother and sister)
Mount Moriah Cemetery, Fairview, N.J. – Section D03, Section D; Buried 5/29/49
American Jews in World War II – 256

Crash location in Luftgaukommando Report:
1) Hannover / near Huepede
2) 3 km southwest of Pattensen

Stevens, Charles W., Jr., 1 Lt. – (0-811461), Charlotte, N.C. – Pilot (Survived)
Thornburg, Brice E., 1 Lt. – (0-813609), Davidson, N.C. – Co-Pilot (Survived)
McCarty, David W., 1 Lt. – (0-702065), New York, N.Y. – Navigator (Survived)
Boyer, Joseph L., T/Sgt. – (37261239), Mullen, Ne. – Flight Engineer
Dechaine, Joseph P., T/Sgt. – (31215932), Waterville, Me. – Radio Operator (Survived)
Ryan, Troy L., S/Sgt. – (34622806), Balwyn, Ms. – Gunner (Nose)
Shepherd, Elmore W., S/Sgt. – (32755264), Virgilina, Va. – Gunner (Right Waist)
McJimsey, John D., Jr., S/Sgt. – (38387667), Bethany, La. – Gunner (Left Waist) (Survived)
Steinman, Elmer, S/Sgt. – (32775794), Bayonne, N.J. – Gunner (Tail)

Infantry

Brodsky, Milton, Cpl., 32707024, Bronze Star Medal, Purple Heart
United States Army, 821st Tank Destroyer Battalion, B Company
Born 1916
Mrs. Norma Brodsky (wife), 495 Vermont St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Netherlands American Cemetery, Margraten, Holland – Plot C, Row 6, Grave 12
Casualty List 4/3/45
American Jews in World War II – 284

____________________

Feldblum, Charles V., Pvt., 31373724, Purple Heart (Germany)
United States Army, 104th Infantry Division, 414th Infantry Regiment, C Company
Born April 14, 1925
Mr. Harry J. Feldblum (father), #9 Pleasant St., Hillsboro, N.H.
Beth Jacob Cemetery, Concord, N.H.
American Jews in World War II – 224

A photo by FindAGrave contributor bhd, of Pvt. Goldblum’s matzeva, at Beth Jacob Cemetery…

____________________

Gollender, Warren, Pvt., 19132367, Purple Heart (Germany)
United States Army
Mr. and Mrs. Albert and Rae Gollender (parents), Morton (brother), 63-109 Saunders St., Forest Hills, N.Y.
Mount Ararat Cemetery, Farmingdale, N.Y. – Section 25, Range I, Lot 22 (?); Buried 11/23/47
Casualty List 2/17/45
The New York Times (Obituary Section) 11/22/47
American Jews in World War II – 329

Greenblatt, Morris, PFC, 39715208, Purple Heart
United States Army, 35th Infantry Division, 134th Infantry Regiment
Born August 29, 1925
Mrs. Annie Greenblatt (mother), 1467 Canfield Ave., Los Angeles, Ca.
Beth Olam Cemetery of Hollywood, Hollywood Memorial Park Cemetery, Los Angeles, Ca. – Section 14, Row J, Grave 41
Casualty List 2/14/45
American Jews in World War II – 45

Lewis, Leonard Sidney, PFC, 35927001, Purple Heart (France)
United States Army
Born 1919
Mr. and Mrs. Hyman and Sarah Lewis (parents), 290 Parkwood Drive, NE, Cleveland, Oh.
Martin, Sam, Mrs. Lillian L. Jacober, Mrs. Dorothy Rothman, Mrs. Adele Bass, and Mrs. Shirley Friedlander (brothers and sisters)
Mount Olive Cemetery, Cleveland, Oh.
Cleveland Press & Plain Dealer, 1/7/45, 1/8/45, 9/10/48
American Jews in World War II – 493

Merrill, Edwin J., T/4, 35608805, Radio Operator, Purple Heart
United States Army
DNB (“…as a result of injuries incurred in a vehicle accident.”)
Born April 11, 1924
Mr. Ralph Merrill (father), 1368 W. 64th St., Cleveland, Oh.
Arlington National Cemetery, Arlington, Va. – Section 12, Grave 5906
Cleveland Press 1/12/45
American Jews in World War II – 495

______________________________

Sadowsky, Louis M. (Ari bar Moshe Yakov), Pvt., 33847832, Purple Heart (Germany)
United States Army, 5th Armored Division, 47th Armored Infantry Battalion
Born 6/20/14
Mrs. Marian Sadowsky (wife), 249 Atwood St., Pittsburgh, Pa.
Beth Abraham Cemetery, Pittsburgh, Pa.; Matzeva unveiled 9/18/49
Casualty List 3/11/45
Jewish Criterion 9/7/45
American Jewish Outlook 9/9/49, 9/16/49
American Jews in World War II – 548

A photo by FindAGrave contributor Bill Bodkin, of Pvt. Sadowsky’s matzeva, at Beth Abraham Cemetery…

______________________________

Weiler, Arthur, 1 Lt., 0-1054299, Purple Heart
United States Army, 1st Infantry Division, 18th Infantry Regiment
Mrs. Caroline H. Weiler (wife), 1506 West 4th St., Wilmington, De.
Henri-Chapelle American Cemetery, Henri-Chapelle, Belgium – Plot H, Row 6, Grave 49
Jewish Criterion 2/14/45
American Jews in World War II – 74

______________________________

England

Sonenthal, Alfred, WO, 1814140, Wireless Operator
England, Royal Air Force Volunteer Reserve, No. 131 Operational Training Unit
Aircraft: Catalina IVA (PBY-5A) JX252, Pilot Sgt. John Rew, 9 crew – no survivors
As described at Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives, “The crew was scheduled to land on the Lough Erne but due to a visibility reduced by foggy conditions, he misjudged Lake Navar with the Lough Erne.  On approach, the seaplane hit a mountain and disintegrated.  All nine crew members were killed.”  (Data from BAAA.)
Crashed near Ely Lodge, County Fermanagh, Northern Ireland (For additional information, see JoeLoughlin.com)

Crew: (All Royal Air Force)
Sgt. John Rew
F/Sgt. Noel George Edward Ladbrook
Sgt. Bernard Alfred Rosentreter
Sgt. Alfred Sonenthal
W/O Reginald William Shallis

Sgt. David Henry Pidgeon
Sgt. Kenneth Percy West
Sgt. Edmond Thomas Crow
Sgt. James Pringle

Mrs. H. Sonenthal (mother), 37 Garden Road, Dunstable, Beds., England
Enfield (Adath Yisroel) Cemetery, Middlesex, England – Section D, Row 1, Grave 30
The Jewish Chronicle 12/1/44
We Will Remember Them – A Record of the Jews Who Died in the Armed Forces of the Crown 1939 – 1945 – 228

In 2006, a memorial for the crew was visited by Joyce Hotson, fiancée of W/O Shallis, as reported in The Mirror (London).  “CLOSURE: 62 YEARS LATER; EXCLUSIVE Joyce finally gets to grieve WWII airman who crashed on Ulster”  (May 31, 2006)

A photo by FindAGrave contributor DerealJolo, of W/O Sonenthal’s matzeva, at Enfield Cemetery…

______________________________

France

Hertz, Andre (AC-21P-48961) (France, Haut-Rhin, Riesen)
France, Armée de Terre, 152eme Regiment d’Infanterie
Born 1/19/12
Benfeld, Bas-Rhin, France

Mochet, Marcel Louis, Soldat (AC 21 P 93870), Croix de Guerre (France, Territoire de Belfort, Bretagne / Montreaux-Chateau)
France, 21eme Regiment d’Infanterie Coloniale
Born France, Haute-Marne, Charmoy; 6/8/21
“On November 26, 1944, during a reconnaissance patrol on Montreux-Chateau, he was the first to search for a passage.  He crossed a region flooded with water up to his belt.  _____ on the opposite bank, where the enemy was not revealed, he went with a comrade to the first houses of the locality.  He fell gloriously, avoiding by his sacrifice that his group would be caught in an ambush.”
[Le 26 novembre 1944, lors d’une patrouille de reconnaissance sur Montreux-Chateau, s’est mis le premier à l’eau pour rechercher un passage.  A traversé une région inondée avec de l’eau jusqu’à la ceinture.  Parve-un sur la rive opposée où l’ennemi ne se dévoilait pas, s’est porté avec un camarade aux premières maisons de la localité.  Est tombé glorieusement, évitant par son sacrifice que son groupe ne soit pris dans une embuscade.]
Livre d’Or et de Sang – Les Juifs au Combat: Citations 1939-1945 de Bir-Hakeim au Rhin et Danube – 169
Information also at Memorial Gen Web

Mosseri
, Nessim Lionel (AC 21 P 102408) (France, Haut-Rhin, Masevaux)

France , 1ere Groupe de C.D.O.S Legers de France
Born Sannen, Switzerland, 8/31/21

Slomsky, Armand, Second-Maitre, CC8 62 K 12505, Char (Fusilier), Croix de Guerre
France, Régiment Blindé de Fusiliers Marins
Born Moselle, France, 11/15/14
“Disappeared after having commanded his tank; burnt by the enemy’s fire to the last extremity.”
[Disparu aprés avoir commandé jusqu’à la derniére extrémité son char mis en flammes par le feu d l’ennemi.]
Livre d’Or et de Sang – Les Juifs au Combat: Citations 1939-1945 de Bir-Hakeim au Rhin et Danube – 169
Information also at Memorial Gen Web, and, 2ème Division Blindée de Leclerc

______________________________

Soviet Union

Red Army
РККА (Рабоче-крестьянская Красная армия)

Amelkin, Ilya Samoylovich – Lieutenant [Амелькин, Илья Самойлович – Лейтенант]
Infantry (Company Commander)
337th Rifle Division, 1127th Rifle Regiment
Died of wounds
Born 1919, in Saint Petersburg (Leningrad)
Mr. Solomon Mikhaylovich Amelkin (father)
Buried Arad, Rumania

Abramovich, Pavel Fedorovich – Guards Senior Lieutenant [Абрамович, Павел Федорович – Гвардии Старший Лейтенант]
Infantry (Rifle Company Commander)
Lightly wounded in action 6/14/42 (Southern Front, 353rd Rifle Division, 1145th Rifle Regiment)
Killed in action 11/26/44 (4th Guards Army, 41st Guards Rifle Division, 124th Guards Rifle Regiment)
Born 1921, in Dnepopetrovsk
Mrs. Mariya Moiseevna Abramovich (wife)
Buried Lanchok, Hungary

Dumay, Isay Borisovich – Junior Lieutenant [Думай, Исай Борисович – Младший Лейтенант]
Infantry (Mortar Platoon Commander)
113th Rifle Division, 1290th Rifle Regiment, Headquarters
Died of wounds
Born 1925, in Pervomansk, Odessa Oblast
Mrs. Esfir Izrailovna Dumay (wife)
Buried in Yugoslavia (Osevskaya region, Batinsky district)

Grishpun, Shaul Moiseevich – Guards Senior Lieutenant [Гришпун, Шаул Моисеевич – Гвардии Старший Лейтенант]
Infantry (Rifle Platoon Commander)
Wounded 8/25/41 (Southern Front)
Killed in action 11/26/44 (3rd Ukrainian Front, 20th Guards Rifle Division, 6th Autonomous Army Penal Company)
Born 1907, in Mogilev-Podolsk
Mrs. Anna Adolfovna Grinshpun (wife)
Buried in Hungary

Menster, Matvey Efimovich – Guards Lieutenant [Менстер, Матвей Ефимович – Гвардии Лейтенант]
Infantry (Platoon Commander)
228th Rifle Division, 767th Rifle Regiment
Died of wounds at Evacuation Hospital 3332
Born 1918
Mrs. P.P. Menster (wife)
Buried Lithuania (Kaunas district, Upper Shantsy, military cemetery, Grave No. 24A)

Morchik, Ruvik Davidovich – Senior Lieutenant [Морчик, Рувик Давыдович – Старший Лейтенант]
Infantry (Platoon Commander)
43rd Engineer-Sapper Brigade
Killed in action / Died of wounds
Born 1915, in Moscow
Relative – Ekaterina Mikhaylovna Derevyankina
Buried Hungary

Military Air Forces
VVS [Военно-воздушные cилы России – ВВС]

Kleyman (Клейман), Mordko Volfovich (Мордко Вольфович), Technician-Lieutenant [Техник-Лейтенант]
13th Air Army, 203rd Autonomous Corrective Reconnaissance Aviation Regiment [203 ОКРАП [Отдельный Корректировочно-Разведывательный Авиационный Полк]]
Two other crewmen – also killed – were…
Pilot: Lieutenant Vasiliy Pavlovich Kuznetsov (Лейтенант Василий Павлович Кузнецов)
Pilot-Observer: Junior Lieutenant Viktor Vasilevich Sovenko (Младшии Лейтенант Виктор Васильевич Совенко)
Aircraft lost (in accident?) in vicinity of Kirimäe, Estonia
Year and Place of Birth: 1920; city of Odessa
Mr. Volf Mordko Kleyman (father), Vostochnaya Street, city of Samarkand, Uzbekistan
Place of Burial: Estonia

This document is a “List of Irrecoverable Losses” for the 13th Air Army, dated 10 December 1944.  Mordko Kleyman’s crew are listed as #4 (Kuznetsov), #5 (Kleyman), and #6 (Sovenko)…

Prisoners of War

United States Army Air Force

Aschendorf, Irving, F/O, T-127406, Navigator, Air Medal, 1 Oak Leaf Cluster, 12 missions
United States Army Air Force, 8th Air Force, 390th Bomb Group, 568th Bomb Squadron
MACR 11209, Luftgaukommando Reports KU 1160A and KU 3474, Aircraft B-17G 44-6491 (BI * Y / I’ll Be Around), Pilot 2 Lt. Gilbert A. Meyer, 10 crew – all survived
Prisoner of war at Stalag Luft I (Barth, Germany), North Compound 3
Mrs. Joan E. Aschendorf (wife), 1916 Robinson Ave. (or) 1818 Kendall St., Apt. E, Portsmouth, Oh.
Mrs. Francis (Marder) Aschendorf (mother), 1938 Green St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Casualty List (Liberated POW) 6/11/45
The Story of the 390th Bombardment Group (H) – 448
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Some years ago, Mr. Aschendorf kindly shared with me memories of his experiences as a navigator and prisoner of war, as well as documents and photographs.  Some of the latter are shown below…

Irving Aschendorf’s crew, during training in the United States.  The plane is probably B-17G 42-102462, a Flying Fortress assigned throughout the war to various Army Air Force Base Units, which never left the continental United States and finally passed on to Walnut Ridge, Arkansas, in December of 1945. 

Unfortunately, the image does not carry any names (albeit Irving is designated by the “x”), but the men, based on the crew list in MACR 11209 (the plane was lost with a crew of 9, as opposed to the ten men in the photo!), probably were:

Front (L-R)

2 Lt. Gilbert A. Meyer, Pilot
2 Lt. Alfred W. Burkhart, Co-Pilot
2 Lt. Dan W. Finlayson, Bombardier

Rear (L-R)

S/Sgt. Dale T. Westell, Radio Operator
S/Sgt. John L. Bartram, Flight Engineer
Sgt. Raymond W. Maul, Gunner (Ball Turret)
Sgt. Richard W. Kuerten, Gunner (Tail)
Sgt. Aaron E. Mickelson, Gunner (Waist)

__________

Irving.  The chalked “6364” might represent a crew number. 

__________

From KU 3474, here’s the document’s header sheet, listing seven of I’ll be Around’s ten crew members.  

Here’s the English-language translation of KU 3474’s “Report on Captured Aircraft”, covering equipment in I’ll Be Around.  While the data in this report is typical of technical information about American aircraft appearing in Luftgaukommando Reports, some Luftgaukommando Reports are very perfunctory in this regard, while others are vastly more detailed.

__________

This is the English-language translation of the Luftgaukommando Report (KU 1160A) listing Irving’s possessions at the time of his capture.  Note that the information stamped on Irving’s dog-tag (serial number, and symbols for blood-type and religion) has also been recorded.

Here’s the original document, with Irving’s dog-tag still attached.

__________

Irving’s German Prisoner of War Kriegsgefangenenkartel – Prisoner of War [information] card.  Though the card has numerous data entry fields, information in this example is relatively limited.  Significantly, however, it includes two images of Irving (front and profile) taken shortly after his capture – with his German POW number (“6375”) – and thumbprint.

__________

A front photo…

__________

…and an (almost) side photo.  It looks as if Irving has a half-smile: Humor?  Defiance?  Irony?    

__________

Kuptsow, Aaron, 2 Lt., 0-710276, Radar Navigator, Air Medal
United States Army Air Force, 8th Air Force, 398th Bomb Group, 600th Bomb Squadron
MACR 11146, Luftgaukommando Report KU 3375, Aircraft B-17G 42-97740 (“N8 * Q”), Pilot Capt. Gene L. Douglas, 10 crew – all survived
Solitary confinement at Oberursel between 11/28 and 12/24/44.  “To this day [2000], I don’t know if the length of my stay in solitary was because he [interrogator] really wanted that information [about frequency of H2X radar navigation system] or if it was because I was Jewish.”
POW at Stalag Luft I, Barth, Germany
Born 1922
Mrs. Anita L. Kuptsow (wife)
Mr. David Kuptsow (father), 3000 S. Sydenham St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Jewish Exponent 3/23/45
Philadelphia Record 3/9/45
Philadelphia Inquirer and Philadelphia Record 3/12/45, 6/1/45
American Jews in World War II – 534

____________________

Here the crew list in the header sheet for Luftgaukommando Report KU 3375.  

____________________

And, something odd.  A map of Lager Nürnberg Buchenbühl [Nuremberg Buchenbühl Camp] (prison camp?), which somehow became part of KU 3375.  Buildings outlined in dark blue are correlated to the map keygeschäftszimmer” – translating as “business room”.  How, and why, this map was incorporated into KU 3375 (it certainly wasn’t carried aboard N8 * Q!) is a matter of conjecture.    

____________________

But, though the following paper may be surprising, there is no surprise as to why it’s found in KU 3385:  This paper, text almost entirely in Yiddish, is a protective amulet or talisman which was carried by Lt. Kuptsow … perhaps on all his missions?

The “rear” of the paper (the “bottom” sheet, below) bears Aaron’s Hebrew name: אהרן בן דוד בן יהודת, which phonetically is pronounced “Aharon ben Dovid ben Yehúdes”, translating as “Aaron, son of David [his father] son of Yehuda“, Yehuda having been Aaron’s grandfather.

As to the front of the paper (the “top” sheet, above) which bears text arranged in boxes?  An explanation follows, care of scholar and translator Avi Gold:  

The contents are described in the following manner:

1. Above the large rectangle
2. Under the large rectangle
3. Three compartments on the right (a, b, c) with vertical writing
4. Three compartments on the left (a, b, c), also with vertical writing.
5. Three middle compartments (a, b, c) (with horizontal writing)
6. The one remaining thin compartment on the bottom with horizontal writing)

Hebrew Transcription

1. שמירה ; עזרי מעם ד’ עושה שמים וארץ
2. מהרב הצדיק המקובל ר’ משה טייטלבוים אב”ד אוהעל זצוק”ל ע”י נכדו הרה”צ ר’ משה ליפשיץ שליט”א
3a. ד’ ישמר צאתך ובואך
3b. ויעמד פנחס ויפלל ותעצר המגיפה
3c. ושם בת אשר שרח
4a. ד’ ישמרך מכל רע
4b. אבינו מלכנו מנע מגפה מנחלתך
4c. אימא דאברהם אמתלאי בת כרנבו
5a. בזה השער לא יבא צער, בזה הדלת לא יבא בהלת, בזה הפתח לא יבא רצח
5b. רבש”ע כשם שפסחת על בתי בני ישראל במצרים ולא נתת המשחית לבא אל בתיהם, כן תעצור המגפה מעלינו ומעל כל בני ישראל אמן.
5c. דא האט מען שוין געפאקט, געמוזעלט און געשרלכט
6. וישב אהרן אל משה אל פתח אהל מועד ומגפה נעצרה

English Translation

1. Protection (underlined); [under that word] My help is from God, Creator of Heaven and Earth

2. From the Righteous Mystical Rabbi, Rabbi Moshe Teitelboim, [otherwise known as the Yismach Moshe] Chief Judge of the Rabbinical Court of the town of Oyhel by his grandson, the Righteous Rabbi, Rabbi Moshe Lifshitz, Shlita [abbreviation meaning “May he live a long and good life, Amen”]  [Thus, the talisman was presumably transcribed from a talisman authored by Rabbi Teitelboim, the original talisman dating to some time within the late 18th and early 19th centuries.]

3a. May God protect your going out and your coming in

3b. And Phineas stood and prayed, and the plague stopped [a verse from Psalms which refers to an event in the Torah, in the Book of Numbers, where Phineas is credited with stopping a plague which afflicted the Israelites in the desert]

3c. And the name of the daughter of Asher was Serah [Serah, the daughter of Asher, appears in some midrashim as the female parallel to Elijah, and according to midrashic tradition she lived a very long life indeed: She was a young girl when Jacob and his family went down to Egypt, and she was an elderly woman when the Exodus took place centuries later!  Several midrashim say that she was the one who helped Moses find the tomb of Joseph, because she remembered where his sarcophagus had been placed centuries earlier!]

4a. May God protect you from all evil

4b. O our Father, O our King, prevent plague from afflicting Your Land

4c. The mother of Abraham, Amtelai, daughter of Karnevo

5a. Through this gate, no sorrow will enter, through this door no terror will enter, through this entrance no murder will come.  [In Hebrew, the three lines are meant to rhyme.]

5b. Master of the Universe, just as You protected the homes of the Israelites in Egypt and did not allow the destroyer to enter their homes, so too may the plague cease to afflict us and all of Bne Yisrael, Amen!

5c. Here one had already caught / packed (This is Yiddish, rather than Hebrew) 

6. And Aaron returned to Moses to the entrance of the Tent of Meeting, and (the) plague ceased

According to Avi, “Interestingly enough, this protective amulet/talisman speaks of protection against a plague, and causing the plague to cease, and it even has a Pesach connection.”

Avi’s final comment, from early 2021:

May we all see better days soon, and may the plague of authoritarian politicians as well as the plague of the Chinese virus both cease soon!

P.S. Thanks very much, Avi!

____________________

The experiences of Aaron Kuptsow – who was among the Jewish POWs segregated at Stalag Luft I in early 1945 – are recounted in detail at:

Stalag Luft I (“World War II – Prisoners of War – Stalag Luft I ) – A collection of stories, photos, art and information on Stalag Luft I”) incldues Aaron’s story, in his own words.

You can read Robert W. Martin’s interview of Aaron Kuptsow at the website of Clyde D. Willis, radio operator / gunner in the 451st Bomb Squadron, 322nd Bomb Group, 9th Air Force.  (Clyde Willis was shot down and captured during the disastrous mission of the 450th and 452nd Bomb Squadrons to Ijmuiden, Holland, on May 17, 1943; he was one of the 26 survivors of that mission.)

It’s interesting none of these accounts make mention of the presence of this document, particularly in light speculation about the motivation for his month-long solitary confinement before being released to Stalag Luft I.

The Library of Congress Veterans History project’s biographical profile of Aaron Kuptsow includes a half-hour duration audio interview.

Men who were Aaron’s barrack-mates after the segregation of the Jewish POWs at Stalag Luft I were:

Bauman, Mort (2 Lt. Morton Bauman, Bombardier; 506th Bomb Squadron, 44th Bomb Group, 8th Air Force)

Edgar, Richard (2 Lt. Richard Edgar, Navigator; 861st Bomb Squadron, 493rd Bomb Group, 8th Air Force)

Davis, “Bwana” (2 Lt. David Davis, Navigator; 725th Bomb Squadron, 451st Bomb Group, 15th Air Force)

Eskenazi, “Esky” (1 Lt. Jack Eskenazi, Bombardier; 553rd Bomb Squadron, 386th Bomb Group, 9th Air Force)

Finklestein, “Fink” (1 Lt. Frederick G. Finkelstein, Co-Pilot; 331st Bomb Squadron, 94th Bomb Group, 8th Air Force)

Galfunt, “Hap” (2 Lt. Abraham Galfunt, Co-Pilot; 861st Bomb Squadron, 493rd Bomb Group, 8th Air Force)

Kattef, Max (2 Lt. Maxwell Samuel Kateff, Navigator; 863rd Bomb Squadron, 493rd Bomb Group, 8th Air Force)

Labowitz, Jack (2 Lt. Jack Oscar Labovitz, Pilot; 743rd Bomb Squadron, 455th Bomb Group, 15th Air Force)

Oppenheimer, “Oppy” (2 Lt. Alfred Martin Oppenheimer, Bombardier; 578th Bomb Squadron, 392nd Bomb Group, 8th Air Force)

Rubin, Melvin (2 Lt. Melvin Rubin, Co-Pilot; 824th Bomb Squadron, 485th Bomb Group, 15th Air Force)

Safer, Henry (1 Lt. Henry Safer, Bombardier; 429th Bomb Squadron, 2nd Bomb Group, 15th Air Force)

Scheer, Harold (2 Lt. Harold Scheer, Navigator; 359th Bomb Squadron, 303rd Bomb Group, 8th Air Force)

Stovroff, “Russian” (2 Lt. Irwin Joseph Stovroff, Bombardier; 506th Bomb Squadron, 44th Bomb Group, 8th Air Force)

______________________________

8th Air Force, 491st Bomb Group, 853rd Bomb Squadron

Pollak, Harry Hamilton, T/Sgt., 12093803, Radio Operator, Air Medal, 5 Oak Leaf Clusters
MACR 10767, Luftgaukommando Report KU 3368, Aircraft B-24J 42-51530 (Idiot’s Delight), Pilot Capt. Wayne E. Stewart, 10 crew – 5 survivors
Crashed at Annaturm-Deister, 5 kilometers north of Springe
Prisoner of War at Stalag Luft IV (Gross-Tychow, Germany)
Born New York, March 21, 1921;
Mr. Sigmond Pollak (father), 278 Ackerman Ave., Clifton, N.J.
Casualty List (Liberated POW) 6/7/45
Harry Pollak, who served in the States Department as an authority on international labor affairs, died on September, 27, 1980.  His obituary can be found at the Washington Post
American Jews in World War II – 249

Crash location in Luftgaukommando Report:
1) Annaturm
2) Deister, 5 km north of Springe

Stewart, Wayne E., Capt. – (0-811152), Meadow, Ut. – Pilot
Spady, Frank A., Jr., 1 Lt. – (0-815007), Chuckatuck, Va. – Co-Pilot (Survived)
Johnson, Woodrow G., 1 Lt. – (0-702443), Iron River, Mi. – Navigator
Reese, William L., 1 Lt. – (0-703016), Garfield Heights, Oh. – Navigator (Nose)
Valachovic, George A., 1 Lt. – (0-886529), Johnstown, N.Y. – Bombardier (Survived)
Anderson, Laverne G., T/Sgt. – (17154654), Littlefield, Ma. – Flight Engineer
Pollack, Harry H., T/Sgt. – (12093803), Clifton, N.J. – Radio Operator (Survived)
Corona, George H., S/Sgt. – (39122650), San Francisco, Ca. – Gunner (Right Waist)
Mosley, Henry K., Jr., S/Sgt. – (15140725), Arcade, N.Y. – Gunner (Left Waist) (Survived)
Reichenau, Walter W., S/Sgt. – (38366475), Fredericksburg, Tx. – Gunner (Tail) (Survived)

____________________

Rosenfield, Samuel Stanley, S/Sgt., 12075010, Right Waist Gunner, Distinguished Flying Cross, Air Medal, 4 Oak Leaf Clusters, Purple Heart
MACR 10761, Luftgaukommando Report KU 3362, Aircraft B-24J 44-10534, Pilot 1 Lt. Charles J. Ecklund, 9 crew – 8 survivors
Crashed at Rieste, District of Bersenbrueck
Prisoner of War at Stalag Luft IV (Gross-Tychow, Germany) and Stalag Luft I (Barth, Germany) (North Compound 3)
Mr. Frank M. Rosenfield (father), 2067 Mapes Ave., Bronx, N.Y.
Casualty List (Liberated POW) 6/6/45
American Jews in World War II – 419

Crash location in Luftgaukommando Report: Rieste, County of Bersenbrueck


Ecklund, Charles J., 1 Lt. – (0-772320), Harveyville, Ks. – Pilot (Survived)
Strohl, Marvin E., 2 Lt. – (0-720957), Detroit, Mi. – Co-Pilot (Survived)
Vosiepka, George K., 2 Lt. – (0-2056649), Omaha, Ne. – Navigator (Survived)
Simms, Horace R., Jr., 2 Lt. – (0-773343), Oakland, Ca. – Bombardier (Survived)
Guerry, Edward C., T/Sgt. – (39281104), Imperial, Ca. – Flight Engineer (Survived)
Heib, John N., T/Sgt. – (39203497), Seattle, Wa. – Radio Operator
Rosenfield, Samuel S., S/Sgt. – (12075010), New York, N.Y. – Gunner (Right Waist) (Survived)
Johns, Burton A., S/Sgt. – (39290817), Los Angeles, Ca. – Gunner (Left Waist) (Survived)
Cole, Dennis C., S/Sgt. – (16115245), Westby, Wi. – Gunner (Tail) (Survived)

____________________

445th Bomb Group, 703rd Bomb Squadron

Spiegel, Harvey, 2 Lt., 0-834053, Co-Pilot
MACR 11217, Luftgaukommando Report KU 3387, Aircraft B-24J 42-50756 (RN * J), Pilot 2 Lt. Dance W. Snow, 9 crew – all survived
Crashed at Fischbeck / Weser (1 kilometer north of Fischbeck, 6 kilometers northwest of Rinteln)
Prisoner of war at Stalag Luft I (Barth, Germany), North Compound 3
Born April 7, 1924
Mrs. Janice Spiegel (wife), 1739 Dahill Road, Brooklyn, N.Y.
Casualty List (Liberated POW) 6/20/45
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Statement in MACR: “No information has been received about ship # 756.  The four (4) ships flying nearby all failed to return.”

Crash location:
In MACR: 15 miles southeast of Hannover
In Luftgaukommando Report: Fischbeck, 6 km northwest of Rinteln

Snow, Dance W., 2 Lt. – (0-690264), Silver City, N.M. – Pilot (Survived)
Spiegel, Harvey, 2 Lt. – (0-834053), Brooklyn, N.Y. – Co-Pilot (Survived)
Hudson, Robert F., 2 Lt. – (0-2056798), Rochester, N.Y. – Bombardier / Navigator (Survived)
Barbieri, Joseph W., Jr., T/Sgt. – (32781916), Jamaica, N.Y. – Flight Engineer (Survived)
McKim, Ernest M., T/Sgt. – (32905189), Glen Cove, N.Y. – Radio Operator (Survived)
Valore, Biaggio F., Sgt. – (35924434), Cleveland, Oh. – Gunner (Nose) (Survived)
Maronski, Stanley J., Sgt. – (42029120), Angola, N.Y. – Gunner (Waist) (Survived)
Rogers, J.B., S/Sgt. – (38346476), Wheeler, Tx. – Gunner (Waist) (Survived)
Jordan, Robert, Sgt. – (42101534), Upper Montclair, N.J. – Gunner (Tail) (Survived)

From Luftgaukommando Report KU 3387, here’s co-pilot Harvey Spiegel’s wallet-size Identification Card, issued almost three months before the Misburg mission…  

____________________

…and, his New York state driver’s license. 

United States Army

Cromnick, Harry, S/Sgt., 32167040
United States Army, 44th Infantry Division, 71st Infantry Regiment
Prisoner of War at Stalag 3B (Furstenberg, Germany)
Mr. Hyman Cromnick (father), Alex (brother), 120 West 54th St., Bayonne, N.J.
Casualty List (List of Liberated POWs) 6/4/45
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Goldsmith, Clifford H., Pvt., 42050862
United States Army, 34th Infantry Division, 168th Infantry Regiment
Prisoner of War at Stalag 7A (Moosburg, Germany)
Mr. Fred Singer (brother-in-law), 680 West 204th St., New York, N.Y.
Casualty List 4/1/45; List of Liberated POWs 6/21/45
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Greenberg, Sam, Pvt., 33699813
United States Army, 34th Infantry Division, 168th Infantry Regiment
Prisoner of War at Stalag 7A (Moosburg, Germany); German POW # 142238
Mrs. Geraldine R. Greenberg (wife), 43 South Remington Road, Columbus, Oh.
Mr. Paul Greenberg (father), 2328 Sherbrook St., Pittsburgh, Pa.
Employee of Frank and Seder’s Department Store
List of Liberated POWs 6/5/45
Pittsburgh Press 3/21/45
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Ratner, Alvin J., T/5, 32702618
United States Army, 44th Infantry Division, 71st Infantry Regiment
Prisoner of War at Stalag 12A (Limburg an der Lahn, Germany)
Mrs. Sarah Ratner (mother), 85-37 91st St., Woodhaven (Brooklyn?), N.Y.
Lists of Liberated POWs 6/10/45, 6/14/45
Casualty List 4/19/45
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Wounded

Canada

Gilboord, Norman, Gunner, B/18743
Canada, Royal Canadian Artillery
310 Roxton Road, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Canadian Jews in World War II – Part II: Casualties – 98

United States

Etkin, Morris S., Cpl., 33173559, Purple Heart (France)
United States Army
Wounded
Born 1914
Mrs. Gussie R. Etkin (wife), 513 Reed St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Jewish Exponent 3/9/45
Philadelphia Inquirer, Philadelphia Record 2/28/45
American Jews in World War II – 519

Kaiser, Arthur, Pvt., 32000743, Purple Heart (France)
United States Army
Wounded
Born 1913
Mrs. Fannie Kaiser (mother), 307 Fox Hill Place, Exeter, Pa.
Mrs. Esther Burmil (sister), 207 Fox Hill Place, Pittston, Pa.
Originally from New York, N.Y.; Worked at Lee Manufacturing Company, West Pittston, Pa.
Wilkes-Barre Record 1/11/45
American Jews in World War II – 530

Another incident…

Witness to the loss of two B-17s

Tolochko, Joseph S., 2 Lt., 0-820102, Bomber Pilot, Air Medal, 6 Oak Leaf Clusters, 35 missions
United States Army Air Force, 8th Air Force, 398th Bomb Group, 600th Bomb Squadron
Born in Pennsylvania
Mr. and Mrs. M. Leon and Bess Tolochko (parents), Dorothy and Jacob (sister and brother), 5840 Phillips Ave., Pittsburgh, Pa.
Jewish Criterion (Pittsburgh) 2/9/45
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

On 11/26/44, witness to loss of two B-17s:

1) B-17G 43-37846 (“N8 * T”, “Phony Express”), Pilot 1 Lt. Kermit R. Pope, 10 crew – all survived ; MACR 11144, Luftgaukommando Report KU 3371

An image of the wreck of Phony Express (near Velswijk, in the Eastern Netherlands) via the American Air Museum in England, taken by the grandfather of American Air Museum Contributor Fer Radstake… The appearance of the bedraggled wreck (sans engines and armament, with a multitude of holes in the airframe) suggests that the plane had received ample attention from souvenir hunters.

2) B-17G 42-97740 (“N8 * Q”), Pilot Capt. Gene L. Douglas, 10 crew – all survived; MACR 11146, Luftgaukommando Report KU 3375

On 11/30/44, witness to loss of another B-17:

Aircraft 43-38463 (“N8 * X”), Pilot 1 Lt. Roger J. Weum, 10 crew – 7 survivors; MACR 11145

The February 9, 1945 issue of Pittsburgh’s Jewish Criterion, which – as was typical through the war – presented in every issue news about Jewish servicemen from Pittsburgh and the surrounding area.


A news item about Lieutenant Tolochko, whose name never appeared in American Jews in World War II.

Acknowledgement

Special thanks to Avi Gold, for Hebrew and Yiddish scholarship and translation!

References

Books

Abelow, Samuel P., History of Brooklyn Jewry, Scheba Publishing Company, Brooklyn, N.Y., 1937

Caldwell, Don, and Muller, Richard, Luftwaffe Over Germany: Defense of the Reich, Frontline Books, Barnsley, South Yorkshire, England, 2014

Carter, Kit C., and Mueller, Robert, Combat Chronology – U.S. Army Air Forces in World War II, 1941-1945, Center for Air Force History, Washington, D.C., 1991

Chiche, F., Livre d’Or et de Sang – Les Juifs au Combat: Citations 1939-1945 de Bir-Hakeim au Rhin et Danube, Edition Brith Israel, Tunis, Tunisie, 1946

Dorr, Robert F., B-24 Liberator Units of the Eighth Air Force (Osprey Combat Aircraft 15), (Mark Rolfe, Illustrator), Osprey Publishing, Inc., 1999

Dublin, Louis I., and Kohs, Samuel C., American Jews in World War II – The Story of 550,000 Fighters for Freedom – Compiled by the Bureau of War Records of the National Jewish Welfare Board, The Dial Press, New York, N.Y., 1947

Forman, Wallace F., B-24 Nose Art Name Directory, Specialty Press Publishers and Wholesalers, North Branch, Mn., 1996

Freeman, Roger A., The Mighty Eighth – A History of the U.S. 8th Army Air Force, Doubleday and Company, Inc., New York,. N.Y., 1970

Freeman, Roger A., and Osborne, David, The B-17 Flying Fortress Story: Design – Production – History, Arms & Armour Press, London, England, 1998

Kamarainen, Edwin, This Is War and We Are Prisoners of the Enemy, lulu.com, June 5, 2007

Morris, Henry, Edited by Gerald Smith, We Will Remember Them – A Record of the Jews Who Died in the Armed Forces of the Crown 1939 – 1945, Brassey’s, United Kingdom, London, 1989

Rottman, Gordon, US Army Air Force: 1, Osprey Publishing Ltd., London, England, 1993 (with color plates by Francis Chinn)

Other Works

Binghamton Press, February 23, 1945, “Two Binghamton Lieutenants Win New Honors in Battles in Air: Harold Lanning Awarded DFC; Richard Bailey Hits Nazi Plane” (via FultonHistory.com)

Canadian Jews in World War II – Part II: Casualties, Canadian Jewish Congress, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, 1948

The Story of the 390th Bombardment Group (H) (Privately printed for the Men and Officers of the 390th Bombardment Group 1947), 1947

The 491st Bombardment Group (H) Inc., “Ringmasters”: History of the 491st Bombardment Group (H), Taylor Publishing Company, Dallas, Tx., 1992

USAAF Credits for the Destruction of Enemy Aircraft, World War II, USAF Historical Study No. 85, Office of Air Force History, Albert F. Simpson Historical Research Center – Air University, 1985

Websites

Misburg-Anderten, Germany, at Wikipedia

Deurag-Nerag Synthetic Oil Refinery, Germany

Eighth Air Force Historical Society – Missions by Date – November 26, 1944  

Eighth Air Force Historical Society – Mission to Deurag-Nerag Industry Oil Refinery, Misburg, Germany – November 26, 1944

445th Bomb Group – Kassel Mission of September 27, 1944

The Kassel Mission Historical Society

491st Bomb Group

B-24J 42-110167, at B-24 Best Web

Jagdgeschwader 301 History, at Wikipedia

8/25/18

An Unintended Return:  The Tale of S/Sgt. Walter Bonne, a German-Born Jewish Soldier’s Experiences as a Prisoner of War – Aufbau, May 18, 1945

Sometimes, life can be an unintended circle:  You return to the place from which you started or start from a place to which you’ll return.  At least, for a while.    

Such was the case of United States Army Staff Sergeant Walter Bonne, whose experience as a prisoner of war was reported by literary agent and “literatus” (that’s a term new to me!) Kurt Hellmer in the May 18, 1945 issue of Aufbau.  While mainstream in literary style and stylistically akin to postwar accounts of captivity penned about or by many another American Ex-POW – at least, captured in the European Theater of War – S/Sgt. Bonne’s tale is at the same time unusual:  Not only was he a Jew, but he was born in Germany, which in the hindsight of 2021 could be thought to have leant a very fraught dimension to his experiences.  But…  

____________________

In June, 1943, Walter posed for this snapshot at Fort McClellan, Alabama  (From the album of Linda Nachenberg.)

____________________

As for Walter Bonne himself, born in Nurnberg on May 6, 1908, he was one of seven children born to Nathan and Bertha (Stern) Bonne, who passed away in 1933 and 1929, respectively, thus by fate essentially and really being spared the ordeal of surviving in and escaping from Nazi Germany.  Mercifully and thankfully, five of Walter’s six siblings – Alfred, Bella Bernhardine, Felix, and Martin – also survived the war.  However, his older brother Justin Jehuda, born in 1895, died during the influenza epidemic in February of 1919, due to wounds incurred during military service during the First World War.  

Walter sailed from Rotterdam aboard the SS Statendam, arriving in Havana on October 1, 1938.  He reached Miami the following December 6 via the Pan Am Sikorsky S-40 seaplane “Southern Clipper” (NC752V).  In his Declaration of Intention, dated November 29, 1939, he listed his Race as Hebrew and Nationality as German, his last foreign residence as Havana, and, his Occupation as Merchant.  

____________________

From famgus.se, here’s an undated photo of the Southern Clipper, taken at Miami.  

____________________

Walter Bonne’s Draft Card, filed on October 26, 1940, lists his employer as the Greta Restaurant, at 112 Central Park South in Manhattan, consistent with his work in the hospitality business, as described in Aufbau.  The “Name of Person Who Will Always Know Your Address” was his brother Martin, at 287 Ocean Avenue in Brooklyn.   

____________________

From Apartments.com, here’s an undated – but I guess recent! – photo of 112 Central Park South, the building appearing in the center of the photo.

____________________

According to NARA’s World War II Army Enlistment Records database, Walter enlisted in the Army on March 11, 1943, in Manhattan, his serial number being 32860314.  Eventually, he was assigned to the 54th Armored Infantry Battalion of the 10th Armored Division.  Captured during the Ardennes Offensive on December 17, 1944, he was first interned at Stalag 9B (Bad Orb), and then Stalag 9A (Ziegenhain), the latter probably commencing in February of 1945.  Liberated from that POW camp on March 28, 1945, he was flown to Camp Lucky Strike, at Le Havre, France, on April 9.  And from there, he returned to the United States.  

Along with Kurt Hellmer’s Aufbau article of May 18, Staff Sergeant Bonne’s name appeared in that newspaper on April 27, while his name was published in an Official Casualty list – under the very apropos heading “Liberated Prisoners” – in The New York Times on May 5, 1945.  There, rather than his brother Martin, his next of kin is listed as his wife Genia, who resided at 535 West 111th Street in Manhattan.  His name never appeared in the book American Jews in World War Two.  The absence of his name from this reference work is not unusual, since a soldier’s status as a returned POW – per se – was not specifically a criteria for inclusion in the book.  

Walter Bonne passed away on November 3, 200, while Genia (born Genia Eisenstaedter), born on November 3, 1917, died on May 24 of the same year. 

Some twenty images of the Bonne family can be found at Geni.com, where the three photographs below (and the one above, of Walter as a soldier!) were found.  

______________________________________

Dated 1927 and taken in Nuremberg, this photo shows Martin (left) and Walter.  The lady’s name is unknown.  (From the album of Linda Nachenberg.)

____________________

Walter, probably photographed in Gemany.  (From the Bonne Family album, via Nurit Bertha Gillath)

____________________

Passenger list for the SS Statendam, date October, 1938.  Walter’s name is the third entry.  

____________________

Walter’s Declaration of Intention, of November, 1939.

____________________

Walter’s Draft Card.

________________________________________

And so, Kurt Hellmer’s article.  The German text of the article follows these two images, and in turn is followed by an English-language translation.

Interestingly, the article does not address a central question about Walter Bonne’s experiences as a prisoner of war:  Did he personally experience any repercussions from his captors upon capture and interrogation (even if his interrogation was only cursory) or later, given that he was a Jew, born in Germany?  Since this topic is unmentioned, there are three possible answers:  1) This didn’t happen.  2) If he did experience any mistreatment, he didn’t wish to dwell upon the subject.  3) He didn’t deem the subject of sufficient importance for discussion with Kurt Hellmer.  Well, some questions will have to remain unanswered.

In a larger sense, the article alludes to an event that received little serious focus until the 1990s, though it received nominal attention in the news media as early as the summer of 1945: The segregation of Jewish POWs at Stalag 9B, as a preliminary step towards the “transport” of 350 American POWS to the slave labor camp at Berga-am-Elster.  Hellmer’s article states, “There were special barracks for Jewish prisoners of war, against which the Americans successfully protested.”  Though S/Sgt. Bonne probably believed and hoped this was so, it was not:  There was no collective protest, let alone a successful one, over the segregation of the Jewish POWs at Stalag 9B. 

And so, on to Bonne’s story…

In Deutschland kriegsgefangen
Die Erlebnisse des Sgt. Bonne – Von KURT HELLMER

Aufbau
May 18, 1945

Die Nichteinhaltung den Genfer-Konvention durch die Deutschen ist heute eine notorische Tatsache.  Schon seit langem haben wir hier an dieser Stelle auf diesen Skandal hingewiesen und ihm die korrekte Beachtung der Bestimmungen, wie sie von den amerikanischen Behörden durchgeführt werden, gegenübergestellt.  Leider ist man heute jedoch nur allzu leicht geneigt, rasch abgestumpft zu werden und neuen Nachrichten über die Verletzung der Genfer-Konvention die nötige Aufmerksamkeit zu versagen.  Das liegt an der Schnellebigkeit unserer Zeit; die Ereignisse überschlagen sich, die Eindrücke konkurrieren miteinander.  Das Ende des Krieges in Europe scheint alles überholt zu haben.  Was gestern noch die Gemüter erregt hat, ist heute schon so verblasst, als wäre es nie gesch_hen.

Diese Einstellung ist nicht ungefährlich.  Denn wenn man die Entwicklung, die heute in der Welt von sich geht, beeinflussen, wenn man zu dem gewaltigen Aufbau Europas beitragen und wenn man den von den Deutschen in Europa Unterdrückten das bringen will, was sie von ihren Befreiern erwarten, nämlich Gerechtigkeit, dann muss man allen neuen Nachrichten aus Deutschland das richtige Gewicht geben.  Dann, und nur dann, wind es möglich sein, gerecht zu handeln.

Die Erlebnisse des S/Sgt. Walter Bonne, eines in Nürnberg gebürtigen amerikanischen Soldaten, der jetzt aus deutscher Gefangenschaft nach New York zurückgekehrt ist, sprechen für sich.  Man braucht sie nicht weiter zu kommentieren.  Aber man muss immer wieder darauf hinweisen, mit welcher darauf hinweisen, mit welcher Bewusstheit die Deutschen die Genfer Konvention gebrochen haben.  Man muss betonen, dass es sich hier nicht um sogenannte Einzelaktionen sogenannter unverantwortlicher Nazis handelt, sondern um die von der deutschen Wehrmacht planmässig durchgeführte Missachtung der in der Genfer Konvention enthaltenen Bestimmungen.  Die deutsche Armee und ihr Generalstab können sich nicht darauf ausreden, dass die Nazis sie zu diesem Bruch veranlasst haben.  Der Generalstab, der jetzt den Zusammenbruch Nazi-Deutschlands zu überleben scheint, ist dafür verantwortlich.  Er gehört ebenso in die Reihe der Kriegsverbrecher wie die Nazis, die sich an deutschen und ausländischen Zivilisten vergangen haben.

In knappen Zügen sind das die Erlebnisse – von S/Sgt. Bonne und tausender anderer amerikanischer Kriegsgefangener in Deutschland:

Die Gefangennahme

Es war acht Uhr abends am Sonntag, den 17 Dezember 1944 als S/Sgt. Walter Bonne zusammen mit 60 seiner Kameraden im Keller eines Hauses in dem luxemburgischen Kurort Clervaux bei Bastogne von den Deutschen gefangen genommen wurde.  Zwei Tage schon hatte schweres Artilleriefeuer getobt; am Sonntag morgen hatten die Deutschen die Amerikaner in dem Ort emgekreist.  Ein Entkommen war nicht moglich: Widerstand gegen den zahlenmässig überlegenen Feind sinnlos.

Mit wurfbereiten Granaten in der Hand kamen einige Deutsche die Kellertreppe herunter und befahlen den Amerikanern, nach oben zu kommen.  Die Deutschen “beschlagnahmten” nicht nun ihre Jeeps, sondern auch ihre Füllfederhalter, Zigaretten, Süssigkeiten, ihre Reisesäcke, Mäntel, Unterwäsche und Toiletteartikel.  Dann pferchten sie die Gefangenen in ein Zimmer ein, das so klein war, dass sie die Nacht stehend verbringen mussten.…

Fünf Tagemärsche

Am Montag früh mussten die Gefangenen losmarschieren.  Den ganzen Tag, ohne Unterbrechung.  Spät abends wurden sie in einer Kegelbahn einquartiert, in der sie die Nacht sitzend zubringen mussten, da zum Liegen kein Platz war.

Am Dienstag kamen die Gefangenen spät abends in einem kleinen Ort in der Eiffel an.  Die Deutschen hatten beschlossen, sie die Nacht — mitten im Dezember! — im Freien verbringen zu lassen.  Die Gruppe, die inzwischen auf 1200 Gefangene angewachsen war, Offiziere und Mannschaften, protestierte.  Man öffnete ihnen die Kirche und gab ihnen zu essen — zum ersten Male nach 72 Stunden schweren Marschierens!  Jeder bekam ein Drittel Laib Brot, einen Löffel Rübenmarmelade und nichts zu trinken, nicht einmal Wasser.

Die Dorfbewohner sahen recht deprimiert drein und manche gaben den Amerikanern heimlich das “V”-Zeichen mit den Fingern. . . .

Inzwischen hatte es zu schneien begonnen und es wurde kälter und kälter.  In der Kirche war es kalt und das Liegen auf dem Steinboden, noch dazu ohne Decke, kein Vergnügen.

Nach einem weiteren Tagesmarsch am Mittwoch wurden die Gefangenen wiederum in einer Kirche untergebracht.  Diesmal erhielten sie eine Tasse Kaffee und nichts zu essen.  Am Donnerstag wurde der Marsch fortgesetzt; spät nachts wurden die Gefangenen in einem Eisenbahnschuppen einquartiert, der so klein war, dass die 1200 Mann stehend schlafen mussten.  Am nächsten Tag, dem fünften Tag seit den Gefangennahme, erreichten die Amerikaner Gerolstein am Nachmittag, wo jeder einen halben Laib trockenes Brot bekam.  Für Getränke waren sie auf Bäche, Brunnen, Schnee und Eis angewiesen.

Im Güterzug

In Gerolstein wurden die Gefangenen in einen Güterzug verfrachtet, je 50 bis 60 Mann in einen Viehwagen mit Stroh und Pferdedreck auf dem Boden.  Die Deutschen schlossen sie ein und machten die nächsten drei Nächte und vier Tage nicht wieder auf.  Ihre Bedürfnisse mussten sie in ihre Helme verrichten und diese durch die kleinen Fenster ausleeren — dieselben Helme, in denen sie auf den Bahnhöfen Wasser fassen mussten.

Auf der Reise wurde der Zug von allierten Bombern beschossen, denn er war nicht als Kriegsgefangenen zug markiert.  Ein Amerikaner wurde bei einem Fluchtversuch niedergeknallt; ein anderer so schwer verletzt, dass er 16 Stunden später, während der Fahrt, gestorben ist.

Ankunft in Bad Orb

Am vierten Tag um 4 Uhr früh erhielten die Gefangenen je ein Drittel Laib Brot und eine Büchse Corned Beef für 15 Mann.  Am Nachmittag kamen sie in Bad Orb an und erhielten die erste warme Mahlzeit: einen Liter Suppe.  Von nun an war ihr tägliches “Menü”: zum Frühstück schwarzer Tee ohne Zucker oder Milch, mittags ein Liter Rüben- oder Gemüsesuppe mit ein paar Gramm Hundeoder Pferdefleisch, und abends etwas Brot mit Margarine und wieder ein halber Liter von dem sogenannten Tee.

Das Lager war die vielen aus ihrer in Deutschland verbrachten Jugend bekannte “Wegscheide”.  Hier gab es Sonderbaracken für jüdische Kriegsgefangene, gegen die die Amerikaner mit Erfolg protestierten.  Die Baracken waren aus Holz und für je 140 Mann bestimmt.  Jetzt waren je 250 in einer Baracke untergebracht und zwei mussten auf einer Matratze schlafen.

In Bad Orb blühte der tollste Tauschhandel.  Für eine herrliche Armbanduhr, die $60 wert war, bekam man zwei Stück Brot und 20 Zigaretten.  Ein erstklassiger Füllfederhalter brachte drei Zigaretten oder ein Drittel Laib Brot.  Ein Päckchen Zigaretten kostete $40.

Stalag 9-A

Ungefähr einen Monat nach der Ankunft in Bad Orb wunden die amerikanischen Kriegsgefangenen in Güterwagen nach Stalag 9-A in Ziegenhain gebracht.  Während der Nachtfahrt herrschte ein schneidender Schneesturm und vielen Soldaten erfroren die Füsse.

In Ziegenhain war die Situation etwas besser, denn die Deutschen hatten das Lager, in dem sich noch rund 20,000 Franzosen, Belgier, Russen und Engländer befanden, gründlicher organisiert.  Ausserdem traf S/Sgt. Bonne dort 120 Palästinenser, darunter sehr viele in Deutschland Geborene, die in Griechenland gefangen genommen wurden und zuerst in einem Lager in Schlesien waren, bis die Deutschen sie von dort vor den Russen “in Sicherheit “ brachten.  Ihr Führer war ein Sgt.  Friedlein, der aus Köln stammte.

Die Verpflegung war ungefähr dieselbe wie in Bad Orb, aber nach einem Monat wurden die täglichen Rationen auf ein Siebentel Laib Brot, ¾ Liter Suppe und 1/4 Liter Tee gekürzt.  Alle Gefangenen verloren an Gewicht und sahen wie Skelette aus; das Krankenhaus war überfüllt.

Einmal wurde Ziegenhain, das nicht als Kriegsgefangenenlager markiert war, von den Amerikaner bombardiert, wobei elf Franzosen getötet und 35 verwundet wurden.  Ein anderes Mal zwangen die Deutschen die Amerikaner, eine bombardierte Eisenbahnstrecke drei Tage und drei Nächte lang zu reparieren.

Die Deutschen versuchten die Amerikaner auch propagandistisch zu beeinflussen und verteilten eine englische Uebersetzung von “Mein Kampf” und viele andere Bücher hauptsächlich antisemitischen Inhalts.

Theater!  Theater!

Inzwischen ging der Krieg gut vorwärts.  Der Rheinübergang hob die Stimmung der Gefangenen und jeder machte Prognosen über die voraussichtliche Dauer des Krieges.  Die Gefangenen erhielten ihre Nachrichten nicht nur durch den amtlichen deutschen Heeresbericht, sondern vor allem von “Kommando-Arbeitern”, jenen Kriegsgefangenen, die zur Arbeit das Lager verliessen und die sie von Zivilisten erfuhren, die das BBC hörten.

Da wurden plötzlich Gerüchte über einen baldigen Abtransport der Gefangenen laut.  Die Deutschen wollten die Gefangenen weiter ins Land schaffen, um ihre Befreiung durch die vorrückenden Alliierten zu verhindern.  Am 27. März war die Front nur mehr 21 Meilen von Ziegenhain entfernt; am nächsten Morgen, um 5 Uhr sollten alle Gefangenen zu einem neuen Bestimmungsort abmarschieren.

Während der ganzen Nacht hielten die Gefangenen Versammlungen ab.  Die phantastischsten Fluchtpläne und Vorschläge, wie man sich im Lager verstecken könnte, wurden gemacht und zum Teil auch ausgeführt.  Der amerikanische Lagerführer gab jedoch den Befehl, alles solange als möglich hinauszuschieben – mit anderen Worten: am nächsten Morgen den Kranken und Schwachen zu spielen.  Das war für die meisten Gefangenen ohnehin leicht genug.

Beim Appell traten die Amerikaner auf dem Fussballplatz an.  Es begann zu regnen.  Die Jungens wurden ohnmächtig, zwölf in einer Sekunde.  Innerhalb einer halben Stunde lagen 3-400 Mann auf dem Boden, stöhnten, ächzten und vollbrachten eine so ausgezeichnete Vorstellung, dass die Deutschen sich entschliessen mussten, den Amerikanern die Rückkehr in ihre Baracken zu erlauben, bis sie für einen Transport mit Lastwagen oder Eisenbahn sorgen konnten.

Die Amerikaner hatten ihr erstes Ziel erreicht: einen Aufschub um 12-15 Stunden.  Während die anderen Gefangenen aus dem Lager abmarschierten, lagen die Amerikaner in ihren Betten und sahen aus, als wären sie bereits gestorben.  Die Deutschen hatten irgend einem Hauptquartier telefoniert; um 2 Uhr kam der Befehl, dass 250 Amerikaner ausmarschieren mussten und die übrigen 1000 im Lager warten konnten.

Die Befreiung

In der Zwischenzeit hatten sich jedoch viele der deutschen Wachen selbst aus dem Staub gemacht und so blieben auch die 250 Amerikaner in Ziegenhain.  Die Amerikaner übernahmen das Lager und waren theoretisch frei.  Es war Sederabend und die Juden unter ihnen veranstalteten einen Dankgottesdienst.

Aber noch waren die Alliierten nicht in Sicht.  S/Sgt. Bonne setzte sich auf ein Fahrrad, fuhr zur Hauptstrasse und wartete, bis die ersten Alliierten kamen.  Es waren amerikanische Tanks, die aber nicht nach Ziegenhain fuhren, sondern geradeaus weiter.  Damit lag Ziegenhain im besetzten Gebiet.

Ziegenhain wurde nun ein deutsches Kriegsgefangenenlager.  Tausend deutsche Soldaten wurden eingeliefert, und die bekamen von den Amerikanern nicht mehr zu essen als diese vorher von den Deutschen erhielten.  Und auch sie mussten eine Nacht im Freien schlafen, genau wie ihre Kameraden es vorher mit den Amerikanern getan hatten.

Die Frauen von Allendorf

In den zwölf Tagen, in denen die bisherigen amerikanischen Kriegsgefangenen auf Ablösung warteten, kamen auch die vielen hundert Frauen, die im Juni 1944 von den Deutschen aus Ungarn nach Allendorf bei Marburg gebracht worden waren, nach Ziegenhain.  (Mit der Veröffentlichung ihrer Namen haben wir im vorigen “Aufbau” begonnen!)  Es waren nur Frauen zwischen 15 und 50 Jahren.  Sie berichteten, dass sie zusammen mit Mädchen unter 15 Jahren und Flauen über 50 Jahren deportiert worden waren, aber bei ihrer Ankunft in Deutschland von den zu jungen und den zu alten getrennt wurden.  Diese wurden als “arbeitsunfähig” bezeichnet und “vernichtet” — verbrannt.  Die Ueberlebenden mussten in einer Munitionsfabrik arbeiten…

Happy End

Am 9, April wurden S/Sgt. Bonne und seine Kameraden nach Le Havre geflogen, wo alle in dem Riesenlager Lucky Strike neu eingekleidet wurden.  Nach einem für alle GI’s obligaten Ausflug nach Paris wurden sie per Schiff nach Amerika zurückgebracht, wo sie einen 60tägigen Urlaub erhielten, nach dem sie neue Aufgaben zugewiesen bekommen — sofern sie nicht 85 Punkte erreichen und entlassen werden.

Für S/Sgt. Bonne, der bis zu seinem Einrücken in die Armee vor zwei Jahren in der Hotelbranche tätig war und der an den Kämpfen in der Normandie, in der Bretagne und in Luxemburg teilnahm, der über 30,000 deutsche Kriegsgefangene interviewte, der zeitweise zu den berühmten “Ghost Riders” von General Patton gehörte und der einmal von einer Landmine verwundet und mit dem Purple Heart ausgezeichnet wurde, war der schwärzeste Traum seines Lebens zu Ende.

____________________

A Prisoner of War in Germany
The Adventures of Sgt. Bonne – by KURT HELLMER

Aufbau
May 18, 1945

Non-compliance with the Geneva Convention by the Germans is today a notorious fact.  For a long time now we have referred to this scandal on this point and compared it with the correct observance of the provisions, as they are carried out by the American authorities.  Unfortunately, today one is now all to prone to be quickly jaded and to refuse to pay attention to news about the violation of the Geneva Convention.  That’s because of the fast pace of our time; events turn over; impressions compete with each other.  The end of the war in Europe seems to have overtaken everything.  What excited people’s minds yesterday has already faded as if it had never happened.

This attitude is not safe.  For if you influence the development that is taking place in the world today; if you contribute to the enormous reconstruction of Europe, and if you want to bring to the Germans what the oppressed of Europe expect from their liberators, namely justice, then you have to give all the new news from Germany the proper weight.  Then, and only then, will it be possible to act righteously.

The experiences of S/Sgt. Walter Bonne, an American soldier born in Nuremberg, who has now returned to New York from German captivity, speak for themselves.  You do not need to comment further.  But one must always point out, point out with which, with what awareness the Germans have broken the Geneva Convention.  It must be emphasized that these are not so-called individual actions of so-called irresponsible Nazis, but disregard of the provisions contained in the Geneva Convention as planned by the German Wehrmacht.  The German army and its general staff cannot be persuaded that the Nazis have led them to this breach.  The General Staff, which now seems to survive the collapse of Nazi Germany, is responsible.  It belongs as much in the line of war criminals as the Nazis, who have passed onto German and foreign civilians.

In a nutshell these are the experiences – from S/Sgt. Bonne and thousands of other American prisoners of war in Germany:

The Capture

It was eight o’clock in the evening on Sunday, December 17, 1944, as S/Sgt. Walter Bonne, along with 60 of his comrades, was captured by the Germans in the basement of a house in the Luxembourg spa town of Clervaux near Bastogne.  Heavy artillery fire had already raged two days; on Sunday morning, the Germans had encircled the Americans in the place.  An escape was not possible: resistance against the numerically superior enemy meaningless.

With grenades in hand, some Germans came down the basement stairs and ordered the Americans to come upstairs.  The Germans did not “confiscate” only their jeeps, but also their fountain pens, cigarettes, sweets, their travel bags, coats, underwear and toiletries.  Then they put the prisoners in a room that was so small that they had to spend the night standing…

Five-Day March

The prisoners had to march on Monday morning.  The whole day, without interruption.  Late in the evening they were quartered in a bowling alley, where they had to spend the night sitting, as there was no room to lie down.

On Tuesday, the prisoners arrived late at night in a small town in the Eiffel.  The Germans had decided to take them the night – in the middle of December! – to spend outdoors.  The group, which had now grown to 1200 prisoners, officers and men, protested.  They opened the church for them and gave them food – for the first time after 72 hours of heavy marching!  Everyone got a third of a loaf of bread, a spoonful of beet jam and nothing to drink, not even water.

The villagers looked quite downcast and some secretly gave the Americans the “V” sign with their fingers.

It had begun to snow and it was getting colder and colder.  It was cold in the church and lying on the stone floor, with no ceiling, no enjoyment.

After another day’s march on Wednesday, the prisoners were again housed in a church.  This time they got a cup of coffee and nothing to eat.  On Thursday, the march continued; late at night, the prisoners were quartered in a train shed so small that the 1,200 men had to sleep standing.  The next day, the fifth day since capture, the Americans reached Gerolstein in the afternoon, where everyone got half a loaf of dry bread.  For drinks they were dependent on streams, wells, snow and ice.

In the Freight Train

In Gerolstein, the prisoners were shipped into a freight train, 50 to 60 men each in a cattle car with straw and horse dung on the ground.  The Germans locked them in and did not rejoin them for the next three nights and four days.  They had to put their needs in their helmets and empty them through the small windows – the same helmets they had to hold water at the stations.

On the trip, the train was bombarded by allied bombers, because it was not marked as for prisoners of war.  An American was crushed during an escape attempt; another injured so badly that he died 16 hours later, on the journey.

Arrival in Bad Orb

On the fourth day at 4 o’clock in the morning, the prisoners received one third of loaf of bread and one box of corned beef for fifteen men.  In the afternoon they arrived in Bad Orb and received the first warm meal: a liter of soup.  From now on their daily “menu” was: for breakfast black tea without sugar or milk, for lunch a liter of beet or vegetable soup with a few grams of dog or horsemeat, and in the evening some bread with margarine and again half a liter of the so-called tea.

The camp was known by many from their spent in Germany youth as “Wegscheide”.  There were special barracks for Jewish prisoners of war, against which the Americans successfully protested.  The barracks were made of wood and intended for each 140 men.  Now 250 were each housed in a barrack and two had to sleep on a mattress.

In Bad Orb the greatest barter flourished.  For a splendid wristwatch that was worth $60, you got two pieces of bread and twenty cigarettes.  A first-class fountain pen brought three cigarettes or a third of loaf of bread.  A packet of cigarettes cost $40.

Stalag 9-A

About a month after arriving in Bad Orb, American prisoners of war were brought in freight cars to Stalag 9-A in Ziegenhain.  During the night driving there was a cutting blizzard and many soldiers froze their feet.

In Ziegenhain the situation was a little better, for the Germans had organized the camp, in which there were still around 20,000 French, Belgians, Russians and English, more thoroughly.  In addition, S/Sgt. Bonne met with 120 Palestinians, including many born in Germany, who were captured in Greece and were first in a camp in Silesia until the Germans brought them from there before the Russians “to safety”.  Their leader was a Sgt. Friedlein, who came from Cologne. [This man was probably Sergeant James Friedland, PAL/10165.]

The food was about the same as in Bad Orb, but after a month, the daily rations were cut to a seventh of loaf of bread, ¾ liter of soup and 1/4 liter of tea.  All prisoners lost weight and looked like skeletons; the hospital was overcrowded.

Once, Ziegenhain, which was not marked as a POW camp, was bombed by the Americans, killing eleven Frenchmen and wounding 35.  On another occasion, the Germans forced the Americans to repair a bombed railway line for three days and three nights.

The Germans also tried to influence the Americans propagandistically and distributed an English translation of “Mein Kampf” and many other books mainly of anti-Semitic content.

Theater!  Theater!

Meanwhile the war went well.  The crossing of the Rhine raised the mood of the prisoners and each made predictions about the probable duration of the war.  The prisoners received their news not only through the official German army report, but above all from “commanders”, those prisoners of war who left the camp for work, and who learned about them from civilians who heard the BBC.

There were suddenly rumors of a speedy removal of the prisoners.  The Germans wanted to bring the prisoners further into the country to prevent their liberation by the advancing Allies.  On March 27, the front was only 21 miles from Ziegenhain; the next morning, at 5 o’clock, all the prisoners were to march off to a new destination.

Throughout the night, the prisoners held meetings.  The most fantastic escape plans and suggestions on how to hide in the camp were made and partly executed.  However, the American camp leader gave the order to postpone everything as long as possible – in other words, to play the sick and weak the next morning.  That was easy enough for most prisoners anyway.

At the roll-call, the Americans appeared on the football field.  It began to rain.  The boys fainted, twelve in a second.  Within half an hour, 3-400 men were lying on the ground groaning, groaning, and accomplished such an excellent performance that the Germans had to decide to allow the Americans to return to their barracks until they could arrange for transport by truck or train.

As the other prisoners marched out of the camp, the Americans lay in their beds looking as if they had already died.  The Germans had phoned some headquarters; at 2 o’clock came the order that 250 Americans had to march out and the remaining 1000 could wait in the camp.

Liberation

In the meantime, however, many of the German guards had made themselves off as dust and so there were 250 Americans in Ziegenhain.  The Americans took over the camp and were theoretically free.  It was Seder evening and the Jews among them organized a thanksgiving service.

But still the Allies were not in sight.  S/Sgt. Bonne sat on a bicycle, drove to the main road and waited until the first Allies came.  They were American tanks, but they did not go to Ziegenhain, but straight on.  So Ziegenhain was located in the occupied territory.

Ziegenhain was now a German prisoner of war camp.  Thousands of German soldiers were taken in and they did not get to eat from the Americans any more than they had received from the Germans before.  And they, too, had to sleep one night in the open, just as their comrades had previously done to the Americans.

The Women of Allendorf

During the twelve days, in which the American prisoners of war were waiting to be removed, hundreds of women who in June 1944 had been brought by the Germans from Hungary to Allendorf near Marburg, arrived in Ziegenhain.  (We started with the publication of their names in the previous “Aufbau”!)  They were only women between 15 and 50 years.  They reported that they had been deported together with girls under the age of fifteen and fifty over 50 years, but were separated from the young and the old on arrival in Germany.  These were called “incapacitated” and “destroyed” – burned.  The survivors had to work in an ammunition factory…

Happy Ending

On April 9, S/Sgt. Bonne and his comrades flew to Le Havre, where everyone was newly dressed in the giant camp Lucky Strike.  After an obligatory trip to Paris for all GIs, they were taken back to America by ship, where they received a 60-day holiday, after which they were given new assignments – unless they reached 85 points and were dismissed.

For S/Sgt. Bonne, who worked in the hotel industry two years ago until joining the army and who participated in the battles in Normandy, Brittany and Luxembourg, who interviewed over 30,000 German prisoners of war, who at one time belonged to the famous “Ghost Riders” of General Patton and was once wounded by a land mine and awarded the Purple Heart, the blackest dream of his life was over.

____________________

The war is (long!) over:  Walter and Genia in 1985. 

References

Walter Bonne, at…

…Biography, at geni.com

…Photos, at geni.com

Kurt Hellmer, at…

Wikipedia

 Serial numbers of WW II US Army enlisted personnel, at…

Electronic Army Serial Number Merged File

Sikorsky S-40 Flying Boat, at…

… Wikipedia

…and…

Pan American Airways – The Flying Clipper Ships

110-112 Central Park South, at…

Apartments.com

Plus, a book!

Prisoners of War – Armies and Other Land Forces of The British Empire, 1939-1945 (“All Lists Corrected Generally Up to 30th March 1945″), J.B. Hayward & Son, in Association with The Imperial War Museum Department of Printed Books, Polstead, Suffolk, England, 1990 (First published in 1945 by His Majesty’s Stationary Office)

A Question At War: “Shall I Not Fight For the Rights of the Jews?”

“I FIGHT not so much because of Pearl Harbor,
but because of what Pearl Harbor meant, because,
dually after skirmishes with the Ethiopians,
the Manchurians,
the Chinese,
the Austrians,
the Czechoslovakians,
the Danes,
the Spaniards,
and the Norwegians,
fascism was menacing us as we had never before been menaced,
because only the craven will not defend themselves.”

——————–

“I fight to remain free.”

– Corporal Jack J. Zurofsky, May, 1944

____________________
____________________
____________________

“As an American,
I am aware of the fact that in relation to the Zionist movement,
some persons, undoubtedly sincere,
have raised the question of dual allegiance.
They ask how I,
as an American,
can take a great interest in the Jewish people and in Palestine.
To that my answer is quite simple.
I as a soldier am at present fighting for the rights of the French,
the Russians,
the English,
the Poles,
the Czechs,
the Yugoslavs,
etc.,
that they too may have a chance for “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.”

——————–

“Shall I not fight for the rights of the Jews?”

– Corporal Ben Weiner, September, 1943

________________________________________

A central and natural facet of human behavior – of men and groups; of men in groups – is aggression: Whether in terms of the emotional frisson generated by the random (and, not-at-all-so-random) violence of mobs; as cool self-defense and its mirror image in pacifism; by the calculated choreography of military offensives and defensives.  Well, given the constancy of human nature, the need to understand the origins, nature, and often the dire necessity of aggression – whether understood through accounts of history, legend, or myth; whether viewed through the contemporary lenses of religion and science – will ever remain, regardless of changes in military technology or the changing fortunes or men and nations. 

But, while the nature of what motivates aggression – what prompts men to fight – can also be approached from the vantage points of psychology, sociology, and politics, on occasion we can find at least an explanation of aggression that is as profound as it is simple:  The intersection between a man’s values and priorities; his beliefs and ideals, with his sense of justice.

In this context, during 1943 and 1944, two American Jewish soldiers – Ben Weiner (residence unknown), and Jack Zurofsky of Brooklyn – both Corporals who’d served in the ground forces of the United States Army in the North African Theater of War – addressed this question in essays that were strikingly different in the nature of their arguments and literary style.  Their writings offer a glimpse of the self-perception of American Jews during the Second World War, in terms of their identity as Americans, Jews, and, American Jews, in a way that continues to have resonance over seventy-five years later, in this year of 2020.

____________________

The “first” essay, “We Fight For The Jew, Too”, penned by Weiner, was published in The Jewish Times (Baltimore) and Jewish Advocate (Boston) on Friday, September 24, and Thursday, December 16, 1943, respectively.  I’ve not been able to find anything “about” Corporal Weiner, per se, beyond the nominal description of him as having been a veteran of the campaign in North Africa.  (Well, that’s kind of vague!)  Alas, his name doesn’t appear in the 1947 book American Jews in World War II, which – as mentioned in many of my prior posts – is notable for the absence of many of the names that should have appeared in its several hundred pages.

So, here’s an image of Ben’s essay, from The Jewish Times

…and, verbatim as verbatim can be, here’s the text of Ben’s essay:

We Fight For The Jew, Too –

A Soldier in North Africa Describes His Credo

By CORPORAL BEN WEINER
Somewhere in North Africa

September 24, 1943

There are hundreds of thousands of American Jews in the armed forces.  They are fighting for the preservation of their country.  But they are also fighting for the Four Freedoms.  Here is one Jewish soldier, a participant in the first conquest of American arms overseas, who says that the Jews, too, are among the peoples for whom the Americans are fighting.  He gives his reasons why.  It is said that when the war is over, soldiers will do much to mold the thinking of the country.  They are likely to do the same for Jewish life. – The Editor.

As soldiers at war we have but one major task in front of us – to win the war.  It is however very important that we soldiers stop some times to think of the issues and principles we are fighting for, perhaps some day to give our lives for.

Among the things that the United Nations are fighting for are the rights, the respect and self-determination of the small as well as the large nations.  We are sympathetic to the needs of the Greeks, the Yugoslavs, the Czechs, The French, the Poles, Russians and heroic Chinese.  The small nations particularly have suffered from the German military machine and ideology.  Yet, their only desire had been to develop their own culture under their own flag and government.  The United Nations are deeply concerned with the problems of these small nations and are bound to give them due consideration at the peace table.

Throughout the centuries, ever since the Jewish people were destroyed as a nation by the Romans and were scattered to the far corners of the world, their life has been one endless struggle for existence.  It is a story of a people who have been continually oppressed and denied a peaceful life, not because of anything wrong they had done as a people, but because of the nations among whom they lived.

In Poland, Germany, Austria, Rumania, France, Hungary and numerous other countries the same conditions existed in varying degrees.

During the latter part of the nineteenth century and the early part of the twentieth, Germany was one of the most progressive nations in the world, industrially, technically and in the arts, sciences, literature and music.  The Jews were given certain freedoms and their contribution to that country soon became apparent.  More and more they thought that they had at last found the freedom that they had been constantly searching for.  They mingled with the Germans; they intermarried.  A few left their faith; many denied that they were Jews.  They believed that assimilation would solve their problem.

The first World War came and went.  Conditions became worse.  There arose in Germany a bestiality of anti-Semitism that its predecessors had never known.  History not merely repeated itself but made the blackest chapters ever recorded.  At least 2,000,000 of my fellow Jews have died of the Nazi terror during the period of this war alone.

Can anyone wonder why I, as an American citizen, wish to find a constructive solution to the needs of the Jewish people?

Submit To “Fate”

For centuries the Jewish people of Europe submitted with resignation to the degrees of fate.  They had to rely upon “chance,” “fate,” and “hope”.  The time has come for them to rely upon themselves, upon their own resources both spiritual and physical, upon their energies, their youth and their faith in democracy.  The time has come for the Jewish people to become the masters of their fate, to shape their destiny according to their needs and desires.

Many people speak of alleviating the conditions of these people.  This alleviation must be carried forward aggressively and persistently.  The solution is to give the Jewish people of Europe the country of Palestine as an independent state of their own, with their own flag and their own government.

In Palestine today one finds a rejuvenated people.  From the far corners of the world they are coming to the land to build up a new world for themselves.  They come from every nation; they speak every language; they bring with them a wealth of culture, knowledge and wisdom.  They bring with them the ideals that are embodied in their heritage.  Many of them have undergone cruel sufferings; yet, when they enter the land of Palestine their sufferings become a thing of the past.  As they look about them and see their people creatively engaged in building a country for themselves they slowly lose the fear they have had for centuries and they join in the task of rebuilding their lives and their homes.

As an American, I am aware of the fact that in relation to the Zionist movement, some persons, undoubtedly sincere, have raised the question of dual allegiance.  They ask how I, as an American, can take a great interest in the Jewish people and in Palestine.  To that my answer is quite simple.  I as a soldier am at present fighting for the rights of the French, the Russians, the English, the Poles, the Czechs, the Yugoslavs, etc., that they too may have a chance for “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.”  Shall I not fight for the rights of the Jews?

I am a young American, 23 years of age, who love my country and the flag more than anything else in the world.  For the privilege of being an American I am ready and willing to give my life.  My country stands for Justice, Truth, and Freedom, for the right to live a peaceful and honest life.  In my heart there is not a doubt as to where my loyalty lies.  Yes, it is because I am an American, because America has taught me the principles of Freedom and Justice that I look at the Jewish people and see that a great injustice is being done.

When Catholics or Protestants or any other human beings are in need, do not our hearts go out to them?  Do we not try in every possible way to help them?  When the Chinese were bombed [sic] did we not help them in various ways?  Did we not do the same for the English, the Russians and the Greeks?  Does not Christianity itself teach us, “Love thy neighbor,” and does it not tell us “Help thy neighbor in distress”?    My loyalty to my country and my desire to help the Jewish people do not conflict.  In fact my country has taught me that the principle of Justice is a universal one and should be applied to all people.  I as a soldier at war am fighting so that principle shall prevail.

Against the White Paper

At present there exists a “White Paper” which states that immigration to Palestine shall stop in March, 1944.  This, at a time when most countries will not allow immigration laws to be relaxed.  The carrying out of this brutal statement would be pure and simple murder of several more million of our people who could perhaps in the future escape the hellhole of Europe.  It must be our first duty as fighters of democracy to expose this farce.  We must definitely go ahead with our plans for the upbuilding of Palestine.  Our Senators and our Congressmen must be informed of this infamous “White Paper”.

Many writers of today have written clearly about the conditions that exist.  Ben Hecht wrote “Remember Us”; others have written in the same vein.  They always end up in despair, in helplessness; they never have a constructive conclusion.  They seem fail to recognize that if Palestine were established as a Jewish State it would help tremendously the morale and strengthen the lives of the Jews the world over.  They seem to fail to recognize that if they had a State of their own, throughout the world the Jews would be recognized as equals.

Jews in America do not have to go to Palestine.  The fact that there are Irish in America does not mean that they have to go to Ireland, or that the French in America have to go to France or the Italians to Italy, the Poles to Poland, etc.  It is for the Jewish people of Europe that Palestine stands as a beacon of light and a symbol of freedom.  After the war the desire of millions will be to go to that land.  The country itself is not very large but because of its intensified agriculture and the development of its industries it will be able to absorb millions of people.  Perhaps some day in the not too distant future they too will make a “Louisiana Purchase” which will enlarge the country many times its size, and forever solve the problem of Jewish homelessness.  Shall we not help them in their endeavor?

Destiny has placed in the hands of the Jewish community in America a great responsibility.  It does not matter whether one be a Conservative, a Reform, an Orthodox or a Zionist Jew.  The only thing that matters is that the entire community should realize its responsibilities and immediately take the proper action.  This demands the energies and thoughts of all our people, young and old.

(Copyright, 1943)

Commentary

I like what Ben has written. 

More importantly, I respect what Ben has written.

That his prose is not quite “purple” is hardly important, for the message of his essay takes priority over subtleties of literary expression.  Simply expressed, his ideas are iron-solid, and the simplicity of his writing serves to reinforce the strength of his arguments.  He minimizes appeals to emotion – totally foregoing personal references, except for the enigmatic fact that he was born (well, where?) in 1920 – which in any event is secondary to the overall “design” and purpose of his essay. 

In this sense, his thoughts are presented to the reader in a structured manner, in three distinct sections. 

Ben first discusses the fate of “small” nations in terms of their political autonomy and national survival, in the greater context of Germany’s (then, 1943) military occupation of much of Europe, and only-recently ended control of North Africa. 

This is followed by laying out the dire implications of the lack of political and geographic nationhood for the Jewish people, in light of the abrogation of their citizenship and persecution by Germany – thus, negating assumptions about the possibility of Jewish assimilation, at least in a European context.

Ben then talks about the logic, morality, and simple justice of Zionism – the revival of Jewish political and social autonomy in the ancestral home of the Jewish people – secondarily in the context of world events and as being a haven from persecution, and primarily in terms of Jewish national autonomy being a natural right and need, paralleling – no more and no less – that manifested by other peoples of the world. 

Admittedly, there’s an awkwardness to the statement, “…The Jewish people were destroyed as a nation by the Romans and were scattered to the far corners of the world.”  While this passage adds dramatic weight to Ben’s essay, it’s a misreading of history, and retrospectively deterministic.  Even if Jewish political and national autonomy was oppressed, curtailed and eventually eliminated in the wake of the first and second Jewish uprisings against Rome (66-73 and 132-135 B.C.E., respectively), Jewish communities had by then already existed throughout the Mediterranean coast, and beyond.

More importantly, the loss of Jewish territorial nationhood and political autonomy for over eighteen hundred years – between 135 and 1948 B.C.E. – did not destroy the Jewish people’s sense of nationhood: It transformed it.

Well, then, in the “literary center” of Ben’s essay, we find the statement, so refreshing to see in American-Jewish writing from 1943,They ask how I, as an American, can take a great interest in the Jewish people and in Palestine.  To that my answer is quite simple.  I as a soldier am at present fighting for the rights of the French, the Russians, the English, the Poles, the Czechs, the Yugoslavs, etc., that they too may have a chance for “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.”  Shall I not fight for the rights of the Jews?”

In his conclusion section, Ben expresses his thoughts about Britain’s “White Paper”, and comments upon Ben Hecht’s Reader’s Digest essay of February, 1943, “Remember Us“.  He closes with a prescient view of the future of the (then, only five years hence) re-established Jewish nation-state, and – a perennially true and thus perennially necessary – plea for Jewish unity. 

Alas, that’s true today, as well:  It often seems that the only unifying quality of the Jewish people is their utter lack of unity.  Such is the way of the world.

____________________

Let’s move ahead eight months:  Here’s Jack Zurofsky’s essay, as it appeared on page five of The Philadelphia Inquirer on Sunday, May 14, 1944.

First, a view of the entire page, found via Thomas M. Tryniski’s FultonHistory website.  (Off topic:  Those advertisements are pretty cool…)

…and now, a close-up of the essay…

…and now, from a pixeled picture to pixeled text. 

[But first, a caveat: The Inquirer misspelled Jack’s middle initial: It’s actually “J.”, not “F.”  Perhaps – in the era before spellcheck – someone made an error in the Inquirer’s compositing department?]

Corporal, 28, in North Africa Wins Army Essay Contest
(A “Why I Fight” essay contest, conducted in the North African Theater of Operations by the Morale Services Station, has been won by Corporal Jack F. Zurofsky [correct spelling is Jack J. Zurofsky], a 23-year-old infantryman, of Brooklyn, N. Y., who has been in the Army 16 months, the War Department announced yesterday.  Corporal Zurofsky’s prize-winning essay, for which he was awarded a $100 War Bond, was selected from entries submitted by more than 300 soldiers, sailors and WACs in all service branches.  It is printed herewith:)

By Corporal Jack F. Zurofsky

THIS IS why I fight.

I fight because it’s my fight.

I fight because my eyes are unafraid to look into other eyes; because they have seen happiness and because they have seen suffering; because they are curious and searching; because they are free.

I fight because my ears can listen to both sides of a question; because they can hear the groanings of a tormented people as well as the laughter of free people; because they are a channel for information, not a route for repetition; because, if I hear and do not think, I am deaf.

I fight because my mouth does not fear to utter my opinions; because, though I am only one, my voice helps forge my identity; because I can speak from a soap-box, or from a letter to the newspapers, or from a question that I may ask my representatives in Congress; because when my mouth speaks and can only say what everyone is forced to say it is gagged.

I fight because my knees kneel only to God.

I fight because my feet can go where they please, because they need no passport to go from New York to New Jersey and back again; because if I want to leave my country I can go without being forced and without bribing and without the loss of my savings; because I can plant my feet in farm soil or city concrete without anybody’s by-your-leave; because when my feet walk only the way they are forced to walk they are hobbled.

I fight because of all these and because I have a mind, a mind which has been trained in a free school to accept or to reject, to ponder and to weigh – a mind which knows the flowing stream of thought, not the stagnant swamp of blind obedience; a mind schooled to think for itself, to be curious, skeptical, to analyze, to formulate and to express its opinions; a mind capable of digesting the intellectual food it receives from a free press – because if a mind does not think it is the brain of a slave.

I fight because I think I am as good as anybody else; because of what other people have said better than ever I could, “certain inalienable rights” “right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness,” “government of the people, by the people, and for the people,” “give me liberty or give me death.”

I FIGHT because of my memories – the laughter and play of my childhood, the ball games I was in and the better ones I watched, my mother telling me why my father and she came to America at the turn of the century, my sisters marrying, my high school graduation, the first time I saw a cow, the first year we could afford a vacation, the crib at Camp Surprise Lake after the crowded, polluted Coney Island waters, hikes in the fall with the many-colored leaves falling, weenie and marshmallow roasts over a hot fire, the first time I voted, my first date and the slap in the face I got instead of the kiss I attempted, the way the nostrum quack would alternate with political orators on our street corner, seeing the changes for the better in my neighborhood – the El going down, streets being widened to let the sun in, new tenements replacing the old slums – the crowd applauding the time I came through with the hit that won us the borough championship: the memories, which if people like me do not fight, our children will never have.

I fight because I have something to fight for.

I FIGHT because of the life I hope to live when the fighting is finished, because that life offers opportunity and security and the freedom to read and write and listen and think and talk, because, as before, my home will be my castle with the drawbridge down only to those I invite.  Because if I do not fight, life itself will be death.

I fight because I believe in progress, not reaction; because, despite our faults, there is hope in our manner of life, because if we lose there is no hope.

I fight because some day I want to get married and I want my children to be born into free world because my forefathers left me a heritage of freedom which it is my duty to pass on, because if we lost, it would be a crime to have children.

I fight because it is an obligation, because free people must fight to remain free, because when the freedom of one nation or one person is taken away the rights of all nations and all people are threatened, because through our elected representatives I had the choice: To fight or not to fight.

I FIGHT not so much because of Pearl Harbor, but because of what Pearl Harbor meant, because, dually after skirmishes with the Ethiopians, the Manchurians, the Chinese, the Austrians, the Czechoslovakians, the Danes, the Spaniards, and the Norwegians, fascism was menacing us as we had never before been menaced, because only the craven will not defend themselves.

I fight because “It is better to die than live on one’s knees.”

I fight because only by fighting today will there be peace tomorrow.  I fight because I am thankful that I am not on the other side; because, but for the Grace of God or an accident of Nature, the brutalized Nazi could have been me and, but for my fighting, will be my child.

I fight in the fervent hope that those who follow me will not have to fight again but in the knowledge that if they have to, they will not be found wanting in the crisis.

I fight to remain free.

Commentary

Jack was an excellent writer.

That, I will more than readily grant. 

The literary style of his essay, attributable to its organization as much as of its language, make it a fast-paced, emotionally compelling, very easy “read”.   

Every paragraph, regardless of content, topic, or length, commences with the two-word phrase, “I fight…”.  This phrase also appears in the piece’s title.  This repetition – commencing at the very start of the essay – is particularly effective in setting up a kind of literary rhythm, by which as soon as you fish one paragraph, well…  You anticipate the next.  And, so, on.  Until the end: 

It draws you in, and keeps you going.    

So, yes.  Jack was an excellent writer.

And yet, behind everything is “the dog that didn’t bark”; a certain “thing” that by virtue of its absence undermines the message could otherwise have blossomed via Jack’s literary skill. 

There are allusions to abstract, universal (and valid) ideals of freedom, thought, and association.  There are comments about threat of totalitarianism.  There’s mention of Jack’s residence in the New York metropolitan area, colorful allusions to his parent’s “immigrant” origins, and memories of his upbringing in New York City.

But, in the entirety of this essay, published in mid-1944, by which time news about the fate of European Jewry was certainly known in a general sense – and even in relative detail, assuming one followed the secular and Jewish media with even moderate attention and focus – there’s absolutely no allusion or reference – amidst mention of the “…Ethiopians, the Manchurians, the Chinese, the Austrians, the Czechoslovakians, the Danes, the Spaniards, and the Norwegians,” – to the fate of the Jews.

Why?  Well, one can surmise…

Compare and Contrast

Perhaps it was a question of time and an issue of place. 

The “Why I Fight” essay contest was conducted by the “Morale Services Section” in the North African Theater of War, probably (a guess here…) under the auspices of the War Department.  As a skilled writer; cognizant of his primary and secondary audience and the prevailing zeitgeist, perhaps Jack rightly believed – given the tenor of the times; given the social “place” of the Jews of the United States (and beyond, even in the other Allied nations) in the 1940s – that a literary work calling attention to the Jewish people as Jews, in an explicit, singular, and specific sense, in the context of a larger war, might well have negated the work’s literary acceptability, let alone its public acceptance. 

Well, as reported in The New York Times, of the 300 essays received by the Morale Services Section, the top three winners – along with Corporal Zurofsky – included Private Clarence Weinstock of 219 East 12th Street, Manhattan (second place), and Sergeant Henry C. Nelson, 1250 Brooklyn Avenue, Brooklyn (third place).  According to the Times, there were twelve judges (names not given), who, “represented a cross-section of the Army and included men and women, officers and enlisted men.”  Honorable mention awards went to, “Sergeant Kenneth Board, member of an Army Air Forces heavy bomber unit, whose home is at 9765 North Martindale Street, Detroit; Private Robert E. Stark, Medical Department, of 2140 Sixteenth Avenue, South Birmingham, Alabama; and Private First Class Benjamin E. Karn, member of an anti-aircraft unit, of 1997 Fillmore Avenue, Buffalo.”

On the other hand, assuming that Ben Weiner intended that his essay would appear in the Jewish press, perhaps what could superficially be perceived as a constraint gave him the ironic freedom to express himself frankly and fully.

________________________________________

But, things aren’t what they seem…

And yet, appearances, whether visual or literary, can be deceiving: 

Jack Zurofsky was a deeply identified and committed Jew, in both word and action.  For example, while serving in the Jewish Community Council of Essex County, New Jersey, he authored the professional article “Interpreting Jewish Social Work Today”, which appeared in the publication The Jewish Social Service Quarterly, I think some time in the 50s.  Later, in the Daily News Bulletin of the Jewish Telegraphic Agency of June, 1961, his name appeared in an announcement concerning his appointment as “Director of Community Publicity Services of the Council of Jewish Federations and Welfare Funds” (whew – long title!).   

This was apparent even earlier.  In 1944, his short story about the Warsaw Ghetto Rebellion, “Warsaw Epitaph”, was published in The Jewish Advocate of October 19, 1944.  If “the dog didn’t bark” for the “Why I Fight” literary contest, it certainly howled (and quite loudly!) here.  Notably, the essay was expressly written for publication by the Jewish Telegraphic Agency, which literary setting – paralleling Ben Weiner’s essay in The Jewish Times – may have granted Jack Zurofsky free reign to express his ideas and beliefs (albeit in the context of fiction, through the words of the symbolically named narrator “Israel”) in a manner not feasible for the “Why We Fight” contest.

Thus, “Warsaw Epitaph”:

WARSAW EPITAPH

“Today I Die”
By Corporal Jack J. Zurofsky, U.S.A.

(The author of the following short story based on the heroic resistance of the Jews of the Warsaw Ghetto recently won first prize in a contest among U.S. servicemen overseas for the best essay on “What I Am Fighting For.”  He is now stationed in this country.  This story was written exclusively for the Jewish Telegraphic Agency. – THE EDITOR.)

Today I am going to die.

I do not know exactly bow.  Perhaps it will be by a rifle slug tearing through my heart or a machine gun bullet clipping my brain.  Who knows?  It may be a grenade exploding through my vitals.

The thought is not pleasant.  I do not like to dwell upon it but this I know, today I must die and not only I but the rest of us, the handful that is left.

We have resisted them now for forty-two days.  No longer do they despise us Jews.  Our ghetto streets have become passages to Hell for them.  No longer do they come here arrogant and unafraid.  Now they advance behind a curtain of fire, after an artillery barrage, taking advantage of whatever cover remains.  Now they keep their heads down and their proud chins tucked in.  Now they fear a well-placed bullet from our pistols or one of our accurately hurled grenades.

They were surprised that first day.  Symbolically, it was the first Passover Seder.  They came in as they always do with the lists in their hands.  And they suspected nothing.  We watched them round up their victims as we had watched them round them up before.  As always they took the old and the weak, the ones who could not work for them, the lame, the halt, and the blind, the decrepit, the ones who were useless to the Master Race.

The scene was an old one to us.  We had seen it many times before.  We betrayed no emotion when they tore a child from the arms of its mother, clubbing it to death before our eyes.  This was routine.  Nor did we cry out when they took Reb Shmulkevich, that harmless old sage, a lover of the classics and a student of the Talmud all his life.  Half-starved, old, infirm, he did not move as fast as the gauleiter desired.  They pulled his beard, and booted him in the genitals, leaving him writhing on the cobblestones.  Perhaps it was mercy when a storm-trooper spitted him with a bayonet.

No, we said nothing.  We watched and said nothing.  But the call was already out.  Our time had come.

We had made our decision.  Unanimously.  Like the Maccabees whose blood flowed in our veins we would fight.  For so long we had submitted, tried to appease those whom nothing could appease.

What had we to lose?  Our lives.  Our laughter is harsh and ironic.  What were our lives?  We were outcasts, pariahs, beyond the pale, slaves to the Master Race.  They killed us without -mercy, looted, plundered, raped our women and we adapted ourselves.

Our elders said we had to submit.  It was our duty to survive.  God would help us.  The wrath of God would fall upon the oppressor as his hand fell upon Pharaoh.

They were our elders, our rabbis, the leaders of our people.  We listened.  Some of us never listened.  I was for fight from the beginning.  But we heeded the admonition of our elders and our resistance was only passive.

But all the time we planned.  We contacted the Polish underground.  Many of my friends joined the guerrillas in the forest.  I stayed.  My place was here.  It takes courage to keep your hands at your sides, to wait, and wait, and wait.

But we could not wait if we had not planned.  We smuggled in arms – pistols, hand grenades, knives, some rifles, even a few machine guns.  In the depth of our misery we waited and prepared.

When they came with the deportation plan we saw through their diabolical scheme.  But we were not ready, not yet ready.  By now we had organization.  We met in little cells.  We could trust each other.  Who among us would betray a fellow Jew to the enemy?

Each of us had a pistol and by now the rabbis were with us.  They too knew of the crematorium at Lublin, the death camps at Trawnicki and Krakow.

Adam Czymansky, the president of the Warsaw synagogue, committed suicide.  He hoped his action would bring our plight to the rest of the world.  He was wrong.  Suicide is not the way.  If you die you must take an enemy with you.  Do not do his work for him.

While the Nazi brutes gathered their pitiful victims we gathered our forces.  Long ago we had picked out our password for that day.

“Kill”

The gestapo rats suspected nothing.  They did not notice us creeping out of the cellars.  None of them saw me creep up to the sentinel at the ghetto gate.  None of them heard when I slit his throat, like a schochet would a chicken.  How could they hear: His sound went no further than his throat where the knife met and stilled it.

They laughed and chuckled at their work.  The pigs enjoyed it.  For these it was their last laugh, their last chuckle.

It is beautiful to kill a Nazi.  It is honest work, a satisfying duty, like pulling weeds, or exterminating rats.

Sometimes I wonder at myself.  How could I feel that way?  I, a Talmud student, a believer in the Commandments.  “Thou Shalt Not Kill.”

I used to blanche at the sight of blood.  My mother wanted me to become a doctor, a healer.  But I was against it.  I thought that I could not stand the sight I or stench of blood.

Since then I had seen much blood spilled, always Jewish blood, and always let by the Nazis.  I had seen the corpses of my people in the streets of the ghetto and fat the factories.  I had seen the Nazis stride into our synagogue and desecrate our altars with their killing.  How often they violated the Sabbath eve with their murder.

The sight of blood became as familiar as the veins in my hand, as normal as the anger which grew in my heart, as inevitable as the purpose which sharpened in my mind.

So it became a pleasure to destroy those who had destroyed pleasure.  I would think as I would draw a bead with a rifle, “This will hit him in the stomach right about the belly button.  He will sit down suddenly and watch his guts desert him.  The bullet will make a small hole in the front and a large hole in the back and it will rip his intestines as it passes.  He will not like the feeling.  Maybe then he will remember the little boy he clubbed to death, or the Jewish girl he raped.  He will suffer a long time and his moans will disturb his comrades.  It will remind them of the fate which awaits them.  Even then he will die too soon though he lived too long.”

In that first fight we learned we were better men than the Nazis.  We saw then that they were afraid of us, that they were only little men wearing large and heavy armor.  When it came to the showdown we had more courage.  But they had the tanks and the incendiaries.  We had purpose and determination but they had all the food and all the drink that they wanted.

On that day we left none of them alive.  Not one storm-trooper who came into the ghetto left it.  They hardly put up a fight.  Terrorized completely they died like rabbits.  We did not lose a man and we gained many rifles and lugers.

Most important we gained several uniforms.  Once- we removed the damned yellow badge and put one of them on who of the super race could tell us from them.

Thus the battle began.

We knew the Hitlerites would strike to quell our revolt.  We knew that already gestapo headquarters had sent out a call for reinforcements, that they were routing the seine out of the beer halls and the brothels.

We prepared.  The ghetto wall was a natural barricade.  The women heated hot water for us to hurl from the roofs.  We dispatched messages to the guerrillas.  Our arms came out of hiding.  Messengers hurried to the slave factories and our young men left their benches and hurried to the defense of the ghetto.

Nor did we wait.  We attacked.  Bands of us tore off our yellow badges and invaded Warsaw proper.  We learned how easy it was to kill, a simple thrust of the knife, a twist, and you can wipe it on his uniform.

They came at us that night.  They hoped to overawe us with six tanks.  We let them come in for, by now we knew how to wait.  When they reached the main street we let loose.  They tried to flee but they were too late.  They were cremated in their tanks.

The uprising became general.  Each house became a fortress, each cellar an arsenal.  We grouped our main strength in the larger houses and all that night we dug trenches in the streets.  Even the children were put to work.  They became our messengers.  They brought us food which the women and the old people prepared in the communal kitchens.

Next morning we hung up our flags.  Beside the Polish colors and the red flag we flew the pennant of Zion, the Star of David flying for the first time in this war.

By noon a cordon had been established around the ghetto by the Germans.  Many Poles, suspected of complicity, were killed.  Ten tanks, besides numerous machine guns and small arms, headed the Nazi array.  They opened fire almost immediately.  Our answering fusillade was telling.

Still they underestimated us.  They refused to admit to themselves the fierceness of our resolve.  But they had to stop us.  The news of this battle must be contained.  The outside world must never learn of this breach of the Nazi festung’s inner defenses.  But that was just why we were fighting, why I am writing.  The world must know what we have done here.

A council of leaders were organized.  In it were the leaders of every schism and sect in ghetto life.  Atheists and orthodox Jews united in a common bond.  Communists fought shoulder to shoulder with Revisionist Zionists.

I was wounded that first day.  Just a scratch.  Not worth mentioning.  I participated in a sortie just about twilight.  The enemy tanks had been destroyed and we were determined to capture the survivors.  In a mad charge we swept them before us but I didn’t see the surrender – the clubbed end of a rifle slugged me unconscious, lacerating and tearing open my scalp.

For one week I was out unable to fight not even knowing what was going on.  During my convalescence I fell in love.  Romantic, isn’t it.  In the midst of all this terror, both of us certain we would never live through the battle, Deborah and I fell in love.

I didn’t find this out until several days later but it was Deborah who saved my life.  When she saw me fall in the melee she dashed out of the shelter of the building and dragged me back.  How she was not hit by a flying bullet, or a stray shell fragment none could explain.

Anyway, for the record, we fell in love.  I write this because it is important not because it was me or even because of Deborah.  It is important because it proves that life went on even in the shadow of death.  We were married during the siege and we both spent our wedding night on the barricades.

Realization had finally come to the gestapo that they were dealing with an organized revolt Orders came from Berlin that the ghetto was to be destroyed.  Somehow we knew this.  How, I cannot tell, but we have our own intelligence which maintained liaison with the Polish underground throughout the siege.

Once, I know, we asked them to rise with us and they sorrowfully answered.  “For us, the time is not yet ripe.”

And we fought on, each apartment a fort, each building a citadel.  Slowly under the weight of superior force we gave up for each advance they made but we paid too.  We fought with everything we had, boiling water, bricks, cobblestones, but still our ammunition could not last.  Each day our ranks were thinned, more and more.

On the eighth day of the siege our spirits were greatly raised by the news that the prisoners in the Pawiak jail had heard of our uprising and had sent a message to us saying.  “Save us and we will fight for you.”  Now was the time for the captured German uniforms.  That night 400 of us donned the swastika, slipped through the German cordon, and attacked the prison stockade.  We were successful.  All the prisoners, including Nazi deserters joined our ranks.

The fiercest attack came on the ninth day.  Tanks poured through the breaches in the ghetto wall, cannon lumbering behind them.  Volley after volley was leveled against us.  Our suicide squads met this attack by disguising themselves in German uniforms and crawling under the tanks to blow themselves and the tanks up.  For the Nazis their loss of life was terrific.  They withdrew and gave up the attack.

From then on the horror began in the ghetto.  Each night we would be bombed with incendiaries.  We organized fire brigades and fought the flames as best as we could but we could not save all the buildings.  Night after night other houses were consumed in the flames.  The ghetto became a funeral pyre for our warriors, and our women and children.

We hoped and prayed that our example would fire the rest of enslaved Poland to revolt.  But the days passed and the battle did not spread beyond the confines of the ghetto.

Meanwhile we fought on and on and on, retreating from building to building, killing as long as we could, dying as best we could.

Now this is the morning of the forty-second day.  This is the last day.  We know it Deborah knows it.  I know it

Today all of us will die.

Already, as I write this on that roof of the last building left standing in the area, the sun is beginning to rise in the east.  With the dawn will come the last and final attack.

It is a miracle that we have lasted this long.  Forty-two days.  Six weeks.  Seven, days to each week.  Twenty-four hours to each day.  Sixty minutes to each hour.  Sixty seconds to each minute – and each second filled with fighting, the rumble of tanks through the narrow ghetto streets, the clipped staccato of machine gun bullets, the bark of rifles, the crackle of flames burning the ghetto, the sound St buildings collapsing, bombs bursting, the sound and the smell of death.

From my eyrie up here I can see all of the ghetto.  Remnants, of buildings thrust upward from the ground like jagged teeth.  There is debris everywhere.  Bodies lie unburied, rotting.  In the distance, out of rifle shot, I can see the Germans regrouping, getting ready for the final lunge.

I have little time for they will come soon.  I do not know whether or not this will ever be read.  But this story must be told.  The world must listen.  They must know of the Jews of Warsaw.  They must hear of the descendants of the Maccabees, the sons of Joshua and of Gideon, the warriors whom, unafraid as David, faced the nazi Goliath.

***

Again I am on the roof.  Fate has reserved me for the last.  This building has six floors.  Fourteen stairs separate each floor.  On each of these steps we have left a life, taking two for each one we gave.

Deborah, my wife, was the first to die this morning.  She expired in my arms.  I ask no more.  Soon I will join her.

We fought for every room, every stick of furniture.  We covered ourselves with glory.

Now only I am left but they will not have me alive.

With me on the roof I have the flag of the Jews, the flag of the nation that is no nation.

I am going to wrap myself in it and I am going to jump off the roof.  I will die as Anna and her sons did in ancient times.

I die but in my dying I know the Jews will live, forever.  We are tough.  We will bounce back.  The Jews will never die.

I will die as a Jew should, shrouded with the flag of my people, with the Shema on my lips, for my name is Israel.

Some comments…

Obviously a work of fiction, perhaps “Warsaw Epitaph” was inspired by contemporary news accounts and fiction in The Forward (Forverts), The Jewish Morning Journal, and Der Tog, as well as the “general” press.

In any event, regardless of his sources, some facets of his story are intriguing.  Such as…

…The comment about, “…Reb Shmulkevich, that harmless old sage, a lover of the classics and a student of the Talmud all his life,” evokes the question: Would an elderly Talmudic Scholar in the Warsaw of 1943 even be a devotee of “the classics” (implying secular literature…?), in the first place?  Perhaps this characterization of a rabbi as a scholar who bridged the worlds of Talmud and contemporary culture, was intended to facilitate a largely secular audience’s identification with the story.

…The narrator, symbolically named “Israel”, describes himself as, “…a Talmud student, a believer in the Commandments.  “Thou Shalt Not Kill.”  Really?  If “Israel” was a “Talmud student”, then he certainly needed to brush up on his Tanach, for that statement is a disconcertingly common mistranslation of the sixth commandment, probably inspired by secular or non-Jewish sources.  The correct text actually reads, “You shall not murder.”      

…The sentence, “We knew the Hitlerites would strike to quell our revolt,” would – yes – actually be correct in the setting of this story.  Though I’ve never encountered this word  – “Hitlerites” – in American or British news reports, military documents, or popular articles in reference to German military forces or German WW II war crimes, the appellation was commonly used as a noun and / or epithet in Soviet WW II news items and military documents (along with the terms “Fascist”, “German-Fascists”, and “Occupiers”) as opposed to the simple and more valid term “Germans”.

“Beside the Polish colors and the red flag we flew the pennant of Zion, the Star of David flying for the first time in this war.”  I don’t know enough about the history of the Warsaw Ghetto Revolt to know if the Polish national flag, some variant of a communist or Soviet “red” flag, and Zionist flag, were simultaneously flown during the revolt.  Perhaps there’s something about this in Marek Edelman’s The Ghetto Fights (listed below).

Withall, the essay, like “Why I Fight,” is a fine example of Jack’s literary skill.  What it lacks in historical veracity it makes up for – at least, by the standards of the day – in being an attempt at sincerely expressing anguish, solidarity, and inspiration. 

______________________________

Jack Zurofsky’s portrait, which accompanied the article in The Philadelphia Inquirer

______________________________

A photo of Jack and New York Mayor Fiorello H. La Guardia, in a photo published in the Brooklyn Eagle on June 3, 1944.  Originally from Manhattan, Jack resided lived in Brooklyn with his sister, prior to entering the Army.

______________________________

Jack Zurofsky passed away in mid-September of 1999. 

Alas, I know nothing more about Ben Weiner.  I assume that he, too, has since left this life. 

But, Ben’s words remain as valid now, as they did seventy-seven years ago. 

And, given ideological, political, and sociological trends in the world of 2020, even more.

________________________________________

________________________________________

References

Communication from Jack J. Zurofsky’s daughter, Rena.  (Thank you, Rena!)

News Articles (Chronologically Listed)

Corporal Ben Weiner

Jewish Times (Baltimore), Sept. 24, 1943, “We Fight For The Jew, Too” – A Soldier in North Africa Describes His Credo (Essay by Ben Weiner)

Jewish Advocate (Boston), Dec. 16, 1943 – “We Fight for the Jew, Too”, by Corporal Ben Weiner

Corporal Jack J. Zurofsky

New York Times, Dec. 25, 1943, “Yule Cheer Buoys Troops in Algiers”

New York Times, Feb. 27, 1944, “G.I. Cast In Algiers Ready For Its Show”

New York Times, May 14, 1944, “Brooklyn Soldier Wins Essay Prize”

New York Times, Sept. 14, 1999, Death notice for Jack J. Zurofsky

Philadelphia Inquirer, May 14, 1944, “‘Why I Fight’ – Corporal, 28, in North Africa Wins Army Essay Contest”

New York Daily News, May 22, 1944, “Listening In, with Ben Gross” (Eddie Cantor’s upcoming radio narration of Jack Zurofsky’s essay, scheduled for June 11, 1944)

Jewish Advocate, June 8, 1944, “In Our Country’s Service” (Biographical profile of Corporal Jack Zurofsky)

Jewish Advocate, Oct. 19, 1944, “Warsaw Epitaph – ‘Today I Die'”, by Corporal Jack J. Zurofsky (Essay about Warsaw Ghetto Revolt)

Jewish Telegraphic Agency News Bulletin, No. 124, June 29, 1961, “Jack J. Zurofsky to Head CJFWF Community Relations Programs”

– and –

Dublin, Louis I., and Kohs, Samuel C., American Jews in World War II – The Story of 550,000 Fighters for Freedom, The Dial Press, New York, N.Y., 1947

Edelman, Marek, The Ghetto Fights – Translation of a pamphlet published in Warsaw, Poland, in 1945 by the Central Committee of the “Bund”, American Representation of the General Jewish Workers’ Union of Poland, New York, N.Y., 1946

Gilbert, Martin, Atlas of Jewish History, Dorset Press, 1976

161

2020 06 30

Last Days in Captivity: Reminiscences of WW II Ex-POWs Lieutenant Norman Fruman and Private Sidney Thomas

Several of my prior blog posts have addressed the experiences of Jewish prisoners of war, either directly – through first-person accounts of capture and captivity – or indirectly – within the larger context of posts focusing upon specific historical events, or, biographies of specific Jewish servicemen.  While the topic of POWs naturally; inevitably, arises from study of any military conflict, it’s particularly significant in the context of the Jewish POWs of the Third Reich, given the ethos, ideology, and goals of Nazi Germany. 

This post, respectively covering an essay and letter from Ex-POWs Norman Fruman and Sydney Thomas, provides further insight into this subject.

Norman Fruman, a Second Lieutenant (0-553210) in the 232nd Infantry Regiment of the 42nd Infantry Division, was captured on January 5, 1945, and interned at Stalag 5A (Malsbach / Ludwigsburg) and eventually Stalag 7A (Moosburg). 

Born in December of 1923, Norman was the son of Minnie Fruman of 1590 East 172nd Street in the Bronx, while his sister, Dolly F. Epstein, resided at 1225 White Plains Road (also, the Bronx!). 

Postwar a professor of English at the University of Minnesota, he penned an essay that was published in Times Literary Supplement on May 5, 1995 (transcribed below), concerning his POW experiences, but equally reflecting upon the changes in American society in the four decades since the war’s end.  He passed away in January of 2012.

Other information about Norman’s experiences is found in E.T. Levy’s comment, in the context of Bob William’s “On the Air” New York Post column of October, 1957, covering “The $64,000 Challenge”.  Mr. Levy noted that, “In the German POW camp where we were all incarcerated, Lt. Norman Fruman maintained our morale under terribly adverse conditions, organized and led a successful prison escape, was recaptured a second time and underwent privation until liberated at the end of the war … [he was] broken in body, [weighing] less than 100 pounds, and [had] lost his hearing.”  You can view the full Williams’ article – found via FultonHistory, – below:

Digital Newspaper Archives of US & Canada

On The Air
By Bob Williams

New York Post
October 7, 1957

Viewer’s View:

Norman Fruman added $4,000 to his $64,000 bankroll on The $64,000 Challenge last night as a ”general knowledge” expert.  Writes E.T. Levy of 1205 Av. R, Brooklyn:

“You may be interested to know that [he] was my company commander in the Battle of the Bulge and he became a legendary hero to all of us who were captured along with him.

“In the German POW camp where we were all incarcerated, Lt. Norman Fruman maintained our morale under terribly adverse conditions, organized and led a successful prison escape, was recaptured a second time and underwent privation until liberated at the end of the war … [he was] broken in body, [weighing] less than 100 pounds, and [had] lost his hearing.

“For years he received rehabilitation help … partially recovering his hearing … taught English literature at Columbia and City College and is about to complete his Ph.D. at NYU.  He has written articles for encyclopedias and is one of the foremost authorities on symbolism in Coleridge’ (the English poet).

“It was surprising to me to hear [him] referred to on the $64,000 Challenge as a ‘comic book writer,’ which is the least of his attributes.  Is CBS trying to keep him incognito?

The Times Literary Supplement article includes a photograph showing Norman immediately upon entering his mother’s home, after his return from captivity.  According to the caption, the waving hand in the foreground is that of his mother, Minnie.  What the picture lacks in focus and contrast (well, even in the original issue of TLS – the image in this post is a scan of a photocopy of that periodical – the picture isn’t of the best quality) it more than makes up for in spontaneity and symbolism.

Herewith, Norman’s article:

Last Days at Stalag 7A

NORMAN FRUMAN

Times Literary Supplement
May 5, 1995

We stood there at the edge of a rural airfield, about a dozen of us, our filthy, lice-infested clothes hanging from our emaciated bodies, anxiously scanning the skies for the aeroplanes we’d been told would fly us back to France or England, to medical attention, nourishing food and, at last, safety.  Nine days before, on April 19, we’d awakened to find that during the night our guards had abandoned Stalag 7A, the huge prisoner-of-war camp near Moosburg in south-eastern Germany, which, it was said, housed as many, as 100,000 Allied prisoners from all over Europe and the Soviet Union.  Although the Nazi armies were in retreat on all fronts, unconditional surrender would not necessarily come soon.  The Germans had been declared beaten in December of 1944, and then came the Battle of the Bulge.  The German attack was no sooner contained in the north than a three-division offensive in the Strasbourg area shredded the thinly drawn American lines.  As far as I was concerned, the war was very much
on.

Until American tank troops arrived later in the day on April 29, conditions in Stalag 7A were chaotic.  With no system of discipline in place, famished prisoners pillaged whatever stores of food could be found in the kitchens.  Others, especially the Russians, according to the rumours which flew about wildly, broke out of the camp and smashed down doors in the nearby village, raping and looting.  I was skeptical about the raping.  Experience had demonstrated alarmingly that after just two weeks on starvation rations, sexual desire vanished.

Our liberators, fortuitously, proved to be from my own 42nd Infantry Division, widely known as the “Rainbow”.  The intelligence officer of my regiment, having heard that a dozen or so officers from the Rainbow were in the camp, hastened over with two satchels of Scotch and bourbon, the last things in the world we hungry POWs needed or wanted.  (There was almost complete ignorance in 1945 about how to treat people who had been starved for a long time, an ignorance that was to have widespread and serious consequences.)

Naturally, now that we were liberated, we wanted to get back home as soon as possible.  Above all, we wanted to get the hell out of Germany and flee the possibility of being killed at any moment.  I had been freed once already, just one month before, when a powerful tank force sent by General Patton in a now hotly controversial action plunged fifty miles behind Germany lines to liberate Oflag 13B, a POW camp for American and Serbian officers near Hammelburg, in the Rhone Valley leading to Bavaria.  The tank force, expecting to rescue 200 American officers, in fact found almost 1,500.  During the night-time dash back to American lines, we were attacked several times at German roadblocks, and suffered heavy casualties, mainly to the prisoners clinging precariously to the vehicles.

As dawn approached, our erstwhile liberators had doubled back to a hill a few miles from the Oflag, which was burning furiously in the distance.  The tankers advised us to march back to the camp under a white flag and wait there in safety for the arrival of the main American forces which, they assured us, could only be a few days away.  They, conversely, would have to fight their way back, and couldn’t do so effectively while encumbered with us.  Even after fifty years, the memory of that moment remains intense.  Twelve hours before, we “kriegies” (from Kriegsgefangener, prisoner of war), as we called ourselves, had been in a state of euphoria.  “Eggs for breakfast!” we shouted as we clambered aboard the tanks and troop-carriers – a phrase that had come to stand for everything normal and good in life.

Most of the POWs trooped wearily off towards the camp.  A few of us decided to risk making it back to the American lines fifty miles away on our own.  As it happened, hardly was the column of prisoners out of sight when the American force was attacked by a cluster of German Tiger tanks.  In the brief but fierce battle that followed, the American unit was destroyed.  Understandably, many military historians have condemned Patton for sending this force on so problematic a mission and accused him of doing so only because his son-in-law was a prisoner in the camp.

I and four fellow kriegies reached the nearby woods moments after the battle began and staggered as far as possible from the gunfire before dropping exhausted.  For the next five nights, we plodded westward, sleeping during the day, and coping as best we could with dysentery, exhaustion, bleeding gums, and the oedema that resulted from months on a diet mainly of two watery soups a day.  The Geneva Convention stipulated that as captured officers we were not required to work, and this the Junker command at Offizierslager 13B observed scrupulously.  The result was that 13B was on the lowest food ration in Germany outside the death camps.  Almost all of us there lost one-quarter of our body weight during the first month.

After five days behind German lines, we were recaptured and sent by boxcar to camps deeper into Germany.  Almost every day, Allied fighter planes strafed us.  Once, moments after we reached Ingolstadt, the city was attacked by a vast fleet of Flying Fortresses.  The ground heaved, shuddered and rocked under the bombardment, as we crawled frantically into whatever hollow in the earth might give protection.  After watching the Fortresses fly in tight formation through a flak-pocked sky, some to explode in spectacular balls of flame, none of us was ever afterwards inclined to complain about how much better the guys in the Air Corps had it, what with their hot showers at night and dancing with the local girls in USO clubs after the day’s mission, while we were lucky to have a dry foxhole.

I thought about all this a month later, while waiting with increasing impatience on that makeshift airfield near Stalag 7 A for the planes to arrive.  The previous nine days had been a succession of mounting frustrations.  We began every day feeling confident that transport would arrive to take us away.  And every day ended in gloom.  What was taking so long?  Rumours flew about wildly.  Hitler was dead, not dead.  The German High Command was negotiating surrender.  Not true.  Vague rumours about a nearby camp named Dachau where the liberators had seen terrible, unspeakable horrors.  And some strange things were happening at 7A.  When trains arrived from the east to take the many thousands of Russian prisoners back to the Soviet Union, there had been some rioting.  Unaccountably to us, many of the Russians did not want to go back home!  Years passed before I understood the meaning of this.

Suddenly a plane appeared in the distance, its shape unfamiliar.  Someone groaned, “Jesus, it doesn’t look like one of ours…  It could be a Kraut!”  We froze, but only for an instant.  It was German, all right, but not a fighter plane, and within a moment we made out that it was trailing a long white sheet, doubtless signifying surrender.  It quickly landed and taxied to a bumpy halt near us.  Out stepped the pilot, throwing up his arms, smiling, to be immediately followed by a young woman clutching a small pig.  “Alles kaput!  It’s over!  The war’s over!” he shouted in German.  “The high command has surrendered!”  “Thank God”, said the woman.

I felt a deeper sense of weary relief than joy.  The war might be over for them but not for me.  Though we knew nothing of the savage carnage at the recent battle for Iwo Jima, we were certain that the Japanese, like the Germans, would fight fanatically long after any rational hope of victory was gone, and would not surrender until their home islands lay in smouldering ruins.  I fully expected to participate in the invasion.  None of us, of course, had an inkling that in three months the atomic age would begin with the instantaneous obliteration of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

An hour or so later, transport planes arrived to fly us to Le Havre, where we were deloused, showered, issued with new uniforms, underwear, socks and boots – our first change of clothes since becoming prisoners.  Within days, I was on a luxury liner converted to a hospital ship and among the very first troops to return from Europe after VE-Day.  Thus our arrival in New York harbour was greeted by scores of ship whistles and foghorns, huge arcs of water thrown up by fire-ship hoses, and wild cheering from the milling crowds on the docks.

I was a few months past twenty-one years old on VE-Day, and when I think back on that day I am struck once again, and more than a little dismayed, by how little sense I had in 1945 of a future whose horizons might be radically different from the ones any of us had imagined for ourselves.  When the war in Europe began in 1939, the United States was in the tenth year of a crushing depression.  Hard times seemed to be the normal condition of economic life.  It wasn’t until well into President Eisenhower’s second term (1956-60), after more than a decade of booming prosperity, that Americans began to feel that happy days were not only here again, but maybe here to stay.  Memory of the Depression faded.  The young began to take for granted that their lives would be far more prosperous, secure and full of exciting choices than their parents could ever have imagined.

The great, transforming agency of social change, which was to alter the United States in ways whose consequences have yet to be determined, came about as a result of a wartime law universally known as the “GI Bill”.  It guaranteed to every veteran a month of free higher education for every month of service, plus a full year bonus for the first three months, up to a limit of four years, together with a monthly stipend sufficient for living expenses.  (That stipend, $75 a month, permitted me to live quite well in Paris as a graduate student at the Sorbonne in 1950 and 1951.)

Passage of the GI Bill represented another kind of VE-Day – a Victory for Education.  This act was to demonstrate the incalculable value to a nation’s economic life of an educated public, a lesson only now being learned in many countries.  Between 1955 and 1965, there was built somewhere in the United States, on average every two weeks, an institution of higher learning at least the size of a junior college, and this happened at the same time that the vast majority of colleges and universities were expanding at a frenzied pace.  To everyone’s astonishment, there was no pause in the swelling tide of incoming students after the first waves of veterans passed successfully through college life.  Intoxicated with the idea of universal higher education, legislatures in state after state voted that anybody with a high school diploma was entitled to enter college.  Within a single generation, “Open Enrollment” arrived, whereby students unprepared for college work, sometimes drastically so, were admitted anyway.  “Remedial” courses proliferated.  Grade inflation soon undermined the meaning of graduating with honours.  Once again, the perverse law of unintended consequences had dripped its poison into the chalice of utopian visions.

On May 8, 1945, when that German couple told us that the war was over, who could have predicted that fifty years later defeated Germany and Japan would again be among the most powerful nations on earth, that Europe would lose its colonies, the British Empire shrink to the shadow of its former self, the Soviet Union disappear, Communism be repudiated almost everywhere?  Or that men would walk on the moon, that the population of the world would more than double despite the arrival of a safe birth-control pill, which would itself make possible the most revolutionary change in sexual mores ever known, that millions would take for granted unheard-of technologies like television, computers, video recorders, faxes and compact discs, that the women’s movement would metamorphose millennia-old relations between the sexes – and that those fifty years would witness vicious wars large and small in every corner of the globe, and that our naive hopes of a United Nations that would keep the peace everywhere would be utterly dashed?

To reflect on VE-Day is to realize how pitifully limited is our capacity to predict the future.  Experience thus warns us against both optimism and pessimism.  The past fifty years of astonishing progress and appalling retrogression confirm yet again that Pope was right to describe our species as “in endless error hurled; / The glory, jest, and riddle of the world”.

Norman Fruman is Professor of English at the University of Minnesota.  He is the author of Coleridge: The Damaged Archangel, 1972, and is preparing an edition of Coleridge’s Biographia Literaria.

______________________________

Though his name is listed in the 1947 compilation American Jews in World War II (on page 316 of Volume II, to be specific) Norman’s essay – unlike that of Rabbi Leonard Winograd – despite its detail, depth, and literary quality, lacks either mention of allusion to any aspect of having been a Jewish infantry officer in combat against the Third Reich, and, a Jewish POW in German captivity.  The reasons for the curious “absence” of these topics – a literary kind of “dog that didn’t quite bark”, let alone growl! – are open to conjecture…    

This is unfortunate, for a reading of his article reveals that Dr. Fruman manifested the invaluable ability to view events – events personal; events collective – in the context of a time span beyond their immediacy.  This is especially evident in terms of the article’s last five paragraphs, which focus upon the enormous changes that have ensued in the United States in particular, and the world in general (well, at least the now deliberately-self-atrophying “West”) in the then fifty – and now in 2019 seventy-four – gad, is it seventy-four? – years since the war’s end in 1945. 

The central and overlapping “take-aways” that emerge are a deep and obvious sense of disillusionment about the post-WW II emphasis on the centrality of the chimera otherwise known as “higher education”; the effects of the enormous sociological changes that have eventuated and continue so, at an unrelenting pace – from scientific and technological developments (particularly in terms of the relationship between the sexes, and ensuing economic and sociological changes in society); ultimately, a sense of humility in terms of mans’ “limited capacity to predict the future”. 

This trio of realizations is anticipated in two newspaper articles – from 1959 and 1995 – (via Fulton History) quoting Dr. Fruman’s opinion about I.Q. tests, (“They do NOT evaluate creativity, reasoning power, or judgement.”), and, the imperative to study and evaluate literature as art, rather than viewing texts through the ideological prisms of “race, class, and sex.”

These two articles follow: 

Old Newspapers

This Week
August 23, 1959

Question 5: “What do I.Q. tests really measure?” Mrs. Perry Davis of Wapello, Iowa, writes.

Answer: Norman Fruman, professor and quiz-show winner: I.Q. tests measure acquired knowledge in certain academic areas.  Unfortunately, such an examination does not mirror certain mental traits which may be much more important than academic learning and ability to memorize.  They do NOT evaluate creativity, reasoning power, or judgement.

Incidentally, one team of intelligence researchers rates about 2.2 per cent of the American population as “very superior” in intellect.

Old Newspapers

Professors Reject Political Correctness

Richmond County Daily Journal & Moore County Citizen News-Record
September 20, 1995

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) – English professor Norman Fruman is fed up with the kind of literary criticism that reduces Shakespeare to an apologist for European hegemony and sees a lesbian subtext in every Emily Dickinson poem.

Fruman, a University of Minnesota English professor emeritus, just wants to read, analyze and talk about literature as art.  He’s sick of analyzing novels and poems for what they say about the politics of race, class and sex.

So Fruman and like-minded colleagues have formed an organization that aspires to promote literature as fine writing foremost.

The Association of Literary Scholars and Critics holds its first conference this weekend in Minnneapolis.  The group was formed in February 1944 and has more than 1,300 members.

For those of us who entered teaching because we had fallen in love with literature, nothing is more urgent than a return to an open, rather than a close, reading of stories and poems and plays that convey the very stuff of human life,” Roger Shattuck of Boston University, a member of the association, write in a recent article about the group in Civilization, the magazine of the Library of Congress.

Shattuck recalled a student in his sophomore humanities course who presented an Emily Dickinson poem on bird hopping, feeding, pausing and taking flight as a metaphor for a lesbian sexual encounter.  When asked about the versification and literal meaning, the student had nothing to add, he said.
Taught from a political point of view, Shakespeare is not the bard of Avon but a cheerleader for the British Empire, complained Professor John Ellis of the University of California, Santa Cruz, secretary-treasurer of ALSC.

Teachers “think that’s the most important thing you can say about Shakespeare, is that he was an apologist for European domination,” Ellis said.  “Why would one bother to make statements about Shakespeare that you could make about any Elizabethan?”

Fruman said association members want to “get back to the feeling about literature that made them readers in the first place.”

Politics Not Literature

“If you take ‘Moby Dick’ and spend a lot of time on why there are no women in the book, then you’re talking politics and not the book,” Fruman said.

“The question is a very interesting one in general, but once you’ve made the statement, how long does it take to deal with it?”, he said.  “To make that a major issue might be appropriate in a course on sociology or social studies, but it’s a perversion of literature to deal with such matters extensively.”

If this was foresight and wisdom in 1959 and 1995, how much more so is it in 2019?  And, beyond?

Other Jewish prisoners of war captured on January 5, 1945, include:

United States Army

PFC Saul E. Lipnick (1110175), 42nd Infantry Division, 232rd Infantry Regiment, Silver Star, Purple Heart
Stalag 5B (Villingen)

Pvt. Milton M. Roth (13185360), 35th Infantry Division, 134th Infantry Regiment
Stalag Lust III (Sagan)

PFC Morris Weiner (36752698), 1st Infantry Division, 16th Infantry Regiment
Stalag 11B (Fallingbostel)

(Oddly, I’m unable to find any information about the capture of an “E.T. Levy”, quoted in the Post article of 1957.)

Royal Canadian Air Force

Flight Officer David Elkin (J/39299), Navigator, No. 408 Squadron, on 28th mission
Born Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada, July 1, 1923
Mr. S. Elkin (father) and Pvt. Eugene Elkin (brother), 4587 Marcil Ave., Montreal, Quebec, Canada

Crew member of Halifax III NR209, EQ * A, piloted by F/Lt. Andrew F. Scheelar, shot down by Ju-88 during mission to Hannover, Germany at 19:50 hours.  Aircraft crashed near Hohlstedt (Hollenstede?), about three miles (2 km?) south of Furstenau, Hannover. 

Three survivors from crew of seven: Besides F/O Elkin, these comprised F/O Fred Alfred Winter (air bomber) and air gunner (tail gunner?) F/O William Albert Baker

According to F/O Elkin’s biographical entry in Canadian Jews in World War II, “…the pilot [F/Lt. Scheelar] and flight engineer [Sgt. John Daly] … sacrificed their lives by holding the plane steady while the others parachuted out.  After two days of freedom F/O Elkin was captured by the German S.S., and interned at Luchenwald.” 

Flight Lieutenant Andrew F. Scheelar, J/13449, from his military Service File, available within the database “Canada, WWII Service Files of War Dead, 1939-1947”, at Ancestry.com.   Born in Kimball, Minnesota, and residing at Strome, Alberta before joining the RCAF, he is buried at the Sage War Cemetery, in Germany

The last report about Halifax NR209, also from F/Lt. Scheelar’s Military service file.  Note that every crew member had completed more than twenty “trips”.   

Given that neither duckduckgo nor the search engine headquartered at Mountain View (y’know, where it’s asserted that “the moral arc of history bends toward progress” (1) … oops, I digress!) yield records for a POW camp by the name of “Luchenwald”, could F/O Elkin actually have been imprisoned at Buchenwald? 

I do not know, but the phonetic coincidence is intriguing.    

In any event, F/O Elkin returned to the United Kingdom on May 14, 1945.

______________________________

Sidney Thomas’ letter to the New York Review of Books in April, 1990, in response to Istvan Deak’s ‘The Incomprehensible Holocaust’: An Exchange” (2) is far shorter than Norman’s essay (but of course – it’s a letter!).  Its central focus is a discussion of the reasons for the survival of Jewish POWs of the Third Reich – specifically Jewish POWs from the armed forces of the United States and British Commonwealth (and perhaps by implication, other “western” nations) – within the larger context of the Shoah.  Though not mentioned by Deak, this is especially notable in comparison with the fate of Jewish POWs in German captivity, who were members of the armed forces of Poland and the Soviet Union. 

Sidney attributes this – I think quite correctly – to self-interest on the part of the mens’ captors, who did not wish to place themselves in postwar jeopardy as war criminals, given the realization (albeit not to all) of an eventual Allied victory.

Here’s Sidney’s letter:

IN STALAG VIIA

New York Review of Books
April 12, 1990

To the Editors:

May I add a footnote to Istvan Deak’s statement [“’The Incomprehensible Holocaust’: An Exchange,” NYR, February 1] that “German fairness towards Allied prisoners of war was even extended to Jews in British or American uniform: they alone of all the Jews in Nazi captivity had little to worry about.”  As a Jew and an American prisoner of war in Stalag VIIA at Moosburg, near Munich, where I arrived on December 15, 1944 in transit from a processing camp at Ludwigsburg, I encountered no overt discrimination for several months.  However, early in 1945 (I am not certain of the exact date) an order came down from the camp administration segregating all Jewish prisoners and forbidding them to go into Munich on work details with the other prisoners.  Whether this was meant as a first step in future measures against Jewish prisoners, we never learned.  Fortunately, nothing further came of this order, and after some time, as I recall, we were able to take part, once again, in the regular routine of the camp.  I would assume that this abortive attempt at special treatment of Jewish prisoners had its origin in a directive from higher Nazi authority and was not confined to Stalag VIIA.  If we “had little to worry about,” it was not, in my opinion, because of “German fairness” but because of Nazi fears, certainly in the lower echelons, at a time when Germany was clearly losing the war, of future punishment as war criminals.

Sidney Thomas
Syracuse, New York

 _____________________________

Sidney’s supposition about the early-1945 order for the segregation of Jewish POWs at Ludwigsburg having been issued from a “higher Nazi authority” may have very solid basis in fact.  The segregation of Jewish POWs at Stalag Luft I (Barth), and, Stalag 9B (Bad Ord) (from which 350 American POWs, including 77 Jewish soldiers, were sent to the Berga am Elster slave labor camp) transpired during the same time-frame in mid-January of 1945: At Stalag Luft I on January 10 (according to Mozart Kaufman), and at Stalag 9A, during the evening of January 18-19 (according to Sydney Goodman).  This suggests that orders for the segregation of American Jewish POWs emanated from the same level or body within the German military hierarchy. 

Though his name does not appear in American Jews in World War II (akin to innumerable American Jewish servicemen whose names should have appeared therein), I believe that Syracusan letter-writer Sidney Thomas was a PFC (32788833) in the 399th Infantry Regiment of the 100th Infantry Division, and was captured on November 21, 1944.  If correct (I think so…) his status as a liberated POW was noted in the Long Island Star Journal on June 19, 1945, where his wife was listed as Rae Thomas, at 73-12 35th Ave., in Jackson Heights, New York. 

Other Jewish prisoners of war captured on November 21, 1944, include:

United States Army

S/Sgt. Jacob Eines (32787009), 47th Infantry Regiment, 9th Infantry Division
Stalag 12A (Limburg an der Lahn)

PFC Isaac Geller (32894672)
Stalag 2A (Neubrandenburg)

PFC Jack Rubin (34543743), 334th Infantry Regiment, 84th Infantry Division
Stalag 11B (Fallingbostel)

Pvt. Ira S. Shulman (32645751), 406th Infantry Regiment, 102nd Infantry Division
Stalag 12A (Limburg an der Lahn)

PFC Charles Soloff (34493463), 143rd Infantry Regiment, 36th (“Texas”) Infantry Division
Stalag 7A (Moosburg)

United States Army Air Force (8th Air Force)

T/Sgt. Albert Miller (33777588), Radio Operator
359th Bomb Squadron, 303rd Bomb Group
Hohe Mark Hospital

S/Sgt. David Levy (16078484), Tail Gunner
603rd Bomb Squadron, 398th Bomb Group
Stalag Luft IV (Gross-Tychow)

1 Lt. Matthew I. Radnofsky (0-717500), Navigator
423rd Bomb Squadron, 306th Bomb Group
Vechta; Stalag 11B Lager Lazaret Fallingbostel

861st Bomb Squadron, 493rd Bomb Group (Auerbach and Edgar)

S/Sgt. Merle Auerbach (36760072), Waist Gunner
Stalag Luft IV (Gross-Tychow)

2 Lt. Richard Edgar (0-886467), Navigator
Stalag Luft I (Barth)

2 Lt. Harold Scheer (0-694733), Navigator
359th Bomb Squadron, 303rd Bomb Group
Stalag Luft I (Barth), North Compound 3

2 Lt. Marvin Laufer (0-710281), Bombardier / Navigator
603rd Bomb Squadron, 398th Bomb Group
Hohe Mark Hospital

References

Canadian Jews in World War II – Part II: Casualties, Canadian Jewish Congress, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, 1948, p. 121

Chorley, W.R., Royal Air Force Bomber Command Losses of the Second World War – 1944 (Volume VI), Midland Publishing, Hinckley, England, 1998, p. 34

Kaufman, Mozart, Fighter Pilot – Aleutians to Normandy to Stalag Luft 1, M&A Kaufman Publishers, San Aselmo, Ca., 1993

Dublin, Louis I., and Kohs, Samuel C., American Jews in World War II – The Story of 550,000 Fighters for Freedom, The Dial Press, New York, N.Y., 1947

Goodman, Sydney L., Private, 36889334, M Company, 110th Infantry Regiment, 28th Infantry Division, Prisoner of War at Stalag 9B and Berga-am-Elster, Diary covering events from December 16, 1944, through March 16, 1945.

Comments

(1) The combination of hubris and shallow thinking inherent in such a belief is as frightening as it is staggering.

(2) Contemplated through the overlapping perspectives of Eliezer Berkovits, David Birnbaum, Hyam Maccoby, William Nicholls, and Robert S. Wistrich, the Shoah is not nearly as incomprehensible, mysterious, or perplexing as once – and perhaps still? – assumed.    

Soldiers from New York: Jewish Soldiers in The New York Times, in World War Two: A Soldier from Germany – T/4 Alexander H. Hersh (January 21, 1945)

Oftimes in our world, a “story” – ostensibly minor and of little immediate notice – is embedded within a larger tale, and will only become revealed; it not apparent; if not finally noticed, with the passage of time:

Think of a Russian Matryoshka doll, manifest in words and memories… 

One such story – in reality, a multiplicity of stories, part of the larger historical episode of the participation of Jewish soldiers in the Second World War – is the military service of German and Austrian-born Jewish servicemen in the armed forces of the Allied nations.      

In recent years, this topic has increasingly become the focus of books, documentaries, and news items, examples of which include Bruce Henderson’s Sons and Soldiers: The Untold Story of the Jews Who Escaped the Nazis and Returned with the U.S. Army to Fight Hitler; Steve Karas’ 2005 About Face: The Story of the Jewish Refugee Soldiers of World War II; Arthur Allen’s 2011 Politico’s story The Jewish Immigrants Who Helped the U.S. Take on Nazis; and most recently Lisa Ades GI Jews – Jewish Americans in World War II, which was broadcast on PBS on April 11.

The all-too-brief brief story about one such man appeared in The New York Times on March 1, 1945, in the form of an obituary for Technician 4th Grade (T/4) Alexander H. Hersh, serial number 32417431.

Alexander served as a radio operator for Battalion Commander Colonel William J. Boydstun, in the 317th Infantry Regiment of the 80th Infantry Division.  He was killed by artillery fire from a German railroad gun on the morning of January 21, 1945, during a retaliatory offensive towards Bourscheid, Luxembourg, along with Colonel Boydstun, 313th Field Artillery Battalion, Forward Observer Lt. Joe R. Clark, PFC Ernest H. Fuller, and Sgt. Emil Tumolo.  The sole survivor of the group – remarkably uninjured – was Cpl. Robert H. Burrows, whose detailed account of the incident, entitled “Grabbing an Opportunity”, appeared in the August, 2013 issue of The Bulge Bugle

Paralleling the accounts about S/Sgt. Heinz H. Thannhauser and PFC George E. Rosing in Aufbau, (at The Reconstruction of Memory: Soldiers of Aufbau), news about Sgt. Hirsch also appeared in that publication.  The newspaper’s February 23 issue (his name later being mentioned on March 9) published a brief notice about his death, which was accompanied by the same portrait that appeared in the Times

That announcement and its translation follow below, followed by an image of the article, and, his portrait.

Für die Freiheit gefallen
Sgt. Alexander H. Hirsch

ist am 21 Januar im Alter von 23 Jahren bei den schweren Kämpfen der Dritten Armee von General Patton in Luxembourg gefallen.  Sgt. Hirsch wurde in Karlsruhe geboren und ist 1937 in Amerika eigewandert.  Nachdem alle seine Angehörigen von den Nazis verschleppt worden waren, hatte er sich als Freiwillger zur amerikanischen Armee gemeldet.

Fallen For Freedom
Sgt. Alexander H. Hirsch

died on January 21 at the age of 23 in the heavy fighting of General Patton’s Third Army in Luxembourg.  Sgt. Hirsch was born in Karlsruhe and immigrated to America in 1937.  After all his relatives had been kidnapped by the Nazis, he had volunteered for the US Army.

Born in Karlsruhe, Germany, on July 3, 1921, Alexander resided with his uncle Isidore at 22 Central Park South, in Manhattan, seen below. 

The recipient of the Purple Heart, he is buried at Grave 9135, Section H, of the Long Island National Cemetery, in Farmingdale, N.Y.  His name appeared in the Times in an official Casualty List on March 15, and can be found on page 344 of American Jews in World War II.

(Curiously, though both the Times and Aufbau give Alexander’s surname as “Hirsch”, the surname actually was “Hersh”, which appears in the World War II Honor List of Dead and Missing Army and Army Air Forces Personnel from New York, and, on his matzeva.)

Some other Jewish military casualties on Sunday, January 21, 1945, include the following…

Killed in Action
– .ת.נ.צ.ב.ה. –

Allen, Edwin W., 2 Lt., 0-785157, Bombardier, Purple Heart
United States Army Air Force, 10th Air Force, 7th Bomb Group, 9th Bomb Squadron
Born 1925
Mr. Reuben Allen (father), 4740 Bedford Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.
No MACR, Aircraft B-24J 42-73311, Pilot 2 Lt. Roy W. Howser, 8 crew – no survivors
Cemetery location unknown
Casualty List 3/20/45
American Jews in World War II – 265

Ben Hammou
, Georges Isaac (AC-21P-19263) France (Algeria), (At Region of Schuvergausse, Haut-Rhin, France)

French Army, 9eme Bataillon Médical, 2eme Compagnie de Ramassage
Born January 27, 1923
Algerie, Oran, Perregaux
Place of burial – unknown

____________________

Though the famous T-34 tank is emblematic of the armored forces of the Soviet Union during the Second World War, the U.S.S.R. received 4,102 American M4A2 Sherman tanks via Lend-Lease.  Wikipedia entries for the M4 Sherman can be found in English (here), and Russian (here).

One such tank was commanded by Guards Junior Lieutenant [Гвардии Младший Лейтенант] Yakov Moiseevich Blat [Яков Моисеевич Блат] from Proskurov, who was killed in action at Kápolnásnyék, Hungary. 

U.S.S.R. [C.C.C.Р.], Red Army [РККА [Рабоче-крестьянская Красная армия]], 1st Ukrainian Front, 1st Guards Mechanized Corps, 2nd Guards Mechanized Brigade, 19th Guards Tank Regiment

Year and Place of Birth: 1921; Proskurov, Kamenets-Podolsk Oblast, Ukraine
Buried 1 km. east of Kápolnásnyék, Hungary.

____________________

Cooper, Fred H., S/Sgt., 39093677, Purple Heart
United States Army
Born 1907
Mr. Morris Cooper (father), 1515 North West Everett St., Portland, Or. / Santa Cruz, Ca.
Ahavai Shalom Cemetery, Portland, Or. – 103, 31
American Jews in World War II – 506

Dement / Diment [Демент / Димент], Moisey Borisovich [Моисей Борисович], Guards Senior Lieutenant [Гвардии Старший Лейтенант]
Tank Commander/ Platoon Commander – T-34 Tank
U.S.S.R. [C.C.C.Р.], Red Army [РККА [Рабоче-крестьянская Красная армия]], 2nd Guards Tank Brigade
Killed in action at Gumbinnen, Prussia
Year and Place of Birth: 1909; Chernivtsi, Ukraine

Gamburg [Гамбург], Lev Zinovevich [Лев Зиновьевич], Private [Рядовой], Sapper [Сапер]
U.S.S.R. [C.C.C.Р.], Red Army [РККА [Рабоче-крестьянская Красная армия]], 181st Tank Brigade

Gelfer, Howard L., Cpl., 32647108, Purple Heart (in Belgium)
United States Army, 30th Infantry Division, 230th Field Artillery Battalion
Born 1921
Mrs. Ada S. Gelfer (mother), 2754 Grand Concourse, Bronx, N.Y.
Long Island National Cemetery, Farmingdale, N.Y. – Section H, Grave 8131
Casualty List 3/8/45
American Jews in World War II – 318

This image of Cpl. Gelfer’s matzeva is by FindAGrave Contributor Maryann.

Gelsman, Eugene, 2 Lt., 0-571762
United States Army Air Force, Air Transport Command
Died in a jeep accident in Algeria
Born June 4, 1921
Mr. and Mrs. Harry J. [5/4/92-6/20/72] and Caroline [9/19/95-4/25/57] Gelsman (parents), S/Sgt. Arthur and PFC Norman (brothers), 1611 Nedro Ave., Philadelphia, Pa.
Roosevelt Memorial Park, Trevose, Philadelphia, Pa. – Lot U, Plot 141, Grave 4; Buried 5/30/48
Jewish Exponent 6/4/48
Philadelphia Inquirer 5/29/48
American Jews in World War II – 523

Horowitz, Morris M., Pvt., 32656830, Purple Heart
United States Army, 94th Infantry Division, 301st Infantry Regiment
Born 1911
Mrs. Rose Horowitz (wife), c/o Fisher, 234 NE 47th St., Miami, Fl.
Luxembourg American Cemetery, Luxembourg City, Luxembourg – Plot A, Row 6, Grave 11
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Kendall, Milton R., 1 Lt., 0-1303902, Purple Heart (Belgium)
United States Army
Born July 23, 1914
Mr. Abraham S. Kendall (father), 19 Darwood Place, Mount Vernon, N.Y.
Sgt. Irving B. Kendall (brother), Mrs. Jerome J. Slote (sister)
Arlington National Cemetery, Arlington, Va. – Section 12, Grave 2710
Mount Vernon Daily Argus 2/13/45
American Jews in World War II – 361

This image of Lt. Kendall’s matzeva is by FindAGrave Contributor Anne Cady.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

Lang, Marvin, PFC, 42024449, Purple Heart
United States Army, 94th Infantry Division, 301st Infantry Regiment, B Company
Born Rochester, N.Y., June 8, 1923
Mr. and Mrs. Charles and Fay Lang (parents), Seymour (brother), 24 OK Terrace, Rochester, N.Y.
Britton Road Cemetery, Rochester, N.Y. – Beth Israel Hock Hochodosh Section; Buried 5/29/49
Casualty List 10/3/45
Rochester Democrat and Chronicle 12/16/45
American Jews in World War II – 371

A photo of PFC Lang’s matzeva, by Robert Coomber, of the Rochester Genealogical Society…

Levi [Леви], Filipp Semenovich [Филипп Семенович], Junior Lieutenant [Младший Лейтенант]
Tank Commander – T-34 Tank
U.S.S.R. [C.C.C.Р.], Red Army [РККА [Рабоче-крестьянская Красная армия]], 89th Tank Brigade, 3rd Tank Battalion
Lightly wounded in action twice previously [Слегка раненый в действии дважды ранее] – 8/2/42 and 6/25/44
Year and Place of Birth: 1924; Krimskaya ASSR; City of Karasu-Bazar

Levin [Левин], Lev Moiseevich [Лев Моисеевич], Lieutenant [Лейтенант]
Company Commander – Motorized Submachine Gun Battalion [Командир Роты Моторизованного Батальона Автоматчнков]
U.S.S.R. [C.C.C.Р.], Red Army [РККА [Рабоче-крестьянская Красная армия]], 1st Byelorussian Front, 9th Tank Corps, 23rd Tank Brigade
Year and Place of Birth: 1923; Stalinskaya Oblast; City of Nikitovna

____________________

A review of Missing Air Crew Reports for B-17 and B-24 losses of the 8th and 15th Air Forces – as well as personal memoirs and historical literature covering the air war over Europe – reveals that mid-air collisions between heavy bombardment aircraft during combat and training missions were – alas – sadly not uncommon. 

On such incident occurred on January 21, 1945, in the skies southwest of Stuttgart, Germany.  (Another will be recounted below.) 

That day, as covered in Missing Air Crew Reports 11759 and 11760, two Hell’s Angel’s (303rd Bomb Group) Flying Fortresses were lost during the Group’s mission to the marshalling yards at Aschaffenburg.  The planes, flying at 23,000 feet, collided at the Group’s turning point, prior to the IP (Initial Point) of the bomb run: The right wing of the aircraft leading the squadron formation (Scorchy II, 42-95078, piloted by 2 Lt. Richard A. Tasker) colliding with the left wing of the lead plane of the second flight (the “un-nicknamed” 44-8137, a radar-equipped pathfinder aircraft piloted by 1 Lt. Richard B. Duffield). 

The damaged wings of both planes broke away, and the two aircraft fell to earth.  Luftgaukommando Report KU 3625, for 44-8137 (curiously, there appears to be no Luftgaukommando Report for Scorchy II; at least no such document is associated with MACR 11760!) records that the plane (therefore both planes?) crashed 1 kilometer southeast of Lossburg, or, 9 kilometers southeast of Freudenstadt.   

Of the twenty men aboard the two aircraft – ten in each plane – only two escaped: 1 Lt. James C. Flemmons, bombardier of 44-8137, and Sgt. Arthur H. Driver, tail gunner of Scorchy II.  Sgt. Driver escaped from within the severed tail of Scorchy II only 1,000 feet above the ground, miraculously managing to deploy his partially attached parachute a moment later, for a hard but safe landing.  Both he and Lt. Flemmons survived the war as POWs.

The flight engineer of 44-8137 was T/Sgt. Raymond Levine, of the Bronx.  On December 7, 1944, only one and a half months prior to her father’s last mission, a photograph of his six-month-old daughter, Susan Roberta, appeared in the New York Post, accompanied by a letter from her mother, Phyllis, found via Thomas Tryniski’s FultonHistory website

(The following letter and photograph came to The Post from the wife of Technical Sergeant Raymond Levine, gunner on a B-17, who is serving overseas.)

Dear Editor: Will you please published the enclosed picture in your paper, as an inducement to sell war bonds?  The baby’s name is Susan Roberta Levine, age six months. – MRS. PHYLLIS LEVINE

New York State Digital library

Levine, Raymond, T/Sgt., 32422716, Flight Engineer, Air Medal, 3 Oak Leaf Clusters, Purple Heart
United States Army Air Force, 8th Air Force, 303rd Bomb Group, 359th Bomb Squadron
Mrs. Phyllis S. Levine (wife), Susan Roberta Levine (daughter; born July, 1944) 1819 Weeks Ave., Bronx, N.Y.
National WW II Memorial Honoree Record by Grace Weiner

MACR 11759, Luftgaukommando Report KU 3625, Aircraft B-17G 44-8137, Pilot 1 Lt. Richard B. Duffield, 10 crew – 1 survivor (1 Lt. James C. Flemmons, Bombardier)
Lorraine American Cemetery, St. Avold, France – Plot J, Row 43, Grave 17
New York Post 12/7/44
American Jews in World War II – 378

This image of T/Sgt. Levine’s matzeva is by FindAGrave Contributor Suzanne Hye.

____________________

While serving on screen and radar picket duty as a part of Fast Carrier Task Group 38.1 of the 3rd Fleet, the destroyer USS Maddox (DD-731) was hit by a Kamikaze suicide-plane (specifically, a Mitsubishi Zero fighter) while off the coast of Formosa.  The aircraft, carrying an aerial bomb estimated to have weighed 100 pounds, struck the ship’s starboard superstructure.  The explosion and fire killed eight sailors and wounded and thirty-five.     

Among the casualties was Seaman Harry Paul, whose name appeared in the Philadelphia Record in mid-March.  But – like many Jewish WW II servicemen and military casualties from the Philadelphia area – his name never appeared in The Jewish Exponent.  Like many Jewish Philadelphians of that era, he hailed from (south) Philadelphia; in his family’s case, the Whitman section of that city.    

Paul, Harry, S1C, 2463835, Seaman, Purple Heart
United States Navy, USS Maddox
Born 1926
Mr. Samuel Paul (father); Jack (brother), 2635 S. 7th St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Tablets of the Missing at Manila American Cemetery, Manila, Philippines
Philadelphia Record 3/14/45
American Jews in World War II – 542

____________________

Two Flying Fortresses were lost in a mid-air collision over Germany, and two other B-17s were similarly lost in the skies of England… 

As the 381st Bomb Group returned to its base at Ridgewell from the 8th Air Force’s mission to Aschaffenburg, two aircraft on the base leg of the landing pattern – neither actually with the Group’s formation – were flying between 1,000 and 1,500 feet.  B-17G 42-40011 (GD * O, SCHNOZZLE, of the 532nd Bomb Squadron, piloted by F/O Nicholas P. Tauro) attempted to climb over B-17G 42-97511 (MS * K, Egg Haid of the 535th Bomb Squadron, piloted by 2 Lt. James E. Smith) but instead collided with that aircraft.  The incident is covered in Missing Air Crew Report 15283. 

Both planes fell to earth southwest of the airdrome. 

Two Army Air Force images of Schnozzle (named after singer, comedian, and actor Jimmy Durante, and assigned to the 532nd Bomb Squadron almost exactly one year previously) are shown below.  The black and white image, photo C-65837AC / A46358, was taken on March 31, 1944, while the Army Air Force color image K2198 is also available via the American Air Museum in England.  Also shown is the simple nose art of Egg Haid, photo A-65835AC / A-46348. 

Radio Operator S/Sgt. Morris Shapiro and Navigator F/O Seymour L. Sobole were crewmen aboard SCHNOZZLE.  Flight Officer Sobole’s award of the Purple Heart – and no Air Medals – would suggest that he had flown fewer than five combat missions, while S/Sgt. Shapiro had probably flown less than 15.   

Shapiro, Morris A., S/Sgt., 32716674, Radio Operator, Air Medal, 1 Oak Leaf Cluster, Purple Heart
Mrs. Sylvia Shapiro (wife), 1718 Washington Ave., Bronx, N.Y.
Casualty List 3/27/45
Cambridge American Cemetery, Cambridge, England – Plot C, Row D, Grave 24
Brooklyn Eagle 6/20/44
American Jews in World War II – 196, 439

Morris’ matzeva, in a photo by julia&keld…

Sobole, Seymour L. (Yekutiel Yehudah Bar Reuben), F/O, T-128479, Navigator, Purple Heart
Born 1922
Mr. and Mrs. Robert E. [1891-2/21/50] and May Devora [1899-6/28/82] Sobole (parents), 108 Woodmere Ave., Detroit, Mi.
Nusach Harai Cemetery, Ferndale, Mi. – Grave G-184 / Congregation Beth Tefilo Cemetery, Ferndale, Mi. – Section G, Row 2
American Jews in World War II – 196

This image of the matzeva of Seymour and his parents is by FindAGrave contributor Gilly.

____________________

Stone, Leonard Alfred, Trooper, 6027261, England
British Army, 141st Regiment (7th Buffs)
Born 1913
Mrs. Harriet Stone (wife), Whitechapel, London, England
Sittard War Cemetery, Limburg, Netherlands – K,15
We Will Remember Them – A Record of the Jews Who Died in the Armed Forces of the Crown 1939 – 1945 – 166

Tibber, Jack, Pvt., 13085593, England
British Army, Pioneer Corps
Born 1906
Mrs. Eva Tibber (wife), 10 Chester House, 130 New Cavendish St., Marylebone, London, W1, England
Mr. and Mrs. Morris and Anne Tibber (parents)
The Jewish Chronicle 2/16/45
Schoonselhof Cemetery, Antwerpen, Belgium – V,A,90
We Will Remember Them – A Record of the Jews Who Died in the Armed Forces of the Crown 1939 – 1945 – 170

Weiner
, Morris, Pvt., 32413350, Purple Heart

United States Army, 2nd Infantry Division, 23rd Infantry Regiment
Born 1921
Mr. Harry Weiner (father), 370 S. 2nd St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Long Island National Cemetery, Farmingdale, N.Y. – Section H, Grave 10425
Casualty List 3/14/45
American Jews in World War II – 467

Zaltsman / Zaytsman [Зальцман / Зайцман], Petr Abramovich [Петр Абрамович], Senior Technician-Lieutenant [Старший Техник-Лейтенант]
Deputy Company Commander – Technical Section [Заместитель по Технический Части Командира Роты]
U.S.S.R. [C.C.C.Р.], Red Army [РККА [Рабоче-крестьянская Красная армия]], 181st Tank Brigade, 3rd Tank Battalion
Year and Place of Birth: 1919; Mohyliv-Podilsky, Vinnytsia Oblast
Buried at Sóskút, Hungary

____________________

United States Navy
Aboard the Aircraft Carrier USS Ticonderoga (CV-14)

The destroyer USS Maddox was not the only United States Navy ship that was struck by Kamikaze aircraft on the twenty-first of January.  The aircraft carrier USS Ticonderoga, part of Task Force 38, was among the Task Force’s three Task Groups whose aircraft struck airfields on Formosa, in the Pescadores (an archipelago of islands west of Taiwan, in the Taiwan Strait), and at Sakashima Gunto (an archipelago at the southernmost end of the Japanese archipelago).

The carrier was struck by two Kamikaze aircraft.  The first crashed through the ship’s flight deck and exploded just above the hangar deck, killing men and destroying several aircraft.  Damage was kept under control under the directions of Captain Dixie Kiefer, who, by changing the ship’s course and selectively flooding magazines and other compartments, induced a list which eventually dumped the fire overboard. 

The ship then underwent an attack by four more Kamikazes.  Three were shot down into the sea, but the fourth impacted the carrier’s starboard side near the island, the explosion of the plane’s bomb and the resulting fires killing a further 100 crewmen and injuring others, among the latter Captain Kiefer.  The fires were brought under control not long after two in the afternoon, and the ship retired, reaching Ulithi (in the Caroline islands) three days later.

The impact of the second kamikaze can be seen in this film, which clearly shows the ship’s list.

According to the Aviation Archeology database, the Kamikaze attacks on the Ticonderoga resulted in the loss of 31 F6F Hellcats fighters, 4 SB2C Helldiver dive-bombers, and 5 TBM Avenger torpedo-bombers.  A solitary Helldiver and a single Avenger were also lost during combat missions that day, with their crews having been rescued. 

The following three films show the results of the kamikaze strikes on the Ticonderoga. 

The first film, from the YouTube channel of Colonel Tannenbusch, very clearly shows the impact of one of the Kamikazes (at 0:24) upon the Ticonderoga, and, from 0:51 to 1:14, the list by which Captain Kiefer was able to control the fire.   

The second film, recorded shortly after the ship was struck by (probably…) the second Kamikaze, shows (from 0:00 to 8:40) damage to the ship, the crew’s efforts to contain and control fire raging on and within the ship’s flight and hangar decks, and efforts to aid wounded crewmen.  The remainder of the film shows damage to the hangar deck, a damaged Hellcat fighter, and the jettisoning of Hellcat from the flight deck.  Produced on January 29, 1945, the film was discovered at the WWIIPublicDomain YouTube channel, having first been uploaded to the Internet Archive.  (The film is Naval Photographic Center film 428-NPC-6982 (local identified 428-NPC-6982; United States National Archives Identifier 77925.) 

The third film, produced on November 21, 1945, shows battle damage to the flight deck and island of the Ticonderoga, and, the jettisoning of damaged aircraft into the waters of the Pacific.

Scenes are the following:

0:09 – 0:31: Flight deck and island of the carrier.
0:32 – 0:51:  A damaged F6F Hellcat is jettisoned from the carrier’s deck.  Notice the damage to the aircraft’s wing from the heat of the fire.
0:52 – 1:01:  Damaged to the carrier’s island.
1:02 – 1:04:  Another aircraft is jettisoned.
1:05 – 1:47: Closer views of damage to the island.
1:48 – 2:48: Another Hellcat is jettisoned, albeit leaving the ship with tremendous reluctance. 

The film was also discovered at the WWIIPublicDomain YouTube channel, also having first been uploaded to the Internet Archive.  (The film is Naval Photographic Center film 428-NPC-6981 (local identified 428-NPC-6981; United States National Archives Identifier 77924.)

Killed in Action aboard the USS Ticonderoga
– .ת.נ.צ.ב.ה. –

Lifland, Bernard, S1C, 9221115, Seaman, Purple Heart
Mrs. Grace Catherine Lifland (wife), 316 N. 9th St., Allentown, Pa.
Tablets of the Missing at Manila American Cemetery, Manila, Philippines
American Jews in World War II – 536

Maher, Miles Morris, S1C, 7123151, Seaman, Purple Heart
Mrs. Rose Maher (mother), 1627 York Ave., New York, N.Y.
Tablets of the Missing at Manila American Cemetery, Manila, Philippines
American Jews in World War II – 385

Wounded or Injured aboard the USS Ticonderoga

Kaufman, Harold Bernard, RT2C, Radio Technician, 7099966, Purple Heart
Mr. B. Kaufman (father), 892 Bergen St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Casualty List 4/30/45
American Jews in World War II – 359

Shestack
, Jerome Joseph (“Jerry”), Ensign or Lieutenant, Gunnery Officer, 0-256022, Purple Heart

Born Atlantic City, N.J., February 11, 1923; Died August 18, 2011
Mr. and Mrs. Isadore and Olga Shestack (parents), 5452 Lebanon Ave., Philadelphia, Pa.
Philadelphia Inquirer 8/20/11
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

A candid image of Jerome Shestack, from the Remembering Jerome J. Shestack (Gallery)

____________________

Prisoners of War

Applestine, Bernard, PFC, 33001573
United States Army, 30th Infantry Division, 120th Infantry Regiment
Prisoner of War at Stalag 12A (Limburg an der Lahn, Germany)
Born Maryland, December 19, 1918
Mr. and Mrs. Simeon and Rose H. (Miller) Applestine (parents), 3012 W. Garrison Ave., Baltimore, Md.
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Artin, Philip, Pvt., 42138150
United States Army, 45th Infantry Division, 157th Infantry Regiment
Prisoner of War at Stalag 11B (Fallingbostel, Germany)
Born New York, February 16, 1919
Mrs. Rose Artin (wife), 2114 Mapes Ave., Bronx, N.Y.
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Barlas, Benjamin, Pvt., 42138568
United States Army, 45th Infantry Division, 157th Infantry Regiment
Prisoner of War at Stalag 11B (Fallingbostel, Germany)
Born New York, 1923
Mr. and Mrs. Mordecai and Bella Barlas (parents), Dora (sister), 1817 Tenth Ave., Bronx, N.Y.
Casualty List 4/20/45
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Cohn, Albert D., Pvt., 13126322
United States Army, 94th Infantry Division, 301st Infantry Regiment
Prisoner of War at Stalag 11B (Fallingbostel, Germany)
Born Pennsylvania, December 14, 1922
Mr. and Mrs. Samuel and _____ (Shander) Cohn (parents), 5443 Wyndale Ave., Philadelphia, Pa.
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Fiman, Meyer, PFC, 37639179
United States Army, 45th Infantry Division, 157th Infantry Regiment
Prisoner of War at Stalag 12A (Limburg an der Lahn, Germany)
Born Missouri, April 4, 1912
Mr. and Mrs. Henry and Sylvia (Ratner) Fiman (parents), 1615 South Jefferson Ave., St. Louis, Mo.
(also) 5718 Waterman Blvd., St. Louis, Mo.
Saint Louis Post Disptach 2/15/45
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Fineblum, Solomon S., PFC, 33731236
United States Army, 94th Infantry Division, 301st Infantry Regiment, A Company
Prisoner of War at Stalag 11B (Fallingbostel, Germany)
Born Maryland, April 21, 1925
Mr. and Mrs. Morris and _____ (Rochlin) Fineblum (parents), Pvt. Jerome Fineblum (brother), 2501 Manhattan Ave., Baltimore, Md.
WW II Memorial Honoree Record by his friend, Chet Obukowicz
Jewish Times (Baltimore) 5/4/45
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Friedman, Abraham J., PFC, 33386834
United States Army, 94th Infantry Division, 301st Infantry Regiment
Prisoner of War at Stalag 12A (Limburg an der Lahn), and, Stalag 11B (Fallingbostel, Germany)
Born Maryland, July 27, 1915
Mrs. Nettie (Goldiner) Friedman (mother), 1618 McKean Ave., Baltimore, Md.
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Kaplan, Milton, PFC, 32598178
United States Army, 94th Infantry Division, 301st Infantry Regiment
Prisoner of War at Stalag 11B (Fallingbostel, Germany)
Born New Jersey, September 8, 1920
Mrs. Sarah Kaplan (mother), 126 Ridgewood / 507 Belmont Ave., Newark, N.J.
Casualty List 6/25/45
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Kaplan, Robert J., S/Sgt., 35146114
United States Army, 45th Infantry Division, 157th Infantry Regiment
Prisoner of War at Stalag 12A (Limburg an der Lahn, Germany)
Born Indiana, February 16, 1925
Mr. and Mrs. Ralph and _____ (Risman) Kaplan (parents), 612 Cleveland St., Garry, In.
WW II Honoree Record by “Susie, Steve, Nancy, Jim, Brian and Michael, Children and Grandchildren”
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Novick, Alvin, PFC, 42037918, Purple Heart
United States Army, 94th Infantry Division, 301st Infantry Regiment
Prisoner of War at Stalag 11B (Fallingbostel, Germany)
Born June 27, 1925
Mr. and Mrs. Irving (“Isidore”) and Lena (Janowitz) Novick (parents), Rosalind Novick (sister), 145-11 33rd Ave., Flushing, N.Y.
Studied Physics at Columbia University
Long Island Star Journal 5/22/45
American Jews in World War II – 400

____________________

Shapiro, Seymour, Pvt., 32649328, Purple Heart
United States Army, 45th Infantry Division, 157th Infantry Regiment
Prisoner of War at Stalag 11B (Fallingbostel, Germany); German POW Number 99435
Born New York, April 4, 1922
Mr. and Mrs. Samuel and Millie (Deskin) Shapiro (parents), 665 Riverdale Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.
American Jews in World War II – 62

Private Shapiro’s German POW Personalkarte (Personal Card) found in the National Archives, is shown below.  Though Personalkarte forms allocate a space for a POW’s identification (“mug shot”) photograph, the great majority of forms for American POWs at Stalag 11B lack such photographs.   

____________________

Shindel, Solomon, Cpl., 36852136, Ball Turret Gunner, Air Medal, 2 Oak Leaf Clusters, Purple Heart
United States Army Air Force, 8th Air Force, 486th Bomb Group, 833rd Bomb Squadron
Wounded; Prisoner of War (camp unknown)
MACR 11798, Luftgaukommando Reports KU 3602 and KU 3627, Aircraft B-17G 43-38925 (4N * T), Pilot 1 Lt. George W. Holdefer, 9 crew – all survived
Born May 5, 1919
Mrs. Sylvia Tutnick (sister), 17159 Greenlawn St., Detroit, Mi.
Casualty List 6/20/45
American Jews in World War II – 196

Shocket, Murray, Cpl., 42036772
United States Army, 45th Infantry Division, 157th Infantry Regiment
Prisoner of War at Stalag 12A (Limburg an der Lahn, Germany)
Born August 17, 1920
Mr. and Mrs. Michael and Gloria (Fink) Shocket (parents), 313 S. 5th St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Solomon, Isaac, PFC, 42055485, Purple Heart
United States Army, 45th Infantry Division, 157th Infantry Regiment
Prisoner of War at Stalag 11B (Fallingbostel, Germany)
Born New York, April 26, 1925
Mr. and Mrs. Max and S. (Sidransky) Solomon (parents), 190 E. 52nd St., Brooklyn, 3, N.Y.
American Jews in World War II – 419

Weingarten, Sol, PFC, 42034540
United States Army, 94th Infantry Division, 301st Infantry Regiment
Prisoner of War at Stalag 11B (Fallingbostel, Germany)
Born New York, 1923
Mr. and Mrs. Benjamin and Estelle Weingarten (parents), Anna, Bertha, and Moses (sisters and brother), 1496 Flatbush Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Casualty List 4/20/45
American Jews in World War II – Not listed

Wounded in Action

Three Jewish aviators who were killed during combat missions – T/Sgt. Raymond Levine, S/Sgt. Morris A. Schwartz, and F/O Seymour L. Sobole – have been mentioned above.

Two other Jewish Eighth Air Force fliers were also casualties on this day, but – both wounded – survived the war.  Coincidentally, they served in the same Bombardment Group (the 486th), in the same squadron (the 835th), and – as pilot and co-pilot of a Flying Fortress – within the cockpit of the same plane: B-17G 44-8615, otherwise known as Mary Lou (H8 * G).

They were Gerson Bacher and Nathan Spungin.

The aircraft was struck by a burst of flak during the 486th’s mission to Mannheim, Germany, shrapnel and debris from which blinded Lt. Bacher and severely injured Lt. Spungin’s legs.  Sharing control of Mary Lou, with Lt. Spungin manipulating the bomber’s control column and Lt. Bacher the aircraft’s rudder pedals, they brought the damaged plane back to a safe landing at Sudbury, England.

According to the 486th Bombardment Group Website, besides Lt. Spungin, Lieutenant Bacher’s crew consisted of:

Navigator (Dead-Reckoning):  Lt. Charles Monk
Navigator (Radar): Lt. Walter Dinwiddie
Bombardier: Lt. George “Pop” Edgar
Flight Engineer: T/Sgt. Charles “Blink” Blankenship
Radio Operator / Waist Gunner: T/Sgt. Alfred “Beam” Bain

Ball Turret Gunner: S/Sgt. Paul “Shorty” Bolduc
Waist Gunner: S/Sgt. William Curtis
Tail Gunner: S/Sgt. Albin “Red” Markiewicz

A (copyrighted, that’s why I’m linking to it!) image of the crew can he found here

…while a list of the crew’s missions appears here

…and Lieutenant Edgar’s diary of the crew’s missions (extending beyond January 21, 1945) can be read here

…with images of Mary Lou here and here.

The incident was briefly covered by the Associated Press, and in greater detail by the newspapers respectively serving Bayonne, New Jersey, and Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, for Bacher and Spungin.  They flew no further combat missions.

Also notable is his Lt. Bacher’s pre-war vocation:  He was a welder: A reminder of an age in which the value – moral as much as purely economic – of vocational trades was not obscured by the near-monolithic (and continuing, but eventually dissolving) primacy of academic credentials in post WW II America.

(But, that’s another subject!)

United States Army Air Force, 8th Air Force, 486th Bomb Group, 835th Bomb Squadron
Pilot and Co-Pilot – Both wounded
Aircraft B-17G 44-8615 (“H8 * G”, “Mary Lou”) – entire crew survived
News Item 3/5/45

Bacher, Gerson “Bach”, 1 Lt., 0-798231, Bomber Pilot, Silver Star, Air Medal, 2 Oak Leaf Clusters, Purple Heart, completed 22 combat missions
Born Harrisburg, Pa., October 11, 1920; Died March 15, 1989
Mrs. Mildred (Fastov) Bacher (wife), 399 Avenue C, Bayonne, N.J.
Mrs. Ruby Cohen (mother), 1132 Boulevard, Bayonne, N.J.
American Jews in World War II – 226

Spungin, Nathan “Sponge”, 1 Lt., 0-825704, Co-Pilot, Air Medal, 2 Oak Leaf Clusters, Purple Heart, completed 21 missions
Born Harrisburg, Pa., 10/11/20
Mrs. Elaine Ruth (Morris) Spungin (wife), Patricia Ann, Barbara Jean, and Janis Louise (daughters), 2801 Morgan St., Tampa, Fl.
Mr. and Mrs. Samuel and Fannie Spungin (parents), 2911 North Second St., Harrisburg, Pa.
Harrisburg Telegraph 12/30/44, 5/11/45
The Evening News (Harrisburg) 7/9/44, 2/19/45, 5/9/45
American Jews in World War II – 555

This pair of portraits show Lieutenants Bacher (left) and Spungin, the former image from a Bayonne newspaper and the latter from Nathan Spungin’s William Penn High School 1938 class yearbook.  (Thanks, Ancestry.com!)

Transcribed newspaper articles about the incident, found at FultonHistory, follow…

They Swapped Eyes and Legs

Albany Times-Union
1945

When a burst of Nazi flak all but tore the nose off a flying fortress, the bomber’s pilot, Lieut. Gerson Bacher, was blinded and his co-pilot, Lieut. Nathan Spungin, had a leg ripped off.  [Update, November, 2020:  According to a recent communication from Nathan’s daughter Janis, her father did not lose his leg.  Though he eventually recovered, he carried a scar from the incident for the rest of his life.] 

Despite their injuries, the pair carried on in the best Air Force tradition.

Refusing sedatives, the wounded men headed the big ship back for its home field in England.  Spungin, unable to take over the controls with only one leg, literally lent his eyes to Bacher, who depended on his co-pilot to tell him when to go up or down, to the right or left.

They brought the battered plane in to a perfect landing by one of the most heroic examples of teamwork in this toughest of all wars.

Blinded Bayonne Boy Flies Plane Safely Home

New York Post
February 19, 1945

A U.S. 8th Air Force Station in England, Feb. 19 (AP) – Lt. Gerson Bacher, 339 Avenue C, Bayonne, N.J., pilot of a Flying Fortress, was temporarily blinded in a recent raid on one [of] Mannheim’s railyards by a burst of flak which tore the nose from the plane, but he and his co-pilot, Lt. Nathan Spungin, Tampa., Fla., who was badly wounded in the leg by flak, teamed up to bring the ship home safely.

With Spungin “calling the plays,” Bacher, blinded by splinters, worked the rudder controls with his feet and they got the big ship back to its base without further mishap.  Both are recovering from their wounds.

Bayonne Flier Bombed Nazi Target Despite Loss of Fortress Engine

(Unidentified Newspaper)
December 30, 1944

Though he was unable to keep up with his Eighth Air Force formation, 2nd Lt. Gerson Bacher, 25, pilot, of Bayonne, flew his damaged B-17 Flying Fortress to a successful bombing of an active Luftwaffe base.  He and his crew returned safely to England from the recent attack, despite threatening enemy fighters.

Well into Germany, Lt. Bacher’s Fort lost an engine.  The loss of power prevented him from continuing on with his group, so he turned away to seek a closer target.

After considerable searching, the crew discovered a Nazi fighter base.  The target was partly covered with scattered clouds, but by making a short bomb run, the bombardier centered the target in his bombsight and dropped every bomb on the airfield.

As they turned away from the bombing, rockets shot past them – but not hitting the plane.  Two twin-engined fighters streaked out of the clouds, making straight for the Fort’s tail.  The tail gunner and the top gunner opened fire on the Nazis, but the planes suddenly veered off to the side.

A swarm of P-51 Mustangs had “appeared out of nowhere” and was blasting the enemy fighters away.  Later the tail gunner saw one of the German planes go down in flames.

Lt. Bacher, holder of the Air Medal, is the son of Mr. and Mrs. R. Cohn.  His wife, Mildred Bacher, lives with his parents at 399 Avenue C.  Before entering the AAF in May, 1941, he was a welder for the General Motors Corp., Linden.

The airman is a member of the 486th Bomb Group.

According to Lieutenant Edgar’s diary, the above incident occurred on December 6, 1944, during a mission to Meresburg, Germany.  As he recorded, “When we reached the Hanover area a supercharger went out, and the engine was not much good to us from then on.  Unable to keep up with the formation we decided to turn back.  Only at times could we see the ground because of heavy clouds.  While hunting for a good break in the things so we could make a bomb run on the Ems Canal our pin point navigator sighted an airfield.  I didn’t have time to use our bombsight so I dropped my bombs from 22,000 ft. just estimating the release point.  Luckily about six of them messed up one of the Luftwaffe’s runways.  We had been flying around so long with our doors open they froze open, and we were in the process of cranking them closed when we saw two ME 210’s getting ready to start making passes at us.  Just as the first one started his pass about five P-51’s appeared out of nowhere, and we last saw them all diving hell-bent for the clouds.  This was the first time I saw any enemy fighters.”

Here is Lt. Edgar’s account of the events of January 21: Once more the air forces were called on to give support to the ground troops, this time we were going to the rail yards at Mannheim.  This city was also a nice nest of flak guns.  It was planned that we would bomb “Cat and Mouse” so as to avoid the heavy anti-aircraft fire around Karlsruhe.  On the bomb run, which took us right up the Rhine Valley, the lead ship’s blind bombing equipment went out making it necessary to make a straight run on the target.  The whole group went right over Karlsruhe, and they were good shots down there.  Halfway down the bomb run a burst went off right over our nose.  A large piece of flak came through the nose taking out my gunsight and barely missing my head.  I was afraid to look around at Dinwiddie because he had always been in the habit of standing right behind me on the bomb runs.  This day he stayed lying on the floor, and it was a good thing.  The piece of flak went through the instrument panel in the cockpit and sprayed tachometers, and glass all over it.  One of the oil pressure instruments hit Spungin in the leg, and made a nice hole in it for him.  Bacher got some plexiglass in his eyes, and couldn’t see very well.  As soon as I dropped our bombs and had the doors closed, I went back, and gave Spungin first aid.  As soon as it was possible we left the formation, and with plane on automatic pilot we went on back to the base alone.  Bach and Spungin and both received the Purple Heart, as did seven other men in our squadron from that day, and later General Partridge (Division Commander) presented Bach with the Silver Star.  After that we all went to the flak house for a rest, and Bacher and Spungin were sent home.

Injured Flier Lands Plane

(Unidentified Newspaper)
February 26, 1945

Blinded temporarily by the flak that ripped through the nose of a Flying Fortress during an attack on Mannheim, January 21, Lt. Gerson Bacher, 25, of 399 Avenue C, managed to reach England safety with the aid of his co-pilot.

Shell splinters blinded Bacher and cut through the co-pilot’s leg.  Despite the wound the co-pilot took over the hand controls, calling out orders so that Bacher could work the rudder controls with his feet.  Both were sent to a hospital in England for treatment.

Another incident proving Bacher’s courage took place this winter when he was flying with the 8th Air Force over Germany.  Unable to keep up with the other planes, this airman flew his damaged B-17 to a successful bombing on active Luftwaffe base.

Holder of the Air Medal, the Lieutenant is a member of the 486th Bomb Group, cited by the President for the England-Africa shuttle bombing of Messerschmitt plants at Regensburg, Germany.  [Error! –  The article is referring to the Schweinfurt-Regensburg mission of August 17, 1943.  The 486th’s first mission occurred on May 7, 1944, over eight months later.]  At the time of his last trip he was finishing his 20th mission.

Son of Mr. and Mrs. Ruby Cohn, of 1132 Boulevard, Bacher has been married for three years to Mildred Bacher who lives with her parents, Mr. and Mrs. Gus Fastov, at 399 Avenue C.  He was employed as a welder with General Motors Corp., Linden prior to joining the Army in May, 1941.

Service News

(Unidentified Newspaper)
May 29, 1945

Lt. Gerson Bacher, returnee veteran of air combat with the England-based Eighth Air Force as pilot of a B-17, is now stationed at Boca Raton Army Air Field, a technical school of the AAF Training Command.  Foer his meritorious service he wears the Silver Star, the Air Medal with two Oak Leaf Clusters and the Purple Heart.

He flew 20 combat missions, totaling 200 combat hours, before being wounded.  A graduate from Bayonne High School, Lieutenant Bacher is the son of Mr. and Mrs. R. Cohn, 1132 Blvd., Bayonne.  His wife resides at 399 Avenue C.

Another account of the story can be found at the 486th Bomb Group’s website.

________________

Ehrlich, Maxim E., Pvt., 13151212, Purple Heart (Luxembourg)
United States Army
Mr. and Mrs. William T. and Gladys B. Ehrlich (parents), 112 S. 49th St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Philadelphia Record 3/13/45
American Jews in World War II – 518

Paraf, Alexis, Aspirant, Char (Chef de Section), Croix de Guerre (At Cernay, France)
French Army
Wounded; Wounded subsequently – on 1/26/45
On January 20 and 21, 1945, before Cernay, he admirably trained his section on the attack.  He counter-attacked in flat terrain; fired anti-tank grenades at short range on enemy tanks.  Wounded in the face, would not abandon the battle.  Was seriously wounded on 26 January by shelling.  [Les 20 et 21 janvier 1945 devant Cernay, a entrainé admirablement sa section à l’attaque.  Contre-attaque en terrain plat, a tiré des grenades anti-chars à courte distance sur des blindés ennemis.  Blessé à la face, ne voulut pas abandonner le combat.  A été sérieusement blessé le 26 janvier par éclat d’obus.]
Livre d’Or et de Sang – Les Juifs au Combat: Citations 1939-1945 de Bir-Hakeim au Rhin et Danube – 196

________________

Evaded Capture After Crash-Landing in Yugoslavia

A notable aspect of 15th Air Force B-17 and B-24 losses during combat missions over eastern and southeastern Europe, especially towards the war’s end, was the frequency with which bomber crews, in part and oftimes in entirety, were able to escape capture and (eventually!) return to American military forces.  This occurred with the aid of Partisan forces, civilians, and sometimes after landing in Soviet-controlled territory.  The MACRs covering such losses describe the “route” of the return of such airmen in varying detail.  Some denote the return of crewmen with the simple acronym RTD (“Returned to Duty”) next to an aviator’s name, while other reports contain perfunctory postwar statements by former crew members.

In the case of a 483rd Bomb Group B-17 lost over the former Yugoslavia on January 21, a substantive account of the crew’s return appeared 29 years after the war, in an Associated Press news story.  It was revealed that the aircraft, B-17G 44-6423, piloted by 1 Lt. Robert M. Grossman, crash-landed in a valley north of Banja Luka after a mission to the Lobau Oil Refinery, at Vienna.  The entire crew were escorted by Chetniks to the village (hamlet? crossroad?) of “Celiac” (probably Celinovac), where they were sheltered and hidden from capture by the family of Dragutin and Vasilia Cvijanovich.  In April, the crew returned to American military control in Italy through the aid of Communist partisans.

Postwar statements by four of the bomber’s crewmen give highly varied locations for the place of the bomber’s landing.  These are: 1) 3 miles northeast of Banja Luka (Grossman), 15 miles north of Banja Luka (Keane), 10 km north and a little west of Banja Luka at 45-5 N, 17-10 E (Daniels), and 15 km north of Banja Luka (LeClair).

______________________________

Banja Luka, in Bosnia-Herzegovina.

______________________________

The area north of Banja Luka (red oval) where 44-6423 was probably belly-landed by Lt. Grossman.   (Do any remnants of the plane still exist?)

______________________________

Zooming in on the above image, with Celinovac denoted by the red oval. 

______________________________

A Google Earth CNES view of the above area (at the same scale), with  Celinovac again denoted in red.  (Note the faint gray “line” running southeast to northwest, adjacent to Celinovac…)

______________________________

A much closer view, showing Celinovac, which essentially is a small group of homes at a cross-road.   (The gray “line” referred to above is revealed to be an aircraft contrail!)

______________________________

The occasion for the AP story was a reunion of four of aircraft 423’s crewmen (Stanley Taxel, (1 Lt. – Navigator) George A. Daniels, Jr., (S/Sgt. – Tail Gunner) Russell A. White, and (S/Sgt. – Left Waist Gunner) James R. Gourley) with Dragutin and Vasilia, at the home of their son Momchilo in Dutchess County, New York.  The AP articles are presented below.

Lifesaver Honored at Special Reunion

The Batavia Daily News

February 12, 1974

WAPPINGERS FALLS, N.Y. (AP) – Stanley Taxel, a Manhattan stationery manufacturer, has been reunited with an 80-year-old man who saved his life and the lives of 11 other Americans in Yugoslavia 29 years ago.

The reunion Saturday with Dragutin Cvijanovic took place in this Dutchess County community at the home of Dragutin’s son, Momchilo.  The younger Cvijanovic was brought to the United States in 1959 chiefly through Taxel’s efforts.

The elder Cvijanovic sheltered Taxel and the rest of this 10-man B-17 bomber crew after they were shot down during a World War II mission in January 1945.

Taxel and the rest of the crew were found by the Cetniks [sic], an underground group loyal to the Allies, after the plane crash-landed in a mountain range in Yugoslavia.

“We were on our 48th mission,” Taxel said.  “I would have had two more missions and I could have gone home.  As it turned out, I’m glad we were shot down over Yugoslavia.”

The Cetniks brought the bomber crew to the village of Celinak [sic].  It was there that the crew found a home with the Cvijanovics.

Momchilo was only 10 when his father offered the Americans a home during the war.  Today he has only vague recollections of the event that brought his family guests for the winter.

“I remember building a snowman with the Americans,” Momchilo said.  “And I remember sleeping on my father’s feet to keep him warm.”

Eventually two more Americans parachuted behind the German lines, and the Cvijanovics’ household grew to 12 American soldiers in addition to Dragutin, his wife and their six children.

“It was the burden of feeding that became the most difficult,” Taxel said.  “This man laid it all on the line for us, his wife and the lives of his family.”

Once he returned to the United States, Taxel kept in close contact with Cvijanovics and was eventually responsible for Momchilo’s migration to this country in 1969.

Dragutin recently emigrated to the United States.

“Today,” Taxel said, “I rely very heavily on the experience with the Cvijanovics.  When things get very heavy for me, I think back to the mountains and I remember Dragutin.”

Taxel paused and hugged the old man who cannot speak English.  “It’s so good to see him again,” he said.”

Tears Mark Reunion of Cvijanovich and the GIs He saved

Cortland Standard

June 19, 1974

By PAUL STEVENS

Associated Press Writer

WAPPINGERS FALLS, N.Y. (AP) – For a moment, tears filled the eyes of the old Yugoslav man as he watched the festive reunion of his sons and the American airmen he sheltered nearly 30 years ago.

“It still seems like they’re my sons,” said Dragutin Cvijanovich, 80.  “I always had a feeling that way…  There’s no doubt in my mind and heart that it’s the happiest day of my life.”

During World War II, while German soldiers roamed the Yugoslavian countryside, 10 American airmen broke bread with Cvijanovich and his wife and their seven children.

So this weekend was a time for remembering at the homes of Dragutin’s sons, Momchilo and Milorad, who he and his wife, Vasilia, 81, have been visiting from their home in Banja Luka, Yugoslavia.

Only four of the airmen taken in by the Cvijanoviches were able to attend.  But the atmosphere was drastically different from the time in 1945 when they sat down with the family to share a single chicken.

American and Yugoslavian flags flew side by side Saturday at Momchilo’s home here.  An accordionist played Old World polkas as well as pop tunes.  A pig and a lamb were roasted on an open outdoor pit.

The wine flowed freely, so did the memories.

One of the airmen, Stanley Taxel, 51, of New York City, nodded toward the elder Cvijanovich and said, “He’s the guy who saved our lives.  This old man…put his neck on the line for us.”

Taxel was one of 10 crew members of a B-17 which was crippled by flak on a mission over Vienna and forced to crash-land near the Cvijanoviches’ home.

“We were bombing an oil refinery on the Dabube,” recalled George Daniels of Stamford, Conn., the plane’s navigator.  “We lost an engine and had to come down when the fuel was running out.”

The plane landed smoothly on the heavy snowfall in January 1945 and the men were quickly whisked away by the Chetniks, a guerilla group, who took them to the Cvijanoiches’ home in Celniac.

Dragutin, his wife and seven children slept in a bedroom and an outside shed while the airman occupied the other bedroom in the farmhouse.  When Germans would come to the home, Taxel recalled, the men were taken into the mountains to safety.

Mrs. Cvijanovic stretched the limited food supply.

“She was a crackerjack,” said Taxel.  “There was little food.  Everyone was starving – we ate rotten goat meat at times.  She knew how much food to dole out to keep people alive.”

In April, Communist partisans helped the men to escape through the mountains to Italy, where the 15th Air Force was headquartered.

Most of the men had not seen the Cvijanoviches since.  But Russ White of Denver, who came here from Colorado with fellow airman James Gourley of Two Buttes, said time hadn’t blotted his memory.  “I would know them anywhere.”

Here is Stanley Taxel’s 1941 Erasmus Hall High School graduation portrait, while this AP image, from The Evening News (Dutchess County), shows Stanley and Dragutin during their 1974 reunion.

Biographical information about Stanley Taxel, whose name never appeared in American Jews in World War II, follows, along with his 1941 Erasmus Hall High School graduation portrait.  (Thanks again, Ancestry.com!)

Taxel, Stanley, T/Sgt., 12156149, Radio Operator, on 48th mission

United States Army Air Force, 15th Air Force, 483rd Bomb Group, 840th Bomb Squadron
MACR 11273, Aircraft B-17G 44-6423, 10 crew – all survived; Pilot 1 Lt. Robert M.
Crash-landed near Banja-Luka, Yugoslavia; Entire crew rescued by Chetniks; Returned to base 67 days later

Born Brooklyn, N.Y., 5/5/23; Died 12/25/95
Mrs. Elaine E. Taxel (wife), 501 Avenue A, Brooklyn, N.Y.
Mr. and Mrs. Meyer [6/16/93 – 10/29/74] and Gussie (Schmidt) [1894-1960] Taxel (parents)
Harold, Irving, and Manuel (brothers), 133 Clinton St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Cortland Standard – 6/19/74
The Batavia Daily News – 2/12/74
The Daily News (Tarrytown) – 2/11/74
The Evening News (Dutchess County) – 2/11/74
The Journal News – 6/17/74
American Jews in World War II – Not listed
Heroes of the 483rd: Crew Histories of a Much-Decorated B-17 Bomber Group During World War II – 100

________________

Rescued After Ditching in the Philippines

Horwitz, Irving, F/O (Lt.?), Navigator
United States Army Air Force, 5th Air Force, 345th Bomb Group, 500th Bomb Squadron
No MACR, Aircraft B-25J 44-29586, Pilot 1 Lt. Lynn W. Daker, 6 crew – 5 survivors

From Lawrence Hickey’s Warpath Across the Pacific: “The poor single engine performance of the new B-25J-22s was emphasized on the 21st when the 500th’s 1st Lt. Lynn W. Daker lost an engine while skirting around a weather front which had forced cancellation of the day’s mission.  Despite all efforts to lighten the ship, Daker found himself trapped down on the deck, unable to gain enough altitude for the run home.  The resultant landing in the Pacific [off Negros Island, Philippines] cost the life of the engineer, S/Sgt. Desire W. Chatigny, Jr., who went to the bottom with the plane.  Other planes from the flight circled overhead while a Catalina flew in to puck the five survivors from the sea.”  The image below, in Warpath (from the collection of Maurice J. Eppstein), shows the rescue of the five survivors by a PBY Catalina.

______________________________

Maps of the location of the plane’s ditching are shown below.

The Philippine Islands.

______________________________

A closer view.  Moving from northwest to southeast, the islands are Panay, Negros, Mactan, and Panglao Island.  Lt. Daker ditched his B-25 in the waters north of Cadiz City, off the coast of Negros Island. 

______________________________

An even closer view, showing the eastern coast of Panay and northern end of Negros Island.  Google’s red location designator shows the approximate location where B-25J 44-29586 was ditched. 

In mid-February of 2009, Lynn Daker visited the location of his aircraft’s ditching in an attempt to recover and return the remains of S/Sgt. Chatigny to his family for burial.  Though the plane’s wreckage was located, little remained except for the aircraft’s two engines, the remainder of the plane probably having been removed in the intervening decades as a danger to local fishing vessels. 

As a symbolic gesture, a bottle was filled with sand was retrieved from the ocean bottom near the plane’s engines, and, a plaque commemorating Sergeant Chatigny and identifying the plane was left on the sea floor. 

Mr. Daker, head of the 345th Bomb Group Association, passed away one month later.

The plane’s crew:

Pilot – 1 Lt. Lynn W. Daker
Co-Pilot – Lt. Jensen (2 Lt. Robert W. Jensen?)
Bombardier or Navigator (both?) – F/O (Lt.?) Horwitz
Flight Engineer – S/Sgt. Desire W. Chatigny, Jr. (Newburyport, Ma.; Died in ditching)
Radio Operator or Gunner – T/Sgt. Dunn
Radio Operator or Gunner – S/Sgt. Wachtel

From Burlington, N.J. – possibly 463 High Street
American Jews in World War II – Not listed
The Strafer (345th Bomb Group Newsletter): March, 2009, V 27, N 1
Warpath: The Story of the 345th Bombardment Group In World War II – 47
Warpath Across the Pacific – The Illustrated History of the 345th Bombardment Group During World War II – 258, 395

References

Books and Periodicals

Burrows, Robert H., “Grabbing An Opportunity”, The Bulge Bugle, V 32, N 3, August 2013, pp 9-11

Chiche, F., Livre d’Or et de Sang – Les Juifs au Combat: Citations 1939-1945 de Bir-Hakeim au Rhin et Danube, Edition Brith Israel, Tunis, Tunisie, 1946

Dublin, Louis I., and Kohs, Samuel C., American Jews in World War II – The Story of 550,000 Fighters for Freedom, The Dial Press, New York, N.Y., 1947

Grimm, Jacob L., and Cole, Vernon H., Heroes of the 483rd: Crew Histories of a Much-Decorated B-17 Bomber Group During World War II, 483rd Bombardment Group (H) Association, (Georgia?), 1997

Hickey, Lawrence J., Warpath Across the Pacific – The Illustrated History of the 345th Bombardment Group During World War II, International Research and Publishing Corporation, Boulder, Co., 1984

Morris, Henry, Edited by Gerald Smith, We Will Remember Them – A Record of the Jews Who Died in the Armed Forces of the Crown 1939 – 1945, Brassey’s, United Kingdom, London, 1989

Mortensen, Max H., Warpath: The Story of the 345th Bombardment Group In World War II, (1945?)

Memorial Book of Jewish Soldiers Who Died in Battles Against Nazism – 1941-1945, Maryanovskiy, M.F., Pivovarova, N.A., Sobol, I.S. (editors), Union of Jewish War Invalids and Veterans, Moscow, Russia, 1999

Other Documents

Prisoner of War Personalkarte (Personal Card) for Pvt. Seymour Shapiro, at United States National Archives: In Records Group 242, Entry 279, Stack Area 190, Row 16, Compartment 1, Shelf 1, Box 62

Soldiers from New York: Jewish Soldiers in The New York Times, in World War Two: First Lieutenant Sidney Diamond – January 9, 1945

Though Lieutenant Sidney Diamond’s obituary appeared in the Times on March 2, 1945, his name appeared in a Casualty List over three weeks later:  On March 24. 

Awarded the Silver Star, he is buried at Cedar Park Cemetery, in Paramus, New Jersey. 

Bronx Boy Killed on Luzon Received Two Citations

First Lieut. Sidney Diamond, who was with the Eighty-Second Chemical Battalion, was killed on Luzon on Jan. 9, according to word receive yesterday by his parents, Mr. and Mrs. Solomon Diamond, of 1375 Nelson Avenue, the Bronx.  He was 22 years old.

Lieutenant Diamond, who served nineteen months in the South Pacific, received two citations.  On April 20, 1944, somewhere in the South Pacific, he was cited for giving “outstanding effective support” to another division by “fire laid down by your 4.2 mortar which proved to be a powerful and devastating supplement to the division’s artillery and mortar fire and helped reduce the loss of life.”

In Bougainville on June 25, 1944, he was cited again.  Although the infantry withdrew for the duration of a barrage laid down by the enemy, Lieutenant Diamond stuck to his post as a forward observer of a mortar battery.  “Your courageous and conspicuously efficient action assisted greatly in defeating a determined enemy,” the citation read.

Lieutenant Diamond was studying chemical engineering at City College when he entered the Army.  Besides his parents he leaves a sister, Mrs. Anita Diamond Nicholson.

____________________

Some other Jewish military casualties on Tuesday, January 9, 1945, include…

Killed in Action
– .ת.נ.צ.ב.ה. –

Beitchman, Sidney, PFC, 33799580, Purple Heart (in France)
United States Army, 100th Infantry Division, 397th Infantry Regiment
Mrs. Lucille L. (Herman) Beitchman (wife) [Married 2/4/39], 260 South 3rd St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Mrs. Sarah Beitchman (mother), 1224 N. 42nd St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Born Philadelphia, Pa., 4/6/18
Epinal American Cemetery, Epinal, France – Plot A, Row 42, Grave 17
American Jews in World War II – 510

Benson, Alvin, S/Sgt., 32056817, Medical Corps, Bronze Star Medal, Purple Heart
United States Army, 44th Infantry Division, 114th Infantry Regiment
Mrs. Minnie Benson (Mother), 112 Palmet St., Passaic, N.J.
Born 12/25/17
Beverly National Cemetery, Beverly, N.J. – Section C, Grave 1935 (Buried 12/27/48)
Casualty List 2/22/45
American Jews in World War II – 226

Dronzik, Julius, Pvt., 32900185, Purple Heart (On Luzon, in the Philippines)
United States Army, 43rd Infantry Division, 169th Infantry Regiment
Mrs. Anna Dronzik (mother), 346 Pennsylvania Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Born 12/28/13
Casualty List 3/20/45
Beth David Cemetery, Elmont, N.Y.
American Jews in World War II – 299

Feingold, Murray W., Pvt., 14118554, Silver Star, Purple Heart, 1 Oak Leaf Cluster
United States Army, 84th Infantry Division, 335th Infantry Regiment
Mr. Pat Feingold (father), Atlanta Ga. / Albany, Ga.
Henri-Chapelle American Cemetery, Henri-Chapelle, Belgium – Plot G, Row 10, Grave 54
American Jews in World War II – 87

Heit, Meyer, T/5, 31349281, Combat Engineer, Silver Star, Bronze Star Medal, Purple Heart (in Luxembourg)
United States Army, 90th Infantry Division, 315th Engineer Combat Battalion
Mrs. Soli Heit (mother), 290 Franklin St., Springfield, Ma.
Born 1918
Luxembourg American Cemetery, Luxembourg City, Luxembourg – Plot A, Row 5, Grave 11
American Jews in World War II – 163

____________________

Kubrick, Harry Edward, PFC, 33419627, Purple Heart (in Germany)
United States Army, 90th Infantry Division, 357th Infantry Regiment
Mr. and Mrs. Israel and Mary Kubrick (parents), 1305 Center St., Pittsburgh, Pa.; Mrs. Louise Cox (sister) (1930 Census gives step-parents as Samuel and Sarah Winer)
Born Washington, Pa., 11/6/17
Long Island National Cemetery, Farmingdale, N.Y. – Section J, Grave 14789
First three National Jewish Welfare Board biographical cards state “No Publicity”‘; publicity permissible on 7/24/46;
Jewish Criterion (Pittsburgh) 9/7/45
American Jews in World War II – 534

____________________

Rosenfeld, Gerald F., Pvt., 42131631, Purple Heart
United States Army, 84th Infantry Division, 334th Infantry Regiment
Mrs. Liza M. Rosenfeld (mother), 2149 Southern Blvd., Bronx, N.Y.
Born 1924; City College of New York Class of 1948
Place of burial unknown
Casualty List 3/7/45
The New York Times
– Obituary Section (Memorial Listing) 1/9/46

American Jews in World War II – 419

Sommer, Herbert, PFC, 12091899, Silver Star, Purple Heart (in Belgium)
United States Army, 101st Airborne Division, 502nd Parachute Infantry Regiment, G Company
Mr. Abraham W. Sommer (father), 2954 W. 30th St., Brooklyn, N.Y. / 221 E. 168th St., Bronx, N.Y.
Born 2/22/23
Long Island National Cemetery, Farmingdale, N.Y. – Section J, Grave 13989
Casualty List 3/15/45
American Jews in World War II – 450

Weidman, Norman, PFC, 12227186, Purple Heart (in France)
United States Army, 100th Infantry Division, 397th Infantry Regiment
Mr. Louis Weidman (father), 456 Schenectady Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Born 1926
Place of burial unknown
Casualty List 3/29/45
American Jews in World War II – 466

Yudelson, Marvin, S/Sgt., 14118699, Purple Heart (in Belgium)
United States Army, 75th Infantry Division, 290th Infantry Regiment
Mr. Leo Yudelson (father), 2603 S. 10th Ave., Birmingham, Al.
Born 4/29/22
Beth El Cemetery, Jefferson County, Al.
American Jews in World War II – 36

Died While Prisoners of the Japanese

Buchman, Arthur H., 2 Lt., 0-392308
United States Army, Coast Artillery Corps, 59th Coast Artillery Regiment
Captured in Philippines; Died while POW 1/9/45 aboard Enoura Maru
Mr. Harry H. Buchman (father), 100 Greensboro Lane, Greentree, Pittsburgh, Pa.
Born 1917
Tablets of the Missing at Manila American Cemetery, Manila, Philippines
American Jews in World War II – 514

____________________

Omansky, Herman, PFC, 37026102, Purple Heart
United States Army, Medical Corps, 194th Tank Battalion
Captured 4/9/42; Died while POW 1/9/45 aboard Enoura Maru
Mr. and Mrs. David and Rose (Cohen) Burnstein (parents), 206 State St., St. Paul, Mn.
Born Saint Paul, Mn., 6/22/05; Mechanics Art School, Class of 1924
Tablets of the Missing at Manila American Cemetery, Manila, Philippines
War Department Release 5/43
American Jews in World War II – 203

This photograph of PFC Omansky, and, some of the biographical information presented above, are from the Proviso East High School Bataan Commemorative Research Project website. 

____________________

Rathblott, Irving, 1 Lt., 0-402449, Purple Heart
United States Army, Quartermaster Corps
Philippine Detachment, Headquarters
Captured in Philippines; Died while POW 1/9/45 aboard Enoura Maru
Mr. Nathan Rathblott (father), 1824 68th Ave., Philadelphia, Pa.
Born 1915; President of Sigma Alpha Rho Fraternity
Tablets of the Missing at Manila American Cemetery, Manila, Philippines
The Jewish Exponent – 12/25/42;
American Jews in World War II
– 545

This photograph of Lt. Rathblott appeared in The Jewish Exponent on December 25, 1942. 

____________________

Schwartz, Abe, 2 Lt., 0-890089, Purple Heart
United States Army, Quartermaster Corps
Captured in Philippines; Died while POW 1/9/45 aboard Enoura Maru
Mrs. Antonia Schwartz (wife), 3155 West Van Buren, Chicago, Il.
Miss Katie Schwartz (sister), 3770 Beechwood Blvd., Pittsburgh, Pa.
Tablets of the Missing at Manila American Cemetery, Manila, Philippines
Jewish Criterion (Pittsburgh) 5/21/43, 9/24/43, 9/7/45 (Name only)
American Jews in World War II – 550

____________________

Prisoners of War (European Theater)

Adler, Arnold A., PFC, 32684309
United States Army, 100th Infantry Division, 397th Infantry Regiment
Stalag 9B (Bad Orb), Berga am Elster
New York, N.Y., 1/1/21
Mr. and Mrs. Al and Hannah Adler (parents), 1304 Merriam Ave., Bronx, N.Y.
Casualty List (Liberated POW) 5/24/45
American Jews in World War II – 264

Berger, Peter J., S/Sgt., 33107277
United States Army, 42nd Infantry Division, 242nd Infantry Regiment
Stalag 9B (Bad Orb)
Mrs. Lena Berger (mother), 3201 Longshore Ave., Philadelphia, Pa.
Casualty List 5/8/45
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

Brimberg, Morton D., PFC, 12228345, Purple Heart
United States Army, 42nd Infantry Division, 242nd Infantry Regiment, C Company
Stalag 9B (Bad Orb), Berga am Elster
Mr. Hyman Brimberg (father), 5211 17th Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y. (Phone: WI8-1184) / 69 Custer St., Buffalo, 14, N.Y.
Born N.Y., 1/6/26 (?); Surname changed to “Brooks” after World War II
Casualty Lists 4/1/45, 5/19/45
American Jews in World War II – 284

____________________

Daub, Gerald M., PFC, 32961478
United States Army, 100th Infantry Division, 397th Infantry Regiment
Stalag 9B (Bad Orb), Berga am Elster
Mr. Sidney Daub (father), 422 Avenue I, Brooklyn, N.Y. (Phone: CL8-1309)
Born N.Y., 1/26/25
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

Gerald Daub, in training in the United States.  (c/o Gerald Daub)

Gerald Daub tells his story.  The interview below, uploaded to YouTube in June of 2015, is one of many interviews of WW II veterans at the website of the New York State Military Museum.  

____________________

Filler, Milton, Pvt., 31387184
United States Army, 36th Infantry Division, 142nd Infantry Regiment, B Company
Stalag 9B (Bad Orb), Berga am Elster
Mr. Max Filler (father), 171 (169?) Home Ave., Providence, R.I.
Born 8/10/14
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

Herz, Heinz Leon, PFC, 36897301
United States Army, 100th Infantry Division, 397th Infantry Regiment, F Company
Stalag 4B (Muhlberg)
Born Saarbrucken, Germany, 6/19/25
Mrs. Henrietta Herz (mother), 2492 Clairmount Ave., Detroit, Mi.
The Jewish News (Detroit) 6/1/45
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

The above news article, about PFC Herz’s liberation from Stalag 4B, appeared in the Jewish News (of Detroit) on June 1, 1945. 

____________________

Horowitz, Leon, PFC, 32995294
United States Army, 100th Infantry Division, 397th Infantry Regiment, F Company
Stalag 9B (Bad Orb)
Brooklyn, N.Y.
Born N.Y., 1925
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

Katz
, Jack, S/Sgt., 36348962

United States Army, 79th Infantry Division, 313th Infantry Division
Stalag 9B (Bad Orb)
Mrs. Dorothy Katz (wife), c/o Adel Shop, 134 Marguette St., La Salle, Il.
Casualty List 5/22/45
American Jews in World War II – 105

Kohn
, Seymour, PFC, 32598509

United States Army, 100th Infantry Division, 397th Infantry Regiment
Stalag 9B (Bad Orb), Berga am Elster
Philadelphia, Pa., 5/8/19
Mrs. Rachel (Monnes) Kohn (wife?), 749 Chancellor Ave., Irvington, N.J.
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

Levin
, Marvin, PFC, 36707768, Purple Heart

United States Army, 42nd Infantry Division, 242nd Infantry Regiment
Stalag 4B (Muhlberg)
Mrs. Lillian Levin (mother), 2626 East 75th St., Chicago, Il.
Casualty List 6/11/45
American Jews in World War II – 107

Levy
, Nathan, T/3, 32651951

United States Army, 100th Infantry Division, 397th Infantry Regiment
Stalag 9A (Ziegenhain)
Mrs. Irene Levy (wife), 446 Kingston Ave., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Casualty Lists 4/1/45, 5/23/45
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

Linet
, Harry, Pvt., 35917634

United States Army, 36th Infantry Division, 142nd Infantry Regiment, B Company
Stalag 9B (Bad Orb), Berga am Elster
Cleveland, Oh., 12/29/13
Mrs. Minnie Linet (wife), 3714 Sudbury, Shaker Heights, Cleveland, 20, Oh.
Mr. Ben Linet (father), General Delivery, Apco, Oh.
Casualty List 5/18/45
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

Rubin
, Arthur I., PFC, 31427773

United States Army, 100th Infantry Division, 397th Infantry Regiment
Stalag 9B (Bad Orb), Berga am Elster
Mr. and Mrs. Samuel and Alice (Baum) Rubin (parents), 110 Shute St., Everett, Ma.
Born Malden, Ma., 5/7/25
Casualty List 5/22/45
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

Rudnick
, Robert, PFC, 42044091

United States Army, 100th Infantry Division, 397th Infantry Regiment
Stalag 9B (Bad Orb), Berga am Elster
Mr. Morris Rudnick (father), 1516 East 32nd St., Brooklyn, N.Y.
Born Brooklyn, N.Y., 7/11/25
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

Siegel
, Martin, PFC, 42104184

United States Army, 42nd Infantry Division, 242nd Infantry Regiment
Stalag 4B (Muhlberg)
Mrs. Frances S. Bloom (sister), 19 Block Ave., Newark, N.J.
Casualty Lists 4/17/45, 6/18/45 (Liberated POW)
American Jews in World War II – Not Listed

Trachtman
, Leon E., PFC, 12225750

United States Army, 95th Infantry Division, 397th Infantry Regiment, 2nd Battalion, Headquarters Company
Stalag 9B (Bad Orb), Berga am Elster
Mr. Max Trachtman (father), 1463 Ocean Ave., Brooklyn, 30, N.Y. (Phone: NA3-6242)
Born Brooklyn, N.Y., 9/26/25
Casualty Lists 4/26/45, 5/31/45
American Jews in World War II – 461

References

Dublin, Louis I., and Kohs, Samuel C., American Jews in World War II – The Story of 550,000 Fighters for Freedom, The Dial Press, New York, N.Y., 1947